Soil Organic Matter and Phosphate Sorption on Natural and Synthetic Fe Oxides under in Situ Conditions

Aluminum substitution stabilizes organic matter in ferrihydrite transforming into hematite: A molecular analysis

The association of soil organic matter (SOM) with iron (Fe) oxyhydroxides, particularly ferrihydrite, plays a pivotal role in the biogeochemical cycling of carbon (C) in both terrestrial and aquatic environment. The aging of ferrihydrite to more crystalline phases can impact the stability of associated organic C, a process potentially influenced by aluminum (Al) substitution due to its abundance. However, the molecular mechanisms governing the temporal and spatial distribution of SOM during the aging process of Al-substituted Fe oxyhydroxides remain unclear. This study aims to bridge this knowledge gap through a comprehensive approach, utilizing batch experiments, solid characterization techniques, and atomic force microscopy (AFM) based peak-force quantitative nanomechanical mapping (PF-QNM). Batch experiments revealed that humic acid (HA) was released into the aqueous phase during aging, with Al inhibiting this release. Various solid characterization methods collectively suggested that Al hindered the crystalline transformation of ferrihydrite and significantly preserved HA on the surface of newly formed hematite, rather than it being occluded within the interior of the new minerals. Results from 3-Dimensional fluorescence spectroscopy (3D-EEM) and Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) indicated that the structure of HA remained constant, with the carboxyl-rich and hydroxyl-rich portions of HA fixed at the mineral interface during the aging period. Furthermore, we developed AFM-based PF-QNM to both quantify and visualize the interactions between Fe oxyhydroxides and HA, demonstrating variations in HA affinity among different Fe oxyhydroxides and highlighting the influence of the Al substitution rate.

Iron-containing nanominerals for sustainable phosphate management: A comprehensive review and future perspectives

Adsorption, which is a quick and effective method for phosphate management, can effectively address the crisis of phosphorus mineral resources and control eutrophication. Phosphate management systems typically use iron-containing nanominerals (ICNs) with large surface areas and high activity, as well as modified ICNs (mICNs). This paper comprehensively reviews phosphate management by ICNs and mICNs in different water environments. mICNs have a higher affinity for phosphates than ICNs. Phosphate adsorption on ICNs and mICNs occurs through mechanisms such as surface complexation, surface precipitation, electrostatic ligand exchange, and electrostatic attraction. Ionic strength influences phosphate adsorption by changing the surface potential and isoelectric point of ICNs and mICNs. Anions exhibit inhibitory effects on ICNs and mICNs in phosphate adsorption, while cations display a promoting effect. More importantly, high concentrations and molecular weights of natural organic matter can inhibit phosphate adsorption by ICNs and mICNs. Sodium hydroxide has high regeneration capability for ICNs and mICNs. Compared to ICNs with high crystallinity, those with low crystallinity are less likely to desorb. ICNs and mICNs can effectively manage municipal wastewater, eutrophic seawater, and eutrophic lakes. Adsorption of ICNs and mICNs saturated with phosphate can be used as fertilizers in agricultural production. Notably, mICNs and ICNs have positive and negative effects on microorganisms and aquatic organisms in soil. Finally, this study introduces the following: trends and prospects of machine learning-guided mICN design, novel methods for modified ICNs, mICN regeneration, development of mICNs with high adsorption capacity and selectivity for phosphate, investigation of competing ions in different water environments by mICNs, and trends and prospects of in-depth research on the adsorption mechanism of phosphate by weakly crystalline ferrihydrite. This comprehensive review can provide novel insights into the research on high-performance mICNs for phosphate management in the future.

Importance of inner-sphere P-O-Fe bonds in natural and synthetic mineral-organic associations

