Dehalococcoides-Containing Enrichment Cultures Transform Two Chlorinated Organophosphate Esters

Mechanistic insights into tris(2-chloroisopropyl) phosphate biomineralization coupled with lead (II) biostabilization driven by denitrifying bacteria

The ubiquity and persistence of organophosphate esters (OPEs) and heavy metal (HMs) pose global environmental risks. This study explored tris(2-chloroisopropyl)phosphate (TCPP) biomineralization coupled to lead (Pb2+) biostabilization driven by denitrifying bacteria (DNB). The domesticated DNB achieved synergistic bioremoval of TCPP and Pb2+ in the batch bioreactor (efficiency: 98 %).TCPP mineralized into PO43- and Cl-, and Pb2+ precipitated with PO43-. The TCPP-degrading/Pb2+-resistant DNB: Achromobacter, Pseudomonas, Citrobacter, and Stenotrophomonas, dominated the bacterial community, and synergized TCPP biomineralization and Pb2+ biostabilization. Metagenomics and metaproteomics revealed TCPP underwent dechlorination, hydrolysis, the TCA cycle-based dissimilation, and assimilation; Pb2+ was detoxified via bioprecipitation, bacterial membrane biosorption, EPS biocomplexation, and efflux out of cells. TCPP, as an initial donor, along with NO3-, as the terminal acceptor, formed a respiratory redox as the primary energy metabolism. Both TCPP and Pb2+ can stimulate phosphatase expression, which established the mutual enhancements between their bioconversions by catalyzing TCPP dephosphorylation and facilitating Pb2+ bioprecipitation. TCPP may alleviate the Pb2+-induced oxidative stress by aiding protein phosphorylation. 80 % of Pb2+ converted into crystalized pyromorphite. These results provide the mechanistic foundations and help develop greener strategies for synergistic bioremediation of OPEs and HMs.

Comprehensive dietary exposure assessment of the Chinese population to organophosphate esters (OPEs): Results of the sixth China total diet study

Organophosphate esters (OPEs) are emerging pollutants, while data on their occurrence in foods and human dietary intake are limited. Based on the 6th China total diet study conducted in 2016-2019, this study implemented a comprehensive survey of OPEs in plant-derived foods of cereals, potatoes, legumes, fruits, vegetables, and further assessed dietary exposure from both plant- and animal-derived food. The sum concentrations of 15 OPEs in the plant-derived samples ranged from 0.567 to 106 ng/g ww. 2-Ethylhexyl diphenyl phosphate (EHDPP) (median: 1.14 ng/g ww) had the highest level in plant-derived foods, with a proportion of 35.6% in the total median OPEs. Regional distribution analysis showed a higher contamination of OPEs in plant-derived food from northern area of China. Estimated dietary intakes (EDIs) of ∑OPEs for Chinese population were from 109 ng/kg bw/day in Beijing to 1164 ng/kg bw/day in Gansu province, with mean and median of 296 and 222 ng/kg bw/day, respectively. Although animal-derived foods had higher levels of OPEs, plant-derived foods, specifically cereals, was the major source of dietary OPE intake. The EDIs were much lower than reference doses, which suggested the intakes of OPEs via food consumption could not cause significant health risks to the Chinese population at present.

Metagenomic analyses of aerobic bacterial enrichment cultures that degraded Tris(2-chloroethyl) phosphate (TCEP) and its transformation products

