A functional ribosomal RNA tertiary structure involves a base triple interaction

Combinatorics of RNA Secondary Structures with Base Triples

The structure of RNA has been the subject of intense research over the last decades due to its importance for the correct functioning of RNA molecules in biological processes. Hence, a large number of models for RNA folding and corresponding algorithms for structure prediction have been developed. However, previous models often only consider base pairs, although every base is capable of up to three edge-to-edge interactions with other bases. Recently, Höner zu Siederdissen et al. presented an extended model of RNA secondary structure, including base triples together with a folding algorithm-the first thermodynamics-based algorithm that allows the prediction of secondary structures with base triples. In this article, we investigate the search space processed by this new algorithm, that is, the combinatorics of extended RNA secondary structures with base triples. We present generalized definitions for structural motifs like hairpins, stems, bulges, or interior loops occurring in structures with base triples. Furthermore, we prove precise asymptotic results for the number of different structures (size of search space) and expectations for various parameters associated with structural motifs (typical shape of folding). Our analysis shows that the asymptotic number of secondary structures of size n increases exponentially to [Formula: see text] compared to the classic model by Stein and Waterman for which [Formula: see text] structures exist. A comparison with the classic model reveals large deviations in the expected structural appearance, too. The inclusion of base triples constitutes a significant refinement of the combinatorial model of RNA secondary structure, which, by our findings, is quantitatively characterized. Our results are of special theoretical interest, because a closer look at the numbers involved suggests that extended RNA secondary structures constitute a new combinatorial class not bijective with any other combinatorial objects studied so far.

Structural constraints identified with covariation analysis in ribosomal RNA

Covariation analysis is used to identify those positions with similar patterns of sequence variation in an alignment of RNA sequences. These constraints on the evolution of two positions are usually associated with a base pair in a helix. While mutual information (MI) has been used to accurately predict an RNA secondary structure and a few of its tertiary interactions, early studies revealed that phylogenetic event counting methods are more sensitive and provide extra confidence in the prediction of base pairs. We developed a novel and powerful phylogenetic events counting method (PEC) for quantifying positional covariation with the Gutell lab’s new RNA Comparative Analysis Database (rCAD). The PEC and MI-based methods each identify unique base pairs, and jointly identify many other base pairs. In total, both methods in combination with an N-best and helix-extension strategy identify the maximal number of base pairs. While covariation methods have effectively and accurately predicted RNAs secondary structure, only a few tertiary structure base pairs have been identified. Analysis presented herein and at the Gutell lab’s Comparative RNA Web (CRW) Site reveal that the majority of these latter base pairs do not covary with one another. However, covariation analysis does reveal a weaker although significant covariation between sets of nucleotides that are in proximity in the three-dimensional RNA structure. This reveals that covariation analysis identifies other types of structural constraints beyond the two nucleotides that form a base pair.

Three-way RNA junctions with remote tertiary contacts: a recurrent and highly versatile fold

Three-way junction RNAs adopt a recurrent Y shape when two of the helices form a coaxial stack and the third helix establishes one or more tertiary contacts several base pairs away from the junction. In this review, the structure, distribution, and functional relevance of these motifs are examined. Structurally, the folds exhibit conserved junction topologies, and the distal tertiary interactions play a crucial role in determining the final shape of the structures. The junctions and remote tertiary contacts behave as flexible hinge motifs that respond to changes in the other region, providing these folds with switching mechanisms that have been shown to be functionally useful in a variety of contexts. In addition, the juxtaposition of RNA domains at the junction and at the distal tertiary complexes enables the RNA helices to adopt unusual conformations that are frequently used by proteins, RNA molecules, and antibiotics as platforms for specific binding. As a consequence of these properties, Y-shaped junctions are widely distributed in all kingdoms of life, having been observed in small naked RNAs such as riboswitches and ribozymes or embedded in complex ribonucleoprotein systems like ribosomal RNAs, RNase P, or the signal recognition particle. In all cases, the folds were found to play an essential role for the functioning or assembly of the RNA or ribonucleoprotein systems that contain them.

