Mild Open-Shell Character of BODIPY and Its Impact on Singlet and Triplet Excitation Energies

Singlet Fission as the Gateway to Triplet Generation in Heavy Atom-Free Organic Molecules

Triplet generations in heavy atom-free organic molecules are primarily revealed to proceed through singlet fissions (SFs) by investigating the contributions of SFs and intersystem crossings to the generation rates. The spin-flip long-range corrected time-dependent density functional theory calculations on 11 organic molecules known for triplet generation under photoirradiation are performed. The correlation between the descriptors for SF and the experimental singlet-to-triplet conversion rates strongly supports the predominance of SF progressions in all these molecules, corroborated by experimental observations of their triplet-triplet annihilations. Based on these findings, we propose updated conditions for SF progression: There is a high-absorption singlet state just above the triplet-triplet excitation of the chromophore dimer, or the singlet (triplet-triplet) excitation itself is responsible for photoabsorption. To the best of our knowledge, all organic molecules known for rapid triplet state generation fulfill these conditions.

Solvent and alkyl substitution effects on charge-transfer mediated triplet state generation in BODIPY dyads: a combined computational and experimental study

Donor-acceptor dyads based on BODIPYs have been recently employed to enhance the formation of triplet excited states with the process of spin-orbit charge transfer intersystem crossing (SOCT-ISC) which does not require introduction of transition metals or other heavy atoms into the molecule. In this work we compare two donor-acceptor dyads based on meso-naphthalenyl BODIPY by combining experimental and computational investigations. The photophysical and electrochemical characterization reveals a significant effect of alkylation of the BODIPY core, disfavoring the SOCT-ISC mechanism for the ethylated BODIPY dyad. This is complemented with a computational investigation carried out to rationalize the influence of ethyl substituents and solvent effects on the electronic structure and efficiency of triplet state population via charge recombination (CR) from the photoinduced electron transfer (PeT) generated charge-transfer (CT) state. Time dependent-density functional theory (TD-DFT) calculations including solvent effects and spin-orbit coupling (SOC) calculations uncover the combined role played by solvent and alkyl substitution on the lateral positions of BODIPY.

Spin-Vibronic Coupling Controls the Intersystem Crossing of Iodine-Substituted BODIPY Triplet Chromophores

4,4-Difluoro-4-borata-3a-azonia-4a-aza-s-indacene (BODIPY) dyes are extensively used in various applications of their triplet states, ranging from photoredox catalysis, through triplet sensitization to photodynamic therapy. However, the rational design of BODIPY triplet chromophores by ab initio modelling is limited by their strong interactions of spin, electronic and vibrational dynamics. In particular, spin-vibronic coupling is often overlooked when estimating intersystem crossing (ISC) rates. In this study, a combined experimental and theoretical approach using spin-vibronic coupling to correctly describe ISC in BODIPY dyes was developed. For this purpose, seven π-extended BODIPY derivatives with iodine atoms in different positions were examined. It was found that the heavy-atom effect of iodine atoms is site specific, causing high triplet yields in only some positions. This site-specific ISC was explained by El-Sayed rules, so both the contribution and character of the molecular orbitals involved in the excitation must be considered when predicting the ISC rates. Overall, the rational design of BODIPY triplet chromophores requires using (i) the high-quality electronic structure theory, including both static and dynamical correlations; and (ii) the two-component wave function Hamiltonian, and rationalizing; and (iii) ISC based on the character of the molecular orbitals of heavy atoms involved in the excitation, expanding El-Sayed rules beyond their traditional applications.

Singlet fission initiating organic photosensitizations

The feasibility of singlet fission (SF) in organic photosensitizers is investigated through spin-flip long-range corrected time-dependent density functional theory. This study focuses on four major organic photosensitizer molecules: benzophenone, boron-dipyrromethene, methylene blue, and rose bengal. Calculations demonstrate that all these molecules possess moderate [Formula: see text]-stacking energies and closely-lying singlet (S) and quintet (triplet-triplet, TT) excitations, satisfying the essential conditions for SF: (1) Near-degenerate low-lying S and (TT) excitations with a significant S-T energy gap, and (2) Moderate [Formula: see text]-stacking energy of chromophores, slightly higher than solvation energy, enabling dissociation for triplet-state chromophore generation. Moreover, based on the El-Sayed rule, intersystem crossing is found to simultaneously proceed at very slow rates in all these photosensitizers. This is attributed to the fact that the lowest singlet excitation of the monomers partly involves [Formula: see text] transitions alongside the main [Formula: see text] transitions. The proposed mechanisms are strongly substantiated by comparisons with experimental studies.

