Liquid-Liquid Phase Separation? Ask the Water!

Emergent microenvironments of nucleoli

In higher eukaryotes, the nucleolus harbors at least three sub-phases that facilitate multiple functionalities including ribosome biogenesis. The three prominent coexisting sub-phases are the fibrillar center (FC), the dense fibrillar component (DFC), and the granular component (GC). Here, we review recent efforts in profiling sub-phase compositions that shed light on the types of physicochemical properties that emerge from compositional biases and territorial organization of specific types of macromolecules. We highlight roles played by molecular grammars which refers to protein sequence features including the substrate binding domains, the sequence features of intrinsically disordered regions, and the multivalence of these distinct types of domains / regions. We introduce the concept of a barcode of emergent physicochemical properties of nucleoli. Although our knowledge of the full barcode remains incomplete, we hope that the concept prompts investigations into undiscovered emergent properties and engenders an appreciation for how and why unique microenvironments control biochemical reactions.

Raman spectroscopy in the study of amyloid formation and phase separation

Neurodegenerative diseases, such as Alzheimer's and Parkinson's, share a common pathological feature of amyloid structure accumulation. However, the structure-function relationship between these well-ordered, β-sheet-rich, filamentous protein deposits and disease etiology remains to be defined. Recently, an emerging hypothesis has linked phase separation, a process involved in the formation of protein condensates, to amyloid formation, suggesting that liquid protein droplets serve as loci for amyloid initiation. To elucidate how these processes contribute to disease progression, tools that can directly report on protein secondary structural changes are needed. Here, we review recent studies that have demonstrated Raman spectroscopy as a powerful vibrational technique for interrogating amyloid structures; one that offers sensitivity from the global secondary structural level to specific residues. This probe-free technique is further enhanced via coupling to a microscope, which affords structural data with spatial resolution, known as Raman spectral imaging (RSI). In vitro and in cellulo applications of RSI are discussed, highlighting studies of protein droplet aging, cellular internalization of fibrils, and Raman imaging of intracellular water. Collectively, utilization of the myriad Raman spectroscopic methods will contribute to a deeper understanding of protein conformational dynamics in the complex cellular milieu and offer potential clinical diagnostic capabilities for protein misfolding and aggregation processes in disease states.

Real-time measure of solvation free energy changes upon liquid-liquid phase separation of α-elastin

Biological condensates are known to retain a large fraction of water to remain in a liquid and reversible state. Local solvation contributions from water hydrating hydrophilic and hydrophobic protein surfaces were proposed to play a prominent role for the formation of condensates through liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS). However, although the total free energy is accessible by calorimetry, the partial solvent contributions to the free energy changes upon LLPS remained experimentally inaccessible so far. Here, we show that the recently developed THz calorimetry approach allows to quantify local hydration enthalpy and entropy changes upon LLPS of α-elastin in real time, directly from experimental THz spectroscopy data. We find that hydrophobic solvation dominates the entropic solvation term, whereas hydrophilic solvation mainly contributes to the enthalpy. Both terms are in the order of hundreds of kJ/mol, which is more than one order of magnitude larger than the total free energy changes at play during LLPS. However, since we show that entropy/enthalpy mostly compensates, a small entropy/enthalpy imbalance is sufficient to tune LLPS. Theoretically, a balance was proposed before. Here we present experimental evidence based on our spectroscopic approach. We finally show that LLPS can be steered by inducing small changes of solvation entropy/enthalpy compensation via concentration or temperature in α-elastin.

Entropy Tug-of-War Determines Solvent Effects in the Liquid-Liquid Phase Separation of a Globular Protein

Liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS) plays a key role in the compartmentalization of cells via the formation of biomolecular condensates. Here, we combined atomistic molecular dynamics (MD) simulations and terahertz (THz) spectroscopy to determine the solvent entropy contribution to the formation of condensates of the human eye lens protein γD-Crystallin. The MD simulations reveal an entropy tug-of-war between water molecules that are released from the protein droplets and those that are retained within the condensates, two categories of water molecules that were also assigned spectroscopically. A recently developed THz-calorimetry method enables quantitative comparison of the experimental and computational entropy changes of the released water molecules. The strong correlation mutually validates the two approaches and opens the way to a detailed atomic-level understanding of the different driving forces underlying the LLPS.