Structure of the thiostrepton resistance methyltransferase.S-adenosyl-L-methionine complex and its interaction with ribosomal RNA

The x-ray crystal structure of the thiostrepton resistance RNA methyltransferase (Tsr).S-adenosyl-L-methionine (AdoMet) complex was determined at 2.45-A resolution. Tsr is definitively confirmed as a Class IV methyltransferase of the SpoU family with an N-terminal "L30-like" putative target recognition domain. The structure and our in vitro analysis of the interaction of Tsr with its target domain from 23 S ribosomal RNA (rRNA) demonstrate that the active biological unit is a Tsr homodimer. In vitro methylation assays show that Tsr activity is optimal against a 29-nucleotide hairpin rRNA though the full 58-nucleotide L11-binding domain and intact 23 S rRNA are also effective substrates. Molecular docking experiments predict that Tsr.rRNA binding is dictated entirely by the sequence and structure of the rRNA hairpin containing the A1067 target nucleotide and is most likely driven primarily by large complementary electrostatic surfaces. One L30-like domain is predicted to bind the target loop and the other is near an internal loop more distant from the target site where a nucleotide change (U1061 to A) also decreases methylation by Tsr. Furthermore, a predicted interaction with this internal loop by Tsr amino acid Phe-88 was confirmed by mutagenesis and RNA binding experiments. We therefore propose that Tsr achieves its absolute target specificity using the N-terminal domains of each monomer in combination to recognize the two distinct structural elements of the target rRNA hairpin such that both Tsr subunits contribute directly to the positioning of the target nucleotide on the enzyme.

Systematic deletion of the adenovirus-associated RNAI terminal stem reveals a surprisingly active RNA inhibitor of double-stranded RNA-activated protein kinase

Adenoviruses use the short noncoding RNA transcript virus-associated (VA) RNA(I) to counteract two critical elements of the host cell defense system, innate cellular immunity and RNA interference, mediated by the double-stranded RNA-activated protein kinase (PKR) and Dicer/RNA-induced silencing complex, respectively. We progressively shortened the VA RNA(I) terminal stem to examine its necessity for inhibition of PKR. Each deletion, up to 15 bp into the terminal stem, resulted in a cumulative decrease in PKR inhibitory activity. Remarkably, however, despite significant apparent destabilization of the RNA structure, the final RNA mutant that lacked the entire terminal stem (TSDelta21 RNA) efficiently bound PKR and exhibited wild-type inhibitory activity. TSDelta21 RNA stability was strongly influenced by solution pH, indicating the involvement of a protonated base within the VA RNA(I) central domain tertiary structure. Gel filtration chromatography and isothermal titration calorimetry analysis indicated that wild-type VA RNA(I) and TSDelta21 RNA form similar 1:1 complexes with PKR but that the latter lacks secondary binding site(s) that might be provided by the terminal stem. Although TSDelta21 RNA bound PKR with wild-type K(d), and overall change in free energy (DeltaG), the thermodynamics of binding (DeltaH and DeltaS) were significantly altered. These results demonstrate that the VA RNA(I) terminal stem is entirely dispensable for inhibition of PKR. Potentially, VA RNA(I) is therefore a truly bi-functional RNA; Dicer processing of the VA RNA(I) terminal stem saturates the RNA interference system while generating a "mini-VA RNA(I)" molecule that remains fully active against PKR.

Optimization of a ribosomal structural domain by natural selection

A conserved, independently folding domain in the large ribosomal subunit consists of 58 nt of rRNA and a single protein, L11. The tertiary structure of an rRNA fragment carrying the Escherichia coli sequence is marginally stable in vitro but can be substantially stabilized by mutations found in other organisms. To distinguish between possible reasons why natural selection has not evolved a more stable rRNA structure in E. coli, mutations affecting the rRNA tertiary structure were assessed for their in vitro effects on rRNA stability and L11 affinity (in the context of an rRNA fragment) or in vivo effects on cell growth rate and L11 content of ribosomes. The rRNA fragment stabilities ranged from -4 to +9 kcal/mol relative to the wild-type sequence. Variants in the range of -4 to +5 kcal/mol had almost no observable effect in vivo, while more destabilizing mutations (>7 kcal/mol) were not tolerated. The data suggest that the in vivo stability of the complex is roughly -6 kcal/mol and that any single tertiary interaction is dispensable for function as long as a minimum stability of the complex is maintained. On the basis of these data, it seems that the evolution of this domain has not been constrained by inherent structural or functional limits on stability. The estimated stability corresponds to only a few ribosomes per bacterial cell dissociated from L11 at any time; thus the selective advantage for any further increase in stability may be so small as to be outweighed by other competing selective pressures.

