A comparison of the resonance Raman properties of the fast and slow forms of cytochrome oxidase

Improved Immunotherapy Efficacy by Vascular Modulation

Several strategies have been developed to modulate the tumour vasculature for cancer therapy including anti-angiogenesis and vascular normalisation. Vasculature modulation results in changes to the tumour microenvironment including oxygenation and immune cell infiltration, therefore lending itself to combination with cancer therapy. The development of immunotherapies has led to significant improvements in cancer treatment. Particularly promising are immune checkpoint blockade and CAR T cell therapies, which use antibodies against negative regulators of T cell activation and T cells reprogrammed to better target tumour antigens, respectively. However, while immunotherapy is successful in some patients, including those with advanced or metastatic cancers, only a subset of patients respond. Therefore, better predictors of patient response and methods to overcome resistance warrant investigation. Poor, or periphery-limited, T cell infiltration in the tumour is associated with poor responses to immunotherapy. Given that (1) lymphocyte recruitment requires leucocyte-endothelial cell adhesion and (2) the vasculature controls tumour oxygenation and plays a pivotal role in T cell infiltration and activation, vessel targeting strategies including anti-angiogenesis and vascular normalisation in combination with immunotherapy are providing possible new strategies to enhance therapy. Here, we review the progress of vessel modulation in enhancing immunotherapy efficacy.

Kinetics and mechanism for the binding of HCN to cytochrome c oxidase

The kinetics of cyanide binding to cytochrome c oxidase were systematically studied as a function of [HCN], [oxidase], pH, ionic strength, temperature, type and concentration of solubilizing detergent, and monomer-dimer content of oxidase. On the basis of these results a minimum reaction mechanism is proposed in which the spectrally visible rapid and slow cyanide binding reactions are two consecutive first-order reactions, not parallel reactions with different conformers of cytochrome c oxidase. The fast reaction (k'obs) follows saturation type kinetics to form an HCN complex that subsequently undergoes a slow reaction (k'obs). The fast k'obs reaction is independent of ionic strength but is strongly dependent upon pH. Two pK values were evaluated from the bell-shaped rate versus pH profile; one is due to an ionizable group on the protein (pKa = 7.45), while the other is that of HCN (pKHCN = 9.15). Therefore, oxidase is reactive toward HCN only when the group on the protein is unprotonated. The slow k'obs reaction is not a reaction of oxidase with either CN- or HCN; in fact, the product formed by the fast k'obs reaction, the oxidase-HCN complex, still undergoes the slow k" process even if all of the excess KCN is removed. The apparent rate constant of the slower phase (k"obs) is independent of all the variations done in this study, and it probably corresponds to either a slow conformational change in the protein or a change in ligand coordination at one of the metal centers after HCN binds to the bimetallic center of oxidase. Based upon the bell-shaped pH dependence of the fast phase and the pH independence of the slow phase, the mechanism also predicts that a single conformer of cytochrome c oxidase can exhibit either monophasic or biphasic cyanide binding kinetics depending upon the pH. At either very low or very high pH, the two rates become comparable in magnitude, which makes the reaction appear to be monophasic even though both reactions still occur. The amount of monomeric or dimeric oxidase only slightly affects the magnitude of k'obs and k"obs values, and both processes are clearly present in both types of oxidase.

'CO2-ligated' cytochrome c oxidase: characterization and comparison with the Cl- -ligated enzyme

A form of fully oxidized bovine heart cytochrome c oxidase that is induced by CO2/HCO3- is described. The ligand-binding properties of this form are similar to those of Cl(-)-ligated oxidase [Moody, Cooper and Rich (1991) Biochim. Biophys. Acta 1059, 189-207]. Both bind cyanide at a rate (0.2 M-1.s-1 at pH 6.5) intermediate between the rate of binding to the fast and slow forms of the enzyme, and binding of formate to both is almost undetectable. They are also similar in showing poor reactivity with H2O2, or with CO in the presence of O2, which, with fast oxidase, induce the formation of the 'ferryl' and 'peroxy' states respectively. However, there is a clear difference in the near-u.v./visible absorption spectra of the two forms; that induced by CO2/HCO3- has a Soret maximum at 427 nm whereas Cl(-)-ligated oxidase has a Soret maximum similar to that of fast oxidase at about 424 nm. It appears that both CO2/HCO3- and Cl- are members of a class of ligands that lowers the reactivity of the binuclear centre but does not impede intramolecular electron transfer from haem a to the binuclear centre, unlike the putative endogenous ligand responsible for slow oxidase.

