Strongly underestimated dispersion energy in cryptophanes and their complexes

Investigation of the complete encapsulation process of the noble gases by cryptophanes

Based on DFT calculations (ωB97XD/def2-SVP/SVPfit), the ability and mechanism of noble gas encapsulation by series of cryptophanes were investigated. The focus was set to study the influence of different functionalization groups placed at the "gates" of cryptophanes cavity entrance by which the energy criteria were chosen as a main indicator for selective encapsulation of noble gases. Chosen functionalization groups were CH3, OCH3, OH, NH2, and Cl, and the encapsulation process of these cryptophanes was compared to a cryptophane without any functionalization group on its outer rim. Those groups were selected based on their different chemical properties and based on their size which will subsequently put additional steric restrictions on the cavity entrance. Chosen functionalization groups, beside their steric influence on the energy barrier magnitude, influence also the gating process through its chemical nature by which they can put an additional stabilization on noble gases encapsulation transition states enhancing the encapsulation process. Objective of this study was clearly to get better insights on the influence of those functional groups on the whole encapsulation process of noble gases. Large-size noble gases (Xe and Rn) from all noble gases are best accommodated in the cavities of selected cryptophanes, on the other hand these noble gases require to pass the highest energy barrier through the gating process. From the series of investigated cryptophanes, the cryptophane with the OCH3 functionalization group has been identified as the one with the best capabilities to host investigated noble gases, but on the other side this cryptophane puts the highest energy criteria required for the previous gating process.

Molecular vessels from preorganised natural building blocks

Supramolecular vessels emerged as tools to mimic and better understand compartmentalisation, a central aspect of living matter. However, many more applications that go beyond those initial goals have been documented in recent years, including new sensory systems, artificial transmembrane transporters, catalysis, and targeted drug or gene delivery. Peptides, carbohydrates, nucleobases, and steroids bear great potential as building blocks for the construction of supramolecular vessels, possessing complexity that is still difficult to attain with synthetic methods - they are rich in functional groups and well-defined stereogenic centers, ready for noncovalent interactions and further functions. One of the options to tame the functional and dynamic complexity of natural building blocks is to place them at spatially designed positions using synthetic scaffolds. In this review, we summarise the historical and recent advances in the construction of molecular-sized vessels by the strategy that couples synthetic predictability and durability of various scaffolds (cyclodextrins, porphyrins, crown ethers, calix[n]arenes, resorcin[n]arenes, pillar[n]arenes, cyclotriveratrylenes, coordination frameworks and multivalent high-symmetry molecules) with functionality originating from natural building blocks to obtain nanocontainers, cages, capsules, cavitands, carcerands or coordination cages by covalent chemistry, self-assembly, or dynamic covalent chemistry with the ultimate goal to apply them in sensing, transport, or catalysis.

A Cyclotriveratrylene Solvent-Dependent Chiral Switch

Chiral molecular switches are attracting attention as they could pave the way to chiral molecular machines. Herein, we report on the design and synthesis of a single molecule chiral switch based on a cyclotriveratrylene scaffold, in which the chirality inversion is controlled by the solvent. Hemicryptophanes are built around a C3 cyclotriveratrylene chiral unit, with either M or P handedness, connected to another tripod and usually displaying an "out" configuration. Here, we demonstrate that solvents are able to control the "in" and "out" configurations of the CTV unit, creating a chiral molecular switch from (M/P)"in" to (P/M)"out" handedness. The full characterization of the "in" and "out" configurations and of the chirality switch were made possible by combining NMR, HPLC, ECD, DFT and molecular dynamics. Interestingly, bulky aromatic solvents such as 2-t-butylphenol favor the "in" configuration while polar aprotic solvents such as acetone favor the "out" configuration. This chiral switch was found to be fully reversible allowing the system to oscillate between two different M and P configurations several times upon the action of solvents stimuli.

