Prehospital Emergency Care in Low- and Middle-Income Countries: A Systematic Review

Diagnosis and management of status epilepticus: improving the status quo

Status epilepticus is a common neurological emergency that is characterised by prolonged or recurrent seizures without recovery between episodes and associated with substantial morbidity and mortality. Prompt recognition and targeted therapy can reduce the risk of complications and death associated with status epilepticus, thereby improving outcomes. The most recent International League Against Epilepsy definition considers two important timepoints in status epilepticus: first, when the seizure does not self-terminate; and second, when the seizure can have long-term consequences, including neuronal injury. Recent advances in our understanding of the pathophysiology of status epilepticus indicate that changes in neurotransmission as status epilepticus progresses can increase excitatory seizure-facilitating and decrease inhibitory seizure-terminating mechanisms at a cellular level. Effective clinical management requires rapid initiation of supportive measures, assessment of the cause of the seizure, and first-line treatment with benzodiazepines. If status epilepticus continues, management should entail second-line and third-line treatment agents, supportive EEG monitoring, and admission to an intensive care unit. Future research to study early seizure detection, rescue protocols and medications, rapid treatment escalation, and integration of fundamental scientific and clinical evidence into clinical practice could shorten seizure duration and reduce associated complications. Furthermore, improved recognition, education, and treatment in patients who are at risk might help to prevent status epilepticus, particularly for patients living in low-income and middle-income countries.

Seizure emergency code strategy: Improving treatment times and hospital outcomes for patients with urgent epileptic seizures

OBJECTIVE

Timely treatment is one of the most relevant prognostic factors in patients with urgent epileptic seizures. Despite the available evidence, treatment times remain suboptimal. The aim of this study was to demonstrate the impact of the "seizure code" in an emergency department, focusing on both treatment times and hospital outcomes of patients with urgent epileptic seizures.

METHODS

An ambispective cohort study was conducted in the emergency department of a public hospital in Bogotá, Colombia. Treatment times and hospital outcomes were evaluated both before and after the implementation of the seizure code.

RESULTS

A total of 336 patients were included (94 in the pre-seizure code period and 242 in the post-seizure code period). Both cohorts were comparable in terms of clinical and demographic baseline characteristics. After the implementation of the seizure code, in-hospital treatment times improved among patients with status epilepticus and seizure cluster. For the group of patients with status epilepticus, the time from arrival to the first benzodiazepine decreased from a median of 100.5 min (IQR: 43-152.5) to a median of 20 min (IQR: 10-45) (p = .0063), and the time from arrival to the first non-benzodiazepine antiseizure medication decreased from a median of 155 min (IQR: 49-194) to a median of 39 min (IQR: 25-57) (p = .0071). For the group of patients with seizure cluster, the time from arrival to the first non-benzodiazepine antiseizure medication decreased from a median of 296 min (IQR: 112.5-409) to a median of 72 min (IQR: 46-111) (p < .001). The seizure code significantly decreased the risk of inappropriate benzodiazepine use (p = .0087), in-hospital seizure recurrence (p < .001), in-hospital mortality (p = .0074), and prolonged hospitalizations (more than 48 h) (p = .0475).

SIGNIFICANCE

The seizure code shortens the time to treatment, reduces the length of hospital stay, decreases the risk of inappropriate benzodiazepine use, and lowers both the in-hospital seizure recurrence and in-hospital mortality among patients with urgent epileptic seizures.

Implementation of a Technology-Based Mobile Obstetric Referral Emergency System (MORES): Qualitative Assessment of Health Workers in Rural Liberia

BACKGROUND

Maternal mortality remains a persistent challenge in low- and middle-income countries, where evidence-based interventions of obstetric triage and prehospital communication remain sparse. There is limited implementation evidence for technology-based approaches to improve obstetric care in such contexts. Liberia struggles with maternal mortality, particularly in rural areas where deaths are attributable to delays from absent triage and interfacility communication. We implemented a Mobile Obstetric Referral Emergency System (MORES) in rural Bong County to improve prehospital transfer, health worker attentiveness, and patient care for critical obstetric patients. MORES consisted of triage training and a 2-way, templated WhatsApp communication system to reduce delays among patients transferred from rural health facilities (RHF) to hospitals.

