Interfacial Strength and Surface Damage Characteristics of Atomically Thin h-BN, MoS2, and Graphene

Cyclic Wear Reliability of 2D Monolayers

Understanding wear, a critical factor impacting the reliability of mechanical systems, is vital for nano-, meso-, and macroscale applications. Due to the complex nature of nanoscale wear, the behavior of nanomaterials such as two-dimensional materials under cyclic wear and their surface damage mechanism is yet unexplored. In this study, we used atomic force microscopy coupled with molecular dynamic simulations to statistically examine the cyclic wear behavior of monolayer graphene, MoS2, and WSe2. We show that graphene displays exceptional durability and lasts over 3000 cycles at 85% of the applied critical normal load before failure, while MoS2 and WSe2 last only 500 cycles on average. Moreover, graphene undergoes catastrophic failure as a result of stress concentration induced by local out-of-plane deformation. In contrast, MoS2 and WSe2 exhibit intermittent failure, characterized by damage initiation at the edge of the wear track and subsequent propagation throughout the entire contact area. In addition to direct implications for MEMS and NEMS industries, this work can also enable the optimization of the use of 2D materials as lubricant additives on a macroscopic level.

Graphene Failure under MPa: Nanowear of Step Edges Initiated by Interfacial Mechanochemical Reactions

The low wear resistance of macroscale graphene coatings does not match the ultrahigh mechanical strength and chemical inertness of the graphene layer itself; however, the wear mechanism responsible for this issue at low mechanical stress is still unclear. Here, we demonstrate that the susceptibility of the graphene monolayer to wear at its atomic step edges is governed by the mechanochemistry of frictional interfaces. The mechanochemical reactions activated by chemically active SiO2 microspheres result in atomic attrition rather than mechanical damage such as surface fracture and folding by chemically inert diamond tools. Correspondingly, the threshold contact stress for graphene edge wear decreases more than 30 times to the MPa level, and mechanochemical wear can be described well with the mechanically assisted Arrhenius-type kinetic model, i.e., exponential dependence of the removal rate on the contact stress. These findings provide a strategy for improving the antiwear of graphene-based materials by reducing the mechanochemical interactions at tribological interfaces.

Determination of electric and thermoelectric properties of molecular junctions by AFM in peak force tapping mode

Molecular thin films, such as self-assembled monolayers (SAMs), offer the possibility of translating the optimised thermophysical and electrical properties of high-Seebeck-coefficient single molecules to scalable device architectures. However, for many scanning probe-based approaches attempting to characterise such SAMs, there remains a significant challenge in recovering single-molecule equivalent values from large-area films due to the intrinsic uncertainty of the probe-sample contact area coupled with film damage caused by contact forces. Here we report a new reproducible non-destructive method for probing the electrical and thermoelectric (TE) properties of small assemblies (10-103) of thiol-terminated molecules arranged within a SAM on a gold surface, and demonstrate the successful and reproducible measurements of the equivalent single-molecule electrical conductivity and Seebeck values. We have used a modified thermal-electric force microscopy approach, which integrates the conductive-probe atomic force microscope, a sample positioned on a temperature-controlled heater, and a probe-sample peak-force feedback that interactively limits the normal force across the molecular junctions. The experimental results are interpreted by density functional theory calculations allowing quantification the electrical quantum transport properties of both single molecules and small clusters of molecules. Significantly, this approach effectively eliminates lateral forces between probe and sample, minimising disruption to the SAM while enabling simultaneous mapping of the SAMs nanomechanical properties, as well as electrical and/or TE response, thereby allowing correlation of the film properties.

Layer-Dependent Nanowear of Graphene Oxide

The mechanical performance and surface friction of graphene oxide (GO) were found to inversely depend on the number of layers. Here, we demonstrate the non-monotonic layer-dependence of the nanowear resistance of GO nanosheets deposited on a native silicon oxide substrate. As the thickness of GO increases from ∼0.9 nm to ∼14.5 nm, the nanowear resistance initially demonstrated a decreasing and then an increasing tendency with a critical number of layers of 4 (∼3.6 nm in thickness). This experimental tendency corresponds to a change of the underlying wear mode from the overall removal to progressive layer-by-layer removal. The phenomenon of overall removal disappeared as GO was deposited on an H-DLC substrate with a low surface energy, while the nanowear resistance of thicker GO layers was always higher. Combined with density functional theory calculations, the wear resistance of few-layer GO was found to correlate with the substrate's surface energy. This can be traced back to substrate-dependent adhesive strengths of GO, which correlated with the GO thickness originating from differences in the interfacial charge transfer. Our study proposes a strategy to improve the antiwear properties of 2D layered materials by tuning their own thickness and/or the interfacial interaction with the underlying substrate.

