Elliptical structure of phospholipid bilayer nanodiscs encapsulated by scaffold proteins: casting the roles of the lipids and the protein

Small angle scattering reveals the orientation of cytochrome P450 19A1 in lipoprotein nanodiscs

Human aromatase (CYP19A1), the cytochrome P450 enzyme responsible for conversion of androgens to estrogens, was incorporated into lipoprotein nanodiscs (NDs) and interrogated by small angle X-ray and neutron scattering (SAXS/SANS). CYP19A1 was associated with the surface and centered at the edge of the long axis of the ND membrane. In the absence of the N-terminal anchor, the amphipathic A'- and G'-helices were predominately buried in the lipid head groups, with the possibly that their hydrophobic side chains protrude into the hydrophobic, aliphatic tails. The prediction is like that for CYP3A4 based on SAXS employing a similar modeling approach. The orientation of CYP19A1 in a ND is consistent with our previous predictions based on molecular dynamics simulations and lends additional credibility to the notion that CYP19A1 captures substrates from the membrane.

The structure, self-assembly and dynamics of lipid nanodiscs revealed by computational approaches

Nanodisc technology is increasingly being used in structural, biochemical and biophysical studies of membrane proteins. The computational approaches have revealed many important features of nanodisc assembly, structures and dynamics. Therefore, we reviewed the application of computational approaches, especially molecular modeling and molecular dyncamics (MD) simulations, to characterize nanodiscs, including the structural models, assembly and disassembly, protocols for modeling, structural properties and dynamics, and protein-lipid interactions in nanodiscs. More amazing computational studies about nanodiscs are looked forward to in the future.

Lipid exchange of apolipoprotein A-I amyloidogenic variants in reconstituted high-density lipoprotein with artificial membranes

High-density lipoproteins (HDLs) are responsible for removing cholesterol from arterial walls, through a process known as reverse cholesterol transport. The main protein in HDL, apolipoprotein A-I (ApoA-I), is essential to this process, and changes in its sequence significantly alter HDL structure and functions. ApoA-I amyloidogenic variants, associated with a particular hereditary degenerative disease, are particularly effective at facilitating cholesterol removal, thus protecting carriers from cardiovascular disease. Thus, it is conceivable that reconstituted HDL (rHDL) formulations containing ApoA-I proteins with functional/structural features similar to those of amyloidogenic variants hold potential as a promising therapeutic approach. Here we explored the effect of protein cargo and lipid composition on the function of rHDL containing one of the ApoA-I amyloidogenic variants G26R or L174S by Fourier transformed infrared spectroscopy and neutron reflectometry. Moreover, small-angle x-ray scattering uncovered the structural and functional differences between rHDL particles, which could help to comprehend higher cholesterol efflux activity and apparent lower phospholipid (PL) affinity. Our findings indicate distinct trends in lipid exchange (removal vs. deposition) capacities of various rHDL particles, with the rHDL containing the ApoA-I amyloidogenic variants showing a markedly lower ability to remove lipids from artificial membranes compared to the rHDL containing the native protein. This effect strongly depends on the level of PL unsaturation and on the particles' ultrastructure. The study highlights the importance of the protein cargo, along with lipid composition, in shaping rHDL structure, contributing to our understanding of lipid-protein interactions and their behavior.

Structural characterisation of α-synuclein-membrane interactions and the resulting aggregation using small angle scattering

The presence of amyloid fibrils is a hallmark of several neurodegenerative diseases. Some amyloidogenic proteins, such as α-synuclein and amyloid β, interact with lipids, and this interaction can strongly favour the formation of amyloid fibrils. In particular the primary nucleation step, i.e. the de novo formation of amyloid fibrils, has been shown to be accelerated by lipids. However, the exact mechanism of this acceleration is still mostly unclear. Here we use a range of scattering methods, such as dynamic light scattering (DLS) and small angle X-ray and neutron scattering (SAXS and SANS) to obtain structural information on the binding of α-synuclein to model membranes formed from negatively charged lipids and their co-assembly into amyloid fibrils. We find that the model membranes take an active role in the reaction. The binding of α synuclein to the model membranes immediately induces a major structural change in the lipid assembly, which leads to a break-up into small and mostly disc- or rod-like lipid-protein particles. This transition can be reversed by temperature changes or proteolytic protein removal. Incubation of the small lipid-α-synuclein particles for several hours, however, leads to amyloid fibril formation, whereby the lipids are incorporated into the amyloid fibrils.

Membrane interaction and selectivity of novel alternating cationic lipid-nanodisc assembling polymers

Synthetic polymer nanodiscs are self-assembled structures formed from amphipathic copolymers encapsulating membrane proteins and surrounding phospholipids into water soluble discs. These nanostructures have served as an analytical tool for the detergent free solubilisation and structural study of membrane proteins (MPs) in their native lipid environment. We established the polymer-lipid nanodisc forming ability of a novel class of amphipathic copolymer comprised of an alternating sequence of N-alkyl functionalised maleimide (AlkylM) of systematically varied hydrocarbon chain length, and cationic N-methyl-4-vinyl pyridinium iodide (MVP). Using a combination of physicochemical techniques, the solubilisation efficiency, size, structure and shape of DMPC lipid containing poly(MVP-co-AlkylM) nanodiscs were determined. Lipid solubilisation increased with AlkylM hydrocarbon chain length from methyl (MM), ethyl (EtM), n-propyl (PM), iso-butyl (IBM) through to n-butyl (BM) maleimide bearing polymers. More hydrophobic derivatives formed smaller sized nanodiscs and lipid ordering within poly(MVP-co-AlkylM) nanodiscs was affected by nanodisc size. In dye-release assays, shorter N-alkyl substituted polymers, particularly poly(MVP-co-EtM), exhibited low activities against eukaryotic mimetic POPC membrane and increased their liposome disruption as POPC : POPG membrane mixtures increased in their anionic POPG component, resembling the charge profile of bacterial membranes. These trends in membrane selectivity were transferred towards native cell systems in which gram-positive Staphylococcus aureus and gram-negative Acenobacter baumannii bacterial strains were relatively susceptible to disruption by hydrophobic n-butyl- and n-propyl-poly(MVP-co-AlkylM) derivatives compared to human red blood cells (HRBCs), with a more pronounced selectivity resulting from poly(MVP-co-PM). Such selective membrane interaction by less hydrophobic polymers provides a framework for polymer design towards applications including selective membrane component solubilisation, biosensing and antimicrobial development.