Coevolution of protein and RNA structures within a highly conserved ribosomal domain

The X-ray crystal structure of a ribosomal L11-rRNA complex with chloroplast-like mutations in both protein and rRNA is presented. The global structure is almost identical to that of the wild-type (bacterial) complex, with only a small movement of the protein alpha helix away from the surface of the RNA required to accommodate the altered protein residue. In contrast, the specific hydrogen bonding pattern of the mutated residues is substantially different, and now includes a direct interaction between the protein side chain and an RNA base edge and a water-mediated contact. Comparison of the two structures allows the observations of sequence variation and relative affinities of wild-type and mutant complexes to be clearly rationalized, but reinforces the concept that there is no single simple code for protein-RNA recognition.

Interactions of the N-terminal domain of ribosomal protein L11 with thiostrepton and rRNA

Ribosomal protein L11 has two domains: the C-terminal domain (L11-C76) binds rRNA, whereas the N-terminal domain (L11-NTD) may variously interact with elongation factor G, the antibiotic thiostrepton, and rRNA. To begin to quantitate these interactions, L11 from Bacillus stearothermophilus has been overexpressed and its properties compared with those of L11-C76 alone in a fluorescence assay for protein-rRNA binding. The assay relies on 2'-amino-butyryl-pyrene-uridine incorporated in a 58-nucleotide rRNA fragment, which gives approximately 15-fold enhancement when L11 or L11-C76 is bound. Although the pyrene tag weakens protein binding, unbiased protein-RNA association constants were obtained in competition experiments with untagged RNA. It was found that (i) intact B. stearothermophilus L11 binds rRNA with K approximately 1.2 x 10(9) m(-1) in buffers with 0.2 m KCl, about 100-fold tighter than Escherichia coli L11; (ii) the N-terminal domain makes a small, salt-dependent contribution to the overall L11-RNA binding affinity (approximately 8-fold enhancement at 0.2 m KCl), (iii) L11 stimulates thiostrepton binding by 2.3 +/- 0.6 x 10(3)-fold, predicting an overall thiostrepton affinity for the ribosome of approximately 10(9) m(-1), and (iv) the yeast homolog of L11 shows no stimulation of thiostrepton binding. The latter observation resolves the question of why eukaryotes are insensitive to the antibiotic. These measurements also show that it is plausible for thiostrepton to compete directly with EF-G.GDP for binding to the L11-RNA complex, and provide a quantitative basis for further studies of L11 function and thiostrepton mechanism.

Structure of the Human Telomerase RNA Pseudoknot Reveals Conserved Tertiary Interactions Essential for Function

Human telomerase contains a 451 nt RNA (hTR) and several proteins, including a specialized reverse transcriptase (hTERT). The 5' half of hTR comprises the pseudoknot (core) domain, which includes the RNA template for telomere synthesis and a highly conserved pseudoknot that is required for telomerase activity. The solution structure of this essential pseudoknot, presented here, reveals an extended triple helix surrounding the helical junction. The network of tertiary interactions explains the phylogenetic sequence conservation and existing human and mouse TR functional studies as well as mutations linked to disease. Thermodynamic stability, dimerization potential, and telomerase activity of mutant RNAs that alter the tertiary contacts were investigated. Telomerase activity is strongly correlated with tertiary structure stability, whereas there is no correlation with dimerization potential of the pseudoknot. These studies reveal that a conserved pseudoknot tertiary structure is required for telomerase activity.

NMR studies of the structure and Mg2+ binding properties of a conserved RNA motif of EMCV picornavirus IRES element

The structure and Mg(2+) binding properties of a conserved 75mer RNA motif of the internal ribosome entry site (IRES) element of encephalomyocarditis virus picornavirus have been investigated by (1)H-NMR and UV melting experiments. The assignment of the imino proton resonances with characteristic chemical shift dispersion for canonical and non-canonical base pairs confirmed the predicted secondary structure of the 75mer and its fragments. Addition of Mg(2+) resulted in a dramatic increase in apparent melting temperature, with the 75mer RNA registering the biggest increase, from 63 to 80 degrees C, thus providing evidence for enhanced stability arising from Mg(2+) binding. Similarly, addition of Mg(2+) induced selective changes to the chemical shifts of the imino protons of a GCGA tetraloop in the 75mer, that is essential for IRES activity, thereby highlighting a possible structural role for Mg(2+) in the folding of the 75mer. Significantly, the same protons show retarded exchange to water solvent, even at elevated temperature, which suggest that Mg(2+) induces a conformational rearrangement of the 75mer. Thus, we propose that Mg(2+) serves two important roles: (i) enhancing thermodynamic stability of the 75mer RNA (and its submotifs) via non-specific interactions with the phosphate backbone and (ii) promoting the folding of the 75mer RNA by binding to the GCGA tetraloop.

