Specific binding of coupling factor 1 lacking the delta and epsilon subunits to thylakoids

ATP synthase of E. coli: F1-ATPase activity is functionally decoupled from the proton-transporting complex (FO) by tributyltin

The F-type ATP synthase/ATPase (FOF1) is important for cellular bioenergetics in eukaryotes and bacteria. We recently showed that venturicidins, a class of macrolides that inhibit the proton transporting complex (FO), can also induce time-dependent functional decoupling of F1-ATPase from FO on membranes from Escherichia coli and Pseudomonas aeruginosa. This dysregulated ATPase activity could deplete bacterial ATP levels and contribute to venturicidin's capacity to enhance the bactericidal action of aminoglycosides antibiotics. We now show that a distinct type of FO inhibitor, tributyltin, also can decouple FOF1-ATPase activity of E. coli membranes. In contrast to the action of venturicidins, decoupling by tributyltin is not dependent on ATP, indicating mechanistic differences. Tributyltin disrupts the coupling role of the ε subunit of F1 but does not induce dissociation of the F1-ATPase complex from membrane-embedded FO. Understanding such decoupling mechanisms could support development of novel antibacterial compounds that target dysregulation of FOF1 functions.

Chloroplast ATP synthase: From structure to engineering

F-type ATP synthases are extensively researched protein complexes because of their widespread and central role in energy metabolism. Progress in structural biology, proteomics, and molecular biology has also greatly advanced our understanding of the catalytic mechanism, post-translational modifications, and biogenesis of chloroplast ATP synthases. Given their critical role in light-driven ATP generation, tailoring the activity of chloroplast ATP synthases and modeling approaches can be applied to modulate photosynthesis. In the future, advances in genetic manipulation and protein design tools will significantly expand the scope for testing new strategies in engineering light-driven nanomotors.

BIOGENESIS FACTOR REQUIRED FOR ATP SYNTHASE 3 Facilitates Assembly of the Chloroplast ATP Synthase Complex

Thylakoid membrane-localized chloroplast ATP synthases use the proton motive force generated by photosynthetic electron transport to produce ATP from ADP. Although it is well known that the chloroplast ATP synthase is composed of more than 20 proteins with α3β3γ1ε1δ1I1II1III14IV1 stoichiometry, its biogenesis process is currently unclear. To unravel the molecular mechanisms underlying the biogenesis of chloroplast ATP synthase, we performed extensive screening for isolating ATP synthase mutants in Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana). In the recently identified bfa3 (biogenesis factors required for ATP synthase 3) mutant, the levels of chloroplast ATP synthase subunits were reduced to approximately 25% of wild-type levels. In vivo labeling analysis showed that assembly of the CF1 component of chloroplast ATP synthase was less efficient in bfa3 than in the wild type, indicating that BFA3 is required for CF1 assembly. BFA3 encodes a chloroplast stromal protein that is conserved in higher plants, green algae, and a few species of other eukaryotic algae, and specifically interacts with the CF1β subunit. The BFA3 binding site was mapped to a region in the catalytic site of CF1β. Several residues highly conserved in eukaryotic CF1β are crucial for the BFA3-CF1β interaction, suggesting a coevolutionary relationship between BFA3 and CF1β. BFA3 appears to function as a molecular chaperone that transiently associates with unassembled CF1β at its catalytic site and facilitates subsequent association with CF1α during assembly of the CF1 subcomplex of chloroplast ATP synthase.

C-Terminal mutations in the chloroplast ATP synthase gamma subunit impair ATP synthesis and stimulate ATP hydrolysis

Two highly conserved amino acid residues, an arginine and a glutamine, located near the C-terminal end of the gamma subunit, form a "catch" by hydrogen bonding with residues in an anionic loop on one of the three catalytic beta subunits of the bovine mitochondrial F1-ATPase [Abrahams, J. P., Leslie, A. G., Lutter, R., and Walker, J. E. (1994) Nature 370, 621-628]. The catch is considered to play a critical role in the binding change mechanism whereby binding of ATP to one catalytic site releases the catch and induces a partial rotation of the gamma subunit. This role is supported by the observation that mutation of the equivalent arginine and glutamine residues in the Escherichia coli F1 gamma subunit drastically reduced all ATP-dependent catalytic activities of the enzyme [Greene, M. D., and Frasch, W. D. (2003) J. Biol. Chem. 278, 5194-5198]. In this study, we show that simultaneous substitution of the equivalent residues in the chloroplast F1 gamma subunit, arginine 304 and glutamine 305, with alanine decreased the level of proton-coupled ATP synthesis by more than 80%. Both the Mg2+-dependent and Ca2+-dependent ATP hydrolysis activities increased by more than 3-fold as a result of these mutations; however, the sulfite-stimulated activity decreased by more than 60%. The Mg2+-dependent, but not the Ca2+-dependent, ATPase activity of the double mutant was insensitive to inhibition by the phytotoxic inhibitor tentoxin, indicating selective loss of catalytic cooperativity in the presence of Mg2+ ions. The results indicate that the catch residues are required for efficient proton coupling and for activation of multisite catalysis when MgATP is the substrate. The catch is not, however, required for CaATP-driven multisite catalysis or, therefore, for rotation of the gamma subunit.

