Electrochemical DNA methylation detection for enzymatically digested CpG oligonucleotides

Wedged DNA Walker Coupled with a Bimetallic Metal-Organic Framework Electrocatalyst for Rapid and Sensitive Monitoring of DNA Methylation

The dissociation of the walking strand from the track gives rise to decreased efficiency and long reaction time of DNA walkers. In this work, we constructed a DNA walker combining the introduction of a wedge segment with a bimetallic metal-organic framework (MOF) electrocatalyst to solve this problem. The target methylated DNA acted as a single-legged walker, and the immobilization probe assembled on the track contained a wedge segment that was complementary to the target methylated DNA persistently, inhibiting its dissociation from the track. The fuel strand modified with a bimetallic MOF would drive the target strand to conduct branch migration and move processively along the track. The stepwise movement of the target strand resulted in the loading of numerous bimetallic MOF catalysts to reduce H₂O₂ at the electrode interface, thereby a significantly increased current response would be obtained for the detection of methylated DNA. This DNA walker achieved a detection limit of 200 aM within 20 min and effectively distinguished DNA with different methylation statuses, which would pave a way for rapid and sensitive monitoring of DNA methylation.

e-MagnetoMethyl IP: a magnetic nanoparticle-mediated immunoprecipitation and electrochemical detection method for global DNA methylation

The quantification of global 5-methylcytosine (5mC) content has emerged as a promising approach for the diagnosis and prognosis of cancers. However, conventional methods for the global 5mC analysis require large quantities of DNA and may not be useful for liquid biopsy applications, where the amount of DNA available is limited. Herein, we report magnetic nanoparticles-assisted methylated DNA immunoprecipitation (e-MagnetoMethyl IP) coupled with electrochemical quantification of global DNA methylation. Carboxyl (-COOH) group-functionalized iron oxide nanoparticles (C-IONPs) synthesized by a novel starch-assisted gel formation method were conjugated with anti-5mC antibodies through EDC/NHS coupling (anti-5mC/C-IONPs). Anti-5mC/C-IONPs were subsequently mixed with DNA samples, in which they acted as dispersible capture agents to selectively bind 5mC residues and capture the methylated fraction of genomic DNA. The target-bound Anti-5mC/C-IONPs were magnetically separated and directly adsorbed onto the gold electrode surface using gold-DNA affinity interaction. The amount of DNA adsorbed on the electrode surface, which corresponds to the DNA methylation level in the sample, was electrochemically estimated by differential pulse voltammetric (DPV) study of an electroactive indicator [Ru(NH₃)₆]³⁺ bound to the surface-adsorbed DNA. Using a 200 ng DNA sample, the assay could successfully detect differences as low as 5% in global DNA methylation levels with high reproducibility (relative standard deviation (% RSD) = <5% for n = 3). The method could also reproducibly analyze various levels of global DNA methylation in synthetic samples as well as in cell lines. The method avoids bisulfite treatment, does not rely on enzymes for signal generation, and can detect global DNA methylation using clinically relevant quantities of sample DNA without PCR amplification. We believe that this proof-of-concept method could potentially find applications for liquid biopsy-based global DNA methylation analysis in point-of-care settings.

Detection of locus-specific N6-methyladenosine modification based on Ag+-assisted ligation and supersandwich signal amplification

Emerging evidence reveals that the epitranscriptomic mark N6-methyladenosine (m6A) plays vital roles in organisms, including gene regulation and disease progression. However, developing sensitive methods to detect m6A modification, especially the identification of m6A marks at the single-site level, remains a challenge. Therefore, based on target-specific triggered signal amplification, we developed a highly sensitive electrochemical method to detect site-specific m6A modifications in DNA. In this work, the m6A site in DNA can restrict the ligation assisted by Ag+, and this restriction effect can activate the subsequent strand displacement reaction and hybridization chain reaction (HCR), thus achieving signal amplification from the m6A site, and finally realizing high sensitivity analysis of m6A methylation. Benefiting from the high specificity of base pairs and the extremely weak binding affinity between Ag+ and m6A, the proposed method was used for not only detecting the target DNA with a putative m6A site, but also identifying m6A marks at the single-site level in DNA. In addition, this study does not rely on antibodies and radiolabeling, so it has the advantage of cost-effectiveness. Therefore, we believe that the proposed strategy may provide a new perspective for methylation research, which can be used to test more clinical samples in further research.

