Comparison of Combinatorial Fragment Spaces and Its Application to Ultralarge Make-on-Demand Compound Catalogs

The freedom space - a new set of commercially available molecules for hit discovery

The advent of high-performance virtual screening techniques nowadays allows drug designers to explore ultra-large sets of candidate compounds in search of molecules predicted to have desired properties. However, the success of such an endeavor heavily relies on the pertinence (drug-likeness and, foremost, chemical feasibility) of these candidates, or otherwise, virtual screening will return valueless "hits", by the garbage in/garbage out principle. The huge popularity of the judiciously enumerated Enamine REAL Space is clear proof of the strength of this Big Data trend in drug discovery. Here we describe a new dataset of make-on-demand compounds called the Freedom space. It follows the principles of Enamine REAL Space and contains highly feasible molecules (synthesis success rate over 75 percent). However, the scaffold and chemography analysis revealed significant differences to both the REAL and biologically annotated compounds from the ChEMBL database. The Freedom Space is a significant extension of the REAL Space and can be utilized for a more comprehensive exploration of the synthetically feasible chemical space in hit finding and hit-to-lead campaigns.

Impact of C-H Cross-Coupling Reactions in the One-Step Retrosynthesis of Drug Molecules

Pharmaceutical synthesis requires a diversity of chemical reactions. The discovery of new reactions enable novel retrosynthetic disconnections, potentially expediting access to complex molecules. This Synopsis demonstrates the use of enumerative combinatorics to find impactful underdeveloped reactions for drug synthesis. By mapping pharmaceutical target molecules onto available building blocks using just one retrosynthetic disconnection even if the requisite reaction is not yet known, we highlight the importance of site-selective C-H cross-coupling methods. This cheminformatics-driven retrosynthetic analysis identifies novel reaction methods of value to the synthesis toolbox.

The IMS Library: from IN-Stock to Virtual

A chemical library is a key element in the early stages of pharmaceutical research. Its design encompasses various factors, such as diversity, size, ease of synthesis, aimed at increasing the likelihood of success in drug discovery. This article explores the collaborative efforts of computational and synthetic chemists in tailoring chemical libraries for cost-effective and resource-efficient use, particularly in the context of academic research projects. It proposes chemoinformatics methodologies that address two pivotal questions: first, crafting a diverse panel of under 1000 compounds from an existing pool through synthetic efforts, leveraging the expertise of organic chemists; and second, expanding pharmacophoric diversity within this panel by creating a highly accessible virtual chemical library. Chemoinformatics tools were developed to analyse initial panel of about 10,000 compounds into two tailored libraries: eIMS and vIMS. The eIMS Library comprises 578 diverse in-stock compounds ready for screening. Its virtual counterpart, vIMS, features novel compounds guided by chemists, ensuring synthetic accessibility. vIMS offers a broader array of binding motifs and improved drug-like characteristics achieved through the addition of diverse functional groups to eIMS scaffolds followed by filtering of reactive or unusual structures. The uniqueness of vIMS is emphasized through a comparison with commercial suppliers' virtual chemical space.

Perspectives on current approaches to virtual screening in drug discovery

INTRODUCTION

For the past two decades, virtual screening (VS) has been an efficient hit finding approach for drug discovery. Today, billions of commercially accessible compounds are routinely screened, and many successful examples of VS have been reported. VS methods continue to evolve, including machine learning and physics-based methods.

AREAS COVERED

The authors examine recent examples of VS in drug discovery and discuss prospective hit finding results from the critical assessment of computational hit-finding experiments (CACHE) challenge. The authors also highlight the cost considerations and open-source options for conducting VS and examine chemical space coverage and library selections for VS.

EXPERT OPINION

The advancement of sophisticated VS approaches, including the use of machine learning techniques and increased computer resources as well as the ease of access to synthetically available chemical spaces, and commercial and open-source VS platforms allow for interrogating ultra-large libraries (ULL) of billions of molecules. An impressive number of prospective ULL VS campaigns have generated potent and structurally novel hits across many target classes. Nonetheless, many successful contemporary VS approaches still use considerably smaller focused libraries. This apparent dichotomy illustrates that VS is best conducted in a fit-for-purpose way choosing an appropriate chemical space. Better methods need to be developed to tackle more challenging targets.

