Topographic organization of the retinocollicular projection in the neonatal rat

High precision systems require high precision "blueprints": a new view regarding the formation of connections in the Mammalian visual system

Abstract It is well established that early in development interconnections within the mammalian visual system are often more widespread and less precise than at maturity. The literature dealing with the formation of visual connections has largely ignored differences in developmental specificity among species differing in their phylogenetic status and/or the visual ecological niche that they occupy. Based on a review of the available evidence, we have formulated an hypothesis to account for the varying degrees of developmental specificity that characterize different visual systems. It is suggested that extremely precise systems required for high-acuity binocular vision exhibit fewer presumed developmental errors than do visual systems characterized by poorer acuity and relatively crude depth perception. The developmental implications of the hypothesis are considered, and specific experiments are proposed to further test its validity.

Visual Experience Is Necessary for Maintenance But Not Development of Receptive Fields in Superior Colliculus

Sensory deprivation is thought to have an adverse effect on visual development and to prolong the critical period for plasticity. Once the animal reaches adulthood, however, synaptic connectivity is understood to be largely stable. We reported previously that N-methyl-d-aspartate (NMDA) receptor blockade in the superior colliculus of the Syrian hamster prevents refinement of receptive fields (RFs) in normal or compressed retinotopic projections, resulting in target neurons with enlarged RFs but normal stimulus tuning. Here we asked whether visually driven activity is necessary for refinement or maintenance of retinotopic maps or if spontaneous activity is sufficient. Animals were deprived of light either in adulthood only or from birth until the time of recording. We found that dark rearing from birth to 2 mo of age had no effect on the timing and extent of RF refinement as assessed with single unit extracellular recordings. Visual deprivation in adulthood also had no effect. Continuous dark rearing from birth into adulthood, however, resulted in a progressive loss of refinement, resulting in enlarged, asymmetric receptive fields and altered surround suppression in adulthood. Thus unlike in visual cortex, early visually driven activity is not necessary for refinement of receptive fields during development, but is required to maintain refined visual projections in adulthood. Because the map can refine normally in the dark, these results argue against a deprivation-induced delay in critical period closure, and suggest instead that early visual deprivation leaves target neurons more vulnerable to deprivation that continues after refinement.

Postnatal expression of the plasticity-related nerve growth factor-induced gene A (NGFI-A) protein in the superficial layers of the rat superior colliculus: Relation to N-methyl-d-aspartate receptor function

Immediate early gene expression in the CNS is induced by sensory stimulation and seems to be involved in long-term synaptic plasticity. We have used an immunohistochemical method to detect the nerve growth factor-induced gene A (NGFI-A) protein expression in the superficial layers of the rat superior colliculus during postnatal development. Our goal was to correlate the expression of this candidate plasticity protein with developmental events, especially the activity-dependent refinement of the retinocollicular and corticocollicular pathways. We have also investigated the N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA)-receptor dependence of the NGFI-A expression. Animals of various postnatal ages were used. Postnatal day (P) 12 and older animals were submitted to a protocol of dark adaptation followed by light stimulation. NGFI-A expression was never observed during the first 2 postnatal weeks. The first stained cells were observed at P15, 2 days after eye opening (P13). The highest number of stained cells was observed at the end of the third postnatal week (P22). Adult-like level of expression was reached at P30, since at this age, the number of stained cells was comparable to that found in adult rats (P90). Both P22 animals submitted to an acute treatment with MK-801 (i.p. injection) and adult animals submitted to chronic intracranial infusion of a MK-801 presented a clear decrease in the NGFI-A expression in response to light stimulation. These results suggest that the NGFI-A expression is dependent on the NMDA receptor activation, and the observed pattern of expression is in close agreement with previous descriptions of the changes in the NMDA receptor-mediated visual activity in the developing rat superior colliculus (SC). Our results suggest that the plasticity-related NGFI-A protein might play a role in the developmental plasticity of the superficial layers of the rat SC after eye opening.

