The effects of host carbogen (95% oxygen/5% carbon dioxide) breathing on metabolic characteristics of Morris hepatoma 9618a

Carbogen breathing differentially enhances blood plasma volume and 5-fluorouracil uptake in two murine colon tumor models with a distinct vascular structure

For the systemic treatment of colorectal cancer, 5-fluorouracil (FU)-based chemotherapy is the standard. However, only a subset of patients responds to chemotherapy. Breathing of carbogen (95% O2 and 5% CO2) may increase the uptake of FU through changes in tumor physiology. This study aims to monitor in animal models in vivo the effects of carbogen breathing on tumor blood plasma volume, pH, and energy status, and on FU uptake and metabolism in two colon tumor models C38 and C26a, which differ in their vascular structure and hypoxic status. Phosphorus-31 magnetic resonance spectroscopy (MRS) was used to assess tumor pH and energy status, and fluorine-19 MRS was used to follow FU uptake and metabolism. Advanced magnetic resonance imaging methods using ultrasmall particles of iron oxide were performed to assess blood plasma volume. The results showed that carbogen breathing significantly decreased extracellular pH and increased tumor blood plasma volume and FU uptake in tumors. These effects were most significant in the C38 tumor line, which has the largest relative vascular area. In the C26a tumor line, carbogen breathing increased tumor growth delay by FU. In this study, carbogen breathing also enhanced systemic toxicity by FU.

Investigations in vivo of the effects of carbogen breathing on 5-fluorouracil pharmacokinetics and physiology of solid rodent tumours

PURPOSE

We have shown previously that carbogen (95% 0(2), 5% CO(2)) breathing by rodents can increase uptake of anticancer drugs into tumours. The aim of this study was to extend these observations to other rodent models using the anticancer drug 5-fluorouracil (5FU). 5FU pharmacokinetics in tumour and plasma and physiological effects on the tumour by carbogen were investigated to determine the locus of carbogen action on augmenting tumour uptake of 5FU.

METHODS

Two different tumour models were used, rat GH3 prolactinomas xenografted s.c. into nude mice and rat H9618a hepatomas grown s.c. in syngeneic Buffalo rats. Uptake and metabolism of 5FU in both tumour models with or without host carbogen breathing was studied non-invasively using fluorine-19 magnetic resonance spectroscopy ((19)F-MRS), while plasma samples from Buffalo rats were used to construct a NONMEM pharmacokinetic model. Physiological effects of carbogen on tumours were studied using (31)P-MRS for energy status (NTP/Pi) and pH, and gradient-recalled echo magnetic resonance imaging (GRE-MRI) for blood flow and oxygenation.

RESULTS

In both tumour models, carbogan-induced GRE-MRI signal intensity increases of approximately 60% consistent with an increase in tumour blood oxygenation and/or flow. In GH3 xenografts, (19)F-MRS showed that carbogen had no significant effect on 5FU uptake and metabolism by the tumours, and (31)P-MRS showed there was no change in the NTP/Pi ratio. In H9618a hepatomas, (19)F-MRS showed that carbogen had no effect on tumour 5FU uptake but significantly ( p=0.0003) increased 5FU elimination from the tumour (i.e. decreased the t(1/2)) and significantly ( p=0.029) increased (53%) the rate of metabolism to cytotoxic fluoronucleotides (FNuct). The pharmacokinetic analysis showed that carbogen increased the rate of tumour uptake of 5FU from the plasma but also increased the rate of removal. (31)P-MRS showed there were significant ( p<or=0.02) increases in the hepatoma NTP/Pi ratio of 49% and transmembrane pH gradient of 0.11 units.

CONCLUSIONS

We suggest that carbogen can transiently increase tumour blood flow, but this effect alone may not increase uptake of anticancer drugs without a secondary mechanism operating. In the case of the hepatoma, the increase in tumour energy status and pH gradient may be sufficient to augment 5FU metabolism to cytotoxic FNuct, while in the GH3 xenografts this was not the case. Thus carbogen breathing does not universally lead to increased uptake of anticancer drugs.