A conserved element in the yeast RNase MRP RNA subunit can participate in a long-range base-pairing interaction

RNase MRP is a ribonucleoprotein endoribonuclease involved in eukaryotic pre-rRNA processing. The enzyme possesses a putatively catalytic RNA subunit, structurally related to that of RNase P. A thorough structure analysis of Saccharomyces cerevisiae MRP RNA, entailing enzymatic and chemical probing, mutagenesis and thermal melting, identifies a previously unrecognised stem that occupies a position equivalent to the P7 stem of RNase P. Inclusion of this P7-like stem confers on yeast MRP RNA a greater degree of similarity to the core RNase P RNA structure than that described previously and better delimits domain 2, the proposed specificity domain. The additional stem is created by participation of a conserved sequence element (ymCR-II) in a long-range base-pairing interaction. There is potential for this base-pairing throughout the known yeast MRP RNA sequences. Formation of a P7-like stem is not required, however, for the pre-rRNA processing or essential function of RNase MRP. Mutants that can base-pair are nonetheless detrimental to RNase MRP function, indicating that the stem will form in vivo but that only the wild-type pairing is accommodated. Although the alternative MRP RNA structure described is clearly not part of the active RNase MRP enzyme, it would be the more stable structure in the absence of protein subunits and the probability that it represents a valid intermediate species in the process of yeast RNase MRP assembly is discussed.

Quantitation of free energy profiles in RNA-ligand interactions by nucleotide analog interference mapping

RNA interactions with protein and small molecule ligands serve a wide variety of biochemical functions in the cell. To best understand the specificity and affinity of these interactions, the free energy contribution made by individual function groups in the RNA must be determined. As an efficient method for obtaining such energetic profiles, we report quantitative nucleotide analog interference mapping (QNAIM). This extension of the NAIM methodology uses the magnitude of analog interference as a function of ligand concentration to calculate binding constants for RNA with individual analog substitutions. In this way, QNAIM not only defines which functional groups are important to an interaction but simultaneously determines the energetic contribution made by each occurrence of that functional group within the RNA polymer. To establish the utility of this approach, QNAIM was used to quantify functional group interactions within the signal recognition particle (SRP), specifically the 4.5S RNA with the M domain of Ffh. In each of the cases in which energetic data were available from previous site-specific substitution analyses, QNAIM provided nearly equivalent results. These experiments on a model system demonstrate that QNAIM is an efficient method to establish a chemically detailed free energy profile for a wide variety of RNA-ligand interactions.

General plasmids for producing RNA in vitro transcripts with homogeneous ends

In vitro transcripts of bacteriophage RNA polymerases (RNAPs), such as T7 RNAP, often suffer from a considerable degree of 3'-end heterogeneity and, with certain promoter sequences, 5'-end heterogeneity. For some applications, this transcript heterogeneity poses a significant problem. A potential solution is to incorporate ribozymes into the transcripts at the 5'- and/or 3'-end of the target RNA sequence. This approach has been used quite widely but has required the generation of new transcription vectors or PCR-derived templates for each new RNA to be studied. To overcome this limitation, we have created two general plasmids for producing homogeneous RNA transcripts: one encodes a 3'- hepatitis delta virus (HDV) ribozyme and the other, used in combination with a two-step PCR, allows the production of double [5'-hammerhead (HH) and 3'-HDV] ribozyme constructs. A choice of cloning and run-off transcription linearisation restriction enzyme sites ensures that virtually any RNA sequence can be cloned and transcribed from these plasmids. For all the RNA sequences tested, good yields of transcript were obtained. These plasmids provide the tools for the simple, rapid creation of new RNA-coding plasmids to produce milligram quantities of homogeneous in vitro transcripts for all applications.