Induction and axonal localization of epithelial/epidermal fatty acid-binding protein in retinal ganglion cells are associated with axon development and regeneration

Epithelial/epidermal fatty acid-binding protein (E-FABP) is induced in peripheral neurons during nerve regeneration and is found at high levels in central neurons during neuronal migration and development. Furthermore, E-FABP expression is required for normal neurite outgrowth in PC12 cells treated with nerve growth factor (NGF). The present study examined whether E-FABP plays a role in retinal ganglion cell (RGC) differentiation and axon growth. Rat retinal tissues from embryonic (E) and postnatal (P) development through adulthood were examined using immunocytochemical labeling with E-FABP and growth-associated protein 43 (GAP-43) antibodies. E-FABP colocalized with GAP-43 at E14 through P10. At E14, E-FABP immunoreactivity was confined to the somas of GAP-43-positive cells in the ganglion cell layer, but it was localized to their axons by E15. The axons in the optic nerve were GAP-43-positive and E-FABP-negative on E15, but the two proteins were colocalized by E18. Retinal cultures at E15 confirmed that E-FABP and GAP-43 colocalize in RGCs. Postnatally, labeling was present between P1 and P10 but decreased at older ages and was minimally present or absent in adult animals. Western immunoblotting revealed that at E18, P1, and P10 E-FABP levels were at least fourfold greater than those in the adult. By P15, protein levels were only twofold greater, with adult levels reached by P31. Furthermore, E-FABP could be reinduced during axon regeneration. Dissociated P15 retinal cells cultured in the presence of brain-derived neurotrophic factor, ciliary neurotrophic factor, and basic fibroblast growth factor exhibited sixfold more GAP-43 and E-FABP double-positive RGCs (cell body and axons) than controls. Moreover, all GAP-43-immunoreactive RGCs were also positive for E-FABP. Taken together, these results indicate the following: 1) E-FABP is expressed in RGCs as they reached the ganglion cell layer and 2) E-FABP plays a functional role in the elaboration of RGC axons in both development and regeneration.

Reinnervation of the superior colliculus delays down-regulation of ephrin A2 in neonatal rat

Although the adult mammalian optic nerve does not regenerate following lesion, in the neonatal rat, retinal ganglion cell (RGC) axons retain the capacity to grow across lesion sites in the brain. Following a brachial lesion at postnatal day 2 (P2), some RGC axons, together with ingrowing cortico-tectal axons, cross the lesion to reinnervate the superior colliculus (SC). Here we use immunohistochemistry to examine expression of the guidance cue ephrin A2 following a brachial lesion. Normal animals show a steady decrease in ephrin A2 immunoreactivity between P5 and P31, with a low rostral to high caudal gradient being evident only at P5. By contrast, after brachial lesion, values are significantly elevated rostrally at P5 and caudally at P12; moreover, a steep rostro-caudal gradient is present at both ages. By P31 values fall to normal levels. Following unilateral enucleation at P2, levels are not significantly different from normal. Our results show that innervation but not denervation triggers increased ephrin A2 expression after a brachial lesion.

Postnatal development of the retinal projection to the nucleus of the optic tract and accessory optic nuclei in the hooded rat

Retinal projections to the nucleus of the optic tract (NOT) and accessory optic nuclei (AON) were studied in the postnatal hooded rat after monocular injection of cholera toxin B subunit (CTB) into the vitreous chamber of the eye. At all postnatal ages, retinal axons were labeled sensitively; they revealed dense projections to the contralateral, and sparse but distinct projections to the ipsilateral, NOT and AON. The CTB labeling enabled the first delineation of the complete morphology of developing retinal axons in the ipsilateral NOT and AON. From postnatal day (P) 1 to P3, axons with complex growth cones were seen, and unbranched collaterals with simple growth cones increased and extended gradually. At P6, complex growth cones disappeared while branched collaterals with simple growth cones as well as small-sized varicosities increased. By P12 (two days before eye-opening) the adult-like pattern of terminal arbors appeared. The branched collaterals with tiny, small-sized varicosities present probably represented developing synaptic boutons. At P16 (after eye opening), the pattern of terminal arbors was well developed, almost to the same extent as in the adult. By contrast, a broadly distributed, transient retinal projection around NOT and AON was gradually eliminated; it started to disappear during the first few postnatal days, and was fully retracted by the time of eye-opening time to a pattern normal for the adult.

