Thermodynamics of Proton and Electron Transfer in Tetranuclear Clusters with Mn-OH2/OH Motifs Relevant to H2O Activation by the Oxygen Evolving Complex in Photosystem II

Thermodynamics of Proton-Coupled Electron Transfer at Tricopper μ-Oxo/Hydroxo/Aqua Complexes

Multicopper oxidases (MCOs) utilize a tricopper active site to reduce dioxygen to water through 4H+ 4e- proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET). Understanding the thermodynamics of PCET at a tricopper cluster is essential for elucidating how MCOs harness the oxidative power of O2 while mitigating oxidative damage. In this study, we determined the O-H bond dissociation free energies (BDFEs) and pKa values of a series of tricopper hydroxo and tricopper aqua complexes as synthetic models of the tricopper site in MCOs. Tricopper intermediates on the path of alternating electron and proton transfer (ET-PT-ET-PT-ET) have modest BDFE(O-H) values in the range of 53.0-57.1 kcal/mol. In contrast, those not on the path of ET-PT-ET-PT-ET display much higher (78.1 kcal/mol) or lower (44.7 kcal/mol) BDFE(O-H) values. Additionally, the pKa of bridging OH and OH2 motifs increase by 8-16 pKa units per oxidation state. The same oxidation state changes have a lesser impact on the pKa of N-H motif in the secondary coordination sphere, with an increase of ca. 5 pKa units per oxidation state. The steeper pKa increase of the tricopper center promotes proton transfer from the secondary coordination sphere. Overall, our study shed light on the PCET pathway least prone to decomposition, elucidating why tricopper centers are an optimal choice for promoting efficient oxygen reduction reaction.

Impact of Surface Ligand Identity and Density on the Thermodynamics of H Atom Uptake at Polyoxovanadate-Alkoxide Surfaces

An understanding of how molecular structure influences the thermodynamics of H atom transfer is critical to designing efficient catalysts for reductive chemistries. Herein, we report experimental and theoretical investigations summarizing structure-function relationships of polyoxovanadate-alkoxides that influence bond dissociation free energies of hydroxide ligands located at the surface of the cluster. We evaluate the thermochemical descriptors of O-H bond strength for a series of clusters, namely [V6O13-x(OH)x(TRIOLR)2]-2 (x = 2, 4, 6; R = NO2, Me) and [V6O11-x(OMe)2(OH)x(TRIOLNO2)2]-2, via computational analysis and open circuit potential measurements. Our findings reveal that modifications to the TRIOL ligand (e.g., changing from the previously reported electron withdrawing nitro-backed ligand to the electron-donating methyl variant) have limited influence on the strength of surface O-H bonds as a result of near complete thermodynamic compensation in these systems (i.e., correlated changes in redox potential and cluster basicity). In contrast, changes in surface density of alkoxide ligands via direct alkoxylation of the polyoxovanadate-alkoxide surface result in measurable increases in bond dissociation free energies of surface O-H bonds for the mixed-valent derivatives. Our findings indicate that the extent of (de)localization of electron density across the cluster core has an impact on the bond dissociation free energies of surface O-H bonds across all oxidation states of the assembly.

Redox Processes Involving Oxygen: The Surprising Influence of Redox-Inactive Lewis Acids

Metalloenzymes with heteromultimetallic active sites perform chemical reactions that control several biogeochemical cycles. Transformations catalyzed by such enzymes include dioxygen generation and reduction, dinitrogen reduction, and carbon dioxide reduction-instrumental transformations for progress in the context of artificial photosynthesis and sustainable fertilizer production. While the roles of the respective metals are of interest in all these enzymatic transformations, they share a common factor in the transfer of one or multiple redox equivalents. In light of this feature, it is surprising to find that incorporation of redox-inactive metals into the active site of such an enzyme is critical to its function. To illustrate, the presence of a redox-inactive Ca2+ center is crucial in the Oxygen Evolving Complex, and yet particularly intriguing given that the transformation catalyzed by this cluster is a redox process involving four electrons. Therefore, the effects of redox inactive metals on redox processes-electron transfer, oxygen- and hydrogen-atom transfer, and O-O bond cleavage and formation reactions-mediated by transition metals have been studied extensively. Significant effects of redox inactive metals have been observed on these redox transformations; linear free energy correlations between Lewis acidity and the redox properties of synthetic model complexes are observed for several reactions. In this Perspective, these effects and their relevance to multielectron processes will be discussed.