Effects of nicotinamide and carbogen in different murine colon carcinomas: Immunohistochemical analysis of vascular architecture and microenvironmental parameters

PURPOSE

To investigate oxygenation, perfusion, and cell proliferation in two murine colon carcinoma lines with known differences in chemotherapy sensitivity and analyze the effect of nicotinamide and carbogen on these tumor characteristics.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Mice with s.c. transplanted C38 and C26a murine colon tumors were treated with nicotinamide and carbogen and compared with control tumors. Two markers of hypoxia, CCI-103F and pimonidazole, were injected before and after treatment with nicotinamide/carbogen, respectively, allowing each tumor to serve as its own control. Hoechst33342 was used as a perfusion marker and bromodeoxyuridine (BrdUrd) as a proliferation marker. Frozen tumors were cut for multistep immunostaining and computer-controlled microscope scanning for hypoxic fractions (HF), perfused fractions (PF), vascular density, and BrdUrd-labeling index (LI).

RESULTS

Microscopic observation of C38 and C26a tumors showed extensive differences in vascular architecture, distribution patterns of hypoxia, and BrdUrd-labeling. Quantitative analysis of C38 and C26a tumors showed a decrease in HF in response to all treatment modalities. For C38 tumors, the average decrease in HF in response to carbogen containing treatments was larger than to nicotinamide alone. In C26a tumors, no difference in average decrease in HF was observed between the treatments. The PF of C38 and C26a did not change in response to treatment. The LI of C38 and C26a decreased upon all treatments, which was statistically significant in the combination treatment of C38.

CONCLUSIONS

The mechanism that can simultaneously explain all the observed changes in response to treatment may be the conversion of metabolism from less respiration toward more glycolysis due to increased glucose levels (Crabtree effect), although other mechanisms of actions cannot be excluded.

Effects of tumour acidification with glucose+MIBG on the spontaneous metastatic potential of two murine cell lines

In addition to hypoxia, acidic extracellular pH (pH_e) is recognised as one of the microenvironmental characteristics of solid tumours. A number of studies have examined ways to increase tumour acidity in order to improve tumour-specific targeting of certain drugs and the effectiveness of hyperthermia. However, previous data have shown that exposure of murine tumour cells to acid conditions in culture can enhance their metastatic potential when injected subsequently into mice, raising the concern that deliberate tumour acidification might increase the probability of metastasis. In this study, we examined the effects of in vivo tumour acidification and hypoxia on the spontaneous metastatic potential of the murine KHT-C fibrosarcoma and B16F1 melanoma cell lines. A tumour-specific increase in extracellular acidity, demonstrated by measurements with pH electrodes, was achieved by daily intraperitoneal injections of meta-iodo-benzylguanidine (MIBG) and/or glucose. This method of tumour acidification during tumour growth did not significantly enhance the spontaneous metastatic potential of the two murine cell lines.

Morphological and carbogen-based functional MRI of a chemically induced liver tumor model in mice

A multifocal mouse liver tumor model chemically induced with 5,9-dimethyl-7H-dibenzo[c,g]carbazole was investigated by respiratory-triggered morphological and functional MRI (fMRI) at 4.7 Tesla. The model is characterized by the presence of two tumor types: hypovascular cholangioma and vascularized hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC). Growth curves measured by 3D-MRI showed limited growth of cholangiomas and rapid growth of HCCs after a latency of about 25 weeks. Functional imaging based on T(2) (*)-weighted fast gradient-echo MRI and carbogen breathing was optimized for liver imaging in mice. A response to carbogen was observed in HCCs but not in cholangiomas. Transversal analysis (50 HCCs) of signal change upon carbogen revealed four different types of response patterns: 1) signal increase upon carbogen administration (74%); 2) small or insignificant signal change (10%), 3) transient signal decrease and delayed increase (8%), and 4) signal decrease (8%). Longitudinal follow-up of a subgroup (N = 17) showed that an initially observed type 1 response, attesting to the presence of a functional vasculature, remained stable for at least 3 weeks in 14 HCCs. A switch from a type 1 response to another response type may be useful for demonstrating, in a noninvasive manner, a disturbance of tumor vasculature induced by anti-vascular or anti-angiogenic therapy.