NOS inhibition during postnatal development leads to increased ipsilateral retinocollicular and retinogeniculate projections in rats

Synthesis of nitric oxide (NO) occurs downstream from activation of N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) receptors; NO reportedly acts as a retrograde messenger, influencing the refinement and stabilization of coactive afferent terminals. Cells and neuropil in the rat superior colliculus (SC) and lateral geniculate body (LGB) show intense, developmentally regulated activity for NO synthase (NOS). To study the role of NO in the development of retinogeniculate and retinotectal axon arbors, we examined primary visual projections of rats that had received intraperitoneal injections of Nomega-nitro-L-arginine (L-NoArg, an NOS inhibitor) on postnatal day 0, and daily thereafter for 4-6 weeks. Treated rats showed significant alterations in ipsilateral retinotectal projections, in the mediolateral and anteroposterior axes; there was an increase in the density of fibres entering the SC, in branch length, and in the numbers of boutons on retinotectal arbors in the treated group. Ipsilaterally projecting retinal axons also showed an increase in density and distribution in the dorsal nucleus of the LGB. If animals were allowed to survive for several months after stopping treatment, similar changes were also noted, but these were much less striking. Our results support the hypothesis that, in the mammalian visual system, NO released from target neurons in the SC and LGB serves as a retrograde signal which feeds back on retinal afferents, influencing their growth. The effects of NOS inhibition are partially reversed after treatment is stopped, indicating that lack of NO synthesis delays the maturation of retinofugal connections, and also that NO plays a constitutive role in their development.

Spontaneous regeneration of severed optic axons restores mapped visual responses to the adult rat superior colliculus

To test whether a spontaneous and functional regeneration of severed axons could occur within the adult mammalian central nervous system, a long-term recovery of microelectrode-mapped visual response was sought in the superior colliculus (SC) after its total or near-total abolition by a precise guillotine cut of the retinocollicular pathway. Recoveries were found 3 weeks or later in 15 of the 36 animals studied; in 10 of these recoveries, half or more of the width of the SC was involved. The recovered responses were often activated from within a normally small area of the visual field. Appropriate retinotopic maps were restored. Intraocular horseradish peroxidase tracing revealed a variety of novel optic trajectories, passing around lesions even of totally cut pathways, which eventually terminated in normally retinorecipient layers of those recovered SCs. Such detours could not be explained by a mechanical reorientation of brain structures. When exactly comparable lesions were examined within a few days, there were no detours: severed optic axons faced the cuts. In long-term animals where responsiveness remained absent, optic axonal reorientations were observed near lesions but the SC was not innervated. Extensive long-term recoveries were in marked contrast to the occasional rapid ones, found within a few days postlesion, which involved only an outermost silenced border of SC. These were attributed to a rapid reversal of conduction failure in spared, bordering, axons of this topographically organized pathway. The findings support the conclusion that, after they are cut, numbers of optic axons can regenerate to the SC and restore appropriate circuitry therein.

Conduction and synaptic transmission in the optic nerve and the superior colliculus during development of the retinocollicular projection in the wallaby (Macropus eugenii)

When do the developing connections between mammalian retinal ganglion cells and the superior colliculus become functional? Evoked potentials elicited by optic nerve stimulation in the pouch young of the wallaby were used to answer the question. Up to 42 days after birth, the evoked potentials in the colliculus appeared to be generated by axon conduction. Synaptic activity was first recorded from the rostral colliculus at 45 days, and was found to be progressively more caudal, spreading to cover the colliculus, by 65 days. From the earliest indication of synaptic activity until eye opening at 140 days, current source density (CSD) analysis consistently showed the same basic pattern: an initial deep sink from synaptic activity of fast (Y type) fibres, and a more superficial longer-latency sink from slower (W type) fibres. All features became more clearly delineated with age. The indirect retinocorticocollicular connection appeared between 134 days and 146 days. The ability of optic nerve fibres to sustain action potentials precedes their formation of functional synapses with collicular neurons, which happens abruptly at three months before eye opening. CSD analysis showed that the relationship between the conduction velocity of optic nerve fibres and their depth of termination is evident from the first signs of synapse formation.