Bridging the Gap in Cryopreservation Mechanism: Unraveling the Interplay between Structure, Dynamics, and Thermodynamics in Cryoprotectant Aqueous Solutions

Cryoprotectants play a crucial role in preserving biological material, ensuring their viability during storage and facilitating crucial applications such as the conservation of medical compounds, tissues, and organs for transplantation. However, the precise mechanism by which cryoprotectants modulate the thermodynamic properties of water to impede the formation and growth of ice crystals, thus preventing long-term damage, remains elusive. This is evident in the use of empirically optimized recipes for mixtures that typically contain DMSO, glycerol, and various sugar constituents. Here, we use terahertz calorimetry, Overhauser nuclear polarization, and molecular dynamics simulations to show that DMSO exhibits a robust structuring effect on water around its methyl groups, reaching a maximum at a DMSO mole fraction of XDMSO = 0.33. In contrast, glycerol exerts a smaller water-structuring effect, even at higher concentrations (Scheme 1). These results potentially suggest that the wrapped water around DMSO's methyl group, which can be evicted upon ligand binding, may render DMSO a more surface-active cryoprotectant than glycerol, while glycerol may participate more as a viscogen that acts on the entire sample. These findings shed light on the molecular intricacies of cryoprotectant solvation behavior and have potentially significant implications for optimizing cryopreservation protocols.

Hydration water drives the self-assembly of guanosine monophosphate

Guanosine monophosphate (GMP) is a nucleotide that can self-assemble in aqueous solution under certain conditions. An understanding of the process at the molecular level is an essential step to comprehend the involvement of DNA substructures in transcription and replication, as well as their relationship to genetic diseases such as cancer. We present the temperature-dependent terahertz (1.5-12 THz, 50-400 cm-1) absorptivity spectra of aqueous Na2 GMP solution in comparison with the aqueous solutions of other RNA nucleotides. Distinct absorption features were observed in the spectrum of GMP, which we attribute to the intramolecular modes of the self-assemblies (i.e., G-complexes) that, at 1 M, start to form at 313 K and below. Changes in broad-band features of the terahertz spectrum were also observed, which we associate with the release of hydration water in the temperature-dependent formation of guanine quadruplexes. Using a state-of-the-art THz calorimetry approach correlating spectroscopic to thermodynamic changes, we propose a molecular mechanism of hydrophilic hydration driving GMP self-assembly as a function of temperature. The free energy contribution of hydrophilic hydration is shown as a decisive factor in guanine-quadruplex formation. Our findings spotlight the role of hydration in the formation of macromolecular structures and suggest the potential of hydration tuning for regulating DNA transcription and replication.

Effect of trimethylamine-N-oxide on the phase separation of aqueous polyethylene glycol-600-Dextran-75 two-phase systems

The emergence of phase separation in both intracellular biomolecular condensates (membrane-less organelles) and in vitro aqueous two-phase systems (ATPS) relies on the formation of immiscible water-based phases/domains. The solvent properties and arrangement of hydrogen bonds within these domains have been shown to differ and can be modulated with the addition of various inorganic salts and osmolytes. The naturally occuring osmolyte, trimethylamine-N-oxide (TMAO), is well established as a biological condensate stabilizer whose presence results in enhanced phase separation of intracellular membrane-less compartments. Here, we show the unique effect of TMAO on the mechanism of phase separation in model PEG-600-Dextran-75 ATPS using dynamic and static light scattering in conjunction with ATR-FTIR and solvatochromic analysis. We observe that the presence of TMAO may enhance or destabilize phase separation depending on the concentration of phase forming components. Additionally, the behavior and density of mesoscopic polymer agglomerates, which arise prior to macroscopic phase separation, are altered by the presence and concentration of TMAO.

