Fetal cardiac cine magnetic resonance imaging in utero

Electric potential energy optimized 3D radial sampling trajectories for MRI

A novel method for creating "golden" 3D center-out radial MRI sampling trajectories was developed and analyzed. This method, called ELECTRO (ELECTRic potential energy Optimized), uses repulsive forces to minimize electric potential energy. An objective function [Formula: see text], the electric potential energies of all subsets of consecutive readouts in a 3D radial trajectory, and its reduced form were minimized using a multi-stage optimization strategy. A metric called normalized mean nearest neighbor angular distance (NMNA) was proposed for describing distributions of points on a sphere. ELECTRO and other relevant golden trajectories were compared in silico using NMNA and point spread function analysis. Consecutive readouts from an ELECTRO trajectory were well spread out, with consistent NMNA values across sphere sizes (σNMNA = 0.005) and between regions on the sphere (NMNA ≈ 1.49). Conversely, the supergolden trajectory had poor consistency in NMNA values (σNMNA = 0.090) and clustering (NMNA = 1.28 at the pole with 40,000 readouts) that lead to artifact in the point spread function. Multi-stage optimization was faster than single-stage and obtained lower values of [Formula: see text] (e.g., 0.87 vs. 0.91, for a sphere size of 40). In conclusion, ELECTRO trajectories are more golden than other 3D center-out radial trajectories, making them a suitable candidate for dynamic 3D MR imaging.

Fetal Cardiac MRI Using Doppler US Gating: Emerging Technology and Clinical Implications

Fetal cardiac MRI using Doppler US gating is an emerging technique to support prenatal diagnosis of congenital heart disease and other cardiovascular abnormalities. Analogous to postnatal electrocardiographically gated cardiac MRI, this technique enables directly gated MRI of the fetal heart throughout the cardiac cycle, allowing for immediate data reconstruction and review of image quality. This review outlines the technical principles and challenges of cardiac MRI with Doppler US gating, such as loss of gating signal due to fetal movement. A practical workflow of patient preparation for the use of Doppler US-gated fetal cardiac MRI in clinical routine is provided. Currently applied MRI sequences (ie, cine or four-dimensional flow imaging), with special consideration of technical adaptations to the fetal heart, are summarized. The authors provide a literature review on the clinical benefits of Doppler US-gated fetal cardiac MRI for gaining additional diagnostic information on cardiovascular malformations and fetal hemodynamics. Finally, future perspectives of Doppler US-gated fetal cardiac MRI and further technical developments to reduce acquisition times and eliminate sources of artifacts are discussed. Keywords: MR Fetal, Ultrasound Doppler, Cardiac, Heart, Congenital, Obstetrics, Fetus Supplemental material is available for this article. © RSNA, 2024.

Advanced imaging of fetal cardiac function

Over recent decades, a variety of advanced imaging techniques for assessing cardiovascular physiology and cardiac function in adults and children have been applied in the fetus. In many cases, technical development has been required to allow feasibility in the fetus, while an appreciation of the unique physiology of the fetal circulation is required for proper interpretation of the findings. This review will focus on recent advances in fetal echocardiography and cardiovascular magnetic resonance (CMR), providing examples of their application in research and clinical settings. We will also consider future directions for these technologies, including their ongoing technical development and potential clinical value.

Cardiovascular Magnetic Resonance from Fetal to Adult Life-Indications and Challenges: A State-of-the-Art Review

Cardiovascular magnetic resonance (CMR) imaging offers a comprehensive, non-invasive, and radiation-free imaging modality, which provides a highly accurate and reproducible assessment of cardiac morphology and functions across a wide spectrum of cardiac conditions spanning from fetal to adult life. It minimises risks to the patient, particularly the risks associated with exposure to ionising radiation and the risk of complications from more invasive haemodynamic assessments. CMR utilises high spatial resolution and provides a detailed assessment of intracardiac and extracardiac anatomy, ventricular and valvular function, and flow haemodynamic and tissue characterisation, which aid in the diagnosis, and, hence, with the management of patients with cardiac disease. This article aims to discuss the role of CMR and the indications for its use throughout the different stages of life, from fetal to adult life.

Quantitative measurements and morphological evaluation of fetal cardiovascular structures with fetal cardiac MRI

PURPOSE

Fetal cardiac magnetic resonance imaging (FCMR) can be used as an imaging modality in fetal cardiovascular evaluation as studied in recent years. We aimed to evaluate cardiovascular morphology using FCMR and to observe the development of cardiovascular structures according to gestational age (GA) in pregnant women.

METHOD

In our prospective study, 120 pregnant women between 19 and 37 weeks of gestation in whom absence of cardiac anomaly could not be excluded by ultrasonography (US) or, who were referred to us for magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) for suspected non-cardiovascular system pathology, were included. According to the axis of the fetal heart, axial, coronal, and sagittal multiplanar steady-state free precession (SSFP) and 'real time' untriggered SSFP sequence, respectively, were obtained. The morphology of the cardiovascular structures and their relationships with each other were evaluated, and their sizes were measured.

RESULTS

Seven cases (6.3%) contained motion artefacts that did not allow the assessment and measurement of cardiovascular morphology, and three (2.9%) cases with cardiac pathology in the analysed images were excluded from the study. The study included a total of 100 cases. Cardiac chamber diameter, heart diameter, heart length, heart area, thoracic diameter, and thoracic area were measured in all fetuses. The diameters of the aorta ascendens (Aa), aortic isthmus (Ai), aorta descendens (Ad), main pulmonary artery (MPA), ductus arteriosus (DA, superior vena cava (SVC), and inferior vena cava (IVC) were measured in all fetuses. The left pulmonary artery (LPA) was visualised in 89 patients (89%). The right PA (RPA) was visualised in 99 (99%) cases. Four pulmonary veins (PVs) were seen in 49 (49%) cases, three in 33 (33%), and two in 18 (18%). High correlation values were found for all diameter measurements performed with GW.