The role of subunit epsilon in the catalysis and regulation of FOF1-ATP synthase

The regulation of ATP synthase activity is complex and involves several distinct mechanisms. In bacteria and chloroplasts, subunit epsilon plays an important role in this regulation, (i) affecting the efficiency of coupling, (ii) influencing the catalytic pathway, and (iii) selectively inhibiting ATP hydrolysis activity. Several experimental studies indicate that the regulation is achieved through large conformational transitions of the alpha-helical C-terminal domain of subunit epsilon that occur in response to membrane energization, change in ATP/ADP ratio or addition of inhibitors. This review summarizes the experimental data obtained on different organisms that clarify some basic features as well as some molecular details of this regulatory mechanism. Multiple functions of subunit epsilon, its role in the difference between the catalytic pathways of ATP synthesis and hydrolysis and its influence on the inhibition of ATP hydrolysis by ADP are also discussed.

ATP synthase of chloroplast thylakoid membranes: a more in depth characterization of its ATPase activity

In contrast to everted mitochondrial inner membrane vesicles and eubacterial plasma membrane vesicles, the ATPase activity of chloroplast ATP synthase in thylakoid membranes is extremely low. Several treatments of thylakoids that unmask ATPase activity are known. Illumination of thylakoids that contain reduced ATP synthase (reduced thylakoids) promotes the hydrolysis of ATP in the dark. Incubation of thylakoids with trypsin can also elicit higher rates of ATPase activity. In this paper the properties of the ATPase activity of the ATP synthase in thylakoids treated with trypsin are compared with those of the ATPase activity in reduced thylakoids. The trypsin-treated membranes have significant ATPase activity in the presence of Ca2+, whereas the Ca2+-ATPase activity of reduced thylakoids is very low. The Mg2+-ATPase activity of the trypsinized thylakoids was only partially inhibited by the uncouplers, at concentrations that fully inhibit the ATPase activity of reduced membranes. Incubation of reduced thylakoids with ADP in Tris buffer prior to assay abolishes Mg2+-ATPase activity. The Mg2+-ATPase activity of trypsin-treated thylakoids was unaffected by incubation with ADP. Trypsin-treated membranes can make ATP at rates that are 75-80% of those of untreated thylakoids. The Mg2+-ATPase activity of trypsin-treated thylakoids is coupled to inward proton translocation and 10 mM sulfite stimulates both proton uptake and ATP hydrolysis. It is concluded that cleavage of the gamma subunit of the ATP synthase by trypsin prevents inhibition of ATPase activity by the epsilon subunit, but only partially overcomes inhibition by Mg2+ and ADP during assay.

Substitutions of the conserved Gly47 affect the CF1 inhibitor and proton gate functions of the chloroplast ATP synthase epsilon subunit

The conserved residue Gly47 of the chloroplast ATP synthase beta subunit was substituted with Leu, Arg, Ala and Glu by site-directed mutagenesis. This process generated the mutants epsilon G47L, epsilon G47R, epsilon G47A and epsilon G47E, respectively. All the beta variants showed lower inhibitory effects on the soluble CF1(-epsilon) Ca2+-ATPase compared with wild-type epsilon. In reduced conditions, epsilon G47E and epsilon G47R had a lower inhibitory effect on the oxidized CF1(-epsilon) Ca2+-ATPase compared with wild-type epsilon. In contrast, epsilon G47L and epsilon G47A increased the Ca2+-ATPase activity of soluble oxidized CF1(-epsilon). The replacement of Gly47 significantly impaired the interaction between the subunit epsilon and gamma in an in vitro binding assay? Further study showed that all epsilon variants were more effective in blocking proton leakage from the thylakoid membranes. This enhanced ATP synthesis of the chloroplast and restored ATP synthesis activity of the reconstituted membranes to a level that was more efficient than that achieved by wild-type epsilon. These results indicate that the conserved Gly47 residue of the epsilon subunit is very important for maintaining the structure and function of the epsilon subunit and may affect the interaction between the epsilon subunit, beta subunit of CF1 and subunit III of CFo, thereby regulating the ATP hydrolysis and synthesis, as well as the proton translocation role of the subunit III of CFo.

Effects of site-directed mutation on the function of the chloroplast ATP synthase epsilon subunit

The previous work in our lab showed that the spinach chloroplast ATP synthase epsilon mutant with 3 amino acid residues deleted from the N-terminus had much lower ability to inhibit ATP hydrolysis and block proton leakage in comparison to a mutant with 1 or 2 residues deleted from the N-terminus. The present study aimed at determining whether there is special importance in the structure and function of the N-terminal third residue of the chloroplast epsilon subunit. The leucine residue at the N-terminal third site (Leu3) of the spinach chloroplast epsilon subunit was replaced with Ile, Phe, Thr, Arg, Glu or Pro by site-directed mutagenesis, forming mutants epsilonL3I, epsilonL3F, epsilonL3T, epsilonL3R, epsilonL3E and epsilonL3P, respectively. These epsilon variants all showed lower abilities to inhibit ATP hydrolysis and to block proton leakage, as compared to the wild type epsilon subunit (epsilonWT). The abilities of mutants epsilonL3I and epsilonL3F to restore the ATP synthesis activity of reconstituted membranes were higher than those of epsilonWT, but the abilities of the other epsilon variants were lower than that of epsilonWT. These results indicate that the hydrophobic and neutral characteristics of Leu3 of the chloroplast epsilon subunit are very important for its ability to inhibit ATP hydrolysis and block proton leakage, and for the ATP synthesis ability of ATP synthase.