Tris(2-chloroethyl) phosphate (TCEP) is of growing public concern worldwide because of its ubiquitous contamination, toxicity, and persistence. In this study, we investigated bacterial communities in aerobic enrichment cultures with TCEP and its two major transformation products bis(2-chloroethyl) phosphate (BCEP) and 2-chloroethanol (2-CE) as the sole carbon source. Burkholderiales and Rhizobiales were likely two main bacterial guilds involved in the hydrolysis of TCEP, while Rhizobiales and Sphingomonadales may play an important role in the hydrolysis of BCEP, given the increase of Rhizobiales and Sphingomonadales-related phosphoesterase genes when the carbon source was switched from TCEP to BCEP. All Burkholderiales, Rhizobiales, Sphingomonadales were probably efficient in 2-CE metabolism, because their dehydrogenase genes and dehalogenase genes increased after 2-CE enrichment. The different substrate preference of different bacterial guilds highlighted the importance to understand the diversity and collaboration among functional bacteria. Meanwhile, two TCEP-degrading strains affiliated with Xanthobacter and Ancylobacter were isolated. Xanthobacter sp. strain T2-1 was able to degrade both TCEP and BCEP following the pseudo-first-order kinetics with reaction rates of 1.66 h-1 for TCEP and 1.02 h-1 for BCEP, respectively. Ancylobacter sp. strain T3-4 could degrade TCEP following the pseudo-first-order kinetics with a reaction rate of 2.54 h-1, but is unable to degrade BCEP. Additionally, strains that were phylogenetically closely related were found to have different degradation capabilities toward TCEP and/or BCEP, indicating the importance to investigate functional genes such as phosphoesterase genes.

Organophosphate esters and their metabolites in silver pomfret (Pampus argenteus) of the Vietnamese coastal areas: Spatial-temporal distribution and exposure risk

A large number of studies on organophosphate esters (tri-OPEs) in marine organisms have not assessed the simultaneous occurrence of tri-OPEs and their metabolites (di-OPEs) in these species. This research investigated the concentration and geographical distribution of 15 tri-OPEs and 7 di-OPEs in 172 samples of Pampus argenteus that were collected annually from 2021 to 2023 at three distinct locations along the Vietnamese coast. As a result, tri-OPEs and di-OPEs were detected in numerous fish samples, indicating their widespread spatial and temporal occurrence in marine fish and pointing out the importance of monitoring their levels. The tri-OPEs and di-OPEs ranged within 2.1-38.9 ng g-1 dry weight (dw) and 3.2-263.4 ng g-1 dw, respectively. The mean concentrations of tri-OPEs ranged from 0.4 (TIPrP) to 5.4 ng g-1 dw (TBOEP), with TBOEP and TEHP having the highest mean values. In addition, the profiles of tri-OPEs in fish exhibited a descending order: Σalkyl OPEs > ΣCl-alkyl OPEs > Σaryl OPEs. The di-OPEs, namely BEHP and DMP, had the highest mean levels, measuring 33.4 ng g-1 dw and 23.8 ng g-1 dw, respectively. Furthermore, there have been significant findings of strong positive correlations between di-OPEs and tri-OPE pairs (p < 0.05). It is worth noting that there is a noticeable difference in the composition of tri-OPEs between the North and other regions. Despite these findings, the presence of OPE-contaminated fish did not pose any health risks to Vietnam's coastal population.

Unveiling the inhibitory mechanisms of chromium exposure on microbial reductive dechlorination: Kinetics and microbial responses

Chromium and organochlorine solvents, particularly trichloroethene (TCE), are pervasive co-existing contaminants in subsurface aquifers due to their extensive industrial use and improper disposal practices. In this study, we investigated the microbial dechlorination kinetics under different TCE-Cr(Ⅲ/VI) composite pollution conditions and elucidated microbial response mechanisms based on community shift patterns and metagenomic analysis. Our results revealed that the reductive dechlorinating consortium had high resistance to Cr(III) but extreme sensitivity to Cr(VI) disturbance, resulting in a persistent inhibitory effect on subsequent dechlorination. Interestingly, the vinyl chloride-respiring organohalide-respiring bacteria (OHRB) was notably more susceptible to Cr(III/VI) exposure than the trichloroethene-respiring one, possibly due to inferior competition for growth substrates, such as electron donors. In terms of synergistic non-OHRB populations, Cr(III/VI) exposure had limited impacts on lactate fermentation but significantly interfered with H2-producing acetogenesis, leading to inhibited microbial dechlorination due to electron donor deficiencies. However, this inhibition can be effectively mitigated by the amendment of exogenous H2 supply. Furthermore, being the predominant OHRB, Dehalococcoides have inherent Cr(VI) resistance defects and collaborate with synergistic non-OHRB populations to achieve concurrent bio-detoxication of Cr(VI) and TCE. Our findings expand the understanding of the response patterns of different functional populations towards Cr(III/VI) stress, and provide valuable insights for the development of in situ bioremediation strategies for sites co-contaminated with chloroethene and chromium.