CONCLUSION

In cases where US cannot achieve adequate image quality, FCMR can contribute to diagnosis. The very short acquisition time and parallel imaging technique with the SSFP sequence allow for adequate image quality without maternal or fetal sedation.

Fetal MRI at 3 T: Principles to Optimize Success

Fetal MRI has emerged as a cornerstone of prenatal imaging, helping to establish the correct diagnosis in pregnancies affected by congenital anomalies. In the past decade, 3 T imaging was introduced as an alternative to increase the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of the pulse sequences and improve anatomic detail. However, imaging at a higher field strength is not without challenges. Many artifacts that are barely appreciable at 1.5 T are amplified at 3 T. A systematic approach to imaging at 3 T that incorporates appropriate patient positioning, a thoughtful protocol design, and sequence optimization minimizes the impact of these artifacts and allows radiologists to reap the benefits of the increased SNR. The sequences used are the same at both field strengths and include single-shot T2-weighted, balanced steady-state free-precession, three-dimensional T1-weighted spoiled gradient-echo, and echo-planar imaging. Synergistic use of these acquisitions to sample various tissue contrasts and in various planes provides valuable information about fetal anatomy and pathologic conditions. In the authors' experience, fetal imaging at 3 T outperforms imaging at 1.5 T for most indications when performed under optimal circumstances. The authors condense the cumulative experience of fetal imaging specialists and MRI technologists who practice at a large referral center into a guideline covering all major aspects of fetal MRI at 3 T, from patient preparation to image interpretation. © RSNA, 2023 Quiz questions for this article are available in the supplemental material.

Fetal Cardiac Cine MRI with Doppler US Gating in Complex Congenital Heart Disease

Purpose

To apply Doppler US (DUS)-gated fetal cardiac cine MRI in clinical routine and investigate diagnostic performance in complex congenital heart disease (CHD) compared with that of fetal echocardiography.

Materials and Methods

In this prospective study (May 2021 to March 2022), women with fetuses with CHD underwent fetal echocardiography and DUS-gated fetal cardiac MRI on the same day. For MRI, balanced steady-state free precession cine images were acquired in the axial and optional sagittal and/or coronal orientations. Overall image quality was assessed on a four-point Likert scale (from 1 = nondiagnostic to 4 = good image quality). The presence of abnormalities in 20 fetal cardiovascular features was independently assessed by using both modalities. The reference standard was postnatal examination results. Differences in sensitivities and specificities were determined by using a random-effects model.

Results

The study included 23 participants (mean age, 32 years ± 5 [SD]; mean gestational age, 36 weeks ± 1). Fetal cardiac MRI was completed in all participants. The median overall image quality of DUS-gated cine images was 3 (IQR, 2.5-4). In 21 of 23 participants (91%), underlying CHD was correctly assessed by using fetal cardiac MRI. In one case, the correct diagnosis was made by using MRI only (situs inversus and congenitally corrected transposition of the great arteries). Sensitivities (91.8% [95% CI: 85.7, 95.1] vs 93.6% [95% CI: 88.8, 96.2]; P = .53) and specificities (99.9% [95% CI: 99.2, 100] vs 99.9% [95% CI: 99.5, 100]; P > .99) for the detection of abnormal cardiovascular features were comparable between MRI and echocardiography, respectively.

Conclusion

Using DUS-gated fetal cine cardiac MRI resulted in performance comparable with that of using fetal echocardiography for diagnosing complex fetal CHD.Keywords: Pediatrics, MR-Fetal (Fetal MRI), Cardiac, Heart, Congenital, Fetal Imaging, Cardiac MRI, Prenatal, Congenital Heart DiseaseClinical trial registration no. NCT05066399 Supplemental material is available for this article. © RSNA, 2023See also the commentary by Biko and Fogel in this issue.

Fetal MRI of the heart and brain in congenital heart disease

Antenatal assessment of congenital heart disease and associated anomalies by ultrasound has improved perinatal care. Fetal cardiovascular MRI and fetal brain MRI are rapidly evolving for fetal diagnostic testing of congenital heart disease. We give an overview on the use of fetal cardiovascular MRI and fetal brain MRI in congenital heart disease, focusing on the current applications and diagnostic yield of structural and functional imaging during pregnancy. Fetal cardiovascular MRI in congenital heart disease is a promising supplementary imaging method to echocardiography for the diagnosis of antenatal congenital heart disease in weeks 30-40 of pregnancy. Concomitant fetal brain MRI is superior to brain ultrasound to show the complex relationship between fetal haemodynamics in congenital heart disease and brain development.

The Evolution and Developing Importance of Fetal Magnetic Resonance Imaging in the Diagnosis of Congenital Cardiac Anomalies: A Systematic Review

Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) is a reliable method, with a complementary role to Ultrasound (US) Echocardiography, that can be used to fully comprehend and precisely diagnose congenital cardiac malformations. Besides the anatomical study of the fetal cardiovascular system, it allows us to study the function of the fetal heart, remaining, at the same time, a safe adjunct to the classic fetal echocardiography. MRI also allows for the investigation of cardiac and placental diseases by providing information about hematocrit, oxygen saturation, and blood flow in fetal vessels. It is crucial for fetal medicine specialists and pediatric cardiologists to closely follow the advances of fetal cardiac MRI in order to provide the best possible care. In this review, we summarize the advance in techniques and their practical utility to date.

Fetal Cardiovascular MRI - A Systemic Review of the Literature: Challenges, New Technical Developments, and Perspectives

BACKGROUND

Fetal magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) has become a valuable adjunct to ultrasound in the prenatal diagnosis of congenital pathologies of the central nervous system, thorax, and abdomen. Fetal cardiovascular magnetic resonance (CMR) was limited, mainly by the lack of cardiac gating, and has only recently evolved due to technical developments.

