Molecular water oxidation mechanisms followed by transition metals: state of the art

A ruthenium catalyst linked to a redox-active ruthenium polypyridine for water oxidation

Chromophore-catalyst assemblies are interesting benchmark molecules for photocatalysis. We have prepared two examples of these assemblies and characterized their behaviour as catalysts for the water oxidation reaction. In the bimetallic complexes [Ru(tpy)(4,4'-X2-bpy)(μ-CN)Ru(bda)(DMSO)](PF6) (X = -H (1), -OCH3 (2), tpy = 2,2':6',2''-terpyridine, bpy = 2,2'-bipyridine, H2bda = 2,2'-bipyridine-6,6'-dicarboxylic acid and DMSO = (CH3)2SO), a Ru(II)-polypiridine chromophore {Ru(tpy)(4,4'-X2-bpy)} is linked by a cyanide bridge to a {Ru(bda)} water oxidation catalyst. Both complexes catalyze water oxidation both chemically, using Ce(IV) as the terminal oxidant, and electrochemically. Electrochemical and spectroelectrochemical studies, aided with (TD)DFT calculations, allowed us to study the different species involved in the catalytic cycle. For the RuIIRuIII, an intense MMCT (metal-to-metal charge transfer) band suggests a geometrical reorganization during the oxidation process. The wave associated with oxidation to the RuIIIRuIV species shows an increased current that suggests that it may be a catalyst for the water oxidation reaction. Further oxidation results in the RuIIIRuV redox state which is an active catalyst for the water oxidation reaction as demonstrated by the evolution of oxygen.

Structural modification of nickel tetra(thiocyano)corroles during electrochemical water oxidation

In this study, we present two fully characterized nickel tetrathiocyanocorroles, representing a novel class of 3d-metallocorroles. These nickel(II) ions form square planar complexes, exhibiting a d8-electronic configuration. These anionic complexes are stabilized by the electron-withdrawing SCN groups on the bipyrrole unit of the corrole. The reduced aromaticity in these anionic nickel(II) corrole complexes is evidenced by single crystal X-ray diffraction (XRD) data and a markedly altered absorption profile, with stronger Q bands compared to Soret bands. Notably, the UV-Vis and electrochemical data exhibit significant differences from previously reported nickel(II) corrole radical cation and nickel(II) porphyrin complexes. While these electrochemical data bear a resemblance to those of the anionic nickel(II) corrole by Gross et al., the UV-Vis data show substantial distinctions. Additionally, we explore the utilization of nickel(II)-corrole@CC (where CC denotes carbon cloth) as an electrocatalyst for the oxygen evolution reaction (OER) in an alkaline medium. During electrochemical water oxidation, the molecular catalyst is partially converted to nickel (oxy)hydroxide, Ni(O)OH. The structure reveals the coexistence of the molecular complex and Ni(O)OH in the active catalyst, achieving a turnover frequency (TOF) of 3.32 × 10-2 s-1. The synergy between the homogeneous and heterogeneous phases improves the OER activity, providing more active sites and edge sites and enhancing interfacial charge transfer.

Effect of Anchoring Dynamics on Proton-Coupled Electron Transfer in the Ru(bda) Coordination Oligomer on a Graphitic Surface

The oligomeric ruthenium-based water oxidation catalyst, Ru(bda), is known to be experimentally anchored on graphitic surfaces through CH-π stacking interactions between the auxiliary bda ([2,2'-bipyridine]-6,6'-dicarboxylate) ligand bonded to ruthenium and the hexagonal rings of the surface. This anchoring provides control over their molecular coverage and enables efficient catalysis of water oxidation to dioxygen. The oligomeric nature of the molecule offers multiple anchoring sites at the surface, greatly enhancing the overall stability of the hybrid catalyst-graphitic surface anode through dynamic bonding. However, the impact of this dynamic anchoring on the overall catalytic mechanism is still a topic of debate. In this study, a crucial proton-coupled electron transfer event in the catalytic cycle is investigated using DFT-based molecular dynamics simulations plus metadynamics. The CH-π stacking anchoring plays a critical role not only in stabilizing this hybrid system but also in facilitating the proton-coupled electron transfer event with possible vibronic couplings between the anchoring bonds motion and charge fluctuations at the catalyst - graphitic surface interface. Furthermore, this computational investigation displays the presence of a quartet spin state intermediate that can lead to the experimentally observed and thermodynamically more stable doublet spin state.

Tetranuclear CoII4O4 Cubane Complex: Effective Catalyst Toward Electrochemical Water Oxidation

The reaction of Co(OAc)2·6H2O with 2,2'-[{(1E,1'E)-pyridine-2,6-diyl-bis(methaneylylidene)bis(azaneylylidene)}diphenol](LH2) a multisite coordination ligand and Et3N in a 1:2:3 stoichiometric ratio forms a tetranuclear complex Co4(L)2(μ-η1:η1-OAc)2(η2-OAc)2]· 1.5 CH3OH· 1.5 CHCl3 (1). Based on X-ray diffraction investigations, complex 1 comprises a distorted Co4O4 cubane core consisting of two completely deprotonated ligands [L]2- and four acetate ligands. Two distinct types of CoII centers exist in the complex, where the Co(2) center has a distorted octahedral geometry; alternatively, Co(1) has a distorted pentagonal-bipyramidal geometry. Analysis of magnetic data in 1 shows predominant antiferromagnetic coupling (J = -2.1 cm-1), while the magnetic anisotropy is the easy-plane type (D1 = 8.8, D2 = 0.76 cm-1). Furthermore, complex 1 demonstrates an electrochemical oxygen evolution reaction (OER) with an overpotential of 325 mV and Tafel slope of 85 mV dec-1, required to attain a current density of 10 mA cm-2 and moderate stability under alkaline conditions (pH = 14). Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy studies reveal that compound 1 has a charge transfer resistance (Rct) of 2.927 Ω, which is comparatively lower than standard Co3O4 (5.242 Ω), indicating rapid charge transfer kinetics between electrode and electrolyte solution that enhances higher catalytic activity toward OER kinetics.