Oxygen-Atom Defect Formation in Polyoxovanadate Clusters via Proton-Coupled Electron Transfer

The uptake of hydrogen atoms (H-atoms) into reducible metal oxides has implications in catalysis and energy storage. However, outside of computational modeling, it is difficult to obtain insight into the physicochemical factors that govern H-atom uptake at the atomic level. Here, we describe oxygen-atom vacancy formation in a series of hexavanadate assemblies via proton-coupled electron transfer, presenting a novel pathway for the formation of defect sites at the surface of redox-active metal oxides. Kinetic investigations reveal that H-atom transfer to the metal oxide surface occurs through concerted proton–electron transfer, resulting in the formation of a transient V^III–OH₂ moiety that, upon displacement of the water ligand with an acetonitrile molecule, forms the oxygen-deficient polyoxovanadate-alkoxide cluster. Oxidation state distribution of the cluster core dictates the affinity of surface oxido ligands for H-atoms, mirroring the behavior of reducible metal oxide nanocrystals. Ultimately, atomistic insights from this work provide new design criteria for predictive proton-coupled electron-transfer reactivity of terminal M=O moieties at the surface of nanoscopic metal oxides.

Multiple Proton-Coupled Electron Transfers at a Tricopper Cluster: Modeling the Reductive Regeneration Process in Multicopper Oxidases

Metal clusters in enzymes carry out the life-sustaining reactions by accumulating multiple redox equivalents in a narrow potential range. This redox potential leveling effect commonly observed in Nature has yet to be reproduced with synthetic metal clusters. Herein, we employ a fully encapsulated synthetic tricopper complex to model the three-electron two-proton reductive regeneration of fully reduced trinuclear copper cluster Cu^ICu^ICu^I(μ₂-OH₂) (FR) from native intermediate Cu^IICu^IICu^II(μ₃-O) (NI) in multicopper oxidases (MCOs). The tricopper cluster can access four oxidation states (I,I,I to II,II,II) and four protonation states ([Cu₃(μ₃-O)]LH, [Cu₃(μ₃-OH)]L, [Cu₃(μ₃-OH)]LH, and [Cu₃(μ₃-OH₂)]L, where LH denotes the protonated ligand), allowing mechanistic investigation of proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) relevant to MCOs. Seven tricopper complexes with discrete oxidation and protonation states were characterized with spectroscopy or X-ray single-crystal diffraction. A stepwise electron transfer-proton transfer (ET-PT) mechanism is established for the reduction of Cu^IICu^IICu^II(μ₃-O)LH to Cu^IICu^IICu^I(μ₃-OH)L, while a stepwise PT-ET mechanism is determined for the reduction of Cu^IICu^ICu^I(μ₃-OH)LH to Cu^ICu^ICu^I(μ₂-OH₂)L. The switch-over from ET-PT to PT-ET mechanism showcases that the tricopper complex can adopt different PCET mechanisms to circumvent high-barrier proton transfer steps. Overall, three-electron two-proton reduction occurs within a narrow potential range of 170 mV, exemplifying the redox potential leveling effect of secondary proton relays in delivering multiple redox equivalents at metal clusters.

Thermally stable manganese(III) peroxido complexes with hindered N3 tripodal ligands: Structures and their physicochemical properties

Mononuclear manganese(III) peroxido complexes are candidates for the reaction intermediates in manganese containing proteins, such as manganese superoxide dismutase (Mn-SOD) etc. In this study, manganese(III) peroxido complexes [Mn(O₂)(L3)] and [Mn(O₂)(L10)] ligated by anionic N3 type ligands with sterically hindered substituents, hydrotris(3-tertiary butyl-5-isopropyl-1-pyrazolyl)borate (L3^-) and hydrotris(3-adamantyl-5-isopropyl-1-pyrazolyl)borate (L10^-), respectively, were structurally characterized. These complexes are the first examples of structurally characterized five-coordinate manganese(III) peroxido complexes. Their characteristic ν(OO) and ν(MnO) stretchings were determined by using H₂¹⁸O₂ for the first time. Theoretical calculations were performed to obtain further insight into their structural parameters. The decomposed products were obtained as [{Mn^III(μ-O)(L3)}₂Mn^IV] and [Mn^III(OH){L10(O)}] from [Mn(O₂)(L3)] and [Mn(O₂)(L10)], respectively.

