Dynamics of Silica-Supported Catalysts Determined by Combining Solid-State NMR Spectroscopy and DFT Calculations

Comparison of methods for the NMR measurement of motionally averaged dipolar couplings

Motionally averaged dipolar couplings are an important tool for understanding the complex dynamics of catalysts, polymers, and biomolecules. While there is a plethora of solid-state NMR pulse sequences available for their measurement, in can be difficult to gauge the methods' strengths and weaknesses. In particular, there has not been a comprehensive comparison of their performance in natural abundance samples, where 1H homonuclear dipolar couplings are important and the use of large MAS rotors may be required for sensitivity reasons. In this work, we directly compared some of the more common methods for measuring C-H dipolar couplings in natural abundance samples using L-alanine (L-Ala) and the N-formyl-L-methionyl-L-leucyl-L-phenylalanine (fMLF) tripeptide as model systems. We evaluated their performance in terms of accuracy, resolution, sensitivity, and ease of implementation. We found that, despite the presence of 1H homonuclear dipolar interactions, all methods, with the exception of REDOR, were able to yield the reasonable dipolar coupling strengths for both mobile and static moieties. Of these methods, PDLF provides the most convenient workflow and precision at the expense of low sensitivity. In low-sensitivity cases, MAS-PISEMA and DIPSHIFT appear to be the better options.

The Synergy between Nuclear Magnetic Resonance and Density Functional Theory Calculations

This paper deals with the synergy between Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) spectroscopic investigations and DFT calculations, mainly of NMR parameters. Both the liquid and the solid states are discussed here. This text is a mix of published results supplemented with new findings. This paper deals with examples in which useful results could not have been obtained without combining NMR measurements and DFT calculations. Examples of such cases are tautomeric systems in which NMR data are calculated for the tautomers; hydrogen-bonded systems in which better XH bond lengths can be determined; cage compounds for which assignment cannot be made based on NMR data alone; revison of already published structures; ionic compounds for which reference data are not available; assignment of solid-state spectra and crystal forms; and the creation of libraries for biological molecules. In addition to these literature cases, a revision of a cage structure and substituent effects on pyrroles is also discussed.

1H chemical shift anisotropy: a high sensitivity solid-state NMR dynamics probe for surface studies?

Dynamics play significant roles in chemistry and biochemistry-molecular motions impact both large- and small-scale chemical reactions in addition to biochemical processes. In many systems, including heterogeneous catalysts, the characterization of dynamics remains a challenge. The most common approaches involve the solid-state NMR measurement of anisotropic interactions, in particular ²H quadrupolar coupling and ¹H-X dipolar coupling, which generally require isotope enrichment. Due to the high sensitivity of ¹H NMR, ¹H chemical shift anisotropy (CSA) is a particularly enticing, and underexplored, dynamics probe. We carried out ¹H CSA and ¹H-¹³C dipolar coupling measurements in a series of model supported complexes to understand how ¹H CSA can be leveraged to gain dynamic information for heterogeneous catalysts. Mathematical descriptions are given for the dynamic averaging of the CSA tensor, and its dependence on orientation and asymmetry. The variability of the orientation of the tensor in the molecular frame, in addition to its magnitude and asymmetry, negatively impacts attempts to extract quantitative dynamic information. Nevertheless, ¹H CSA measurements can reveal useful qualitative insights into the motions of a particularly dilute site, such as from a surface species.

Evidence for πCHR→dM bonding in transition metal carbene compounds (LnMCHR) and its decisive role in the α-agostic effect

It has been generally recognized that the α-agostic interaction (M⋯H-C) in transition metal carbene compounds L_nMCHR (R = H, Me etc.) can be interpreted with a double metal-carbon bonding model. This bonding model involves the reorganization of the σ component, which can be illustrated in terms of three-center two-electron (3c-2e) M-H-C covalent bond as in transition metal alkyl compounds. Herein, we propose an alternative partial triple metal-carbon bonding model to elucidate the agostic interaction in L_nMCHR. Apart from the well-defined σ and π bonds, there exists a seemingly weak but decisive third force, namely the π_CHR→d_M bonding between an occupied π-like symmetric CHR orbital and a vacant metal d orbital, which is the true origin of the α-agostic effect. This partial triple bonding model is authenticated on both Fischer- and Schrock-type carbenes by an ab initio valence bond (VB) method or the block-localized wavefunction (BLW) method, which has the capability to quantify this notable π bonding and further demonstrate its geometric, energetic and spectral impacts on agostic transition metal carbene compounds. We also show that ancillary ligands can modulate the π_CHR→d_M bonding through electronic and steric effects.