A compact RNA tertiary structure contains a buried backbone-K+ complex

The structure of a 58 nucleotide ribosomal RNA fragment buries several phosphate groups of a hairpin loop within a large tertiary core. During refinement of an X-ray crystal structure containing this RNA, a potassium ion was found to be contacted by six oxygen atoms from the buried phosphate groups; the ion is contained completely within the solvent-accessible surface of the RNA. The electrostatic potential at the ion chelation site is unusually large, and more than compensates for the substantial energetic penalties associated with partial dehydration of the ion and displacement of delocalized ions. The very large predicted binding free energy, approximately -30 kcal/mol, implies that the site must be occupied for the RNA to fold. These findings agree with previous studies of the ion-dependent folding of tertiary structure in this RNA, which concluded that a monovalent ion was bound in a partially dehydrated environment where Mg2+ could not easily compete for binding. By compensating the unfavorable free energy of buried phosphate groups with a chelated ion, the RNA is able to create a larger and more complex tertiary fold than would be possible otherwise.

Structure and function of the conserved 690 hairpin in Escherichia coli 16 S ribosomal RNA. III. Functional analysis of the 690 loop

An instant-evolution experiment was performed on the eight nucleotides comprising the loop region of the 690 hairpin in Escherichia coli 16 S ribosomal RNA. Positions 690 to 697 were randomly mutated and 101 unique functional mutants were isolated, sequenced and analyzed for function in vivo. Non-random nucleotide distributions were observed at each of the mutated positions except 693 and 694. Nucleotide identity significantly affected ribosome function at positions 690, 695, 696 and 697. Pyrimidines were absent at position 696 in the instant-evolution pool as were C at position 691 and G at position 697. A highly significant covariation was observed between nucleotides 690 and 697. No functional double mutants at positions 691 and 696 were obtained from the instant-evolution pool. In our NMR structure of the 690 loop, both the G690.U697 and G691.A696 form sheared hydrogen-bonded mismatches. To further examine the functional constraints between these paired nucleotides, one set of site-directed mutations was constructed at positions 690:697 and another set was constructed at positions 691:696. Functional analysis of the site-directed mutants is consistent with our instant-evolution findings and revealed constraints on the placement of specific functional groups observed in the NMR structure. Ten instant-evolution mutants were isolated that are more functional than the wild-type. Hyperactivity in these mutants correlates with a single mutation at position 693.

Improved statistical methods reveal direct interactions between 16S and 23S rRNA

Recent biochemical studies have indicated a number of regions in both the 16S and 23S rRNA that are exposed on the ribosomal subunit surface. In order to predict potential interactions between these regions we applied novel phylogenetically-based statistical methods to detect correlated nucleotide changes occurring between the rRNA molecules. With these methods we discovered a number of highly significant correlated changes between different sets of nucleotides in the two ribosomal subunits. The predictions with the highest correlation values belong to regions of the rRNA subunits that are in close proximity according to recent crystal structures of the entire ribosome. We also applied a new statistical method of detecting base triple interactions within these same rRNA subunit regions. This base triple statistic predicted a number of new base triples not detected by pair-wise interaction statistics within the rRNA molecules. Our results suggest that these statistical methods may enhance the ability to detect novel structural elements both within and between RNA molecules.

A covariant change of the two highly conserved bases in the GTPase-associated center of 28 S rRNA in silkworms and other moths

The GTPase-associated center in 23/28 S rRNA is one of the most conserved functional domains throughout all organisms. We detected a unique sequence of this domain in Bombyx mori species in which the bases at positions 1094 and 1098 (numbering from Escherichia coli 23 S rRNA) are C and G instead of the otherwise universally conserved bases U and A, respectively. These changes were also observed in four other species of moths, but not in organisms other than the moths. Characteristics of the B. mori rRNA domain were investigated by native polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis using RNA fragments containing residues 1030-1128. Although two bands of protein-free RNA appeared on gel, they shifted to a single band when bound to Bombyx ribosomal proteins Bm-L12 and Bm-P complex, equivalent to E. coli L11 and L8, respectively. Bombyx RNA showed lower binding capacity than rat RNA for the ribosomal proteins and anti-28 S autoantibody, specific for a folded structure of the eukaryotic GTPase-associated domain. When the C(1094)/G(1098) bases in Bombyx RNA were replaced by the conserved U/A bases, the protein-free RNA migrated as a single band, and the complex formation with Bm-L12, Bm-P complex, and anti-28 S autoantibody was comparable to that of rat RNA. The results suggest that the GTPase-associated domain of moth-type insects has a labile structural feature that is caused by an unusual covariant change of the U(1094)/A(1098) bases to C/G.

