Molecular Geometry Directed Kagomé and Honeycomb Networks: Toward Two-Dimensional Crystal Engineering

On-Surface Fabrication toward Polar 2D Macromolecular Crystals

Polar 2D macromolecular structures have attracted significant attention because of their ferroelectricity and ferro-magnetism. However, it is challenging to synthesize them experimentally because dipoles or spins of these macromolecules tend to cancel each other. So far, there has been no successful strategy for assembling macromolecules in a unidirectional manner, achieving stereoregular polymerization on metal surfaces, and creating polar 2D polymer crystals. Recent progress in molecular assembly, on-surface polymer synthesis, and direct control of molecules using electric field applications provides an opportunity to develop such strategies. In this regard, we first review past studies on chiral and achiral molecular assembly, on-surface polymer synthesis, and orientation control of polar molecules. Then, we discuss our newly developed approach called "vectorial on-surface synthesis", which is based on "dynamic chirality" of compass precursors, stereoselective polymerization, and favorable interchain interactions originating from CH-π interactions. Finally, we conclude with a prospective outlook.

Two-dimensional molecular networks at the solid/liquid interface and the role of alkyl chains in their building blocks

Nanoarchitectonics has attracted increasing attention owing to its potential applications in nanomachines, nanoelectronics, catalysis, and nanopatterning, which can contribute to overcoming global problems related to energy and environment, among others. However, the fabrication of ordered nanoarchitectures remains a challenge, even in two dimensions. Therefore, a deeper understanding of the self-assembly processes and substantial factors for building ordered structures is critical for tailoring flexible and desirable nanoarchitectures. Scanning tunneling microscopy is a powerful tool for revealing the molecular conformations, arrangements, and orientations of two-dimensional (2D) networks on surfaces. The fabrication of 2D assemblies involves non-covalent interactions that play a significant role in the molecular arrangement and orientation. Among the non-covalent interactions, dispersion interactions that derive from alkyl chain units are believed to be weak. However, alkyl chains play an important role in the adsorption onto substrates, as well as in the in-plane intermolecular interactions. In this review, we focus on the role of alkyl chains in the formation of ordered 2D assemblies at the solid/liquid interface. The alkyl chain effects on the 2D assemblies are introduced together with examples documented in the past decades.

Symmetry and spacing controls in periodic covalent functionalization of graphite surfaces templated by self-assembled molecular networks

We herein present the periodic covalent functionalization of graphite surfaces, creating a range of patterns of different symmetries and pitches at the nanoscale. Self-assembled molecular networks (SAMNs) of rhombic-shaped bis(dehydrobenzo[12]annulene) (bisDBA) derivatives having alkyl chain substituents of different lengths were used as templates for covalent grafting of electrochemically generated aryl radicals. Scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) observations at the 1,2,4-trichlorobenzene/graphite interface revealed that these molecules form a variety of networks that contain pores of different shapes and sizes. The covalently functionalized surfaces show hexagonal, oblique, and quasi-rectangular periodicities. This is attributed to the favorable aryl radical addition at the pore(s). We also confirmed the successful transmission of chirality information from the SAMNs to the alignment of the grafted aryls. In one case, the addition of a guest molecule was used to switch the SAMN symmetry and periodicity, leading to a change in the functionalized surface periodicity from oblique to hexagonal in the presence of the guest molecule. This contribution highlights the potential of SAMNs as templates for the controlled formation of nanopatterned carbon materials.

Light Controlled 3D Crystal Morphology for Droplet Evaporative Crystallization on Photosensitive Hydrophobic Substrate

Controlling crystal morphology is crucial in analytical chemistry and smart materials synthesis, etc. However, flexible manipulation of 3D crystal morphology still remains challenging. Herein, we present a novel and facile light strategy for droplet evaporative crystallization to manipulate macroscopic crystal morphology on photosensitive hydrophobic substrate possessing photothermal conversion property. We demonstrate that the spherical coronal shell and alms bowl-like crystal skeletons can be achieved on smooth photosensitive hydrophobic substrate, depending on the salt concentration. Rough photosensitive hydrophobic substrate further creates a bubble-assisted light strategy, by which a cylindrical shell-like crystal skeleton with a directionally controllable cavity is achieved. Amazingly, the proper additive endows droplet evaporative crystallization to form a closed crystal skeleton with the solution wrapped inside. The present study provides new ideas for designing a novel optical droplet microfluidic platform for controlling crystal morphology.

