Simultaneous Resonance Raman Optical Activity Involving Two Electronic States

Why Does One Measure Resonance Raman Optical Activity? A Unique Case of Measurements under Strong Resonance versus Far-from-Resonance Conditions

Raman optical activity (ROA) spectroscopy exhibits significant potential in the study of (bio)molecules as it encodes information on their molecular structure, chirality, and conformations. Furthermore, the method reveals details on excited electronic states when applied under resonance conditions. Here, we present a combined study of the far from resonance (FFR)-ROA and resonance ROA (RROA) of a single relatively small molecular system. Notably, this study is the first to employ the density functional theory (DFT) analysis of both FFR-ROA and RROA spectra. This is illustrated for cobalamin derivatives using near-infrared and visible light excitation. Although the commonly observed monosignate RROA spectra lose additional information visible in bisignate nonresonance ROA spectra, the RROA technique acts as a complement to nonresonance ROA spectroscopy. In particular, the combination of these methods integrated with DFT calculations can reveal a complete spectral picture of the structural and conformational differences between tested compounds.

Molecular Properties of 3d and 4f Coordination Compounds Deciphered by Raman Optical Activity Spectroscopy

Molecular properties of coordination compounds can be efficiently studied by vibrational spectroscopy. The scope of Raman spectroscopy has been greatly enhanced by the introduction of Raman optical activity (ROA) sensitive to chirality. The present review describes some of its recent applications to study the coordination compounds. 3d and 4f metal complexes often absorb the excitation light, or exhibit luminescence. Therefore, effects caused in ROA spectra by electronic circular dichroism (ECD) and circularly polarized luminescence (CPL) must be taken into consideration.In 3d metal complexes ECD and circularly-polarized Raman scattering compete with the resonance ROA (RROA) signal. Pure RROA spectrum can thus be obtained by subtracting the so-called ECD-Raman component. CPL is frequently encountered in 4f systems. While it can mask the ROA spectra, it is useful to study molecular structure. These electronic effects can be reduced by using near-infrared excitation although vibrational ROA signal is much weaker compared to the usual green laser excitation scenario. The ROA methodology is thus complex, but capable of providing unique information about the molecules of interests and their interaction with light.

Comparative Study of Vibrational Raman Optical Activity with Different Time-Dependent Density Functional Approximations: The VROA36 Database

A new database, VROA36, is introduced to investigate the performance of computational approaches for vibrational Raman optical activity (VROA) calculations. The database is composed of 36 molecules with known experimental VROA spectra. It includes 93 conformers. Normal modes calculated with B3LYP-D3(BJ)/def2-TZVP are used to compute the VROA spectra with four functionals, B3LYP-D3(BJ), ωB97X-D, M11, and optimally tuned LC-PBE, as well as several basis sets. SimROA indices and frequency scaling factors are used to compare calculated spectra with each other and with experimental data. The four functionals perform equally well independently of the basis set and usually achieve good agreement with the experimental data. For molecules in near- or at-resonance conditions, the inclusion of a complex (damped) linear response approach is important to obtain physically meaningful VROA intensities. The use of any of the tested functional approximations with the def2-SVPD Gaussian-type basis set, or a basis of similar flexibility, can be recommended for efficient and reliable theoretical VROA studies.

Resolving Resonant Electronic States in Chiral Metal Complexes by Raman Optical Activity Spectroscopy

Chiral metal complexes exhibit rich photophysical properties and are important for applications ranging from biosensing to photocatalysis. We present a combined experimental and computational approach leading to information about energies and transition moments of excited electronic states, documented on two chiral metal complexes. The experimental protocol for measurement of the resonance Raman optical activity comprises multiple techniques, i.e., absorption, circular dichroism, and polarized and differential Raman scattering. An accurate formula for subtraction of the interfering circular dichroism/polarized Raman scattering effect is given. An analysis of the spectra based on density functional theory calculations unveils the geometric and electronic structures of the molecules. Such insight into molecular electronic states of chromophores may be useful for understanding and tuning photochemical properties of metal-containing complexes, biomolecules, and supramolecules.

New chiral ECD-Raman spectroscopy of atropisomeric naphthalenediimides

In this study, we found that a recently discovered ECD-Raman effect dominated over the natural Raman optical activity in a series of atropisomeric naphthalenediimides, and we investigated the kind of information about the molecular structure that could be obtained from the spectra. The ECD-Raman effect is polarised Raman scattering modulated by electronic circular dichroism. We showed that the spectra significantly depended on the substitution of the solute and/or the change of the solvent. Moreover, the spectra could be well-predicted by the theory, thus providing an interesting tool to monitor the chirality of the binaphthyl compounds.