Hybrid Carbon Film Electrodes for Electroanalysis

Carbon materials have been widely used for electrochemical analysis and include carbon nanotubes, graphene, and boron-doped diamond electrodes in addition to conventional carbon electrodes, such as those made of glassy carbon and graphite. Of the carbon-based electrodes, carbon film has advantages because it can be fabricated reproducibly and micro- or nanofabricated into electrodes with a wide range of shapes and sizes. Here, we report two categories of hybrid-type carbon film electrodes for mainly electroanalytical applications. The first category consists of carbon films doped or surface terminated with other atoms such as nitrogen, oxygen and fluorine, which can control surface hydrophilicity and lipophilicity or electrocatalytic performance, and are used to detect various electroactive biochemicals. The second category comprises metal nanoparticles embedded in carbon film electrodes fabricated by co-sputtering, which exhibits high electrocatalytic activity for environmental and biological samples including toxic heavy metal ions and clinical sugar markers, which are difficult to detect at pure carbon-based electrodes.

Quantitative analysis of global 5-methyl- and 5-hydroxymethylcytosine in TET1 expressed HEK293T cells

DNA methylation at the 5-position of cytosine bases (5-methylcytosine, 5mC) in genomic DNA is representative epigenetic modification and is involved in many cellular processes, including gene expression and embryonic development. The hydroxylation of 5mC provide 5-hydroxymethylcytosine (5hmC), the so-called sixth base rediscovered recently in mammalian cells, is also considered to act as an epigenetic regulator. We report herein the immunochemical assessment of 5hmC achieved by an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) using our linker technology. The keys to this assay are 1) the immobilization of genomic DNA with the bifunctional linker molecule, and 2) quantitative analysis by using guaranteed standard samples containing defined amounts of 5hmC. We succeeded in the sensitive and quantitative detection of 5hmC as well as 5mC in HEK293T cells transfected with TET1, and also monitored the effect of ascorbate on the TET1 catalyzed conversion of 5mC to 5hmC. Our linker technology enables the rapid and stable immobilization of genomic samples and thus contributes to the realization of a reproducible 5hmC evaluation method.

Direct DNA Methylation Profiling with an Electric Biosensor

DNA methylation is one of the principal epigenetic mechanisms that control gene expression in humans, and its profiling provides critical information about health and disease. Current profiling methods require chemical modification of bases followed by sequencing, which is expensive and time-consuming. Here, we report a direct and rapid determination of DNA methylation using an electric biosensor. The device consists of a DNA-tweezer probe integrated on a graphene field-effect transistor for label-free, highly sensitive, and specific methylation profiling. The device performance was evaluated with a target DNA that harbors a sequence of the methylguanine-DNA methyltransferase, a promoter of glioblastoma multiforme, a lethal brain tumor. The results show that we successfully profiled the methylated and nonmethylated forms at picomolar concentrations. Further, fluorescence kinetics and molecular dynamics simulations revealed that the position of the methylation site(s), their proximity, and accessibility to the toe-hold region of the tweezer probe are the primary determinants of the device performance.

Signal-on electrochemical detection of DNA methylation based on the target-induced conformational change of a DNA probe and exonuclease III-assisted target recycling

A promising electrochemical system was explored for DNA methylation detection according to the construction of a signal-on biosensor. Based on the ingenious design of probe DNA and auxiliary DNA, methylated target DNA triggered the exonuclease III (Exo III) digestion of auxiliary DNA from 3'-terminus, resulting in the conformational change of probe DNA with an electroactive methylene blue (MB) tag at 5'-terminus. Consequently, the MB tag in the probe DNA was close to the electrode surface for electron transfer, generating an increased current signal. Because of the target recycling of methylated DNA, significant signal amplification was obtained. Moreover, bisulfite conversion conferred an efficient approach for the universal analysis of any CpG sites without the restriction of specific DNA sequence. As a result, the target DNA with different methylation statuses were clearly recognized, and the fully methylated DNA was quantified in a wide range from 10 fM to 100 pM, with a detection limit of 4 fM. The present work realized the assay of methylated target DNA in serum samples with satisfactory results, illustrating the application performance of the system in complex sample matrix.