An overview of current knowledge on organophosphate di-esters in environment: Analytical methods, sources, occurrence, and behavior

Organophosphate di-esters (di-OPEs) are highly related to tri-OPEs. The presence of di-OPEs in the environment has gained global concerns, as some di-OPEs are more toxic than their respective tri-OPE compounds. In this study, current knowledge on the analytical methods, sources, environmental occurrence, and behavior of di-OPEs were symmetrically reviewed by compiling data published till March 2023. The determination of di-OPEs in environmental samples was exclusively achieved with liquid chromatography mass spectrometry operated in negative mode. There are several sources of di-OPEs, including industrial production, biotic and abiotic degradation from tri-OPEs under environmental conditions. A total of 14 di-OPE compounds were determined in various environments, including dust, sediment, sludge, water, and atmosphere. The widespread occurrence of di-OPEs suggested that human and ecology are generally exposed to di-OPEs. Among all environmental matrixes, more data were recorded for dust, with the highest concentration of di-OPEs up to 32,300 ng g-1. Sorption behavior, phase distribution, gas-particle partitioning behavior was investigated for certain di-OPEs. Suggestions on future studies in the perspective of human exposure to and environmental behavior of di-OPEs were proposed.

New dechlorination products and mechanisms of tris(2-chloroethyl) phosphate by an anaerobic enrichment culture from a vehicle dismantling site

End-of-life vehicles (ELVs) dismantling sites are the notorious hotspots of chlorinated organophosphate esters (Cl-OPEs). However, the microbial-mediated dechlorination of Cl-OPEs at such sites has not yet been explored. Herein, the dechlorination products, pathways and mechanisms of tris(2-chloroethyl) phosphate (TCEP, a representative Cl-OPE) by an anaerobic enrichment culture (ZNE) from an ELVs dismantling plant were investigated. Our results showed that dechlorination of TCEP can be triggered by reductive transformation to form bis(2-chloroethyl) phosphate (BCEP), mono-chloroethyl phosphate (MCEP) and by hydrolytic dechlorination to form bis(2-chloroethyl) 2-hydroxyethyl phosphate (TCEP-OH), 2-chloroethyl bis(2-hydroxyethyl) phosphate (TCEP-2OH), 2-chloroethyl (2-hydroxyethyl) hydrogen phosphate (BCEP-OH). The combination of 16S rRNA gene amplicon sequencing, quantitative real-time PCR (qPCR) and metagenomics revealed that the Dehalococcoides played an important role in the reductive transformation of TCEP to BCEP and MCEP. A high-quality metagenome-assembled genome (completeness >99% and contamination <1%) of Dehalococcoides was obtained. The sulfate-reducing bacteria harboring haloacid dehalogenase genes (had) may be responsible for the hydrolytic dechlorination of TCEP. These findings provide insights into microbial-mediated anaerobic transformation products and mechanisms of TCEP at ELVs dismantling sites, having implications for the environmental fate and risk assessment of Cl-OPEs at those sites.

Genome-Resolved Metagenomics and Metatranscriptomics Reveal Insights into the Ecology and Metabolism of Anaerobic Microbial Communities in PCB-Contaminated Sediments

Growth of organohalide-respiring bacteria such as Dehalococcoides mccartyi on halogenated organics (e.g., polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs)) at contaminated sites or in enrichment culture requires interaction and support from other microbial community members. To evaluate naturally occurring interactions between Dehalococcoides and key supporting microorganisms (e.g., production of H2, acetate, and corrinoids) in PCB-contaminated sediments, metagenomic and metatranscriptomic sequencing was conducted on DNA and RNA extracted from sediment microcosms, showing evidence of both Dehalococcoides growth and PCB dechlorination. Using a genome-resolved approach, 160 metagenome-assembled genomes (MAGs), including three Dehalococcoides MAGs, were recovered. A novel reductive dehalogenase gene, distantly related to the chlorophenol dehalogenase gene cprA (pairwise amino acid identity: 23.75%), was significantly expressed. Using MAG gene expression data, 112 MAGs were assigned functional roles (e.g., corrinoid producers, acetate/H2 producers, etc.). A network coexpression analysis of all 160 MAGs revealed correlations between 39 MAGs and the Dehalococcoides MAGs. The network analysis also showed that MAGs assigned with functional roles that support Dehalococcoides growth (e.g., corrinoid assembly, and production of intermediates required for corrinoid synthesis) displayed significant coexpression correlations with Dehalococcoides MAGs. This work demonstrates the power of genome-resolved metagenomic and metatranscriptomic analyses, which unify taxonomy and function, in investigating the ecology of dehalogenating microbial communities.