Carbon dioxide reactivity of computed tomography functional parameters in rabbit VX2 soft tissue tumour

Tumour blood flow is one of the important factors limiting the efficacy of radiation therapy (hypoxic radioresistance), chemotherapy (drug delivery) and thermal therapy (heat dissipation) in treating cancer. The modification of tumour blood flow has been an area of intense investigation. In the current study, the arterial carbon dioxide tension (PaCO2) was changed in order to investigate the tumour vascular response to carbon dioxide. Functional maps of blood flow, blood volume and mean transit time were generated at four PaCO2 levels in VX2 tumour in the rabbit thigh and normal soft tissue. The PaCO2 levels investigated were normocapnia (PaCO2 = 40.9 +/- 1.2 mmHg), hypocapnia (27.2 +/- 2.3 and 33.5 +/- 2.3 mmHg) and hypercapnia (54.9 +/- 4.4 mmHg). The carbon dioxide reactivity of the global tumour blood flow and mean transit time showed significant differences between normocapnia and the two levels of hypocapnia, but not between normocapnia and hypercapnia. The average fractional change of blood flow from normocapnia for the two levels of hypocapnia was -0.41 +/- 0.06 and -0.29 +/- 0.08, respectively (P < 0.05). In the case of mean transit time the fractional change was +0.39 +/- 0.30 and +0.23 +/- 0.24, respectively (P < 0.05). The fractional change of blood volume from normocapnia, however, was not significantly different at any capnic level, as was the case with respect to each of the functional parameters in normal tissue. The ability to reduce blood flow and increase mean transit time through hypocapnia has significant implications in thermal therapy, since heat dissipation is a major factor in limiting the effectiveness of treatment.

Enhanced uptake of ifosfamide into GH3 prolactinomas with hypercapnic hyperoxic gases monitored in vivo by (31)P MRS

Previously, (31)P magnetic resonance spectroscopy (MRS) has been used to detect ifosfamide (IF) in vivo and to show that breathing carbogen (5% CO(2)/95% O(2)) enhances the uptake and increases the efficacy of IF in rat GH3 prolactinomas [Rodrigues LM, Maxwell RJ, McSheehy PMJ, Pinkerton CR, Robinson SP, Stubbs M, and Griffiths JR (1997). In vivo detection of ifosfamide by (31)P MRS in rat tumours; increased uptake and cytotoxicity induced by carbogen breathing in GH3 prolactinomas. Br J Cancer 75, 62-68]. We now show that other hypercapnic and/or hyperoxic (5% CO(2) in air, 2.5% CO(2) in O(2)) gas mixtures also increase the uptake of IF into tumors, measured by (31)P MRS. All gases caused an increased uptake (C(max)) of IF compared to air breathing, with carbogen inducing the largest increase (85% (P<.02) compared to 46% with 2.5% CO(2) in O(2) (P<.004) and 48% with 5% CO(2) in air (P<.004)). The T(max) (time of maximum concentration in tumor posintravenous injection of IF) was significantly (P<.04) later in the cohort that breathed 5% CO(2) in air. The increased uptake of IF with carbogen breathing was selective to tumor tissue and there were no significant increases in any of the normal tissues studied, suggesting that any host tissue toxicity would be minimal. Carbogen breathing by patients causes breathlessness. There was no significant difference in IF uptake between breathing carbogen and 2.5% CO(2) in O(2) and, therefore, the ability of 2.5% CO(2) in O(2) to also increase IF uptake may be clinically useful as it causes less patient discomfort.

MRI of the tumor microenvironment

The microenvironment within tumors is significantly different from that in normal tissues. A major difference is seen in the chaotic vasculature of tumors, which results in unbalanced blood supply and significant perfusion heterogeneities. As a consequence, many regions within tumors are transiently or chronically hypoxic. This exacerbates tumor cells' natural tendency to overproduce acids, resulting in very acidic pH values. The hypoxia and acidity of tumors have important consequences for antitumor therapy and can contribute to the progression of tumors to a more aggressive metastatic phenotype. Over the past decade, techniques have emerged that allow the interrogation of the tumor microenvironment with high resolution and molecularly specific probes. Techniques are available to interrogate perfusion, vascular distribution, pH, and pO(2) nondestructively in living tissues with relatively high precision. Studies employing these methods have provided new insights into the causes and consequences of the hostile tumor microenvironment. Furthermore, it is quite exciting that there are emerging techniques that generate tumor image contrast via ill-defined mechanisms. Elucidation of these mechanisms will yield further insights into the tumor microenvironment. This review attempts to identify techniques and their application to tumor biology, with an emphasis on nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) approaches. Examples are also discussed using electron MR, optical, and radionuclear imaging techniques.

