Hyperacute autoimmune encephalomyelitis induced by a synthetic autoantigen

Abnormal hormonal control of gut hydrolytic enzymes causes autoimmune attack on the CNS by production of immune-mimic and adjuvant molecules: A comprehensive explanation for the induction of multiple sclerosis

Multiple sclerosis (MS) is generally thought to be caused by an autoimmune attack on central nervous system (CNS) myelin. A microorganism containing a mimic of an immunogenic region of a myelin protein initiates the autoimmune process. However, no specific "MS" microorganism has been found. Recently a large number of normal human gut bacteria were found to possess different encephalitogenic mimics. A hypothesis is presented that the autoimmune process is started by abnormal proteolytic digestion of these bacteria. Sufficient quantities of the mimics are produced to be recognized by the immune system. Since proteolytic processes in the gut are strictly controlled, it is proposed that the MS process is triggered by abnormal hormonal control of gut proteolytic enzymes. It has previously been suggested that the recognition of CNS myelin antigens by activated MS immune cells is facilitated by proteolytic processing of myelin proteins. The CNS proteases are also under rigid control and these control processes are the same as is in the gut. Therefore, MS clinical activity is the result of improper hydrolytic degradation in the brain-gut axis caused by an abnormal hormonal variation.

Molecular mimicry revisited: gut bacteria and multiple sclerosis

Molecular mimicry is a possible explanation for autoimmune side effects of microorganism infections. Protein sequences from a particular microorganism are compared to known autoimmune immunogens. For diseases such as multiple sclerosis (MS), where the infectious agent is unknown, guesses to its identity are made. Mimics are assumed to be rare. This study takes a radically different approach. Reported sequences from all known human bacterial and viral agents were searched for autoimmune immunogen mimics. Three encephalitogenic peptides, whose autoimmune requirements have been studied extensively, were selected for comparison. Mimics were seen in a wide variety of organisms. For each immunogen, the mimics were found predominantly in nonpathogenic gut bacteria. Since the three immunogens used in this study are related to MS, it is suggested that a microorganism responsible for autoimmune activity in MS could be a normally occurring gut bacterium. This would explain many of the peculiar MS epidemiological data and why no infective agent has been identified for MS and supports recently found MS gut metabolism abnormalities.

Histo-clinical variation in multiple sclerosis: Heterogeneous proteolytic immunogenic processing

Multiple sclerosis (MS) presents an incredible histo-clinical variation. It consists of an unpredictable series of relapses, remissions and stationary phases. The initial symptoms vary considerably. Any hypothesis of the pathology of MS must include an explanation of this oddity. Current theory suggests that MS is a collection of diseases which produce generally the same result. However, this is not a satisfactory explanation. MS appears as an enormous continuum of disease paths rather than a finite group of well-defined courses. A hypothesis is presented that histo-clinical variation in MS is due to variable proteolytic processing of several potential immunogens. MS is generally thought to be caused by an autoimmune attack on myelin components. Several myelin proteins, myelin basic protein, lipoprotein, oligodendrocyte related glycoprotein and oligodendrocyte basic protein, are encephalitogenic. Within these proteins are short sequences, which themselves are encephalitogenic. In order for potential immunogens to be "seen" by the immune system they first must be processed. This processing is performed by intracellular and extracellular proteases. A large number of different proteases are located throughout the central nervous system. Their concentrations vary with location and time. Most are under strict control. While myelin has a consistent structure, the action of proteases can present variable concentrations of immunogenic peptides. Because of the differences in location, concentration and control of the central nervous system's (CNS) proteases, the same potential immunogen could be presented to the immune system in different locations within the CNS at different times. At a given time and location, the immune system may be presented with no potential immunogens, one potential immunogen or possibly many immunogens. Therefore, because of the dynamic characteristic of presentation, one would expect to see the initial MS symptoms to be variable. This variability would be continued with subsequent symptoms. This is what is seen in multiple sclerosis. A procedure for testing this hypothesis is presented.

Molecular mimicry or structural mimicry?

"Molecular mimicry" should be changed to "structural mimicry". The immune system recognizes shapes--three-dimensional shapes--not sequences. For two sequences to act biologically similar they must possess similar three-dimensional structures.