S = 3 Ground State for a Tetranuclear MnIV4O4 Complex Mimicking the S3 State of the Oxygen-Evolving Complex

The S₃ state is currently the last observable intermediate prior to O-O bond formation at the oxygen-evolving complex (OEC) of Photosystem II, and its electronic structure has been assigned to a homovalent Mn^IV₄ core with an S = 3 ground state. While structural interpretations based on the EPR spectroscopic features of the S₃ state provide valuable mechanistic insight, corresponding synthetic and spectroscopic studies on tetranuclear complexes mirroring the Mn oxidation states of the S₃ state remain rare. Herein, we report the synthesis and characterization by XAS and multifrequency EPR spectroscopy of a Mn^IV₄O₄ cuboidal complex as a spectroscopic model of the S₃ state. Results show that this Mn^IV₄O₄ complex has an S = 3 ground state with isotropic ⁵⁵Mn hyperfine coupling constants of -75, -88, -91, and 66 MHz. These parameters are consistent with an αααβ spin topology approaching the trimer-monomer magnetic coupling model of pseudo-octahedral Mn^IV centers. Importantly, the spin ground state changes from S = 1/2 to S = 3 as the OEC is oxidized from the S₂ state to the S₃ state. This same spin state change is observed following oxidation of the previously reported Mn^IIIMn^IV₃O₄ cuboidal complex to the Mn^IV₄O₄ complex described here. This sets a synthetic precedent for the observed low-spin to high-spin conversion in the OEC.

Remote Ligand Modifications Tune Electronic Distribution and Reactivity in Site-Differentiated, High-Spin Iron Clusters: Flipping Scaling Relationships

We report the synthesis, characterization, and reactivity of [LFe₃O(^RArIm)₃Fe][OTf]₂, the first Hammett series of a site-differentiated cluster. The cluster reduction potentials and CO stretching frequencies shift as expected on the basis of the electronic properties of the ligand: electron-donating substituents result in more reducing clusters and weaker C-O bonds. However, unusual trends in the energetics of their two sequential CO binding events with the substituent σ_p parameters are observed. Specifically, introduction of electron-donating substituents suppresses the first CO binding event (ΔΔH by as much as 7.9 kcal mol^-1) but enhances the second (ΔΔH by as much as 1.9 kcal mol^-1). X-ray crystallography, including multiple-wavelength anomalous diffraction, Mössbauer spectroscopy, and SQUID magnetometry, reveal that these substituent effects result from changes in the energetic penalty associated with electronic redistribution within the cluster, which occurs during the CO binding event.

A Terminal FeIII-Oxo in a Tetranuclear Cluster: Effects of Distal Metal Centers on Structure and Reactivity

Tetranuclear Fe clusters have been synthesized bearing a terminal Fe^III-oxo center stabilized by hydrogen-bonding interactions from pendant ( tert-butylamino)pyrazolate ligands. This motif was supported in multiple Fe oxidation states, ranging from [Fe^II₂Fe^III₂] to [Fe^III₄]; two oxidation states were structurally characterized by single-crystal X-ray diffraction. The reactivity of the Fe^III-oxo center in proton-coupled electron transfer with X-H (X = C, O) bonds of various strengths was studied in conjunction with analysis of thermodynamic square schemes of the cluster oxidation states. These results demonstrate the important role of distal metal centers in modulating the reactivity of a terminal metal-oxo.

What Are We Missing by Not Measuring the Net Charge of Proteins?