Expanding the molecular language of protein liquid-liquid phase separation

Understanding the relationship between a polypeptide sequence and its phase separation has important implications for analysing cellular function, treating disease and designing novel biomaterials. Several sequence features have been identified as drivers for protein liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS), schematized as a 'molecular grammar' for LLPS. Here we further probe how sequence modulates phase separation and the material properties of the resulting condensates, targeting sequence features previously overlooked in the literature. We generate sequence variants of a repeat polypeptide with either no charged residues, high net charge, no glycine residues or devoid of aromatic or arginine residues. All but one of 12 variants exhibited LLPS, albeit to different extents, despite substantial differences in composition. Furthermore, we find that all the condensates formed behaved like viscous fluids, despite large differences in their viscosities. Our results support the model of multiple interactions between diverse residue pairs-not just a handful of residues-working in tandem to drive the phase separation and dynamics of condensates.

Emerging experimental methods to study the thermodynamics of biomolecular condensate formation

The formation of biomolecular condensates in vivo is increasingly recognized to underlie a multitude of crucial cellular functions. Furthermore, the evolution of highly dynamic protein condensates into progressively less reversible assemblies is thought to be involved in a variety of disorders, from cancer over neurodegeneration to rare genetic disorders. There is an increasing need for efficient experimental methods to characterize the thermodynamics of condensate formation and that can be used in screening campaigns to identify and rationally design condensate modifying compounds. Theoretical advances in the field are also identifying the key parameters that need to be measured in order to obtain a comprehensive understanding of the underlying interactions and driving forces. Here, we review recent progress in the development of efficient and quantitative experimental methods to study the driving forces behind and the temporal evolution of biomolecular condensates.

Ensemble structure of the N-terminal domain (1-267) of FUS in a biomolecular condensate

Solutions of some proteins phase separate into a condensed state of high protein concentration and a dispersed state of low concentration. Such behavior is observed in living cells for a number of RNA-binding proteins that feature intrinsically disordered domains. It is relevant for cell function via the formation of membraneless organelles and transcriptional condensates. On a basic level, the process can be studied in vitro on protein domains that are necessary and sufficient for liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS). We have performed distance distribution measurements by electron paramagnetic resonance for 13 sections in an N-terminal domain (NTD) construct of the protein fused in sarcoma (FUS), consisting of the QGSY-rich domain and the RGG1 domain, in the denatured, dispersed, and condensed state. Using 10 distance distribution restraints for ensemble modeling and three such restraints for model validation, we have found that FUS NTD behaves as a random-coil polymer under good-solvent conditions in both the dispersed and condensed state. Conformation distribution in the biomolecular condensate is virtually indistinguishable from the one in an unrestrained ensemble, with the latter one being based on only residue-specific Ramachandran angle distributions. Over its whole length, FUS NTD is slightly more compact in the condensed than in the dispersed state, which is in line with the theory for random coils in good solvent proposed by de Gennes, Daoud, and Jannink. The estimated concentration in the condensate exceeds the overlap concentration resulting from this theory. The QGSY-rich domain is slightly more extended, slightly more hydrated, and has slightly higher propensity for LLPS than the RGG1 domain. Our results support previous suggestions that LLPS of FUS is driven by multiple transient nonspecific hydrogen bonding and π-sp2 interactions.

Antidepressants enter cells, organelles, and membranes

We begin by summarizing several examples of antidepressants whose therapeutic actions begin when they encounter their targets in the cytoplasm or in the lumen of an organelle. These actions contrast with the prevailing view that most neuropharmacological actions begin when drugs engage their therapeutic targets at extracellular binding sites of plasma membrane targets-ion channels, receptors, and transporters. We review the chemical, pharmacokinetic, and pharmacodynamic principles underlying the movements of drugs into subcellular compartments. We note the relationship between protonation-deprotonation events and membrane permeation of antidepressant drugs. The key properties relate to charge and hydrophobicity/lipid solubility, summarized by the parameters LogP, pKa, and LogDpH7.4. The classical metric, volume of distribution (Vd), is unusually large for some antidepressants and has both supracellular and subcellular components. A table gathers structures, LogP, PKa, LogDpH7.4, and Vd data and/or calculations for most antidepressants and antidepressant candidates. The subcellular components, which can now be measured in some cases, are dominated by membrane binding and by trapping in the lumen of acidic organelles. For common antidepressants, such as selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) and serotonin/norepinephrine reuptake inhibitors (SNRIs), the target is assumed to be the eponymous reuptake transporter(s), although in fact the compartment of target engagement is unknown. We review special aspects of the pharmacokinetics of ketamine, ketamine metabolites, and other rapidly acting antidepressants (RAADs) including methoxetamine and scopolamine, psychedelics, and neurosteroids. Therefore, the reader can assess properties that markedly affect a drug's ability to enter or cross membranes-and therefore, to interact with target sites that face the cytoplasm, the lumen of organelles, or a membrane. In the current literature, mechanisms involving intracellular targets are termed "location-biased actions" or "inside-out pharmacology". Hopefully, these general terms will eventually acquire additional mechanistic details.

