Environmental mutagen testing in Escherichia coli and phage lambda

The role of formaldehyde and S-chloromethylglutathione in the bacterial mutagenicity of methylene chloride

Methylene chloride was less mutagenic in Salmonella typhimurium TA100/NG-11 (glutathione-deficient) compared to TA100, indicating that glutathione is involved in the activation of methylene chloride to a mutagen in bacteria. In rodents, the pathway of methylene chloride metabolism utilizing glutathione produces formaldehyde via a postulated S-chloromethylglutathione conjugate (GSCH2Cl). Formaldehyde is known to cause DNA-protein cross-links, and GSCH2Cl may act as a monofunctional DNA alkylator by analogy with the glutathione conjugates of 1,2-dihaloalkanes. The lack of sensitivity of Salmonella TA100 towards formaldehyde (Schmid et al., Mutagenesis, 1 (1986) No. 6, 427-431) suggests that GSCH2Cl is responsible for methylene chloride mutagenicity in Salmonella. In Escherichia coli K12 (AB1157), formaldehyde was mutagenic only in the wild-type, a characteristic shared with cross-linking agents, whereas 1,2-dibromoethane (1,2-DBE) was more mutagenic in uvrA cells (AB1886). Methylene chloride, activated by S9 from mouse liver, was mutagenic only in wild-type cells, suggesting a mutagenic role for metabolically derived formaldehyde in E. coli. Mouse-liver S9 also enhanced the cell-killing effect of methylene chloride in the uvrA, and a recA/uvrA double mutant (AB2480) which is very sensitive to DNA damage. This pattern was consistent with formaldehyde damage. However, a mutagenic role in bacteria for the glutathione conjugate of methylene chloride cannot be ruled out by these E. coli experiments because S9 fractions did not increase 1,2-DBE mutagenicity, suggesting lack of cell wall penetration by this reactive species. Rat-liver S9 did not activate methylene chloride to a bacterial mutagen or enhance methylene chloride-induced cell-killing, which is consistent with the carcinogenicity difference between the species.

DNA damage and prophage induction and toxicity of nitrofurantoin in Escherichia coli and Vibrio cholerae cells

Repair-deficient and repair-proficient strains of E. coli K12 were sensitive to nitrofurantoin treatment to varying degrees with the double mutant strain (uvrA 6, recA 13) being most sensitive. Ultraviolet absorption data and thermal chromatography through a hydroxyapatite column revealed that nitrofurantoin treatment of V. cholerae strain OGAWA 154 produced a maximal amount of 55% reversibly bihelical DNA at a nitrofurantoin dose of 120 micrograms/ml/h, which indicated the formation of inter-strand cross-links in DNA. Nitrofurantoin also produced prophage-lambda induction in E. coli K12 strain GY 5027: envA, uvrB, ampA 1, strA (lambda), in a dose-dependent manner, the maximum induction being highly significant (P less than 0.001). Previously published mutation data coupled with the prophage induction data presented here suggest that the genotoxic properties of nitrofurantoin are mediated through the SOS pathway.

DNA damage by 5-nitro-2-furylacrylic acid, a nitrofuran derivative

5-Nitro-2-furylacrylic acid (5-NFA) caused dose dependent inhibition of growth of Escherichia coli K-12 strain AB 2480 (uvr-, rec-), the 37% (D37) and 10% (D10) survival doses being 1.0 microgram/ml.h and 1.75 micrograms/ml.h, respectively. Although much higher doses of drug were required to achieve comparable inhibition of growth of E. coli strain 1157 (repair proficient), significant filamentation of these cells was produced by treatment with 1.0 microgram/ml 5-NFA for 4 hr. Ultraviolet absorption data and thermal chromatography through hydroxyapatite (HAP) column revealed that 5-NFA treatment of E. coli strain AB 2480 produced more than 80% of DNA reversibly bihelical due to the formation of interstrand cross-links and the initial part of the reaction obeyed a first order relation. 5-NFA also produced dose-dependent increase of prophage induction in E. coli strain GY 5027: envA, uvrB, ampA1, strA (lambda). The implications of the action of 5-NFA on DNA in relation to the induction of 'SOS' functions and carcinogenesis were discussed.