Dual-Signal Readout of DNA Methylation Status Based on the Assembly of a Supersandwich Electrochemical Biosensor without Enzymatic Reaction

A highly sensitive and selective biosensing system was designed to analyze DNA methylation using a dual-signal readout technique in combination with the signal amplification of supersandwich DNA structure. Through the ingenious design of target-triggered cascade of hybridization chain reaction, one target DNA could initiate the formation of supersandwich structure with multiple signal probes. As a result, one-to-multiple amplification effect was achieved, which conferred high sensitivity to target molecular recognition. Based on probe 1 labeled with ferrocene and probe 2 modified with methylene blue, the target DNA was clearly recognized by two electrochemical signals at independent potentials, which was helpful for the acquisition of more accurate detection results. Taking advantage of bisulfite conversion, the methylation status of cytosine (C) was changed to nucleic acid sequence status, which facilitated the hybridization-based detection without enzymatic reaction. Consequently, the methylated DNA was detected at the femtomolar level with satisfactory analytical parameters. The proposed system was effectively used to assess methylated DNA in human blood serum samples, illuminating the possibility of the sensing platform for applications in disease diagnosis and biochemistry research.

An electrochemical DNA biosensor analytic technique for identifying DNA methylation specific sites and quantify DNA methylation level

We herein developed a novel electrochemical biosensor to detect DNA methylation level, and to quantitatively analyze multiple methylated sites. Graphene oxide was modified with anti-5-methylcytosine antibody to specifically bind CpG methylation sites, and horseradish peroxidase (HRP)-labeled IgG secondary antibody was bound to the former antibody. In buffer containing H₂O₂ and hydroquinone, HRP-IgG catalyzed the oxidation of hydroquinone into benzoquinone over H₂O₂, thereby generating electrochemical reduction signals. The number of 5-methylcytosine was directly proportional to current signal, thereby allowing accurate quantification of methylation level. We also analyzed monomethylated target sequences with different sites. After different methylated sites were captured by the probe, the steric hindrance differences between -CH₃ hydrophobic sphere and the electrode surface were induced. The peak current decreased with reducing distance from the electrode surface, so DNA methylation sites were identified by measuring corresponding peak current responses. With a low detection limit (1 fM), this DNA biosensor was suitable for ultrasensitive DNA methylation detection. The linear detection range was 10^-15 M to 10^-8 M. Meanwhile, this method had high specificity, stability and repeatability, thus being widely applicable to the clinical detection of DNA methylation.

DNA methylation detection: recent developments in bisulfite free electrochemical and optical approaches

DNA methylation is one of the significant epigenetic modifications involved in mammalian development as well as in the initiation and progression of various diseases like cancer. Over the past few decades, an enormous amount of research has been carried out for the quantification of DNA methylation in the mammalian genome. Earlier, most of these methodologies used bisulfite treatment. However, the low conversion, false reading, longer assay time and complex chemical reaction are the common limitations of this method that hinder their application in routine clinical screening. Thus, as an alternative to bisulfite conversion-based DNA methylation detection, numerous bisulfite-free methods have been proposed. In this regard, electrochemical biosensors have gained much attention in recent years for being highly sensitive yet cost-effective, portable, and simple to operate. On the other hand, biosensors with optical readouts enable direct real time detection of biological molecules and are easily adaptable to multiplexing. Incorporation of electrochemical and optical readouts into bisulfite free DNA methylation analysis is paving the way for the translation of this important biomarker into standard patient care. In this review, we provide a critical overview of recent advances in the development of electrochemical and optical readout based bisulfite free DNA methylation assays.

Towards DNA methylation detection using biosensors

DNA methylation, a stable and heritable covalent modification which mostly occurs in the context of a CpG dinucleotide, has great potential as a biomarker to detect disease, provide prognoses and predict therapeutic responses. It can be detected in a quantitative manner by many different approaches both genome-wide and at specific gene loci, in various biological fluids such as urine, plasma, and serum, which can be obtained without invasive procedures. The current, classical methods are effective in studying DNA methylation patterns, however, for the most part; they have major drawbacks such as expensive instruments, complicated and time consuming protocols as well as relatively low sensitivity, and high false positive rates. To overcome these obstacles, great efforts have been made toward the development of reliable sensor devices to solve these limitations, providing sensitive, fast and cost-effective measurements. The use of biosensors for DNA methylation biomarkers has increased in recent years, because they are portable, simple, rapid, and inexpensive which offers a straightforward way to detect methylated biomarkers. In this review, we give an overview of the conventional techniques for the detection of DNA methylation and then will focus on recent advances in biosensor based methylation detection that eliminate bisulfite conversion and PCR amplification.

