Personalized Proteomics for Precision Diagnostics in Hearing Loss: Disease-Specific Analysis of Human Perilymph by Mass Spectrometry

Comparative Proteomic Analysis of Endolymphatic Sac Luminal Fluid in Patients with Meniere's Disease and Controls

Introduction

Meniere's disease (MD) is known to be caused by the dysfunction of the endolymphatic sac (ES), but its molecular mechanism is unknown.

Methods

We performed a comparative proteomic analysis of ES luminal fluids (ELFs) from patients with MD and controls.

Results

We found 6 differentially expressed proteins, including 2 significantly increased proteins and 4 significantly decreased proteins, 8 proteins identified exclusively in at least 7 of the 8 ELF samples from MD patients and 3 proteins detected solely in at least 4 of the 5 ELF samples from controls.

Discussion

The increased levels of IGLV 3-9 and IGLV1-47 in MD group compared with control group suggested an increased inflammatory reactions and a decreased level of Aldehyde dehydrogenase 2 in MD group compared with control group might result in oxidative damage and inflammatory lesions in the ES of MD. Whereas CD44 identified exclusively in MD samples might be involved in the metabolism of its ligand, hyaluronic acid for overproduction of endolymph in the ES of MD.

Alzheimer's Disease-Related Analytes Amyloid-β and Tau in Perilymph: Correlation With Patient Age and Cognitive Score

OBJECTIVE

To describe the collection methods for perilymph fluid biopsy during cochlear implantation, detect levels of amyloid β 42 and 40 (Aβ42 and Aβ40), and total tau (tTau) analytes with a high-precision assay, to compare these levels with patient age and Montreal Cognitive Assessment (MoCA) scores, and explore potential mechanisms and relationships with otic pathology.

STUDY DESIGN

Prospective study.

SETTING

Tertiary referral center.

METHODS

Perilymph was collected from 25 patients using polyimide tubing to avoid amyloid adherence to glass, and analyzed with a single-molecule array advanced digital enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay platform for Aβ40, Aβ42, and tTau. Cognition was assessed by MoCA.

RESULTS

Perilymph volumes ranged from ∼1 to 13 µL, with analyte concentrations spanning 2.67 to 1088.26 pg/mL. All samples had detectable levels of tTau, Aβ40, and Aβ42, with a significant positive correlation between Aβ42 and Aβ40 levels. Levels of Aβ42, Aβ40, and tTau were positively correlated with age, while MoCA scores were inversely correlated with age. tTau and Aβ42/Aβ40-ratios were significantly correlated with MoCA scores.

CONCLUSION

Alzheimer's disease-associated peptides Aβ42, Aβ40, and tau analytes are detectable in human perilymph at levels approximately 10-fold lower than those found in cerebrospinal fluid (CSF). These species increase with age and correlate with cognitive impairment indicators, suggesting their potential utility as biomarkers for cognitive impairment in patients undergoing cochlear implantation. Future research should investigate the origin of these analytes in the perilymph and their potential links to inner ear pathologies and hearing loss, as well as their relationships to CSF and plasma levels in individuals.

IL-1β promotes glutamate excitotoxicity: indications for the link between inflammatory and synaptic vesicle cycle in Ménière's disease

Ménière's disease (MD) is a complex inner ear disorder characterized by a range of symptoms, with its pathogenesis linked to immune-related mechanisms. Our previous research demonstrated that IL-1β maturation and release can trigger cell pyroptosis, exacerbating the severity of the endolymphatic hydrops in a mouse model; however, the specific mechanism through which IL-1β influences MD symptoms remains unclear. This study conducted on patients with MD examined changes in protein signatures in the vestibular end organs (VO) and endolymphatic sac (ES) using mass spectrometry. Gene ontology and protein pathway analyses showed that differentially expressed proteins in the ES are closely related to adhesion, whereas those in the VO are related to synapse processes. Additionally, the study found elevated expression of Glutaminase (GLS) in the VO of MD patients compared to controls. Further investigations revealed that IL-1β increased glutamate levels by upregulating GLS expression in HEI-OC1 cells. Treatment with a GLS inhibitor or an IL-1β receptor antagonist alleviated auditory-vestibular dysfunction and reduced glutamate levels in mice with endolymphatic hydrops. These findings collectively suggest that imbalanced neurotransmitter release and immune responses contribute to the pathology of MD, potentially explaining the hearing loss and vertigo associated with the disease and offering new avenues for therapeutic interventions.

