Alport's syndrome: audiological manifestations and implications

Characterization of Sensorineural Hearing Loss in Children with Alport Syndrome

Most adults with Alport syndrome (AS) suffer from progressive sensorineural hearing loss. However, little is known about the early characteristics of hearing loss in children with AS. As a part of the EARLY PRO-TECT Alport trial, this study was the first clinical trial ever to investigate hearing loss in children with AS over a timespan of up to six years Nine of 51 children (18%) had hearing impairment. Audiograms were divided into three age groups: in the 5–9-year-olds, the 4-pure tone average (4PTA) was 8.9 decibel (dB) (n = 15) in those with normal hearing and 43.8 dB (n = 2, 12%) in those with hearing impairment. Among the 10–13-year-olds, 4PTA was 4.8 dB (healthy, n = 12) and 41.4 dB (hearing impaired, n = 6.33%). For the 14–20-year-olds, the 4PTA was 7.0 dB (healthy; n = 9) and 48.2 dB (hearing impaired, n = 3.25%). On average, hearing thresholds of the hearing impaired group increased, especially at frequencies between 1–3 kHz. In conclusion, 18% of children developed hearing loss, with a maximum hearing loss in the audiograms at 1–3 kHz. The percentage of children with hearing impairment increased from 10% at baseline to 18% at end of trial as did the severity of hearing loss.

Renal impairment in Alport syndrome pregnant woman: Case report and review of the literature

Pregnant women affected by Alport syndrome often struggle with worsening of renal function during pregnancy. We focused the attention on the optimal management of the kidney disease in these women in order to avoid maternal-fetal complications.

Cochlear histopathology in human genetic hearing loss: State of the science and future prospects

Sensorineural hearing loss (SNHL) is an extraordinarily common disability, affecting 466 million people across the globe. Half of these incidents are attributed to genetic mutations that disrupt the structure and function of the cochlea. The human cochlea's interior cannot be imaged or biopsied without damaging hearing; thus, everything known about the morphologic correlates of hereditary human deafness comes from histopathologic studies conducted in either cadaveric human temporal bone specimens or animal models of genetic deafness. The purpose of the present review is to a) summarize the findings from all published histopathologic studies conducted in human temporal bones with known SNHL-causing genetic mutations, and b) compare the reported phenotypes of human vs. mouse SNHL caused by the same genetic mutation. The fact that human temporal bone histopathologic analysis has been reported for only 22 of the nearly 200 identified deafness-causing genes suggests a great need for alternative and improved techniques for studying human hereditary deafness; in light of this, the present review concludes with a summary of promising future directions, specifically in the fields of high resolution cochlear imaging, intracochlear fluid biopsy, and gene therapy.

X-linked Alport syndrome: pathogenic variant features and further auditory genotype-phenotype correlations in males

OBJECTIVE

To analyze the clinical audiological characteristics of X-Linked Alport syndrome (XLAS) in males and their relationships with genotypes.

METHODS

The clinical data of 87 male patients with AS were reviewed. Hearing levels were evaluated using pure tone audiometry (PTA) testing, acoustic immittance, and otoacoustic emissions (OAE) testing. The genotypes of COL4A5 and the pathogenic variants were analyzed. The relationships between auditory phenotypes and genotypes were analyzed.

RESULTS

Among the 87 patients, the number of patients with normal hearing and hearing loss were 32 and 55, respectively. In all cases, the hearing loss was characterized as bilateral symmetrical sensorineural deafness. Majority of the patients had mild-to-moderate hearing loss. Hearing loss usually started in the middle frequency range and gradually affected high frequencies, at school age and gradually increased with increasing age. However, it maintained a relatively steady level of 50-60 dB HL during the teenage years. The audiometric curves included groove-type in 51 cases (92.73%). Patients were identified to have 60 different COL4A5 pathogenic variants. Of the 49 patients who were followed-up for more than 2 years, 28 cases presented a decreasing trend in the hearing level of about 5 dB per year. The degree of hearing loss was positively correlated with gene mutation type and renal function.

CONCLUSIONS

Hearing loss in males with XLAS is symmetrical sensorineural, and progressive with increasing age. There is a significant correlation between the degree of hearing loss and genotype, renal function, and age.

Temporal Bone Histopathology of X-linked Inherited Alport Syndrome

OBJECTIVE

To describe the histopathologic findings within the human cochlea in X-linked Alport syndrome.