The effects of arsenic on dechlorination of trichloroethene by consortium DH: Microbial response and resistance

Inorganic arsenic and organochlorines are frequently co-occurring contaminants in anoxic groundwater environments, and the bioremediation of their composite pollution has long been a rigorous predicament. Currently, the dechlorination behaviors and stress responses of microbial dechlorination consortia to arsenic are not yet fully understood. This study assessed the reductive dechlorination performance of a Dehalococcoides-bearing microcosm DH under gradient concentrations of arsenate [As(V)] or arsenite [As(III)] and investigated the response patterns of different functional microorganisms. Our results demonstrated that although the dechlorination rates declined with increasing arsenic concentrations in both As(III/V) scenarios, the inhibitory impact was more pronounced in As(III)-amended groups compared to As(V)-amended groups. Moreover, the vinyl chloride (VC)-to-ethene step was more susceptible to arsenic exposure compared to the trichloroethene (TCE)-to-dichloroethane (DCE) step, while high levels of arsenic exposure [e.g. As(III) > 75 μM] can induce significant accumulation of VC. Functional gene variations and microbial community analyses revealed that As(III/V) affected reductive dechlorination by directly inhibiting organohalide-respiring bacteria (OHRB) and indirectly inhibiting synergistic populations such as acetogens. Metagenomic results indicated that arsenic metabolic and efflux mechanisms were identical among different Dhc strains, and variations in arsenic uptake pathways were possibly responsible for their differential responses to arsenic exposures. By comparison, fermentative bacteria showed high potential for arsenic resistance due to their inherent advantages in arsenic detoxification and efflux mechanisms. Collectively, our findings expanded the understanding of the response patterns of different functional populations to arsenic stress in the dechlorinating consortium and provided insights into modifying bioremediation strategies at co-contaminated sites for furtherance.

A critical review on sources and environmental behavior of organophosphorus flame retardants in the soil: Current knowledge and future perspectives

Organophosphorus flame retardants (OPFRs) have been widely used in industrial and commercial applications. Unfortunately, the chemical constituents of OPFRs, organophosphate esters (OPEs), which have been proven to be carcinogenic and biotoxic, can release into the environment and pose potential risks to human health. This paper reviews the research progress of OPEs in the soil through bibliometric analysis and comprehensively elaborates on their pollution status, potential sources, and environmental behaviors. The OPE pollution is widely distributed in the soil at concentrations ranging from several to tens of thousands of ng/g dw. Some novel OPEs, newly discovered OPEs in the environment in recent years, are also detected. OPE concentrations vary substantially among landuses, and waste processing areas are important point sources of OPE pollution in the soil. Emission source intensity, physicochemical properties of compounds, and soil properties play important roles in the transfer process of OPEs in the soil. Biodegradation, especially microbial degradation, has potential application prospects in the remediation of OPE-contaminated soil. Brevibacillus brevis, Sphingomonas, Sphingopyxis, Rhodococcus, and other microorganisms can degrade some OPEs. This review helps clarify the pollution status of OPEs in the soil and highlights perspectives for future research.