Modeling of flexible membrane-bound biomolecular complexes for solution small-angle scattering

Recent advances in protein expression protocols, sample handling, and experimental set up of small-angle scattering experiments have allowed users of the technique to structurally investigate biomolecules of growing complexity and structural disorder. Notable examples include intrinsically disordered proteins, multi-domain proteins and membrane proteins in suitable carrier systems. Here, we outline a modeling scheme for calculating the scattering profiles from such complex samples. This kind of modeling is necessary for structural information to be refined from the corresponding data. The scheme bases itself on a hybrid of classical form factor based modeling and the well-known spherical harmonics-based formulation of small-angle scattering amplitudes. Our framework can account for flexible domains alongside other structurally elaborate components of the molecular system in question. We demonstrate the utility of this modeling scheme through a recent example of a structural model of the growth hormone receptor membrane protein in a phospholipid bilayer nanodisc which is refined against experimental SAXS data. Additionally we investigate how the scattering profiles from the complex would appear under different scattering contrasts. For each contrast situation we discuss what structural information is contained and the related consequences for modeling of the data.

Effect of Cholesterol on the Structure and Composition of Glyco-DIBMA Lipid Particles

Different amphiphilic co-polymers have been introduced to produce polymer-lipid particles with nanodisc structure composed of an inner lipid bilayer and polymer chains self-assembled as an outer belt. These particles can be used to stabilize membrane proteins in solution and enable their characterization by means of biophysical methods, including small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS). Some of these co-polymers have also been used to directly extract membrane proteins together with their associated lipids from native membranes. Styrene/maleic acid and diisobutylene/maleic acid are among the most commonly used co-polymers for producing polymer-lipid particles, named SMALPs and DIBMALPs, respectively. Recently, a new co-polymer, named Glyco-DIBMA, was produced by partial amidation of DIBMA with the amino sugar N-methyl-d-glucosamine. Polymer-lipid particles produced with Glyco-DIBMA, named Glyco-DIBMALPs, exhibit improved structural properties and stability compared to those of SMALPs and DIBMALPs while retaining the capability of directly extracting membrane proteins from native membranes. Here, we characterize the structure and lipid composition of Glyco-DIBMALPs produced with either 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (POPC) or 1,2-dimyristoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DMPC). Glyco-DIBMALPs were also prepared with mixtures of either POPC or DMPC and cholesterol at different mole fractions. We estimated the lipid content in the Glyco-DIBMALPs and determined the particle structure and morphology by SAXS. We show that the Glyco-DIBMALPs are nanodisc-like particles whose size and shape depend on the polymer/lipid ratio. This is relevant for designing nanodisc particles with a tunable diameter according to the size of the membrane protein to be incorporated. We also report that the addition of >20 mol % cholesterol strongly perturbed the formation of Glyco-DIBMALPs. Altogether, we describe a detailed characterization of the Glyco-DIBMALPs, which provides relevant inputs for future application of these particles in the biophysical investigation of membrane proteins.

Structural Insights into Polymer-Bounded Lipid Nanodiscs

Membrane proteins are an essential part of signaling and transport processes and are targeted by multiple drugs. To isolate and investigate them in their native state, polymer-bounded nanodiscs have become valuable tools. In this study, we investigate the lipid model system dimyristoyl-phosphocholine (DMPC) with the nanodisc-forming copolymers styrene maleic acid (SMA) and diisobutylene maleic acid (DIBMA). Using small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) and dynamic light scattering (DLS), we studied the influence of polymer concentration and temperature on the nanodisc structure. In Tris buffer, the size of nanodiscs formed with SMA is smaller compared to DIBMA at the same polymer ratio. In both cases, the size decreases monotonically with increasing polymer concentration, and this effect is more pronounced when using SMA. Measurements at temperatures (T) between 5 and 30 °C in phosphate buffer showed an incomplete solubilization at high T even at polymer/lipid ratios above that required for complete lipid solubilization. For DIBMA, the nanodiscs developed at lower temperatures are stable and the net repulsion increases, while for SMA, the individual nanodiscs possess smaller sizes and are less affected by T. However, using DLS, one can observe SMA agglomerates at low T. Interestingly, for both polymers, no drastic changes of the observable parameters (radius and bilayer thickness) are seen upon cooling, which would indicate a sharp (first-order) phase transition from liquid-crystalline to gel, but only gradual changes. Hence, we conclude that the transition from a gel toward a liquid-crystalline lipid phase proceeds over a broad T-range compared to a continuous lipid bilayer. These results can pave the way toward the development of better protocols for studying membrane proteins stabilized in this type of membrane mimics.

Travel light: Essential packing for membrane proteins with an active lifestyle

We review the considerable progress during the recent decade in the endeavours of designing, optimising, and utilising carrier particle systems for structural and functional studies of membrane proteins in near-native environments. New and improved systems are constantly emerging, novel studies push the perceived limits of a given carrier system, and specific carrier systems consolidate and entrench themselves as the system of choice for particular classes of target membrane protein systems. This review covers the most frequently used carrier systems for such studies and emphasises similarities and differences between these systems as well as current trends and future directions for the field. Particular interest is devoted to the biophysical properties and membrane mimicking ability of each system and the manner in which this may impact an embedded membrane protein and an eventual structural or functional study.

Cell-free synthesis and reconstitution of Bax in nanodiscs: Comparison between wild-type Bax and a constitutively active mutant

Bax is a major player in the mitochondrial pathway of apoptosis, by making the Outer Mitochondrial Membrane (OMM) permeable to various apoptogenic factors, including cytochrome c. In order to get further insight into the structure and function of Bax when it is inserted in the OMM, we attempted to reconstitute Bax in nanodiscs. Cell-free protein synthesis in the presence of nanodiscs did not yield Bax-containing nanodiscs, but it provided a simple way to purify full-length Bax without any tag. Purified wild-type Bax (BaxWT) and a constitutively active mutant (BaxP168A) displayed biochemical properties that were in line with previous characterizations following their expression in yeast and human cells followed by their reconstitution into liposomes. Both Bax variants were then reconstituted in nanodiscs. Size exclusion chromatography, dynamic light scattering and transmission electron microscopy showed that nanodiscs formed with BaxP168A were larger than nanodiscs formed with BaxWT. This was consistent with the hypothesis that BaxP168A was reconstituted in nanodiscs as an active oligomer.