METHOD

A literature search was performed on PubMed, focusing on technical advancements to perform fetal CMR. In total, 20 publications on cardiac gating techniques in the human fetus were analyzed.

RESULTS

Fetal MRI is a safe imaging method with no developmental impairments found to be associated with in utero exposure to MRI. Fetal CMR is challenging due to general drawbacks (e. g., fetal motion) and specific limitations such as the difficulty to generate a cardiac gating signal to achieve high spatiotemporal resolution. Promising technical advancements include new methods for fetal cardiac gating, based on novel post-processing approaches and an external hardware device, as well as motion compensation and acceleration techniques.

CONCLUSION

Newly developed direct and indirect gating approaches were successfully applied to achieve high-quality morphologic and functional imaging as well as quantitative assessment of fetal hemodynamics in research settings. In cases when prenatal echocardiography is limited, e. g., by an unfavorable fetal position in utero, or when its results are inconclusive, fetal CMR could potentially serve as a valuable adjunct in the prenatal assessment of congenital cardiovascular malformations. However, sufficient data on the diagnostic performance and clinical benefit of new fetal CMR techniques is still lacking.

KEY POINTS

· New fetal cardiac gating methods allow high-quality fetal CMR.. · Motion compensation and acceleration techniques allow for improvement of image quality.. · Fetal CMR could potentially serve as an adjunct to fetal echocardiography in the future..

CITATION FORMAT

· Knapp J, Tavares de Sousa M, Schönnagel BP. Fetal Cardiovascular MRI - A Systemic Review of the Literature: Challenges, New Technical Developments, and Perspectives. Fortschr Röntgenstr 2022; 194: 841 - 851.

Golden-Angle Radial MRI: Basics, Advances, and Applications

In recent years, golden‐angle radial sampling has received substantial attention and interest in the magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) community, and it has become a popular sampling trajectory for both research and clinical use. However, although the number of relevant techniques and publications has grown rapidly, there is still a lack of a review paper that provides a comprehensive overview and summary of the basics of golden‐angle rotation, the advantages and challenges/limitations of golden‐angle radial sampling, and recommendations in using different types of golden‐angle radial trajectories for MRI applications. Such a review paper is expected to be helpful both for clinicians who are interested in learning the potential benefits of golden‐angle radial sampling and for MRI physicists who are interested in exploring this research direction. The main purpose of this review paper is thus to present an overview and summary about golden‐angle radial MRI sampling. The review consists of three sections. The first section aims to answer basic questions such as: what is a golden angle; how is the golden angle calculated; why is golden‐angle radial sampling useful, and what are its limitations. The second section aims to review more advanced trajectories of golden‐angle radial sampling, including tiny golden‐angle rotation, stack‐of‐stars golden‐angle radial sampling, and three‐dimensional (3D) kooshball golden‐angle radial sampling. Their respective advantages and limitations and potential solutions to address these limitations are also discussed. Finally, the third section reviews MRI applications that can benefit from golden‐angle radial sampling and provides recommendations to readers who are interested in implementing golden‐angle radial trajectories in their MRI studies.

Contribution of fetal magnetic resonance imaging in fetuses with congenital heart disease

BACKGROUND

Increasing evidence supports an association among congenital heart disease (CHD), structural brain lesions on neuroimaging, and increased risk of neurodevelopmental delay and other structural anomalies. Fetal MRI has been found to be effective in demonstrating fetal structural and developmental abnormalities.

OBJECTIVE

To determine the contribution of fetal MRI to identifying cardiovascular and non-cardiovascular anomalies in fetuses with CHD compared to prenatal US and fetal echocardiography.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We performed a retrospective study of fetuses with CHD identified by fetal echocardiography. Exams were performed on 1.5-tesla (T) or 3-T magnets using a balanced turbo field echo sequence triggered by an external electrocardiogram simulator with a fixed heart rate of 140 beats per minute (bpm). Fetal echocardiography was performed by pediatric cardiologists and detailed obstetrical US by maternal-fetal medicine specialists prior to referral to MRI. We compared the sensitivity of fetal MRI and fetal echocardiography for the diagnosis of cardiovascular anomalies, as well as the sensitivity of fetal MRI and referral US for the diagnosis of non-cardiac anomalies. We performed statistical analysis using the McNemar test.

RESULTS

We identified 121 anomalies in 31 fetuses. Of these, 73 (60.3%) were cardiovascular and 48 (39.7%) involved other organ systems. Fetal echocardiography was more sensitive for diagnosing cardiovascular anomalies compared to fetal MRI, but the difference was not statistically significant (85.9%, 95% confidence interval [CI] 77.8-94.0% vs. 77.5%, 95% CI 67.7-87.2%, respectively; McNemar test 2.29; P=0.13). The sensitivity of fetal MRI was higher for diagnosing extracardiac anomalies when compared to referral US (84.1%, 95% CI 73.3-94.9% vs. 31.8%, 95% CI 18.1-45.6%, respectively; McNemar test 12.9; P<0.001). The additional information provided by fetal MRI changed prognosis, counseling or management for 10/31 fetuses (32.2%), all in the group of 19 fetuses with anomalies in other organs and systems besides CHD.

CONCLUSION

Fetal MRI performed in a population of fetuses with CHD provided additional information that altered prognosis, counseling or management in approximately one-third of the fetuses, mainly by identifying previously unknown anomalies in other organs and systems.