Calculating nucleic acid secondary structure

New results for calculating nucleic acid secondary structure by free energy minimization and phylogenetic comparisons have recently been reported. A complete set of DNA energy parameters is now available and the RNA parameters have been improved. Although databases of RNA secondary structures are still derived and expanded using computer-assisted, ad hoc comparative analysis, a number of new computer algorithms combine covariation analysis with energy methods.

Energetics of a strongly pH dependent RNA tertiary structure in a frameshifting pseudoknot

Retroviruses employ -1 translational frameshifting to regulate the relative concentrations of structural and non-structural proteins critical to the viral life cycle. The 1.6 A crystal structure of the -1 frameshifting pseudoknot from beet western yellows virus reveals, in addition to Watson-Crick base-pairing, many loop-stem RNA tertiary structural interactions and a bound Na(+). Investigation of the thermodynamics of unfolding of the beet western yellows virus pseudoknot reveals strongly pH-dependent loop-stem tertiary structural interactions which stabilize the molecule, contributing a net of DeltaH approximately -30 kcal mol(-1) and DeltaG degrees (37) of -3.3 kcal mol(-1) to a total DeltaH and DeltaG degrees (37) of -121 and -16 kcal mol(-1), respectively, at pH 6.0, 0.5 M K(+) by DSC. Characterization of mutant RNAs supports the presence of a C8(+).G12-C26 loop 1-stem 2 base-triple (pK(a)=6.8), protonation of which contributes nearly -3.5 kcal mol(-1) in net stability in the presence of a wild-type loop 2. Substitution of the nucleotides in loop 2 with uridine bases, which would eliminate the minor groove triplex, destroys pseudoknot formation. An examination of the dependence of the monovalent ion and type on melting profiles suggests that tertiary structure unfolding occurs in a manner quantitatively consistent with previous studies on the stabilizing effects of K(+), NH(4)(+) and Na(+) on other simple duplex and pseudoknotted RNAs.

Mapping the ribosomal RNA neighborhood of protein L11 by directed hydroxyl radical probing

Ribosomal protein L11 is a highly conserved protein that has been implicated in binding of elongation factors to ribosomes and associated GTP hydrolysis. Here, we have analyzed the ribosomal RNA neighborhood of Escherichia coli L11 in 50 S subunits by directed hydroxyl radical probing from Fe(II) tethered to five engineered cysteine residues at positions 19, 84, 85, 92 and 116 via the linker 1-(p -bromoacetamidobenzyl)-EDTA. Correct assembly of the L11 derivatives was analyzed by incorporating the modified proteins into 50 S subunits isolated from an E. coli strain that lacks L11 and testing for previously characterized L11-dependent footprints in domain II of 23 S rRNA. Hydroxyl radicals were generated from Fe(II) tethered to L11 and sites of cleavage in the ribosomal RNA were detected by primer extension. Strong cleavages were detected within the previously described binding site of L11, in the 1100 region of 23 S rRNA. Moreover, Fe(II) tethered to position 19 in L11 targeted the backbone of the sarcin loop in domain VI while probing from position 92 cleaved the backbone around bases 900 and 2470 in domains II and V, respectively. Fe(II) tethered to positions 84, 85 and 92 also generated cleavages in 5 S rRNA around helix II. These data provide new information about the positions of specific features of 23 S rRNA and 5 S rRNA relative to protein L11 in the 50 S subunit and show that L11 is near highly conserved elements of the rRNA that have been implicated in binding of tRNA and elongation factors to the ribosome.

Crystal structure of a conserved ribosomal protein-RNA complex

The structure of a highly conserved complex between a 58-nucleotide domain of large subunit ribosomal RNA and the RNA-binding domain of ribosomal protein L11 has been solved at 2.8 angstrom resolution. It reveals a precisely folded RNA structure that is stabilized by extensive tertiary contacts and contains an unusually large core of stacked bases. A bulge loop base from one hairpin of the RNA is intercalated into the distorted major groove of another helix; the protein locks this tertiary interaction into place by binding to the intercalated base from the minor groove side. This direct interaction with a key ribosomal RNA tertiary interaction suggests that part of the role of L11 is to stabilize an unusual RNA fold within the ribosome.