Dispersion Interactions in Condensed Phases and inside Molecular Containers

ConspectusThe past decade has seen significant progress in the understanding and appreciation of the importance of London dispersion interactions (LDIs) in supramolecular systems and solutions. The Slater-Kirkwood formula relates LDIs to the molecular polarizabilities of the two interacting molecular species (α) and their interaction distance (a dependence of R-6). When advancing arguments related to intermolecular interactions, it is frequently assumed that molecules with larger molecular polarizabilities are more amenable to larger LDIs. However, arguments related to molecular polarizabilities are not always transferable to the condensed phase. In fact, the underlying bulk and molecular polarizabilities of common solvents show opposing trends. The intuitive concept that aromatic molecules are more polarizable than saturated hydrocarbons and that perfluorinated molecules are less polarizable than saturated hydrocarbons applies to the condensed phase only. When treating association phenomena in solution, where LDIs are generally very attenuated, the use of bulk polarizabilities is recommended, which are experimentally accessible through either refractive index measurements or suitable solvatochromic probes. Such probes can also be used to assess polarizabilities inside molecular container compounds, such as cucurbit[n]urils (CBn), cyclodextrins, calixarenes, and hemicarcerands. These macrocyclic cavities can have extreme microenvironments. For example, the inner concave phase of CB7 has been shown to be weakly polarizable, falling in between the gas phase and perfluorohexane; those of β-cyclodextrin and p-sulfonatocalix[4]arene have been found to be similarly polarizable as water and alkanes, respectively, and the inside of hemicarcerands displays a very large bulk polarizability, exceeding that of diiodomethane. CBn compounds are privileged molecular container compounds, which we exemplify in this Account through case studies. (1) CBn macrocycles are prime water-soluble receptors for hydrocarbons, allowing for the reduction of the binding free energies to two components: the hydrophobic effect and dispersion interactions. To understand hydrocarbon binding, we initiated the HYDROPHOBE challenge, which revealed the shortcomings of both quantum-chemical and molecular dynamics approaches. (2) The smallest CBn receptor, CB5, is uniquely suited to bind the entire noble gas series, where hydrophobic effects and dispersion interactions operate in opposite directions. CB5 was revaled to be a unique synthetic receptor for noble gases, with the dominant driving force being the recovery of the cavitation energies for the hydration of noble gases in aqueous solution. Computational methods that encounter challenges in predicting hydrocarbon affinities and trends for CB6 and CB7 perform well for noble gases binding to CB5. (3) The larger homologue, CB8, allows one to set up intermolecular interaction chambers by the encapsulation of a (first) aromatic guest, thereby tuning LDIs inside the receptor cavity. In this manner, CB8 can be modulated to preferentially bind unsaturated and aromatic rather than saturated hydrocarbons, while the unmodified cavities of the smaller macrocycles CB6 and CB7 show selective binding of saturated hydrocarbons. (4) The (charged) host-guest complexes of CBn hosts are sufficiently stable in the gas phase, allowing for the study of the influence of LDIs on inner-phase chemical reactions. These studies are particularly interesting for the theoretical analysis of isolated host-guest LDIs, as experimental and computational data are directly comparable in the gas phase due to the absence of the solvation effect.

Enantiopure cryptophane derivatives: Synthesis and chiroptical properties

This review addresses the synthesis of enantiopure cryptophane and the study of their chiroptical properties. Cryptophane derivatives represent an important class of macrocyclic compounds that can bind a large range of species in solution under different conditions. The overwhelming majority of these host molecules is chiral, and their chiroptical properties have been thoroughly investigated. The first part of this review is dedicated to the optical resolution and the synthesis of enantiopure cryptophane derivatives. In a second part, the study of the chiroptical properties of these molecular hosts by different techniques such as electronic and vibrational circular dichroism and Raman optical activity is detailed. These techniques allow the determination of the absolute configuration of cryptophane derivatives and provide useful information about their conformation in different conditions.