Optimal Molecular Design: Generative Active Learning Combining REINVENT with Precise Binding Free Energy Ranking Simulations

Active learning (AL) is a specific instance of sequential experimental design and uses machine learning to intelligently choose the next data point or batch of molecular structures to be evaluated. In this sense, it closely mimics the iterative design-make-test-analysis cycle of laboratory experiments to find optimized compounds for a given design task. Here, we describe an AL protocol which combines generative molecular AI, using REINVENT, and physics-based absolute binding free energy molecular dynamics simulation, using ESMACS, to discover new ligands for two different target proteins, 3CLpro and TNKS2. We have deployed our generative active learning (GAL) protocol on Frontier, the world's only exa-scale machine. We show that the protocol can find higher-scoring molecules compared to the baseline, a surrogate ML docking model for 3CLpro and compounds with experimentally determined binding affinities for TNKS2. The ligands found are also chemically diverse and occupy a different chemical space than the baseline. We vary the batch sizes that are put forward for free energy assessment in each GAL cycle to assess the impact on their efficiency on the GAL protocol and recommend their optimal values in different scenarios. Overall, we demonstrate a powerful capability of the combination of physics-based and AI methods which yields effective chemical space sampling at an unprecedented scale and is of immediate and direct relevance to modern, data-driven drug discovery.

Carbenoid-involved reactions integrated with scaffold-based screening generates a Nav1.7 inhibitor

The discovery of selective Nav1.7 inhibitors is a promising approach for developing anti-nociceptive drugs. In this study, we present a novel oxindole-based readily accessible library (OREAL), which is characterized by readily accessibility, unique chemical space, ideal drug-like properties, and structural diversity. We used a scaffold-based approach to screen the OREAL and discovered compound C4 as a potent Nav1.7 inhibitor. The bioactivity characterization of C4 reveals that it is a selective Nav1.7 inhibitor and effectively reverses Paclitaxel-induced neuropathic pain (PINP) in rodent models. Preliminary toxicology study shows C4 is negative to hERG. The consistent results of molecular docking and molecular simulations further support the reasonability of the in-silico screening and show the insight of the binding mode of C4. Our discovery of C4 paves the way for pushing the Nav1.7-based anti-nociceptive drugs forward to the clinic.

Remapping the Chemical Space and the Pharmacological Space of Drugs: What Can We Expect from the Road Ahead?

This work examines the current landscape of drug discovery and development, with a particular focus on the chemical and pharmacological spaces. It emphasizes the importance of understanding these spaces to anticipate future trends in drug discovery. The use of cheminformatics and data analysis enabled in silico exploration of these spaces, allowing a perspective of drugs, approved drugs after 2020, and clinical candidates, which were extracted from the newly released ChEMBL34 (March 2024). This perspective on chemical and pharmacological spaces enables the identification of trends and areas to be occupied, thereby creating opportunities for more effective and targeted drug discovery and development strategies in the future.

AI is a viable alternative to high throughput screening: a 318-target study

High throughput screening (HTS) is routinely used to identify bioactive small molecules. This requires physical compounds, which limits coverage of accessible chemical space. Computational approaches combined with vast on-demand chemical libraries can access far greater chemical space, provided that the predictive accuracy is sufficient to identify useful molecules. Through the largest and most diverse virtual HTS campaign reported to date, comprising 318 individual projects, we demonstrate that our AtomNet® convolutional neural network successfully finds novel hits across every major therapeutic area and protein class. We address historical limitations of computational screening by demonstrating success for target proteins without known binders, high-quality X-ray crystal structures, or manual cherry-picking of compounds. We show that the molecules selected by the AtomNet® model are novel drug-like scaffolds rather than minor modifications to known bioactive compounds. Our empirical results suggest that computational methods can substantially replace HTS as the first step of small-molecule drug discovery.

Large-Scale Pretraining Improves Sample Efficiency of Active Learning-Based Virtual Screening

Virtual screening of large compound libraries to identify potential hit candidates is one of the earliest steps in drug discovery. As the size of commercially available compound collections grows exponentially to the scale of billions, active learning and Bayesian optimization have recently been proven as effective methods of narrowing down the search space. An essential component of those methods is a surrogate machine learning model that predicts the desired properties of compounds. An accurate model can achieve high sample efficiency by finding hits with only a fraction of the entire library being virtually screened. In this study, we examined the performance of a pretrained transformer-based language model and graph neural network in a Bayesian optimization active learning framework. The best pretrained model identifies 58.97% of the top-50,000 compounds after screening only 0.6% of an ultralarge library containing 99.5 million compounds, improving 8% over the previous state-of-the-art baseline. Through extensive benchmarks, we show that the superior performance of pretrained models persists in both structure-based and ligand-based drug discovery. Pretrained models can serve as a boost to the accuracy and sample efficiency of active learning-based virtual screening.

Fake it until you make it? Generative de novo design and virtual screening of synthesizable molecules

Computational techniques, including virtual screening, de novo design, and generative models, play an increasing role in expediting DMTA cycles for modern molecular discovery. However, computationally proposed molecules must be synthetically feasible for laboratory testing. In this perspective, we offer a succinct introduction to the subject, and showcase typical workflows to integrate synthesis planning, synthesizability scoring, and molecule generation. Finally, we address limitations and opportunities for future research.