Roles of Singlet Fission in the Photosensitization of Silicon Phthalocyanine

The roles of singlet fission in the triplet generation of silicon phthalocyanine (SiPc), a compound analogous to the IRDye700DX photosensitizer used in near-infrared photoimmunotherapy, are investigated by considering the energetical relation between the excitations of this compound. These excitations are obtained through spin-flip long-range corrected time-dependent density functional theory calculations. To initiate singlet fission, chromophores must meet two conditions: (1) near-degenerate low-lying singlet and quintet (triplet-triplet) excitations with a considerable energy gap of the lowest singlet and triplet excited states and (2) moderate π-stacking energy of chromophores, which is higher than but not far from the solvation energy, to facilitate the dissociation and generation of triplet-state chromophores. The present calculations demonstrate that SiPc satisfies both of these conditions after the formation of π-stacking irrespective of the presence of an axial ligand(s), suggesting that singlet fission plays a crucial role in the triplet generation process, although intersystem crossing occurs simultaneously at a very slow rate.

Halogen-free photosensitizers based on meso-enamine-BODIPYs for bioimaging and photodynamic therapy

The search for efficient heavy atom free photosensitizers (PSs) for photodynamic therapy (PDT) is a very active field. We describe herein a simple and easily accessible molecular design based on the attachment of an enamine group as an electron-donor moiety at the meso position of the BODIPY core with different alkylation patterns. The effect of the alkylation degree and solvent polarity on the photophysical properties in terms of splitting absorption bands, fluorescence efficiencies and singlet oxygen production is analyzed in depth experimentally using spectroscopic techniques, including femtosecond and nanosecond transient absorption (fs- and ns-TA) and using computational simulations based on time-dependent density functional theory. The correlation between the theoretical/experimental results permits the rationalization of the observed photophysical behavior exhibited by meso-enamine-BODIPY compounds and the determination of mechanistic details, which rule the population of the triplet state manifold. The potential applicability as a theragnostic agent for the most promising compound is demonstrated through in vitro assays in HeLa cells by analyzing the internalization, localization and phototoxic action.

Singlet fission initiating triplet generations of BODIPY derivatives through [Formula: see text]-stacking: a theoretical study

The role of singlet fission (SF) in the triplet-state generation mechanism of 1,3,5,7-tetramethyl-boron-dipyrromethene derivatives is revealed by exploring the cause for the solvent dependence of the generation rate. Comparing the adsorption energy calculations of solvent molecules, i.e., cyclohexane, chloroform and acetonitrile molecules, to the derivatives with the [Formula: see text]-stacking energies of these derivatives surprisingly show that the hierarchy of the solvation energies and [Formula: see text]-stacking energies strongly correlates with the experimentally-suggested solvent dependence of the triplet-state generation of these derivatives for five and more adsorbing solvent molecules. Following this finding, the excitation spectra of these derivatives in acetonitrile solvent are explored using the proprietary spin-flip long-range corrected time-dependent density functional theory. It is, consequently, confirmed that the [Formula: see text]-stacking activates the second lowest singlet excitation to trigger the spin-allowed transition to the singlet doubly-excited tetraradical (TT)[Formula: see text] state, which generates the long-lived quintet (TT)[Formula: see text] state causing the SF. However, it is also found that the [Formula: see text]-stacking also get a slow intersystem crossing active around the intersections of the lowest singlet excitations with the lowest triplet T[Formula: see text] excitations in parallel with the SF due to the charge transfer characters of the lowest singlet excitations. These results suggest that SF initiates the triplet-state generations through near-degenerate low-lying singlet and (TT) excitations with a considerable singlet-triplet energy gap after the [Formula: see text]-stacking of chromophores stronger than but not far from the solvation. Since these derivatives are organic photosensitizers, this study proposes that SF should be taken into consideration in developing novel heavy atom-free organic photosensitizers, which will contribute to a variety of research fields such as medical care, photobiology, energy science, and synthetic chemistry.