One-step electrodeposition of V-doped NiFe nanosheets for low-overpotential alkaline oxygen evolution

As a non-noble metal electrocatalyst for the oxygen evolution reaction (OER), the binary NiFe layer double hydroxide (LDH) is expected to replace Ru-based and Ir-based anode materials for water decomposition. To attain threshold current density, nevertheless, a somewhat significant overpotential is still needed. In this work, layered double hydroxides of NiFe LDH are doped with V to form the terpolymer NiFeV LDH, which greatly increases the intrinsic activity of NiFe LDH and improves OER performance. This process is a straightforward and quick one-step electrodeposition process. Notably, NiFeV/NF has a low overpotential (218 mV at 10 mA cm-2) and faster kinetics (Tafel slope of 31 mV dec-1) as well as excellent durability and stability in 1 M KOH solution. In addition, the OER performance of the catalyst prepared in this work is better than that of a non-valuable metal catalyst that was recently reported. The V-doped NiFe LDH layered double hydroxides and the investigation of electrodeposition electrocatalytic methods in this work offer a fresh opportunity for the advancement of electrochemical technology.

Manipulating Intermetallic Charge Transfer for Switchable External Stimulus-Enhanced Water Oxidation Electrocatalysis

Electrocatalytic processes involving the oxygen evolution reaction (OER) present a kinetic bottleneck due to the existence of linear-scaling relationships, which bind the energies of the different intermediates in the mechanism limiting optimization. Here, we offer a way to break these scaling relationships and enhance the electrocatalytic activity of a Co-Fe Prussian blue modified electrode in OER by applying external stimuli. Improvements of ≈11 % and ≈57 % were achieved under magnetic field (0.2 T) and light irradiation (100 mW cm-2 ), respectively, when working at fixed overpotential, η=0.6 V at pH 7. The observed enhancements strongly tie in with the intermetallic charge transfer (IMCT) intensity between Fe and Co sites. Density Functional Theory simulations suggest that tuning the IMCT can lead to a change of the OER mechanism to an external stimuli-sensitive spin crossover-based pathway, which opens the way for switchable electrocatalytic devices.

Copper Complex Catalyzed Two-Electron and Proton Shuttle Mechanism of O-O Bond Formation from DFT-Based Metadynamics Simulations

We performed first-principles metadynamics simulations to explore the mechanistic pathway of oxygen-oxygen bond formation catalyzed by cis-bis(hydroxo) and cis-(hydroxo)oxo copper complexes. The ligands of considered complexes involve modified bipyridine ligands with oxo and hydroxo groups on 6, 6' positions. The study focuses on the kinetics and thermodynamics of the oxygen-oxygen bond formation. The individual migration of the proton to the hydroxyl group and hydroxide to the oxo and hydroxo moieties of the complexes was examined. The proton transfer requires more kinetic barrier than the hydroxide migration. The nature of the electronic density was analyzed with the help of spin population analysis. The molecular orbitals and natural orbital analysis were carried out to examine the nature of the orbitals involved in the oxygen-oxygen bond formation. The σ*(d_x²_-y²-p_x) molecular orbital of the Cu-O or Cu-OH bond overlaps with the p_z orbital of the hydroxide ion in forming the oxygen-oxygen bond. The two-electron two-centered (2e^--2C) bond is observed in the oxygen-oxygen bond formation. In the oxidation process, these ligands stabilize the electron density from the water or hydroxide ion. These redox-active ligands also help stabilize the formed hydrogen peroxide or peroxide complexes.

Unusual Water Oxidation Mechanism via a Redox-Active Copper Polypyridyl Complex

To improve Cu-based water oxidation (WO) catalysts, a proper mechanistic understanding of these systems is required. In contrast to other metals, high-oxidation-state metal-oxo species are unlikely intermediates in Cu-catalyzed WO because π donation from the oxo ligand to the Cu center is difficult due to the high number of d electrons of CuII and CuIII. As a consequence, an alternative WO mechanism must take place instead of the typical water nucleophilic attack and the inter- or intramolecular radical-oxo coupling pathways, which were previously proposed for Ru-based catalysts. [CuII(HL)(OTf)2] [HL = Hbbpya = N,N-bis(2,2'-bipyrid-6-yl)amine)] was investigated as a WO catalyst bearing the redox-active HL ligand. The Cu catalyst was found to be active as a WO catalyst at pH 11.5, at which the deprotonated complex [CuII(L-)(H2O)]+ is the predominant species in solution. The overall WO mechanism was found to be initiated by two proton-coupled electron-transfer steps. Kinetically, a first-order dependence in the catalyst, a zeroth-order dependence in the phosphate buffer, a kinetic isotope effect of 1.0, a ΔH⧧ value of 4.49 kcal·mol-1, a ΔS⧧ value of -42.6 cal·mol-1·K-1, and a ΔG⧧ value of 17.2 kcal·mol-1 were found. A computational study supported the formation of a Cu-oxyl intermediate, [CuII(L•)(O•)(H2O)]+. From this intermediate onward, formation of the O-O bond proceeds via a single-electron transfer from an approaching hydroxide ion to the ligand. Throughout the mechanism, the CuII center is proposed to be redox-inactive.