OBJECTIVE

This study aimed to examine MORES implementation outcomes of usability, fidelity, effectiveness, sustainability, and scalability, as well as additional impacts on the wider health system.

METHODS

A structured case study design interview was developed by Liberian and US experts in obstetric triage. Participants included 62 frontline obstetric health providers including midwives (38/62, 61%), nurses (20/62, 32%), physicians assistants (3/62, 5%), and physicians (1/62, 2%) from 19 RHFs and 2 district hospitals who had used MORES for 1 year. Individual interviews were conducted on MORES implementation outcomes, transcribed, and analyzed in NVivo (version 12; Lumivero) with a team-based coding methodology. Content analysis with a deductive approach examined implementation outcomes of usability, fidelity, effectiveness, sustainability, and scalability, while an inductive approach categorized the unanticipated impacts of MORES on the wider health system.

RESULTS

Four domains were identified regarding MORES implementation: Usability and Fidelity, Effectiveness, Sustainability and Scalability, and Health System Impact. All participants perceived MORES to have high usability and fidelity, as the triage and messaging system was implemented as intended for critical obstetric patients (62/62, 100%). For effectiveness, MORES accomplished its intended aims by improving prehospital transfer (57/62, 92%), increasing health worker attentiveness (39/62, 63%), and contributing to improved patient care (34/62, 55%). MORES was perceived as sustainable and scalable (62/62, 100%), particularly if technological barriers (21/62, 34%) and staff training (19/62, 31%) were addressed. MORES impacted the wider health system in unanticipated ways including improved coordination and accountability (55/62, 89%), feedback mechanisms for hospitals and RHFs (48/62, 77%), interprofessional teamwork (21/62, 34%), longitudinal follow-up care (20/62, 32%), creating a record of care delays (17/62, 27%), and electronic health record infrastructure (13/62, 21%).

CONCLUSIONS

MORES was perceived to have high usability, fidelity, effectiveness, sustainability, and scalability by frontline obstetric providers in rural Liberia. MORES accomplished the intended aims of improving prehospital transfer, increasing health worker attentiveness, and contributing to improved patient care. Additionally, MORES strengthened the health system through 6 domains which impacted individual and system levels. Future studies should quantitatively evaluate delay and morbidity reductions and strategies for scaling MORES.

Factors Associated With Delayed Hospital Arrival After Stroke Onset: An Observational Study in Thanh Hoa Province, Vietnam

BACKGROUND

Delayed hospital arrival lowers the proportion of patients with stroke receiving recanalization therapy and results in poor outcomes. This study investigated the factors associated with pre-hospital delays in hospital arrival after stroke onset in the Thanh Hoa Province, Vietnam.

METHODS

Clinical data were collected from stroke patients within seven days of symptom onset who were prospectively registered in this study. Patients and their relatives were interviewed using a structured questionnaire about patient social demographics, address, post-stroke support actions, and stroke awareness. Pre-hospital delay in hospital arrival was dichotomized into ≤ 4.5 hours and > 4.5 hours, and multivariable logistic regression analysis was used to investigate factors associated with the delay.

RESULT

Of the 328 participants analyzed, 181 (55.4%) arrived at the hospital 4.5 hours after the symptom onset. The patients' and relatives' awareness of stroke was poor, with 298 (91.4%) who had never heard about signs of stroke onset, facial drooping, arm weakness, speech difficulties, and time to call emergency service (FAST). Pre-hospital delays were longer for patients living >10 km away from a healthcare facility and those with secondary or lower education levels, with odds ratios of 2.07 and 1.99, respectively. Seeking care at a district or private hospital as the first point of healthcare or non-use of emergency medical services did not show significant associations with odds ratio and 95% CI of 1.57 (0.93-2.65).

DISCUSSION

The study revealed that most patients with stroke did not arrive at the hospital in time for recanalization therapy. Moreover, the low stroke awareness among patients and their relatives is concerning. Further research is needed to investigate the reasons for pre-hospital delays and develop targeted interventions to improve stroke awareness and reduce these delays.