Inverse Relationship between Thickness and Wear of Fluorinated Graphene: "Thinner Is Better"

Atomically thin two-dimensional (2D) materials are excellent candidates for utilization as a solid lubricant or additive at all length scales from macro-scale mechanical devices to micro/nano-electromechanical systems (MEMS/NEMS). In such applications, wear resistance of ultrathin 2D materials is critical for sustained lubrication performance. Here, we investigated the wear of fluorinated graphene (FG) nanosheets deposited on silicon surfaces using atomic force microscopy (AFM) and discovered that the wear resistance of FG improves as the FG thickness decreases from 4.2 to 0.8 nm (corresponding to seven layers to single layer) and the surface energy of the substrate underneath the FG nanosheets increases. On the basis of density function theory (DFT) calculations, the negative correlation of wear resistance to FG thickness and the positive correlation to substrate surface energy could be explained with the degree of interfacial charge transfer between FG and substrate which affects the strength of FG adhesion to the substrate.

High-yield parallel fabrication of quantum-dot monolayer single-electron devices displaying Coulomb staircase, contacted by graphene

It is challenging for conventional top-down lithography to fabricate reproducible devices very close to atomic dimensions, whereas identical molecules and very similar nanoparticles can be made bottom-up in large quantities, and can be self-assembled on surfaces. The challenge is to fabricate electrical contacts to many such small objects at the same time, so that nanocrystals and molecules can be incorporated into conventional integrated circuits. Here, we report a scalable method for contacting a self-assembled monolayer of nanoparticles with a single layer of graphene. This produces single-electron effects, in the form of a Coulomb staircase, with a yield of 87 ± 13% in device areas ranging from < 800 nm² to 16 μm², containing up to 650,000 nanoparticles. Our technique offers scalable assembly of ultra-high densities of functional particles or molecules that could be used in electronic integrated circuits, as memories, switches, sensors or thermoelectric generators.

The integration of nano-molecules into microelectronic circuitry is challenging. Here, the authors provide a scalable method for contacting a self-assembled monolayer of nanoparticles with a single layer of graphene that produces single-electron effects, in the form of a Coulomb staircase, with a yield of at least 70%.

Optimised power harvesting by controlling the pressure applied to molecular junctions

A major potential advantage of creating thermoelectric devices using self-assembled molecular layers is their mechanical flexibility. Previous reports have discussed the advantage of this flexibility from the perspective of facile skin attachment and the ability to avoid mechanical deformation. In this work, we demonstrate that the thermoelectric properties of such molecular devices can be controlled by taking advantage of their mechanical flexibility. The thermoelectric properties of self-assembled monolayers (SAMs) fabricated from thiol terminated molecules were measured with a modified AFM system, and the conformation of the SAMs was controlled by regulating the loading force between the organic thin film and the probe, which changes the tilt angle at the metal-molecule interface. We tracked the thermopower shift vs. the tilt angle of the SAM and showed that changes in both the electrical conductivity and Seebeck coefficient combine to optimize the power factor at a specific angle. This optimization of thermoelectric performance via applied pressure is confirmed through the use of theoretical calculations and is expected to be a general method for optimising the power factor of SAMs.

How Good Are the Performances of Graphene and Boron Nitride Against the Wear of Copper?

We investigate the copper-wear-protective effects of graphene and boron nitride in single asperity sliding contact with a stiff diamond-coated atomic force microscopy (AFM)-tip. We find that both graphene and boron nitride retard the onset of wear of copper. The retardment of wear is larger with boron nitride than with graphene, which we explain based on their respective out-of-plane stiffnesses. The wear protective effect of boron nitride comes, however, at a price. The out-of-plane stiffness of two-dimensional materials also determines their friction coefficient in a wear-less friction regime. In this regime, a higher out-of-plane stiffness results in larger friction forces.