Functional Consequences of N- or C-Terminal Deletions of the δ Subunit of Chloroplast ATP Synthase

Mutagenesis was used to generate seven truncation mutants of the spinach (Spinacia oleracea) chloroplast ATP synthase delta subunit lacking 5, 11, 17, or 35 amino acid residues from the N-terminus or 3, 9, or 15 residues from the C-terminus. Interactions between these mutants and all other subunits of the chloroplast ATPase were investigated by a yeast two-hybrid system. The results indicate that the N-terminal deletions mainly affected interactions between the delta subunit and the other part of CF(1), but did not significantly affect interactions with the CF(0) sector. In contrast, C-terminal truncations of the delta subunit mainly affected its interaction with the CF(0) sector and caused little impairment in interactions with the other part of CF(1). The conformation of the delta subunit C-terminal domain seems to be more sensitive to the truncations, as shown by minimal expression driven by C-terminal deleted (nine residues) mutants. Further studies showed C-terminal truncations of the delta subunit greatly impaired its ability to restore cyclic photophosphorylation in NaBr vesicles, whereas N-terminal truncations had little effect on the ability of delta to plug the CF(0) channel. None of the mutants impaired ATP hydrolysis by CF(1).

The two rotor components of yeast mitochondrial ATP synthase are mechanically coupled by subunit delta

The mitochondrial ATP synthase is made of a membrane-integrated F0 component that forms a proton-permeable pore through the inner membrane and a globular peripheral F1 domain where ATP is synthesized. The catalytic mechanism is thought to involve the rotation of a 10-12 c subunit ring in the F0 together with the gamma subunit of F1. An important and not yet resolved question is to define precisely how the gamma subunit is connected with the c-ring. In this study, using a doxycycline-regulatable expression system, we provide direct evidence that the rest of the enzyme can assemble without the delta subunit of F1, and we show that delta-less mitochondria are uncoupled because of an F0-mediated proton leak. Based on these observations, and taking into account high-resolution structural models, we propose that subunit delta plays a key role in the mechanical coupling of the c-ring to subunit gamma.

The C-terminal domain of the epsilon subunit of the chloroplast ATP synthase is not required for ATP synthesis

The epsilon subunit of the ATP synthases from chloroplasts and Escherichia coli regulates the activity of the enzyme and is required for ATP synthesis. The epsilon subunit is not required for the binding of the catalytic portion of the chloroplast ATP synthase (CF1) to the membrane-embedded part (CFo). Thylakoid membranes reconstituted with CF1 lacking its epsilon subunit (CF1-epsilon) have high ATPase activity and no ATP synthesis activity, at least in part because the membranes are very leaky to protons. Either native or recombinant epsilon subunit inhibits ATPase activity and restores low proton permeability and ATP synthesis. In this paper we show that recombinant epsilon subunit from which 45 amino acids were deleted from the C-terminus is as active as full-length epsilon subunit in restoring ATP synthesis to membranes containing CF1-epsilon. However, the truncated form of the epsilon subunit was significantly less effective as an inhibitor of the ATPase activity of CF1-epsilon, both in solution and bound to thylakoid membranes. Thus, the C-terminus of the epsilon subunit is more involved in regulation of activity, by inhibiting ATP hydrolysis, than in ATP synthesis.

The structure of the chloroplast F1-ATPase at 3.2 A resolution

The structure of the F(1)-ATPase from spinach chloroplasts was determined to 3.2 A resolution by molecular replacement based on the homologous structure of the bovine mitochondrial enzyme. The crystallized complex contains four different subunits in a stoichiometry of alpha(3)beta(3)gammaepsilon. Subunit delta was removed before crystallization to improve the diffraction of the crystals. The overall structure of the noncatalytic alpha-subunits and the catalytic beta-subunits is highly similar to those of the mitochondrial and thermophilic subunits. However, in the crystal structure of the chloroplast enzyme, all alpha- and beta-subunits adopt a closed conformation and appear to contain no bound adenine nucleotides. The superimposed crystallographic symmetry in the space group R32 impaired an exact tracing of the gamma- and epsilon-subunits in the complex. However, clear electron density was present at the core of the alpha(3)beta(3)-subcomplex, which probably represents the C-terminal domain of the gamma-subunit. The structure of the spinach chloroplast F(1) has a potential binding site for the phytotoxin, tentoxin, at the alphabeta-interface near betaAsp(83) and an insertion from betaGly(56)-Asn(60) in the N-terminal beta-barrel domain probably increases the thermal stability of the complex. The structure probably represents an inactive latent state of the ATPase, which is unique to chloroplast and cyanobacterial enzymes.

THECHLOROPLASTATP SYNTHASE: A Rotary Enzyme?

The chloroplast adenosine triphosphate (ATP) synthase is located in the thylakoid membrane and synthesizes ATP from adenosine diphosphate and inorganic phosphate at the expense of the electrochemical proton gradient formed by light-dependent electron flow. The structure, activities, and mechanism of the chloroplast ATP synthase are discussed. Emphasis is given to the inherent structural asymmetry of the ATP synthase and to the implication of this asymmetry to the mechanism of ATP synthesis and hydrolysis. A critical evaluation of the evidence in support of and against the notion that one part of the enzyme rotates with respect to other parts during catalytic turnover is presented. It is concluded that although rotation can occur, whether it is required for activity of the ATP synthase has not been established unequivocally.

