SFG analysis of surface bound proteins: a route towards structure determination

De Novo Design and Characterization of Amphiphilic Peptides with Basic Side Chains for Tailored Interfacial Chemistries

Lysine-leucine (LK) peptides have been used as model systems and platforms for 2D material design for decades. LK peptides are amphiphilic sequences designed to bind and fold at hydrophobic surfaces through hydrophobic leucine side chains and hydrophilic lysine side chains extending into the aqueous subphase. The hydrophobic periodicity of the sequence dictates the secondary structure at the interface. This robust design makes them ideal candidates for controlling interfacial chemistry. This study presents the de novo design and characterization of two novel peptides: LRα14 and LHα14, which substitute lysine with arginine and histidine, respectively, in the helical LKα14 sequence. This modification is intended to expand the LK peptide platform to a new basic interfacial chemistry. We explore the stability of the new LRα14 and LHα14 designs with respect to changes in pH and salt concentration in bulk solution and at the interface using circular dichroism (UV-CD) and vibrational sum-frequency generation spectroscopy, respectively. Notably, the structural stability of the peptides remains unaffected across a wide range of pH and ionic strength values. At the same time, the variation of side-chain chemistry leads to a wide spectrum of interfacial water structures. By extension of the LK platform to include arginine and histidine, this study broadens the toolbox for designing tailored interfacial chemistries with applications in material and biomedical sciences.

Probing Backbone Coupling within Hydrated Proteins with Two-Color 2D Infrared Spectroscopy

The vibrational coupling between protein backbone modes and the role of water interactions are important topics in biomolecular spectroscopy. Our work reports the first study of the coupling between amide I and amide A modes within peptides and proteins with secondary structure and water contacts. We use two-color two-dimensional infrared (2D IR) spectroscopy and observe cross peaks between amide I and amide A modes. In experiments with peptides with different secondary structures and side chains, we observe that the spectra are sensitive to secondary structure. Water interactions affect the cross peaks, which may be useful as probes for the accessibility of protein sites to hydration water. Moving to two-color 2D IR spectra of proteins, the data demonstrate that the cross peaks integrate the sensitivities of both amide I and amide A spectra and that a two-color detection scheme may be a promising tool for probing secondary structures in proteins.

Theoretical basis for interpreting heterodyne chirality-selective sum frequency generation spectra of water

Chirality-selective vibrational sum frequency generation (chiral SFG) spectroscopy has emerged as a powerful technique for the study of biomolecular hydration water due to its sensitivity to the induced chirality of the first hydration shell. Thus far, water O-H vibrational bands in phase-resolved heterodyne chiral SFG spectra have been fit using one Lorentzian function per vibrational band, and the resulting fit has been used to infer the underlying frequency distribution. Here, we show that this approach may not correctly reveal the structure and dynamics of hydration water. Our analysis illustrates that the chiral SFG responses of symmetric and asymmetric O-H stretch modes of water have opposite phase and equal magnitude and are separated in energy by intramolecular vibrational coupling and a heterogeneous environment. The sum of the symmetric and asymmetric responses implies that an O-H stretch in a heterodyne chiral SFG spectrum should appear as two peaks with opposite phase and equal amplitude. Using pairs of Lorentzian functions to fit water O-H stretch vibrational bands, we improve spectral fitting of previously acquired experimental spectra of model β-sheet proteins and reduce the number of free parameters. The fitting allows us to estimate the vibrational frequency distribution and thus reveals the molecular interactions of water in hydration shells of biomolecules directly from chiral SFG spectra.