Nanometer-scale patterning of hard and soft interfaces: from photolithography to molecular-scale design

Many areas of modern materials chemistry, from nanoscale electronics to regenerative medicine, require design of precisely-controlled chemical environments at near-molecular scales on both hard and soft surfaces.

Chirality in porous self-assembled monolayer networks at liquid/solid interfaces: induction, reversion, recognition and transfer

Chirality in two dimensions (2D) has attracted increasing attention with regard to interesting fundamental aspects as well as potential applications. This article reports several aspects of supramolecular chirality control as exemplified by self-assembled monolayer networks (SAMNs) formed by a class of chiral building blocks consisting of a triangular conjugated core and alkoxy chains on the periphery. It highlights 2D chirality induction phenomena through a classic "sergeants-and-soldiers" mechanism, in which the inducer is incorporated into a network component, as well as through a "supramolecular host-guest" mechanism, in which the inducer is entrapped in the porous space, leading to counterintuitive chirality reversal. Stereochemical control can be extended to three dimensions too, based on interlayer hydrogen bonding of the same class of building blocks bearing hydroxy groups, exhibiting diastereospecific bilayer formation at both single molecule level and supramolecular level arising from orientation between the top and bottom layers. Finally, we showcase that homochiral SAMNs can also be used as templates for the grafting of in situ generated aryl radicals, by covalent bond formation to the basal graphitic surface, thereby yielding topologically chiral functionalized graphite, and thus extending the potential of chiral SAMNs.

Revealing the Limits of Intermolecular Interactions: Molecular Rings of Ferrocene Derivatives on Graphite Surface

We report the formation of discrete molecular rings/spirals of small molecules (1,3-dithia derivatives of ferrocene) on a highly oriented pyrolytic graphite (HOPG) surface. On the basis of microscopy and theoretical calculations, molecular level arrangement within the molecular rings is understood. The molecular rings show a limiting inner diameter, and we interpret it to be related to the critical intermolecular interaction limit. This limiting value of the inner diameter is surprisingly correlated with that observed for molecular rings/disks of a few reported molecules. The correlation reveals that molecular rings formed typically by weak van der Waals interactions should always show a limiting inner diameter and should be independent of molecular structure, size, and chemical nature.

Template-assisted 2D self-assembled chiral Kagomé network for selective adsorption of coronene

Coadsorbed solvents can serve as a template to fabricate a Kagomé network, which could be used to select adsorption of coronene.

Self-assembly and spectroscopic fingerprints of photoactive pyrenyl tectons on hBN/Cu(111)

The controlled modification of electronic and photophysical properties of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons by chemical functionalization, adsorption on solid supports, and supramolecular organization is the key to optimize the application of these compounds in (opto)electronic devices. Here, we present a multimethod study comprehensively characterizing a family of pyridin-4-ylethynyl-functionalized pyrene derivatives in different environments. UV-vis measurements in toluene solutions revealed absorption at wavelengths consistent with density functional theory (DFT) calculations, while emission experiments showed a high fluorescence quantum yield. Scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) and spectroscopy (STS) measurements of the pyrene derivatives adsorbed on a Cu(111)-supported hexagonal boron nitride (hBN) decoupling layer provided access to spatially and energetically resolved molecular electronic states. We demonstrate that the pyrene electronic gap is reduced with an increasing number of substituents. Furthermore, we discuss the influence of template-induced gating and supramolecular organization on the energies of distinct molecular orbitals. The selection of the number and positioning of the pyridyl termini in tetrasubstituted, trans- and cis-like-disubstituted derivatives governed the self-assembly of the pyrenyl core on the nanostructured hBN support, affording dense-packed arrays and intricate porous networks featuring a kagome lattice.