Electrochemical affinity biosensors for fast detection of gene-specific methylations with no need for bisulfite and amplification treatments

This paper describes two different electrochemical affinity biosensing approaches for the simple, fast and bisulfite and PCR-free quantification of 5-methylated cytosines (5-mC) in DNA using the anti-5-mC antibody as biorecognition element. One of the biosensing approaches used the anti-5-mC as capture bioreceptor and a sandwich type immunoassay, while the other one involved the use of a specific DNA probe and the anti-5-mC as a detector bioreceptor of the captured methylated DNA. Both strategies, named for simplicity in the text as immunosensor and DNA sensor, respectively, were implemented on the surface of magnetic microparticles and the transduction was accomplished by amperometry at screen-printed carbon electrodes by means of the hydrogen peroxide/hydroquinone system. The resulting amperometric biosensors demonstrated reproducibility throughout the entire protocol, sensitive determination with no need for using amplification strategies, and competitiveness with the conventional enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay methodology and the few electrochemical biosensors reported so far in terms of simplicity, sensitivity and assay time. The DNA sensor exhibited higher sensitivity and allowed the detection of the gene-specific methylations conversely to the immunosensor, which detected global DNA methylation. In addition, the DNA sensor demonstrated successful applicability for 1 h-analysis of specific methylation in two relevant tumor suppressor genes in spiked biological fluids and in genomic DNA extracted from human glioblastoma cells.

Evaluation of DNA Methyltransferase Activity and Inhibition via Isothermal Enzyme-Free Concatenated Hybridization Chain Reaction

Methyltransferase (MTase)-catalyzed DNA methylation plays a vital role in the biological epigenetic processes of key diseases and has attracted increasing attention, making the amplified detection of MTase activity of great significance in clinical disease diagnosis and treatment. Herein, we developed an isothermal, enzyme-free, and autonomous strategy for analyzing MTase activity based on concatenated hybridization chain reaction (C-HCR)-mediated Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET). In a typical C-HCR procedure without MTase (Dam), Y-shaped initiator DNA activates upstream HCR-1 to assemble a double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) copolymeric nanowire consisting of multiple tandem DNA trigger units that motivate downstream HCR-2 to successively bring a fluorophore donor/acceptor (FAM/TAMRA) pair into close proximity, leading to the generation of an amplified FRET readout signal. The target Dam MTase and auxiliary DpnI endonuclease can sequentially and specifically recognize/methylate and cleave the Y-shaped initiator oligonucleotide, respectively, and thus prohibit the C-HCR process and FRET signal generation, resulting in the construction of a signal-on sensing platform for MTase assay. Our proposed isothermal enzyme-free C-HCR amplification approach was further utilized for screening MTase inhibitors. Furthermore, the proposed C-HCR approach can be easily adapted for probing other different MTases and for screening the corresponding inhibitors just by changing the recognition sequence of Y-shaped initiator DNA through a "plug-and-play" format. It provides a versatile and robust tool for highly sensitive detection of various biotransformations and thus holds great promise in clinical assessment and diagnosis.

Current trends in electrochemical sensing and biosensing of DNA methylation

DNA methylation plays an important role in physiological and pathological processes. Several genetic diseases and most malignancies tend to be associated with aberrant DNA methylation. Among other analytical methods, electrochemical approaches have been successfully employed for characterisation of DNA methylation patterns that are essential for the diagnosis and treatment of particular diseases. This article discusses current trends in the electrochemical sensing and biosensing of DNA methylation. Particularly, it provides an overview of applied electrode materials, electrode modifications and biorecognition elements applications with an emphasis on strategies that form the core DNA methylation detection approaches. The three main strategies as (i) bisulfite treatment, (ii) cleavage by restriction endonucleases, and (iii) immuno/affinity reaction were described in greater detail. Additionally, the availability of the reviewed platforms for early cancer diagnosis and the approval of methylation inhibitors for anticancer therapy were discussed.

Quantification of gene-specific DNA methylation in oesophageal cancer via electrochemistry

Development of simple and inexpensive method for the analysis of gene-specific DNA methylation is important for the diagnosis and prognosis of patients with cancer. Herein, we report a relatively simple and inexpensive electrochemical method for the sensitive and selective detection of gene-specific DNA methylation in oesophageal cancer. The underlying principle of the method relies on the affinity interaction between DNA bases and unmodified gold electrode. Since the affinity trend of DNA bases towards the gold surface follows as adenine (A) > cytosine (C) > guanine (G)> thymine (T), a relatively larger amount of bisulfite-treated adenine-enriched unmethylated DNA adsorbs on the screen-printed gold electrodes (SPE-Au) in comparison to the guanine-enriched methylated sample. The methylation levels were (i.e., different level of surface attached DNA molecules due to the base dependent differential adsorption pattern) quantified by measuring saturated amount of charge-compensating [Ru(NH₃)₆]³⁺ molecules in the surface-attached DNAs by chronocoulometry as redox charge of the [Ru(NH₃)₆]³⁺ molecules quantitatively reflects the amount of the adsorbed DNA confined at the electrode surface. The assay could successfully distinguish methylated and unmethylated DNA sequences at single CpG resolution and as low as 10% differences in DNA methylation. In addition, the assay showed fairly good reproducibility (% RSD= <5%) with better sensitivity and specificity by analysing various levels of methylation in two cell lines and eight fresh tissues samples from patients with oesophageal squamous cell carcinoma. Finally, the method was validated with methylation specific-high resolution melting curve analysis and Sanger sequencing methods.