Classifying and Understanding the Reactivities of Mo-Based Alkyne Metathesis Catalysts from 95Mo NMR Chemical Shift Descriptors

The most active alkyne metathesis catalysts rely on well-defined Mo alkylidynes, X₃Mo≡CR (X = OR), in particular the recently developed canopy catalyst family bearing silanolate ligand sets. Recent efforts to understand catalyst reactivity patterns have shown that NMR chemical shifts are powerful descriptors, though previous studies have mostly focused on ligand-based NMR descriptors. Here, we show in the context of alkyne metathesis that ⁹⁵Mo chemical shift tensors encode detailed information on the electronic structure of these catalysts. Analysis by first-principles calculations of ⁹⁵Mo chemical shift tensors extracted from solid-state ⁹⁵Mo NMR spectra shows a direct link of chemical shift values with the energies of the HOMO and LUMO, two molecular orbitals involved in the key [2 + 2]-cycloaddition step, thus linking ⁹⁵Mo chemical shifts to reactivity. In particular, the ⁹⁵Mo chemical shifts are driven by ligand electronegativity (σ-donation) and electron delocalization through Mo-O π interactions, thus explaining the reactivity patterns of the silanolate canopy catalysts. These results further motivate exploration of transition metal NMR signatures and their relationships to electronic structure and reactivity.

Alkane C-H activation and ligand exchange on silica supported d0 metal alkylidenes: relevance to alkane metathesis

In this work, we study the ligand exchange process between an alkane and a series of silica supported metal alkylidenes, which may occur by different pathways: C-H addition, σ-bond metathesis, and α-H abstraction. The results indicate that the α-H abstraction pathway is the preferred one, regardless of the catalyst and ligands. This is in contrast to the expected preference for the C-H addition route. When looking for the origin of this preference, our calculations revealed that the α-H abstraction pathway is driven by entropy, which favors the initial dissociation of the alkyl ligand from the catalyst.

Double echo symmetry-based REDOR and RESPDOR pulse sequences for proton detected measurements of heteronuclear dipolar coupling constants

¹H{X} symmetry-based rotational echo double resonance pulse sequences (S-REDOR) and symmetry-based rotational echo saturation pulse double resonance (S-RESPDOR) solid-state NMR experiments have found widespread application for ¹H detected measurements of difference NMR spectra, dipolar coupling constants, and internuclear distances under conditions of fast magic angle spinning (MAS). In these experiments the supercycled R4₁² (SR4₁²) symmetry-based recoupling pulse sequence is typically applied to the ¹H spins to reintroduce heteronuclear dipolar couplings. However, the timing of SR4₁² and other symmetry-based pulse sequences must be precisely synchronized with the rotation of the sample, otherwise, the evolution of ¹H CSA and other interactions will not be properly refocused. For this reason, significant distortions are often observed in experimental dipolar dephasing difference curves obtained with S-REDOR or S-RESPDOR pulse sequences. Here we introduce a family of double echo (DE) S-REDOR/S-RESPDOR pulse sequences that function in an analogous manner to the recently introduced t₁-noise eliminated (TONE) family of dipolar heteronuclear multiple quantum coherence (D-HMQC) pulse sequences. Through numerical simulations and experiments the DE S-REDOR/S-RESPDOR sequences are shown to provide dephasing difference curves similar to those obtained with S-REDOR/S-RESPDOR. However, the DE sequences are more robust to the deviations of the MAS frequency from the ideal value that occurs during typical solid-state NMR experiments. The DE sequences are shown to provide more reliable ¹H detected dipolar dephasing difference curves for nuclei such as ¹⁵N (with isotopic labelling), ¹⁸³W and ³⁵Cl. The double echo sequences are therefore recommended to be used in place of conventional S-REDOR/S-RESPDOR sequences for measurement of weak dipolar coupling constants and long-range distances.

Solid-state NMR studies of non-ionic surfactants confined in mesoporous silica

This review gives an overview of current trends in the investigation of confined molecules such as higher alcohols, ethylene glycol and polyethylene glycol as guest molecules in neat and functionalized mesoporous silica materials. All these molecules have both hydrophobic and hydrophilic parts. They are characteristic role-models for the investigation of confined surfactants. Their properties are studied by a combination of solid-state NMR and relaxometry with other physicochemical techniques and molecular dynamics techniques. It is shown that this combination delivers unique insights into the structure, arrangement, dynamical properties and the guest-host interactions inside the confinement.