Patterning Porous Networks through Self-Assembly of Programmed Biomacromolecules

Two-dimensional (2D) porous networks are of great interest for the fabrication of complex organized functional materials for potential applications in nanotechnologies and nanoelectronics. This review aims at providing an overview of bottom-up approaches towards the engineering of 2D porous networks by using biomacromolecules, with a particular focus on nucleic acids and proteins. The first part illustrates how the advancements in DNA nanotechnology allowed for the attainment of complex ordered porous two-dimensional DNA nanostructures, thanks to a biomimetic approach based on DNA molecules self-assembly through specific hydrogen-bond base pairing. The second part focuses the attention on how polypeptides and proteins structural properties could be used to engineer organized networks templating the formation of multifunctional materials. The structural organization of all examples is discussed as revealed by scanning probe microscopy or transmission electron microscopy imaging techniques.

Concentration-Directed Polymorphic Surface Covalent Organic Frameworks: Rhombus, Parallelogram, and Kagome

Polymorphic single-layered covalent organic frameworks (sCOFs) via on-surface synthesis have been investigated by employing the tetradentate monomer 1,3,6,8-tetrakis(p-formylphenyl)pyrene with D_2h symmetry and ditopic linear diamine building blocks. Three kinds of well-ordered sCOFs, including rhombus, parallelogram, and Kagome networks, are observed on the graphite surface by scanning tunnel microscopy. The pore size and periodicity of sCOFs are tunable by employing diamine monomers with different lengths. Statistical analysis reveals that two types of quadrate networks are preferred at high concentration, whereas the occupancy of Kagome networks increases at low concentration. This trend can be understood by the differences in the network density of three kinds of networks. The reversibility and the self-sorting ability of the dynamic covalent reaction make it possible to control the polymorphic distribution similar to the principle demonstrated in supramolecular self-assembly.

Chiral Kagome Lattices from On-Surface Synthesized Molecules

Kagome lattices have attracted much attention owing to their potential applications in spin-frustrated magnetism and host-guest chemistry. Examples toward the fabrication of 2D Kagome lattices reported previously have in common that the precursor molecules were typically deposited on the surface structurally intact with no chemical reactions accompanied. Herein, by using a combination of synchrotron radiation photoelectron spectroscopy (SRPES) and scanning tunneling microscopy (STM), we demonstrated the fabrication of two types of chiral Kagome lattices from on-surface synthesized organometallic compounds, which are known as intermediates of Glaser coupling on silver single crystal surfaces. These Kagome lattices are stabilized by the interplay of various intermolecular interactions, including Br⋅⋅⋅Br bonds, C-Br⋅⋅⋅π bonds and π-π stacking. The chiral transference and host-guest supramolecular structure in the novel Kagome lattices were also studied. Our studies may pave a new way to engineer complex supramolecular networks through on-surface reactions.

Two side chains, three supramolecules: exploration of fluorenone derivatives towards crystal engineering

Structural diversity obtained through two-dimensional molecular self-assembly induced by the chain length effect has gained immense attention, not only because of its significance in crystal engineering but also for its potential application in nanoscience and nanotechnology. Three kinds of fluorenone derivative, named F-C₇C₇, F-C₁₄C₇, and F-C₁₄C₁₄, were synthesized and used for systematic exploration of their crystalline difference. At first, scanning electron microscopy and X-ray powder diffraction were performed to investigate their differences in morphology and three-dimensional crystal structure. Then scanning tunneling microscopy experiments were conducted to compare the self-assembled monolayers. Moreover, different solvents were used to repeatedly investigate the occurrence of structural diversity. F-C₇C₇ could not self-assemble into a stable monolayer on the graphite surface under ambient conditions due to its weak molecule-substrate interaction. F-C₁₄C₇ was observed to self-assemble into twist, plier-like, octamer-curve, and random structures in 1-octanoic acid, 1-phenyloctane, n-tetradecane, and dichloromethane, respectively. However, when the same solvents were used and at similar concentrations, the F-C₁₄C₁₄ molecules were arranged into interval, mixed, linear, and plier-like configurations. These self-assembled nanopatterns formed under the driving forces of dipole-dipole interactions, hydrogen bonds, and chain-chain, molecule-substrate, and molecule-solvent van der Waals interactions. Furthermore, from the viewpoint of thermal analysis, differential scanning calorimetry, as well as polarized optical microscopy, was performed to further elucidate the difference between these three compounds in the solid and liquid crystal states. The present system is believed to provide understanding of how the chain length effect induces different crystalline properties, and to open up the possibility of fabricating diverse self-assembled networks for crystal engineering.