The modification of human tumour blood flow using pentoxifylline, nicotinamide and carbogen

AIM

To assess the effect of combining oral nicotinamide, oral pentoxifylline and carbogen gas (2% CO2, 98% O2) breathing on human tumour red cell flux.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Microregional red blood cell flux was measured in accessible tumour nodules using laser Doppler microprobes in 11 patients with histologically proven malignancy. Patients received single oral doses of nicotinamide 40 mgkg-1 and pentoxifylline 1200 mg 2h before a 10-min period of carbogen gas breathing, corresponding to peak plasma concentrations of these drugs. Red cell flux in up to six microregions in each tumour was measured for 30 min, recording pre-, during and post-carbogen breathing for 10 min each.

RESULTS

Data from ten of the 11 patients could be assessed. The red cell flux in 48 microregions was analysed and the mean red cell flux was calculated. A mean relative increase in red cell flux of 1.18 (+/-0.09, 95% confidence interval (CI)) was observed after 6 min of carbogen breathing, 2h after the administration of nicotinamide and pentoxifylline. This compares to relative increases of 1.4 (+/-0.39, 95%CI) after nicotinamide with carbogen and 1.15 (+/-0.10, 95%CI) after pentoxifylline with carbogen. These differences are not statistically significant (P>0.05). The increased red cell flux persisted after the cessation of carbogen gas breathing.

CONCLUSIONS

A combination of pentoxifylline, nicotinamide and carbogen produces an increase in human tumour red cell flux, similar to that observed when each of the drugs are used alone with carbogen breathing.

Issues in flow and oxygenation dependent contrast (FLOOD) imaging of tumours

The sensitivity of blood oxygenation level dependent (BOLD) contrast techniques to changes to tumour deoxyhaemoglobin concentration is of relevance to many strategies in cancer treatments. In the context of tumour studies, which frequently involve the use of agents to modify blood flow, there are underlying physiological changes different to those of BOLD in the brain. Hence we use the term, flow and oxygenation dependent (FLOOD) contrast, to emphasize this difference and the importance of flow effects. We have measured the R(2)* changes in a prolactinoma tumour model for a variety of vasoactive challenges [carbogen, 100% oxygen and 100% nitrogen as different breathing gases, and administration of tumour blood flow modifiers such as calcitonin gene related peptide (CGRP), hydralazine and nicotinamide]. In addition we have measured other relevant physiological parameters, such as bioenergetic status from (31)P MRS, and blood pH and glucose, that may change during a vasoactive challenge. Here we discuss how they relate to our understanding of FLOOD contrast in tumours. We frequently observe R(2)* changes that match the expected action of the vascular stimulus: R(2)* decreases with agents expected to improve tumour oxygenation and blood flow, and increases with agents designed to increase tumour hypoxia. Unlike most normal tissues, tumours have a chaotic and poorly regulated blood supply, and a mix of glycolytic and oxidative metabolism; thus the response to a vasoactive challenge is not predictable. Changes in blood volume can counteract the effect of blood oxygenation changes, and changes in blood pH and glucose levels can alter oxygen extraction. This can lead to R(2)* changes that are smaller or the reverse of those expected. To properly interpret FLOOD contrast changes these effects must be accounted for.

Oxygen tension in primary gynaecological tumours: the influence of carbon dioxide concentration

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

To assess the effect of inhalation of various high oxygen content gases (HOCG) with different carbon dioxide concentrations on the tumour oxygen tension in patients with primary gynaecological malignancies.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Tumour oxygen tension was assessed on two protocols in those patients with locally advanced visible or palpable primary gynaecological malignancies. Patients were assessed initially while breathing room air (R/A). After 4 min of inhaling the first HOCG, a second assessment of the oxygen tension within the tumour was made. After a 10 min rest period while inhaling R/A, the second HOCG was administered for 4 min after which the third set of measurements were obtained. Protocol A involved assessing the tumour oxygen tension in 12 patients while breathing R/A, 100% oxygen (O(2)) and 5% carbogen (95% O(2), 5% CO(2)). For protocol B, tumour oxygen tension assessments of 13 patients while breathing R/A, 2.5% carbogen (97.5% O(2), 2.5% CO(2)), and 5% carbogen. Median pO(2) and percentage of values </=2.5 mmHg were assessed.