Phase-sensitive γ-encoded recoupling of heteronuclear dipolar interactions and 1H chemical shift anisotropy

γ-encoded recoupling sequences are known to produce strong amplitude modulations that lead to sharp doublets when Fourier transformed. These doublets depend very little on the recoupled tensor asymmetry and thus enable for the straightforward determination of dynamic order parameters. It can, however, be difficult to measure small anisotropies, or small order parameters, using such sequences; the resonances from the doublet may overlap with each other, or with the zero-frequency glitch. This limitation has prevented the widespread use of ¹H chemical shift anisotropy (CSA) for the measurement of dynamics, particularly for CH protons which typically have CSAs of only a few ppm when immobile. Here, we introduce a simple modification to the traditional ¹H CSA and proton-detected local field pulse sequences that enables the acquisition of a hypercomplex dataset and the removal of the uncorrelated magnetization that results in the zero-frequency glitch. These new sequences then yield a frequency shift in the indirect dimension, rather than a splitting, which is easily identifiable even in cases of weak interactions.

Probing β-alkyl elimination and selectivity in polyolefin hydrogenolysis through DFT

A long chain substrate with [(SiO)3ZrH] has been investigated to elucidate selectivity rules in β-alkyl elimination. DFT studies indicate that polypropylene preferentially undergoes β-Me elimination.

Observing the three-dimensional dynamics of supported metal complexes

The dynamics of heterogeneous catalysts are linked to their activity and selectivity but are poorly understood. NMR enables for the determination of high-resolution dynamic structures for such sites and the mapping of accessible conformations.

Small Molecules, Non-Covalent Interactions, and Confinement

This review gives an overview of current trends in the investigation of small guest molecules, confined in neat and functionalized mesoporous silica materials by a combination of solid-state NMR and relaxometry with other physico-chemical techniques. The reported guest molecules are water, small alcohols, and carbonic acids, small aromatic and heteroaromatic molecules, ionic liquids, and surfactants. They are taken as characteristic role-models, which are representatives for the typical classes of organic molecules. It is shown that this combination delivers unique insights into the structure, arrangement, dynamics, guest-host interactions, and the binding sites in these confined systems, and is probably the most powerful analytical technique to probe these systems.

Molecular-level insight in supported olefin metathesis catalysts by combining surface organometallic chemistry, high throughput experimentation, and data analysis

A combination of high-throughput experimentation (HTE), surface organometallic chemistry (SOMC) and statistical data analysis provided the platform to analyze in situ silica-grafted Mo imido alkylidene catalysts based on a library of 35 phenols. Overall, these tools allowed for the identification of σ-donor electronic effects and dispersive interactions and as key drivers in a prototypical metathesis reaction, homodimerization of 1-nonene. Univariate and multivariate correlation analysis confirmed the categorization of the catalytic data into two groups, depending on the presence of aryl groups in ortho position of the phenol ligand. The initial activity (TOFin) was predominantly correlated to the σ-donor ability of the aryloxy ligands, while the overall catalytic performance (TON1 h) was mainly dependent on attractive dispersive interactions with the used phenol ligands featuring aryl ortho substituents and, in sharp contrast, repulsive dispersive interactions with phenol free of aryl ortho substituents. This work outlines a fast and efficient workflow of gaining molecular-level insight into supported metathesis catalysts and highlights σ-donor ability and noncovalent interactions as crucial properties for designing active d0 supported metathesis catalysts.

"Canopy Catalysts" for Alkyne Metathesis: Molybdenum Alkylidyne Complexes with a Tripodal Ligand Framework

A new family of structurally well-defined molybdenum alkylidyne catalysts for alkyne metathesis, which is distinguished by a tripodal trisilanolate ligand architecture, is presented. Complexes of type 1 combine the virtues of previous generations of silanolate-based catalysts with a significantly improved functional group tolerance. They are easy to prepare on scale; the modularity of the ligand synthesis allows the steric and electronic properties to be fine-tuned and hence the application profile of the catalysts to be optimized. This opportunity is manifested in the development of catalyst 1f, which is as reactive as the best ancestors but exhibits an unrivaled scope. The new catalysts work well in the presence of unprotected alcohols and various other protic groups. The chelate effect entails even a certain stability toward water, which marks a big leap forward in metal alkylidyne chemistry in general. At the same time, they tolerate many donor sites, including basic nitrogen and numerous heterocycles. This aspect is substantiated by applications to polyfunctional (natural) products. A combined spectroscopic, crystallographic, and computational study provides insights into structure and electronic character of complexes of type 1. Particularly informative are a density functional theory (DFT)-based chemical shift tensor analysis of the alkylidyne carbon atom and ⁹⁵Mo NMR spectroscopy; this analytical tool had been rarely used in organometallic chemistry before but turns out to be a sensitive probe that deserves more attention. The data show that the podand ligands render a Mo-alkylidyne a priori more electrophilic than analogous monodentate triarylsilanols; proper ligand tuning, however, allows the Lewis acidity as well as the steric demand about the central atom to be adjusted to the point that excellent performance of the catalyst is ensured.