Mechanistic characterization of anaerobic microbial degradation of BTBPE in coastal wetland soils: Implication by compound-specific stable isotope analysis

As a novel brominate flame retardants, 1,2-bis(2,4,6-tribromophenoxy)ethane (BTBPE) has been extensively used in various consumer products, and frequently detected in various environmental matrices. However, the microbial degradation of BTBPE remains unclear in the environment. This study comprehensively investigated the anaerobic microbial degradation of BTBPE and therein stable carbon isotope effect in the wetland soils. BTBPE degradation followed the pseudo-first-order kinetic, with degradation rate of 0.0085 ± 0.0008 day^-1. Based on identification of degradation products, stepwise reductive debromination was the main transformation pathway of BTBPE, and tended to keep the stable of 2,4,6-tribromophenoxy group during the microbial degradation. The pronounced carbon isotope fractionation was observed for BTBPE microbial degradation, and carbon isotope enrichment factor (ε_C) was determined to be -4.81 ± 0.37‰, indicating cleavage of C-Br bond as the rate-limiting step. Compared to previously reported isotope effects, carbon apparent kinetic isotope effect (AKIE_C = 1.072 ± 0.004) suggested that the nucleophilic substitution (S_N2 reaction) was the potential reaction mechanism for reductive debromination of BTBPE in the anaerobic microbial degradation. These findings demonstrated that BTBPE could be degraded by the anaerobic microbes in wetland soils, and the compound-specific stable isotope analysis was a robust method to discover the underlying reaction mechanisms.

Organophosphate Esters (OPEs) Flame Retardants in Water: A Review of Photocatalysis, Adsorption, and Biological Degradation

As a substitute for banned brominated flame retardants (BFRs), the use of organophosphate esters (OPEs) increased year by year with the increase in industrial production and living demand. It was inevitable that OPEs would be discharged into wastewater in excess, which posed a great threat to the health of human beings and aquatic organisms. In the past few decades, people used various methods to remove refractory OPEs. This paper reviewed the photocatalysis method, the adsorption method with wide applicability, and the biological method mainly relying on enzymolysis and hydrolysis to degrade OPEs in water. All three of these methods had the advantages of high removal efficiency and environmental protection for various organic pollutants. The degradation efficiency of OPEs, degradation mechanisms, and conversion products of OPEs by three methods were discussed and summarized. Finally, the development prospects and challenges of OPEs’ degradation technology were discussed.

Source Identification of Organophosphate Esters through the Profiles in Proglacial and Ocean Sediments from Ny-Ålesund, the Arctic

Little is known about the sources and environmental behavior of organophosphate esters (OPEs) in the Arctic, especially their transformation products. The present study unprecedentedly investigated both 16 tri-OPEs and 8 di-OPEs in proglacial and ocean sediments from Ny-Ålesund, the Arctic. Mean concentrations of tri-OPEs and di-OPEs in proglacial sediments were 487 and 341 pg/g dry weight (dw), respectively, which were significantly lower than those in ocean sediments (1692 and 525 pg/g dw). Ocean sediments might be simultaneously influenced by long-range atmospheric transport (LRAT), oceanic transport, and human activities, whereas proglacial sediments, since they are isolated from human settlements, may be dominantly affected by LRAT. Such source difference was evidenced by the contamination profile of OPEs: chlorinated tri-OPEs with high environmental persistence and high LRAT were dominant in proglacial sediments (66%); however, weakly environmentally persistent and highly hydrophobic aryl tri-OPEs were dominant in ocean sediments (47%), which were plausibly from local emission sources due to their low LRAT potential. Di-OPEs in proglacial and ocean sediments were dominated by groups of parent tri-OPEs with strong photodegradability, such as alkyl (75%) and aryl (58%). A higher mean molar ratio of di-OPE/tri-OPE in the proglacial sediment (14) than that in the ocean sediment (2.2) may be related to its higher photodegradation than that of the ocean sediment.

Dynamic processes in conjunction with microbial response to unveil the attenuation mechanisms of tris (2-chloroethyl) phosphate (TCEP) in non-sanitary landfill soils

