Pharyngitis clinical prediction rules: effect of interobserver agreement: a MetroNet study

Accuracy of Signs and Symptoms for the Diagnosis of Acute Rhinosinusitis and Acute Bacterial Rhinosinusitis

PURPOSE

To evaluate the accuracy of signs and symptoms for the diagnosis of acute rhinosinusitis (ARS).

METHODS

We searched Medline to identify studies of outpatients with clinically suspected ARS and sufficient data reported to calculate the sensitivity and specificity. Of 1,649 studies initially identified, 17 met our inclusion criteria. Acute rhinosinusitis was diagnosed by any valid reference standard, whereas acute bacterial rhinosinusitis (ABRS) was diagnosed by purulence on antral puncture or positive bacterial culture. We used bivariate meta-analysis to calculate summary estimates of test accuracy.

RESULTS

Among patients with clinically suspected ARS, the prevalence of imaging confirmed ARS is 51% and ABRS is 31%. Clinical findings that best rule in ARS are purulent secretions in the middle meatus (positive likelihood ratio [LR+] 3.2) and the overall clinical impression (LR+ 3.0). The findings that best rule out ARS are the overall clinical impression (negative likelihood ratio [LR-] 0.37), normal transillumination (LR- 0.55), the absence of preceding respiratory tract infection (LR- 0.48), any nasal discharge (LR- 0.49), and purulent nasal discharge (LR- 0.54). Based on limited data, the overall clinical impression (LR+ 3.8, LR- 0.34), cacosmia (fetid odor on the breath) (LR+ 4.3, LR- 0.86) and pain in the teeth (LR+ 2.0, LR- 0.77) are the best predictors of ABRS. While several clinical decision rules have been proposed, none have been prospectively validated.

CONCLUSIONS

Among patients with clinically suspected ARS, only about one-third have ABRS. The overall clinical impression, cacosmia, and pain in the teeth are the best predictors of ABRS. Clinical decision rules, including those incorporating C-reactive protein, and use of urine dipsticks are promising, but require prospective validation.

Selective testing strategies for diagnosing group A streptococcal infection in children with pharyngitis: a systematic review and prospective multicentre external validation study

BACKGROUND

Several clinical prediction rules for diagnosing group A streptococcal infection in children with pharyngitis are available. We aimed to compare the diagnostic accuracy of rules-based selective testing strategies in a prospective cohort of children with pharyngitis.

METHODS

We identified clinical prediction rules through a systematic search of MEDLINE and Embase (1975-2014), which we then validated in a prospective cohort involving French children who presented with pharyngitis during a 1-year period (2010-2011). We diagnosed infection with group A streptococcus using two throat swabs: one obtained for a rapid antigen detection test (StreptAtest, Dectrapharm) and one obtained for culture (reference standard). We validated rules-based selective testing strategies as follows: low risk of group A streptococcal infection, no further testing or antibiotic therapy needed; intermediate risk of infection, rapid antigen detection for all patients and antibiotic therapy for those with a positive test result; and high risk of infection, empiric antibiotic treatment.

RESULTS

We identified 8 clinical prediction rules, 6 of which could be prospectively validated. Sensitivity and specificity of rules-based selective testing strategies ranged from 66% (95% confidence interval [CI] 61-72) to 94% (95% CI 92-97) and from 40% (95% CI 35-45) to 88% (95% CI 85-91), respectively. Use of rapid antigen detection testing following the clinical prediction rule ranged from 24% (95% CI 21-27) to 86% (95% CI 84-89). None of the rules-based selective testing strategies achieved our diagnostic accuracy target (sensitivity and specificity>85%).

INTERPRETATION

Rules-based selective testing strategies did not show sufficient diagnostic accuracy in this study population. The relevance of clinical prediction rules for determining which children with pharyngitis should undergo a rapid antigen detection test remains questionable.

Chronic Pharyngitis: Role of Atypical Organisms

Background

Bacteria including Chlamydophila pneumoniae, Mycoplasma pneumoniae, and anaerobic bacteria such as Fusobacterium necrophorum have been implicated as etiological agents of chronic pharyngitis in Western literature. Because there are no data regarding this from India, the authors undertook this study.

Study Design

Prospective case-control study.

Setting

Tertiary-level medical college and hospital.