RESULTS

Regarding protocol A, the median of the median pO(2) values increased from 5 mmHg when breathing R/A to 47 mmHg for 100% O(2) and to 105 mmHg for 5% carbogen inhalation. The median of the percentage of values </=2. 5 mmHg decreased: 17% for R/A vs. 16% for 100% O(2) (P=ns) vs. 0% for 5% carbogen (P=0.015). In protocol B, the median of the median pO(2) values increased from 3 mmHg when breathing R/A to 73 mmHg when inhaling 2.5% carbogen and to 72 mmHg for 5% carbogen inhalation. The median of the percentage of values </=2.5 mmHg decreased with both carbogen mixtures compared with room air: 42% for R/A vs. 0% for 2.5% carbogen (P=0.05) and 3% for 5% carbogen (P=0.015). No statistically significant difference in this parameter was found between the two carbogen concentrations.

CONCLUSION

Oxygen tension as measured with an Eppendorf pO(2) histograph, increased with inhalation of the oxygen and carbon dioxide gas mixtures tested. While 100% oxygen inhalation increased the median pO(2) compared with R/A a significantly greater increase in oxygen tension was seen with inhalation of either carbogen gas mixture. Pure oxygen inhalation did not decrease the percentage of values </=2.5 mmHg whereas inhalation of either 2.5 and 5% carbogen gas resulted in a significant decrease in this parameter. Both carbogen concentrations appear equal at increasing the oxygen tension in primary gynaecological tumours as measured with the Eppendorf pO(2) histograph.

Effect of carbogen breathing on the pharmacodynamics of 5-fluorouracil in a murine colon carcinoma

To determine whether carbogen breathing has an effect on 5-fluorouracil (5-FU) uptake, retention and metabolism in C38 murine colon tumours grown in C57Bl/6 mice, we used in vivo 19F nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy. Eleven tumour-bearing mice were treated with 150 mg/kg of 5-FU given intraperitoneally (i.p.). Five mice received carbogen gas (95% O(2) and 5% CO(2)) for 9.5 min, starting 1 min before 5-FU administration. We found increased levels of 5-FU and its anabolites and catabolites by sequential ¿19F NMR spectroscopy in the group treated with 5-FU in combination with carbogen compared with the group treated with 5-FU alone. The maximum of normalised values of 5-FU and its metabolites, reached after carbogen breathing, was almost 2-fold higher than after treatment with 5-FU alone. Despite these increased concentrations no significant effect of carbogen on growth inhibition of the tumour by 5-FU was observed, which may be related to the size as well as the well vascularised and perfused conditions of the tumours studied.

Effects of nicotinamide and carbogen on tumour oxygenation, blood flow, energetics and blood glucose levels

Both host carbogen (95% oxygen/5% carbon dioxide) breathing and nicotinamide administration enhance tumour radiotherapeutic response and are being re-evaluated in the clinic. Non-invasive magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and 31P magnetic resonance spectroscopy (MRS) methods have been used to give information on the effects of nicotinamide alone and in combination with host carbogen breathing on transplanted rat GH3 prolactinomas. Gradient recalled echo (GRE) MRI, sensitive to blood oxygenation changes, and spin echo (SE) MRI, sensitive to perfusion/flow, showed large signal intensity increases with carbogen breathing. Nicotinamide, thought to act by suppressing the transient closure of small blood vessels that cause intermittent tumour hypoxia, induced a small increase in blood oxygenation but no detectable change in perfusion/flow. Carbogen combined with nicotinamide was no more effective than carbogen alone. Both carbogen and nicotinamide caused significant increases in the nucleoside triphosphate/inorganic phosphate (betaNTP/Pi) ratio, implying that the tumour cells normally receive sub-optimal substrate supply, and is consistent with either increased glycolysis and/or a switch to more oxidative metabolism. The most striking observation was the marked increase in blood glucose (twofold) induced by both nicotinamide and carbogen. Whether this may play a role in tumour radiosensitivity has yet to be determined.

