DNA cancer vaccines: a gene gun approach

Application of DNA Replicons in Gene Therapy and Vaccine Development

DNA-based gene therapy and vaccine development has received plenty of attention lately. DNA replicons based on self-replicating RNA viruses such as alphaviruses and flaviviruses have been of particular interest due to the amplification of RNA transcripts leading to enhanced transgene expression in transfected host cells. Moreover, significantly reduced doses of DNA replicons compared to conventional DNA plasmids can elicit equivalent immune responses. DNA replicons have been evaluated in preclinical animal models for cancer immunotherapy and for vaccines against infectious diseases and various cancers. Strong immune responses and tumor regression have been obtained in rodent tumor models. Immunization with DNA replicons has provided robust immune responses and protection against challenges with pathogens and tumor cells. DNA replicon-based COVID-19 vaccines have shown positive results in preclinical animal models.

Nonviral Delivery Systems of mRNA Vaccines for Cancer Gene Therapy

In recent years, the use of messenger RNA (mRNA) in the fields of gene therapy, immunotherapy, and stem cell biomedicine has received extensive attention. With the development of scientific technology, mRNA applications for tumor treatment have matured. Since the SARS-CoV-2 infection outbreak in 2019, the development of engineered mRNA and mRNA vaccines has accelerated rapidly. mRNA is easy to produce, scalable, modifiable, and not integrated into the host genome, showing tremendous potential for cancer gene therapy and immunotherapy when used in combination with traditional strategies. The core mechanism of mRNA therapy is vehicle-based delivery of in vitro transcribed mRNA (IVT mRNA), which is large, negatively charged, and easily degradable, into the cytoplasm and subsequent expression of the corresponding proteins. However, effectively delivering mRNA into cells and successfully activating the immune response are the keys to the clinical transformation of mRNA therapy. In this review, we focus on nonviral nanodelivery systems of mRNA vaccines used for cancer gene therapy and immunotherapy.

Viral and nonviral delivery systems for gene delivery

Gene therapy is the process of introducing foreign genomic materials into host cells to elicit a therapeutic benefit. Although initially the main focus of gene therapy was on special genetic disorders, now diverse diseases with different patterns of inheritance and acquired diseases are targets of gene therapy. There are 2 major categories of gene therapy, including germline gene therapy and somatic gene therapy. Although germline gene therapy may have great potential, because it is currently ethically forbidden, it cannot be used; however, to date human gene therapy has been limited to somatic cells. Although numerous viral and nonviral gene delivery systems have been developed in the last 3 decades, no delivery system has been designed that can be applied in gene therapy of all kinds of cell types in vitro and in vivo with no limitation and side effects. In this review we explain about the history of gene therapy, all types of gene delivery systems for germline (nuclei, egg cells, embryonic stem cells, pronuclear, microinjection, sperm cells) and somatic cells by viral [retroviral, adenoviral, adeno association, helper-dependent adenoviral systems, hybrid adenoviral systems, herpes simplex, pox virus, lentivirus, Epstein-Barr virus)] and nonviral systems (physical: Naked DNA, DNA bombardant, electroporation, hydrodynamic, ultrasound, magnetofection) and (chemical: Cationic lipids, different cationic polymers, lipid polymers). In addition to the above-mentioned, advantages, disadvantages, and practical use of each system are discussed.

Trypanosoma cruzi calreticulin: a novel virulence factor that binds complement C1 on the parasite surface and promotes infectivity

In Trypanosoma cruzi, calreticulin (TcCRT) translocates from the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) to the area of flagellum emergence. We propose herein that the parasite uses this molecule to capture complement C1, in an infective apoptotic mimicry strategy. Thus, TcCRT/C1 interactions, besides inhibiting the classical pathway of complement activation as previously shown in our laboratories, will also promote infectivity. This fact correlates with significant increases in TcCRT mRNA levels during early infection stages of a VERO cell line. In vitro, the collagenous and globular C1q domains simultaneously bind TcCRT and antigen aggregated Igs, respectively. Accordingly, mouse immunizations with TcCRT induced humoral responses that, after challenge, correlated with increased parasitemia. Thus, on the parasite surface, whole Igs anti-TcCRT promote C1 deposits on trypomastigotes while, as expected, F(ab')₂ fragments decrease it. Likewise, pretreatment of the parasites with whole anti-TcCRT antibodies augmented parasitemia and mortality in mice. In contrast, pretreatment with F(ab')₂ fragments anti-TcCRT, devoid of their capacity to provide additional C1q binding sites, was protective. Most important, while pretreatment of trypomastigotes with C1q increased infectivity in the RAW murine cell line, as well as mice mortality and parasitemia, the F(ab')₂ fragments significantly interfered with the C1q-dependent infectivity. Differently from other surface molecules involved in infectivity, TcCRT uses C1 as an adaptor molecule to recognize host cells. As expected, since TcCRT is one of several cell surface parasite molecules participating in infectivity, attempts to interfere with the C1/TcCRT interactions with F(ab')₂ fragments, were moderately but significantly effective, both in vitro and in vivo.