Host-Guest Chemistry in Integrated Porous Space Formed by Molecular Self-Assembly at Liquid-Solid Interfaces

Host-guest chemistry in two-dimensional (2D) space, that is, physisorbed monolayers of a single atom or a single molecular thickness on surfaces, has become a subject of intense current interest because of perspectives for various applications in molecular-scale electronics, selective sensors, and tailored catalysis. Scanning tunneling microscopy has been used as a powerful tool for the visualization of molecules in real space on a conducting substrate surface. For more than a decade, we have been investigating the self-assembly of a series of triangle-shaped phenylene-ethynylene macrocycles called dehydrobenzo[12]annulenes (DBAs). These molecules are substituted with six alkyl chains and are capable of forming hexagonal porous 2D molecular networks via van der Waals interactions between interdigitated alkyl chains at the interface of organic solvents and graphite. The dimension of the nanoporous space or nanowell formed by the self-assembly of DBAs can be controlled from 1.6 to 4.7 nm by simply changing the alkyl chain length from C₆ to C₂₀. Single molecules as well as homoclusters and heteroclusters are capable of coadsorbing within the host matrix using shape- and size-complementarity principles. Moreover, on the basis of the versatility of the DBA molecules that allows chemical modification of the alkyl chain terminals, we were able to decorate the interior space of the nanoporous networks with functional groups such as azobenzenedicarboxylic acid for photoresponsive guest adsorption/desorption or fluoroalkanes and tetraethylene glycol groups for selective guest binding by electrostatic interactions and zinc-porphyrin units for complexation with a guest by charge-transfer interactions. In this Feature Article, we describe the general aspects of molecular self-assembly at liquid/solid interfaces, followed by the formation of programmed porous molecular networks using rationally designed molecular building blocks. We focus on our own work involving host-guest chemistry in integrated nanoporous space that is modified for specific purposes.

Supramolecular Spangling, Crocheting, and Knitting of Functionalized Pyrene Molecules on a Silver Surface

Pyrenes, as photoactive polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), represent promising modules for the bottom-up assembly of functional nanostructures. Here, we introduce the synthesis of a family of pyrene derivatives peripherally functionalized with pyridin-4-ylethynyl termini and comprehensively characterize their self-assembly abilities on a smooth Ag(111) support by scanning tunneling microscopy. By deliberate selection of number and geometric positioning of the pyridyl-terminated substituents, two-dimensional arrays, one-dimensional coordination chains, and chiral, porous kagomé-type networks can be tailored. A comparison to phenyl-functionalized reference pyrenes, not supporting the self-assembly of ordered structures at low coverage, highlights the role of the pyridyl moieties for supramolecular crocheting and knitting. Furthermore, we demonstrate the selective spangling of pores in the two-dimensional pyrene assemblies by a distinct number of iodine atoms as guests by atomically resolved imaging and complementary X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy.

Potential Interference of Protein-Protein Interactions by Graphyne

Graphyne has attracted tremendous attention recently due to its many potentially superior properties relative to those of graphene. Although extensive efforts have been devoted to explore the applicability of graphyne as an alternative nanomaterial for state-of-the-art nanotechnology (including biomedical applications), knowledge regarding its possible adverse effects to biological cells is still lacking. Here, using large-scale all-atom molecular dynamics simulations, we investigate the potential toxicity of graphyne by interfering a protein-protein interaction (ppI). We found that graphyne could indeed disrupt the ppIs by cutting through the protein-protein interface and separating the protein complex into noncontacting ones, due to graphyne's dispersive and hydrophobic interaction with the hydrophobic residues residing at the dimer interface. Our results help to elucidate the mechanism of interaction between graphyne and ppI networks within a biological cell and provide insights for its hazard reduction.