Enhancement of tumor perfusion and oxygenation by carbogen and nicotinamide during single- and multifraction irradiation

Numerous experimental and clinical studies have been completed regarding the effects of carbogen and nicotinamide on tumor oxygenation and radiosensitivity. The current study incorporates three physiological measurement techniques to further define spatial variations in oxygen availability and development of hypoxia after single- and multifraction irradiation in KHT murine fibrosarcomas. Distances to anatomical and perfused blood vessels were measured using immunohistochemical and fluorescent staining, intravascular oxygen levels were determined cryospectrophotometrically, and tumor hypoxia was quantified using uptake of EF5, a marker of hypoxia. Carbogen, nicotinamide, and the combination of both all increased intravascular oxygen availability compared to controls. While nicotinamide had no effect on the number of perfused blood vessels in nonirradiated tumors, carbogen produced a substantial closing of vessels. After a single dose of 4 Gy, only the combination of nicotinamide and carbogen produced significant improvements in oxygen availability, while numbers of perfused vessels were significantly increased for nicotinamide, unchanged for the combination of nicotinamide and carbogen, and significantly decreased for carbogen. After 4 x 4-Gy fractions, oxygen availability was increased substantially with the combination of nicotinamide and carbogen, somewhat with carbogen, and not at all with nicotinamide. Tumor oxygenation changes were estimated by EF5/Cy3 intensity distributions, which demonstrated that manipulative agents could produce disparate effects on tumor hypoxia when combined with either single- or multifraction irradiation.

Clinical outcome and tumour microenvironmental effects of accelerated radiotherapy with carbogen and nicotinamide

Experimental studies have shown an almost 2-fold increase in effectiveness if accelerated radiotherapy combined with carbogen and nicotinamide (ARCON) was compared with standard radiotherapy. This combination was chosen in order to overcome repopulation of clonogens during radiotherapy and to minimize tumour hypoxia. Analysis of microenvironmental parameters is required to identify tumours that can benefit from these new treatment approaches. In this study 124 patients with stage III or IV head and neck squamous cell carcinomas received ARCON treatment. Vascular architecture, perfusion, proliferation and oxygenation were studied in two human laryngeal squamous cell carcinoma xenograft lines and the effects of carbogen and nicotinamide were analysed. Loco-regional control for stage III-IV larynx carcinomas was 85%, for hypopharynx carcinomas 50% and for oral cavity and oropharynx carcinomas 65%. In the experimental studies, carbogen treatment resulted in one tumour line in a decrease of blood perfusion, which was reversed if nicotinamide was added. The other tumour line showed no perfusion changes after carbogen or nicotinamide treatment. Both tumour lines showed a drastic reduction of hypoxia after carbogen breathing only or carbogen breathing plus nicotinamide. The ARCON schedule results in high loco-regional tumour control rates. Analysis of tumour microenvironmental parameters showed differences in response to carbogen and nicotinamide between different tumour lines of similar histology and site of origin. This indicates that it may be advantageous to base the selection of patients for oxygenation modifying treatment on microenvironmental tumour characteristics.

Response of hepatoma 9618a and normal liver to host carbogen and carbon monoxide breathing

The effects of hyperoxia (induced by host carbogen [95% oxygen/5% carbon dioxide breathing] and hypoxia (induced by host carbon monoxide [CO at 660 ppm] breathing) were compared by using noninvasive magnetic resonance (MR) methods to gain simultaneous information on blood flow/oxygenation and the bioenergetic status of rat Morris H9618a hepatomas. Both carbogen and CO breathing induced a 1.5- to 2-fold increase in signal intensity in blood oxygenation level dependent (BOLD) MR images. This was due to a decrease in deoxyhemoglobin (deoxyHb), which acts as an endogenous contrast agent, caused either by formation of oxyhemoglobin in the case of carbogen breathing, or carboxyhemoglobin with CO breathing. The results were confirmed by observation of similar changes in deoxyHb in arterial blood samples examined ex vivo after carbogen or CO breathing. There was no change in nucleoside triphosphates (NTP)/P(i) in either tumor or liver after CO breathing, whereas NTP/P(i) increased twofold in the hepatoma (but not in the liver) after carbogen breathing. No changes in tumor intracellular pH were seen after either treatment, whereas extracellular pH became more alkaline after CO breathing and more acid after carbogen breathing, respectively. This tumor type and the liver are unaffected by CO breathing at 660 ppm, which implies an adequate oxygen supply.