Time-Dependent Deep Image Prior for Dynamic MRI

We propose a novel unsupervised deep-learning-based algorithm for dynamic magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) reconstruction. Dynamic MRI requires rapid data acquisition for the study of moving organs such as the heart. We introduce a generalized version of the deep-image-prior approach, which optimizes the weights of a reconstruction network to fit a sequence of sparsely acquired dynamic MRI measurements. Our method needs neither prior training nor additional data. In particular, for cardiac images, it does not require the marking of heartbeats or the reordering of spokes. The key ingredients of our method are threefold: 1) a fixed low-dimensional manifold that encodes the temporal variations of images; 2) a network that maps the manifold into a more expressive latent space; and 3) a convolutional neural network that generates a dynamic series of MRI images from the latent variables and that favors their consistency with the measurements in k -space. Our method outperforms the state-of-the-art methods quantitatively and qualitatively in both retrospective and real fetal cardiac datasets. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first unsupervised deep-learning-based method that can reconstruct the continuous variation of dynamic MRI sequences with high spatial resolution.

Seeing the fetus from a DOHaD perspective: discussion paper from the advanced imaging techniques of DOHaD applications workshop held at the 2019 DOHaD World Congress

Advanced imaging techniques are enhancing research capacity focussed on the developmental origins of adult health and disease (DOHaD) hypothesis, and consequently increasing awareness of future health risks across various subareas of DOHaD research themes. Understanding how these advanced imaging techniques in animal models and human population studies can be both additively and synergistically used alongside traditional techniques in DOHaD-focussed laboratories is therefore of great interest. Global experts in advanced imaging techniques congregated at the advanced imaging workshop at the 2019 DOHaD World Congress in Melbourne, Australia. This review summarizes the presentations of new imaging modalities and novel applications to DOHaD research and discussions had by DOHaD researchers that are currently utilizing advanced imaging techniques including MRI, hyperpolarized MRI, ultrasound, and synchrotron-based techniques to aid their DOHaD research focus.

Update on fetal cardiovascular magnetic resonance and utility in congenital heart disease

Background

Congenital heart disease (CHD) is the most common birth defect, affecting approximately eight per thousand newborns. Between one and two neonates per thousand have congenital cardiac lesions that require immediate post-natal treatment to stabilize the circulation, and the management of these patients in particular has been greatly enhanced by prenatal detection. The antenatal diagnosis of CHD has been made possible through the development of fetal echocardiography, which provides excellent visualization of cardiac anatomy and physiology and is widely available. However, late gestational fetal echocardiographic imaging can be hampered by suboptimal sonographic windows, particularly in the setting of oligohydramnios or adverse maternal body habitus.

Main body

Recent advances in fetal cardiovascular magnetic resonance (CMR) technology now provide a feasible alternative that could be helpful when echocardiography is inconclusive or limited. Fetal CMR has also been used to study fetal circulatory physiology in human fetuses with CHD, providing new insights into how these common anatomical abnormalities impact the distribution of blood flow and oxygen across the fetal circulation. In combination with conventional fetal and neonatal magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) techniques, fetal CMR can be used to explore the relationship between abnormal cardiovascular physiology and fetal development. Similarly, fetal CMR has been successfully applied in large animal models of the human fetal circulation, aiding in the evaluation of experimental interventions aimed at improving in utero development. With the advent of accelerated image acquisition techniques, post-processing approaches to correcting motion artifacts and commercial MRI compatible cardiotocography units for acquiring gated fetal cardiac imaging, an increasing number of CMR methods including angiography, ventricular volumetry, and the quantification of vessel blood flow and oxygen content are now possible.

Conclusion

Fetal CMR has reached an exciting stage whereby it may now be used to enhance the assessment of cardiac morphology and fetal hemodynamics in the setting of prenatal CHD.

Cerebral Blood Flow Monitoring in High-Risk Fetal and Neonatal Populations

Cerebrovascular pressure autoregulation promotes stable cerebral blood flow (CBF) across a range of arterial blood pressures. Cerebral autoregulation (CA) is a developmental process that reaches maturity around term gestation and can be monitored prenatally with both Doppler ultrasound and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) techniques. Postnatally, there are key advantages and limitations to assessing CA with Doppler ultrasound, MRI, and near-infrared spectroscopy. Here we review these CBF monitoring techniques as well as their application to both fetal and neonatal populations at risk of perturbations in CBF. Specifically, we discuss CBF monitoring in fetuses with intrauterine growth restriction, anemia, congenital heart disease, neonates born preterm and those with hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy. We conclude the review with insights into the future directions in this field with an emphasis on collaborative science and precision medicine approaches.

Fetal Flow Quantification in Great Vessels Using Motion-Corrected Radial Phase Contrast MRI: Comparison With Cartesian

BACKGROUND

Phase contrast MRI in the great vessels is a potential clinical tool for managing fetal pathologies. One challenge is the uncontrollable fetal motion, potentially corrupting flow quantifications.

PURPOSE

To demonstrate improvements in fetal blood flow quantification in great vessels using retrospectively motion-corrected golden-angle radial phase contrast MRI relative to Cartesian phase contrast MRI.

STUDY TYPE

Method comparison.

PHANTOM/SUBJECTS

Computer simulation. Seventeen pregnant volunteers.

FIELD STRENGTH/SEQUENCE

1.5T and 3T. Cartesian and golden-angle radial phase contrast MRI.

ASSESSMENT

Through computer simulations, radial (with and without retrospective motion correction) and Cartesian phase contrast MRI were compared using flow deviations. in vivo Cartesian and radial phase contrast MRI measurements and reconstruction qualities were compared in pregnancies. Cartesian data were reconstructed into gated reconstructions (CINEs) after cardiac gating with metric optimized gating (MOG). For radial data, real-time reconstructions were performed for motion correction and MOG followed by CINE reconstructions.

STATISTICAL TESTS

Wilcoxon signed-rank test. Linear regression. Bland-Altman plots. Student's t-test.