Current status of implementation of trauma registries' in LMICs & facilitators to implementation barriers: A literature review & consultation

Background & objectives Many low- and middle- income countries (LMICs) have attempted to implement trauma registries with varying degrees of success. This study aimed to understand the registry implementation mechanism in LMICs better. Study objectives include assessment of the current use of trauma registries in LMICs, identification of barriers to the process and potential areas for intervention, and investigation of the registry implementation experience of key stakeholders in LMICs. Methods An initial narrative review of articles on trauma registry use in LMICs published in English between January 2017 and September 2023 was conducted. Key findings identified in this review were used to establish a theoretical framework from which an interview guide was subsequently developed. Expert consultation with key stakeholders in trauma registry implementation in two LMICs was conducted to assess the experience of registry implementation further. Results The presence of trauma registries in LMICs is limited. Key implementation barriers include funding concerns, uncoordinated administrative efforts, lack of human and physical resources (i.e., technology, equipment), and challenges in data management, analysis, and quality. Stakeholder interviews highlighted the importance of trauma registry development but echoed some obstacles, notably funding and data collection barriers. Interpretation & conclusions Barriers to registry implementation are ubiquitous and may contribute to the low uptake of registries in LMICs. One potential solution to these challenges is the application of the WHO International Registry for Trauma and Emergency Care. Future studies examining context-specific challenges to registry implementation and sustained utilization are required.

Comprehensive Risk Analysis of Emergency Medical Response Systems in Serbian Healthcare: Assessing Systemic Vulnerabilities in Disaster Preparedness and Response

BACKGROUND/OBJECTIVES

Emergency Medical Response Systems (EMRSs) play a vital role in delivering medical aid during natural and man-made disasters. This quantitative research delves into the analysis of risk and effectiveness within Serbia's Emergency Medical Services (EMS), with a special emphasis on how work organization, resource distribution, and preparedness for mass casualty events contribute to overall disaster preparedness.

METHODS

The study was conducted using a questionnaire consisting of 7 sections and a total of 88 variables, distributed to and collected from 172 healthcare institutions (Public Health Centers and Hospitals). Statistical methods, including Pearson's correlation, multivariate regression analysis, and chi-square tests, were rigorously applied to analyze and interpret the data.

RESULTS

The results from the multivariate regression analysis revealed that the organization of working hours (β = 0.035) and shift work (β = 0.042) were significant predictors of EMS organization, explaining 1.9% of the variance (R2 = 0.019). Furthermore, shift work (β = -0.045) and working hours (β = -0.037) accounted for 2.0% of the variance in the number of EMS points performed (R2 = 0.020). Also, the availability of ambulance vehicles (β = 0.075) and financial resources (β = 0.033) explained 4.1% of the variance in mass casualty preparedness (R2 = 0.041). When it comes to service area coverage, the regression results suggest that none of the predictors were statistically significant. Based on Pearson's correlation results, there is a statistically significant correlation between the EMS organization and several key variables such as the number of EMS doctors (p = 0.000), emergency medicine specialists (p = 0.000), etc. Moreover, the Chi-square test results reveal statistically significant correlations between EMS organization and how EMS activities are conducted (p = 0.001), the number of activity locations (p = 0.005), and the structure of working hours (p = 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

Additionally, the results underscore the necessity for increased financial support, standardized protocols, and enhanced intersectoral collaboration to strengthen Serbia's EMRS and improve overall disaster response effectiveness. Based on these findings, a clear roadmap is provided for policymakers, healthcare administrators, and EMS personnel to prioritize strategic interventions and build a robust emergency medical response system.

Challenges in traumatic spinal cord injury care in developing countries - a scoping review

Objective

To evaluate the leading challenges in developing countries' traumatic spinal cord injury (TSCI) care.

Methods

We conducted a systematic search in electronic databases of PubMed, SCOPUS, Web of Science, EMBASE, and Cochrane Library on 16 April 2023. Studies that investigated challenges associated with the management of TSCI in developing countries were eligible for review. We extracted related outcomes and categorized them into four distinct parts: injury prevention, pre-hospital care, in-hospital care, and post-hospital care.