Proposal of a Theoretically Feasible Method to Perform Perilymph Sampling in Clinical Settings

The ability to analyze perilymph could allow inner ear pathologies to be studied. However, today, perilymph sampling is only performed for research purposes because of the risk of negative outcomes such as hearing loss or balance disorders. This paper aims to analyze the current literature on perilymph sampling and propose a method to collect perilymph in clinical settings. The published literature on perilymph sampling and its analyses was screened, and the results were analyzed and discussed in this mini review. Also, articles that discussed microneedle technology were reviewed and included in the analysis of the data. Based on the results of this review, we would like to propose a feasible technique to perform perilymph sampling in clinical settings. A total of eight studies analyzing perilymph were identified; data on proteomic, metabolomic and miRNA features present within human perilymph were collected and described. Two articles describing the use and auditory outcomes post microneedle drug injection into the inner ear were identified. Based on the methods for perilymph sampling described in humans and the recent innovations introduced by the use of microneedles, we suggested a feasible method to collect perilymph in the outpatient setting. The analysis of perilymph undoubtedly represents a valid instrument to fully understand inner ear diseases. A combination of traditional and innovative techniques, such as gaining access to the round window through the transcanalar approach using micro-endoscopes and microneedles to perform sampling, might simplify the sampling procedure and make it practicable in a clinical setting.

Artificial Intelligence in Otology and Neurotology

Clinical applications of artificial intelligence (AI) have grown exponentially with increasing computational power and Big Data. Data rich fields such as Otology and Neurotology are still in the infancy of harnessing the power of AI but are increasingly involved in training and developing ways to incorporate AI into patient care. Current studies involving AI are focused on accessible datasets; health care wearables, tabular data from electronic medical records, electrophysiologic measurements, imaging, and "omics" provide huge amounts of data to utilize. Health care wearables, such as hearing aids and cochlear implants, are a ripe environment for AI implementation.

Exploring Inner Ear and Brain Connectivity through Perilymph Sampling for Early Detection of Neurological Diseases: A Provocative Proposal

Recent evidence shows that it is possible to identify the elements responsible for sensorineural hearing loss, such as pro-inflammatory cytokines and macrophages, by performing perilymph sampling. However, current studies have only focused on the diagnosis of such as otologic conditions. Hearing loss is a feature of certain neuroinflammatory disorders such as multiple sclerosis, and sensorineural hearing loss (SNHL) is widely detected in Alzheimer's disease. Although the environment of the inner ear is highly regulated, there are several communication pathways between the perilymph of the inner ear and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF). Thus, examination of the perilymph may help understand the mechanism behind the hearing loss observed in certain neuroinflammatory and neurodegenerative diseases. Herein, we review the constituents of CSF and perilymph, the anatomy of the inner ear and its connection with the brain. Then, we discuss the relevance of perilymph sampling in neurology. Currently, perilymph sampling is only performed during surgical procedures, but we hypothesize a simplified and low-invasive technique that could allow sampling in a clinical setting with the same ease as performing an intratympanic injection under direct visual check. The use of this modified technique could allow for perilymph sampling in people with hearing loss and neuroinflammatory/neurodegenerative disorders and clarify the relationship between these conditions; in fact, by measuring the concentration of neuroinflammatory and/or neurodegenerative biomarkers and those typically expressed in the inner ear in aging SNHL, it could be possible to understand if SNHL is caused by aging or neuroinflammation.

The Current State of Proteomics and Metabolomics for Inner Ear Health and Disease

Characterising inner ear disorders represents a significant challenge due to a lack of reliable experimental procedures and identified biomarkers. It is also difficult to access the complex microenvironments of the inner ear and investigate specific pathological indicators through conventional techniques. Omics technologies have the potential to play a vital role in revolutionising the diagnosis of ear disorders by providing a comprehensive understanding of biological systems at various molecular levels. These approaches reveal valuable information about biomolecular signatures within the cochlear tissue or fluids such as the perilymphatic and endolymphatic fluid. Proteomics identifies changes in protein abundance, while metabolomics explores metabolic products and pathways, aiding the characterisation and early diagnosis of diseases. Although there are different methods for identifying and quantifying biomolecules, mass spectrometry, as part of proteomics and metabolomics analysis, could be utilised as an effective instrument for understanding different inner ear disorders. This study aims to review the literature on the application of proteomic and metabolomic approaches by specifically focusing on Meniere's disease, ototoxicity, noise-induced hearing loss, and vestibular schwannoma. Determining potential protein and metabolite biomarkers may be helpful for the diagnosis and treatment of inner ear problems.