Peptide Orientation Strongly Affected by the Nanoparticle Size as Revealed by Sum Frequency Scattering Spectroscopy

The orientation of proteins at interfaces has a profound effect on the function of proteins. For nanoparticles (NPs) in a biological environment, protein orientation determines the toxicity, function, and identity of the NP. Thus, understanding how proteins orientate at NP surfaces is a critical parameter in controlling NP biochemistry. While planar surfaces are often used to model NP interfaces for protein orientation studies, it has been shown recently that proteins can orient very differently on NP surfaces. This study uses sum frequency scattering vibrational spectroscopy of the model helical leucine-lysine (LK) peptide on NPs of different sizes to determine the cause for the orientation effects. The data show that, for low dielectric constant materials, the orientation of the helical LK peptide is a function of the coulombic forces between peptides across different particle volumes. This finding strongly suggests that flat model systems are only of limited use for determining protein orientation at NP interfaces and that charge interactions should be considered when designing medical NPs or assessing NP biocompatibility.

Lysozyme Interaction with Phospholipid Nanodroplets Probed by Sum Frequency Scattering Vibrational Spectroscopy

When a nanoparticle (NP) is introduced into a biological environment, its identity and interactions are immediately attributed to the dense layer of proteins that quickly covers the particle. The formation of this layer, dubbed the protein corona, is in general a combination of proteins interacting with the surface of the NP and a contest between other proteins for binding sites either at the surface of the NP or upon the dense layer. Despite the importance for surface engineering and drug development, the molecular mechanisms and structure behind interfacial biomolecule action have largely remained elusive. We use ultrafast sum frequency scattering (SFS) spectroscopy to determine the structure and the mode of action by which these biomolecules interact with and manipulate interfaces. The majority of work in the field of sum frequency generation has been done on flat model interfaces. This limits some important membrane properties such as membrane fluidity and dimensionality─important factors in biomolecule-membrane interactions. To move toward three-dimensional (3D) nanoscopic interfaces, we utilize SFS spectroscopy to interrogate the surface of 3D lipid monolayers, which can be used as a model lipid-based nanocarrier system. In this study, we have utilized SFS spectroscopy to follow the action of lysozyme. SFS spectra in the amide I region suggest that there is lysozyme at the interface and that the lysozyme induces an increased lipid monolayer order. The binding of lysozyme with the NP is demonstrated by an increase in acyl chain order determined by the ratio of the CH₃ symmetric and CH₂ symmetric peak amplitudes. Furthermore, the lipid headgroup orientation s-PO₂^- change strongly supports lysozyme insertion into the lipid layer causing lipid disruption and reorientation. Altogether, with SFS, we have made a huge stride toward understanding the binding and structure change of proteins within the protein corona.

Determination of protein conformation and orientation at buried solid/liquid interfaces

Protein structures at solid/liquid interfaces mediate interfacial protein functions, which are important for many applications. It is difficult to probe interfacial protein structures at buried solid/liquid interfaces in situ at the molecular level. Here, a systematic methodology to determine protein molecular structures (orientation and conformation) at buried solid/liquid interfaces in situ was successfully developed with a combined approach using a nonlinear optical spectroscopic technique - sum frequency generation (SFG) vibrational spectroscopy, isotope labeling, spectra calculation, and computer simulation. With this approach, molecular structures of protein GB1 and its mutant (with two amino acids mutated) were investigated at the polymer/solution interface. Markedly different orientations and similar (but not identical) conformations of the wild-type protein GB1 and its mutant at the interface were detected, due to the varied molecular interfacial interactions. This systematic strategy is general and can be widely used to elucidate protein structures at buried interfaces in situ.

Atomistic simulations for investigation of substrate effects on lipid in-source fragmentation in secondary ion mass spectrometry