Post eye-opening maturation of visual receptive field diameters in the superior colliculus of normal- and dark-reared rats

When the rat's eyes open (P14) the retino-collicular projection is largely mature but the cortico-collicular afferents are naive and mature considerably in the following week. At P14, single units in the superior colliculus' superficial grey layer (SGS) had discrete receptive fields (RFs) (diameter = 15 +/- 1.6 degrees) which expanded with age, reaching 30 +/- 2.6 degrees at P21, possibly reflecting the increasing influence of the visual cortex, whose RFs are known to be enlarged at P21. Subsequently SGS RFs retracted to 13 +/- 1.3 degrees by P23. Dark-reared (DR) rats followed a similar but delayed developmental pattern, such that RFs were still large (27 +/- 3.4 degrees) at P24. By P30 however the RFs of DR rats were the same as those of normal adults. Thus visual experience accelerates the emergence of normal RFs in the SGS.

Spatiotemporal pattern of ontogenetic expression of calbindin-28/kD in the retinorecipient layers of rat superior colliculus

Using an antibody against calbindin-28kD, we have studied the spatial pattern of expression of this protein in the superior colliculi (SC) of four strains of mature laboratory rats. In all four strains, calbindin-expressing cells (CECs) formed horizontally oriented tiers in the retinorecipient and intermediate gray layers but were diffusely distributed throughout the deep layers. Ontogenetically, calbindin-28kD was expressed for the first time in the retinorecipient layers at postconceptional day 20 (PCD 20), by cells located in the rostrolateral region where the first born retinal ganglion cells (RGCs) are represented. Although on the day of birth (PCD 22/23), the CECs were distributed more widely, they were still absent in the most medial part of the SC, that is, the region where the latest born RGCs are represented. The spatial distribution of CECs became adultlike only by PCD 29, that is, at the end of the period of the naturally occurring death of the RGCs. Monocular eye enucleations on PCD 23 prevented the expression of calbindin in the medial fifth of the retinorecipient layers of the contralateral SC, while the unilateral removal of the visual cortices had no discernable effect on the numbers and distribution of the CECs in either SC. Thus, the spatiotemporal pattern of ontogenetic expression of calbindin-28kD in the retinorecipient layers of SC reflects the spatiotemporal pattern of generation of the RGCs, and the retinal input appears to induce neuronal expression of calbindin-28kD in these layers.

The initial stages of development of the retinocollicular projection in the wallaby (Macropus eugenii): distribution of ganglion cells in the retina and their axons in the superior colliculus

The time course of ingrowth of retinal projections to the superior colliculus in the marsupial mammal, the wallaby (Macropus eugenii), was determined by anterograde labelling of axons from the eye with horseradish peroxidase, from birth to 46 days, when axons cover the colliculus contralaterally and ipsilaterally. The position of retinal ganglion cells giving rise to these projections over this period was determined in fixed tissue by retrograde labelling from the colliculus with a carbocyanine dye. Axons first reach the rostrolateral contralateral colliculus 4 days after birth and extend caudally and medially, reaching the caudal pole at 18 days and the far caudomedial pole at 46 days. The first contralaterally projecting cells are in the central dorsal and temporal retina, followed by cells in the nasal and finally the ventral retina. They are distributed closer to the periphery with increasing age. The first sign of a visual streak appears by 18 days. Axons reach the ipsilateral colliculus a day later than contralateral axons and come from a similar region of the retina. The sparser ipsilateral projection reaches the caudal and medial collicular margins by 46 days but by 16-18 days, ganglion cells giving rise to this transient projection are already concentrated in the temporoventral retina. The orderly recruitment of ganglion cells from retinotopically appropriate regions of the retina as axons advance across the contralateral colliculus suggests that the projection is topographically ordered from the beginning. The ipsilateral projection is less ordered as cells are located in the temporoventral crescent at a time when their axons are still transiently covering the colliculus prior to becoming restricted to the rostral colliculus. Features of mature retinal topography such as the visual streak and the location of ipsilaterally projecting cells begin to be established very early in development, before the period of ganglion cell loss and long before eye opening at 140 days.