The net electrostatic charge (Z) of a folded protein in solution represents a bird's eye view of its surface potentials-including contributions from tightly bound metal, solvent, buffer, and cosolvent ions-and remains one of its most enigmatic properties. Few tools are available to the average biochemist to rapidly and accurately measure Z at pH≠pI. Tools that have been developed more recently seem to go unnoticed. Most scientists are content with this void and estimate the net charge of a protein from its amino acid sequence, using textbook values of pK_a . Thus, Z remains unmeasured for nearly all folded proteins at pH≠pI. When marveling at all that has been learned from accurately measuring the other fundamental property of a protein-its mass-one wonders: what are we missing by not measuring the net charge of folded, solvated proteins? A few big questions immediately emerge in bioinorganic chemistry. When a single electron is transferred to a metalloprotein, does the net charge of the protein change by approximately one elementary unit of charge or does charge regulation dominate, that is, do the pK_a values of most ionizable residues (or just a few residues) adjust in response to (or in concert with) electron transfer? Would the free energy of charge regulation (ΔΔG_z ) account for most of the outer sphere reorganization energy associated with electron transfer? Or would ΔΔG_z contribute more to the redox potential? And what about metal binding itself? When an apo-metalloprotein, bearing minimal net negative charge (e.g., Z=-2.0) binds one or more metal cations, is the net charge abolished or inverted to positive? Or do metalloproteins regulate net charge when coordinating metal ions? The author's group has recently dusted off a relatively obscure tool-the "protein charge ladder"-and used it to begin to answer these basic questions.

Ligand-Based Control of Single-Site vs. Multi-Site Reactivity by a Trichromium Cluster

The trichromium cluster (^tbs L)Cr₃ (thf) ([^tbs L]^6- =[1,3,5-C₆ H₉ (NC₆ H₄ -o-NSi^t BuMe₂ )₃ ]^6- ) exhibits steric- and solvation-controlled reactivity with organic azides to form three distinct products: reaction of (^tbs L)Cr₃ (thf) with benzyl azide forms a symmetrized bridging imido complex (^tbs L)Cr₃ (μ³ -NBn); reaction with mesityl azide in benzene affords a terminally bound imido complex (^tbs L)Cr₃ (μ¹ -NMes); whereas the reaction with mesityl azide in THF leads to terminal N-atom excision from the azide to yield the nitride complex (^tbs L)Cr₃ (μ³ -N). The reactivity of this complex demonstrates the ability of the cluster-templating ligand to produce a well-defined polynuclear transition metal cluster that can access distinct single-site and cooperative reactivity controlled by either substrate steric demands or reaction media.

Morphology-dependent third-order optical nonlinearity of a 2D Co-based metal-organic framework with a porphyrinic skeleton

A two-dimensional (2D) Co-based metal-organic framework (MOF) with porphyrinic skeleton forms crystalline plates, flower-shaped clusters, and ultrathin films under optimized conditions, including the use of polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP) as a surfactant. Ultrathin films demonstrate the best solution-based third-order nonlinear optical properties, featuring a nonlinear transmittance (T) value of 0.54, absorption coefficient (α2) of 9.5 × 10-10 m W-1 and second hyperpolarizability (γ) value of 1.37 × 10-28 esu, which are slightly better than those of the flower-shaped clusters (T = 0.65, α2 = 7.0 × 10-10 m W-1; γ = 1.27 × 10-28 esu), but marginally better than those of the crystalline thin plates (T = 0.94, α2 = 2.4 × 10-10 m W-1; γ = 0.24 × 10-28 esu).

Synthesis, Characterization and Magnetic Studies of a Tetranuclear Manganese(II/IV) Compound Incorporating an Amino-Alcohol Derived Schiff Base

A new tetranuclear mixed-valence manganese(II/IV) compound [MnIIMnIV3(μ-Cl)3(µ3-O)(L)3] (1) (where H3L = (3E)-3-((Z)-4-hydroxy-4-phenylbut-3-en-2-ylideneamino)propane-1,2-diol) has been synthesized and characterized by different physicochemical methods. Single crystal X-ray diffraction analysis reveals that 1 is a tetrahedral cluster consisting of a Mn4Cl3O4 core in which the only Mn(II) ion is joined through three μ2-O bridges to an equilateral triangle of Mn(IV) ions, which are connected by a μ3-O and three μ2-Cl bridges. The redox behavior of 1 was studied by cyclic voltammetry. Variable temperature magnetic susceptibility measurements of 1 revealed predominant antiferromagnetic coupling inside the Mn4Cl3O4 cluster.