Measurement and Theory of Resonance Raman Optical Activity for Gases, Liquids, and Aggregates. What It Tells about Molecules

Resonance Raman Optical Activity (RROA) appeared as a natural extension of the nonresonance branch. It combines the structural sensitivity of chiroptical spectroscopy with the signal enhancement coming from the resonance of molecular electronic transitions with the excitation laser light. However, the idea has been hampered by many technical and theoretical problems that are being clarified only in recent years. We provide the theoretical basis and several examples documenting the problems, achievements, and potential of RROA, in particular in biomolecular studies.

Chiral recognition via a stereodynamic vanadium probe using the electronic circular dichroism effect in differential Raman scattering

Intermolecular interactions sensitive to chirality occur in many biological events. We report a complex formation between a versatile vanadium-based probe and a chiral co-ligand monitored via the combination of electronic circular dichroism (ECD) and Raman scattering. This "ECD-Raman" effect was discovered relatively recently and can be measured using a Raman optical activity (ROA) spectrometer. Simulated spectra based on experimental ECD and degree of circularity (DOC) values agree with the observed ones. Sensitive recognition of the chiral enantiopure co-ligand is thus enabled by a combination of resonance of the excitation light with the diastereoisomeric complex, co-ligand complexation, circular dichroism, and polarized Raman scattering from the achiral solvent. Relatively dilute solutions could be detected (10^-4 mol dm^-3), about 1000× less than is necessary for conventional ROA detection of the pure co-ligand and comparable to concentrations needed for conventional ECD spectroscopy. The results thus show that differential ECD-Raman measurements can be conveniently used to monitor molecular interactions and molecular spectroscopic properties.

Recognition of the True and False Resonance Raman Optical Activity

Resonance Raman optical activity (RROA) possesses all aspects of a sensitive tool for molecular detection, but its measurement remains challenging. We demonstrate that reliable recording of RROA of chiral colorful compounds is possible, but only after considering the effect of the electronic circular dichroism (ECD) on the ROA spectra induced by the dissolved chiral compound. We show RROA for a number of model vitamin B12 derivatives that are chemically similar but exhibit distinctively different spectroscopic behavior. The ECD/ROA effect is proportional to the concentration and dependent on the optical pathlength of the light propagating through the sample. It can severely alter relative band intensities and signs in the natural RROA spectra. The spectra analyses are supported by computational modeling based on density functional theory. Neglecting the ECD effect during ROA measurement can lead to misinterpretation of the recorded spectra and erroneous conclusions about the molecular structure.

Can One Measure Resonance Raman Optical Activity?

Resonance Raman optical activity (RROA) is commonly measured as the difference in intensity of Raman scattered right and left circularly polarized light, I_R -I_L , when a randomly polarized light is in resonance with a chiral molecule. Strong and sometimes mono-signate experimental RROA spectra of several chiral solutes were reported previously, although their signs and relative intensities could not be reproduced theoretically. By examining multiple light-matter interaction events which can occur simultaneously under resonance, we show that a new form of chiral Raman spectroscopy, eCP-Raman, a combination of electronic circular dichroism and circularly polarized Raman, prevails. By incorporating the finite-lifetime approach for resonance, the experimental patterns of the model chiral solutes are captured theoretically by eCP-Raman, without any RROA contribution. The results open opportunity for applications of eCP-Raman spectroscopy and for extracting true RROA experimentally.

Raman and ROA analyses of twisted anthracenes: connecting vibrational and electronic/photonic structures

In this article the Raman and Raman Optical Activity (ROA) spectra of a series of enantiomeric twisted anthracenes are presented. The evolution of their vibrational spectra is understood in the context of the variation of π-electron delocalization as a result of the twisting imparted by the belt structure and in terms of the modulation of the resonance Raman/ROA effects which are photonic properties also tuned by anthracene twisting. The Raman/ROA vibrational spectra are simulated by several theoretical approaches to account for their vibrational and electronic properties including the theoretical evaluation of resonance effects. We furthermore incorporate a vibrational and ROA activity dissection analysis as provided in the Pyvib2 program valid to establish correlations among vibrational modes of different molecules with different electronic structures and equivalent vibrational dynamics. This paper is one of the very first attempts to use ROA spectroscopy in π-conjugated molecules with twisted and helical morphologies that contrast with the well-known cases of ROA studies of chiral helicenes in which the impact of π-electron delocalization in the electronic/photonic/vibrational (Raman/ROA) spectra is negligible.