Three-Electron Two-Centered Bond and Single-Electron Transfer Mechanism of Water Splitting via a Copper-Bipyridine Complex

We report the atomistic and electronic details of the mechanistic pathway of the oxygen-oxygen bond formation catalyzed by a copper-2,2'-bipyridine complex. Density functional theory-based molecular dynamics simulations and enhanced sampling methods were employed for this study. The thermodynamics and electronic structure of the oxygen-oxygen bond formation are presented in this study by considering the cis-bishydroxo, [Cu^III(bpy)(OH)₂]⁺, and cis-(hydroxo)oxo, [Cu^IV(bpy)(OH)(═O)]⁺, complexes as active catalysts. In the cis-bishydroxo complex, the hydroxide transfer requires a higher kinetic barrier than the proton transfer process. In the case of [Cu^IV(bpy)(OH)(═O)]⁺, the proton transfer requires a higher free energy than the hydroxide one. The peroxide bond formation is thermodynamically favorable for the [Cu^IV(bpy)(OH)(═O)]⁺ complex compared with the other. The hydroxide ion is transferred to one of the Cu-OH moieties, and the proton is transferred to the solvent. The free energy barrier for this migration is higher than that for the former transfer. From the analysis of molecular orbitals, it is found that the electron density is primarily present on the water molecules near the active sites in the highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO) state and lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) of the ligands. Natural bond orbital (NBO) analysis reveals the electron transfer process during the oxygen-oxygen bond formation. The σ*Cu(d_xz)-O(p) orbitals are involved in the oxygen-oxygen bond formation. During the bond formation, three-electron two-centered (3e^--2C) bonds are observed in [Cu^III(bpy)(OH)₂]⁺ during the transfer of the hydroxide before the formation of the oxygen-oxygen bond.

Borate Buffer as a Key Player in Cu-Based Homogeneous Electrocatalytic Water Oxidation

Borate buffer was found to have both structural and functional roles within a low-cost tri-copper electrocatalyst for homogeneous water oxidation that exhibits a high turnover frequency of 310 s-1 . The borate buffer was shown to facilitate the catalytic activity by both bridging the three Cu ions and participating in O-O bond formation. Phosphate and acetate buffers did not show such roles, making borate a unique player in this catalytic system.

Non-heme oxoiron complexes as active intermediates in the water oxidation process with hydrogen/oxygen atom transfer reactions

In this study, we explore the water oxidation process with the help of density functional theory. The formation of an oxygen-oxygen bond is crucial in the water oxidation process. Here, we report the formation of the oxygen-oxygen bond by the N5-coordinate oxoiron species with a higher oxidation state of Fe^IV and Fe^V. This bond formation is studied through the nucleophilic addition of water molecules and the transfer of the oxygen atom from meta-chloroperbenzoic acid (mCPBA). Our study reveals that the oxygen-oxygen bond formation by reacting mCPBA with Fe^VO requires less activation barrier (13.7 kcal mol^-1) than the other three pathways. This bond formation by the oxygen atom transfer (OAT) pathway is more favorable than that achieved by the hydrogen atom transfer (HAT) pathway. In both cases, the oxygen-oxygen bond formation occurs by interacting the σ*d_z²-2p_z molecular orbital of the iron-oxo intermediate with the 2p_x orbital of the oxygen atom. From this study, we understand that the oxygen-oxygen bond formation by Fe^IVO with the OAT process is also feasible (16 kcal mol^-1), suggesting that Fe^VO may not always be required for the water oxidation process by non-heme N5-oxoiron. After the oxygen-oxygen bond formation, the release of the dioxygen molecule occurs with the addition of the water molecule. The release of dioxygen requires a barrier of 7.0 kcal mol^-1. The oxygen-oxygen bond formation is found to be the rate-determining step.

Mechanistic Insights into Cobalt-Based Water Oxidation Catalysis by DFT-Based Molecular Dynamics Simulations

We report the mechanistic details of the water oxidation process by the complex, [Co^II(bpbH₂)Cl₂], where bpbH₂ = N, N'-bis(2'-pyridinecarboxamide)-1,2-benzene. An experimental study reported the complex as the efficient catalyst for the water oxidation process. We performed density functional theory calculations at the M06-L level and first-principles molecular dynamics simulations to study the catalytic nature of the complex. We investigated the energetics of the total catalytic cycle, which combines the oxygen-oxygen bond formation, proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) steps, and release of oxygen molecule. The formed peroxide and superoxide intermediates in the catalytic cycle were characterized with the help of the Mulliken spin density parameters. Mulliken spin densities of the metal-oxo bond reveal that the triplet state of Co^V═O has a double-bond nature, but the quintet state of the complex has a radical nature (Co^IV-O^•-). In an alternative way, the deprotonation of the amide groups of the ligand is also considered. The deprotonation and formation of higher oxidation metal-oxo intermediates are also possible. In addition to this, we have considered the effect of phosphate buffer on water nucleophilic addition. The oxygen-oxygen bond formation is favorable by the catalyst with the deprotonated form of the ligand, with the addition of water as the nucleophile. In the oxidation process, the C═O bonds of the ligand transfer the electron density to nitrogen atoms, stabilizing the higher order oxo, peroxide, and superoxide bonds. The oxygen-oxygen bond formation is the rate-determining step in the overall water oxidation process. This bond was further investigated using first-principles molecular dynamics at the PBE-D2 level. The dynamics of proton, hydroxide ion, and the nature of the ligand structure on the oxygen-oxygen bond were examined. We find that the oxygen molecule is released from the superoxide complex with the addition of water molecules.

Molecular Mechanism of the Mononuclear Copper Complex-Catalyzed Water Oxidation from Cluster-Continuum Model Calculations

Cluster-continuum model calculations were conducted to decipher the mechanism of water oxidation catalyzed by a mononuclear copper complex. Among various O-O bond formation mechanisms investigated in this study, the most favorable pathway involved the nucleophilic attack of OH^- onto the ^.+ L-Cu^II -OH^- intermediate. During such process, the initial binding of OH^- to the proximity of ^.+ L-Cu^II -OH^- would result in the spontaneous oxidation of OH^- , leading to OH⋅ radical and Cu^II -OH^- species. The further O-O coupling between OH⋅ radical and Cu^II -OH^- was associated with a barrier of 14.8 kcal mol^-1 , leading to the formation of H₂ O₂ intermediate. Notably, the formation of "Cu^III -O^.- " species, a widely proposed active species for O-O bond formation, was found to be thermodynamically unfavorable and could be bypassed during the catalytic reactions. On the basis the present calculations, a catalytic cycle of the mononuclear copper complex-catalyzed water oxidation was proposed.