RESULTS

Simulations showed significant improvements (P < 0.05) in flow accuracy and reconstruction quality with motion correction ([mean/peak] flow errors with ±5 mm motion corruption: Cartesian [35 ± 1/115 ± 7] mL/s, motion uncorrected radial [25 ± 1/75 ± 2] mL/s and motion-corrected radial [1.0 ± 0.5/-5 ± 1] mL/s). in vivo Cartesian reconstructions without motion correction had lower quality than the motion-corrected radial reconstructions (P < 0.05). Across all fetal mean flow measurements, the bias [limits of agreement] between the two measurements were -0.2 [-76, 75] mL/min/kg, while the linear regression coefficients were (M_radial = 0.81 × M_Cartesian + 29.8 [mL/min/kg], r² = 0.67). The corresponding measures for the peak fetal flows were -23 [-214, 167] mL/min/kg and (P_radial = 0.95 × P_Cartesian -1.2 [mL/min/kg], r² = 0.80). Cartesian reconstructions of low quality showed significantly higher estimated mean and peak (P < 0.05) flows than the corresponding radial reconstructions.

DATA CONCLUSION

Simulations showed that radial phase contrast MRI with motion compensation improved flow accuracy. For fetal measurements, motion-corrected radial reconstructions showed better image quality than, and different flow values from, Cartesian reconstructions. Level of Evidence 1. Technical Efficacy Stage 1. J. MAGN. RESON. IMAGING 2021;53:540-551.

Fetal dynamic magnetic resonance imaging using Doppler ultrasound gating for the assessment of the aortic isthmus: A feasibility study

INTRODUCTION

Cardiovascular magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is established in cardiac evaluation in postnatal life, but its application to the fetus has been hampered by technical limitations. We aimed to investigate the feasibility of dynamic MRI of the fetal aortic isthmus using a magnetic resonance-compatible Doppler ultrasound device for cardiac gating.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

This prospective study included 19 fetuses at a median gestational age of 32.3 weeks (range 26-38 weeks). Imaging of the fetal aortic isthmus was assessed by (a) dynamic steady-state free precession MRI using a magnetic resonance-compatible Doppler ultrasound device for cardiac gating and (b) echocardiography. Diameters of the aortic isthmus were compared by two blinded observers. Magnetic resonance image quality was assessed independently by two observers using a four-point scale (1 = low quality, 4 = high quality). Furthermore, we performed four-dimensional flow MRI of the fetal aorta in three of these fetuses.

RESULTS

The Doppler ultrasound device for cardiac gating allowed successful dynamic MRI examinations of the aortic isthmus in 18/19 (95%) fetuses. Evaluation of the fetal aortic isthmus was possible by both MRI (15/18, 83%) and echocardiography (16/18, 89%) (P < .05). Diameters of the aortic isthmus were concordant for MRI (3.8 ± 0.9 mm) and echocardiography (4.0 ± 1.1 mm), with a variability of 10.8% (bias -2.3%, 95% limits of agreement -23.9% to 19.3%). Overall magnetic resonance image quality was good (score 4 in 67% and score 3 in 23%) with good inter-observer agreement (κ = 0.75; 95% CI 0.5-1). Fetal four-dimensional flow MRI allowed visualization of aortic flow dynamics.

CONCLUSIONS

Doppler ultrasound-gating allows dynamic MRI of the fetal aorta with the potential to serve as a complementary imaging tool in cases where echocardiography is inconclusive.

Feasibility of ventricular volumetry by cardiovascular MRI to assess cardiac function in the fetal sheep

KEY POINTS

The application of fetal cardiovascular magnetic resonance imaging (CMR) to assess fetal cardiovascular physiology and cardiac function through the quantification of ventricular volumes has previously been investigated, but the approach has not yet been fully validated. Ventricular output measurements calculated from heart rate and stroke volumes (SV) of the right and left ventricles measured by ventricular volumetry (VV) exhibited a high level of agreement with phase-contrast (PC) blood flow measurements in the main pulmonary artery and ascending aorta, respectively. Ejection fraction of the right ventricle, which is lower than that of the left ventricle in postnatal subjects, was similar to the left ventricular ejection fraction in the fetus; probably due to the different loading conditions present in the fetal circulation. This study provides evidence to support the reliability of VV in the sheep fetus, providing evidence for its use in animal models of human diseases affecting the fetal circulation.

ABSTRACT

The application of ventricular volumetry (VV) by cardiovascular magnetic resonance imaging (CMR) in the fetus remains challenging due to the small size of the fetal heart and high heart rate. The reliability of this technique in utero has not yet been established. The aim of this study was to assess the feasibility and reliability of VV in a fetal sheep model of human pregnancy. Right and left ventricular outputs by stroke volume (SV) measured using VV were compared with 2D phase-contrast (PC) CMR measurements of blood flow in the main pulmonary artery (MPA) and ascending aorta (AAo). At 124-140 days (d) gestation, singleton bearing Merino ewes underwent CMR under general anaesthesia using fetal femoral artery catheters, implanted at 109-117d, to trigger cine steady state free precession acquisitions of ventricular short-axis stacks. The short-axis cine stacks were segmented at end-systole and end-diastole, yielding right and left ventricular SV, ejection fraction, and cardiac outputs (SV × heart rate). PC cine acquisitions of MPA and AAo were analysed to measure blood flow, which served as comparators for the right and left cardiac outputs by VV. There was good correlation and agreement between VV and PC measures of ventricular outputs with no significant bias (r²  = 0.926; P < 0.0001; Bias = -4.7 ± 10.5 ml min^-1  kg^-1 ; 95% limits of agreement: -15.9 to 25.2 ml min^-1  kg^-1 ). This study validates fetal VV by CMR in a large animal model of human pregnancy and provides preliminary reference values of fetal sheep right and left ventricles in late gestation.