Although the environmental and health risks of chlorinated organophosphate esters (OPEs-Cl) have drawn much attention, its environmental behaviors have been insufficiently characterized. As a notable sink of this emerging contaminant, non-sanitary landfills, which may decompose/accumulate OPEs-Cl, is of particular concern. In the present study, the dynamic processes of the typical OPEs-Cl, tris(2-chloroethyl) phosphate (TCEP), in non-sanitary landfill soils were analyzed under anaerobic condition, and the microbial taxa involved in these processes were explored. Our results showed that TCEP could be simultaneously reduced by abiotic and biotic processes, as it was reduced by 73.9% and 65.5% over the 120-day experiment in landfill humus and subsoil, respectively. Notably, the degradation of TCEP was significantly (p < 0.05) enhanced under the stress of a high TCEP concentration (10 μg g^-1), while its ecological consequences were found insignificant regarding the microbial diversity and community structure and the typical soil redox processes, including Fe(III)/SO₄^2- reduction and methanogenesis, in both soils. The microbial diversity of subsoil was significantly lower, and acetate was an important factor in changing microbial communities in landfill soils. The microbes in the family Nocardioidaceae and genus Pseudomonas might contribute to in the degradation of TCEP in landfill humus and subsoil, respectively. The metabolism related to sulfur and sulfate respiration were significantly (p < 0.05) correlated with TCEP reduction, and Desulfosporosinus were found as a potentially functional microbial taxon in TCEP degradation in both soils. The results could advance our understanding of the environmental behavior of OPEs-Cl in landfill-like complex environments.

Organophosphate tri-esters and di-esters in drinking water and surface water from the Pearl River Delta, South China: Implications for human exposure

Some organophosphate di-esters (di-OPEs) have been found to be more toxic than their respective tri-esters. The environmental occurrence of di-OPEs remains largely unclear. A total of 106 water samples, including 56 drinking water (bottled, barreled, and tap water) and 50 surface water (lake and river) samples were collected and analyzed for 10 organophosphate tri-esters (tri-OPEs) and 7 di-OPEs. The concentrations (range (median)) of ∑₇di-OPE were 2.8-22 (9.7), 1.1-5.8 (2.6), 3.7-250 (120), 13-410 (220), and 92-930 (210) ng/L in bottled water, barreled water, tap water, lake water, and river water, respectively. In all types of water samples, tris(1-chloro-2-propyl) phosphate was the dominant tri-OPE compound. Diphenyl phosphate was the predominant di-OPE compound in tap water and surface water, while di-n-butyl phosphate and bis(2-ethylhexyl) phosphate was the dominant compound in bottled water and barreled water, respectively. Source analysis suggested diverse sources of di-OPEs, including industrial applications, effluents of municipal wastewater treatment plants, degradation from tri-OPEs during production/usage and under natural environmental conditions. The non-carcinogenic and carcinogenic risks of OPEs were lower than the theoretical threshold of risk, indicating the human health risks to OPEs via drinking water consumption were negligible. More studies are needed to explore environmental behaviors of di-OPEs in the aquatic environment and to investigate ecological risks.

Rhizobiales as the Key Member in the Synergistic Tris (2-chloroethyl) Phosphate (TCEP) Degradation by Two Bacterial Consortia

Tris(2-chloroethyl) phosphate (TCEP) is of growing concern because of its ubiquitous occurrence, potential toxicity, and persistence in the environment. In this study, two efficient TCEP degradation consortia (AT1 and AT3) were developed and were able to completely hydrolyze TCEP within 20-25 h. Rhizobiales was identified as the key degrader in both consortia, because Rhizobiales-related phosphoesterase genes were enriched by one to two orders of magnitude when the carbon source was changed from acetate to TCEP. In addition, the increase in Rhizobiales abundance was related to the development of TCEP degradation. The isolation of Xanthobacter strains confirmed the efficient TCEP and bis(2-chloroethyl) phosphate (BCEP) degradation of Rhizobiales. The higher abundances of phosphoesterase genes affiliated with Rhizobiales genera (Bradyrhizobium and Ancylobacter), Cytophagales genus (Spirosoma), Sphingobacteriales genus (Pedobacter), and Burkholderia genus (Methylibium), may be related to the faster TCEP degradation in AT3, while the higher abundance of Rhizobiales genus (Hyphomicrobium)-related phosphodiesterase (PDE) genes may contribute to the faster BCEP degradation in AT1. The stepwise hydrolysis of TCEP was likely catalyzed by different bacterial guilds, which was confirmed by the coculture of TCEP- and BCEP-degrading isolates and highlighted the importance of synergistic interactions during TCEP degradation.