Homogeneous Water Oxidation Catalyzed by First-Row Transition Metal Complexes: Unveiling the Relationship between Turnover Frequency and Reaction Overpotential

The utilization of earth-abundant low-toxicity metal ions in the construction of highly active and efficient molecular catalysts promoting the water oxidation reaction is important for developing a sustainable artificial energy cycle. However, the kinetic and thermodynamic properties of the currently available molecular water oxidation catalysts (MWOCs) have not been comprehensively investigated. This Review summarizes the current status of MWOCs based on first-row transition metals in terms of their turnover frequency (TOF, a kinetic property) and overpotential (η, a thermodynamic property) and uses the relationship between log(TOF) and η to assess catalytic performance. Furthermore, the effects of the same ligand classes on these MWOCs are discussed in terms of TOF and η, and vice versa. The collective analysis of these relationships provides a metric for the direct comparison of catalyst systems and identifying factors crucial for catalyst design.

Catalytic Mechanism of Competing Proton Transfer Events from Water and Acetic Acid by [CoII(bpbH2)Cl2] for Water Splitting Processes

We performed first principles simulations to explore the water reduction process of the cobalt complex [Co^II(bpbH₂)Cl₂], where bpbH₂ = N,N'-bis(2'-pyridine carboxamide)-1,2-benzene. We considered the sequence steps of electron reduction followed by the proton addition process to observe the hydrogen evolution process. An experimental study of the catalyst showed that the increase in the acetic acid concentration triggers catalytic current and reduction of Co(II) to Co(I), and protonation occurred, yielding a Co(III)-H intermediate. Therefore, we used water and acetic acid as the proton sources. We compare the proton transfer kinetics from both the water and acetic acid. The reduction potentials and proton transfer kinetics from water or acetic acid to the reaction center were studied in a DMF solvent through the implicit solvent model. The first proton transfer from the acetic acid is more favorable, forming a Co^III-H complex and further reducing to Co^II-H. The second proton transfer from water to the Co^II-H moiety requires less free energy than acetic acid and is the rate-limiting step. The nature of the reduction process is also examined through the charge analysis, which reveals that the ligand becomes softer due to the C═O groups.

Dangling Carboxylic Group That Participates in O-O Bond Formation Reaction to Promote Water Oxidation Catalyzed by a Ruthenium Complex: Experimental Evidence of an Oxide Relay Pathway

Two mononuclear ruthenium(II) complexes of the types [Ru(trpy)(HL¹)(OH₂)]²⁺ (1^Aq) and [Ru(trpy)(L²-κ-N²O)] (2) [where trpy = 2,2':6',2″-terpyridine, HL¹ = 2-(2-pyridyl)benzimidazole, H₂L² = 2-(pyridin-2-yl)-1H-benzo[d]imidazole-4-carboxylic acid] have been synthesized and thoroughly characterized by analytical and spectroscopic [UV-vis, NMR, high-resolution mass spectrometry, and IR] techniques. Complex 1^Aq has been further characterized by X-ray crystallography. In an acidic aqueous medium (pH 1), complex 2 undergoes carboxylate/water exchange readily to form an aqua-ligated complex, [Ru(trpy)(H₂L²-κ-N²)(OH₂)]²⁺ (2^Aq), having a dangling carboxylic group. This exchange phenomenon has been followed by IR, ¹H NMR, and UV-vis spectroscopic techniques. Electrochemical analyses of 1^Aq and 2^Aq (Pourbaix diagram) suggest the generation of a formal Ru^V═O species that can potentially promote the oxidation of water. A comparative study of the water oxidation activity catalyzed by 1^Aq and 2^Aq is reported here to see the effect of a dangling carboxylic group in the catalytic performance. Complex 2^Aq shows an enormously higher rate of reaction than 1^Aq. The pendant carboxylic group in 2^Aq participates in an intramolecular O-O bond formation reaction with the reactive formal Ru^V═O unit to form a percarboxylate intermediate and provides an electron-deficient carbon center where water nucleophilic attack takes place. The isotope labeling experiment using ¹⁸O-labeled water verifies the attack of water at the carbon center of the carboxylic group rather than a direct attack at the oxo of the formal Ru^V═O unit. The present work provides experimental evidence of the uncommon functionality of the carboxylic group, the oxide relay, in molecular water oxidation chemistry.

Soft x-ray signatures of ionic manganese-oxo systems, including a high-spin manganese(V) complex

Manganese-oxo species catalyze key reactions, including C–H bond activation or dioxygen formation in natural photosynthesis. To better understand relevant reaction intermediates, we characterize electronic states and geometric structures of [MnOn]+...

New ruthenium polypyridyl complexes as potential sensors of acetonitrile and catalysts for water oxidation

New ruthenium(ii) polypyridyl complexes of formulae [RuCl(Me₂Ntrpy)(bpy-OMe)]Cl, 1, and [Ru(Me₂Ntrpy)(bpy-OMe)(OH₂)](CF₃SO₃)₂, 2, with Me₂Ntrpy = 4′-N,N-dimethylamino-2,2′:6′,2′′-terpyridine and bpy-OMe = 4,4′-dimethoxy-2,2′-bipyridine, were synthetized and characterized by spectroscopic and electrochemical techniques. Besides, [Ru(Me₂Ntrpy)(bpy-OMe)(NCCH₃)]²⁺, 3, was obtained and characterized by UV-vis spectroscopy in acetonitrile solution. All experimental results were complemented with DFT and TD-DFT calculations. The complete structure of complex 1 was determined by X-ray diffraction, evidencing that the Ru–N and Ru–Cl bond lengths are longer than those determined in [RuCl(trpy)(bpy)](PF₆). The strong electron donating properties of the substituents of both bpy and trpy rings in complexes 1 and 2 led to their potential applications for detecting traces of acetonitrile as a contaminant in aqueous solutions of radiopharmaceuticals and to utilization of complex 2 as a promising candidate for catalyzing water oxidation processes.