Liquid-Liquid Phase Separation of the Intrinsically Disordered Domain of the Fused in Sarcoma Protein Results in Substantial Slowing of Hydration Dynamics

Formation of liquid condensates plays a critical role in biology via localization of different components or via altered hydrodynamic transport, yet the hydrogen-bonding environment within condensates, pivotal for solvation, has remained elusive. We explore the hydrogen-bond dynamics within condensates formed by the low-complexity domain of the fused in sarcoma protein. Probing the hydrogen-bond dynamics sensed by condensate proteins using two-dimensional infrared spectroscopy of the protein amide I vibrations, we find that frequency-frequency correlations of the amide I vibration decay on a picosecond time scale. Interestingly, these dynamics are markedly slower for proteins in the condensate than in a homogeneous protein solution, indicative of different hydration dynamics. All-atom molecular dynamics simulations confirm that lifetimes of hydrogen-bonds between water and the protein are longer in the condensates than in the protein in solution. Altered hydrogen-bonding dynamics may contribute to unique solvation and reaction dynamics in such condensates.

Chirality-Selected Coacervate by Chiral Gemini Surfactant

Chiral surfactants present opportunities to self-assemble into supramolecules with a chiral trait; however, the effects of stereochemistry on the formation of simple coacervates remain unclear. Here, we investigate the chirality-selected phase behavior in mixtures of chiral gemini surfactant 1,4-bis(dodecyl-N,N-dimethylammonium bromide)-2,3-butanediol (12-4(OH)2-12) with an oppositely charged chiral mandelic acid (MA). It demonstrates that altering the chirality of surfactants yields a heightened ability to regulate the phase behavior, leading to the formation of three different network-like structures, i.e., wormlike micelle, coacervate, and hydrogel, in the racemate, enantiomer, and mesomer, respectively. The different aggregate structures arise from the intermolecular and intramolecular hydrogen-bond interactions of the two hydroxyl groups located at stereogenic centers. Intriguingly, although they contain similar microstructures, the solid-like hydrogel and liquid-like wormlike micelle show similar low hydration ability and have no encapsulation capability, whereas only coacervate formed by the enantiomers of 12-4(OH)2-12 displays liquid-like characteristics, strong capacity to sequester diverse solutes, and high affinity for tightly bound water simultaneously. These findings further highlight the unique and advantageous properties of coacervates as a promising model for exploring the biological process and understanding how chirality plays a crucial role in early life scenarios and cell evolution at the molecular level.

Modulation of biomolecular phase behavior by metal ions

Liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS) appears to be a newly appreciated aspect of the cellular organization of biomolecules that leads to the formation of membraneless organelles (MLOs). MLOs generate distinct microenvironments where particular biomolecules are highly concentrated compared to those in the surrounding environment. Their thermodynamically driven formation is reversible, and their liquid nature allows them to fuse with each other. Dysfunctional biomolecular condensation is associated with human diseases. Pathological states of MLOs may originate from the mutation of proteins or may be induced by other factors. In most aberrant MLOs, transient interactions are replaced by stronger and more rigid interactions, preventing their dissolution, and causing their uncontrolled growth and dysfunction. For these reasons, there is great interest in identifying factors that modulate LLPS. In this review, we discuss an enigmatic and mostly unexplored aspect of this process, namely, the regulatory effects of metal ions on the phase behavior of biomolecules.