A Computational-Experimental Approach to Unravel the Excited State Landscape in Heavy-Atom Free BODIPY-Related Dyes

We performed a time-gated laser-spectroscopy study in a set of heavy-atom free single BODIPY fluorophores, supported by accurate, excited-state computational simulations of the key low-lying excited states in these chromophores. Despite the strong fluorescence of these emitters, we observed a significant fraction of time-delayed (microseconds scale) emission associated with processes that involved passage through the triplet manifold. The accuracy of the predictions of the energy arrangement and electronic nature of the low-lying singlet and triplet excited states meant that an unambiguous assignment of the main deactivation pathways, including thermally activated delayed fluorescence and/or room temperature phosphorescence, was possible. The observation of triplet state formation indicates a breakthrough in the "classic" interpretation of the photophysical properties of the renowned BODIPY and its derivatives.

Exploring optimal multimode vibronic pathways in singlet fission of azaborine analogues of perylene

The development of new singlet fission chromophores is a vibrant area of research to explore the possibility of efficient photovoltaic devices. Using high-level ab-initio density matrix renormalization group calculations, we present a systematic analysis of BN-doped perylenes for their potential application as singlet fission candidates. Four singlet fission chromophores are identified considering the monomer-based properties and their excitonic characters are further analyzed in a dimer configuration optimized in a six-dimensional space for local maxima of fission rates. Furthermore, a multistate multimode vibronic Hamiltonian is employed to identify intra- and interstate vibrational pathways for excitation energy modulation. Several photophysical properties such as Davydov splitting, activation energy and vibronic admixture of multiexcitonic and charge-transfer states are calculated for physically accessible dimers. The optimal dimer packing results in appropriate vibrational relaxation of singlet fission states and promotes significant population transfer which would be more attenuated without such couplings. This work not only identifies potential singlet fission systems with favorable electronic properties but also highlights the sensitivity of dimer packings with respect to the substitution patterns in singlet fission chromophores.

Generation of multiple triplet states in an orthogonal bodipy dimer: a breakthrough spectroscopic and theoretical approach

Generation of triplet states in assemblies of organic chromophores is extremely appealing for their potential use in optoelectronic applications. In this work, we investigate the intricacies of triplet state generation in an orthogonal BODIPY dimer by combining delayed photoemission techniques with electronic structure calculations. Our analysis provides a deep understanding of the electronic states involved, and describes different competing deactivation channels beyond prompt radiative decay. In particular, we identify charge-transfer (CT) mediated intersystem crossing (ISC) as the most likely mechanism for the triplet state generation in this system. The different emission bands at long times can be associated with delayed fluorescence, CT emission and phosphorescence from multiple low-energy triplets. Interestingly, the dependence of the yield of triplet state population and emission profiles with the solvent polarity evidences the decisive role of the CT configuration in the fate of the photoactivated dimer, controlling the relative ISC, reverse ISC, and internal conversion efficiencies. Overall, the present results provide a rather complete description of the delayed photophysics in the BODIPY dimer, but are not able to fully rationalize the unexpected photoluminescence recorded at long wavelengths (≥ 900 nm). We hypothesize that the origin of this emission, not present in BODIPY monomers, emerges from intermonomer interactions triggered by intramolecular distortions opening up a new vision in the controverted mechanism driving the photophysical behavior from orthogonally linked organic monomers.

Effect of the iodine atom position on the phosphorescence of BODIPY derivatives: a combined computational and experimental study

A new BODIPY derivative (o-I-BDP) containing an iodine atom in the ortho position of the meso-linked phenyl group was prepared. Photophysical and electrochemical properties of the molecule were compared to previously reported iodo BODIPY derivatives, as well as to the non-iodinated analog. While in the case of derivatives featuring iodine substituents in the BODIPY core, efficient population of the triplet state is accompanied by a substantial positive shift of the reduction potential compared to pristine BODIPY, o-I-BDP displays phosphorescence and simultaneously maintains the electrochemical properties of unsubstituted BODIPYs. A theoretical investigation was settled to analyze results and rationalize the influence of iodine position on electronic and photophysical properties, with the purpose of preparing a fully organic phosphorescent BODIPY derivative. TD-DFT and spin-orbit coupling calculations shed light on the subtle effects played by the introduction of iodine atom in different positions of BODIPY.