Fetal Cardiac MRI: A Review of Technical Advancements

Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is an appealing technology for fetal cardiovascular assessment. It can be used to visualize fetal cardiac and vascular anatomy, to quantify fetal blood flow, and to quantify fetal blood oxygen saturation and hematocrit. However, there are practical limitations to the use of conventional MRI for fetal cardiovascular assessment, including the small size and high heart rate of the human fetus, the lack of conventional cardiac gating methods to synchronize data acquisition, and the potential corruption of MRI data due to maternal respiration and unpredictable fetal movements. In this review, we discuss recent technical advances in accelerated imaging, image reconstruction, cardiac gating, and motion compensation that have enabled dynamic MRI of the fetal heart.

Preliminary Experience Using Motion Compensated CINE Magnetic Resonance Imaging to Visualise Fetal Congenital Heart Disease

BACKGROUND

Recent advances in cardiovascular magnetic resonance (CMR) imaging have facilitated CINE imaging of the fetal heart. In this work, a preliminary investigation of the utility of multislice CINE CMR for assessing fetal congenital heart disease is performed and compared with echocardiography.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Multislice CINE CMR and echocardiography images were acquired in 25 pregnant women wherein the fetus had a suspected congenital heart defect based on routine obstetric ultrasound. Pathognomonic images were identified for each subject for qualitative comparison of CMR and echocardiography. Quantitative comparison of CMR and echocardiography was then performed by 2 reviewers using a binary scoring of 9 fetal cardiac anatomic features (identifiable/not-identifiable). Pathognomonic images demonstrated the ability of CMR to visualize a variety of congenital heart defects. Overall CMR was able to identify the majority of the 9 assessed fetal cardiac anatomic features (reviewer 1, 7.1±2.1; reviewer 2, 6.7±2.3). Although both reviewers identified more anatomic features with echocardiography (reviewer 1, 7.8±2.3; reviewer 2, 7.5±2.4; P=0.01), combining information from both modalities enabled identification of additional anatomic features across subjects (reviewer 1, 8.4±1.3; reviewer 2, 8.4±1.2). The primary limiting factor for CMR was inadequate coverage of the fetal cardiac anatomy or noncontiguous slices because of gross fetal movement.

CONCLUSIONS

CINE CMR enables visualization of fetal congenital heart disease. This work demonstrates the potential of CMR for diagnosing congenital heart disease in utero in conjunction with echocardiography during late gestation.

Fetal iGRASP cine CMR assisting in prenatal diagnosis of complicated cardiac malformation with impact on delivery planning

Limited visualization of the fetal heart and vessels by fetal ultrasound due to suboptimal fetal position, patient habitus and skeletal calcification may lead to missed diagnosis, overdiagnosis and parental uncertainty. Counselling and delivery planning may in those cases also be tentative. The recent fetal cardiac magnetic resonance (CMR) reconstruction method utilizing tiny golden-angle iGRASP (iterative Golden-angle RAdial Sparse Parallel MRI) allows for cine imaging of the fetal heart for use in clinical practice. This case describes an unbalanced common atrioventricular canal where limited ultrasound image quality and visibility of the aortic arch precluded confirming or ruling out presence of a ventricular septal defect. Need of prostaglandins or neonatal intervention was thus uncertain. Cardiovascular magnetic resonance imaging confirmed ultrasound findings and added value by ruling out a significant ventricular septal defect and diagnosing arch hypoplasia. This confirmed the need of patient relocation for delivery at a paediatric cardiothoracic surgery centre and prostaglandins could be initiated before the standard postnatal ultrasound. The applied CMR method can thus improve diagnosis of complicated fetal cardiac malformation and has direct clinical impact.

MR imaging of the fetal heart

In the last decade, technological advances have enabled the acquisition of high spatial and temporal resolution cardiac magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in the fetus. Fetal cardiac MRI has emerged as an alternative to ultrasound, which may be helpful to confirm a diagnosis of congenital heart disease when ultrasound assessment is hampered, for example in late gestation or in the setting of oligohydramnios. MRI also provides unique physiologic information, including vessel blood flow, oxygen saturation and hematocrit, which may be helpful to investigate cardiac and placental diseases. In this review, we summarize some of the main techniques and significant advances in the field to date. Level of Evidence: 5 Technical Efficacy: Stage 5 J. Magn. Reson. Imaging 2020;51:1030-1044.

Fetal XCMR: a numerical phantom for fetal cardiovascular magnetic resonance imaging

BACKGROUND

Validating new techniques for fetal cardiovascular magnetic resonance (CMR) is challenging due to random fetal movement that precludes repeat measurements. Consequently, fetal CMR development has been largely performed using physical phantoms or postnatal volunteers. In this work, we present an open-source simulation designed to aid in the development and validation of new approaches for fetal CMR. Our approach, fetal extended Cardiac-Torso cardiovascular magnetic resonance imaging (Fetal XCMR), builds on established methods for simulating CMR acquisitions but is tailored toward the dynamic physiology of the fetal heart and body. We present comparisons between the Fetal XCMR phantom and data acquired in utero, resulting in image quality, anatomy, tissue signals and contrast.

METHODS

Existing extended Cardiac-Torso models are modified to create maternal and fetal anatomy, combined according to simulated motion, mapped to CMR contrast, and converted to CMR data. To provide a comparison between the proposed simulation and experimental fetal CMR images acquired in utero, images from a typical scan of a pregnant woman are included and simulated acquisitions were generated using matching CMR parameters, motion and noise levels. Three reconstruction (static, real-time, and CINE), and two motion estimation methods (translational motion, fetal heart rate) from data acquired in transverse, sagittal, coronal, and short-axis planes of the fetal heart were performed to compare to in utero acquisitions and demonstrate feasibility of the proposed simulation framework.