Results

We identified 82 articles that met the eligibility criteria including 13 studies on injury prevention, 25 on pre-hospital care, 32 on in-hospital care, and 61 on post-hospital care. Challenges related to post-hospital problems including the personal, financial, and social consequences of patients' disabilities and the deficiencies in empowering people with TSCI were foremost studied. Lack of trained human resources, insufficient public education and delays in care delivery were barriers in the acute and chronic management of TSCI. A well-defined pre-hospital network and standard guidelines for the management of acute neurotrauma are needed. Critical challenges in injury prevention include deficiencies in infrastructure and supportive legislation.

Conclusion

Studies focusing on injury prevention and pre-hospital care in TSCI management in developing countries warrant further investigation. It is imperative to develop systematic and evidence-based initiatives that are specifically tailored to the unique circumstances of each country to address these challenges effectively. By understanding the primary obstacles, policymakers and healthcare providers can establish goals for improving education, planning, legislation, and resource allocation.

Transportation and equipment needs for emergency medical services development in low- and middle-income countries

Prehospital emergency medical services play a vital role in reducing mortality and disease burden in low- and middle-income countries. However, the availability of adequate prehospital emergency care remains a significant challenge in many resource-limited communities, with over 91% of the African population lacking access to sufficient emergency medical services. This commentary aims to highlight the critical components of transportation infrastructure and medical supply chain challenges for emergency medical service development and propose potential solutions for future study. Transportation is a key factor influencing prehospital mortality, yet many low- and middle-income countries face issues related to timely prehospital transportation, with patients often relying on family members or private vehicles for transportation, leading to delays in reaching healthcare facilities due to poor road infrastructure. Dysfunctional and inadequate vehicles are also common barriers to timely care. Response times and transport times often exceed high-income standards, with some rural areas experiencing total prehospital time, defined as the time of injury to arrival at definitive care, exceeding 24 hours. To address these transportation challenges, some low- and middle-income countries have developed tier-1 emergency medical services programs that use existing transportation infrastructure and involve lay first responders using motorized and non-motorized vehicles. These programs prioritize rapid transportation over advanced on-scene intervention, potentially providing faster response times. A combination of tier-1 and tier-2 emergency medical services systems, as seen in some successful examples, allows for early on-scene guidance and resource allocation. In addition to transportation, the availability of medical equipment is crucial for effective prehospital interventions, particularly in tier-2 systems. However, low- and middle-income countries often face shortages of even basic supplies, limiting the scope of care that emergency medical services personnel can provide. Developing tier-2 emergency medical services upon a foundation of tier-1 prehospital care utilizing sustainable local supply chains and common household items for basic care can help alleviate these equipment challenges. The integration of tier-1 and tier-2 systems may offer a promising solution to address resource limitations and improve timely access to emergency care in low- and middle-income countries. Further research and investment are required to explore and implement these solutions, ultimately reducing mortality and enhancing healthcare services in resource-limited communities.

Mapping the processes and information flows of a prehospital emergency care system in Rwanda: a process mapping exercise

OBJECTIVE

A vital component of a prehospital emergency care system is getting an injured patient to the right hospital at the right time. Process and information flow mapping are recognised methods to show where efficiencies can be made. We aimed to understand the process and information flows used by the prehospital emergency service in transporting community emergencies in Rwanda in order to identify areas for improvement.

DESIGN

Two facilitated process/information mapping workshops were conducted. Process maps were produced in real time during discussions and shared with participants for their agreement. They were further validated by field observations.

SETTING

The study took place in two prehospital care settings serving predominantly rural and predominantly urban patients.

PARTICIPANTS

24 healthcare professionals from various cadres. Field observations were done on 49 emergencies across both sites.

RESULTS

Two maps were produced, and four main process stages were described: (1) call triage by the dispatch/call centre team, (2) scene triage by the ambulance team, (3) patient monitoring by the ambulance team on the way to the health facility and (4) handover process at the health facility. The first key finding was that the rural site had multiple points of entry into the system for emergency patients, whereas the urban system had one point of entry (the national emergency number); processes were otherwise similar between sites. The second was that although large amounts of information were collected to inform decision-making about which health facility to transfer patients to, participants found it challenging to articulate the intellectual process by which they used this to make decisions; guidelines were not used for decision-making.

DISCUSSION

We have identified several areas of the prehospital care processes where there can be efficiencies. To make efficiencies in the decision-making process and produce a standard approach for all patients will require protocolising care pathways.