In beam-based ionization methods, the substrate plays an important role on the desorption mechanism of molecules from surfaces. Both the specific orientation that a molecule adopts at a surface and the strength of the molecule-surface interaction can greatly influence desorption processes, which in turn will affect the ion yield and the degree of in-source fragmentation of a molecule. In the beam-based method of secondary ion mass spectrometry (SIMS), in-source fragmentation can be significant and molecule specific due to the hard ionization method of using a primary ion beam for molecule desorption. To investigate the role of the substrate on orientation and in-source fragmentation, we have used atomistic simulations-molecular dynamics in combination with density functional theory calculations-to explore the desorption of a sphingolipid (palmitoylsphingomyelin) from a model surface (gold). We then compare SIMS data from this model system to our modeling findings. Using this approach, we found that the combined adsorption and binding energy of certain bonds associated with the headgroup fragments (C₃H₈N⁺, C₅H₁₂N⁺, C₅H₁₄NO⁺, and C₅H₁₅PNO₄ ⁺) was a good predictor for fragment intensities (as indicated by relative ion yields). This is the first example where atomistic simulations have been applied in beam-based ionization of lipids, and it presents a new approach to study biointerfacial lipid ordering effects on SIMS imaging.

Peptide Orientation at Emulsion Nanointerfaces Dramatically Different from Flat Surfaces

The adsorption of protein to nanoparticles plays an important role in toxicity, food science, pharmaceutics, and biomaterial science. Understanding how proteins bind to nanophase surfaces is instrumental for understanding and, ultimately, controlling nanoparticle (NP) biochemistry. Techniques probing the adsorption of proteins at NP interfaces exist; however, these methods have been unable to determine the orientation and folding of proteins at these interfaces. For the first time, we probe in situ with sum frequency scattering vibrational spectroscopy the orientation of model leucine-lysine (LK) peptides adsorbed to NPs. The results show that both α-helical and β-strand LK peptides bind the particles in an upright orientation, in contrast to the flat orientation of LKs binding to planar surfaces. The different binding geometry is explained by Coulombic forces between peptides across the particle volume.

Probing Molecular Interactions of Antibody Drugs, Silicone Oil, and Surfactant at Buried Interfaces In Situ

Antibody drugs have been rapidly developed to cure many diseases including COVID-19 infection. Silicone oil is commonly used as a lubricant coating material for devices used in the pharmaceutical industry to store and administer antibody drug formulations. However, the interaction between silicone oil and antibody molecules could lead to the adsorption, denaturation, and aggregation of antibody molecules, impacting the efficacy of antibody drugs. Here, we studied the molecular interactions between antibodies and silicone oil in situ in real time. The effect of the surfactant on such interactions was also investigated. Specifically, the adsorption dynamics of a bispecific antibody (BsAb) onto a silicone oil surface without and with different concentrations of the surfactant PS80 in antibody solutions were monitored. Also the possible lowest effective PS80 concentrations that can prevent the adsorption of BsAb as well as a monoclonal antibody (mAb) onto silicone oil were measured. It was found that different concentrations of PS80 are required for preventing the adsorption of different antibodies. Both BsAB and mAB denature on silicone oil without a surfactant. However, for a low surfactant concentration in the solution, although the surfactant could not completely prevent the antibody from adsorption, it could maintain the native structures of adsorbed BsAb and mAb antibodies on silicone oil. This is important knowledge, showing that to prevent antibody aggregation on silicone oil it is not necessary to add surfactant to a concentration high enough to completely minimize protein adsorption.

Probing and Manipulating Noncovalent Interactions in Functional Polymeric Systems

Noncovalent interactions, which usually feature tunable strength, reversibility, and environmental adaptability, have been recognized as driving forces in a variety of biological and chemical processes, contributing to the recognition between molecules, the formation of molecule clusters, and the establishment of complex structures of macromolecules. The marriage of noncovalent interactions and conventional covalent polymers offers the systems novel mechanical, physicochemical, and biological properties, which are highly dependent on the binding mechanisms of the noncovalent interactions that can be illuminated via quantification. This review systematically discusses the nanomechanical characterization of typical noncovalent interactions in polymeric systems, mainly through direct force measurements at microscopic, nanoscopic, and molecular levels, which provide quantitative information (e.g., ranges, strengths, and dynamics) on the binding behaviors. The fundamental understandings of intermolecular and interfacial interactions are then correlated to the macroscopic performances of a series of noncovalently bonded polymers, whose functions (e.g., stimuli-responsiveness, self-healing capacity, universal adhesiveness) can be customized through the manipulation of the noncovalent interactions, providing insights into the rational design of advanced materials with applications in biomedical, energy, environmental, and other engineering fields.