Nanodisc Lipids Exhibit Singular Behaviors Implying Critical Phenomena

Nanodiscs are broadly used for characterization of membrane proteins as they are generally assumed to provide a near-native environment. In fact, it is an open question whether the physical properties of lipids in nanodiscs and membrane vesicles of the same lipid composition are identical. Here, we investigate the properties of lipids (1,2-dipalmitoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine, 1,2-dilauroyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine, and their mixtures) in two different sample types, nanodiscs and multilamellar vesicles, by means of spin-label electron spin resonance techniques. Our results provide a quantitative description of lipid dynamics and ordering, elucidating the molecular details of how lipids in the two sample types behave differently in response to temperature and lipid composition. We show that the properties of lipids are altered in nanodiscs such that the dissimilarity of the fluid and gel lipid phases is reduced, and the first-order phase transitions are largely abolished in nanodiscs. We unveil that the ensemble of lipids in the middle of a nanodisc bilayer, as probed by the end-chain spin-label 16-PC, is promoted to a state close to a miscibility critical point, thereby rendering the phase transitions continuous. Critical phenomena have recently been proposed to explain features of the heterogeneity in native cell membranes. Our results lay the groundwork for how to establish a near-native environment in nanodiscs with simple organization of lipid components.

A comparative study of interfacial environments in lipid nanodiscs and vesicles

Membrane protein conformations and dynamics are driven by the protein-lipid interactions occurring within the local environment of the membrane. These environments remain challenging to accurately capture in structural and biophysical experiments using bilayers. Consequently, there is an increasing need for realistic cell-membrane mimetics for in vitro studies. Lipid nanodiscs provide certain advantages over vesicles for membrane protein studies. Nanodiscs are increasingly used for structural and spectroscopic characterization of membrane proteins. Despite the common use of nanodiscs, the interfacial environments of lipids confined to a ~10-nm diameter area have remained relatively underexplored. Here, we use ultrafast two-dimensional infrared spectroscopy and temperature-dependent infrared absorption measurements of the ester carbonyls to compare the interfacial hydrogen bond structure and dynamics in lipid nanodiscs of varying lipid compositions and sizes with ~100-nm vesicles. We examine the effects of lipid composition and nanodisc size. We found that nanodiscs and vesicles share largely similar lipid-water H-bond environments and interfacial dynamics. Differences in measured enthalpies of H-bonding suggest that H-bond dynamics in nanodiscs are modulated by the interaction between the annular lipids and the scaffold protein.

SAXS analysis of the intrinsic tenase complex bound to a lipid nanodisc highlights intermolecular contacts between factors VIIIa/IXa

The intrinsic tenase (Xase) complex, formed by factors (f) VIIIa and fIXa, forms on activated platelet surfaces and catalyzes the activation of factor X to Xa, stimulating thrombin production in the blood coagulation cascade. The structural organization of the membrane-bound Xase complex remains largely unknown, hindering our understanding of the structural underpinnings that guide Xase complex assembly. Here, we aimed to characterize the Xase complex bound to a lipid nanodisc with biolayer interferometry (BLI), Michaelis-Menten kinetics, and small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS). Using immobilized lipid nanodiscs, we measured binding rates and nanomolar affinities for fVIIIa, fIXa, and the Xase complex. Enzyme kinetic measurements demonstrated the assembly of an active enzyme complex in the presence of lipid nanodiscs. An ab initio molecular envelope of the nanodisc-bound Xase complex allowed us to computationally model fVIIIa and fIXa docked onto a flexible lipid membrane and identify protein-protein interactions. Our results highlight multiple points of contact between fVIIIa and fIXa, including a novel interaction with fIXa at the fVIIIa A1-A3 domain interface. Lastly, we identified hemophilia A/B-related mutations with varying severities at the fVIIIa/fIXa interface that may regulate Xase complex assembly. Together, our results support the use of SAXS as an emergent tool to investigate the membrane-bound Xase complex and illustrate how mutations at the fVIIIa/fIXa dimer interface may disrupt or stabilize the activated enzyme complex.

Non-ionic detergent assists formation of supercharged nanodiscs and insertion of membrane proteins

Nanodiscs are used to stabilize membrane proteins in a lipid environment and enable investigations of the function and structure of these. Membrane proteins are often only available in small amounts, and thus the stability and ease of use of the nanodiscs are essential. We have recently explored circularizing and supercharging membrane scaffolding proteins (MSPs) for nanodisc formation and found increased temporal stability at elevated temperatures. In the present study, we investigate six different supercharged MSPs and their ability to form nanodiscs: three covalently circularized and the three non-circularized, linear versions. Using standard reconstitution protocols using cholate as the reconstitution detergent, we found that two of the linear constructs formed multiple lipid-protein species, whereas adding n-Dodecyl-B-D-maltoside (DDM) with the cholate in the reconstitution gave rise to single-species nanodisc formation for these MSPs. For all MSPs, the formed nanodiscs were analyzed by small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS), which showed similar structures for each MSP, respectively, suggesting that the structures of the formed nanodiscs are independent of the initial DDM content, as long as cholate is present. Lastly, we incorporated the membrane protein proteorhodopsin into the supercharged nanodiscs and observed a considerable increase in incorporation yield with the addition of DDM. For the three circularized MSPs, a single major species appeared in the size exclusion chromatography (SEC) chromatogram, suggesting monodisperse nanodiscs with proteorhodopsin incorporated, which is in strong contrast to the samples without DDM showing almost no incorporation and high polydispersity.

Structures and Dynamics of Anionic Lipoprotein Nanodiscs

Nanolipoprotein particles known as nanodiscs (NDs) have emerged as versatile and powerful tools for the stabilization of membrane proteins permitting a plethora of structural and biophysical studies. Part of their allure is their flexibility to accommodate many types of lipids and precise control of the composition. However, little is known about how variations in lipid composition impact their structures and dynamics. Herein, we investigate how the introduction of the anionic lipid POPG into POPC NDs impacts these features. Small-angle X-ray and neutron scattering (SAXS and SANS) of variable-composition NDs are complemented with molecular dynamics simulations to interrogate how increasing the concern of POPG impacts the ND shape, structure of the lipid core, and the dynamics of the popular membrane scaffold protein, MSP1D1(-). A convenient benefit of including POPG is that it eliminates D₂O-induced aggregation observed in pure POPC NDs, permitting studies by SANS at multiple contrasts. SAXS and SANS data could be globally fit to a stacked elliptical cylinder model as well as an extension of the model that accounts for membrane curvature. Fitting to both models supports that the introduction of POPG results in strongly elliptical NDs; however, MD simulations predict the curvature of the membrane, thereby supporting the use of the latter model. Trends in the model-independent parameters suggest that increases in POPG reduce the conformational heterogeneity of the MSP1D1(-), which is in agreement with MD simulations that show that the incorporation of sufficient POPG suppresses disengagement of the N-terminal helix from the lipid core. These studies highlight novel structural changes in NDs in response to an anionic lipid and will inform the interpretation of future structural studies of membrane proteins embedded in NDs of mixed lipid composition.