The Nature of Strong Chalcogen Bonds Involving Chalcogen-Containing Heterocycles

Chalcogen bonds are σ hole interactions and have been used in recent years as an alternative to hydrogen bonds. In general, the electrostatic potential at the chalcogen atom and orbital delocalization effects are made responsible for the orientation of the chalcogen bond. Here, we were able to show by means of SAPT calculations that neither the induction (orbital delocalization effects) nor the electrostatic term is causing the spatial orientation of strong chalcogen bonds in tellurium-containing aromatics. Instead, steric interactions (Pauli repulsion) are responsible for the orientation. Against chemical intuition the dispersion energies of the examined tellurium-containing aromatics are far less important for the net attractive forces compared to the energies in the corresponding sulfur and selenium compounds. Our results underline the importance of often overlooked steric interactions (Pauli repulsion) in conformational control of σ hole interactions.

Molecular Sensing with Host Systems for Hyperpolarized 129Xe

Hyperpolarized noble gases have been used early on in applications for sensitivity enhanced NMR. 129Xe has been explored for various applications because it can be used beyond the gas-driven examination of void spaces. Its solubility in aqueous solutions and its affinity for hydrophobic binding pockets allows "functionalization" through combination with host structures that bind one or multiple gas atoms. Moreover, the transient nature of gas binding in such hosts allows the combination with another signal enhancement technique, namely chemical exchange saturation transfer (CEST). Different systems have been investigated for implementing various types of so-called Xe biosensors where the gas binds to a targeted host to address molecular markers or to sense biophysical parameters. This review summarizes developments in biosensor design and synthesis for achieving molecular sensing with NMR at unprecedented sensitivity. Aspects regarding Xe exchange kinetics and chemical engineering of various classes of hosts for an efficient build-up of the CEST effect will also be discussed as well as the cavity design of host molecules to identify a pool of bound Xe. The concept is presented in the broader context of reporter design with insights from other modalities that are helpful for advancing the field of Xe biosensors.

Adsorption Properties of Hydrated Cr3+ Ions on Schiff-base Covalent Organic Frameworks: A DFT Study

Considering the superior physiochemical property, increasing efforts have been devoted to exploiting the covalent organic frameworks (COFs) materials on the environmental remediation of heavy metal ions. Water pollution caused by Cr³⁺ metal ions is of special concern for scientists and engineers. Notwithstanding all the former efforts made, it is surprising that very little is known about the interaction mechanisms between the hydrated Cr³⁺ metal ions and COF materials. In present context, density functional theory (DFT) method is used to elucidate geometric and electronic properties with the purpose of putting into theoretical perspective the application values and interaction mechanisms for COF materials on Cr³⁺ capture. The results showed that all the five selected Schiff-base COFs materials displayed good adsorption performance on Cr³⁺ removal while the phenazine-linked and imine-COFs possessed the most favorable adsorption capacity due to the optimal chemical units and frameworks. The hydration effect was found to play a two-side role in the adsorption process and interaction mechanisms, involving coordination, hydrogen bonds, as well as weak non-covalent interactions, have been illuminated to explain the observed different adsorption behaviors. This study provides a general guidance for the design and selection of efficient COF materials as high-capacity Cr³⁺ adsorbents.

Preferential binding of unsaturated hydrocarbons in aryl-bisimidazolium·cucurbit[8]uril complexes furbishes evidence for small-molecule π-π interactions

Whilst cucurbit[n]urils (CBn) have been utilized in gas encapsulation, only the smaller CBn (n = 5 and 6) have utility given their small cavity size. In this work, we demonstrate that the large cavity of CB8 can be tailored for gaseous and volatile hydrocarbon encapsulation by restricting its internal cavity size with auxiliary aryl-bisimidazolium (Bis, aryl = phenyl, naphthyl, and biphenyl) guests. The binding constants for light hydrocarbons (C ≤ 4) are similar to those measured with CB6, while larger values are obtained with Bis·CB8 for larger guests. A clear propensity for higher affinities of alkenes relative to alkanes is observed, most pronounced with the largest delocalized naphthalene residue in the auxiliary Bis guest, which provides unique evidence for sizable small-molecule π-π interactions.