Electrochemical biosensing strategies for DNA methylation analysis

DNA methylation is one of the key epigenetic modifications of DNA that results from the enzymatic addition of a methyl group at the fifth carbon of the cytosine base. It plays a crucial role in cellular development, genomic stability and gene expression. Aberrant DNA methylation is responsible for the pathogenesis of many diseases including cancers. Over the past several decades, many methodologies have been developed to detect DNA methylation. These methodologies range from classical molecular biology and optical approaches, such as bisulfite sequencing, microarrays, quantitative real-time PCR, colorimetry, Raman spectroscopy to the more recent electrochemical approaches. Among these, electrochemical approaches offer sensitive, simple, specific, rapid, and cost-effective analysis of DNA methylation. Additionally, electrochemical methods are highly amenable to miniaturization and possess the potential to be multiplexed. In recent years, several reviews have provided information on the detection strategies of DNA methylation. However, to date, there is no comprehensive evaluation of electrochemical DNA methylation detection strategies. Herein, we address the recent developments of electrochemical DNA methylation detection approaches. Furthermore, we highlight the major technical and biological challenges involved in these strategies and provide suggestions for the future direction of this important field.

Development of an electrochemical detection system for measuring DNA methylation levels using methyl CpG-binding protein and glucose dehydrogenase-fused zinc finger protein

DNA methylation level at a certain gene region is considered as a new type of biomarker for diagnosis and its miniaturized and rapid detection system is required for diagnosis. Here we have developed a simple electrochemical detection system for DNA methylation using methyl CpG-binding domain (MBD) and a glucose dehydrogenase (GDH)-fused zinc finger protein. This analytical system consists of three steps: (1) methylated DNA collection by MBD, (2) PCR amplification of a target genomic region among collected methylated DNA, and (3) electrochemical detection of the PCR products using a GDH-fused zinc finger protein. With this system, we have successfully measured the methylation levels at the promoter region of the androgen receptor gene in 10⁶ copies of genomic DNA extracted from PC3 and TSU-PR1 cancer cell lines. Since no sequence analysis or enzymatic digestion is required for this detection system, DNA methylation levels can be measured within 3h with a simple procedure.

Detection of regional DNA methylation using DNA-graphene affinity interactions

We report a new method for the detection of regional DNA methylation using base-dependent affinity interaction (i.e., adsorption) of DNA with graphene. Due to the strongest adsorption affinity of guanine bases towards graphene, bisulfite-treated guanine-enriched methylated DNA leads to a larger amount of the adsorbed DNA on the graphene-modified electrodes in comparison to the adenine-enriched unmethylated DNA. The level of the methylation is quantified by monitoring the differential pulse voltammetric current as a function of the adsorbed DNA. The assay is sensitive to distinguish methylated and unmethylated DNA sequences at single CpG resolution by differentiating changes in DNA methylation as low as 5%. Furthermore, this method has been used to detect methylation levels in a collection of DNA samples taken from oesophageal cancer tissues.

Recent development of carbon electrode materials and their bioanalytical and environmental applications

New synthetic approaches, materials, properties, electroanalytical applications and perspectives of carbon materials are presented.

Electrochemical Label-Free Nucleotide Sensors

Numerous researchers have devoted a great deal of effort over the last few decades to the development of electrochemical oligonucleotide detection techniques, owing to their advantages of simple design, inherently small dimensions, and low power requirements. Their simplicity and rapidity of detection makes label-free oligonucleotide sensors of great potential use as first-aid screening tools in the analytical field of environmental measurements and healthcare management. This review article covers label-free oligonucleotide sensors, focusing specifically on topical electrochemical techniques, including intrinsic redox reaction of bases, conductive polymers, the use of electrochemical indicators, and highly ordered probe structures.