Important subunit interactions in the chloroplast ATP synthase

General structural features of the chloroplast ATP synthase are summarized highlighting differences between the chloroplast enzyme and other ATP synthases. Much of the review is focused on the important interactions between the epsilon and gamma subunits of the chloroplast coupling factor 1 (CF(1)) which are involved in regulating the ATP hydrolytic activity of the enzyme and also in transferring energy from the membrane segment, chloroplast coupling factor 0 (CF(0)), to the catalytic sites on CF(1). A simple model is presented which summarizes properties of three known states of activation of the membrane-bound form of CF(1). The three states can be explained in terms of three different bound conformational states of the epsilon subunit. One of the three states, the fully active state, is only found in the membrane-bound form of CF(1). The lack of this state in the isolated form of CF(1), together with the confirmed presence of permanent asymmetry among the alpha, beta and gamma subunits of isolated CF(1), indicate that ATP hydrolysis by isolated CF(1) may involve only two of the three potential catalytic sites on the enzyme. Thus isolated CF(1) may be different from other F(1) enzymes in that it only operates on 'two cylinders' whereby the gamma subunit does not rotate through a full 360 degrees during the catalytic cycle. On the membrane in the presence of a light-induced proton gradient the enzyme assumes a conformation which may involve all three catalytic sites and a full 360 degrees rotation of gamma during catalysis.

Asymmetry of the alpha subunit of the chloroplast ATP synthase as probed by the binding of Lucifer Yellow vinyl sulfone

The catalytic portion of the chloroplast ATP synthase (CF1) is structurally asymmetric. Asymmetry of the otherwise symmetrical alpha3beta3 heterohexamer is induced by the presence of tightly bound nucleotides and interactions with the single-copy, smaller subunits. Lucifer Yellow vinyl sulfone (4-amino-N-[3-(vinylsulfonyl)phenyl]naphthalimide-3,6-disulfonic acid) rapidly and covalently binds to lysine 378 on one alpha subunit [Nalin, C. M., Snyder, B., and McCarty, R. E., (1985) Biochemistry 24, 2318-2324] [Shapiro, A. B. (1991) Ph.D. Thesis, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY). The asymmetrical binding of Lucifer Yellow to CF1 provides a method to investigate the cause of asymmetry in the alpha subunits. The reaction of CF1 with Lucifer Yellow was monitored by total fluorescence of bound Lucifer Yellow as well as by quantitative determination of Lucifer Yellow bound to the tryptic peptide that contains lysine 378 of the alpha subunit. The total binding of Lucifer Yellow to CF1 was not affected by the presence of tightly bound nucleotides or nucleotide in the medium. Neither the total binding of Lucifer Yellow to CF1 nor the reaction of alpha-lysine 378 with Lucifer Yellow was changed by the removal of the epsilon subunit, the delta subunit, or both subunits. The extent of incorporation of Lucifer Yellow into lysine 378 of the alpha subunit in (alphabeta)n was about three times that of Lucifer Yellow incorporation into CF1. Reconstitution of (alphabeta)n with gamma restored the binding of one Lucifer Yellow per alpha3beta3gamma. Therefore, the interactions between gamma and the alphabeta heterohexamer are important in conferring asymmetry to the alpha subunits of CF1.

Photoinactivation of the F1-ATPase from spinach chloroplasts by dequalinium is accompanied by derivatization of methionine beta183

In contrast to the F1-ATPases from bovine mitochondria and the thermophilic Bacillus PS3, which are reversibly inhibited by dequalinium in the absence of irradiation, the Mg2+-ATPase activity of heat- or dithiothreitol-activated chloroplast F1 (CF1) from spinach chloroplasts is slightly stimulated by dequalinium. Conversely, dequalinium is a partial inhibitor (maximal inhibition is 85-90%) of the Ca2+-ATPase of CF1 activated by heat, dithiothreitol, or octylglucoside. The Mg2+- and Ca2+-ATPase activities of CF1 respond differently in the presence of lauryl dimethylamine oxide (LDAO) in the assay medium. Whereas the Mg2+-ATPase activity of heat- or dithiothreitol-activated CF1 is stimulated up to 14-fold by increasing concentrations of LDAO, the Ca2+-ATPase is inhibited in a biphasic manner by increasing concentrations of LDAO. In the presence of LDAO, dequalinium does not stimulate the heat-activated Mg2+-ATPase over that promoted by LDAO alone. That dequalinium slightly stimulates Mg2+-ATPase activity although it inhibits Ca2+-ATPase activity can be reconciled by assuming that dequalinium binds to two sites in CF1, a stimulatory site that also binds LDAO and an inhibitory site. By acting as a partial inhibitor of the Mg2+-ATPase activity that it activates, the combined effect of dequalinium is modest stimulation. Irradiation of heat- or dithiothreitol-activated CF1 or the alpha3beta3gamma subcomplex of CF1 in the presence of 12 microM dequalinium led to rapid photoinactivation. ATP and ADP, separately or in combination with Mg2+, protect against photoinactivation. After photoinactivating the alpha3beta3gamma subcomplex of CF1 with [14C]dequalinium, tryptic and peptic digests of the isolated, derivatized beta subunit were fractionated by high performance liquid chromatography. Sequencing of the isolated, radioactive tryptic and peptic peptides revealed that Metbeta183, which is at or near the catalytic site, is derivatized in a single beta subunit when CF1 is photoinactivated with [14C]dequalinium.