The explicit role of interfacial hydration during polyethylene glycol induced lipid fusion: a THz spectroscopic investigation

While the phenomenon of excipient mediated membrane fusion has been studied widely, the inherent role of interfacial hydration involved in the process has mostly remained unaddressed. Here we report the experimental validation of the fact that PEG-induced membrane fusion is associated with the dehydration of the membrane(s). We explore the explicit hydration behavior at three different lipids (DOPC, POPC and DPPC) membranes with different aliphatic tails as they undergo fusogenic transition in the presence of PEG of average molecular weight of 4000 using THz-FTIR spectroscopy in the frequency window of 1.5-13.5 THz. Dynamic light scattering and electron microscopic measurements confirm the formation of different intermediate steps of the liposomes during the fusion process: bilayer aggregation, destabilization and finally lipid fusion. We observe that membrane hydration follows a systematic trend with the lipid specificity as the fusion process sets in.

From Local Hydration Motifs in Aqueous Acetic Acid Solutions to Macroscopic Mixing Thermodynamics: A Quantitative Connection from THz-Calorimetry

We report the results of THz measurements (30-440 cm-1) of aqueous acetic acid solutions over the full mixing range (XAcAc = 0-1). We recorded spectroscopic observables as a function of the acetic acid concentration in the frequency range of the intermolecular stretch at 150 cm-1 and of the librational modes at 350-440 cm-1. This allowed us to unravel changes in hydrophobic and hydrophilic hydration motifs, respectively. By means of a novel THz-calorimetry approach, we quantitatively correlated these changes in local hydration motifs to excess mixing entropy and enthalpy. We find that ΔHmix is determined by both hydrophobic and hydrophilic solvation contributions. In contrast, ΔSmix is governed by hydrophobic cavity formation. Our results further suggest that acetic acid-water mixtures are systems at the edge of phase separation due to endothermic contributions from both hydrophilic and hydrophobic solvation in a large portion of the miscibility range. Our work establishes a quantitative relationship between the balance of local hydrophobic and hydrophilic solvation motifs and the macroscopic mixing thermodynamic properties.

Hydration makes a difference! How to tune protein complexes between liquid-liquid and liquid-solid phase separation

Understanding how protein rich condensates formed upon liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS) evolve into solid aggregates is of fundamental importance for several medical applications, since these are suspected to be hot-spots for many neurotoxic diseases. This requires developing experimental approaches to observe in real-time both LLPS and liquid-solid phase separation (LSPS), and to unravel the delicate balance of protein and water interactions dictating the free energy differences between the two. We present a vibrational THz spectroscopy approach that allows doing so from the point of view of hydration water. We focus on a cellular prion protein of high medical relevance, which we can drive to undergo either LLPS or LSPS with few mutations. We find that it is a subtle balance of hydrophobic and hydrophilic solvation contributions that allows tuning between LLPS and LSPS. Hydrophobic hydration provides an entropic driving force to phase separation, through the release of hydration water into the bulk. Water hydrating hydrophilic groups provides an enthalpic driving force to keep the condensates in a liquid state. As a result, when we modify the protein by a few mutations to be less hydrophilic, we shift from LLPS to LSPS. This molecular understanding paves the way for a rational design of proteins.

Sugar Molecules Inhibit Insulin Aggregation: A Decisive Role Being Played by the Protein Solvation Energetics

Insulin plays vital roles in controlling blood sugar level in the human body. However, it sometimes aggregates during the storage, and its efficacy (on the treatment of diabetes II disease) reduces significantly. So, understanding the insulin aggregation could help in long-term storage. Here we investigate the amyloid growth of human insulin protein in the presence of sugar molecules and observe that glucose and sucrose delay the insulin aggregation, the effect being systematically sugar dependent. We then investigate protein hydration during the aggregation process using terahertz spectroscopy, as the hydration plays a pioneering role in maintaining biological systems. Our study infers that the water network changes systematically with protein conformations and solvation entropy-enthalpy balance plays a decisive role in the aggregation process.