Induction of lambda prophage by furazolidone

A dose-dependent prophage induction by furazolidone exhibited a gradual rise to a maximum, corresponding to an exposure dose of 1.2 microgram/ml X h and a gradual fall thereafter. A 2-3-fold higher level of induction was achieved when the lysogens were treated with furazolidone in the presence of a metabolizing mixture. A maximum of about 70% efficiency of induction was achieved. Kinetics of prophage induction by any concentration of furazolidone exhibited a common pattern, viz., an initial rise for 15-20 min, then a plateau extending up to about 60 min and a faster rise thereafter. Higher concentrations of the drug (10 micrograms/ml) exhibited a toxic effect. Chloramphenicol at a concentration of 20 micrograms/ml inhibited the furazolidone-induced prophage induction, the plaque-forming units gradually decreasing from several minutes after the chloramphenicol treatment. The burst size of the lysogens was not significantly affected by treatment with 2 micrograms/ml of furazolidone up to a period of about 10 min, but thereafter, decreased faster with the duration of furazolidone treatment. The "latent period' of induction decreased linearly with the duration of furazolidone treatment.

SOS chromotest, a direct assay of induction of an SOS function in Escherichia coli K-12 to measure genotoxicity

We present and evaluate the SOS chromotest, a bacterial test for detecting DNA-damaging agents. It is a colorimetric assay based on the induction by these agents of the SOS function sfiA, whose level of expression is monitored by means of a sfiA::lacZ operon fusion. The response is rapid (a few hours), and does not require survival of the tester strain. Dose-response curves for various chemicals include a linear region. The slope of this region is taken as a measure of the SOS inducing potency. Comparison for a number of substances of known genotoxicity of the SOS inducing potency determined in the SOS chromotest with the mutagenic potency determined in the Salmonella assay (mutatest) revealed a striking quantitative correlation over more than 7 orders of magnitude. The sensitivity of the SOS chromotest (lowest amount detected) is equal to that of the mutatest and generally 4-40 times higher than that of a phage induction assay (inductest). From a practical point of view our observations contribute to the validation of the SOS chromotest as a test for detecting genotoxins and in particular genotoxic carcinogens. From a theoretical standpoint the results suggest that mutagenic potency measured in the mutatest reflects the level of induction of an SOS function and that most genotoxins are inducers of the SOS response in bacteria.

The SOS chromotest: direct assay of the expression of gene sfiA as a measure of genotoxicity of chemicals

We used a gene fusion, placing the lacZ gene encoding beta-galactosidase under the control of the sfiA promoter, to construct a new tester strain for genotoxic agents. The assay is performed in a few hours and involves simple enzymatic assays. The dose response curves contain a linear portion which enables to define the SOS Inducing Potency (SOSIP) of compounds. For the compounds tested SOSIPs extend over 7 decades and correlate generally well with the mutagenic potency assayed in the Salmonella/microsome assay (Mutatest) and in a phage induction assay (Inductest). Sensitivities (lowest amount detected) are comparable in the SOS Chromotest and Mutatest but lower in the Inductest. Our results suggest that at least part of the response in the Mutatest depends on the induction of an SOS function, and that most of the genotoxins are inducer of the SOS system -i.e. can lead to activation of the RecA protease.

Comparative evaluation of different pairs of DNA repair-deficient and DNA repair-proficient bacterial tester strains for rapid detection of chemical mutagens and carcinogens

The aim of the present study was to evaluate the usefulness of different pairs of DNA repair-deficient and DNA repair-proficient bacterial tester strains in a mutagenicity/carcinogenicity screen, possibly as complements to the Ames test. 70 carcinogenic and non-carcinogenic compounds, representing a variety of chemical structures, were tested for their DNA-damaging effects, using 6 different DNA-repair-deficient bacterial strains. 2 Bacillus subtilis systems, H17/M45 and HLL3g/HJ-15, were used. The susceptibility of Escherichia coli AB1157 was compared with the susceptibility of 4 recombination-deficient mutants, JC5547, JC2921, JC2926 and JC5519. The test compounds were applied onto paper disks (spot test, ST), or incorporated into a top agar layer (agar-incorporation test, AT). The 2 B. subtilis systems were generally found to be more sensitive and reliable than the assays using E coli. The incorporation of the test compounds in the agar increased the sensitivity of the test for polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and other poorly water-soluble compounds. Hydrazines and several other highly polar chemicals could be tested more efficiently when applied onto paper disks. About 30% of the test compounds did not induce any growth inhibition and so could not be tested properly. In order to evaluate the ability of these DNA-repair tests to complement the Ames Salmonella mutagenicity test in a genetic toxicology screening program, results from this study were compared with published data both on mutagenicity in the Ames test and on carcinogenicity. 8 carcinogens generally found to be non-mutagenic for Salmonella were tested: 2 showed DNA-damaging properties (mitomycin C, 1,2-dimethylhydrazine), 5 failed to do so (actinomycin D, griseofulvin, thioacetamide, diethylstilbestrol, safrole), and one (thiourea) was not toxic, so that no classification was possible. 2 non-carcinogenic bacterial mutagens were examined; one, sodium azide, was equitoxic for repair-proficient and -deficient strains, while the other, nitrofurantoin, primarily inhibited repair-deficient strains. The DNA-repair tests failed to indicate the mutagenic and carcinogenic properties of acridine orange. Nalidixic acid, a non-mutagenic DNA synthesis inhibitor, damaged bacterial DNA. Apart from the differences summarized above, carcinogenicity was indicated correctly by the Salmonella S9 assay and most sets of DNA-repair-deficient and DNA-repair-proficient tester strains evaluated in this study. Thus, several more carcinogens could be detected by performing the Ames test and the bacterial DNA-repair tests in tandem than by using either test alone. Nevertheless, the use of both bacterial in vitro systems in a battery of short-term tests for mutagenicity/carcinogenicity evaluation is not considered to be ideal, since the Ames test and the pairs of DNA-repair-deficient and DNA-repair-proficient tester strains used had several shortcomings in common under the conditions of this study.