RESULTS

Overall, CMR contrast, morphologies, and relative proportions of the maternal and fetal anatomy are well represented by the Fetal XCMR images when comparing the simulation to static images acquired in utero. Additionally, visualization of maternal respiratory and fetal cardiac motion is comparable between Fetal XCMR and in utero real-time images. Finally, high quality CINE image reconstructions provide excellent delineation of fetal cardiac anatomy and temporal dynamics for both data types.

CONCLUSION

The fetal CMR phantom provides a new method for evaluating fetal CMR acquisition and reconstruction methods by simulating the underlying anatomy and physiology. As the field of fetal CMR continues to grow, new methods will become available and require careful validation. The fetal CMR phantom is therefore a powerful and convenient tool in the continued development of fetal cardiac imaging.

Fetal whole-heart 4D imaging using motion-corrected multi-planar real-time MRI

Purpose

To develop an MRI acquisition and reconstruction framework for volumetric cine visualization of the fetal heart and great vessels in the presence of maternal and fetal motion.

Methods

Four‐dimensional (4D) depiction was achieved using a highly‐accelerated multi‐planar real‐time balanced steady‐state free precession acquisition combined with retrospective image‐domain techniques for motion correction, cardiac synchronization and outlier rejection. The framework was validated using a numerical phantom and evaluated in a study of 20 mid‐ to late‐gestational age human fetal subjects (23‐33 weeks gestational age). Reconstructed MR data were compared with matched ultrasound. A preliminary assessment of flow‐sensitive reconstruction using the velocity information encoded in the phase of real‐time images is included.

Results

Reconstructed 4D data could be visualized in any two‐dimensional plane without the need for highly specific scan plane prescription prior to acquisition or for maternal breath hold to minimize motion. Reconstruction was fully automated aside from user‐specified masks of the fetal heart and chest. The framework proved robust when applied to fetal data and simulations confirmed that spatial and temporal features could be reliably recovered. Evaluation suggested the reconstructed framework has the potential to be used for comprehensive assessment of the fetal heart, either as an adjunct to ultrasound or in combination with other MRI techniques.

Conclusions

The proposed methods show promise as a framework for motion‐compensated 4D assessment of the fetal heart and great vessels.

Dynamic fetal cardiac magnetic resonance imaging in four-chamber view using Doppler ultrasound gating in normal fetal heart and in congenital heart disease: comparison with fetal echocardiography

OBJECTIVES

To investigate the diagnostic performance of dynamic fetal cardiac magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), using a MR-compatible Doppler ultrasound (DUS) device for fetal cardiac gating, in differentiating fetuses with congenital heart disease from those with a normal heart, and to compare the technique with fetal echocardiography.

METHODS

This was a prospective study of eight fetuses with a normal heart and four with congenital heart disease (CHD), at a median of 34 (range, 28-36) weeks' gestation. Dynamic fetal cardiac MRI was performed using a DUS device for direct cardiac gating. The four-chamber view was evaluated according to qualitative findings. Measurements of the length of the left and right ventricles, diameter of the tricuspid and mitral valves, myocardial wall thickness, transverse cardiac diameter and left ventricular planimetry were performed. Fetal echocardiography and postnatal diagnoses were considered the reference standards.

RESULTS

Direct cardiac gating allowed continuous triggering of the fetal heart, showing high temporal and spatial resolution. Both fetal cardiac MRI and echocardiography in the four-chamber view detected pathological findings in three of the 12 fetuses. Qualitative evaluation revealed overall consistency between echocardiography and MRI. On both echocardiography and MRI, quantitative measurements revealed significant differences between fetuses with a normal heart and those with CHD with respect to the length of the right (P < 0.01 for both) and left (P < 0.01 for both) ventricles and transverse cardiac diameter (P < 0.05 and P < 0.01, respectively). Tricuspid valve diameter on cardiac MRI was found to be significantly different in healthy fetuses from in those with CHD (P < 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

For the first time, this study has shown that dynamic fetal cardiac MRI in the four-chamber view, using external cardiac gating, allows evaluation of cardiac anatomy and diagnosis of congenital heart disease in agreement with fetal echocardiography. Dynamic fetal cardiac MRI may be useful as a second-line investigation if conditions for fetal echocardiography are unfavorable. Copyright © 2018 ISUOG. Published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd.

Fetal MRI findings in a retrospective cohort of 26 cases of prenatally diagnosed CHARGE syndrome individuals

"CHARGE syndrome" (CS) is a multifaceted syndrome associated with a poor prognosis. The prenatal diagnosis remains challenging especially as the fetal anomalies that may evoke suspicion of CS are not comprehensively described.

OBJECTIVE

This study aims to identify the anomalies in MRI with suspected CHARGE syndrome and to propose a possible standardization in the image-based prenatal diagnosis of CS.

METHODS

This was a retrospective study of 26 fetuses who underwent MRI and had a confirmed diagnosis of CS, as proven by histopathological and/or neonatal examinations and/or the presence of the CHD7 gene mutation.

RESULTS

The three most frequent MRI anomalies confirmed at histopathological and/or neonatal examinations were arhinencephaly in 100% (26 of 26), dysplasia of the semicircular canals agenesis (SCA) in 100% (24 of 24), and posterior fossa anomalies in 100% (22 of 22). Our study also revealed short petrous bones with a particular triangular shape in 24 of 24 cases of SCA. Other relevant findings included external ear anomalies in 36% (9 of 25), cleft lip and palate (9 of 9), ventriculomegaly (VMG) (6 of 6), short corpus callosum (3 of 3), and ocular asymmetry in 36.6% (4 of 11).

CONCLUSION

Our study emphasizes the interest of fetal MRI in the diagnosis of CS with an adapted knowledge of semiology.