Cross-linking of chloroplast F0F1-ATPase subunit epsilon to gamma without effect on activity. Epsilon and gamma are parts of the rotor

Cys residues were directed into positions 17, 28, 41 and 85 of a Cys6-->Ser mutant of subunit epsilon of spinach chloroplast F0F1 ATP synthase. Wild-type and engineered epsilon were expressed in Escherichia coli, purified in the presence of urea, refolded and reassembled with spinach chloroplast F1 lacking the epsilon subunit [F1(-epsilon)]. Cys-containing epsilon variants were modified with a sulfhydryl-reactive photolabile cross-linker. Photocross-linking of epsilon to F1(-epsilon) yielded the same SDS gel pattern of cross-link products independent of the presence or absence of Mg2+ x ADP, phosphate and Mg2+ x ATP. Epsilon (wild type) [Ser6,Cys28]epsilon and [Ser6,Cys41]epsilon were cross-linked with subunit gamma. With chloroplast F0F1 the same cross-link pattern was obtained, except for one extra cross-link, probably between [Ser6,Cys28]epsilon and F0 subunit III. [Ser6,Cys17]epsilon and [Ser6,Cys85]epsilon did not produce cross-links. Cross-linking of epsilon, [Ser6,Cys28]epsilon, [Ser6,Cys41]epsilon to gamma in soluble chloroplast F1 impaired the ability of epsilon to inhibit Ca2+-ATPase activity. The Mg2+-ATPase activity of soluble F1 (measured in the presence of 30% MeOH) was not affected by cross-linking epsilon with gamma. Functional reconstitution of photophosphorylation in F1-depleted thylakoids was observed with F1 in which gamma was cross-linked to [Ser6,Cys28]epsilon or [Ser6,Cys41]epsilon but not with wild-type epsilon. In view of the intersubunit rotation of gamma relative to (alphabeta)3, which is driven by ATP hydrolysis, gamma and epsilon would seem to act concertedly as parts of the 'rotor' relative to the 'stator' (alphabeta)3.

The coupling of the relative movement of the a and c subunits of the F0 to the conformational changes in the F1-ATPase

F0F1-ATPase structural information gained from X-ray crystallography and electron microscopy has activated interest in a rotational mechanism for the F0F1-ATPase. Because of the subunit stoichiometry and the involvement of both a- and c-subunits in the mechanism of proton movement, it is argued that relative movement must occur between the subunits. Various options for the arrangement and structure of the subunits involved are discussed and a mechanism proposed.

Structural stability of chloroplast coupling factor 1 determined by differential scanning calorimetry and cold inactivation

At least part of the gamma subunit of the catalytic portion of the chloroplast ATP synthase (CF1) is present in the middle of the alpha3beta3 heterohexamer. Interactions of the alpha/beta subunits with the gamma subunit stabilize the hexameric structure. Surprisingly, neither reduction of the gamma disulfide nor selective proteolysis of alpha, beta and gamma affects the thermal stability of EDTA-treated CF1 preparations, as determined by differential scanning calorimetry. Dissociation of the enzyme in the cold may be monitored by loss of the ATPase activity of CF1 subunit depleted of its epsilon subunit [CF1(-epsilon)]. The rate of cold inactivation of ATPase activity of reduced and alkylated CF1(-epsilon) treated with trypsin in solution was much faster than that CF1(-epsilon)(8.1 versus 38.7 min, respectively, for 50% loss of activity). The increased cold liability of the trypsin-treated enzyme was not a consequence of the cleavage of the gamma. CF1 incubated with trypsin under conditions in which gamma is not cleaved was as cold labile as CF1 with cleaved gamma. Instead, loss of the delta subunit and a few residues from the C-terminal of the beta subunits were responsible for the increased cold liability of the enzyme.

Spinach chloroplast coupling factor CF1-alpha 3 beta 3 core complex: structure, stability, and catalytic properties

A minimal chloroplast coupling factor CF1 core complex, containing only alpha and beta subunits, has been isolated from spinach thylakoids [Avital, S., & Gromet-Elhanan, Z. (1991) J. Biol. Chem. 266, 7067-7072]. This CF1(alpha beta) exhibited a low MgATPase activity, which was stimulated but not inhibited by low concentrations of the species-specific CF1 effector tentoxin. As is reported here, the structure of CF1(alpha beta) could not be determined due to its instability. However, its pretreatment with high tentoxin concentrations resulted in a remarkable 50-fold stimulation of the MgATPase activity as well as stabilization of its hexameric structure, thus enabling the isolation of a more active CF1-alpha 3 beta 3 complex by size-exclusion chromatography. A detailed characterization of the MgATPase activity of this tentoxin-stabilized CF1-alpha 3 beta 3 hexamer, as compared to the activity of a CF1 complex lacking the epsilon subunit, revealed similar apparent Km values and a similar stimulation by the presence of 100 microM tentoxin in the assay medium, but drastic differences in all other tested assays. Most pronounced were their different temperature profiles and different responses to all added inhibitors and stimulators of the CF1 MgATPase activity and to excess free Mg2+ ions. The specific properties of the stable CF1-alpha 3 beta 3 hexamer are identical to those earlier reported for its parent-unstable CF1(alpha beta). These results indicate that, although the CF1 gamma subunit is not required for the low CF1(alpha beta) ATPase activity nor for the higher activity of the tentoxin-stabilized CF1-alpha 3 beta 3, it plays a central role in obtaining the typical functional properties of the CF1-ATPase. Kinetic cooperativity could not be critically tested as yet with any F1-alpha 3 beta 3. However, tentoxin, as azide, has been shown to inhibit multisite but not unisite catalysis. Therefore, the observation that CF1-alpha 3 beta 3 is only stimulated by tentoxin suggests that the required presence of CF1-gamma for obtaining inhibition by tentoxin reflects the role of this subunit in cooperative interactions between the catalytic sites.