Definition of myasthenogenic sites of the human acetylcholine receptor using synthetic peptides

Experimental autoimmune myasthenia gravis (EAMG) and antibodies that modulate AChRs from cultured human muscle are induced by a disulfide-looped peptide comprising the human acetylcholine receptor (AChR) alpha-subunit residues 125-147 (H alpha 125-147). To delineate the essential antigenic requirements for induction of EAMG by this peptide, a series of peptides was synthesized: (a) a nonlooped analog (Cys 128 replaced by Ser) stimulated modulating autoantibodies, induced EAMG, and bound antibodies induced by native AChR; (b) H alpha 131-147, a heptadecylpeptide shorter by 6 N-terminal residues, induced modulating antibodies, EAMG, and T cells that responded to H alpha 125-147, but not to H alpha 137-147; (c) H alpha 137-147, an undecapeptide shorter than H alpha 125-147 by 12 N-terminal residues, did not stimulate T cells or induce antibody production, but it bound antibodies generated by the longer peptides. Thus, when coupled to an epitope that could stimulate helper T cells, the region 137-147 was able to stimulate B cells. This study has defined a myasthenogenic region of the human AChR's alpha-subunit, 17 amino acids long, that contains several distinct epitopes, including at least one N-terminal site inducing T-cell responses (region 131-136) and two possibly overlapping sites that induce antibodies (regions 131-136 and 137-147). Further definition of antigenic sites inducing helper and suppressor T-cell responses and stimulating production of autoantibodies to AChR is essential to the goal of antigen-specific immunotherapy for myasthenia gravis.

Experimental thyroid autoimmunity in the dog

Thyroid autoimmunity was induced in 6 crossbred dogs by a single injection of thyroid extract in complete Freund's adjuvant alone, or followed by reimmunization with thyroid extract and incomplete Freund's adjuvant or peanut oil. Total thyroxine levels, autoantibodies to thyroglobulin and thyroid microsomal antigen and thyroid histopathological changes were sequentially monitored for up to 150 days. All dogs developed fluxuating levels of thyroid autoantibodies detectable by enzyme-linked immunosorbent-assay (ELISA). Histopathological damage was observed in one or more thyroid gland biopsies in 4 of the dogs, in 3 cases the lesions were of lymphocytic thyroiditis, in the fourth dog the lesion was a granulomatous reaction. Histopathological thyroid damage was observed in biopsies taken during periods of maximal autoantibody titer. Fixed immunoglobulin was not demonstrable in thyroid gland biopsies by direct immunofluorescence. In 5 dogs total thyroxine levels fell to below the normal range at some period during the study. However in only one dog did this correlate with a time when biopsy findings revealed histopathological thyroid damage. High levels of thyroid autoantibody may indicate histopathological thyroid damage in dogs, however lower levels of thyroid antibody may be found without evidence of histological damage or alteration in thyroid function.

Induction of lethal experimental allergic encephalomyelitis in nonhuman primates and guinea pigs with human glioblastoma multiforme tissue

✓ The introduction of active specific immunotherapy as an adjunct to conventional therapy of the brain-tumor patient creates the risk of the concomitant induction of experimental allergic encephalomyelitis (EAE). The lack of resolution concerning the total group of central nervous system (CNS) antigens which may be encephalitogenic, and the lack of definition of the necessary conditions for the induction of an anti-CNS myelin response complicate the design of an immunotherapeutic regimen for brain-tumor patients. We report here the ready induction of EAE in four of four guinea pigs and both of two nonhuman primates (Macaca fascicularis) with human glioblastoma multiforme (GBM) tissue injected with either complete or incomplete Freund's adjuvant (CFA, IFA). Immunization protocols utilizing encephalitogenic GBM tissue and adjuvant which did not result in EAE induction were established in both of two macaques, and the production of significant levels of antibodies specifically reactive with immunizing GBM-derived cultured cell lines in all of 12 macaques without EAE induction was demonstrated. As the lower detection limit of the sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylimide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) assay for human myelin basic protein (HBP) was 0.6 µg HBP/gel, and an extract prepared from WR-GBM tumor tissue contained less than 0.6 µg of detectable HBP/25 µg of pH 3 extractable protein, and as 100 to 1000 µg of purified human basic protein (HBP) failed to induce EAE in three of three macaques, it was hypothesized that 1) GBM tissue may act as an adjuvant and markedly lower myelin basic protein (MBP) threshold doses for EAE induction, that 2) MBP encephalitogenic fragments capable of EAE induction may be present in GBM tissue but difficult to quantitate in precipitates by in vitro methods, or that 3) secondary encephalitogenic antigens unrelated to MBP may be present in GBM tissue. The threat of EAE induction and the potential difficulty of its detection in the deteriorating brain-tumor patient receiving active specific immunotherapy warrants a biological screen in immunizing CNS material in experimental animals prior to administration to patients in immunotherapy protocols.