STUDY DESIGN

Histopathologic analysis of cellular elements within the human cochlea by light microscopy.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A right and a left cochleae of a man with genetically confirmed X-linked Alport syndrome was studied post-mortem. The temporal bones underwent standard processing for histologic examination. The slides were examined by light microscopy. Graphic reconstruction of the cochlea was performed to quantify hair cells, pathologic changes of the stria vascularis, and loss of cochlear neuronal cells.

RESULTS

There was severe loss of inner hair cells and all three rows of outer hair cells in the apical two turns of the cochlea. The stria vascularis and spiral ligament showed areas of marked loss which became more prominent from base to apex in each ear. The spiral ganglion cell count in the Rosenthal's canal exhibited loss of 20% to 45% compared to matched historical controls. There was a zone of separation between the organ of Corti and the basilar membrane extending along the basal surface of Deiters cells, Hensen cells, Claudius cells and external sulcus cells. The tunnel of Corti and the space of Nuel were filled with cellular elements along the cochlea.

CONCLUSION

The histopathologic findings of cochlear involvement in Alport's syndrome are basement membrane separation from the cells of the organ of Corti, outer and inner hair cell loss, and cellular infilling of the tunnel and extracellular spaces of the organ of Corti. These observations contribute to our understanding of the mechanism of sensorineural hearing loss in these patients.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Osteopontin deficiency ameliorates Alport pathology by preventing tubular metabolic deficits

Alport syndrome is a rare hereditary renal disorder with no etiologic therapy. We found that osteopontin (OPN) is highly expressed in the renal tubules of the Alport mouse and plays a causative pathological role. OPN genetic deletion ameliorated albuminuria, hypertension, tubulointerstitial proliferation, renal apoptosis, and hearing and visual deficits in the Alport mouse. In Alport renal tubules we found extensive cholesterol accumulation and increased protein expression of dynamin-3 (DNM3) and LDL receptor (LDLR) in addition to dysmorphic mitochondria with defective bioenergetics. Increased pathological cholesterol influx was confirmed by a remarkably increased uptake of injected DiI-LDL cholesterol by Alport renal tubules, and by the improved lifespan of the Alport mice when crossed with the Ldlr-/- mice with defective cholesterol influx. Moreover, OPN-deficient Alport mice demonstrated significant reduction of DNM3 and LDLR expression. In human renal epithelial cells, overexpressing DNM3 resulted in elevated LDLR protein expression and defective mitochondrial respiration. Our results suggest a potentially new pathway in Alport pathology where tubular OPN causes DNM3- and LDLR-mediated enhanced cholesterol influx and impaired mitochondrial respiration.

Targeted exome sequencing integrated with clinicopathological information reveals novel and rare mutations in atypical, suspected and unknown cases of Alport syndrome or proteinuria

We applied customized targeted next-generation exome sequencing (NGS) to determine if mutations in genes associated with renal malformations, Alport syndrome (AS) or nephrotic syndrome are a potential cause of renal abnormalities in patients with equivocal or atypical presentation. We first sequenced 4,041 exons representing 292 kidney disease genes in a Caucasian woman with a history of congenital vesicoureteral reflux (VUR), recurrent urinary tract infections and hydronephrosis who presented with nephrotic range proteinuria at the age of 45. Her biopsy was remarkable for focal segmental glomerulosclerosis (FSGS), a potential complication of longstanding VUR. She had no family history of renal disease. Her proteinuria improved initially, however, several years later she presented with worsening proteinuria and microhematuria. NGS analysis revealed two deleterious COL4A3 mutations, one novel and the other previously reported in AS, and a novel deleterious SALL2 mutation, a gene linked to renal malformations. Pedigree analysis confirmed that COL4A3 mutations were nonallelic and compound heterozygous. The genomic results in conjunction with subsequent abnormal electron microscopy, Collagen IV minor chain immunohistochemistry and progressive sensorineural hearing loss confirmed AS. We then modified our NGS approach to enable more efficient discovery of variants associated with AS or a subset of FSGS by multiplexing targeted exome sequencing of 19 genes associated with AS or FSGS in 14 patients. Using this approach, we found novel or known COL4A3 or COL4A5 mutations in a subset of patients with clinically diagnosed or suspected AS, APOL1 variants associated with FSGS in African Americans and novel mutations in genes associated with nephrotic syndrome. These studies demonstrate the successful application of targeted capture-based exome sequencing to simultaneously evaluate genetic variations in many genes in patients with complex renal phenotypes and provide insights into etiology of conditions with equivocal clinical and pathologic presentations.