Overview of drug delivery and alternative methods to electroporation

This chapter provides an overview of the application of electroporation to areas other than gene delivery. These areas include the delivery of drugs and vaccines to tissues and tumors as well as into and through the skin. Achievements and limitations of electroporation in these areas are presented. Alternative physical methods for gene and drug delivery besides electroporation are described. The advantages and drawbacks of electroporation, compared with these methods, are also discussed.

Vaccines for human papillomavirus-associated anogenital disease and cervical cancer: practical and theoretical approaches

The association of genital warts, cervical dysplasia and cervical cancer with certain human papillomavirus (HPV) types indicates that vaccine strategies that target the virus could be effective in controlling disease onset and progression. Three vaccine strategies are available. Firstly, a prophylactic approach of immunisation with HPV virus-like particles to elicit neutralising antibody would prevent infection. Secondly, vaccination targeting replicating virus in suprabasal cells of infected anogenital epithelium would be an effective therapy for infection and early dysplasias. Thirdly, immunotherapy directed to the oncoprotein products of the HPV E6 and E7 open reading frames would be effective in the control of cervical carcinoma. We examine how these strategies may be augmented by contemporary vaccine technologies, in particular through the use of live recombinant vaccine vectors, specific targeting of antigen processing pathways, dendritic cell and 'polytope' approaches, to produce 'designer' vaccines of maximum specificity and efficacy. How these approaches are being exploited by vaccine manufacturers and in clinical trials is discussed.

Plasmid vaccines and therapeutics: from design to applications

In the late 1980s, Vical and collaborators discovered that the injection into tissues of unformulated plasmid encoding various proteins resulted in the uptake of the plasmid by cells and expression of the encoded proteins. After this discovery, a period of technological improvements in plasmid delivery and expression and in pharmaceutical and manufacturing development was quickly followed by a plethora of human clinical trials testing the ability of injected plasmid to provide therapeutic benefits. In this chapter, we summarize in detail the technologies used in the most recent company-sponsored clinical trials and discuss the potential for future improvements in plasmid design, manufacturing, delivery, formulation and administration. A generic path for the clinical development of plasmid-based products is outlined and then exemplified using a case study on the development of a plasmid vaccine from concept to clinical trial.

Defensive applications of gene transfer technology in the face of bioterrorism: DNA-based vaccines and immune targeting

Gene transfer involves the introduction of an engineered gene into a person's cells with the expectation that the protein expressed from the gene will produce a therapeutic benefit. Strategies based on this principle have led to the approval of > 600 clinical trials and enrollment of approximately 3500 subjects worldwide in attempts to treat diseases ranging from cancer to AIDS to cystic fibrosis. While gene therapy has met with limited success and still has many hurdles to overcome before it sees wide application, it may be useful as a defensive strategy against bioterrorism agents including infectious microbes and toxins. Although many defensive strategies are possible, immunological strategies are currently the most developed and are being actively applied to the development of strategies against several of the most virulent potential bio-weapons. While most of these strategies are not yet ready for human application, DNA-based vaccines appear to be among the most promising in the fight against bioterrorism.

Immunization with a vaccine that combines the expression of MUC1 and B7 co-stimulatory molecules prolongs the survival of mice and delays the appearance of mouse mammary tumors

Human epithelial mucin (MUC1) is expressed by many carcinomas, including breast cancer cells. This breast cancer-associated antigen has been widely used for immunotherapy, despite the fact that cellular immune responses to MUC1 are impaired in breast cancer patients and MUC1 transgenic animals. Previously, we found that immunogenicity to MUC1 was also impaired in BALB/c mice injected with a mammary tumor cell line (410.4) expressing human MUC1. We suggested that one reason for its weak immunogenicity was the lack of expression of B7 molecules by 410.4 cells. Recognition of antigenic epitopes in conjunction with MHCI/II by the T-cell receptor without co-stimulation by B7/CD28 association resulted in T-cell anergy. Therefore, we attempted to enhance protective anti-MUC1-specific immunity in mice using B7 co-stimulatory molecules as a component of the MUC1 vaccine. We also compared cell-based with DNA-based vaccination strategies. One group of mice was vaccinated with an irradiated, 410.4 syngeneic mammary tumor cell line co-expressing human MUC1 and CD80 or CD86 co-stimulatory molecules, and a second group of mice was vaccinated with plasmids encoding MUC1 and CD80 or CD86. These mice along with appropriate controls were challenged with mammary tumor cell line 4T1, which expresses MUC1. There were significant inhibition on rates of tumor growth and survival in mice vaccinated with irradiated 410.4/MUC1 cells co-expressing either CD80 or CD86 molecules, compared to non-vaccinated animals. In addition, there were also significant delays in the appearance of measurable tumors and their growth in mice vaccinated by gene-gun immunization with plasmids encoding MUC1 and CD80 or CD86.