Recent Developments in Ultralarge and Structure-Based Virtual Screening Approaches

Drug development is a wide scientific field that faces many challenges these days. Among them are extremely high development costs, long development times, and a small number of new drugs that are approved each year. New and innovative technologies are needed to solve these problems that make the drug discovery process of small molecules more time and cost efficient, and that allow previously undruggable receptor classes to be targeted, such as protein-protein interactions. Structure-based virtual screenings (SBVSs) have become a leading contender in this context. In this review, we give an introduction to the foundations of SBVSs and survey their progress in the past few years with a focus on ultralarge virtual screenings (ULVSs). We outline key principles of SBVSs, recent success stories, new screening techniques, available deep learning-based docking methods, and promising future research directions. ULVSs have an enormous potential for the development of new small-molecule drugs and are already starting to transform early-stage drug discovery.

Modeling the expansion of virtual screening libraries

Recently, 'tangible' virtual libraries have made billions of molecules readily available. Prioritizing these molecules for synthesis and testing demands computational approaches, such as docking. Their success may depend on library diversity, their similarity to bio-like molecules and how receptor fit and artifacts change with library size. We compared a library of 3 million 'in-stock' molecules with billion-plus tangible libraries. The bias toward bio-like molecules in the tangible library decreases 19,000-fold versus those 'in-stock'. Similarly, thousands of high-ranking molecules, including experimental actives, from five ultra-large-library docking campaigns are also dissimilar to bio-like molecules. Meanwhile, better-fitting molecules are found as the library grows, with the score improving log-linearly with library size. Finally, as library size increases, so too do rare molecules that rank artifactually well. Although the nature of these artifacts changes from target to target, the expectation of their occurrence does not, and simple strategies can minimize their impact.

Relevance of the Trillion-Sized Chemical Space "eXplore" as a Source for Drug Discovery

Within the past two decades, virtual combinatorial compound collections, so-called chemical spaces, became an important molecule source for pharmaceutical research all over the world. The emergence of compound vendor chemical spaces with rapidly growing numbers of molecules raises questions about their application suitability and the quality of the content. Here, we examine the composition of the recently published and, so far, biggest chemical space, "eXplore", which comprises approximately 2.8 trillion virtual product molecules. The utility of eXplore to retrieve interesting chemistry around approved drugs and common Bemis Murcko scaffolds has been assessed with several methods (FTrees, SpaceLight, SpaceMACS). Further, the overlap between several vendor chemical spaces and a physicochemical property distribution analysis has been performed. Despite the straightforward chemical reactions underlying its setup, eXplore is demonstrated to provide relevant and, most importantly, easily accessible molecules for drug discovery campaigns.

Navigating large chemical spaces in early-phase drug discovery

The size of actionable chemical spaces is surging, owing to a variety of novel techniques, both computational and experimental. As a consequence, novel molecular matter is now at our fingertips that cannot and should not be neglected in early-phase drug discovery. Huge, combinatorial, make-on-demand chemical spaces with high probability of synthetic success rise exponentially in content, generative machine learning models go hand in hand with synthesis prediction, and DNA-encoded libraries offer new ways of hit structure discovery. These technologies enable to search for new chemical matter in a much broader and deeper manner with less effort and fewer financial resources. These transformational developments require new cheminformatics approaches to make huge chemical spaces searchable and analyzable with low resources, and with as little energy consumption as possible. Substantial progress has been made in the past years with respect to computation as well as organic synthesis. First examples of bioactive compounds resulting from the successful use of these novel technologies demonstrate their power to contribute to tomorrow's drug discovery programs. This article gives a compact overview of the state-of-the-art.

Computational approaches streamlining drug discovery

Computer-aided drug discovery has been around for decades, although the past few years have seen a tectonic shift towards embracing computational technologies in both academia and pharma. This shift is largely defined by the flood of data on ligand properties and binding to therapeutic targets and their 3D structures, abundant computing capacities and the advent of on-demand virtual libraries of drug-like small molecules in their billions. Taking full advantage of these resources requires fast computational methods for effective ligand screening. This includes structure-based virtual screening of gigascale chemical spaces, further facilitated by fast iterative screening approaches. Highly synergistic are developments in deep learning predictions of ligand properties and target activities in lieu of receptor structure. Here we review recent advances in ligand discovery technologies, their potential for reshaping the whole process of drug discovery and development, as well as the challenges they encounter. We also discuss how the rapid identification of highly diverse, potent, target-selective and drug-like ligands to protein targets can democratize the drug discovery process, presenting new opportunities for the cost-effective development of safer and more effective small-molecule treatments.