Method

In total, 343 consecutive adults with persistent throat pain and/or irritation (duration ≥3 months) were screened for known causes of pharyngitis by a thorough clinical and endoscopic examination. In 71 patients, the evaluation performed was unable to determine any cause, and these were considered cases. An enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay test to detect IgA and IgG antibodies to C pneumoniae and M pneumoniae was performed on 66 of these cases and 62 controls. The posterior pharyngeal swabs taken from both the cases and controls were subjected to aerobic and anaerobic culture.

Results

Individuals with chronic pharyngitis had a 3.43 times odds of being seropositive for C pneumoniae as compared with controls ( P = .001; odds ratio = 3.43). Aerobic organisms and M pneumoniae did not seem to be significant etiological agents for chronic pharyngitis. On the contrary, isolation of Fusobacterium spp was found to be significantly more in controls as compared with cases.

Conclusion

This study suggests an association between IgA antibodies to C pneumoniae and chronic pharyngitis. Further studies using more specific tests combined with long-term follow-up are needed to confirm these findings.

Assessment of helicobacter pylori prevalence by scorpion real-time PCR in chronic tonsillitis patients

Background:

Occasionally, bacteria or viruses enter the tonsils and these organs become overwhelmed by bacterial or viral infection leading to inflammation. Some studies confirmed the presence of Helicobacter pylori in tonsillar specimens of patients suffering from chronic tonsillitis and some others did not. The difference in results in various studies might be due to different laboratory methods. The aim of this study was to investigate the presence of H. pylori Deoxynucleic acid (DNA) in archival tonsillar tissues of patients with chronic tonsillitis by a rapid, sensitive, and specific technique of Scorpion real-time polymerase chain reaction (PCR).

Materials and Methods:

Scorpion real-time PCR and modified McMullen's staining was performed on 103 archival paraffin-embedded tonsillar samples collected from patients with chronic tonsillitis following tonsillectomy operation.

Results:

Our findings showed that H Cell and Molecular Research Center. pylori DNA was present in 21.35% of total specimens by using Scorpion real-time PCR. Modified McMullen's staining of paraffin-embedded sections was positive in 19 patients. Out of our 103 samples, 50 samples showed positive a rapid urease test whereas 53 samples demonstrated negative results, 20 produced positive PCR results, and 83 were negative for H. pylori. There was no significant relationship between the presence of H. pylori, sex, age, and place of residence.

Conclusion:

Although the existence of H. pylori in tonsillar tissue samples of patients with chronic tonsillitis is controversial, however, our results showed that in our studied specimens, a significant number of patients with chronic tonsillitis had H. pylori colonization.

Agreement rate of rapid urease test, conventional PCR, and scorpion real-time PCR in detecting helicobacter pylori from tonsillar samples of patients with chronic tonsillitis

Background:

Helicobacter pylori is capable of inducing systemic inflammatory reactions through immunological processes. There are several methods to identify the presence of H. pylori in clinical samples including rapid urease test (RUT), conventional polymerase chain reaction (PCR), and the Scorpion real-time PCR.

Aim:

The aim of the present study is to compare the agreement rate of these tests in identifying H. pylori in tonsillar biopsy specimens collected from patients with chronic tonsillitis.

Materials and Methods:

A total of 103 tonsil biopsy samples from patients with clinical signs of chronic tonsillitis were examined with RUT, PCR, and Scorpion real-time PCR. The degree of agreement between the three tests was later calculated.

Results:

There was a poor degree of agreement between RUT and PCR and also RUT and Scorpion real-time PCR (Kappa=0.269 and 0.249, respectively). In contrast with RUT, there was a strong degree of agreement between PCR and Scorpion real-time PCR (Kappa=0.970).

Conclusion:

The presence of a strong agreement between the Scorpion real-time PCR and PCR as well as its technical advantage over the conventional PCR assay, made the Scorpion real-time PCR an appropriate laboratory test to investigate the presence of H. pylori in tonsillar biopsy specimens in patients suffering from chronic tonsillitis.

Reliability of clinical examinations for pediatric skin and soft-tissue infections

OBJECTIVE

To determine the interrater reliability of clinical examination by pediatric emergency medicine physicians for the diagnosis of skin and soft-tissue infections (SSTIs).

METHODS

A cross-sectional study of patients presenting to a pediatric emergency department with SSTIs was performed. Each lesion was examined by a treating physician and a study physician (from a pool of 62 physicians) at the bedside during the emergency department visit. The primary outcome was reliability, as measured with the weighted κ statistic, for determining whether the lesion was an abscess and whether the lesion required a drainage procedure.