Sorption of organic molecules on mineral surfaces can occur through several binding mechanisms of varying strength. Here, we investigated the importance of inner-sphere P-O-Fe bonds in synthetic and natural mineral-organic associations. Natural organic matter such as water extracted soil organic matter (WESOM) and extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) from liquid bacterial cultures were adsorbed to goethite and examined by FTIR spectroscopy and P K-edge NEXAFS spectroscopy. Natural particles from a Bg soil horizon (Gleysol) were subjected to X-ray fluorescence (XRF) mapping, NanoSIMS imaging, and NEXAFS spectro-microscopy at the P K-edge. Inner-sphere P-O-Fe bonds were identified for both, adsorbed EPS extracts and adsorbed WESOMs. Characteristic infrared peaks for P-O-Fe stretching vibrations are present but cannot unambiguously be interpreted due to possible interferences with mono- and polysaccharides. For the Bg horizon, P was only found on Fe oxides, covering the entire surface at different concentrations, but not on clay minerals. Linear combination fitting of NEXAFS spectra indicates that this adsorbed P is mainly a mixture of orthophosphate and organic P compounds. By combining atomic force microscopy (AFM) images with STXM-generated C and Fe distribution maps, we show that the Fe oxide surfaces were fully coated with organic matter. In contrast, clay minerals revealed a much lower C signal. The C NEXAFS spectra taken on the Fe oxides had a substantial contribution of carboxylic C, aliphatic C, and O-alkyl C, which is a composition clearly different from pure adsorbed EPS or aromatic-rich lignin-derived compounds. Our data show that inner-sphere P-O-Fe bonds are important for the association of Fe oxides with soil organic matter. In the Bg horizon, carboxyl groups and orthophosphate compete with the organic P compounds for adsorption sites.

Research progress of nano-scale secondary ion mass spectrometry (NanoSIMS) in soil science: Evolution, applications, and challenges

Nano-scale secondary ion mass spectrometry (NanoSIMS) has emerged as a powerful analytical tool for investigating various aspects of soils. In recent decades, the widespread adoption of advanced instrumentation and methods has contributed significantly to our understanding of organic-mineral assemblages. However, few literature reviews have comprehensively summarized NanoSIMS and its evolution, applications, limitations, and integration with other analytical techniques. In this review, we addressed this gap by comprehensively overviewing the development of NanoSIMS as an analytical tool in soils. This review covers studies on soil organic matter (SOM) cycling, soil-root interactions, and the behavior of metals, discussing the capability and limitations related to the distribution, composition, and interactions of various soil components that occur at mineral-organic interfaces. Furthermore, we examine recent advancements in high-resolution imaging and mass spectrometry technologies and their impact on the utilization of NanoSIMS in soils, along with potential new applications such as utilizing multiple ion beams and integrating them with other analytical techniques. The review emphasizes the importance of employing advanced techniques and methods to explore micro-interfaces and provide in situ descriptions of organic-mineral assemblages in future research. The ongoing development and refinement of NanoSIMS may yield new insights and breakthroughs in soil science, deepening our understanding of the intricate relationships between soil components and the processes that govern soil health and fertility.

Transformation kinetics of exogenous lead in an acidic soil during anoxic-oxic alteration: Important roles of phosphorus and organic matter

Lead (Pb) can enter soil environment during flooding events such as surface runoff and intensive rainfall. However, the key transformation processes of exogenous Pb during anoxic-oxic alteration remain poorly understood particularly how phosphorus and organic matter contribute to Pb immobilization/release. Here, a kinetic model was established to investigate the Pb transformation in an acidic soil with two levels of Pb contamination under alternating anoxic-oxic conditions, based on the results of seven-step sequential extraction, dissolved organic carbon, sulfate, iron, phosphorus, and surface sites. Results showed that the potentially available Pb, including dissolved, exchangeable, and specifically adsorbed fractions, was gradually transferred to the fulvic complex, Fe-Mn oxides bound, and sulfides bound Pb after 40-day incubation under anoxic conditions, while the fulvic complex Pb further increased after 20-day incubation under oxic conditions. The concentration of phosphorus that was extracted by 0.5 M HCl or 0.03 M NH4F in 0.025 M HCl increased under anoxic conditions and decreased under oxic conditions. When Pb-binding to phosphorus is considered during kinetic modeling, the simulated results of Pb transformation suggest that phosphorus is more important than organic matter for Pb immobilization under anoxic conditions, while the phosphates, Fe-Mn oxides, and sulfides immobilized Pb is slowly released and then complexed by fulvic acids during the re-immobilization of dissolved organic matter in soil under oxic conditions. The model established with low Pb level has been successfully applied to describe the Pb transformation with high Pb level. This study provides a comprehensive understanding of the roles of phosphorus and organic matter in controlling Pb transformation in soil from kinetic modeling.