The photosynthetic F1-α 3β 3 and α 1β 1 catalytic core complexes

Minimal photosynthetic catalytic F1(αβ) core complexes, containing equimolar ratios of the α and β subunits, were isolated from membrane-bound spinach chloroplast CF1 and Rhodospirillum rubrum chromatophore RrF1. A CF1-α3β3 hexamer and RrF1-α1β1 dimer, which were purified from the respective F1(αβ) complexes, exhibit lower rates and different properties from their parent F1-ATPases. Most interesting is their complete resistance to inhibition by the general F1 inhibitor azide and the specific CF1 inhibitor tentoxin. These inhibitors were earlier reported to inhibit multisite, but not unisite, catalysis in all sensitive F1-ATPases and were therefore suggested to block catalytic site cooperativity. The absence of this typical property of all F1-ATPases in the α1β1 dimer is consistant with the view that the dimer contains only a single catalytic site. The α3β3 hexamer contains however all F1 catalytic sites. Therefore the observation that CF1-α3β3 can bind tentoxin and is stimulated by it suggests that the F1γ subunit, which is required for obtaining inhibition by tentoxin as well as azide, plays an important role in the cooperative interactions between the F1-catalytic sites.

In vitro assembly of the core catalytic complex of the chloroplast ATP synthase

The regulatory gamma subunit and an alpha beta complex were isolated from the catalytic F1 portion of the chloroplast ATP synthase. The isolated gamma subunit was devoid of catalytic activity, whereas the alpha beta complex exhibited a very low ATPase activity (approximately 200 nmol/min/mg of protein). The alpha beta complex migrated as a hexameric alpha 3 beta 3 complex during ultracentrifugation and gel filtration but reversibly dissociated into alpha and beta monomers after freezing and thawing in the presence of ethylenediamine tetraacetic acid and in the absence of nucleotides. Conditions are described in which the gamma and alpha beta preparations were combined to rapidly and efficiently reconstitute a fully functional catalytic core enzyme complex. The reconstituted enzyme exhibited normal tight binding and sensitivity to the inhibitory epsilon subunit and to the allosteric inhibitor tentoxin. However, neither the alpha beta complex nor the isolated gamma subunit alone could bind the epsilon subunit or tentoxin with high affinity. Similarly, high affinity binding sites for ATP and ADP, which are characteristic of the core alpha 3 beta 3 gamma enzyme, were absent from the alpha beta complex. The results indicate that when the gamma subunit binds to the alpha beta complex, it induces a three-dimensional conformation in the enzyme, which is necessary for tight binding of the inhibitors and for high-affinity, asymmetric nucleotide binding.

Reassembly of Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803 F1-ATPase from its over-expressed subunits

Subunits alpha, beta, and gamma of the F1-part of cyanobacterial F0F1-ATPase have been cloned into expression vectors. Over-expressed subunit beta was found soluble in the cytoplasmic fraction of Escherichia coli cells under appropriate culture and induction conditions and was purified from cell extracts. Recombinant alpha and gamma subunits precipitated into inclusion bodies and had to be solubilized, purified and refolded. The correct folding and functional integrity of the alpha and beta subunits was monitored by their ability to bind nucleotides. Active cyanobacterial F1-ATPase was assembled from its purified subunits alpha, beta, gamma, delta and epsilon. The reassembled enzyme reconstituted ATP synthesis in F1-depleted thylakoid membranes of Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803 and hydrolyzed ATP.

Malate regulation of Mg(2+)-ATPase of chloroplast coupling factor 1

The regulatory effects of malate on chloroplast Mg(2+)-ATPase were investigated and the mechanism was discussed. Malate stimulated methanol-activated membrane-bound and isolated CF1 Mg(2+)-ATPase activity. The γ subunit of CF1 may be involved in malate regulation of the enzyme function. Modification of γ subunit at one site of the peptide by NEM may affect malate stimulation of ATPase while at another site may have no effect. The effect of malate on the Mg(2+)-ATPase was also controlled by the Mg(2+)/ATP ratio in the reaction medium. The enhancing effect of malate on Mg(2+)-ATPase activity depended on the presence of high concentrations of Mg(2+) in the reaction mixture. Kinetic study showed that malate raised the Vmax of catalysis without affecting the Km for Mg(2+) ATP. The experiments imply that the stimulation of Mg(2+)-ATPase by malate is probably correlated with the Pi binding site on the enzyme. The regulation of ATPase activity by malate in chloroplasts may be relevant to its function in vivo.