New mononuclear polypyridyl Ru(ii) complexes were synthesized and fully characterized. These species can be potentially applied for detection of CH₃CN as a contaminant in radiopharmaceuticals used in PET studies or for catalysing water oxidation.

Recent Advances and Perspectives in Photodriven Charge Accumulation in Molecular Compounds: A Mini Review

The formation of so-called solar fuels from abundant low-energetic compounds, such as carbon dioxide or water, relies on the chemical elementary steps of photoinduced electron transfer and accumulation of multiple redox equivalents. The majority of molecular systems explored to date require sacrificial electron donors to accumulate multiple electrons on a single acceptor unit, but the use of high-energetic sacrificial redox reagents is unsustainable. In recent years, an increasing number of molecular compounds for reversible light-driven accumulation of redox equivalents that do not need sacrificial electron donors has been reported. Those compounds are the focus of this mini review. Different concepts, such as redox potential compression (achieved by proton-coupled electron transfer, Lewis acid-base interactions, or structural rearrangements), hybrids with inorganic nanoparticles, and diffusion-controlled multi-component systems, will be discussed. Newly developed strategies to outcompete unproductive reaction pathways in favor of desired photoproduct formation will be compared, and the importance of identifying reaction intermediates in the course of multiphotonic excitation by different time-resolved spectroscopic techniques will be discussed. The mechanistic insights gained from molecular donor-photosensitizer-acceptor compounds inform the design of next-generation charge accumulation systems for solar energy conversion.

Beyond Continuum Solvent Models in Computational Homogeneous Catalysis

In homogeneous catalysis solvent is an inherent part of the catalytic system. As such, it must be considered in the computational modeling. The most common approach to include solvent effects in quantum mechanical calculations is by means of continuum solvent models. When they are properly used, average solvent effects are efficiently captured, mainly those related with solvent polarity. However, neglecting atomistic description of solvent molecules has its limitations, and continuum solvent models all alone cannot be applied to whatever situation. In many cases, inclusion of explicit solvent molecules in the quantum mechanical description of the system is mandatory. The purpose of this article is to highlight through selected examples what are the reasons that urge to go beyond the continuum models to the employment of micro-solvated (cluster-continuum) of fully explicit solvent models, in this way setting the limits of continuum solvent models in computational homogeneous catalysis. These examples showcase that inclusion of solvent molecules in the calculation not only can improve the description of already known mechanisms but can yield new mechanistic views of a reaction. With the aim of systematizing the use of explicit solvent models, after discussing the success and limitations of continuum solvent models, issues related with solvent coordination and solvent dynamics, solvent effects in reactions involving small, charged species, as well as reactions in protic solvents and the role of solvent as reagent itself are successively considered.

Identifying Intermediates in Electrocatalytic Water Oxidation with a Manganese Corrole Complex

Water nucleophilic attack (WNA) on high-valent terminal Mn-oxo species is proposed for O-O bond formation in natural and artificial water oxidation. Herein, we report an electrocatalytic water oxidation reaction with Mn^III tris(pentafluorophenyl)corrole (1) in propylene carbonate (PC). O₂ was generated at the Mn^V/IV potential with hydroxide, but a more anodic potential was required to evolve O₂ with only water. With a synthetic Mn^V(O) complex of 1, a second-order rate constant, k₂(OH^-), of 7.4 × 10³ M^-1 s^-1 was determined in the reaction of the Mn^V(O) complex of 1 with hydroxide, whereas its reaction with water occurred much more slowly with a k₂(H₂O) value of 4.4 × 10^-3 M^-1 s^-1. This large reactivity difference of Mn^V(O) with hydroxide and water is consistent with different electrocatalytic behaviors of 1 with these two substrates. Significantly, during the electrolysis of 1 with water, a Mn^IV-peroxo species was identified with various spectroscopic methods, including UV-vis, electron paramagnetic resonance, and infrared spectroscopy. Isotope-labeling experiments confirmed that both O atoms of this peroxo species are derived from water, suggesting the involvement of the WNA mechanism in water oxidation by a Mn complex. Density functional theory calculations suggested that the nucleophilic attack of hydroxide on Mn^V(O) and also WNA to 1e^--oxidized Mn^V(O) are feasibly involved in the catalytic cycles but that direct WNA to Mn^V(O) is not likely to be the main O-O bond formation pathway in the electrocatalytic water oxidation by 1.

C-H Activation by RuCo3O4 Oxo Cubanes: Effects of Oxyl Radical Character and Metal-Metal Cooperativity

High-valent multimetallic-oxo/oxyl species have been implicated as intermediates in oxidative catalysis involving proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) reactions, but the reactive nature of these oxo species has hindered the development of an in-depth understanding of their mechanisms and multimetallic character. The mechanism of C-H oxidation by previously reported RuCo₃O₄ cubane complexes bearing a terminal Ru^V-oxo ligand, with significant oxyl radical character, was investigated. The rate-determining step involves H atom abstraction (HAA) from an organic substrate to generate a Ru-OH species and a carbon-centered radical. Radical intermediates are subsequently trapped by another equivalent of the terminal oxo to afford isolable radical-trapped cubane complexes. Density functional theory (DFT) reveals a barrierless radical combination step that is more favorable than an oxygen-rebound mechanism by 12.3 kcal mol^-1. This HAA reactivity to generate organic products is influenced by steric congestion and the C-H bond dissociation energy of the substrate. Tuning the electronic properties of the cubane (i.e., spin density localized on terminal oxo, basicity, and redox potential) by varying the donor ability of ligands at the Co sites modulates C-H activations by the Ru^V-oxo fragment and enables construction of structure-activity relationships. These results reveal a mechanistic pathway for C-H activation by high-valent metal-oxo species with oxyl radical character and provide insights into cooperative effects of multimetallic centers in tuning PCET reactivity.