Organic carbon preservation in wetlands: Iron oxide protection vs. thermodynamic limitation

The sequestration of organic carbon (OC) in wetland sediments is influenced by the presence of oxygen or lack thereof. The mechanisms of OC sequestration under redox fluctuations, particularly by the co-mediation of reactive iron (Fe) protection and thermodynamic limitation by the energetics of the OC itself, remain unclear. Over the past 26 years, a combination of field surveys and remote sensing images had revealed a strong decline in both natural and constructed wetland areas in Tianjin. This decline could be attributed to anthropogenic landfill practices and agricultural reclamation efforts, which may have significant impacts on the oxidation-reduction conditions for sedimentary OC. The Fe-bound OC (CBD extraction) decreased by 2 to 10-fold (from 8.3 to 10% to 0.7-4.5%) with increasing sediment depth at three sites with varying water depths (WD). The high-resolution spectro-microscopy analysis demonstrated that Fe (oxyhydr)oxides were colocalized with sedimentary OC. Corresponding to lower redox potential, the nominal oxidation state of C (NOSC), which corresponds to the energy content in OC, became more negative (energy content increased) with increasing sediment depth. Taken together, the preservation of sedimentary OC is contingent on the prevailing redox conditions: In environments where oxygen availability is high, reactive Fe provides protection for OC, while in anoxic environments, thermodynamic constraints (i.e., energetic constraints) limit the oxidation of OC.

Unraveling the Mechanisms of Fe Oxidation and Mn Reduction on Mn Indicators of Reduction in Soil (IRIS) Films

Indicators of reduction in soil (IRIS) devices are low-cost soil redox sensors coated with Fe or Mn oxides, which can be reductively dissolved from the device under suitable redox conditions. Removal of the metal oxide coating from the surface, leaving behind the white film, can be quantified and used as an indicator of reducing conditions in soils. Manganese IRIS, coated with birnessite, can also oxidize Fe(II), resulting in a color change from brown to orange that complicates the interpretation of coating removal. Here, we studied field-deployed Mn IRIS films where Fe oxidation was present to unravel the mechanisms of Mn oxidation of Fe(II) and the resulting minerals on the IRIS film surface. We observed reductions in the Mn average oxidation state when Fe precipitation was evident. Fe precipitation was primarily ferrihydrite (30-90%), but lepidocrocite and goethite were also detected, notably when the Mn average oxidation state decreased. The decrease in the average oxidation state of Mn was due to the adsorption of Mn(II) to the oxidized Fe and the precipitation of rhodochrosite (MnCO₃) on the film. The results were variable on small spatial scales (<1 mm), highlighting the suitability of IRIS in studying heterogeneous redox reactions in soil. Mn IRIS also provides a tool to bridge lab and field studies of the interactions between Mn oxides and reduced constituents.

Interactions between organic matter and Fe oxides at soil micro-interfaces: Quantification, associations, and influencing factors

Iron (Fe) oxides are widely recognized to prevent the degradation of organic matter (OM) in environments, thereby promoting the persistence of organic carbon (OC) in soils. Thus, discerning the association mechanisms of Fe oxides and OC interactions is key to effectively influencing the dynamics and extent of organic C cycling in soils. Previous studies have focused on i) quantifying Fe oxide-bound organic carbon (Fe-OC) in individual environments, ii) investigating the distribution and adsorption capacity of Fe-OC, and iii) assessing the redox cycling and transformation of Fe-OC. Furthermore, the widespread application of high-tech instrumentation and methods has greatly contributed to a better understanding of the mechanism of organic mineral assemblages in the past few decades. However, few literature reviews have comprehensively summarized Fe-OC distributions, associations, and characteristics in soil-plant systems. Here, studies investigating the Fe-OC contents among different environments are reviewed. In addition, the mechanisms and processes related to OM transformation dynamics occurring at mineral-organic interfaces are also described. Recent studies have highlighted that diverse interactions occur between Fe oxides and OC, with organic compounds adhering to Fe oxides due to their huge specific surfaces area and active reaction sites. Moreover, we also review methods for understanding Fe-OC interactions at micro-interfaces. Lastly, developmental prospects for understanding coupled Fe-OC geochemical processes in soil environments at molecular- and nano-scales are outlined. The summary suggests that combined advanced techniques and methods should be used in future research to explore micro-interfaces and in situ descriptions of organic mineral assemblages. This review also suggests that future studies need to consider the functional and spatial complexity that is typical of soil/sediment environments where Fe-OC interactions occur.