Individual Analysis of Mice Vaccinated against a Weakly Immunogenic Self Tumor-Specific Antigen Reveals a Correlation between CD8 T Cell Response and Antitumor Efficacy

The weakly immunogenic murine P1A Ag is a useful experimental model for the development of new vaccination strategies that could potentially be used against human tumors. An i.m. DNA-based immunization procedure, consisting of three inoculations with the P1A-coding pBKCMV-P1A plasmid at 10-day intervals, resulted in CTL generation in all treated BALB/c mice. Surprisingly, gene gun skin bombardment with the pBKCMV-P1A vector did not induce CTL, nor was it protective against a lethal challenge with the syngeneic P1A-positive J558 tumor cell line. To speed up the immunization procedure, we pretreated the tibialis anterior muscles with cardiotoxin, which induces degeneration of myocytes while sparing immature satellite cells. The high muscle-regenerative activity observable after cardiotoxin inoculation was associated with infiltration of inflammatory cells and expression of proinflammatory cytokines. A single pBKCMV-P1A plasmid inoculation in cardiotoxin-treated BALB/c mice allowed for sustained expansion of P1A-specific CTL and the induction of strong lytic activity in <2 wk. Cardiotoxin adjuvanticity could not be replaced by another muscle-degenerating substance, such as bupivacaine, or by MF59, a Th1 response-promoting adjuvant. Although this vaccination schedule failed to induce tumor rejection in all immunized mice, the analysis of CD8 T cell responses at an individual mouse level disclosed that the cytotoxic activity of P1A-specific CTL was correlated to the antitumor efficacy. These results highlight the critical need to identify reliable, specific immunological parameters that may predict success or failure of an immune response against cancer.

Enhancing effect of vaxfectin on the ability of a Japanese encephalitis DNA vaccine to induce neutralizing antibody in mice

Vaxfectin, a recently developed adjuvant, was evaluated for its enhancing effect on immunogenicity of a Japanese encephalitis (JE) DNA vaccine plasmid encoding the JE virus premembrane (prM) and envelope (E) genes (designated pcJEME), using BALB/c and ICR mice. Formulation of pcJEME with Vaxfectin provided > or =8-fold higher neutralizing antibody titers than those induced by pcJEME alone and reduced the amount of pcJEME to one-tenth to induce comparable levels of neutralizing antibody. Use of Vaxfectin did not alter a Th1 type IgG isotype immune response (IgG1 < IgG2a) induced by pcJEME in mice. These results indicate that Vaxfectin has an ability to enhance immunogenicity of pcJEME and is considered as a useful adjuvant for DNA vaccines in murine experimental models.

Gene therapy: theoretical and bioethical concepts

Gene therapy holds great promise. Somatic gene therapy has the potential to treat a wide range of disorders, including inherited conditions, cancers, and infectious diseases. Early progress has already been made in the treatment of a range of disorders. Ethical issues surrounding somatic gene therapy are primarily those concerned with safety. Germline gene therapy is theoretically possible but raises serious ethical concerns concerning future generations.

Nonredundant roles of antibody, cytokines, and perforin in the eradication of established Her-2/neu carcinomas

Since the mechanisms by which specific immunity destroys Her-2/neu carcinoma cells are highly undetermined, these were assessed in BALB/c mice vaccinated with plasmids encoding extracellular and transmembrane domains of the protein product (p185(neu)) of the rat Her-2/neu oncogene shot into the skin by gene gun. Vaccinated mice rejected a lethal challenge of TUBO carcinoma cells expressing p185(neu). Depletion of CD4 T cells during immunization abolished the protection, while depletion of CD8 cells during the effector phase halved it, and depletion of polymorphonuclear granulocytes abolished all protection. By contrast, Ig mu-chain gene KO mice, as well as Fcgamma receptor I/III, beta-2 microglobulin, CD1, monocyte chemoattractant protein 1 (MCP1), IFN-gamma, and perforin gene KO mice were protected. Only mice with both IFN-gamma and perforin gene KOs were not protected. Although immunization also cured all BALB/c mice bearing established TUBO carcinomas, it did not cure any of the perforin KO or perforin and IFN-gamma KO mice. Few mice were cured that had knockouts of the gene for Ig mu-chain, Fcgamma receptor I/III, IFN-gamma, or beta-2 microglobulin. Moreover, vaccination cured half of the CD1 and the majority of the MCP1 KO mice. The eradication of established p185(neu) carcinomas involves distinct mechanisms, each endowed with a different curative potential.