Fully Collapsed Imploded Cryptophanes in Solution and in the Solid State

Cryptophanes with flexible linkers derived from (±)-tris-(4-formyl-phenyl)-cyclotriguaiacylene with either bisoxydi(ethylamine) or bis(aminopropyl)ether were isolated as single crystals, the crystal structures of which showed the proposed, but previously uncharacterised, out-in conformation, in which both cyclotriguaiacylene fragments adopt a crown conformation with one crown sitting inside the other. The usual cage-like out-out conformation of the cryptophanes was observed when crystals were dissolved upon heating, and the molecules collapsed back to the out-in isomers over time. In contrast, a cryptophane also derived from (±)-tris-(4-formyl-phenyl)-cyclotriguaiacylene but with rigid dibenzalhydrazine linkers was isolated as the more usual out-out isomer.

HYDROPHOBE Challenge: A Joint Experimental and Computational Study on the Host-Guest Binding of Hydrocarbons to Cucurbiturils, Allowing Explicit Evaluation of Guest Hydration Free-Energy Contributions

The host-guest complexation of hydrocarbons (22 guest molecules) with cucurbit[7]uril was investigated in aqueous solution using the indicator displacement strategy. The binding constants (10³-10⁹ M^-1) increased with guest size, pointing to the hydrophobic effect and dispersion interactions as driving forces. The measured affinities provide unique benchmark data for the binding of neutral guest molecules. Consequently, a computational blind challenge, the HYDROPHOBE challenge, was conducted to allow a comparison with state-of-the-art computational methods for predicting host-guest affinity constants. In total, three quantum-chemical (QM) data sets and two explicit-solvent molecular dynamics (MD) submissions were received. When searching for sources of uncertainty in predicting the host-guest affinities, the experimentally known hydration energies of the investigated hydrocarbons were used to test the employed solvation models (explicit solvent for MD and COSMO-RS for QM). Good correlations were obtained for both solvation models, but a rather constant offset was observed for the COSMO data, by ca. +2 kcal mol^-1, which was traced back to a required reference-state correction in the QM submissions (2.38 kcal mol^-1). Introduction of the reference-state correction improved the predictive power of the QM methods, particularly for small hydrocarbons up to C5.

Experimental Binding Energies in Supramolecular Complexes

On the basis of many literature measurements, a critical overview is given on essential noncovalent interactions in synthetic supramolecular complexes, accompanied by analyses with selected proteins. The methods, which can be applied to derive binding increments for single noncovalent interactions, start with the evaluation of consistency and additivity with a sufficiently large number of different host-guest complexes by applying linear free energy relations. Other strategies involve the use of double mutant cycles, of molecular balances, of dynamic combinatorial libraries, and of crystal structures. Promises and limitations of these strategies are discussed. Most of the analyses stem from solution studies, but a few also from gas phase. The empirically derived interactions are then presented on the basis of selected complexes with respect to ion pairing, hydrogen bonding, electrostatic contributions, halogen bonding, π-π-stacking, dispersive forces, cation-π and anion-π interactions, and contributions from the hydrophobic effect. Cooperativity in host-guest complexes as well as in self-assembly, and entropy factors are briefly highlighted. Tables with typical values for single noncovalent free energies and polarity parameters are in the Supporting Information.

Xe affinities of water-soluble cryptophanes and the role of confined water

Simulations provide molecular insight on the aqueous binding of Xe to cryptophanes.

Given their relevance to drug design and chemical sensing, host–guest interactions are of broad interest in molecular science. Natural and synthetic host molecules provide vehicles for understanding selective molecular recognition in aqueous solution. Here, cryptophane–Xe host–guest systems are considered in aqueous media as a model molecular system that also has important applications. ¹²⁹Xe–cryptophane systems can be used in the creation of biosensors and powerful contrast agents for magnetic resonance imaging applications. Detailed molecular information on the determinants of Xe affinity is difficult to obtain experimentally. Thus, molecular simulation and free energy perturbation methods were applied to estimate the affinities of Xe for six water-soluble cryptophanes. The calculated affinities correlated well with the previously measured experimental values. The simulations provided molecular insight on the differences in affinities and the roles of conformational fluctuations, solvent, and counter ions on Xe binding to these host molecules. Displacement of confined water from the host interior cavity is a key component of the binding equilibrium, and the average number of water molecules within the host cavity is correlated with the free energy of Xe binding to the different cryptophanes. The findings highlight roles for molecular simulation and design in modulating the relative strengths of host–guest and host–solvent interactions.