ATP synthase of yeast mitochondria. Isolation of the F1 delta subunit, sequence and disruption of the structural gene

The delta-subunit was isolated from the purified yeast F1. Partial protein sequences were determined by direct methods. From this information, degenerated primers were constructed. A part of the ATP delta gene was amplified by polymerase chain reaction from yeast genomic DNA. From the amplified DNA sequence, a nondegenerated oligonucleotide probe was constructed to isolate a 2.6-kbp BamHI-EcoRI DNA fragment bearing the whole gene. A 1036-bp DraI fragment was sequenced. A 480-bp open reading frame encoding a 160-amino-acid polypeptide is described. The deduced amino acid sequence is 22 amino acids longer than the mature protein, which is 138 amino acids long with a mass of 14,555 Da. The delta-subunit of Saccharomyces cerevisiae is 21%, 35%, 52% identical and 66%, 61% and 92% similar to the epsilon-subunit of Escherichia coli and the delta-subunits of beef heart and Neurospora crassa, respectively. A null mutant was constructed. The mutation was recessive and dramatically affected mitochondrial DNA stability since the transformed cells were 100% cytoplasmic petite. The double mutant (rho-, ATP delta::URA3) displayed low or no ATPase activity with an unstable catalytic sector, since a polyclonal antibody directed against the beta subunit did not coprecipitate the alpha subunit.

Identification of subunits required for the catalytic activity of the F1-ATPase

F1 (alpha beta) complexes containing equimolar ratios of the alpha and beta subunits have been shown to function as active ATPases, whereas individually isolated alpha and beta subunits show no real ATPase activity. These results indicate that the single-copy subunits are not required for F1-ATPase activity. The minimal F1 (alpha beta)-core complexes exhibit, however, lower rates and some different properties from those of their parent whole F1 or alpha 3 beta 3 gamma complexes. It is therefore concluded that for obtaining a full spectrum of the characteristic functional properties of an F1-ATPase the presence of the F1-gamma subunit is also required. The implications of these findings on the subunit location of both catalytic and noncatalytic nucleotide binding sites is discussed.

Zero-length crosslinking between subunits delta and I of the H(+)-translocating ATPase of chloroplasts

Treatment of spinach thylakoids with 1-ethyl-3-(dimethylaminopropyl)-carbodiimide (EDC)/N-hydroxysulfosuccinimide (sulfo-NHS) induced formation of a zero-length crosslink of an apparent molecular mass of 38 kDa. This product was shown, by immunodetection, to consist of subunit delta of CF1 and subunit I of CF0. The crosslink was isolated by preparative SDS gel electrophoresis and subjected to cyanogen bromide cleavage. Electrophoretic and immunological analysis of the resulting peptides suggested that the crosslink was formed between a glutamyl or aspartyl residue at the C-terminal end of subunit I and a basic amino acid of subunit delta in the range between Val-1 to Met-165. Treatment of thylakoids with EDC/Sulfo-NHS resulted in inhibition of photophosphorylation and CF0CF1-catalyzed ATP hydrolysis without affecting formation of a proton gradient related to phenazine methosulfate-mediated cyclic electron transport. Inhibition of H+ transport-coupled ATP hydrolysis was more pronounced than non-coupled methanol-stimulated ATP hydrolysis. The results suggest that subunits delta and I form a connection between the partial complexes CF1 and CF0 in situ. Crosslinking of the two subunits may impede the translocation of protons through CF0CF1.

The dithiothreitol-stimulated dissociation of the chloroplast coupling factor 1 epsilon-subunit is reversible

The chloroplast coupling factor 1 complex (CF1) contains an epsilon-subunit which inhibits the CF1 ATPase activity. Chloroform treatment of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii thylakoid membranes solubilizes only forms of the enzyme which apparently lack the delta-subunit. Four interrelated observations are described in this paper. (1) The dithiothreitol- (DTT) induced ATPase activation of CF1(-delta) and the DTT-induced formation of a physically resolvable CF1(-delta,epsilon) from the CF1(-delta) precursor are compared. The similar time-courses of these two phenomena suggest that the dissociation of the epsilon-subunit is an obligatory process in the DTT-induced ATPase activation of soluble CF1. (2) The reversible dissociation of the epsilon-subunit of the CF1 is demonstrated by the exchange of subunits between distinguishable oligomers. 35S-labelled chloroplast coupling factor 1 lacking the delta and epsilon subunits [CF1(-delta,epsilon)] was added to a solution of non-radioactive coupling factor 1 lacking only the delta subunit [CF1(-delta)]. After separation of the two enzyme forms, via high resolution anion-exchange chromatography, radioactivity was detected in the chromatographic fractions containing CF1(-delta). (3) epsilon-deficient CF1 can be resolved from DTT pretreated epsilon-containing CF1 for several days after the removal of DTT. On the other hand, brief incubation of the DTT pretreated epsilon-containing CF1 with low concentrations of o-iodosobenzoate results in chromatographs containing only the peak of epsilon-containing CF1. A simple explanation for this phenomenon is that reduction of CF1 with DTT increases the apparent dissociation constant for the epsilon-subunit to an estimated 3.5 x 10(-8) M (+/- 1.0 x 10(-8) M) from a value of less than or equal to 5 x 10(-11) M for the oxidized enzyme. (4) ATPase activity data show that oxidation of the epsilon-deficient enzyme does not completely inhibit its manifest activity, but oxidation of DTT pre-treated CF1 which contains the epsilon-subunit completely inhibits manifest activity. A simple model is proposed for the influence of the oxidation state of the soluble enzyme on the distribution of ATPase-inactive and ATPase-active subunit configurations.