Alport's Syndrome in Pregnancy

Background. Alport's syndrome is an X-linked hereditary disorder affecting the glomerular basement membrane associated with ocular and hearing defects. In women, the disease is much less severe compared to that in men. However, women with Alport's syndrome can have an accelerated form of their disease during pregnancy with worsening of kidney function and can also develop preeclampsia. There are only four described cases of Alport's syndrome in pregnancy. Case Presentation. 20-year-old woman with a history of Alport's syndrome, which during pregnancy worsened resulting in hypertension, proteinuria, and acute kidney injury. Fortunately, there was complete resolution of the proteinuria and kidney injury with delivery, and the patient did not require any renal replacement therapy. Conclusion. One of the four reported cases had an accelerated form of the disease during pregnancy with rapid progression of kidney injury and end-stage renal disease. There are no definite guidelines to monitor these patients during pregnancy. Further studies are required to understand the exact pathophysiology of kidney damage that occurs in pregnant women with Alport's syndrome. This may give us some insight into the prognostic predictors, so that we can monitor these women more thoroughly and prevent adverse outcomes.

Severe to profound hearing loss in patients with progressed Alport's syndrome

CONCLUSION

The concept of hearing loss severity must be redefined, as there is a clear need for more active hearing management in Alport's syndrome patients with severe and profound hearing loss.

OBJECTIVES

Sensorineural hearing loss (SNHL) caused by Alport's syndrome generally does not exceed 60-70 dB, because a cochlear lesion is responsible for this hearing loss. Careful management of renal function improves the prognosis and the longevity of Alport's syndrome patients; it is useful to reassess SNHL caused by Alport's syndrome.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Thirty-two patients with Alport's syndrome were analyzed retrospectively. Pure tone audiograms (PTAs), speech audiograms, and transiently evoked otoacoustic emissions (TEOAEs) were performed. Hearing loss severity was compared to duration of disease and severity of renal dysfunction. We also evaluated the correlation between OAEs and PTAs according to the hypothesis that evoked OAEs would be abnormal even in early stage SNHL in Alport's syndrome.

RESULTS

The level of hearing was positively correlated with disease duration. The hearing of the end-stage renal disease (ESRD) group, whose hearing threshold could exceed 70 dB, was worse than that of the non-ESRD group. OAEs were found in patients with normal hearing and mild hearing loss and had no significant early detection value.

Revisão sobre a perda auditiva na Síndrome de Alport, analisando os aspectos clínicos, genéticos e biomoleculares

A Síndrome de Alport é uma desordem hereditária, caracterizada por hematúria, freqüentemente levando à falência renal. Pode ser acompanhada de alterações extra-renais, tais como: perda auditiva (PA) sensório-neural e alterações oculares. São descritas formas dominantes ligadas ao X, devidas às mutações no lócus COL4A5 e uma forma autossômica recessiva resultando de mutações no lócus COL4A3 ou COL4A4. Ainda foi sugerido um tipo autossômico dominante de SA. A doença decorre de alterações nas cadeias de colágeno tipo IV e os sintomas refletem o comprometimento da membrana basal de vários órgãos. As redes alfa3.alfa4.alfa5(IV) ocorrem no rim, na cóclea e no olho. O objetivo foi caracterizar a PA neste grupo de pacientes. Quando o quadro progride para o estágio final de falência renal, o melhor método de tratamento é o transplante, que tem contribuído para o aumento da sobrevida. Nesta revisão bibliográfica, observamos que: 1. A SA caracteriza-se por hematúria, que evolui para falência renal e pode ser acompanhada de manifestações extra-renais. A PA é um achado extra-renal freqüente e um dos primeiros sintomas na SA, sendo um fator relevante para o prognóstico da evolução da doença renal; 2. A SA é genética e decorre da alteração das cadeias do colágeno tipo IV nas membranas basais; 3. A perda auditiva na SA é sensório-neural, de intensidade variável, progressiva e simétrica. Acomete as freqüências médias e altas; 4. Na investigação das perdas auditivas, o otorrinolaringologista deve incluir um exame de urina. É fundamental que o otologista atue no acompanhamento deste grupo de pacientes.