Microbial short-term assays with thiram in vitro

The fungicide thiram was assayed in the following tests in vitro, with and without metabolic activation: (1) prophage lambda induction of Escherichia coli K12; (2) repair test in Salmonella typhimurium (strains TA1538 and TA1978); (3) induction of gene mutations in Aspergillus nidulans (methA1 suppressor induction). Thiram was positive in the repair test and in the A. nidulans forward-mutation test (4-6 fold increase) in the absence of metabolic activation. A slight increase was observed in prophage lambda induction with thiram in the presence of the metabolic activation system.

Deoxyribonucleic Acid Repair in Bacillus subtilis : Development of Competent Cells into a Tester for Carcinogens

The development of competent transformed Bacillus subtilis into a tester system for carcinogens is described. Precocious or noninduced activation of SOS functions occur in competent cells. Thus, lower doses or concentrations of SOS inducing agents are needed to cause cell death due to indigenous prophage activation and lysis of bacteria. The two known defective prophages in B. subtilis enhance the sensitivity of competent cells to the carcinogens ultraviolet light, mitomycin C, and methyl methanesulfonate. However, these same cells have no enhanced sensitivity for the non-carcinogenic ethyl methanesulfonate or for nalidixic acid. Therefore, competent B. subtilis appear to be a sensitive tester for carcinogens.

Forward mutations to arabinose resistance in Salmonella typhimurium strains: a sensitive assay for mutagenicity testing

The forward-mutation assay using the L-arabinose-sensitive strain SV3 of Salmonella typhimurium has been calibrated against a selected set of mutagens. Strain SV3 is sensitive to chemicals causing base-pair substitutions, frameshift mutations and deletions. New strains deficient for the excision-repair system or the lipopolysaccharide barrier or both have been selected from strain SV3. The additional mutations do not affect the independence of the assay from experimental artifacts due to physiological or lethal damage or differences in plating density. The new strains are more sensitive than SV3 to certain mutagens. Techniques for using this set of strains are presented and their relative advantages discussed.

In vitro mutagenesis assays as predictors of chemical carcinogenesis in mammals

In vitro microbial mutagenesis assays coupled with mammalian activation systems offer promising technique to screen chemicals for their potential carcinogenic activity. The correlation between mutagenic and carcinogenic properties for a large array of chemicals is approximately 0.9. The best correlation exists for those carcinogens which are themselves highly electrophilic or produce electrophilic metabolites. Correlation between mutagenicity and carcinogenicity for hormonal, metallic, or physical carcinogens has been disappointing but not unexpected based on their proposed mechanisms of action. In addition to the application of in vitro mutagenesis techniques to screening chemicals for the identification of potential carcinogens, they are useful tools for investigating genetic, biochemical, and pharmacologic properties of different animal species. Studies with the chemical carcinogen dimethylnitrosamine have been conducted and show a functional relationship between mutagenesis and carcinogenesis. The assays can also be conducted using activation systems prepared from the tissues of any mammalian species. This permits a direct assessment of phylogenic extrapolation by comparing the metabolic activation capabilities of tissues from several mammalian species, including human samples. The advantages of mutagenicity testing are the short period of time required for results, the high sensitivity of the assay (microgram of nanogram quantities of chemicals can be used), and the fact that the ultimate agent can be detected biologically without first necessitating chemical identification and isolation. It appears from current studies that in vitro mutagenesis techniques may well open new avenues of investigation into some old toxicologic problems.