Solvation Plays a Key Role in Antioxidant-Mediated Attenuation of Elevated Creatinine Level: An In Vitro Spectroscopic Investigation

An elevated level of creatinine (CRN) is a mark of kidney ailment, and prolonged retention of such condition could lead to renal failure, associated with severe ischemia. Antioxidants are clinically known to excrete CRN from the body through urine, thereby reducing its level in blood. The molecular mechanism of such an exclusion process is still illusive. As the excretion channel is urine, solvation of the solute is expected to play a pivotal role. Here, we report a detailed time-domain and frequency-domain terahertz (THz) spectroscopic investigation to understand the solvation of CRN in the presence of two model antioxidants, mostly used to treat elevated CRN level: N-Acetyl-l-cysteine (NAC) and ascorbic acid (ASC). FTIR spectroscopy in the mid-infrared region and UV absorption spectroscopy measurements coupled with quantum chemical calculations [at the B3LYP/6-311G++(d,p) level] reveal that both NAC and ASC form HBonded complexes with CRN and rapidly undergo a barrier-less proton transfer process to form creatinium ions. THz measurements provide explicit evidence of the formation of highly solvated complexes compared with bare CRN, which eventually enables its excretion through urine. These observations could provide a foundation for designing more beneficial drugs to resolve kidney diseases..

Terahertz spectroscopy as a method for investigation of hydration shells of biomolecules

The hydration of biomolecules is one of the fundamental processes underlying the construction of living matter. The formation of the native conformation of most biomolecules is possible only in an aqueous environment. At the same time, not only water affects the structure of biomolecules, but also biomolecules affect the structure of water, forming hydration shells. However, the study of the structure of biomolecules is given much more attention than their hydration shells. A real breakthrough in the study of hydration occurred with the development of the THz spectroscopy method, which showed that the hydration shell of biomolecules is not limited to 1-2 layers of strongly bound water, but also includes more distant areas of hydration with altered molecular dynamics. This review examines the fundamental features of the THz frequency range as a source of information about the structural and dynamic characteristics of water that change during hydration. The applied approaches to the study of hydration shells of biomolecules based on THz spectroscopy are described. The data on the hydration of biomolecules of all main types obtained from the beginning of the application of THz spectroscopy to the present are summarized. The emphasis is placed on the possible participation of extended hydration shells in the realization of the biological functions of biomolecules and at the same time on the insufficient knowledge of their structural and dynamic characteristics.

Thermodynamic forces from protein and water govern condensate formation of an intrinsically disordered protein domain

Liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS) can drive a multitude of cellular processes by compartmentalizing biological cells via the formation of dense liquid biomolecular condensates, which can function as membraneless organelles. Despite its importance, the molecular-level understanding of the underlying thermodynamics of this process remains incomplete. In this study, we use atomistic molecular dynamics simulations of the low complexity domain (LCD) of human fused in sarcoma (FUS) protein to investigate the contributions of water and protein molecules to the free energy changes that govern LLPS. Both protein and water components are found to have comparably sizeable thermodynamic contributions to the formation of FUS condensates. Moreover, we quantify the counteracting effects of water molecules that are released into the bulk upon condensate formation and the waters retained within the protein droplets. Among the various factors considered, solvation entropy and protein interaction enthalpy are identified as the most important contributions, while solvation enthalpy and protein entropy changes are smaller. These results provide detailed molecular insights on the intricate thermodynamic interplay between protein- and solvation-related forces underlying the formation of biomolecular condensates.

Dynamics of Hydrogen Bonds between Water and Intrinsically Disordered and Structured Regions of Proteins

Recent studies indicate more restricted dynamics of water around intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) than structured proteins. We examine here the dynamics of hydrogen bonds between water molecules and two proteins, small ubiquitin-related modifier-1 (SUMO-1) and ubiquitin-conjugating enzyme E2I (UBC9), which we compare around intrinsically disordered regions (IDRs) and structured regions of these proteins. It has been recognized since some time that excluded volume effects, which influence access of water molecules to hydrogen-bonding sites, and the strength of hydrogen bonds between water and protein affect hydrogen bond lifetimes. While we find those two properties to mediate lifetimes of hydrogen bonds between water and protein residues in this study, we also find that the lifetimes are affected by the concentration of charged groups on other nearby residues. These factors are more important in determining the hydrogen bond lifetimes than whether a residue hydrogen bonding with water belongs to an IDR or to a structured region.