Revision about hearing loss in the Alport's syndrome, analyzing the clinical, genetic and bio-molecular aspects

Alport Syndrome is a genetic disorder characterized by hematuria, which often leads to renal failure. It may also be accompanied by extra-renal alterations, such as: sensorineural hearing loss, and ocular abnormalities. Dominant forms related to the X chromosome and caused by mutations in the locus COL4A5 have been described, as well as an autossomic recessive form resulting from mutations in the locus COL4A3 or COL4A4. An autossomic dominant type of AS has also been reported. The disease is caused by changes in the collagen type IV chains, where symptoms reflect the damage to the basal membrane of several organs. The α3.α4.α5(IV) networks are found in the kidneys, cochlea and eyes. The objective was to characterize AS in this group of patients. In the current literature review it was found that: 1. AS is characterized by hematuria that may develop into renal failure and can also be accompanied by extra-renal manifestations. Hearing loss is a frequent extra-renal finding and one of the first symptoms of AS, therefore representing a relevant factor in the prognosis of the renal disease; 2. It is a genetic disorder resulting from abnormalities in the chains of collagen type IV in the basal membranes; 3. The hearing loss in AS is typically sensorineural with variable intensities, progressive and symmetrical, affecting middle and high frequencies; 4. Otolaryngologists should include a urine test in the SNHL work-up. It is essential to have an otologist involved in the treatment of these patients.

Temporal Bone Histopathology in Alport Syndrome

OBJECTIVE

To determine the histopathologic abnormalities within the cochlea in Alport syndrome.

BACKGROUND

Alport syndrome, which manifests as hereditary nephritis and sensorineural hearing loss (SNHL), is caused by mutations in genes that code for the proportional, variant3, proportional, variant4, and proportional, variant5 chains of type IV collagen. The proportional, variant3, proportional, variant4, and proportional, variant5 chains of type IV collagen are present in the basement membrane of the organ of Corti. Previous temporal bone studies have failed to identify histopathologic correlates for the SNHL.

METHODS

We examined temporal bones from nine individuals with a clinical diagnosis of Alport syndrome. One of our cases also had genetic testing that showed a mutation in the type IV collagen proportional, variant5 chain gene.

RESULTS

By light microscopy, eight of nine cases demonstrated two unique pathologic changes: 1) a "zone of separation" between the basilar membrane and overlying cells of the organ of Corti and 2) presence of cells filling the tunnel of Corti and extracellular spaces of Nuel. The cytologic losses of hair cells, stria vascularis, and cochlear neuronal cells were insufficient to account for the observed SNHL in our cases. Electron microscopy was performed in four cases; all four demonstrated the following: 1) the zone of separation that was observed at light microscopy occurred between the basement membrane and the basilar membrane, 2) the cells within the tunnel of Corti and spaces of Nuel were morphologically similar to supporting cells, and 3) the basement membrane of strial capillaries and the spiral vessel (under the basilar membrane) were normal.

CONCLUSIONS

The histopathologic correlates of cochlear involvement in Alport syndrome are abnormalities of the basement membrane of cells of the organ of Corti and dysmorphogenesis (cellular infilling of the tunnel and extracellular spaces) of the organ of Corti. We hypothesize that these abnormalities result in SNHL by altering cochlear micromechanics.

The genetic bases for syndromic and nonsyndromic deafness among Jews

There are hundreds of different mutated genes associated with hearing loss. However, recent findings indicate that a large proportion of both syndromic and nonsyndromic forms of deafness in some Jewish populations is caused by a small number of founder mutations. This review is focused on genetic disorders such as nonsyndromic deafness, Usher syndrome and Alport syndrome, in which hearing loss is a major part of the phenotype and in which the underlying prevalent founder mutations have been recently identified in different Jewish populations. These and other examples of common mutations within a distinct population allow for sensitive and specific use of genetic testing for carrier screening and diagnosis, and are an impetus for development of therapeutic strategies.

Hearing loss in a uraemic patient: indications of involvement of the VIIIth nerve

A case of acute renal failure associated with severe uraemic hearing loss is presented. Audiometric site-of-lesion testing revealed cochlear as well as neural involvement. After therapy hearing recovered up to an almost normal level, with normal auditory nerve conduction velocities. This case report supports the suggestion that the improvement of hearing after renal transplantation or dialysis might be correlated with the influences of these forms of therapy upon the peripheral neuropathy.