Indicator of Reduction in Soil (IRIS) devices: A review

Documenting anaerobic conditions is critical for understanding soil processes, identifying hydric soils, delineating wetlands, and managing aquatic resources. Several techniques exist to evaluate the oxidation-reduction status of soils including platinum electrodes, chemical dyes, and analyses of porewater chemistry. Since 2002, Indicator of Reduction in Soils (IRIS) devices have proven a novel, reliable, and cost-effective technique to document anaerobic conditions. This technology involves the application of redox active Fe or Mn oxide based paints onto a durable substrate (e.g., Polyvinyl Chloride pipes or plastic films) which are inserted into the soil. If anaerobic conditions occur during deployment, some or all of the redox active paint will be depleted from the IRIS device surface via chemical reduction and the extent of paint removal can be quantified using a number of approaches. Over the last two decades, IRIS technology has evolved to improve the identification of anaerobic conditions in soils and provide a proxy measure of multiple soil biogeochemical processes (e.g., denitrification, elemental sorption, iron sulfide formation). This review paper provides an overview of developments in IRIS instrumental design and interpretation of results, describes current IRIS applications and benefits, and identifies potential future areas of IRIS device research.

Visualization and quantification of carbon "rusty sink" by rice root iron plaque: Mechanisms, functions, and global implications

Paddies contain 78% higher organic carbon (C) stocks than adjacent upland soils, and iron (Fe) plaque formation on rice roots is one of the mechanisms that traps C. The process sequence, extent and global relevance of this C stabilization mechanism under oxic/anoxic conditions remains unclear. We quantified and localized the contribution of Fe plaque to organic matter stabilization in a microoxic area (rice rhizosphere) and evaluated roles of this C trap for global C sequestration in paddy soils. Visualization and localization of pH by imaging with planar optodes, enzyme activities by zymography, and root exudation by ¹⁴ C imaging, as well as upscale modeling enabled linkage of three groups of rhizosphere processes that are responsible for C stabilization from the micro- (root) to the macro- (ecosystem) levels. The ¹⁴ C activity in soil (reflecting stabilization of rhizodeposits) with Fe²⁺ addition was 1.4-1.5 times higher than that in the control and phosphate addition soils. Perfect co-localization of the hotspots of β-glucosidase activity (by zymography) with root exudation (¹⁴ C) showed that labile C and high enzyme activities were localized within Fe plaques. Fe²⁺ addition to soil and its microbial oxidation to Fe³⁺ by radial oxygen release from rice roots increased Fe plaque (Fe³⁺ ) formation by 1.7-2.5 times. The C amounts trapped by Fe plaque increased by 1.1 times after Fe²⁺ addition. Therefore, Fe plaque formed from amorphous and complex Fe (oxyhydr)oxides on the root surface act as a "rusty sink" for organic matter. Considering the area of coverage of paddy soils globally, upscaling by model revealed the radial oxygen loss from roots and bacterial Fe oxidation may trap up to 130 Mg C in Fe plaques per rice season. This represents an important annual surplus of new and stable C to the existing C pool under long-term rice cropping.

Phosphorus sorption capacity of various iron-organic matter associations in peat soils

This study was carried out to evaluate the contribution of different types of iron-organic matter associations (Fe-OM) to the phosphorus sorption capacity of peatland. Humic substance (HS) and particulate organic matter (POM) were isolated from peat soils, and different types of iron-organic matter associations (Fe-HS and Fe-POM) were prepared. Then, isothermal adsorption experiments were carried out on the synthesized Fe-OM and iron-contained peat soils. The morphology structure of Fe-HS associations is amorphous like that of ferrihydrite. The theoretical maximum adsorption capacity (Q_max) of Fe-HS associations can reach 36.90 mg/g, which is approximately two times higher than that of ferrihydrite (19.23 mg/g) and ten times higher than that of hematite (3.26 mg/g) and goethite (2.08 mg/g). Both peat soils and POM can strongly complex ferric ions, resulting in improved phosphorus sorption capacity. The Q_max of original peat soil and POM is 2.83 mg/g and 4.31 mg/g, which increased to 7.36 mg/g and 5.89 mg/g, respectively, after complexing ferric ions. Compared to inorganic Fe minerals, the associations of iron and organic matter (HS and POM) contribute more to the phosphorus retention ability of peat soils. However, the formation of Fe-OM associations could not fully explain why the addition of iron increases the phosphorus sorption capacity of peat soil by so much. Iron should also participate in other phosphorus retention processes, which need further exploration and research.