Assessment of Tribological Properties of Ti3C2 as a Water-Based Lubricant Additive

Water-based lubrication has attracted remarkable interest due to its environmental and economic advantages. However, practical applications of water-based lubrication are often limited, mainly because of low viscosity and corrosivity. The use of additives has been proposed to overcome these limitations. In this work, the tribological characteristics of titanium carbide (Ti3C2) MXenes, as additives for water-based lubrication, were systematically investigated for contact sliding between stainless steel under various normal forces and Ti3C2 concentrations. Both friction and wear were found to decrease with increasing Ti3C2 concentration up to 5 wt%, and then increased when the concentration was larger than 5 wt%. The results suggest that Ti3C2 flakes hindered direct contact, particularly at the edges of the contact interfaces. It was further shown that the agglomeration of Ti3C2 flakes may have reduced the hindering when an excessive amount of Ti3C2 (e.g., 7 wt%) was applied. The decreases in the friction coefficient and wear rate with 5 wt% of Ti3C2 concentration w approximately 20% and 48%, respectively. The outcomes of this work may be helpful in gaining a better understanding of the tribological properties of Ti3C2 as a feasible water-based lubrication additive.

In Situ Study of Structure-Activity Relationship between Structure and Tribological Properties of Bulk Layered Materials by Four-Ball Friction Tester

Encouragingly, a lot of research studies have demonstrated that two-dimensional (2D) nanosheets applied as an additive in oils show preferable friction-reducing and wear resistance performance. However, the current issue was that an elusive way could be adopted to probe the structure-activity relationship between the structure and tribological properties of bulk layered materials due to the structural evolution during friction testing. In this study, we studied the structure-activity relationship between the structure and tribological properties of bulk layered materials (graphite, h-BN, WS₂, and MoS₂) by an in situ four-ball friction tester. The morphological and structural changes of the layered materials after in situ four-ball-milling were detected by a series of characterizations. This study revealed the friction-induced nanostructural evolution behaviors of bulk layered materials by a four-ball mode.

Tribological Characteristics of Single-Layer h-BN Measured by Colloidal Probe Atomic Force Microscopy

The tribological characteristics of single-layer (1L) hexagonal-boron nitride (h-BN) were systematically investigated using colloidal probe atomic force microscopy, with an aim to elucidate the feasibility as a protective coating layer and solid lubricant for micro- and nanodevices. The experiments were performed to detect the occurrence of failure of 1L h-BN for up to 10,000 cycles under various normal forces. The failure of 1L h-BN did not occur for 10,000 cycles under a 10 μN normal force, corresponding to a contact pressure of about 0.34 GPa. However, the complete failure of 1L h-BN occurred faster with an increasing normal force from 20 to 42 μN. It was observed that the SiO2/Si substrate was locally exposed due to defect formation on the 1L h-BN. The Raman spectroscopy measurement results further suggest that the failure was associated with the compressive strain on 1L h-BN. The friction of 1L h-BN before failure was orders of magnitude smaller than that of a SiO2/Si substrate. The overall results indicate the feasibility of atomically thin h-BN as a protective coating layer and solid lubricant. In particular, the results of this work provide fundamental tribological characteristics of pristine h-BN as a guide, which may be helpful in other practical deposition methods for atomically thin h-BN with enhanced tribological characteristics.

Optimization of Process Parameters for a Chemi-Absorbed Graphene Coating and Its Nano Tribological Investigation

A reduced graphene oxide coating was deposited on a titanium substrate for potential anti-friction applications in nano- or micro-mechanical systems. A γ-aminopropyltriethoxysilane coating was self-assembled on the substrate as an adhesive interlayer beforehand. The process parameters of self-assembly and hydrothermal reduction of graphene oxide coating were explored via water contact angle and tribological tests. Insufficient self-assembly duration of graphene oxide layer can be detected by water contact angle results, and the corresponding coating displayed a higher coefficient of friction and shorter anti-wear lifetime than the optimized one. Proper hydrothermal temperature and duration were also confirmed by its water contact angle, coefficient of friction and anti-wear lifetime. Noticeably, excessive hydrothermal temperature or duration would reduce the coefficient of friction, but diminish the anti-wear resistance. The optimized process parameters were confirmed as assembly duration of graphene oxide coating for 12 h, hydrothermal reduction duration of 6–8 h at 135 °C. Nano tribological behaviors of the obtained hydrothermal reduced graphene oxide coating by AFM tester were then investigated under various testing circumstances. The results showed that the coating performed reliable and low adhesion and friction forces under all circumstances. The nanowear resistance of the titanium substrate was significantly strengthened by the prepared coating.