Global fitting of multiple data frames from SEC–SAXS to investigate the structure of next-generation nanodiscs

The combination of online size-exclusion chromatography and small-angle X-ray scattering (SEC–SAXS) is rapidly becoming a key technique for structural investigations of elaborate biophysical samples in solution. Here, a novel model-refinement strategy centred around the technique is outlined and its utility is demonstrated by analysing data series from several SEC–SAXS experiments on phospholipid bilayer nanodiscs. Using this method, a single model was globally refined against many frames from the same data series, thereby capturing the frame-to-frame tendencies of the irradiated sample. These are compared with models refined in the traditional manner, in which refinement is based on the average profile of a set of consecutive frames from the same data series without an in-depth comparison of individual frames. This is considered to be an attractive model-refinement scheme as it considerably lowers the total number of parameters refined from the data series, produces tendencies that are automatically consistent between frames, and utilizes a considerably larger portion of the recorded data than is often performed in such experiments. Additionally, a method is outlined for correcting a measured UV absorption signal by accounting for potential peak broadening by the experimental setup.

Mg2+-dependent conformational equilibria in CorA and an integrated view on transport regulation

The CorA family of proteins regulates the homeostasis of divalent metal ions in many bacteria, archaea, and eukaryotic mitochondria, making it an important target in the investigation of the mechanisms of transport and its functional regulation. Although numerous structures of open and closed channels are now available for the CorA family, the mechanism of the transport regulation remains elusive. Here, we investigated the conformational distribution and associated dynamic behaviour of the pentameric Mg²⁺ channel CorA at room temperature using small-angle neutron scattering (SANS) in combination with molecular dynamics (MD) simulations and solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy (NMR). We find that neither the Mg²⁺-bound closed structure nor the Mg²⁺-free open forms are sufficient to explain the average conformation of CorA. Our data support the presence of conformational equilibria between multiple states, and we further find a variation in the behaviour of the backbone dynamics with and without Mg²⁺. We propose that CorA must be in a dynamic equilibrium between different non-conducting states, both symmetric and asymmetric, regardless of bound Mg²⁺ but that conducting states become more populated in Mg²⁺-free conditions. These properties are regulated by backbone dynamics and are key to understanding the functional regulation of CorA.

Styrene-Maleic Acid Copolymer Nanodiscs to Determine the Shape of Membrane Proteins

Lipid nanodiscs can be used to solubilize functional membrane proteins (MPs) in nativelike environments. Thus, they are promising reagents that have been proven useful to characterize MPs. Both protein and non-protein molecular belts have shown promise to maintain the structural integrity of MPs in lipid nanodiscs. Small-angle neutron scattering (SANS) can be used to determine low-resolution structures of proteins in solution, which can be enhanced through the use of contrast variation methods. We present theoretical contrast variation SANS results for protein and styrene-maleic acid copolymer (SMA) belt 1,2-dimyristoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphorylcholine (DMPC) nanodiscs with and without additional bound or transmembrane proteins. The predicted scattering properties are derived from atomistic molecular dynamics simulations to account for conformational fluctuations, and we determine deuterium-labeling conditions such that SANS intensity profiles only include contributions from the scattering of the MP of interest. We propose strategies to tune the neutron scattering length densities (SLDs) of the SMA and DMPC using selective deuterium labeling such that the SLD of the nanodisc becomes homogeneous and its scattering can essentially be eliminated in solvents containing an appropriate amount of D₂O. These finely tuned labeled polymer-based nanodiscs are expected to be useful to extract the size and molecular shape information of MPs using SANS-based contrast variation experiments, and they can be used with MPs of any molecular weight.

Ab initio reconstruction of small angle scattering data for membrane proteins in copolymer nanodiscs

Background

Small angle scattering techniques are beginning to be more widely utilised for structural analysis of biological systems. However, applying these techniques to study membrane proteins still remains problematic, due to sample preparation requirements and analysis of the resulting data. The development of styrene-maleic acid co-polymers (SMA) to extract membrane proteins into nanodiscs for further study provides a suitable environment for structural analysis.

Methods

We use small angle neutron scattering (SANS) with three different contrasts to determine structural information for two different polymer nanodisc-incorporated proteins, Outer membrane protein F (OmpF) and gramicidin. Ab initio modelling was applied to generate protein/lipid structures from the SANS data. Other complementary structural methodologies, such as DLS, CD and TEM were compared alongside this data with known protein crystal structures.

Results

A single-phase model was constructed for gramicidin-containing nanodiscs, which showed dimer formation in the centre of the nanodisc. For OmpF-nanodiscs we were able to construct a multi-phase model, providing structural information on the protein/lipid and polymer components of the sample.

Conclusions

Polymer-nanodiscs can provide a suitable platform to investigate certain membrane proteins using SANS, alongside other structural methodologies. However, differences between the published crystal structure and OmpF-nanodiscs were observed, suggesting the nanodisc structure could be altering the folding of the protein.

General significance

Small angle scattering techniques can provide structural information on the protein and polymer nanodisc without requiring crystallisation of the protein. Additional complementary techniques, such as ab initio modelling, can generate alternative models both the protein and nanodisc system.

Experimental noise in small-angle scattering can be assessed using the Bayesian indirect Fourier transformation

Small-angle X-ray and neutron scattering are widely used to investigate soft matter and biophysical systems. The experimental errors are essential when assessing how well a hypothesized model fits the data. Likewise, they are important when weights are assigned to multiple data sets used to refine the same model. Therefore, it is problematic when experimental errors are over- or underestimated. A method is presented, using Bayesian indirect Fourier transformation for small-angle scattering data, to assess whether or not a given small-angle scattering data set has over- or underestimated experimental errors. The method is effective on both simulated and experimental data, and can be used to assess and rescale the errors accordingly. Even if the estimated experimental errors are appropriate, it is ambiguous whether or not a model fits sufficiently well, as the `true' reduced χ2 of the data is not necessarily unity. This is particularly relevant for approaches where overfitting is an inherent challenge, such as reweighting of a simulated molecular dynamics trajectory against small-angle scattering data or ab initio modelling. Using the outlined method, it is shown that one can determine what reduced χ2 to aim for when fitting a model against small-angle scattering data. The method is easily accessible via the web interface BayesApp.

Current Developments in Native Nanometric Discoidal Membrane Bilayer Formed by Amphipathic Polymers

Unlike cytosolic proteins, membrane proteins (MPs) are embedded within the plasma membrane and the lipid bilayer of intracellular organelles. MPs serve in various cellular processes and account for over 65% of the current drug targets. The development of membrane mimetic systems such as bicelles, short synthetic polymers or amphipols, and membrane scaffold proteins (MSP)-based nanodiscs has facilitated the accommodation of synthetic lipids to stabilize MPs, yet the preparation of these membrane mimetics remains detergent-dependent. Bio-inspired synthetic polymers present an invaluable tool for excision and liberation of superstructures of MPs and their surrounding annular lipid bilayer in the nanometric discoidal assemblies. In this article, we discuss the significance of self-assembling process in design of biomimetic systems, review development of multiple series of amphipathic polymers and the significance of these polymeric "belts" in biomedical research in particular in unraveling the structures, dynamics and functions of several high-value membrane protein targets.