A comparison of three preparations of cytochrome c oxidase. Optical absorbance spectra, EPR spectra and reaction towards ligands

Three preparations of cytochrome c oxidase, the preparation as traditionally prepared in our laboratory as described by Van Buuren (1992; PhD Thesis, University of Amsterdam), a preparation according to Volpe and Caughey (Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 61 (1974) 502-509) and a preparation of 'fast' cytochrome c oxidase (Brandt, U., Schägger, H. and Von Jagow, G. (1989) Eur. J. Biochem. 182, 705-711), are compared in their reaction with cyanide and carbon monoxide. The reaction with cyanide is nearly as fast for the Van Buuren preparation as for the 'fast' preparation, but much slower for the Volpe-Caughey preparation. Mixed-valence cytochrome c oxidase (cytochrome a3 and CuB reduced with carbon monoxide bound and cytochrome a and CuA oxidized) is prepared by anaerobic incubation with carbon monoxide. With the Van Buuren preparation complete formation of the species takes 4 h, whereas with the Volpe-Caughey preparation it takes 20 h. Longer incubation under CO results in partial reduction of cytochrome a and CuA. With the 'fast' preparation mixed-valence cytochrome c oxidase is formed after more than one day of incubation with CO, but it is stable for at least 3 days. The presence of oxidized cytochrome c did enhance the reactivity towards cyanide and towards carbon monoxide in cytochrome c oxidase of all three preparations. Furthermore, optical and EPR spectra of the preparations of cytochrome c oxidase are compared. The Volpe-Caughey preparation has an intense g' = 12 EPR-signal, the Van Buuren preparation has hardly any g' = 12 signal and the 'fast' preparation has no g' = 12 signal. In the 'fast' preparation the low-spin heme signal is shifted (from g = 3.00 to g = 2.97). The absorbance spectra of the three preparations in the Soret region are similar with a maximum at 424 nm. Only the 'fast' preparation as isolated was completely oxidized, whereas the other preparations were partially reduced. It was concluded that differences in the reaction of cytochrome c oxidase with ligands are determined by the internal or external ligand bound to the cytochrome a3-CuB couple.

ENDOR and ESEEM studies of cytochrome c oxidase: evidence for exchangeable protons at the CuA site

Electron nuclear double resonance (ENDOR) and electron spin echo envelope modulation (ESEEM) spectroscopies were used to study whether protons in the immediate protein environment around CuA in cytochrome c oxidase are susceptible to solvent exchange. The enzyme was incubated in buffered D2O under resting or turnover conditions for 90 min and then frozen to quench the hydrogen/deuterium-exchange process. ENDOR spectra of the deuterated sample were essentially identical to those of control samples. The ESEEM spectra, however, provided a clear indication of the introduction of deuterium into the CuA environment following incubation in buffered D2O. The extent of deuterium incorporation was not affected by enzyme turnover. An analysis of the ESEEM data indicated that water is in reasonably close proximity to the CuA site, but not in the immediate coordination sphere of the metal(s). We estimate a minimum distance of 5.4 A between the CuA center and the protein/water interface. This relatively short surface separation distance is consistent with the role of CuA as the immediate oxidant of cytochrome c in the cytochrome oxidase (Hill, B. C. (1991) J. Biol. Chem. 266, 2219-2226).

Coordination dynamics of heme-copper oxidases. The ligand shuttle and the control and coupling of electron transfer and proton translocation

Results are presented which, taken with evidence developed by others, suggest a general mechanism for the entry and binding of exogenous ligands (including O2) at the "binuclear site" (CuBFea3) of the heme-copper oxidases. The mechanism includes a "ligand shuttle" wherein the obligatory way station for incoming ligands is CuB and the binding of exogenous ligands at this site triggers the exchange and displacement of endogenous ligands at Fea3. It is suggested that these ligand shuttle reactions might be functionally important in providing a coupling mechanism for electron transfer and proton translocation. Scenarios as to how this might happen are delineated.

Current issues in the chemistry of cytochrome c oxidase

Some contemporary issues relevant to the chemistry of mammalian cytochrome c oxidase are discussed. These include the optical properties of heme A and the spectroscopic consequences of the differences in side-chain substitution compared to heme B; a common fallacy concerning the electrostatic exchange interaction between cytochrome a3 and CuB; the question of the number and location of the copper components of the enzyme; and the mode of binding of ligands such as cyanide and azide.