Cotranscription of the wild-type chloroplast atpE gene encoding the CF1/CF0 epsilon subunit with the 3' half of the rps7 gene in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii and characterization of frameshift mutations in atpE

We have characterized two independently isolated point mutants in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii, ac-u-a-1-15 and FUD 17, mapping to the chloroplast ac-u-a locus which corresponds to the atpE gene. Both mutants have a single A:T base pair deletion in a sequence of 6 A:T base pairs at nucleotide positions 102 to 107. This causes a frameshift, altering the coding sequence for the next 8 amino acids and creating a termination codon at amino acid position 44, 98 amino acids from the C-terminus of the protein. Assembly of the ATP synthase is impaired in the mutants; less than 5% of the wild-type level of alpha and beta subunits and no gamma or epsilon subunits are associated with thylakoid membranes of the mutants. The genes encoding the beta and epsilon subunits of the chloroplast ATP synthase from C. reinhardtii are not cotranscribed, in contrast to all other photosynthetic organisms examined to date. Four transcripts, of approximately 1.7, 2.9, 3.3 and 7.0 x 10(3) nucleotides (nt), are found for the atpE gene. S1 nuclease mapping of the 1.7 x 10(3) nt transcript shows that the atpE gene message is preceded by a leader of about 1250 nt. DNA sequence analysis of this region revealed a 159 bp open reading frame corresponding to the 3' half of the rps7 gene, encoding the S7 protein of the small subunit of the chloroplast ribosome. Only the 5' portion of this gene is located in the opposite unique sequence region of the C. reinhardtii chloroplast genome where the rps7 gene was previously mapped by heterologous hybridization.

Subunit delta of H(+)-ATPases: at the interface between proton flow and ATP synthesis

The ATP synthases in photophosphorylation and respiration are of the F-type with a membrane-bound proton channel, F0, and an extrinsic catalytic portion, F1. The properties of one particular subunit, delta (in chloroplasts and Escherichia coli) and OSCP (in mitochondria), are reviewed and the role of this subunit at the interface between F0 and F1 is discussed. Delta and OSCP from the three sources have in common the molecular mass (approximately 20 kDa), an elongated shape (axial ratio in solution about 3:1), one high-affinity binding site to F1 (Kd approximately 100 nM) plus probably one or two further low-affinity sites. When isolated delta is added to CF1-depleted thylakoid membranes, it can block proton flow through exposed CF0 channels, as do CF1 or CF1(-delta)+ delta. This identifies delta as part of the proton conductor or, alternatively, conformational energy transducer between F0 (proton flow) and F1 (ATP). Hybrid constructs as CF1(-delta)+ E. coli delta and EF1(-delta)+ chloroplast delta diminish proton flow through CF0.CF1(-delta) + E. coli delta does the same on EF0. Impairment of proton leaks either through CF0 or through EF0 causes "structural reconstitution' of ATP synthesis by remaining intact F0F1. Functional reconstitution (ATP synthesis by fully reconstructed F0F1), however, is absolutely dependent on the presence of subunit delta and is therefore observed only with CF1 or CF1(-delta) + chloroplast delta on CF0 and EF1 or EF1(-delta) + E. coli delta on EF0. The effect of hybrid constructs on F0 channels is surprising in view of the limited sequence homology between chloroplast and E. coli delta (36% conserved residues including conservative replacements). An analysis of the distribution of the conserved residues at present does not allow us to discriminate between the postulated conformational or proton-conductive roles of subunit delta.

Chloroplast ATP synthase contains one single copy of subunit delta that is indispensable for photophosphorylation

F0F1 ATP synthases synthesize ATP in their F1 portion at the expense of free energy supplied by proton flow which enters the enzyme through their channel portion F0. The smaller subunits of F1, especially subunit delta, may act as energy transducers between these rather distant functional units. We have previously shown that chloroplast delta, when added to thylakoids partially depleted of the coupling factor CF1, can reconstitute photophosphorylation by inhibiting proton leakage through exposed coupling factor CF0. In view of controversies in the literature, we reinvestigated two further aspects related to subunit delta, namely (a) its stoichiometry in CF0CF1 and (b) whether or not delta is required for photophosphorylation. By rocket immunoelectrophoresis of thylakoid membranes and calibration against purified delta, we confirmed a stoichiometry of one delta per CF0CF1. In CF1-depleted thylakoids photophosphorylation could be reconstituted not only by adding CF1 and subunit delta but, surprisingly, also by CF1 (-delta). We found that the latter was attributable to a contamination of CF1 (-delta) preparations with integral CF1. To lesser extent CF1 (-delta) acted by complementary rebinding to CF0 channels that were closed because they contained delta [CF0(+delta)]. This added catalytic capacity to proton-tight thylakoid vesicles. The ability of subunit delta to control proton flow through CF0 and the absolute requirement for delta in restoration of photophosphorylation suggest an essential role of this small subunit at the interface between the large portions of ATP synthase: delta may be part of the coupling site between electrochemical, conformational and chemical events in this enzyme.