A detailed view of a ribosomal active site: the structure of the L11-RNA complex

We report the crystal structure of a 58 nucleotide fragment of 23S ribosomal RNA bound to ribosomal protein L11. This highly conserved ribonucleoprotein domain is the target for the thiostrepton family of antibiotics that disrupt elongation factor function. The highly compact RNA has both familiar and novel structural motifs. While the C-terminal domain of L11 binds RNA tightly, the N-terminal domain makes only limited contacts with RNA and is proposed to function as a switch that reversibly associates with an adjacent region of RNA. The sites of mutations conferring resistance to thiostrepton and micrococcin line a narrow cleft between the RNA and the N-terminal domain. These antibiotics are proposed to bind in this cleft, locking the putative switch and interfering with the function of elongation factors.

Structural studies of the translational apparatus

Significant progress is occurring at an accelerated rate in structural studies of ribosomes. A 3D cryoelectron microscopy map of the 70S ribosome from Escherichia coli is available at 15 A resolution and a combination of cryoelectron microscopy with X-ray crystallography has yielded a 9 A resolution map of the 50S subunit from Haloarcula marismortui, an archaebacterium. For eukaryotes, 3D cryomaps of the 80S ribosomes from yeast and from mammals have now been produced at resolutions in the range 20 to 30 A. The most ground-breaking results have been obtained from the 3D mapping of ligands in functional studies of prokaryotic ribosomes. These studies, which directly visualize the protein synthesis machine in action, have brought new excitement to a field that was relatively dormant during the past decade.

The antibiotic micrococcin acts on protein L11 at the ribosomal GTPase centre

Micrococcin-resistant mutants of Bacillus megaterium that carry mutations affecting ribosomal protein L11 have been characterised. The mutants fall into two groups. "L11-minus" strains containing an L11 gene with deletions, insertions or nonsense mutations which grow 2.5-fold slower than the wild-type strain, whereas other mutants carrying single-site substitutions within an 11 amino acid residue segment of the N-terminal domain of L11 grow normally. Protein L11 binds to 23 S rRNA within the ribosomal GTPase centre which regulates GTP hydrolysis on ribosomal factors. Micrococcin binding within the rRNA component of this centre was probed on wild-type and mutant ribosomes, in vivo, using dimethyl sulphate where it generated an rRNA footprint indistinguishable from that produced in vitro, even after the cell growth had been arrested by treatment with either kirromycin or fusidic acid. No drug-rRNA binding was detected in vivo for the L11-minus mutants, while reduced binding (approximately 30-fold) was observed for two single-site mutants P23L and P26L. For the latter, the reduced drug affinity alone did not account for the resistance-phenotype because rapid cell growth occurred even at drug concentrations that would saturate the ribosomes. Micrococcin was also bound to complexes containing an rRNA fragment and wild-type or mutant L11, expressed as fusion proteins, and they were probed with proteinases. The drug produced strong protection effects on the wild-type protein and weak effects on the P23L and P26L mutant proteins. We infer that inhibition of cell growth by micrococcin, as for thiostrepton, results from the imposition of a conformational constraint on protein L11 which, in turn, perturbs the function(s) of the ribosomal factor-guanosine nucleotide complexes.

RNA binding strategies of ribosomal proteins

Structures of a number of ribosomal proteins have now been determined by crystallography and NMR, though the complete structure of a ribosomal protein-rRNA complex has yet to be solved. However, some ribosomal protein structures show strong similarity to well-known families of DNA or RNA binding proteins for which structures in complex with cognate nucleic acids are available. Comparison of the known nucleic acid binding mechanisms of these non-ribosomal proteins with the most highly conserved surfaces of similar ribosomal proteins suggests ways in which the ribosomal proteins may be binding RNA. Three binding motifs, found in four ribosomal proteins so far, are considered here: homeodomain-like alpha-helical proteins (L11), OB fold proteins (S1 and S17) and RNP consensus proteins (S6). These comparisons suggest that ribosomal proteins combine a small number of fundamental strategies to develop highly specific RNA recognition sites.