Measuring Protein Conformation at Aqueous Interfaces with 2D Infrared Spectroscopy of Emulsions

Determining the secondary and tertiary structures of proteins at aqueous interfaces is crucial for understanding their function, but measuring these structures selectively at the interface is challenging. Here we demonstrate that two-dimensional infrared (2D-IR) spectroscopy of protein stabilized emulsions offers a new route to measuring interfacial protein structure with high levels of detail. We prepared hexadecane/water oil-in-water emulsions stabilized by model LK peptides that are known to fold into either α-helix or β-sheet conformations at hydrophobic interfaces and measured 2D-IR spectra in a transmission geometry. We saw clear spectral signatures of the peptides folding at the interface, with no detectable residue from remaining bulk peptides. Using 2D spectroscopy gives us access to correlation and dynamics data, which enables structural assignment in cases where linear spectroscopy fails. Using the emulsions allows one to study interfacial spectra with standard transmission geometry spectrometers, bringing the richness of 2D-IR to the interface with no additional optical complexity.

Tutorials in vibrational sum frequency generation spectroscopy. III. Collecting, processing, and analyzing vibrational sum frequency generation spectra

In this Tutorial series, we aim to provide an accessible introduction to vibrational sum frequency generation (VSFG) spectroscopy, targeted toward people entering the VSFG world without a rigorous formal background in optical physics or nonlinear spectroscopy. In this article, we discuss in detail the processes of collecting and processing VSFG data, and user-friendly processing software (sfgtools) is provided for use by people new to the field. Some discussion of analyzing VSFG spectra is also given, specifically with a discussion of fitting homodyne VSFG spectra, and a discussion of what can be learned (both qualitatively and quantitatively) from VSFG spectra.

Protein-Nanoparticle Complex Structure Determination by Cryo-Electron Microscopy

Methods that allow the study of the structure of proteins in complex with nanomaterials promise to enhance our understanding of how biological molecules interface with inorganic materials. We used single-particle cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) to demonstrate the potential for cryo-EM analysis to reveal structural details of protein-nanoparticle complexes. Two protein-nanomaterial complexes, namely, GroEL bound to platinum nanoparticles (GroEL-PtNP) and ferritin bound to an iron oxide nanoparticle, were used as model samples. For the GroEL-PtNP complex, a final reconstruction was obtained to 3.93 Å, which allowed us to fit the atomic model of GroEL into the resulting map. This sets the stage for future work and improvements on the use of cryo-EM for the study of protein-nanomaterial complexes.

Probing Orientations and Conformations of Peptides and Proteins at Buried Interfaces

Molecular structures of peptides/proteins at interfaces determine their interfacial properties, which play important roles in many applications. It is difficult to probe interfacial peptide/protein structures because of the lack of appropriate tools. Sum frequency generation (SFG) vibrational spectroscopy has been developed into a powerful technique to elucidate molecular structures of peptides/proteins at buried solid/liquid and liquid/liquid interfaces. SFG has been successfully applied to study molecular interactions between model cell membranes and antimicrobial peptides/membrane proteins, surface-immobilized peptides/enzymes, and physically adsorbed peptides/proteins on polymers and 2D materials. A variety of other analytical techniques and computational simulations provide supporting information to SFG studies, leading to more complete understanding of structure-function relationships of interfacial peptides/proteins. With the advance of SFG techniques and data analysis methods, along with newly developed supplemental tools and simulation methodology, SFG research on interfacial peptides/proteins will further impact research in fields like chemistry, biology, biophysics, engineering, and beyond.