Fetal dynamic phase-contrast MR angiography using ultrasound gating and comparison with Doppler ultrasound measurements

OBJECTIVES

To investigate the feasibility of fetal phase-contrast (PC)-MR angiography of the descending aorta (AoD) using an MR-compatible Doppler ultrasound sensor (DUS) for fetal cardiac gating and to compare velocimetry with Doppler ultrasound measurements.

METHODS

In this prospective study, 2D PC-MR angiography was performed in 12 human fetuses (mean gestational age 32.8 weeks) using an MR-compatible DUS for gating of the fetal heart at 1.5 T. Peak flow velocities in the fetal AoD were compared with Doppler ultrasound measurements performed on the same day. Reproducibility of PC-MR measurements was tested by repeated PC-MR in five fetuses.

RESULTS

Dynamic PC-MR angiography in the AoD was successfully performed in all fetuses using the DUS, with an average fetal heart rate of 140 bpm (range 129-163). Time-velocity curves revealed typical arterial blood flow patterns. PC-MR mean flow velocity and mean flux were 21.2 cm/s (range 8.6-36.8) and 8.4 ml/s (range 3.2-14.6), respectively. A positive association between PC-MR mean flux and stroke volume with gestational age was obtained (r = 0.66, p = 0.02 and r = 0.63, p = 0.03). PC-MR and Doppler ultrasound peak velocities revealed a highly significant correlation (r = 0.8, p < 0.002). Peak velocities were lower for PC-MR with 69.1 cm/s (range 39-125) compared with 96.7 cm/s (range 60-142) for Doppler ultrasound (p < 0.001). Reproducibility of PC-MR was high (p > 0.05).

CONCLUSION

The MR-compatible DUS for fetal cardiac gating allows for PC-MR angiography in the fetal AoD. Comparison with Doppler ultrasound revealed a highly significant correlation of peak velocities with underestimation of PC-MR velocities. This new technique for direct fetal cardiac gating indicates the potential of PC-MR angiography for assessing fetal hemodynamics.

KEY POINTS

• The developed MR-compatible Doppler ultrasound sensor allows direct fetal cardiac gating and can be used for prenatal dynamic cardiovascular MRI. • The MR-compatible Doppler ultrasound sensor was successfully applied to perform intrauterine phase-contrast MR angiography of the fetal aorta, which revealed a highly significant correlation with Doppler ultrasound measurements. • As fetal flow hemodynamics is an important parameter in the diagnosis and management of fetal pathologies, fetal phase-contrast MR angiography may offer an alternative imaging method in addition to Doppler ultrasound and develop as a second line tool in the evaluation of fetal flow hemodynamics.

Multidimensional fetal flow imaging with cardiovascular magnetic resonance: a feasibility study

PURPOSE

To image multidimensional flow in fetuses using golden-angle radial phase contrast cardiovascular magnetic resonance (PC-CMR) with motion correction and retrospective gating.

METHODS

A novel PC-CMR method was developed using an ungated golden-angle radial acquisition with continuously incremented velocity encoding. Healthy subjects (n = 5, 27 ± 3 years, males) and pregnant females (n = 5, 34 ± 2 weeks gestation) were imaged at 3 T using the proposed sequence. Real-time reconstructions were first performed for retrospective motion correction and cardiac gating (using metric optimized gating, MOG). CINE reconstructions of multidimensional flow were then performed using the corrected and gated data.

RESULTS

In adults, flows obtained using the proposed method agreed strongly with those obtained using a conventionally gated Cartesian acquisition. Across the five adults, bias and limits of agreement were - 1.0 cm/s and [- 5.1, 3.2] cm/s for mean velocities and - 1.1 cm/s and [- 6.5, 4.3] cm/s for peak velocities. Temporal correlation between corresponding waveforms was also high (R~ 0.98). Calculated timing errors between MOG and pulse-gating RR intervals were low (~ 20 ms). First insights into multidimensional fetal blood flows were achieved. Inter-subject consistency in fetal descending aortic flows (n = 3) was strong with an average velocity of 27.1 ± 0.4 cm/s, peak systolic velocity of 70.0 ± 1.8 cm/s and an intra-class correlation coefficient of 0.95 between the velocity waveforms. In one fetal case, high flow waveform reproducibility was demonstrated in the ascending aorta (R = 0.97) and main pulmonary artery (R = 0.99).

CONCLUSION

Multidimensional PC-CMR of fetal flow was developed and validated, incorporating retrospective motion compensation and cardiac gating. Using this method, the first quantification and visualization of multidimensional fetal blood flow was achieved using CMR.

MR imaging of subaortic and retroesophageal anomalous courses of the left brachiocephalic vein in the fetus

The purpose of this study was to report fetal cases of subaortic and retroesophageal anomalous courses of the left brachiocephalic vein (LBCV) evaluated by fetal cardiac magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). A retrospective review of 7282 fetal cardiac MRI from June 2006 to March 2017, nine cases of anomalous courses of the LBCV were correctly diagnosed by fetal cardiac MRI, one case of abnormal subaortic left brachiocephalic vein (ASLBV) missed by fetal MRI was identified postnatally during further imaging of the TOF. The diagnosis was confirmed postnatally by cardiac CT/MRI. An ASLBV was found in 8 cases, a retroesophageal LBCV was found in 2 additional cases with right aortic arch and aberrant left subclavian artery. 3 of 8 ASLBV cases were with a right aortic arch, 4 ASLBV cases had additional cardiovascular anomalies with one case isolated. 7 of 8 ASLBV and 2 retroesophageal LBCV were correctly diagnosed by fetal cardiac MRI; however fetal cardiac MRI missed 2 cases of associated pulmonary atresia (PA). Prenatal echocardiography (echo) correctly diagnosed five ASLBV and one retroesophageal LBCV as well as associated intracardiac anomalies. Fetal cardiac MRI can be a useful adjunct in the identification of subaortic and retroesophageal anomalous courses of the LBCV prenatally.