Surface-Promoted Evolution of Ru-bda Coordination Oligomers Boosts the Efficiency of Water Oxidation Molecular Anodes

A new Ru oligomer of formula {[Ru^II(bda-κ-N²O²)(4,4'-bpy)]₁₀(4,4'-bpy)}, 10 (bda is [2,2'-bipyridine]-6,6'-dicarboxylate and 4,4'-bpy is 4,4'-bipyridine), was synthesized and thoroughly characterized with spectroscopic, X-ray, and electrochemical techniques. This oligomer exhibits strong affinity for graphitic materials through CH-π interactions and thus easily anchors on multiwalled carbon nanotubes (CNT), generating the molecular hybrid material 10@CNT. The latter acts as a water oxidation catalyst and converts to a new species, 10'(H₂O)₂@CNT, during the electrochemical oxygen evolution process involving solvation and ligand reorganization facilitated by the interactions of molecular Ru catalyst and the surface. This heterogeneous system has been shown to be a powerful and robust molecular hybrid anode for electrocatalytic water oxidation into molecular oxygen, achieving current densities in the range of 200 mA/cm² at pH 7 under an applied potential of 1.45 V vs NHE. The remarkable long-term stability of this hybrid material during turnover is rationalized based on the supramolecular interaction of the catalyst with the graphitic surface.

Mechanistic Insight into the O2 Evolution Catalyzed by Copper Complexes with Tetra- and Pentadentate Ligands

The mononuclear complexes ([(bztpen)Cu] (BF₄)₂ (bztpen = N-benzyl-N,N',N'-tris (pyridin-2-yl methyl ethylenediamine))) and ([(dbzbpen)Cu(OH₂)] (BF₄)₂ (dbzbpen = N,N'-dibenzyl-N,N'-bis(pyridin-2-ylmethyl) ethylenediamine)) have been reported as water oxidation catalysts in basic medium (pH = 11.5). We explore the O₂ evolution process catalyzed by these copper catalysts with various ligands (L) by applying the first-principles molecular dynamics simulations. First, the oxidation of catalysts to the metal-oxo intermediates [LCu(O)]²⁺ occurs through the proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) process. These intermediates are involved in the oxygen-oxygen bond formation through the water-nucleophilic addition process. Here, we have considered two types of oxygen-oxygen bond formation. The first one is the transfer of the hydroxide of the water molecule to the Cu═O moiety; the proton transfer to the solvent leads to the formation of the peroxide complex ([LCu(OOH)]⁺). The other is the formation of the hydrogen peroxide complex ([LCu(HOOH)]²⁺) by the transfer of proton and hydroxide of the water molecule to the metal-oxo intermediate. The formation of the peroxide complex requires less activation free energy than hydrogen peroxide formation for both catalysts. We found two transition states in the well-tempered metadynamics simulations: one for proton transfer and another for hydroxide transfer. In both cases, the proton transfer requires higher free energy. Following the formation of the oxygen-oxygen bond, we study the release of the dioxygen molecule. The formed peroxide and hydrogen peroxide complexes are converted into the superoxide complex ([LCu(OO)]²⁺) through the transfer of proton, electron, and PCET processes. The superoxide complex releases an oxygen molecule upon the addition of a water molecule. The free energy of activation for the release of the dioxygen molecule is lesser than that of the oxygen-oxygen bond formation. When we observe the entire water oxidation process, the oxygen-oxygen bond formation is the rate-determining step. We calculated the rates of reaction by using the Eyring equation and found them to be close to the experimental values.

Consecutive Ligand-Based Electron Transfer in New Molecular Copper-Based Water Oxidation Catalysts

Water oxidation to dioxygen is one of the key reactions that need to be mastered for the design of practical devices based on water splitting with sunlight. In this context, water oxidation catalysts based on first‐row transition metal complexes are highly desirable due to their low cost and their synthetic versatility and tunability through rational ligand design. A new family of dianionic bpy‐amidate ligands of general formula H₂LNⁿ⁻ (LN is [2,2′‐bipyridine]‐6,6′‐dicarboxamide) substituted with phenyl or naphthyl redox non‐innocent moieties is described. A detailed electrochemical analysis of [(L4)Cu]²⁻ (L4=4,4′‐(([2,2′‐bipyridine]‐6,6′‐dicarbonyl)bis(azanediyl))dibenzenesulfonate) at pH 11.6 shows the presence of a large electrocatalytic wave for water oxidation catalysis at an η=830 mV. Combined experimental and computational evidence, support an all ligand‐based process with redox events taking place at the aryl‐amide groups and at the hydroxido ligands.