Structural and Biophysical Properties of Supercharged and Circularized Nanodiscs

Nanodiscs based on membrane scaffold proteins (MSPs) and phospholipids are used as membrane mimics to stabilize membrane proteins in solution for structural and functional studies. Combining small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS), differential scanning calorimetry (DSC), and time-resolved small-angle neutron scattering (TR-SANS), we characterized the structure and lipid bilayer properties of five different nanodiscs made with dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine and different MSPs varying in size, charge, and circularization. Our SAXS modeling showed that the structural parameters of the embedded lipids are all similar, irrespective of the MSP properties. DSC showed that the lipid packing is not homogeneous in the nanodiscs and that a 20 Å wide boundary layer of lipids with perturbed packing is located close to the MSP, while the packing of central lipids is tighter than in large unilamellar vesicles. Finally, TR-SANS showed that lipid exchange rates in nanodiscs decrease with increasing nanodisc size and are lower for the nanodiscs made with supercharged MSPs compared to conventional nanodiscs. Altogether, the results provide a thorough biophysical understanding of the nanodisc as a model membrane system, which is important in order to carry out and interpret experiments on membrane proteins embedded in such systems.

Order and disorder-An integrative structure of the full-length human growth hormone receptor

Because of its small size (70 kilodalton) and large content of structural disorder (>50%), the human growth hormone receptor (hGHR) falls between the cracks of conventional high-resolution structural biology methods. Here, we study the structure of the full-length hGHR in nanodiscs with small-angle x-ray scattering (SAXS) as the foundation. We develop an approach that combines SAXS, x-ray diffraction, and NMR spectroscopy data obtained on individual domains and integrate these through molecular dynamics simulations to interpret SAXS data on the full-length hGHR in nanodiscs. The hGHR domains reorient freely, resulting in a broad structural ensemble, emphasizing the need to take an ensemble view on signaling of relevance to disease states. The structure provides the first experimental model of any full-length cytokine receptor in a lipid membrane and exemplifies how integrating experimental data from several techniques computationally may access structures of membrane proteins with long, disordered regions, a widespread phenomenon in biology.

General Protocol for Constructing Molecular Models of Nanodiscs

Nanodisc technology is increasingly being applied for structural and biophysical studies of membrane proteins. In this work, we present a general protocol for constructing molecular models of nanodiscs for molecular dynamics simulations. The protocol is written in python and based on geometric equations, making it fast and easy to modify, enabling automation and customization of nanodiscs in silico. The novelty being the ability to construct any membrane scaffold protein (MSP) variant fast and easy given only an input sequence. We validated and tested the protocol by simulating seven different nanodiscs of various sizes and with different membrane scaffold proteins, both circularized and noncircularized. The structural and biophysical properties were analyzed and shown to be in good agreement with previously reported experimental data and simulation studies.

ApoE and ApoE Nascent-Like HDL Particles at Model Cellular Membranes: Effect of Protein Isoform and Membrane Composition

Apolipoprotein E (ApoE), an important mediator of lipid transportation in plasma and the nervous system, plays a large role in diseases such as atherosclerosis and Alzheimer's. The major allele variants ApoE3 and ApoE4 differ only by one amino acid. However, this difference has major consequences for the physiological behaviour of each variant. In this paper, we follow (i) the initial interaction of lipid-free ApoE variants with model membranes as a function of lipid saturation, (ii) the formation of reconstituted High-Density Lipoprotein-like particles (rHDL) and their structural characterisation, and (iii) the rHDL ability to exchange lipids with model membranes made of saturated lipids in the presence and absence of cholesterol [1,2-dimyristoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DMPC) or 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-glycero-3-phosphocholine (POPC) with and without 20 mol% cholesterol]. Our neutron reflection results demonstrate that the protein variants interact differently with the model membranes, adopting different protein conformations. Moreover, the ApoE3 structure at the model membrane is sensitive to the level of lipid unsaturation. Small-angle neutron scattering shows that the ApoE containing lipid particles form elliptical disc-like structures, similar in shape but larger than nascent or discoidal HDL based on Apolipoprotein A1 (ApoA1). Neutron reflection shows that ApoE-rHDL do not remove cholesterol but rather exchange saturated lipids, as occurs in the brain. In contrast, ApoA1-containing particles remove and exchange lipids to a greater extent as occurs elsewhere in the body.

Aescin - a natural soap for the formation of lipid nanodiscs with tunable size

The saponin β-aescin from the seed extract of the horse chestnut tree Aesculus hippocastanum has demonstrated a beneficial role in clinical therapy which is in part related to its strong interaction with biological membranes. In this context the present work investigates the self-assembly of nm-sized discoidal lipid nanoparticles composed of β-aescin and the phospholipid 1,2-dimyristoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DMPC). The discoidal lipid nanoparticles reassemble from small discs into larger discs, ribbons and finally stacks of sheets upon heating from gel-phase to fluid phase DMPC. The morphological transition of the lipid nano-particles is mainly triggered by the phospholipid phase state change. The final morphology depends on the phospholipid-to-saponin ratio and the actual temperature. The study is conducted by small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) and transmission (TEM) and freeze fracture electron microscopy (FFEM) are used to cover larger length scales. Two different models, representing a disc and ribbon-like shape are applied to the SAXS data, evaluating possible geometries and molecular mixing of the nano-particles. The stacked sheets are analysed by the Caillé theory.

Ab initio determination of the shape of membrane proteins in a nanodisc

New software, called Marbles, is introduced that employs SAXS intensities to predict the shape of membrane proteins embedded into membrane nanodiscs. To gain computational speed and efficient convergence, the strategy is based on a hybrid approach that allows one to account for the contribution of the nanodisc to the SAXS intensity through a semi-analytical model, while the embedded membrane protein is treated as a set of beads, similarly to as in well known ab initio methods. The reliability and flexibility of this approach is proved by benchmarking the code, implemented in C++ with a Python interface, on a toy model and two proteins with very different geometry and size.