RESULTS

A total of 371 lesions were analyzed for interrater reliability. The weighted κ value for diagnosis of the lesion as an abscess was 0.39 (95% confidence interval: 0.32-0.47), and that for assessment of the need for drainage was 0.43 (95% confidence interval: 0.36-0.51). Agreement was statistically more likely for lesions in children ≥ 4 years of age but was not more likely for lesions in nonblack patients, lesions in patients with a history of or exposure to a close contact with a SSTI, or lesions examined by 2 experienced pediatric emergency medicine physicians.

CONCLUSIONS

Among the 62 participating physicians at our site, the reliability of the clinical examination was poor. This may indicate that improved education and/or more-objective means for diagnosing these infections in the acute care setting are warranted. Additional studies are needed to determine whether these results are generalizable to other settings.

Determination of Helicobacter pylori in patients with chronic nonspecific pharyngitis

OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS

To determine if there is a relationship between Helicobacter pylori colonization in the pharynx mucous membrane and chronic nonspecific pharyngitis.

STUDY DESIGN

A prospective clinical study.

METHODS

Seventy patients with chronic pharyngitis and 20 healthy control subjects were examined with polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and culture for H. pylori colonization in the pharynx mucous membrane between March 2008 and October 2008. Patients with pharyngitis were seperated into two groups (35 patients in each) by using C-14 urea breath test, according to the presence of gastric H. pylori infection.

RESULTS

In the control group, none of the patients had H. pylori in the pharynx. In the chronic pharyngitis group, in 12 patients (34.3%) with gastric H. pylori infection and in seven patients (20%) without gastric infection, H. pylori colonization in pharynx mucosa was determined with the PCR method. In only two of chronic pharyngitis patients (5.8%), H. pylori infection was detected with culture. In the pharynx mucosa, the H. pylori infection rate was significantly higher in the chronic pharyngitis groups than in the control group (P = .002 between C-14 positive and control groups, P = .040 between C-14 negative and control groups). There was not a significant difference in H. pylori colonization in the pharynx of patients who had chronic pharyngitis with or without gastric ailments and H. pylori infection (P = .179).

CONCLUSIONS

Chronic nonspecific pharyngitis without gastric H. pylori infection is significantly related to H. pylori colonization in the pharynx, and gastric involvement increases the rate of this spread. The gold standart for detection of H. pylori infection is the PCR method.

Helicobacter pylori infection in the pharynx of patients with chronic pharyngitis detected with TDI-FP and modified Giemsa stain

AIM: To detect whether there is Helicobacter pylori (H pylori) colonization in the pharynx mucous membrane of healthy people and whether chronic pharyngitis is related to H pylori infection.

METHODS: Fifty cases of chronic pharyngitis refractory over three months were prospectively studied from March 2004 to August 2004 in the otolaryngology outpatient department of the Second Hospital of Xi’an Jiaotong University. Template-directed dye-terminator incorporated with fluorescence polarization detection (TDI-FP) and modified Giemsa stain were used to examine pharynx mucous membrane tissue for H pylori colonization in the patients with chronic pharyngitis and the healthy people as a control group.

RESULTS: In the control group, no people were detected to have H pylori in the pharynx. In contrast, in 50 cases with chronic pharyngitis, 19 (38.0%) cases were H pylori positive with a TDI-FP assay and 4 (8%) cases were TDI-FP positive with Giemsa staining in the pharynx. Sixteen of the 50 pharyngitis cases had stomach ailment history, 11 cases (68.8%) of these 16 patients were determined to be H pylori positive in the pharynx with the TDI-FP assay. χ² test showed that this infection rate was remarkably higher (P = 0.0007) than that in the cases without stomach ailment history. Giemsa staining showed that 3 cases (18.8%) of the patients with stomach ailment history were infected with H pylori in the pharynx, which was remarkably higher (P  = 0.042) than that in the patients without stomach ailment history (1 case, which was 2.9%).

CONCLUSION: H pylori may not be detected in the pharynx of healthy people. Chronic pharyngitis may be related to H pylori infection. The infection rate with H pylori in the pharynx is higher in patients with stomach ailment histories than in patients without stomach ailment histories, suggesting that chronic pharyngitis may be related to stomach ailment history.