Evidence of dithionite contribution to the low-frequency resonance Raman spectrum of reduced and mixed-valence cytochrome c oxidase

The resonance Raman spectra of deoxygenated solutions of mixed-valence cyanide-bound and fully reduced cytochrome oxidase derivatives that have been reduced in the presence of aqueous or solid sodium dithionite exhibit two new low-frequency lines centered at 474 and 590 cm-1. These lines were not observed when the reductant system was changed to a solution containing ascorbate and N,N,N',N'-tetramethyl-p-phenylenediamine (TMPD). Under enzyme turnover conditions, the addition of dithionite to the reoxidized protein (the 428-nm or "oxygenated" form) increases the intensity of these lines, while reoxidation and rereduction of the enzyme in the presence of ascorbate/TMPD resulted in the absence of both lines. Our data suggest that both lines must have contributions from species formed from aqueous dithionite, presumably the SO2 species, since these two lines are also observed in the Raman spectrum of a solution of aqueous dithionite, but not in the spectrum of an ascorbate/TMPD solution. Since heme metal-ligand stretch vibrations are expected to appear in the low-frequency region from 215 to 670 cm-1, our results indicate that special care should be exercised during the interpretation of the cytochrome a3 resonance Raman spectrum.

Characterisation of 'fast' and 'slow' forms of bovine heart cytochrome-c oxidase

We have prepared cytochrome-c oxidase from bovine heart (using a modification of the method of Kuboyama et al. (1972) J. Biol. Chem. 247, 6375-6383) which binds cyanide rapidly, shows no kinetic distinction between the two haems on reduction by dithionite, has a Soret absorption maximum above 424 nm, and has a negligible 'g' = 12' EPR signal. On incubation at pH 6.5 this 'fast' oxidase reverts to the 'slow' ('resting') form characterised by slow cyanide binding, slow reduction of haem a3 by dithionite, a blue-shifted Soret maximum and a large 'g' = 12' signal. Incubation of 'fast' oxidase with formate produces a form of the enzyme with properties almost identical to those of 'slow' oxidase. The kinetics of formate binding to 'fast' oxidase are found to be biphasic, revealing the presence of at least two 'fast' subpopulations in our preparations. Evidence is presented that there is an equilibrium mixture of high-spin and low-spin forms of haem a3 in both 'fast' subpopulations at room temperature. Incubation of 'fast' oxidase with chloride or bromide at pH 6.5 produces forms of oxidase with much lower rates of cyanide binding. Our working hypothesis is that formate mimics a binuclear centre ligand which is present in the 'slow' form of cytochrome oxidase. Although we show that chloride and bromide can also be ligands of the binuclear centre, possibly onto CuB, we can rule out either of these being the ligand present in the 'slow' enzyme. We will argue that the 'fast' and 'slow' forms of oxidase are equivalent to the 'pulsed' and 'resting' forms of oxidase, respectively.

Magnetic state of the alpha 3 center of cytochrome c oxidase and some of its derivatives

The temperature dependence of the magnetic susceptibility was used to investigate the nature of the coupling between cytochrome alpha 3 and CuB in resting and oxidized cyanide- and formate-bound cytochrome oxidase. Resting and formate-bound enzymes were found to have strong antiferromagnetic coupling with an S = 5/2 cytochrome alpha 3, results that were independent of the dispersing detergent and the enzyme isolation method. The cyanide-bound enzyme was heterogeneous, with a minor fraction showing intermediate strength antiferromagnetic coupling. The magnitude of this coupling was independent of the enzyme isolation method and depended moderately on the identity of the dispersing detergent. The major fraction of the cyanide-bound enzyme had a lowest energy state of Ms = 0. The coupling constant for this fraction did not depend on the isolation technique or on the identity of the dispersing detergent. The use of glucose-glucose oxidase to deoxygenate samples influenced the susceptibility behavior of some preparations of both the resting and formate-bound enzymes, with results indicating an S = 3/2 cytochrome alpha 3 in the resting enzyme samples. Retention of a 417-nm Soret band for formate-bound enzyme concomitant with peroxide-induced changes in susceptibility behavior indicates different sites of enzyme interactions for the formate ion and hydrogen peroxide.

Conformational changes in cytochrome c and cytochrome oxidase upon complex formation: a resonance Raman study

The fully oxidized complex of cytochrome c and cytochrome oxidase formed at low ionic strength was studied by resonance Raman spectroscopy. The spectra of the complex and of the individual components were compared over a wide frequency range using Soret band excitation. In both partners of the complex, structural changes occur in the heme groups and in their immediate protein environment. The spectra of the complex in the 1600-1700 cm-1 frequency range were dominated by bands from the cytochrome oxidase component, whereas those in the 300-500 cm-1 range were dominated by bands from the cytochrome c component, hence allowing separation of the contributions from the two individual species. For cytochrome c, spectral changes were observed which correspond to the induction of the conformational state I and the six-coordinated low-spin configuration of state II on binding to cytochrome oxidase. While in state I the structure of cytochrome c is essentially the same as in solution, state II is characterized by a structural rearrangement of the heme pocket, leading to a weakening of the axial iron-methionine bond and an opening of the heme crevice which is situated in the center of the binding domain for cytochrome oxidase. The relative contributions of the two cytochrome c states were estimated to be approximately in the ratio 1:1 in the complex.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)