Development and applications of Bacillus subtilis test systems for mutagens, involving DNA-repair deficiency and suppressible auxotrophic mutations

A mutagen-tester of Bacillus subtilis was constructed and tested with known carcinogens. The parental strain HA101 of Okubo and Yanagida carrying suppressible nonsense mutations in his and met genes was transformed to carry an excision-repair deficiency mutation. The constructed strain TKJ5211 showed a 20--30-fold higher sensitivity for His+ reversion than the parental strain when treated with UV and UV-mimetic chemicals but unchanged mutation frequency with X-rays and methyl methanesulfonate. The tester strain was used in a spot test of 30 selected chemicals and also for testing with liver homogenate activation. The results showed an almost equivalent but somewhat broader detection spectrum than the Salmonella typhimurium TA100 system. Another test method used a pair of B. subtilis strains differing in their DNA-repair capacity, i.e. the most UV-sensitive mutant HJ-15 and a wild-type strain, to detect repair-dependent DNA damage produced by chemicals. Spores could be used in either test.

Genetic activity of the antimicrobial food additives AF-2 and H-193 in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

The genetic activity of the antimicrobial food additives AF-2 and H-193 has been investigated in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. The strains chosen for the present studies were D5 for the induction of mitotic recombinational events and XV185-14C for the induction of reversion of the mutants lys1-1, his1-7 and homs3-7. When three concentrations (25, 50 and 100 mug/ml) of AF-2 were used in the reversion system of strain XV185-14C, there was an increase in the frequency of hom+ and his+ revertants as a function of incubation time, while the lysine mutant exhibited a very low frequency of induced reversion. When AF-2 and H-193 were compared at the same concentration and exposure time, AF-2 exhibited a higher genetic activity in both systems than H-193. However, H-193 was genetically more active in inducing revertants than AF-2, when the comparison was made at the same survival level. Cells of both haploid and diploid strains were found to be more sensitive to inactivation by AF-2 than by H-193 It should be pointed out that the solubility of H-193 was lower (about 4 mug/ml saturation) than the solubility of AF-2 (120 mug/ml saturation). The haploid strain was more sensitive to both compounds than the diploid strain.

Comparative analysis of deletion and base-change mutabilities of Escherichia coli B strains differing in DNA repair capacity (wild-type, uvrA-, polA-, recA-) by various mutagens

Dose-response curves were compared for deletions [ColBR (resistant to colicin B) mutations being more than 80% deletions] and base changes (reversion of argFam to prototrophy argplus) induced in the same set of E. coli strains (wild-type for DNA repair, uvrA-, polA- and recA-) by N-methyl-N'-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine (NTG), ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS), hydroxylamine (HA), 4-nitroquinoline I-oxide (4NQO), mitomycin C (MTC, UV and X-rays. All these agents induced deletions as well as base changes in the wild-type strain. Thus chemical mutagenesis differed in E. coli and bacteriophages in vitro, for HA, NTG, EMS and perhaps UV produced only point mutations in phage Tr. The patterns of deletion and base-change mutability in E. coli were surprisingly similar. (I) The recombination less recA- strain was mutable by only three (NTG, EMS, HA) of the seven mutagens for either deletions or base changes. (2) The uvrA- strain, unable to excise pyrimidine dimers, was very highly mutable by 4NQO and UV but immutable by MTC for both deletions and base changes. (3) The polA- strain, defective in DNA polymerase I due to a non-suppressible mutation, was very highly mutable by HA and highly mutable by MTC and 4NQO for both deletions and base changes but was highly mutable only for deletions by UV and X-rays, remaining normally mutable by the other agents for both deletions and base changes despite its high sensitivity to their inactivating action. We conclude that errors in the recA-dependent repair of induced DNA damage (after 4NQO, MTC, UV and X-rays) or errors in replication enhanced by damage to the replication system or to the template strands (after NTG, EMS, and HA) give rise to deletions as well as to base changes. From a comparative analysis of 14 dose-response curves for deletions and base changes, we conclude that the order of mutagenic efficiency relative to killing is (EMS, NTG) greater than (UV, 4NQO) greater than HA greater than (X-rays, MTC), and that X-rays, 4NQO, HA and MTC induce more ColBR deletions than Argplus base changes, whereas UV and EMS induce ColBR deletions and Argplus base changes at nearly equal rates and the specificity of NTG is intermediate between these two types.