Effect of Surfactant Concentration and Hydrophobicity on the Ordering of Water at a Silica Surface

The performance of nonionic surfactants is mediated by the interfacial interactions at the solid-liquid interface. Here we applied sum frequency generation (SFG) vibrational spectroscopy to probe the molecular structure of the silica-nonionic surfactant solution interface in situ, supplemented by quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation monitoring (QCM-D) and molecular dynamics (MD) simulations. The combined studies elucidated the effects of nonionic surfactant solution concentration, surfactant composition, and rinsing on the silica-surfactant solution interfacial structure. The nonionic surfactants studied include ethylene-oxide (EO) and butylene oxide (BO) components with different ratios. It was found that the CH groups of the surfactants at the silica-surfactant solution interfaces are disordered, but the interfacial water molecules are ordered, generating strong SFG OH signals. Solutions with higher concentrations of surfactant lead to a slightly higher amount of adsorbed surfactant at the silica interface, resulting in more water molecules being ordered at the interface, or a higher ordering of water molecules at the interface, or both. MD simulation results indicated that the nonionic surface molecules preferentially adsorb onto silanol sites on silica. A surfactant with a higher EO/BO ratio leads to more water molecules being ordered and a higher degree of ordering of water molecules at the silica-surfactant solution interface, exhibiting stronger SFG OH signal, although less material is adsorbed according to the QCM-D data. A thin layer of surfactants remained on the silica surface after multiple water rinses. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first time the combined approaches of SFG, QCM-D and MD simulation techniques have been applied to study nonionic surfactants at the silica-solution interface, which enhances our understanding on the interfacial interactions between nonionic surfactants, water and silica. The knowledge obtained from this study can be helpful to design the optimal surfactant concentration and composition for future applications.

Developments and Ongoing Challenges for Analysis of Surface-Bound Proteins

Proteins at surfaces and interfaces play important roles in the function and performance of materials in applications ranging from diagnostic assays to biomedical devices. To improve the performance of these materials, detailed molecular structure (conformation and orientation) along with the identity and concentrations of the surface-bound proteins on those materials must be determined. This article describes radiolabeling, surface plasmon resonance, quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation, X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, secondary ion mass spectrometry, sum frequency generation spectroscopy, and computational techniques along with the information each technique provides for characterizing protein films. A multitechnique approach using both experimental and computation methods is required for these investigations. Although it is now possible to gain much insight into the structure of surface-bound proteins, it is still not possible to obtain the same level of structural detail about proteins on surfaces as can be obtained about proteins in crystals and solutions, especially for large, complex proteins. However, recent results have shown it is possible to obtain detailed structural information (e.g., backbone and side chain orientation) about small peptides (5-20 amino sequences) on surfaces. Current studies are extending these investigations to small proteins such as protein G B1 (∼6 kDa). Approaches for furthering the capabilities for characterizing the molecular structure of surface-bound proteins are proposed.

Interfacial Structure and Interfacial Tension in Model Carbon Fiber-Reinforced Polymers

Carbon fiber-reinforced plastics (CFRPs) are widely used materials with outstanding mechanical properties. The wettability between the polymer matrix and carbon fiber in the interphase region significantly influences the strength of the composite. Sizing agents consisting of multiple components are therefore frequently applied to improve wetting and interfacial adhesion between polymers and carbon fiber in CFRPs. However, the complex compositions of sizing solutions make detailed interpretations of their impacts on interfacial wetting difficult. In this work, surface-sensitive sum frequency generation (SFG) spectroscopy was utilized to characterize the sizing/polymer and sizing/carbon fiber interfacial structures to gain molecular-level understandings of the wetting improvements afforded by sizing. A mixture sizing solution containing polyethylenimine (PEI, adhesion promoter) and Lutensol (surfactant) was investigated when contacting nylon (model plastics), polypropylene (model plastics), and graphite (model carbon fiber). Our results demonstrated that although the addition of the surfactant led to an interfacial tension decrease (in comparison to pure PEI solution) on nylon and polypropylene, the interfacial tension was surprisingly increased on graphite, contrasting with the commonly accepted function of surfactants. SFG characterizations revealed the multilayer molecular structures at these buried interfaces. The peculiar interfacial tension increase at the graphite/sizing interface was then correlated to the strong amine-π interactions between PEI and graphite. PEI was therefore demonstrated to be an effective adhesion promoter for carbon fiber. This article reports the first investigation of (polymer + surfactant) complex structures at solid-liquid interfaces. The valuable structural insights obtained by SFG analysis enable more accurate understandings of the composition-wettability (structure-function) relationship. These detailed understandings of interactions between sizing and the substrates promote more informed and optimized selections of sizing formulae.