Electrocatalytic Isoxazoline-Nanocarbon Metal Complexes

We report the synthesis of new carbon-nanomaterial-based metal chelates that enable effective electronic coupling to electrocatalytic transition metals. In particular, multiwalled carbon nanotubes (MWCNTs) and few-layered graphene (FLG) were covalently functionalized by a microwave-assisted cycloaddition with nitrile oxides to form metal-binding isoxazoline functional groups with high densities. The covalent attachment was evidenced by Raman spectroscopy, and the chemical identity of the surface functional groups was confirmed by X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) and time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry (ToF-SIMS). The functional carbon nanomaterials effectively chelate precious metals Ir(III), Pt(II), and Ru(III), as well as earth-abundant metals such as Ni(II), to afford materials with metal contents as high as 3.0 atom %. The molecularly dispersed nature of the catalysts was confirmed by X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS) and energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (STEM-EDS) elemental mapping. The interplay between the chelate structure on the graphene surface and its metal binding ability has also been investigated by a combination of experimental and computational studies. The defined ligands on the graphene surfaces enable the formation of structurally precise heterogeneous molecular catalysts. The direct attachment of the isoxazoline functional group on the graphene surfaces provides strong electronic coupling between the chelated metal species and the conductive carbon nanomaterial support. We demonstrate that the metal-chelated carbon nanomaterials are effective heterogeneous catalysts in the oxygen evolution reaction with low overpotentials and tunable catalytic activity.

On the Oxygen Reduction Reaction Mechanism Catalyzed by Pd Complexes on 2D Carbon. A Theoretical Study

Oxygen Reduction Reaction (ORR) is the bottle-neck strategic reaction ruling the fuel cell efficiency process. The slow kinetics of the reaction require highly effective electrocatalysts for proper boosting. In this field, composite catalysts formed by carbon nanotubes functionalized with palladium(II) complexes showed surprising catalytic activity comparable to those of a commercial Pt electrode, but the catalytic mechanisms of these materials still remain open to discussion. In this paper, we propose the combination of experimental and theoretical results to unfold the elementary reaction steps underlying the ORR catalysis.

Synthesis, Characterization, and Water Oxidation Activity of Isomeric Ru Complexes

The synthesis and characterization of the isomeric ruthenium complexes with the general formula cis- and trans-[Ru(trpy)(qc)X]ⁿ⁺ (trpy is 2,2':6',2″-terpyridine, qc is 8-quinolinecarboxylate, cis-1 and trans-1, X = Cl, n = 0; cis-2 and trans-2, X=OH₂, n = 1) with respect to the relative disposition of the carboxylate and X ligands are reported. For comparison purposes, another set of ruthenium complexes with general formula cis- and trans-[Ru(trpy)(pic)(OH₂)]⁺ (pic is 2-picolinate (cis-3, trans-3)) have been prepared. The complexes with a qc ligand show a more distorted geometry compared to the complexes with a pic ligand. In all of the cases, the trans isomers show lower potential values for all of the redox couples relative to the cis isomers. Complexes cis-2 and trans-2 with six-member chelate rings show higher catalytic activity than cis-3 and trans-3. Overall, it was shown that the electronic perturbation to the metal center exerted by different orientation and geometry of the ligands significantly influences both redox properties and catalytic performance.

A Ru diphosphonato complex with a metal-metal bond for water oxidation

Unlike [Ru2(μ-O2CCH3)4], the structurally analogous water-soluble RuII,III2 diphosphonato complex K3[Ru2(hedp)2(H2O)2] (K3·1) is only involved in stoichiometric water oxidation with a maximum 67% O2 yield under CAN/HNO3 solution (pH 1.0) for 2.5 h. The water oxidation mechanism and intermediate products were ascertained by UV-vis, ESI-MS and DFT calculation.

Mechanism and Dynamics of Formation of Bisoxo Intermediates and O-O Bond in the Catalytic Water Oxidation Process

This work elucidates the reactivity of water molecules toward the tridentate nitrogen-containing iron complex in the water oxidation process. Here, we consider the Fe^V-bisoxo complex {[Fe^V(Me₃tacn)(OH₂)(═O)₂]⁺} to be responsible for the oxygen-oxygen bond formation. This O-O bond formation happens through the addition of water as a nucleophile. The transition state was determined by the synchronous transit-guided quasi-Newton method using reactants and products and verified by intrinsic reaction coordinates (IRCs). From the IRC calculations, we observe that the Fe^V═O moiety is attacked by water and assisted by the H-bonded interaction with the oxygen atom of the bisoxo complex. The hydrogen atom is transferred to the oxygen atom of the bisoxo complex through the transition state, and subsequently, the hydroxide is transferred to another oxygen of the bisoxo complex, resulting in the formation of the oxygen-oxygen bond. This work also explains the effect of explicit water molecules on the oxygen-oxygen bond formation. Our results also show how the formation of superoxide plays an essential role in O₂ evolution. We used the potential energy scan method to compute the transition state in the oxygen evolution step. In the present work, we study the effect of chlorine on the formation of the oxygen-oxygen bond formation. In this study, the changes in the oxidation state, spin density, and spin multiplicity of the complexes are investigated for each successive step. Apart from these static theoretical calculations, we also studied the oxygen-oxygen bond formation through first-principles molecular dynamics with the aid of the well-tempered metadynamics sampling technique. From the observation of the free energy surfaces from metadynamics simulations, it is evident that the hydroxide transfer has a lesser free energetic reaction as compared to the proton transfer. This complete mechanistic study may give an idea to design a suitable water oxidation catalyst.