Self-assembly of Natural and Unnatural Nucleobases at Surfaces and Interfaces

The self-assembly of small organic molecules interacting via non-covalent forces is a viable approach towards the construction of highly ordered nanostructured materials. Among various molecular components, natural and unnatural nucleobases can undergo non-covalent self-association to form supramolecular architectures with ad hoc structural motifs. Such structures, when decorated with appropriate electrically/optically active units, can be used as scaffolds to locate such units in pre-determined positions in 2D on a surface, thereby paving the way towards a wide range of applications, e.g., in optoelectronics. This review discusses some of the basic concepts of the supramolecular engineering of natural and unnatural nucleobases and derivatives thereof as well as self-assembly processes on conductive solid substrates, as investigated by scanning tunnelling microscopy in ultra-high vacuum and at the solid/liquid interface. By unravelling the structure and dynamics of these self-assembled architectures with a sub-nanometer resolution, a greater control over the formation of increasingly sophisticated functional systems is achieved. The ability to understand and predict how nucleobases interact, both among themselves as well as with other molecules, is extremely important, since it provides access to ever more complex DNA- and RNA-based nanostructures and nanomaterials as key components in nanomechanical devices.

On-Surface Observation of the Formation of Organometallic Complex in a Supramolecular Network

The on-surface formation of organometallic monomers or oligomers, especially in supramolecular network, attracts an extensive interest for chemists and material scientist. In this work, we have investigated metal coordination between zinc (II) phthalocyanine (ZnPc) and 1, 3-di (4-pyridyl) propane (dipy-pra) in the 2, 6, 11-tricarboxydecyloxy-3, 7, 10-triundecyloxy triphenylene (asym-TTT) supramolecular template by means of scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) on highly oriented pyrolytic graphite (HOPG) substrate under ambient conditions. The experimental results demonstrate that every two ZnPc molecules in one nano-reactor connect with each other through one dipy-pra molecule by metal-coordination interaction. In this coordinating process, the template of asym-TTT supramolecular networks plays a significant role.

Polymorphism in porphyrin monolayers: the relation between adsorption configuration and molecular conformation

Self-assembled monolayers of meso-5,10,15,20-tetrakis(undecyl)porphyrin copper(II) on a graphite/1-octanoic acid interface have been studied by Scanning Tunnelling Microscopy. Four distinct polymorphs were observed, varying in their unit cell size. Arrays of unit cells of the various polymorphs seamlessly connect to each other via shared unit cell vectors. The monolayers are not commensurate, but coincident with the underlying graphite substrate. The seamless transition between the polymorphs is proposed to be the result of an adaptation of the molecular conformations in the polymorphs and at the boundaries, which is enabled by the conformational freedom of the alkyl tails of these molecules.

Kagome-like lattice of π–π stacked 3-hydroxyphenalenone on Cu(111)

Three-dimensional arrangement of 3-HPLN on a 2D surface, involving π–π stacking and perpendicular molecule attachment, results in a Kagome lattice.

One plus two: supramolecular coordination in a nano-reactor on surface

The supramolecular coordination of zinc (II) phthalocyanine (Zn-Pc) with V-shaped bi-pyridine in a nano-reactor is probed by scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) at liquid/solid interface. Combined with density functional theory (DFT) calculations, our STM results show that the V-shaped bi-pyridine and Zn-Pc can generate stable “odd-even” patterned architectures in the TCDB network through a two-step coordination process. Moreover, great changes for the size and the shape of the host cavity have happened during the coordination process. In general, the whole coordination process is regulated by the synergies of ligand and template. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first work on imaging of supramolecular coordination in a nano-reactor. Such a template-regulated supramolecular interconversion opens a new avenue towards the crystal engineering and design as well as the generation of controllable nano-patterns.

Role of substrate in directing the self-assembly of multicomponent supramolecular networks at the liquid-solid interface

The self-assembly of multicomponent networks at the liquid-solid interface between Au(111) or highly oriented pyrolytic graphite (HOPG) and organic solvents was investigated using scanning tunneling microscopy. Alkoxylated dehydrobenzo[12]annulene (DBA) derivatives form hexagonal nanoporous networks, which trap either single molecules of coronene (COR) or small clusters of COR and isophthalic acid to form multicomponent networks. The pattern of interdigitation between alkyl chains from DBA molecules produces hexagonal pores that are either chiral or achiral. On Au(111) substrates multicomponent networks display an ordered superlattice arrangement of chiral and achiral pores. In comparison, similar networks on HOPG display only chiral pores. The unique superlattice structure observed on Au(111) is related to a lower energetic preference for chiral pores than on HOPG and increased diffusion barriers for guest molecules. The increased diffusion barriers for guests allow them to act as nucleation sites for the formation of achiral pores. Following the initial nucleation of an achiral pore, restrictions imposed by the accommodation of guests within the porous network mean that subsequent growth naturally leads to the formation of the superlattice structure.