Pakistan's Emergency Medical Services (EMS) system & out-of-hospital-cardiac-arrest (OHCA): A narrative review of an EMS system of a low middle income country in context of OHCA

Pakistan's Emergency Medical Services (EMS) are a critical component of its healthcare system, providing pre-hospital emergency care across a nation with over 220 million people. This article explores the evolutionary journey of Pakistan's EMS, highlighting both the challenges it faces and the strides it has made, with a specific emphasis on patients experiencing out-of-hospital cardiac arrest (OHCA). To extract relevant information, we searched MEDLINE & Embase data bases using MeSH terms "Emergency Medical Services" OR "EMS" AND "Out-of-Hospital-Cardiac-Arrest" OR "OHCA" AND "Pakistan". In addition, we also retrieved information from the EMS leadership in Pakistan through e-mails. We delve into the significance of key performance indicators for OHCA, advocate for the establishment of OHCA registries to improve patient outcomes, address regional disparities in pre-hospital care, and acknowledge the gradual progress of the EMS system.

Effect of Rural Trauma Team Development on the Outcomes of Motorcycle Accident-Related Injuries (Motor Registry Project): Protocol for a Multicenter Cluster Randomized Controlled Trial

BACKGROUND

Injury is a global health concern, and injury-related mortality disproportionately impacts low- and middle-income countries (LMICs). Compelling evidence from observational studies in high-income countries shows that trauma education programs, such as the Rural Trauma Team Development Course (RTTDC), increase clinician knowledge of injury care. There is a dearth of such evidence from controlled clinical trials to demonstrate the effect of the RTTDC on process and patient outcomes in LMICs.

OBJECTIVE

This multicenter cluster randomized controlled clinical trial aims to examine the impact of the RTTDC on process and patient outcomes associated with motorcycle accident-related injuries in an African low-resource setting.

METHODS

This is a 2-arm, parallel, multi-period, cluster randomized, controlled, clinical trial in Uganda, where rural trauma team development training is not routinely conducted. We will recruit regional referral hospitals and include patients with motorcycle accident-related injuries, interns, medical trainees, and road traffic law enforcement professionals. The intervention group (RTTDC) and control group (standard care) will include 3 hospitals each. The primary outcomes will be the interval from the accident to hospital admission and the interval from the referral decision to hospital discharge. The secondary outcomes will be all-cause mortality and morbidity associated with neurological and orthopedic injuries at 90 days after injury. All outcomes will be measured as final values. We will compare baseline characteristics and outcomes at both individual and cluster levels between the intervention and control groups. We will use mixed effects regression models to report any absolute or relative differences along with 95% CIs. We will perform subgroup analyses to evaluate and control confounding due to injury mechanisms and injury severity. We will establish a motorcycle trauma outcome (MOTOR) registry in consultation with community traffic police.

RESULTS

The trial was approved on August 27, 2019. The actual recruitment of the first patient participant began on September 01, 2019. The last follow-up was on August 27, 2023. Posttrial care, including linkage to clinical, social support, and referral services, is to be completed by November 27, 2023. Data analyses will be performed in Spring 2024, and the results are expected to be published in Autumn 2024.

CONCLUSIONS

This trial will unveil how a locally contextualized rural trauma team development program impacts organizational efficiency in a continent challenged with limited infrastructure and human resources. Moreover, this trial will uncover how rural trauma team coordination impacts clinical outcomes, such as mortality and morbidity associated with neurological and orthopedic injuries, which are the key targets for strengthening trauma systems in LMICs where prehospital care is in the early stage. Our results could inform the design, implementation, and scalability of future rural trauma teams and trauma education programs in LMICs.

TRIAL REGISTRATION

Pan African Clinical Trials Registry (PACTR202308851460352); https://pactr.samrc.ac.za/TrialDisplay.aspx?TrialID=25763.

INTERNATIONAL REGISTERED REPORT IDENTIFIER (IRRID)

DERR1-10.2196/55297.

Comprehensive analysis of vulnerability status and associated affect factors among prehospital emergency patients: a single-center descriptive cross-sectional study

Background

Prehospital emergency care is a critical but often understudied aspect of healthcare. Patient vulnerability in this setting can significantly impact outcomes. The aim of this study was to investigate the vulnerability status and to determine associated affect factors among prehospital emergency patients in China.