Gene transfer in higher animals: theoretical considerations and key concepts

Gene transfer technology provides the ability to genetically manipulate the cells of higher animals. Gene transfer permits both germline and somatic alterations. Such genetic manipulation is the basis for animal transgenesis goals and gene therapy attempts. Improvements in gene transfer are required in terms of transgene design to permit gene targeting, and in terms of transfection approaches to allow improved transgene uptake efficiencies.

An improved method of preparing microcarriers for biolistic transfection

The hand-held gene gun uses a pulse of helium to fire small gold particles coated with desiccated DNA (microcarriers) at target cells. This method of biolistic transfection is becoming increasingly popular as an effective means of rapid gene delivery into mammalian tissue. Current methods of microcarrier preparation, however, are slow (up to 2 days) and can result in variations in transfection efficiency due to a number of problems including shearing of DNA, agglomeration and adhesion of gold particles. Here we describe an improved, more rapid method of microcarrier preparation. To evaluate the new procedure we have used DNA encoding yellow fluorescent protein (EYFP), a modified version of the green fluorescent protein, which we have transfected into HEK293 cells. The data show that transfection by the new method results in high levels of transfection efficiency and low variability compared to an alternative method.

Revealing the potential of DNA-based vaccination: lessons learned from the hepatitis B virus surface antigen

DNA-based vaccination is a novel technique to efficiently stimulate humoral (antibody) and cellular (T cell) immune responses to protein antigens. In DNA-based vaccination, immunogenic proteins are expressed in in vivo transfected cells of the vaccine recipients in their native conformation with correct posttranslational modifications from antigen-encoding expression plasmid DNA. This ensures the integrity of antibody-defined epitopes and supports the generation of protective (neutralizing) antibody titers. Plasmid DNA vaccination is furthermore an exceptionally potent strategy to stimulate CD8+ cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) responses because antigenic peptides are efficiently generated by endogenous processing of intracellular protein antigens. These key features make DNA-based immunization an attractive strategy for prophylactic and therapeutic vaccination against extra- and intracellular pathogens. In this brief review, we summarize the current state of expression vector design, DNA delivery strategies, priming immune responses to intracellular or secreted antigens by DNA vaccines and unique advantages of DNA- versus recombinant protein-based vaccines using the hepatitis B surface antigen (HBsAg) as a model antigen.

Local transgenic expression of granulocyte macrophage-colony stimulating factor initiates autoimmunity

Mechanisms leading to breakdown of immunological tolerance and initiation of autoimmunity are poorly understood. Experimental autoimmune gastritis is a paradigm of organ-specific autoimmunity arising from a pathogenic autoimmune response to gastric H/K ATPase. The gastritis is accompanied by autoantibodies to the gastric H/K ATPase. The best characterized model of experimental autoimmune gastritis requires neonatal thymectomy. This procedure disrupts the immune repertoire, limiting its usefulness in understanding how autoimmunity arises in animals with intact immune systems. Here we tested whether local production of GM-CSF, a pro-inflammatory cytokine, is sufficient to break tolerance and initiate autoimmunity. We generated transgenic mice expressing GM-CSF in the stomach. These transgenic mice spontaneously developed gastritis with an incidence of about 80% after six backcrosses to gastritis-susceptible BALBc/CrSlc mice. The gastritis is accompanied by mucosal hypertrophy, enlargement of draining lymph nodes and autoantibodies to gastric H/K ATPase. An infiltrate of dendritic cells and macrophages preceded CD4 T cells into the gastric mucosa. T cells from draining lymph nodes specifically proliferated to the gastric H/K ATPase. CD4 but not CD8 T cells transferred gastritis to nude mouse recipients. CD4(+) CD25(+) T cells from the spleen retained anergic suppressive properties that were reversed by IL-2. We conclude that local expression of GM-CSF is sufficient to break tolerance and initiate autoimmunity mediated by CD4 T cells. This new mouse model should be useful for studies of organ-specific autoimmunity.