Effects of buried grain boundaries in multilayer MoS2

Two-dimensional transition metal dichalcogenides have been the focus of intense research for their potential application in novel electronic and optoelectronic devices. However, growth of large area two-dimensional transition metal dichalcogenides invariably leads to the formation of grain boundaries that can significantly degrade electrical transport by forming large electrostatic barriers. It is therefore critical to understand their effect on the electronic properties of two-dimensional semiconductors. Using MoS₂ as an example material, we are able to probe grain boundaries in top and buried layers using conductive atomic force microscopy. We find that the electrical radius of the grain boundary extends approximately 2 nm from the core into the pristine material. The presence of grain boundaries affects electrical conductivity not just within its own layer, but also in the surrounding layers. Therefore, electrical grain size is always smaller than the physical size, and decreases with increasing thickness of the MoS₂. These results signify that the number of layers in synthetically grown 2D materials must ideally be limited for device applications.

Layer-by-layer thinning of MoS2 via laser irradiation

Layer-by-layer thinning of molybdenum disulfide (MoS₂) via laser irradiation was examined using Raman spectroscopy and atomic force microscopy. In particular, the effects of number of layers, laser conditions, and substrate were systematically identified. The results demonstrated the presence of nanoparticles on the MoS₂ at sufficient laser treatment conditions prior to layer-by-layer thinning. The volume of nanoparticles was found to increase and then decrease as the number of MoS₂ layers increased; the non-monotonic trend was ascribed to changes in the thermal conductivity of the film and interfacial thermal conductance between the film and substrate with number of layers. Moreover, the volume of nanoparticles was found to increase as the magnification of the objective lens decreased and as laser power and exposure time increased, which was attributed to changes in the power density with laser conditions. The effect of substrate on nanoparticle formation and layer-by-layer thinning was investigated through a comparison of freestanding and substrate-supported MoS₂ subjected to laser irradiation; it was illustrated that freestanding films were thinned at lower laser powers than substrate-supported films, which highlighted the function of the substrate as a heat sink. For conditions that elicited thinning, it was shown that the thinned areas exhibited triangular shapes, which suggested anisotropic etching behavior where the lattice of the basal plane was preferentially thinned along the zigzag direction terminated by an Mo- or S-edge. High-resolution transmission electron microscopy of freestanding MoS₂ revealed the presence of a 2 nm thick amorphous region around the laser-treated region, which suggested that the crystalline structure of laser-treated MoS₂ remained largely intact after the thinning process. In all, the conclusions from this work provide useful insight into the progression of laser thinning of MoS₂, thereby enabling more effective methods for the development of MoS₂ devices via laser irradiation.

Operational and environmental conditions regulate the frictional behavior of two-dimensional materials

The friction characteristics of single-layer h-BN, MoS₂, and graphene were systematically investigated via friction force microscopy measurements at various operational (e.g., normal force and sliding speed) and environmental (e.g., relative humidity and thermal annealing) conditions. The low friction characteristics of these single-layer materials were clearly observed from the normal force-dependent friction results, and their interfacial shear strengths were further estimated using a Hertz-plus-offset model. In addition, speed-dependent friction characteristics clearly demonstrated two regimes of friction as a function of sliding speed - the first is the logarithmic increase in friction with sliding speed regime at sliding speeds smaller than the critical speed and the second is the friction plateau regime at sliding speeds greater than the critical speed. Fundamental parameters such as effective shape of the interaction potential and its corrugation amplitude for these single-layer materials were characterized using the thermally-activated Prandtl-Tomlinson model. Moreover, friction of single-layer h-BN, MoS₂, and graphene was found to increase with relative humidity and decrease with thermal annealing; these trends were attributed to the diffusion of water molecules to the interface between the single-layer materials and their substrates, which leads to an increase in the puckering effect at the tip-material interface and interaction potential corrugation. The enhanced puckering effect was verified via molecular dynamics simulations. Overall, the findings enable a comprehensive understanding of friction characteristics for several classes of two-dimensional materials, which is important to elucidate the feasibility of using these materials as protective and solid-lubricant coating layers for nanoscale devices.