Methods

In this cross-sectional study conducted in China, from April 2023 to July 2023, we assessed the vulnerability of prehospital emergency patients using the Safety in Prehospital Emergency Care Index (SPECI) scale. We conducted a detailed questionnaire-based survey to gather demographic and disease-related information. We employed the SPECI scale, consisting of two subscales, to evaluate patient vulnerability. Statistical analyses, including t-tests, ANOVA, and multiple linear regression, were used to identify factors associated with vulnerability.

Results

The study included a total of 973 prehospital emergency patients, with a response rate of 81.9%. These patients exhibited a low-to-moderate level of vulnerability, with an average SPECI score of 14.46 out of 40. Vulnerability was significantly associated with age (particularly those aged 60 and above), disease severity (severe conditions increased vulnerability), disease type (circulatory diseases correlated with higher vulnerability), alterations in consciousness, and chronic diseases. Unexpectedly, digestive system diseases were negatively correlated with vulnerability.

Conclusion

Addressing patient vulnerability in prehospital care is essential. Tailored interventions, EMS provider training, and interdisciplinary collaboration can mitigate vulnerability, especially in older patients and those with severe conditions.

Triage practices for emergency care delivery: a qualitative study among febrile patients and healthcare workers in a tertiary care hospital in Nepal

BACKGROUND

Improving screening and triage practices is essential for early severity assessments at the first point of contact and ensuring timely attention by healthcare workers (HCWs). The main objective of this study was to explore the triage process among febrile patients and HCWs in the emergency department (ED) of a tertiary care hospital in a resource-constrained setting.

METHODS

This qualitative study was conducted from March to May 2023 at the ED of Tribhuvan University Teaching Hospital (TUTH), Nepal. The study included in-depth interviews with febrile patients (n = 15) and HCWs (n = 15). Additionally, direct observation notes (n = 20) were collected to document the triage process and patients' experiences in the ED. Data underwent thematic analysis using the Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis (IPA) approach.

RESULTS

The ED of TUTH offered comprehensive triage services with clear delineation for the severity of febrile patients in line with the World Health Organization (WHO) guidelines. Nonetheless, challenges and constraints were identified. In the ED, evenings were generally the busiest period, and the triage process was not thorough during night shifts. Perception of triage was limited among patients and variable among HCWs. Digitalizing recordings of patient information including payment was deemed necessary for effective management of patients' waiting times at the triage station. High patient throughput added pressure on HCWs and had a potential influence on the delivery of services. Availability of medical equipment and space were also identified as challenges, with patients sometimes compelled to share beds. There were constraints related to waste disposal, hygiene, cleanliness, and the availability and maintenance of washrooms. Febrile patients experienced delays in receiving timely consultations and laboratory investigation reports, which affected their rapid diagnosis and discharge; nonetheless, patients were satisfied with the overall healthcare services received in the ED.

CONCLUSIONS

Improving current triage management requires resource organization, including optimizing the waiting time of patients through a digitalized system. Urgent priorities involve upgrading visitor facilities, patient consultations, laboratory investigations, hygiene, and sanitation. HCWs' recommendations to resource the ED with more equipment, space, and beds and a dedicated triage officer to ensure 24-hour service, together with training and incentives, warrant further attention.

Emergency Medical Service in the Elderly Population in Iran: A Cross-sectional Study Before and During the COVID-19 Pandemic

This research examines the impact of an aging population in Eastern Iran on prehospital emergency medical services (EMS), with a focus on changes before and during the COVID-19 pandemic. A descriptive cross-sectional analysis was performed on data from 10,264 elderly individuals using EMS in Torbat-e Heydarieh County from March 2019 to March 2022. Statistical analyses, including t-tests and Chi-square tests, were conducted using SPSS software. Findings indicate that 30% of the 33,847 EMS calls received were from older adults. The nature of emergencies evolved from cardiovascular issues pre-pandemic to predominantly impaired consciousness during COVID-19, a statistically significant shift (p < .001). The study concludes with a call for research targeted at this demographic and suggests setting up dedicated EMS response units to cater to the elderly, responding to the increase in elderly-related EMS needs.