Heat-to-connect: surface commensurability directs organometallic one-dimensional self-assembly

Recent experiments demonstrated the assembly of unfunctionalized porphyrin molecules into organometallic wires on the Cu(110) surface through the formation of stable C-Cu-C bonds involving Cu adatoms. The remarkable property of the observed structures is that they adopt a clear direction, despite the lack of functional ligands to direct the assembly. Here we use density functional theory calculations and scanning tunneling microscopy to clarify the mechanism for the highly one-dimensional assembly of the observed nanostructures. An energetic preference for the formation of C-Cu-C bonds is found in several lattice directions, but self-assembly critically relies on the commensurability of appropriate adsorption sites for the Cu atoms involved in the coupling. The experimentally observed structures arise from a geometric self-limitation of the assembly process, which proceeds in the energetically and geometrically most preferred direction. A further extension of the structure in the orthogonal dimension to form 2D assemblies is prevented by the lattice mismatch between the repeat lengths in the <linear span>001<linear span> and <linear span>110<linear span> directions of the underlying (110) lattice and the apparent rigidity of the molecules involved. However, the fusing of two parallel chains is geometrically allowed and leads to some of the energetically most favorable configurations. Finally, the role of van der Waals forces is investigated for the covalent couplings and chemisorbed interactions found in this system.

Heterogeneous bilayer molecular structure at a liquid-solid interface

Hexaphenylbenzene (HPB) derivatives, HPB-6a and HPB-6pa, can form a supramolecular network which is stabilized by the intermolecular hydrogen bonding between carboxyl group at an octanoic acid/graphite interface. The observation of the heterogeneous bilayer structure formed exclusively by coronene and HPB-6pa at the octanoic acid/graphite interface is reported. Pronounced selectivity of coronene for the supramolecular networks with different sizes is reflected through the formation of bilayer structure for HPB-6pa network with the introduction of coronene as the guest species, indicating stronger interactions between HPB-6pa and coronene.

Mixing behavior of alkoxylated dehydrobenzo [12]annulenes at the solid-liquid interface: scanning tunneling microscopy and Monte Carlo simulations

We present a systematic scanning tunneling microscopic study on the mixing behavior of molecules (DBAs) with different alkyl substituents at the solid-liquid interface to reveal the phase behavior of complex systems. The phase behavior of binary mixtures of alkylated DBAs at the solid-liquid interface can be predicted by the 2D isomorphism coefficient. In addition, we also investigated the influence of coadsorption of template molecules on the phase behavior of DBA mixtures. Coadsorption of these molecules significantly promotes mixing of DBAs, possibly by affecting the recognition between alkyl chains. Monte Carlo simulations prove that the 2D isomorphism coefficient can predict the phase behavior at the interface. These results are helpful for the understanding of phase behavior of complex assembling systems and also for the design of programmable porous networks and hierarchical architectures at the solid-liquid interface.

Combined SPM investigation on the interfacial structure of a phthalocyanine/conjugated polymer composite film

The morphology of the composite film of organic semiconductors determines the properties and performances of devices to a large extent. In this work, we present a combined AFM and STM study on the interfacial structures of CuPcOC8 and CuPcOC8/PmPV composite films on graphite surface. For CuPcOC8 thin films, the face-on epitaxial growth of CuPcOC8 could persist within 3 to 5 monolayers and the formation of π-π stacked columns will occur with edge-on configuration when the film thickness further increases. For the CuPcOC8/PmPV composite film with 1:1 weight ratio, STM results reveal a preferential adsorption of PmPV on graphite surface, while AFM results indicate the phase segregation in the upper layer. STM also reveals in the molecular scale good compatibility of CuPcOC8 with PmPV.