Transient retinal ganglion cells in the developing rat are characterized by specific morphological properties

To determine whether dendritic development of mammalian retinal ganglion cells (RGCs) is affected by axonal target specificity, the morphology of three populations of maturing RGCs was examined. These included RGCs that exhibited either a transient, topographically incorrect, projection to the caudal superior colliculus (SC), or a transient projection to the caudal inferior colliculus (IC), in addition to a control group that exhibited a topographically correct projection to the caudal SC. Projection populations were identified by retrograde transport of rhodamine labeled latex microspheres injected into target nuclei. Labeled RGCs were then injected in vitro with Lucifer yellow to reveal the details of their dendritic morphology. Retinal ganglion cells making target errors, most of which ultimately die, were found to undergo a remarkable degree of morphological differentiation and could be categorized according to the adult type I, II, or III criteria. However, the relative proportions of these cell types were different among RGCs making transient connections versus those whose projections were preserved. Approximately half of the RGCs making topographically incorrect projections to the SC belonged to type III, in contrast to 6% that made a topographically correct projection. In addition, the population of cells sending axons to caudal IC did not include type III RGCs, but consisted of small type II neurons. The development of the basic dendritic form of each RGC type was only modestly influenced by its projection pattern; dendritic trees of cells making transient projections were essentially normal with only a slight, but statistically significant, reduction in dimensions. Moreover, dendritic remodeling was evident during maturation of neurons making either transient or normal projections. Together, these findings indicate that target specificity plays a relatively minor role on dendritic development of retinal ganglion cells.

Topographic organization in the retinocollicular pathway of the fetal cat demonstrated by retrograde labeling of ganglion cells

The topographic organization of the developing retinocollicular pathway was assessed by making focal deposits of a retrograde tracer (usually rhodamine latex beads) into the superficial layers of the superior colliculus of fetal cats at known gestational ages. Subsequently, the distributions of labeled cells in the contralateral and ipsilateral retinas were examined. At all stages of development, a high density of labeled cells was found in a delimited area (core region) of both retinas. The locations of the retinal regions containing the high density of labeled cells varied with the locus of the tracer deposit in the superior colliculus in a manner consistent with the topographic organization of the mature cat's retinocollicular pathway. Additionally, some labeled ganglion cells, considered to be ectopic, were found to be scattered throughout the contralateral and ipsilateral fetal retinas. Such ectopic cells were few in number throughout prenatal development. For every 100 cells projecting to the appropriate region of the colliculus, we estimate that less than one ganglion cell makes a gross projection error. The incidence of ectopic cells did not differ between the contralateral and ipsilateral retina, even though the overall density of crossed labeled cells was always greater than that of uncrossed labeled cells. In the youngest fetal animals, tracer deposits into the caudal portion of the superior colliculus resulted in a core region of labeled cells in the contralateral nasal retina as well as in the nasal ipsilateral retina. Such uncrossed nasal cells, not seen in more mature animals, appear to innervate the appropriate topographic location of the superior colliculus, but on the wrong side of the brain. Most likely, these uncrossed nasal ganglion cells contribute to the widespread distribution of the ipsilateral retinocollicular pathway observed in fetal cats after intraocular injections of anterograde tracers (Williams and Chalupa, 1982). Collectively, our findings demonstrate that the developing retinocollicular pathway of the fetal cat is characterized by a remarkable degree of topographic precision.