In vivo transfection of lamprey brain neurons by gene gun delivery of DNA

The lamprey has been used extensively in studies of CNS axon regeneration. Progress in determining molecular mechanisms involved in regeneration will require the ability to manipulate expression of target genes or to introduce new genes, but in vivo neuronal transfection has posed difficulties in the mature intact nervous system of vertebrates, including the lamprey. In this paper we report successful transfection of neurons in the brain of living lampreys by means of a hand-held Helios Gene Gun. Particle-mediated ("gene gun") gene transfer has been applied to a variety of cell and tissue types but although it has been used in brain slices and dissociated cultured neurons, to our knowledge it has not been reported as a method for transfection of brain cells in a living animal. Gold particles coated with plasmids containing the gene for the reporter beta-galactosidase were propelled by helium at 150--200 psi toward the exposed floor of the 4th ventricle. Transfected animals were examined by X-gal histochemistry at various recovery times. beta-glactosidase activity was detected as early as 2 days after gene transfer and lasted for at least 6 weeks, the longest time studied. Transgene expression lasted longer in neurons than in glia. The expression product was transported anterogradely into reticulospinal axons and by 6 weeks could be traced into the spinal cord for 8--10 mm caudal to the obex. This raises the possibility of identifying the growth cones of developing or regenerating axons belonging to transfected neurons in functional studies of manipulated genes.

Particle-mediated gene transfer into murine livers using a newly developed gene gun

Although particle-mediated gene transfer using gene gun technology has been applied for gene transfer into epidermis, applications of this technology to visceral tissues have not been well investigated. Although all helium gas-driven gene gun instruments have used macrocarriers to discharge DNA-coated microprojectiles so far, we used a newly developed gene gun instrument, in which a hammering bullet is used to discharge microprojectiles. With the gene gun, gold particles coated with lacZ expression plasmid were discharged to murine livers. LacZ expression was induced much more profoundly in the liver by particle-mediated gene transfer than by simple plasmid injection and electroporation-mediated gene transfer. LacZ expression was broadly and randomly distributed throughout the bombarded livers, indicating that particle-mediated gene transfer can induce transgene expression even at relatively distant areas from the surface of the bombarded tissue. Furthermore, although transgene expression was at its peak on day 2 after the bombardment, it was still detectable even on day 28. These results indicate that particle-mediated gene transfer with a newly developed gene gun may provide a new approach to gene therapy for human diseases.

Cancer vaccines with emphasis on a viral oncolysate melanoma vaccine

Biotherapy of malignant diseases has become the fourth treatment modality besides surgery, chemo- and radiotherapy. Whole cell melanoma vaccines with or without BCG and other adjuvants, purified ganglioside and shed antigens, recombinant viruses carrying tumor antigens, dendritic cells pulsed with antigenic peptides etc. are in clinical trials. Efficacious viral oncolysate vaccines induce the host to mount tumor-specific cytotoxic T-cell response and prevention of relapses is supported by clinical trials. The use of "polyvalent" whole cell vaccines vs. purified or genetically engineered single antigen vaccines is justified as i. only very few single tumor antigens are present in all tumors of a given histological type; and ii. antigen modulation occurs in tumors rendering them resistant to immune attack generated by vaccine against a single antigen. Thus polyvalent vaccines immunize against several antigens vs. against a selected antigen.

Cytokine transgene expression and promoter usage in primary CD34+ cells using particle-mediated gene delivery

Induction or short-term transgenic expression of specific cytokines, growth factors, or other candidate therapeutic genes in hematopoietic progenitor or stem cells is potentially applicable to gene therapy for cancer. In this study, we explored the application of a gene gun technique, as an alternative to viral vectors, for ex vivo gene transfer into and transient gene expression in highly enriched CD34+ cells derived from human umbilical cord blood. Twenty-four hours posttransfection, 32.6 to 1500 pg/l x 10(6) CD34+ cells of transient gene expression was routinely obtained for specific cytokine and reporter genes. Transgene expression at the single-cell level was revealed by X-Gal staining of lacZ cDNA-transfected CD34+ cells. Expression of four candidate therapeutic genes, namely human granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor, tumor necrosis factor alpha, interleukin 2, and interferon gamma, was detectable for 4 to 7 days in CD34+ cells. A human elongation factor 1alpha promoter/intron 1 transcription unit was identified as a strong cellular promoter for CD34+ cells, exhibiting strength similar to that of the commonly employed cytomegalovirus immediate-early promoter. These results suggest that the nonviral, gene gun technique offers an efficient alternative approach for transient transgenic studies of hematopoietic cells and may provide new possibilities for certain cancer gene therapy strategies using CD34+ cells.