Nanodiscs: A toolkit for membrane protein science

Membrane proteins are involved in numerous vital biological processes, including transport, signal transduction and the enzymes in a variety of metabolic pathways. Integral membrane proteins account for up to 30% of the human proteome and they make up more than half of all currently marketed therapeutic targets. Unfortunately, membrane proteins are inherently recalcitrant to study using the normal toolkit available to scientists, and one is most often left with the challenge of finding inhibitors, activators and specific antibodies using a denatured or detergent solubilized aggregate. The Nanodisc platform circumvents these challenges by providing a self-assembled system that renders typically insoluble, yet biologically and pharmacologically significant, targets such as receptors, transporters, enzymes, and viral antigens soluble in aqueous media in a native-like bilayer environment that maintain a target's functional activity. By providing a bilayer surface of defined composition and structure, Nanodiscs have found great utility in the study of cellular signaling complexes that assemble on a membrane surface. Nanodiscs provide a nanometer scale vehicle for the in vivo delivery of amphipathic drugs, therapeutic lipids, tethered nucleic acids, imaging agents and active protein complexes. This means for generating nanoscale lipid bilayers has spawned the successful use of numerous other polymer and peptide amphipathic systems. This review, in celebration of the Anfinsen Award, summarizes some recent results and provides an inroad into the current and historical literature.

Lipid-bound ApoE3 self-assemble into elliptical disc-shaped particles

Apolipoproteins are vital to lipid metabolism and cholesterol transport in the human body. Here we present a structural study of the lipid-bound particles formed by ApoE3 in a full-length and a truncated version. The particles are formed with, respectively, POPC and DMPC and investigated by small-angle X-ray scattering and negative stain electron microscopy. We find that lipid-bound ApoE3 particles are elliptical, disc-shaped particles composed of a central lipid bilayer encircled by two amphipathic ApoE3 proteins. We went on to investigate a truncated form of ApoE3 containing only residue 80 to 255 (ApoE3^80-255), which is the central helical repeat segment of ApoE3. The lipid-bound ApoE3^80-255 particles are found to have the same morphology as the particles with full-length ApoE3. However, they are larger, and form more heterogeneous discoidal structures with four proteins per particle. This behavior is in contrast to ApoA1 where the highly similar helical repeat domain determines the size and stoichiometry of the formed particles both in the case of full-length and truncated ApoA1. Our data hence points towards different mechanisms for lipid bilayer structural modulation by ApoA1 and ApoE3 due to different roles of the non-repeat segments.

Structure and dynamics of a nanodisc by integrating NMR, SAXS and SANS experiments with molecular dynamics simulations

Nanodiscs are membrane mimetics that consist of a protein belt surrounding a lipid bilayer, and are broadly used for characterization of membrane proteins. Here, we investigate the structure, dynamics and biophysical properties of two small nanodiscs, MSP1D1ΔH5 and ΔH4H5. We combine our SAXS and SANS experiments with molecular dynamics simulations and previously obtained NMR and EPR data to derive and validate a conformational ensemble that represents the structure and dynamics of the nanodisc. We find that it displays conformational heterogeneity with various elliptical shapes, and with substantial differences in lipid ordering in the centre and rim of the discs. Together, our results reconcile previous apparently conflicting observations about the shape of nanodiscs, and pave the way for future integrative studies of larger complex systems such as membrane proteins embedded in nanodiscs.

Aescin-Induced Conversion of Gel-Phase Lipid Membranes into Bicelle-like Lipid Nanoparticles

Mixtures of the phospholipid 1,2-dimyristoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DMPC) and the saponin β-aescin spontaneously form monodisperse, bilayered discoidal micelles (also known as "bicelles" or "nanodisks") in aqueous solution. Such bicelles form below the melting temperature of DMPC when the phospholipids are in the rigid L_β' state and are precursors of spontaneously formed vesicles. The aescin concentration must be far above the cmc_aescin (≈0.3-0.4 mM). It was found that the shape and size of the bicelles are tunable by composition. High amounts of aescin decrease the size of the bicelles from diameters of ∼300 Å at 7 mol % to ∼120 Å at 30 mol % β-aescin. The structures are scrutinized by complementary small-angle X-ray and neutron scattering experiments. The scattering curves are subsequently analyzed by a model-independent (indirect Fourier transform analysis) and a model-based approach where bicelles are described as polydisperse bilayer disks encircled by a β-aescin rim. Moreover, the monomodal distribution and low polydispersity of the samples were confirmed by photon correlation spectroscopy. The discoidal structures were visualized by transmission electron microscopy.

Beyond detergent micelles: The advantages and applications of non-micellar and lipid-based membrane mimetics for solution-state NMR

Membrane proteins are important players in signal transduction and the exchange of metabolites within or between cells. Thus, this protein class is the target of around 60 % of currently marketed drugs, emphasizing their essential biological role. Besides functional assays, structural and dynamical investigations on this protein class are crucial to fully understanding their functionality. Even though X-ray crystallography and electron microscopy are the main methods to determine structures of membrane proteins and their complexes, NMR spectroscopy can contribute essential information on systems that (a) do not crystallize and (b) are too small for EM. Furthermore, NMR is a versatile tool for monitoring functional dynamics of biomolecules at various time scales. A crucial aspect of such studies is the use of a membrane mimetic that resembles a native environment and thus enables the extraction of functional insights. In recent decades, the membrane protein NMR community has moved from rather harsh detergents to membrane systems having more native-like properties. In particular, most recently phospholipid nanodiscs have been developed and optimized mainly for solution-state NMR but are now also being used for solid-state NMR spectroscopy. Nanodiscs consist of a patch of a planar lipid bilayer that is encircled by different (bio-)polymers to form particles of defined and tunable size. In this review, we provide an overview of available membrane mimetics, including nanodiscs, amphipols and bicelles, that are suitable for high-resolution NMR spectroscopy and describe how these advanced membrane mimetics can facilitate NMR studies on the structure and dynamics of membrane proteins. Since the stability of membrane proteins depends critically on the chosen membrane mimetic, we emphasize the importance of a suitable system that is not necessarily developed for solution-state NMR applications and hence requires optimization for each membrane protein. However, lipid-based membrane mimetics offer the possibility of performing NMR experiments at elevated temperatures and studying ligand and partner protein complexes as well as their functional dynamics in a realistic membrane environment. In order to be able to make an informed decision during the selection of a suitable membrane system, we provide a detailed overview of the available options for various membrane protein classes and thereby facilitate this often-difficult selection process for a broad range of desired NMR applications.