Homogeneous Catalysts Based on First-Row Transition-Metals for Electrochemical Water Oxidation

Strategies that enable the renewable production of storable fuels (i. e. hydrogen or hydrocarbons) through electrocatalysis continue to generate interest in the scientific community. Of central importance to this pursuit is obtaining the requisite chemical (H+ ) and electronic (e- ) inputs for fuel-forming reduction reactions, which can be met sustainably by water oxidation catalysis. Further possibility exists to couple these redox transformations to renewable energy sources (i. e. solar), thus creating a carbon neutral solution for long-term energy storage. Nature uses a Mn-Ca cluster for water oxidation catalysis via multiple proton-coupled electron-transfers (PCETs) with a photogenerated bias to perform this process with TOF 100∼300 s-1 . Synthetic molecular catalysts that efficiently perform this conversion commonly utilize rare metals (e. g., Ru, Ir), whose low abundance are associated to higher costs and scalability limitations. Inspired by nature's use of 1st row transition metal (TM) complexes for water oxidation catalysts (WOCs), attempts to use these abundant metals have been intensively explored but met with limited success. The smaller atomic size of 1st row TM ions lowers its ability to accommodate the oxidative equivalents required in the 4e- /4H+ water oxidation catalysis process, unlike noble metal catalysts that perform single-site electrocatalysis at lower overpotentials (η). Overcoming the limitations of 1st row TMs requires developing molecular catalysts that exploit biomimetic phenomena - multiple-metal redox-cooperativity, PCET and second-sphere interactions - to lower the overpotential, preorganize substrates and maintain stability. Thus, the ultimate goal of developing efficient, robust and scalable WOCs remains a challenge. This Review provides a summary of previous research works highlighting 1st row TM-based homogeneous WOCs, catalytic mechanisms, followed by strategies for catalytic activity improvements, before closing with a future outlook for this field.

Nickel is a Different Pickle: Trends in Water Oxidation Catalysis for Molecular Nickel Complexes

The development of novel water oxidation catalysts is important in the context of renewable fuels production. Ligand design is one of the key tools to improve the activity and stability of molecular catalysts. The establishment of ligand design rules can facilitate the development of improved molecular catalysts. In this paper it is shown that chemical oxidants can be used to probe oxygen evolution activity for nickel-based systems, and trends are reported that can improve future ligand design. Interestingly, different ligand effects were observed in comparison to other first-row transition metal complexes. For example, nickel complexes with secondary amine donors were more active than with tertiary amine donors, which is the opposite for iron complexes. The incorporation of imine donor groups in a cyclam ligand resulted in the fastest and most durable nickel catalyst of our series, achieving oxygen evolution turnover numbers up to 380 and turnover frequencies up to 68 min-1 in a pH 5.0 acetate buffer using Oxone as oxidant. Initial kinetic experiments with this catalyst revealed a first order in chemical oxidant and a half order in catalyst. This implies a rate-determining oxidation step from a dimeric species that needs to break up to generate the active catalyst. These findings lay the foundation for the rational design of molecular nickel catalysts for water oxidation and highlight that catalyst design rules are not generally applicable for different metals.

Elucidation of Factors That Govern the 2e-/2H+ vs 4e-/4H+ Selectivity of Water Oxidation by a Cobalt Corrole

Considering the importance of water splitting as the best solution for clean and renewable energy, the worldwide efforts for development of increasingly active molecular water oxidation catalysts must be accompanied by studies that focus on elucidating the mode of actions and catalytic pathways. One crucial challenge remains the elucidation of the factors that determine the selectivity of water oxidation by the desired 4e^-/4H⁺ pathway that leads to O₂ rather than by 2e^-/2H⁺ to H₂O₂. We now show that water oxidation with the cobalt-corrole CoBr₈ as electrocatalyst affords H₂O₂ as the main product in homogeneous solutions, while heterogeneous water oxidation by the same catalyst leads exclusively to oxygen. Experimental and computation-based investigations of the species formed during the process uncover the formation of a Co(III)-superoxide intermediate and its preceding high-valent Co-oxyl complex. The competition between the base-catalyzed hydrolysis of Co(III)-hydroperoxide [Co(III)-OOH]^- to release H₂O₂ and the electrochemical oxidation of the same to release O₂ via [Co(III)-O₂^•]^- is identified as the key step determining the selectivity of water oxidation.

Potential- and Buffer-Dependent Catalyst Decomposition during Nickel-Based Water Oxidation Catalysis

The production of hydrogen by water electrolysis benefits from the development of water oxidation catalysts. This development process can be aided by the postulation of design rules for catalytic systems. The analysis of the reactivity of molecular complexes can be complicated by their decomposition under catalytic conditions into nanoparticles that may also be active. Such a misinterpretation can lead to incorrect design rules. In this study, the nickel-based water oxidation catalyst [NiII (meso-L)](ClO4 )2 , which was previously thought to operate as a molecular catalyst, is found to decompose to form a NiOx layer in a pH 7.0 phosphate buffer under prolonged catalytic conditions, as indicated by controlled potential electrolysis, electrochemical quartz crystal microbalance, and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy measurements. Interestingly, the formed NiOx layer desorbs from the surface of the electrode under less anodic potentials. Therefore, no nickel species can be detected on the electrode after electrolysis. Catalyst decomposition is strongly dependent on the pH and buffer, as there is no indication of NiOx layer formation at pH 6.5 in phosphate buffer nor in a pH 7.0 acetate buffer. Under these conditions, the activity stems from a molecular species, but currents are much lower. This study demonstrates the importance of in situ characterization methods for catalyst decomposition and metal oxide layer formation, and previously proposed design elements for nickel-based catalysts need to be revised.

Water oxidation electrocatalysis using ruthenium coordination oligomers adsorbed on multiwalled carbon nanotubes

Photoelectrochemical cells that utilize water as a source of electrons are one of the most attractive solutions for the replacement of fossil fuels by clean and sustainable solar fuels. To achieve this, heterogeneous water oxidation catalysis needs to be mastered and properly understood. The search continues for a catalyst that is stable at the surface of electro(photo)anodes and can efficiently perform this reaction at the desired neutral pH. Here, we show how oligomeric Ru complexes can be anchored on the surfaces of graphitic materials through CH-π interactions between the auxiliary ligands bonded to Ru and the hexagonal rings of the graphitic surfaces, providing control of their molecular coverage. These hybrid molecular materials behave as molecular electroanodes that catalyse water oxidation to dioxygen at pH 7 with high current densities. This strategy for the anchoring of molecular catalysts on graphitic surfaces can potentially be extended to other transition metals and other catalytic reactions.