On Raman optical activity sign-switching between the ground and excited states leading to an unusual resonance ROA induced chirality

Raman optical activity (ROA) spectra recorded for a chiral naphthalene diimide derivative (nBu-NDI–BINAM) dissolved in a series of solvents exhibit strong solute to solvent induced chirality with: (1) dominating bands of solvents, (2) nBu-NDI–BINAM resonance ROA (RROA) bands which are barely visible, (3) monosignate RROA Solvent spectra with an unexpected sign concordant with that of the ECD band of the resonant electronic state, (4) bisignate RROA bands for a few solvents, and (5) superposition of non-resonant and resonant ROA bands of the chiral solvents. The unusual ROA enhancement was explained in terms of resonance energy transfer with resonant Raman emission. The surprising RROA sign-switching was found to be due to specific conformational equilibria where one solute conformer dominates in the ground and the other in the first excited singlet state, and, the signs of the related ECD bands of these two conformers are opposite.

Unusual solute to solvent induced chirality in ROA comes from specific conformer equilibria in the ground and the excited states.

Theory and algorithms for chiroptical properties and spectroscopies of aqueous systems

Chiroptical properties and spectroscopies are valuable tools to study chiral molecules and assign absolute configurations. The spectra that result from chiroptical measurements may be very rich and complex, and hide much of their information content. For this reason, the interplay between experiments and calculations is especially useful, provided that all relevant physico-chemical interactions that are present in the experimental sample are accurately modelled. The inherent difficulty associated to the calculation of chiral signals of systems in aqueous solutions requires the development of specific tools, able to account for the peculiarities of water-solute interactions, and especially its ability to form hydrogen bonds. In this perspective we discuss a multiscale approach, which we have developed and challenged to model the most used chiroptical techniques.

Resonance Raman Optical Activity Spectroscopy in Probing Structural Changes Invisible to Circular Dichroism Spectroscopy: A Study on Truncated Vitamin B12 Derivatives

This work demonstrates resonance Raman optical activity (RROA) spectra of three truncated vitamin B₁₂ derivatives modified within the nucleotide loop. Since truncated cobalamins possess sufficiently high rotational strength in the range of ROA excitation (532 nm), it was possible to record their spectra in the resonance condition. They showed several distinct spectral features allowing for the distinguishing of studied compounds, in contrast to other methods, i.e., UV-Vis absorption, electronic circular dichroism, and resonance Raman spectroscopy. The improved capacity of the RROA method is based here on the excitation of molecules via more than two electronic states, giving rise to the bisignate RROA spectrum, significantly distinct from a parent Raman spectrum. This observation is an important step in the dissemination of using RROA spectroscopy in studying the complex structure of corrinoids which may prove crucial for a better understanding of their biological role.

Resonance Raman Optical Activity Shows Unusual Structural Sensitivity for Systems in Resonance with Multiple Excited States: Vitamin B12 Case

In this work, cobalamins with different upper axial substituents and a cobalamin derivative with a ring modification were studied using chiroptical spectroscopies, in particular resonance Raman optical activity (RROA), to shed light on the influence of structural modifications on RROA spectra in these strongly chiral systems in resonance with multiple excited states at 532 nm excitation. We have demonstrated that for these unique systems RROA possesses augmented structural specificity, surpassing resonance Raman spectroscopy and enabling at the same time measurement of cobalamins at fairy low concentrations of ∼10^-5 mol dm^-3. The enhanced structural specificity of RROA is a result of bisignate spectra due to resonance via more than one electronic state. The observation of increased structural capability of RROA for cobalamins opens a new perspective for studying chiral properties of other biological systems incorporating d-metal ions.

Resonance Effects in the Raman Optical Activity Spectrum of [Rh(en)3]3

Raman optical activity spectra of Λ-tris(ethylenediamine)-rhodium(III) {[Rh(en)₃]³⁺} have been calculated at 16 on-, near-, and off-resonant wavelengths between 290 and 800 nm. The resulting spectra are analyzed in detail with a focus on the observed resonance effects. Because several electronically excited states are involved, the spectra are never monosignate, as is often observed in resonance Raman optical activity spectra. Most normal modes are enhanced through these resonance effects, but in several cases, de-enhancement effects are found. The molecular origins of the Raman optical activity intensity for selected normal modes are established by means of group coupling matrices. In general, this methodology allows one to produce an intuitive explanation for the intensity behavior of a given normal mode. However, due to the complex electronic structure of [Rh(en)₃]³⁺, there are some intriguing resonance effects the origins of which could not be fully clarified in terms of group coupling effects. Therefore, simple and general rules that predict how the intensity of a specific normal mode is affected by resonance effects are difficult to devise.