CHARMM-GUI Nanodisc Builder for modeling and simulation of various nanodisc systems

Nanodiscs are discoidal protein-lipid complexes that have wide applications in membrane protein studies. Modeling and simulation of nanodiscs are challenging due to the absence of structures of many membrane scaffold proteins (MSPs) that wrap around the membrane bilayer. We have developed CHARMM-GUI Nanodisc Builder (http://www.charmm-gui.org/input/nanodisc) to facilitate the setup of nanodisc simulation systems by modeling the MSPs with defined size and known structural features. A total of 11 different nanodiscs with a diameter from 80 to 180 Å are made available in both the all-atom CHARMM and two coarse-grained (PACE and Martini) force fields. The usage of the Nanodisc Builder is demonstrated with various simulation systems. The structures and dynamics of proteins and lipids in these systems were analyzed, showing similar behaviors to those from previous all-atom and coarse-grained nanodisc simulations. We expect the Nanodisc Builder to be a convenient and reliable tool for modeling and simulation of nanodisc systems. © 2019 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.

The hydrodynamic motion of Nanodiscs

We present a fluorescence-based methodology for monitoring the rotational dynamics of Nanodiscs. Nanodiscs are nano-scale lipid bilayers surrounded by a helical membrane scaffold protein (MSP) that have found considerable use in studying the interactions between membrane proteins and their lipid bilayer environment. Using a long-lifetime Ruthenium label covalently attached to the Nanodiscs, we find that Nanodiscs of increasing diameter, made by varying the number of helical repeats in the MSP, display increasing rotational correlation times. We also model our system using both analytical equations that describe rotating spheroids and numerical calculations performed on atomic models of Nanodiscs. Using these methods, we observe a linear relationship between the experimentally determined rotational correlation times and those calculated from both analytical equations and numerical solutions. This work sets the stage for accurate, label-free quantification of protein-lipid interactions at the membrane surface.

Size-exclusion chromatography small-angle X-ray scattering of water soluble proteins on a laboratory instrument

Coupling of size-exclusion chromatography with biological solution small-angle X-ray scattering (SEC-SAXS) on dedicated synchrotron beamlines enables structural analysis of challenging samples such as labile proteins and low-affinity complexes. For this reason, the approach has gained increased popularity during the past decade. Transportation of perishable samples to synchrotrons might, however, compromise the experiments, and the limited availability of synchrotron beamtime renders iterative sample optimization tedious and lengthy. Here, the successful setup of laboratory-based SEC-SAXS is described in a proof-of-concept study. It is demonstrated that sufficient quality data can be obtained on a laboratory instrument with small sample consumption, comparable to typical synchrotron SEC-SAXS demands. UV/vis measurements directly on the SAXS exposure cell ensure accurate concentration determination, crucial for direct molecular weight determination from the scattering data. The absence of radiation damage implies that the sample can be fractionated and subjected to complementary analysis available at the home institution after SEC-SAXS. Laboratory-based SEC-SAXS opens the field for analysis of biological samples at the home institution, thus increasing productivity of biostructural research. It may further ensure that synchrotron beamtime is used primarily for the most suitable and optimized samples.

Introducing SEC–SANS for studies of complex self-organized biological systems

Small-angle neutron scattering (SANS) is maturing as a method for studying complex biological structures. Owing to the intrinsic ability of the technique to discern between 1H- and 2H-labelled particles, it is especially useful for contrast-variation studies of biological systems containing multiple components. SANS is complementary to small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS), in which similar contrast variation is not easily performed but in which data with superior counting statistics are more easily obtained. Obtaining small-angle scattering (SAS) data on monodisperse complex biological structures is often challenging owing to sample degradation and/or aggregation. This problem is enhanced in the D2O-based buffers that are typically used in SANS. In SAXS, such problems are solved using an online size-exclusion chromatography (SEC) setup. In the present work, the feasibility of SEC–SANS was investigated using a series of complex and difficult samples of membrane proteins embedded in nanodisc particles that consist of both phospholipid and protein components. It is demonstrated that SEC–SANS provides data of sufficient signal-to-noise ratio for these systems, while at the same time circumventing aggregation. By combining SEC–SANS and SEC–SAXS data, an optimized basis for refining structural models of the investigated structures is obtained.

Comprehensive Study of the Self-Assembly of Phospholipid Nanodiscs: What Determines Their Shape and Stoichiometry?

Phospholipid nanodiscs have quickly become a widely used platform for studies of membrane proteins. However, the molecular self-assembly process that ultimately should place a membrane protein inside a nanodisc is not well understood. This poses a challenge for a successful high-yield reconstitution of general membrane proteins into nanodiscs. In the present work, the self-assembly process of POPC-MSP1D1 nanodiscs was carefully investigated by systematically modulating the reconstitution parameters and probing the effect with a small-angle X-ray scattering analysis of the resulting nanodiscs. First, it was established that nanodiscs prepared using the standard protocol followed a narrow but significant size distribution and that the formed nanodiscs were stable at room temperature over a time range of about a week. Systematic variation of the POPC/MSP1D1 stoichiometry of the reconstitution mixture showed that a ratio of less than 75:1 resulted in lipid-poor nanodiscs, whereas ratios of 75:1 and larger resulted in nanodiscs with constant POPC/MSP1D1 ratios of 60:1. A central step in the self-assembly process consists in adding detergent-absorbing resin beads to the reconstitution mixture to remove the reconstitution detergent. Surprisingly, it was found that this step did not play a significant role for the shape and stoichiometry of the formed nanodiscs. Finally, the effect of the choice of detergent used in the reconstitution process was investigated. It was found that detergent type is a central determining factor for the shape and stoichiometry of the formed nanodiscs. A significantly increasing POPC/MSP1D1 stoichiometry of the formed nanodiscs was observed as the reconstitution detergent type is changed in the order: Tween80, DDM, Triton X-100, OG, CHAPS, Tween20, and Cholate, but with no simple correlation to the characteristics of the detergent. This emphasizes that the detergents optimal for solution storage and crystallization of membrane proteins, in particular DDM, should not be used alone for nanodisc reconstitution. However, our data also show that when applying mixtures of the reconstitution detergent cholate and the storage detergents DDM or OG, cholate dominates the reconstitution process and nanodiscs are obtained, which resemble those formed without storage detergents.

Contrast-Matching Detergent in Small-Angle Neutron Scattering Experiments for Membrane Protein Structural Analysis and Ab Initio Modeling

The biological small-angle neutron scattering instrument at the High-Flux Isotope Reactor of Oak Ridge National Laboratory is dedicated to the investigation of biological materials, biofuel processing, and bio-inspired materials covering nanometer to micrometer length scales. The methods presented here for investigating physical properties (i.e., size and shape) of membrane proteins (here, MmIAP, an intramembrane aspartyl protease from Methanoculleus marisnigri) in solutions of micelle-forming detergents are well-suited for this small-angle neutron scattering instrument, among others. Other biophysical characterization techniques are hindered by their inability to address the detergent contributions in a protein-detergent complex structure. Additionally, access to the Bio-Deuteration Lab provides unique capabilities for preparing large-scale cultivations and expressing deuterium-labeled proteins for enhanced scattering signal from the protein. While this technique does not provide structural details at high-resolution, the structural knowledge gap for membrane proteins contains many addressable areas of research without requiring near-atomic resolution. For example, these areas include determination of oligomeric states, complex formation, conformational changes during perturbation, and folding/unfolding events. These investigations can be readily accomplished through applications of this method.