The effects of active site and support on hydrogen elimination over transition-metal-functionalized yttria-decorated metal–organic frameworks

Transition-metal catalysts supported on a metal–organic framework have been screened computationally to reveal the best catalytic candidates for hydrogen elimination reactions, which are critical in many catalytic cycles.

Modelling the surface of amorphous dehydroxylated silica: the influence of the potential on the nature and density of defects

The nature and density of defects on the amorphous dehydroxylated silica surface are studied by molecular dynamics for information on the silanol groups of pretreated silica.

Surface organometallic chemistry in heterogeneous catalysis

Surface organometallic chemistry has been reviewed with a special focus on environmentally relevant transformations (C–H activation, CO₂conversion, oxidation).

Dialing in single-site reactivity of a supported calixarene-protected tetrairidium cluster catalyst

A closed Ir₄ carbonyl cluster, 1, comprising a tetrahedral metal frame and three sterically bulky tert-butyl-calix[4]arene(OPr)₃(OCH₂PPh₂) (Ph = phenyl; Pr = propyl) ligands at the basal plane, was characterized with variable-temperature ¹³C NMR spectroscopy, which show the absence of scrambling of the CO ligands at temperatures up to 313 K. This demonstration of distinct sites for the CO ligands was found to extend to the reactivity and catalytic properties, as shown by selective decarbonylation in a reaction with trimethylamine N-oxide (TMAO) as an oxidant, which, reacting in the presence of ethylene, leads to the selective bonding of an ethyl ligand at the apical Ir site. These clusters were supported intact on porous silica and found to catalyze ethylene hydrogenation, and a comparison of the kinetics of the single-hydrogenation reaction and steady-state hydrogenation catalysis demonstrates a unique single-site catalyst-with each site having the same catalytic activity. Reaction orders in the catalytic ethylene hydrogenation reaction of approximately 1/2 and 0 for H₂ and C₂H₄, respectively, nearly match those for conventional noble-metal catalysts. In contrast to oxidative decarbonylation, thermal desorption of CO from silica-supported cluster 1 occurred exclusively at the basal plane, giving rise to sites that do not react with ethylene and are catalytically inactive for ethylene hydrogenation. The evidence of distinctive sites on the cluster catalyst leads to a model that links to hydrogen-transfer catalysis on metals-involving some surface sites that bond to both hydrocarbon and hydrogen and are catalytically engaged (so-called "*" sites) and others, at the basal plane, which bond hydrogen and CO but not hydrocarbon and are reservoir sites (so-called "S" sites).

Dendritic polarizing agents for DNP SENS

Dendrimer-shielded polarizing agents for the application of DNP SENS to reactive surfaces.

Dynamic Nuclear Polarization Surface Enhanced NMR Spectroscopy (DNP SENS) is an effective method to significantly improve solid-state NMR investigation of solid surfaces. The presence of unpaired electrons (polarizing agents) is crucial for DNP, but it has drawbacks such as leading to faster nuclear spin relaxation, or even reaction with the substrate under investigation. The latter can be a particular problem for heterogeneous catalysts. Here, we present a series of carbosilane-based dendritic polarizing agents, in which the bulky dendrimer can reduce the interaction between the solid surface and the free radical. We thereby preserve long nuclear T′₂ of the surface species, and even successfully enhance a reactive heterogeneous metathesis catalyst.

Alkyne Metathesis with Silica-Supported and Molecular Catalysts at Parts-per-Million Loadings

Improvement of the activity, stability, and chemoselectivity of alkyne-metathesis catalysts is necessary before this promising methodology can become a routine method to construct C≡C triple bonds. Herein, we show that grafting of the known molecular catalyst [MesC≡Mo(OtBu_F6 )₃ ] (1, Mes=2,4,6-trimethylphenyl, OtBu_F6 =hexafluoro-tert-butoxy) onto partially dehydroxylated silica gave a well-defined silica-supported active alkyne-metathesis catalyst [(≡SiO)Mo(≡CMes)(OtBu_F6 )₂ ] (1/SiO_2-700 ). Both 1 and 1/SiO_2-700 showed very high activity, selectivity, and stability in the self-metathesis of a variety of carefully purified alkynes, even at parts-per-million catalyst loadings. Remarkably, the lower turnover frequencies observed for 1/SiO_2-700 by comparison to 1 do not prevent the achievement of high turnover numbers. We attribute the lower reactivity of 1/SiO_2-700 to the rigidity of the surface Mo species owing to the strong interaction of the metal site with the silica surface.