The comparable tumour microenvironment in sporadic and NF2-related schwannomatosis vestibular schwannoma

Bilateral vestibular schwannoma is the hallmark of NF2-related schwannomatosis, a rare tumour predisposition syndrome associated with a lifetime of surgical interventions, radiotherapy and off-label use of the anti-angiogenic drug bevacizumab. Unilateral vestibular schwannoma develops sporadically in non-NF2-related schwannomatosis patients for which there are no drug treatment options available. Tumour-infiltrating immune cells such as macrophages and T-cells correlate with increased vestibular schwannoma growth, which is suggested to be similar in sporadic and NF2-related schwannomatosis tumours. However, differences between NF2-related schwannomatosis and the more common sporadic disease include NF2-related schwannomatosis patients presenting an increased number of tumours, multiple tumour types and younger age at diagnosis. A comparison of the tumour microenvironment in sporadic and NF2-related schwannomatosis tumours is therefore required to underpin the development of immunotherapeutic targets, identify the possibility of extrapolating ex vivo data from sporadic vestibular schwannoma to NF2-related schwannomatosis and help inform clinical trial design with the feasibility of co-recruiting sporadic and NF2-related schwannomatosis patients. This study drew together bulk transcriptomic data from three published Affymetrix microarray datasets to compare the gene expression profiles of sporadic and NF2-related schwannomatosis vestibular schwannoma and subsequently deconvolved to predict the abundances of distinct tumour immune microenvironment populations. Data were validated using quantitative PCR and Hyperion imaging mass cytometry. Comparative bioinformatic analyses revealed close similarities in NF2-related schwannomatosis and sporadic vestibular schwannoma tumours across the three datasets. Significant inflammatory markers and signalling pathways were closely matched in NF2-related schwannomatosis and sporadic vestibular schwannoma, relating to the proliferation of macrophages, angiogenesis and inflammation. Bulk transcriptomic and imaging mass cytometry data identified macrophages as the most abundant immune population in vestibular schwannoma, comprising one-third of the cell mass in both NF2-related schwannomatosis and sporadic tumours. Importantly, there were no robust significant differences in signalling pathways, gene expression, cell type abundance or imaging mass cytometry staining between NF2-related schwannomatosis and sporadic vestibular schwannoma. These data indicate strong similarities in the tumour immune microenvironment of NF2-related schwannomatosis and sporadic vestibular schwannoma.

In Silico Localization of Perilymph Proteins Enriched in Meńier̀e Disease Using Mammalian Cochlear Single-cell Transcriptomics

Hypothesis

Proteins enriched in the perilymph proteome of Meńier̀e disease (MD) patients may identify affected cell types. Utilizing single-cell transcriptome datasets from the mammalian cochlea, we hypothesize that these enriched perilymph proteins can be localized to specific cochlear cell types.

Background

The limited understanding of human inner ear pathologies and their associated biomolecular variations hinder efforts to develop disease-specific diagnostics and therapeutics. Perilymph sampling and analysis is now enabling further characterization of the cochlear microenvironment. Recently, enriched inner ear protein expression has been demonstrated in patients with MD compared to patients with other inner ear diseases. Localizing expression of these proteins to cochlear cell types can further our knowledge of potential disease pathways and subsequent development of targeted therapeutics.

Methods

We compiled previously published data regarding differential perilymph proteome profiles amongst patients with MD, otosclerosis, enlarged vestibular aqueduct, sudden hearing loss, and hearing loss of undefined etiology (controls). Enriched proteins in MD were cross-referenced against published single-cell/single-nucleus RNA-sequencing datasets to localize gene expression to specific cochlear cell types.

Results

In silico analysis of single-cell transcriptomic datasets demonstrates enrichment of a unique group of perilymph proteins associated with MD in a variety of intracochlear cells, and some exogeneous hematologic and immune effector cells. This suggests that these cell types may play an important role in the pathology associated with late MD, suggesting potential future areas of investigation for MD pathophysiology and treatment.