Dispersive interactions in solution complexes

Dispersive interactions are known to play a major role in molecular associations in the gas phase and in the solid state. In solution, however, their significance has been disputed in recent years on the basis of several arguments. A major problem until now has been the separation of dispersive and hydrophobic effects, which are both maximized in water due the low polarizability of this most important medium. Analyses of complexes between porphyrins and systematically varied substrates in water have allowed us to discriminate dispersive from hydrophobic effects, as the latter turned out to be negligible for complexations with flat surfaces such as porphyrins. Also, for the first time, it has become possible to obtain binding free energy increments ΔΔG for a multitude of organic residues including halogen, amide, amino, ether, carbonyl, ester, nitro, sulfur, unsatured, and cyclopropane groups, which turned out to be additive. Binding contributions for saturated residues are unmeasurably small, with ΔΔG > 1 kJ/mol, but they increase to, e.g., ΔΔG = 5 kJ/mol for a nitro group, a value not far from, e.g., that of a stacking pyridine ring. Stacking interactions of heteroarenes with porphyrins depend essentially on the size of the arenes, in line with polarizabilities, and seem to be rather independent of the position of nitrogen within the rings. Measurements of halogen derivatives indicate that complexes with porphyrins, cyclodextrins, and pillarenes as hosts in different media consistently show increasing stability from fluorine to iodine as the substituent. This, and the observed sequence with other substrates, is in line with the expected increase in dispersive forces with increasing polarizability. Induced dipoles, which also would increase with polarizability, can be ruled out as providing the driving source in view of the data with halides: the observed stability sequence is opposite the change of electronegativity from fluorine to iodine. The same holds for the solvent effect observed in ethanol-water mixtures. Dispersive contributions vary not only with the polarizability of the used media but also with the interacting receptor sites; it has been shown that for cucurbiturils the polarizability inside the cavity is extremely low, which also explains why hydrophobic effects are maximized with these hosts. Complexations with other known host compounds, however, such as those between cryptands or cavitands with, e.g., noble gases, bear the signature of dominating dispersive forces. Some recent examples illustrate that such van der Waals forces can also play an important role in complexations with proteins. Again, a clue for this is the increase in ΔG for inhibitor binding by 7 kJ/mol for, e.g., a bromine in comparison to a fluorine derivative.

Water Structure Recovery in Chaotropic Anion Recognition: High-Affinity Binding of Dodecaborate Clusters to γ-Cyclodextrin

Dodecaborate anions of the type B12X12(2-) and B12X11Y(2-) (X=H, Cl, Br, I and Y=OH, SH, NH3(+), NR3(+)) form strong (K(a) up to 10(6) L mol(-1), for B12Br12(2-)) inclusion complexes with γ-cyclodextrin (γ-CD). The micromolar affinities reached are the highest known for this native CD. The complexation exhibits highly negative enthalpies (up to -25 kcal mol(-1)) and entropies (TΔS up to -18.4 kcal mol(-1), both for B12I12(2-)), which position these guests at the bottom end of the well-known enthalpy-entropy correlation for CDs. The high driving force can be traced back to a chaotropic effect, according to which chaotropic anions have an intrinsic affinity to hydrophobic cavities in aqueous solution. In line with this argument, salting-in effects revealed dodecaborates as superchaotropic dianions.

Using dispersion-corrected density functional theory to understand supramolecular binding thermodynamics

A recently published theoretical approach employing a nondynamic structure model using dispersion-corrected density functional theory (DFT-D3) to calculate equilibrium free energies of association (Chem. – Eur. J., 2012, 18, 9955–9964) is illustrated by its application to eight supramolecular complexes.