Time-Dependent Formulation of Resonance Raman Optical Activity Spectroscopy

In this work, we extend the theoretical framework recently developed for the simulation of resonance Raman (RR) spectra of medium-to-large sized systems to its chiral counterpart, namely, resonance Raman optical activity (RROA). The theory is based on a time-dependent (TD) formulation, with the transition tensors obtained as half-Fourier transforms of the appropriate cross-correlation functions. The implementation has been kept as general as possible, supporting adiabatic and vertical models for the PES representation, both in Cartesian and internal coordinates, with the possible inclusion of Herzberg-Teller (HT) effects. Thanks to the integration of this TD-RROA procedure within a general-purpose quantum-chemistry program, both solvation and leading anharmonicity effects can be included in an effective way. The implementation is validated on one of the smallest chiral molecule (methyloxirane). Practical applications are illustrated with three medium-size organic molecules (naproxen-OCD₃, quinidine and 2-Br-hexahelicene), whose simulated spectra are compared to the corresponding experimental data.

Redox-Active Chiroptical Switching in Mono- and Bis-Iron Ethynylcarbo[6]helicenes Studied by Electronic and Vibrational Circular Dichroism and Resonance Raman Optical Activity

Introducing one or two alkynyl-iron moieties onto a carbo[6]helicene results in organometallic helicenes (2 a,b) that display strong chiroptical activity combined with efficient redox-triggered switching. The neutral and oxidized forms have been studied in detail by electronic and vibrational circular dichroism, as well as by Raman optical activity (ROA) spectroscopy. The experimental results were analyzed and spectra were assigned with the help of first-principles calculations. In particular, a recently developed method for ROA calculations under resonance conditions has been used to study the intricate resonance effects on the ROA spectrum of mono-iron ethynylhelicene 2 a.

Can the Resonance Raman Optical Activity Spectrum Display Sign Alternation?

The monosignate character of resonance Raman optical activity (RROA) spectra has been often taken as granted in experimental and computational approaches, on the basis of basic theoretical approximations only considering resonance with a single electronic state of the molecule and the scattering process to be governed by the Franck-Condon mechanism. We show in this letter for the first time that, by resorting to a fully quantum mechanical (QM) methodology able to take into account all terms entering the general definition of RROA, and which considers excited state interference and Herzberg-Teller effects, sign alternation and at the same time intensity enhancement in RROA spectra is obtained. Such features constitute an important milestone toward the exploration of RROA of a wide range of chiral biological molecules.

Aggregation-Induced Resonance Raman Optical Activity (AIRROA) and Time-Dependent Helicity Switching of Astaxanthin Supramolecular Assemblies

New methods for enhancing the Raman optical activity (ROA) signal are desirable due to the low efficiency of ROA, demanding otherwise high sample concentrations, high laser powers, and/or long acquisition times. Previously, we have demonstrated a new phenomenon, aggregation-induced resonance ROA (AIRROA), that produces significant enhancement of the ROA signal provided that the excitation wavelength coincides with the absorption of the measured species and that the electronic circular dichroism (ECD) signal in the range of this absorption is nonzero. In this work, analyzing three very different supramolecular astaxanthin aggregates (H1, H2, and J), we confirm the phenomenon and demonstrate that aggregation itself is not enough to enhance the ROA signal and that the above-mentioned conditions are necessary for induction of the resonance ROA effect. Additionally, by analyzing the changes in the ECD spectra of the H1 assembly, we demonstrate that the supramolecular helicity sign switches with time, which is dependent on the prevalence of kinetic or thermodynamic stabilization of the obtained aggregates.

Vibrational energy distribution analysis (VEDA): scopes and limitations

The principle of operations of the VEDA program written by the author for Potential Energy Distribution (PED) analysis of theoretical vibrational spectra is described. Nowadays, the PED analysis is indispensible tool in serious analysis of the vibrational spectra. To perform the PED analysis it is necessary to define 3N-6 linearly independent local mode coordinates. Already for 20-atomic molecules it is a difficult task. The VEDA program reads the input data automatically from the Gaussian program output files. Then, VEDA automatically proposes an introductory set of local mode coordinates. Next, the more adequate coordinates are proposed by the program and optimized to obtain maximal elements of each column (internal coordinate) of the PED matrix (the EPM parameter). The possibility for an automatic optimization of PED contributions is a unique feature of the VEDA program absent in any other programs performing PED analysis.