Conclusions

Perilymph proteins enriched in MD are expressed by specific cochlear cell types based on in silico localization, potentially facilitating development of disease-specific diagnostic markers and therapeutics.

Prevention of Noise-Induced Hearing Loss In Vivo: Continuous Application of Insulin-like Growth Factor 1 and Its Effect on Inner Ear Synapses, Auditory Function and Perilymph Proteins

As noise-induced hearing loss (NIHL) is a leading cause of occupational diseases, there is an urgent need for the development of preventive and therapeutic interventions. To avoid user-compliance-based problems occurring with conventional protection devices, the pharmacological prevention is currently in the focus of hearing research. Noise exposure leads to an increase in reactive oxygen species (ROS) in the cochlea. This way antioxidant agents are a promising option for pharmacological interventions. Previous animal studies reported preventive as well as therapeutic effects of Insulin-like growth factor 1 (IGF-1) in the context of NIHL. Unfortunately, in patients the time point of the noise trauma cannot always be predicted, and additive effects may occur. Therefore, continuous prevention seems to be beneficial. The present study aimed to investigate the preventive potential of continuous administration of low concentrations of IGF-1 to the inner ear in an animal model of NIHL. Guinea pigs were unilaterally implanted with an osmotic minipump. One week after surgery they received noise trauma, inducing a temporary threshold shift. Continuous IGF-1 delivery lasted for seven more days. It did not lead to significantly improved hearing thresholds compared to control animals. Quite the contrary, there is a hint for a higher noise susceptibility. Nevertheless, changes in the perilymph proteome indicate a reduced damage and better repair mechanisms through the IGF-1 treatment. Thus, future studies should investigate delivery methods enabling continuous prevention but reducing the risk of an overdosage.

Proteome profile of patients with excellent and poor speech intelligibility after cochlear implantation: Can perilymph proteins predict performance?

Modern proteomic analysis and reliable surgical access to gain liquid inner ear biopsies have enabled in depth molecular characterization of the cochlea microenvironment. In order to clarify whether the protein composition of the perilymph can provide new insights into individual hearing performance after cochlear implantation (CI), computational analysis in correlation to clinical performance after CI were performed based on the proteome profile derived from perilymph samples (liquid biopsies). Perilymph samples from cochlear implant recipients have been analyzed by mass spectrometry (MS). The proteins were identified using the shot-gun proteomics method and quantified and analyzed using Max Quant, Perseus and IPA software. A total of 75 perilymph samples from 68 (adults and children) patients were included in the analysis. Speech perception data one year after implantation were available for 45 patients and these were used for subsequent analysis. According to their hearing performance, patients with excellent (n = 22) and poor (n = 14) performance one year after CI were identified and used for further analysis. The protein composition and statistically significant differences in the two groups were detected by relative quantification of the perilymph proteins. With this procedure, a selection of 287 proteins were identified in at least eight samples in both groups. In the perilymph of the patients with excellent and poor performance, five and six significantly elevated proteins were identified respectively. These proteins seem to be involved in different immunological processes in excellent and poor performer. Further analysis on the role of specific proteins as predictors for poor or excellent performance among CI recipients are mandatory. Combinatory analysis of molecular inner ear profiles and clinical performance data using bioinformatics analysis may open up new possibilities for patient stratification. The impact of such prediction algorithms on diagnosis and treatment needs to be established in further studies.

Metabolomic Studies in Inner Ear Pathologies

Sensorineural hearing loss is the most common sensory deficit. The etiologies of sensorineural hearing loss have been described and can be congenital or acquired. For congenital non-syndromic hearing loss, mutations that are related to sites of cochlear damage have been discovered (e.g., connexin proteins, mitochondrial genes, etc.). For cytomegalovirus infection or auditory neuropathies, mechanisms are also well known and well researched. Although the etiologies of sensorineural hearing loss may be evident for some patients, the damaged sites and pathological mechanisms remain unclear for patients with progressive post-lingual hearing loss. Metabolomics is an emerging technique in which all metabolites present in a sample at a given time are analyzed, reflecting a physiological state. The objective of this study was to review the literature on the use of metabolomics in hearing loss. The findings of this review suggest that metabolomic studies may help to develop objective tests for diagnosis and personalized treatment.