The Nature of Secondary Interactions at Electrophilic Metal Sites of Molecular and Silica-Supported Organolutetium Complexes from Solid-State NMR Spectroscopy

Lu[CH(SiMe3)2]3 reacts with [SiO2-700] to give [(≡SiO)Lu[CH(SiMe3)2]2] and CH2(SiMe3)2. [(≡SiO)Lu[CH(SiMe3)2]2] is characterized by solid-state NMR and EXAFS spectroscopy, which show that secondary Lu···C and Lu···O interactions, involving a γ-CH3 and a siloxane bridge, are present. From X-ray crystallographic analysis, the molecular analogues Lu[CH(SiMe3)2]3-x[O-2,6-tBu-C6H3]x (x = 0-2) also have secondary Lu···C interactions. The (1)H NMR spectrum of Lu[CH(SiMe3)2]3 shows that the -SiMe3 groups are equivalent to -125 °C and inequivalent below that temperature, ΔG(⧧)(Tc = 148 K) = 7.1 kcal mol(-1). Both -SiMe3 groups in Lu[CH(SiMe3)2]3 have (1)JCH = 117 ± 1 Hz at -140 °C. The solid-state (13)C CPMAS NMR spectrum at 20 °C shows three chemically inequivalent resonances in the area ratio of 4:1:1 (12:3:3); the J-resolved spectra for each resonance give (1)JCH = 117 ± 2 Hz. The (29)Si CPMAS NMR spectrum shows two chemically inequivalent resonances with different values of chemical shift anisotropy. Similar observations are obtained for Lu[CH(SiMe3)2]3-x[O-2,6-tBu-C6H3]x (x = 1 and 2). The spectroscopic data point to short Lu···Cγ contacts corresponding to 3c-2e Lu···Cγ-Siβ interactions, which are supported by DFT calculations. Calculated natural bond orbital (NBO) charges show that Cγ carries a negative charge, while Lu, Hγ, and Siβ carry positive charges; as the number of O-based ligands increases so does the positive charge at Lu, which in turns shortens the Lu···Cγ distance. The change in NBO charges and the resulting changes in the spectroscopic and crystallographic properties show how ligands and surface-support sites rearrange to accommodate these changes, consistent with Pauling's electroneutrality concept.

Quantitatively analyzing metathesis catalyst activity and structural features in silica-supported tungsten imido-alkylidene complexes

A broad series of fully characterized, well-defined silica-supported W metathesis catalysts with the general formula [(≡SiO)W(═NAr)(═CHCMe2R)(X)] (Ar = 2,6-iPr2C6H3 (AriPr), 2,6-Cl2C6H3 (ArCl), 2-CF3C6H4 (ArCF3), and C6F5 (ArF5); X = OC(CF3)3 (OtBuF9), OCMe(CF3)2 (OtBuF6), OtBu, OSi(OtBu)3, 2,5-dimethylpyrrolyl (Me2Pyr) and R = Me or Ph) was prepared by grafting bis-X substituted complexes [W(NAr)(═CHCMe2R)(X)2] on silica partially dehydroxylated at 700 °C (SiO2-(700)), and their activity was evaluated with the goal to obtain detailed structure-activity relationships. Quantitative influence of the ligand set on the activity (turnover frequency, TOF) in self-metathesis of cis-4-nonene was investigated using multivariate linear regression analysis tools. The TOF of these catalysts (activity) can be well predicted from simple steric and electronic parameters of the parent protonated ligands; it is described by the mutual contribution of the NBO charge of the nitrogen or the IR intensity of the symmetric N-H stretch of the ArNH2, corresponding to the imido ligand, together with the Sterimol B5 and pKa of HX, representing the X ligand. This quantitative and predictive structure-activity relationship analysis of well-defined heterogeneous catalysts shows that high activity is associated with the combination of X and NAr ligands of opposite electronic character and paves the way toward rational development of metathesis catalysts.

Grafting of lanthanide complexes on silica surfaces dehydroxylated at 200 °C: a theoretical investigation

The grafting reaction of lanthanide silylamide complexes has been studied, in the framework of the DFT, highlighting the different grafting modes on a silica surface dehydroxylated at 200 °C.