Membrane Charging and Swelling upon Calcium Adsorption as Revealed by Phospholipid Nanodiscs

Direct binding of calcium ions (Ca²⁺) to phospholipid membranes is an unclarified yet critical signaling pathway in diverse Ca²⁺-regulated cellular phenomena. Here, high-pressure-liquid-chromatography, small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS), UV-vis absorption, and differential refractive index detections are integrated to probe Ca²⁺-binding to the zwitterionic lipid membranes in nanodiscs. The responses of the membranes upon Ca²⁺-binding, in composition and conformation, are quantified through integrated data analysis. The results indicate that Ca²⁺ binds specifically into the phospholipid headgroup zone, resulting in membrane charging and membrane swelling, with a saturated Ca²⁺-lipid binding ratio of 1:8. A Ca²⁺-binding isotherm to the nanodisc is further established and yields an unexpectedly high binding constant K = 4260 M^-1 and a leaflet potential of ca. 100 mV based on a modified Gouy-Chapman model. The calcium-lipid binding ratio, however, drops to 40% when the nanodisc undergoes a gel-to-fluid phase transition, leading to an effective charge capacity of a few μF/cm².

Analysis of small-angle scattering data using model fitting and Bayesian regularization

The structure of macromolecules can be studied by small-angle scattering (SAS), but as this is an ill-posed problem, prior knowledge about the sample must be included in the analysis. Regularization methods are used for this purpose, as already implemented in indirect Fourier transformation and bead-modeling-based analysis of SAS data, but not yet in the analysis of SAS data with analytical form factors. To fill this gap, a Bayesian regularization method was implemented, where the prior information was quantified as probability distributions for the model parameters and included via a functional S. The quantity Q = χ2 + αS was then minimized and the value of the regularization parameter α determined by probability maximization. The method was tested on small-angle X-ray scattering data from a sample of nanodiscs and a sample of micelles. The parameters refined with the Bayesian regularization method were closer to the prior values as compared with conventional χ2 minimization. Moreover, the errors on the refined parameters were generally smaller, owing to the inclusion of prior information. The Bayesian method stabilized the refined values of the fitted model upon addition of noise and can thus be used to retrieve information from data with low signal-to-noise ratio without risk of overfitting. Finally, the method provides a measure for the information content in data, N g, which represents the effective number of retrievable parameters, taking into account the imposed prior knowledge as well as the noise level in data.

Biological small-angle neutron scattering: recent results and development

Small-angle neutron scattering (SANS) has increasingly been used by the structural biology community in recent years to obtain low-resolution information on solubilized biomacromolecular complexes in solution. In combination with deuterium labelling and solvent-contrast variation (H2O/D2O exchange), SANS provides unique information on individual components in large heterogeneous complexes that is perfectly complementary to the structural restraints provided by crystallography, nuclear magnetic resonance and electron microscopy. Typical systems studied include multi-protein or protein–DNA/RNA complexes and solubilized membrane proteins. The internal features of these systems are less accessible to the more broadly used small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) technique owing to a limited range of intra-complex and solvent electron-density variation. Here, the progress and developments of biological applications of SANS in the past decade are reviewed. The review covers scientific results from selected biological systems, including protein–protein complexes, protein–RNA/DNA complexes and membrane proteins. Moreover, an overview of recent developments in instruments, sample environment, deuterium labelling and software is presented. Finally, the perspectives for biological SANS in the context of integrated structural biology approaches are discussed.

Interpretation of solution scattering data from lipid nanodiscs

Solution scattering data from lipid nanodiscs are interpreted on the basis of X-ray scattering data in an extended range of scattering vectors.

The structural information contained in solution scattering data from empty lipid nanodiscs is examined in the context of a multi-component geometric model. X-ray scattering data were collected on nanodiscs of different compositions at scattering vector magnitudes up to 2.0 Å⁻¹. Through the calculation of the partial form factor for each of the nanodisc components before the isotropic average, structural parameters in the model were correlated to the features observed in the X-ray scattering data and to the corresponding distance distribution function. It is shown that, in general, the features at ∼0.3–0.6 Å⁻¹ in the scattering data correlate to the bilayer structure. The data also support the argument that the elliptical shape of nanodiscs found in model fitting is physical, rather than an artefact due to the nanodisc size distribution. The lipid chain packing peak at ∼1.5 Å⁻¹ is visible in the data and reflects the lipid bilayer phase transition. The shape change in the distance distribution function across the phase transition suggests that the nanodiscs are more circular in the fluid phase. The implication of these findings for model fitting of empty and protein-loaded nanodiscs is discussed.

Formation of Lipid-Bilayer Nanodiscs by Diisobutylene/Maleic Acid (DIBMA) Copolymer

Membrane proteins usually need to be extracted from their native environment and separated from other membrane components for in-depth in vitro characterization. The use of styrene/maleic acid (SMA) copolymers to solubilize membrane proteins and their surrounding lipids into bilayer nanodiscs is an attractive approach toward this goal. We have recently shown that a diisobutylene/maleic acid (DIBMA) copolymer similarly solubilizes model and cellular membranes but, unlike SMA(3:1), has a mild impact on lipid acyl-chain order and thermotropic phase behavior. Here, we used fluorescence spectroscopy, small-angle X-ray scattering, size-exclusion chromatography, dynamic light scattering, and ³¹P nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy to examine the self-association of DIBMA and its membrane-solubilization properties against lipids differing in acyl-chain length and saturation. Although DIBMA is less hydrophobic than commonly used SMA(3:1) and SMA(2:1) copolymers, it efficiently formed lipid-bilayer nanodiscs that decreased in size with increasing polymer/lipid ratio while maintaining the overall thickness of the membrane. DIBMA fractions of different molar masses were similarly efficient in solubilizing a saturated lipid. Coulomb screening at elevated ionic strength or reduced charge density on the polymer at low pH enhanced the solubilization efficiency of DIBMA. The free-energy penalty for transferring phospholipids from vesicular bilayers into nanodiscs became more unfavorable with increasing acyl-chain length and unsaturation. Altogether, these findings provide a rational framework for using DIBMA in membrane-protein research by shedding light on the effects of polymer and lipid properties as well as experimental conditions on membrane solubilization.