Expression of the proto-oncogene, trk, receptors in the developing rat retina

The neurotrophins, including nerve growth factor (NGF), brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF), neurotrophin-3 (NT-3) and NT-4/5 are important in a variety of developmental processes in the peripheral and central nervous systems. These molecules bind to a low-affinity receptor and to distinct high-affinity receptors. The high-affinity receptor for NGF is the proto-oncogene product, p140trkA(trkA). Isoforms of p140trkA, p145trkB(trkB), and p140trkC(trkC), are the primary high-affinity receptors for BDNF and NT-3, respectively. We evaluated the developmental regulation of the high-affinity neurotrophin receptors in the rat retina using polyclonal antibodies directed to a highly conserved region of the C-terminus of the p140trkA isoforms (pantrk) and antibodies directed to unique amino-acid sequences of p140trkA, p145trkB, and p140trkC. Immunoreactivities for trkA and trkB, as well as pantrk, were detected in the developing retina and showed similar distributions. At similar antibody concentrations, trkC immunoreactivity was not detected. In the embryo, immunoreactivties were present in cells located throughout the neuroblastic retina, especially in the inner retinal layers, and in fibers in the nerve fiber layer and optic nerve. In the newborn retina, immunoreactivities for these two receptor isoforms were localized to numerous somata in the inner nuclear layer (INL), as well as to cells in the ganglion cell layer (GCL) and axons in the nerve fiber layer and optic nerve. A similar pattern of immunostaining persisted throughout the first postnatal week. By postnatal day-10, immunostaining was confined to large-diameter cells in the GCL, both heavily stained and lightly stained cells in the INL and a plexus of processes in the inner plexiform layer (IPL).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Rapid plastic response following early retinal lesions in rats

Following an early retinal lesion, aberrant uncrossed projections from the opposite, undamaged, retina form in the target visual nuclei. The present study has examined the development of such aberrant projections by making retinal lesions in newborn rat pups, and then examining the nature of the uncrossed retinocollicular projection at different ages following the lesion. Intravitreal injections of horseradish peroxidase were made into the intact eye, and the uncrossed projection was subsequently revealed histochemically. A mature aberrant projection forms as early as postnatal day 9. On postnatal days 5 and 2, aberrant projections are discernable amongst the exuberant uncrossed terminals of normal developing rats, although the former have not matured to form the dense terminal fields characteristic of older projections. Aberrant projections were also detectable as early as 12 h following the lesion, revealed as a relative increase in the density of uncrossed label. These results indicate that lesion-induced plastic responses by intact retinal arbors are initiated shortly after the insult, and they caution the use of retinal lesions in studies of normal retinotopic connectivity during development.

Location of retinal ganglion cells contributing to the early imprecision in the retinotopic order of the developing projection to the superior colliculus of the wallaby (Macropus eugenii)

The position of ganglion cells contributing to the early imprecision in retinotopic order in the developing retinocollicular projection in the wallaby (Macropus eugenii) has been determined. Deposits of horseradish peroxidase conjugated to wheat germ agglutinin (WGA-HRP) were made in the caudal pole of the superior colliculus (SC) at ages ranging from 22 days after birth, when sparse retinal axons have only just reached the caudal pole of the SC and are yet to cover its surface completely, to 96 days when the retinotopy of ganglion cell terminals in the SC is precise (Marotte, '90). From 30 days onwards, the deposit of WGA-HRP resulted in a dense patch of retrogradely labelled retinal ganglion cells that could be seen to be appropriately positioned in nasal retina. However, at all ages prior to 92 days, there were inappropriately positioned labelled cells between the densely labelled patch and the central retina and both dorsal and ventral to the patch. They were not found in far distant regions of retina and composed a relatively small proportion of labelled cells. They reached a peak at 45 days, had decreased to low levels by 63 days, were rare by 81 days, and by 92 days were absent. This latter age fits with the time when retinotopy was judged to be precise in a previous study (Marotte, '90). Inappropriately projecting cells never originate from the entire retina but only from regions adjacent to the appropriate region. Thus, during development there are no gross projection errors. Initially, ganglion cell axons are distributed on the colliculus in a coarse retinotopy. Refinement of the projection then follows, revealed by this technique as a loss of inappropriately projecting ganglion cells. This is complete by 92 days well before eye opening at around 140 days.

Responses of retinal axons in vivo and in vitro to position-encoding molecules in the embryonic superior colliculus

We show that rat retinal ganglion cell axons exhibit no topographic specificity in growth along the rostral-caudal axis of the embryonic superior colliculus (SC). Position-related, morphological differences are not found between temporal and nasal axon growth cones. However, embryonic retinal axons respond in vitro to a position-dependent molecular property of SC membranes. In vivo, regional specificity in side branching is the earliest indication that axons make topographic distinctions along the rostral-caudal SC axis. Our contrasting in vivo and in vitro results indicate that molecules encoding rostral-caudal position in the SC neither guide nor restrict retinal axon growth, but may promote the development of topographic connections by controlling specificity in the extension or stabilization of branches.