Impact of abiotic and biogeochemical processes on halogen concentrations (Cl, Br, F, I) in mineral soil along a climatic gradient

In contrast to earlier ideas that halogens behave inertly in soil, extensive biogeochemical cycling of fluorine (F), chlorine (Cl), bromine (Br) and iodine (I) has been shown for temperate forests. To further advance our understanding of halogen behaviour in soil beyond humid temperate forests, we sampled soil profiles in protected areas along the Chilean Coastal Cordillera, representing a pronounced climatic gradient spanning from arid to humid. Halogen concentrations in soil were analysed by combustion ion chromatography. Highest average total halogen concentrations occurred at the arid site (Cl, F: 4270 and 897 mg kg^-1) as well as the humid end of the climatic gradient (Br, I: 42.6 and 9.8 mg kg^-1). Vertical distribution patterns of halogens were most pronounced at the humid end of the gradient and became less distinct under drier climate. The climatic gradient demonstrates the important role of biotic processes (e.g. the halogenation of organic matter) on the retention of halogens in the soil. However, this climate-specific role may be overridden by mainly abiotic processes within a given climate zone (e.g. weathering, leaching, sorption to secondary soil minerals, evaporative enrichment), resulting in vertical relocation of halogens in the soil. Since some of these processes oppose each other, complex interactions and depth distributions of F, Cl, Br and I occur in the soil. In summary, our findings provide new insights into the fate of halogens in mineral soil of different climatic zones, which is important, for example, when radiohalogens are deposited on a large scale after nuclear accidents.

Speciation of heavy metals in soils and their immobilization at micro-scale interfaces among diverse soil components

Heavy metal (HM) pollution of soils is a globally important ecological and environmental problem. Previous studies have focused on i) tracking pollution sources in HM-contaminated soils, ii) exploring the adsorption capacity and distribution of HMs, and iii) assessing phyto-uptake of HMs and their ecotoxicity. However, few reviews have systematically summarized HM pollution in soil-plant systems over the past decade. Understanding the mechanisms of interaction between HMs and solid soil components is consequently key to effectively controlling and remediating HM pollution. However, the compositions of solid soil phases are diverse, their structures are complex, and their spatial arrangements are heterogeneous, all leading to the formation of soil micro-domains that exhibit different particle sizes and surface properties. The various soil components and their interactions ultimately control the speciation, transformation, and bioavailability of HMs in soils. Over the past few decades, the extensive application of advanced instrumental techniques and methods has greatly expanded our understanding of the behavior of HMs in organic mineral assemblages. In this review, studies investigating the immobilization of HMs by minerals, organic compounds, microorganisms, and their associated complexes are summarized, with a particular emphasis on the interfacial adsorption and immobilization of HMs. In addition, methods for analyzing the speciation and distribution of HMs in aggregates of natural soils with different particle sizes are also discussed. Moreover, we also review the methods for speciating HMs at mineral-organic micro-scale interfaces. Lastly, developmental prospects for HM research at inorganic-organic interfaces are outlined. In future research, the most advanced methods should be used to characterize the interfaces and in situ characteristics of metals and metal complexes. In particular, the roles and contributions of microorganisms in the immobilization of HMs at complex mineral-organic interfaces require significant further investigation.

Adsorption of Cr(VI) on Al-substituted hematites and its reduction and retention in the presence of Fe2+ under conditions similar to subsurface soil environments

Aluminum substitution is common in iron (hydr)oxides in subsurface environments, and can significantly modify mineral interactions with contaminants. However, few studies investigate Cr(VI) adsorption and its subsequent mobility on Al-substituted iron (hydr)oxide surfaces. Here shows that Al substitution gradually modifies hematite crystals from {101}, {112}, {110} and {104} faceted rhombohedra to {001} faceted plates, resulting in a general decrease in Cr(VI) adsorption density and favoring of monodentate mononuclear over bidentate binuclear Cr(VI) adsorption complexes. Consequently, the mobility of Cr(VI) might be increased in environments with an abundance of Al-containing iron (hydr)oxides. However, pre-adsorption of Fe²⁺ on hematite promotes Cr(VI) adsorption, reduction and fixation, and Al-substituted hematite removes more Cr(VI) than pure hematite. Similarly, although addition of Fe²⁺ to Cr(VI)-adsorbed hematite remobilizes a small proportion of Cr, it greatly increases the proportion of Cr fixed. As the coexistence of Fe²⁺ and iron (hydr)oxides is common in subsurface environments, Al-containing iron (hydr)oxides will promote Cr(VI) uptake and retention, with a significant proportion fixed as Cr(III), limiting Cr mobility and toxicity. These results offer new insights into how iron (hydr)oxides might control the behaviors of other high-valence redox-sensitive contaminants, and provide a platform for modeling such processes in complex soil and sediment systems.