Chemical Space Virtual Screening against Hard-to-Drug RNA Methyltransferases DNMT2 and NSUN6

Targeting RNA methyltransferases with small molecules as inhibitors or tool compounds is an emerging field of interest in epitranscriptomics and medicinal chemistry. For two challenging RNA methyltransferases that introduce the 5-methylcytosine (m⁵C) modification in different tRNAs, namely DNMT2 and NSUN6, an ultra-large commercially available chemical space was virtually screened by physicochemical property filtering, molecular docking, and clustering to identify new ligands for those enzymes. Novel chemotypes binding to DNMT2 and NSUN6 with affinities down to K_D,app = 37 µM and K_D,app = 12 µM, respectively, were identified using a microscale thermophoresis (MST) binding assay. These compounds represent the first molecules with a distinct structure from the cofactor SAM and have the potential to be developed into activity-based probes for these enzymes. Additionally, the challenges and strategies of chemical space docking screens with special emphasis on library focusing and diversification are discussed.

ZINC-22─A Free Multi-Billion-Scale Database of Tangible Compounds for Ligand Discovery

Purchasable chemical space has grown rapidly into the tens of billions of molecules, providing unprecedented opportunities for ligand discovery but straining the tools that might exploit these molecules at scale. We have therefore developed ZINC-22, a database of commercially accessible small molecules derived from multi-billion-scale make-on-demand libraries. The new database and tools enable analog searching in this vast new space via a facile GUI, CartBlanche, drawing on similarity methods that scale sublinearly in the number of molecules. The new library also uses data organization methods, enabling rapid lookup of molecules and their physical properties, including conformations, partial atomic charges, c Log P values, and solvation energies, all crucial for molecule docking, which had become slow with older database organizations in previous versions of ZINC. As the libraries have continued to grow, we have been interested in finding whether molecular diversity has suffered, for instance, because certain scaffolds have come to dominate via easy analoging. This has not occurred thus far, and chemical diversity continues to grow with database size, with a log increase in Bemis-Murcko scaffolds for every two-log unit increase in database size. Most new scaffolds come from compounds with the highest heavy atom count. Finally, we consider the implications for databases like ZINC as the libraries grow toward and beyond the trillion-molecule range. ZINC is freely available to everyone and may be accessed at cartblanche22.docking.org, via Globus, and in the Amazon AWS and Oracle OCI clouds.

Overlap of On-demand Ultra-large Combinatorial Spaces with On-the-shelf Drug-like Libraries

On-demand combinatorial spaces are shifting paradigms in early drug discovery, by considerably increasing the searchable chemical space to several billions of compounds while securing their synthetic accessibility. We here systematically compared the on-the-shelf available drug-like chemical space (9 million compounds) to three on-demand ultra-large (ODUL) combinatorial fragment spaces (REAL, CHEMriya, GalaXi) covering 32 billion of readily accessible molecules. Surprisingly, only one space (REAL) intersects almost entirely the currently available drug-like space, suggesting that it is the only ODUL widely suitable for in-stock hit expansion. Of course, expanding a preliminary ODUL hit in the same chemical space is the best possible strategy to rapidly generate structure-activity relationships. All three spaces remain well suited to early hit finding initiatives since they all provide numerous unique scaffolds that are not described by on-the shelf collections.

Calculating and Optimizing Physicochemical Property Distributions of Large Combinatorial Fragment Spaces

The distributions of physicochemical property values, like the octanol-water partition coefficient, are routinely calculated to describe and compare virtual chemical libraries. Traditionally, these distributions are derived by processing each member of a library individually and summarizing all values in a distribution. This process becomes impractical when operating on chemical spaces which surpass billions of compounds in size. In this work, we present a novel algorithmic method called SpaceProp for the property distribution calculation of large nonenumerable combinatorial fragment spaces. The novel method follows a combinatorial approach and is able to calculate physicochemical property distributions of prominent spaces like Enamine's REAL Space, WuXi's GalaXi Space, and OTAVA's CHEMriya Space for the first time. Furthermore, we present a first approach of optimizing property distributions directly in combinatorial fragment spaces.

Exploration of Ultralarge Compound Collections for Drug Discovery

Designing new medicines more cheaply and quickly is tightly linked to the quest of exploring chemical space more widely and efficiently. Chemical space is monumentally large, but recent advances in computer software and hardware have enabled researchers to navigate virtual chemical spaces containing billions of chemical structures. This review specifically concerns collections of many millions or even billions of enumerated chemical structures as well as even larger chemical spaces that are not fully enumerated. We present examples of chemical libraries and spaces and the means used to construct them, and we discuss new technologies for searching huge libraries and for searching combinatorially in chemical space. We also cover space navigation techniques and consider new approaches to de novo drug design and the impact of the "autonomous laboratory" on synthesis of designed compounds. Finally, we summarize some other challenges and opportunities for the future.