Studies of Dynamic Binding of Amino Acids to TiO2 Nanoparticle Surfaces by Solution NMR and Molecular Dynamics Simulations

Adsorption of biomolecules onto material surfaces involves a potentially complex mechanism where molecular species interact to varying degrees with a heterogeneous material surface. Surface adsorption studies by atomic force microscopy, sum frequency generation spectroscopy, and solid-state NMR detect the structures and interactions of biomolecular species that are bound to material surfaces, which, in the absence of a solid-liquid interface, do not exchange rapidly between surface-bound forms and free molecular species in bulk solution. Solution NMR has the potential to complement these techniques by detecting and studying transiently bound biomolecules at the liquid-solid interface. Herein, we show that dark-state exchange saturation transfer (DEST) NMR experiments on gel-stabilized TiO₂ nanoparticle (NP) samples detect several forms of biomolecular adsorption onto titanium(IV) oxide surfaces. Specifically, we use the DEST approach to study the interaction of amino acids arginine (Arg), lysine (Lys), leucine (Leu), alanine (Ala), and aspartic acid (Asp) with TiO₂ rutile NP surfaces. Whereas Leu, Ala, and Asp display only a single weakly interacting form in the presence of TiO₂ NPs, Arg and Lys displayed at least two distinct bound forms: a species that is surface bound and retains a degree of reorientational motion and a second more tightly bound form characterized by broadened DEST profiles upon the addition of TiO₂ NPs. Molecular dynamics simulations indicate different surface bound states for both Lys and Arg depending on the degree of TiO₂ surface hydroxylation but only a single bound state for Asp regardless of the degree of surface hydroxylation, in agreement with results obtained from the analysis of DEST profiles.

Biological responses to physicochemical properties of biomaterial surface

Biomedical scientists use chemistry-driven processes found in nature as an inspiration to design biomaterials as promising diagnostic tools, therapeutic solutions, or tissue substitutes. While substantial consideration is devoted to the design and validation of biomaterials, the nature of their interactions with the surrounding biological microenvironment is commonly neglected. This gap of knowledge could be owing to our poor understanding of biochemical signaling pathways, lack of reliable techniques for designing biomaterials with optimal physicochemical properties, and/or poor stability of biomaterial properties after implantation. The success of host responses to biomaterials, known as biocompatibility, depends on chemical principles as the root of both cell signaling pathways in the body and how the biomaterial surface is designed. Most of the current review papers have discussed chemical engineering and biological principles of designing biomaterials as separate topics, which has resulted in neglecting the main role of chemistry in this field. In this review, we discuss biocompatibility in the context of chemistry, what it is and how to assess it, while describing contributions from both biochemical cues and biomaterials as well as the means of harmonizing them. We address both biochemical signal-transduction pathways and engineering principles of designing a biomaterial with an emphasis on its surface physicochemistry. As we aim to show the role of chemistry in the crosstalk between the surface physicochemical properties and body responses, we concisely highlight the main biochemical signal-transduction pathways involved in the biocompatibility complex. Finally, we discuss the progress and challenges associated with the current strategies used for improving the chemical and physical interactions between cells and biomaterial surface.

Surface analysis tools for characterizing biological materials

Surfaces represent a unique state of matter that typically have significantly different compositions and structures from the bulk of a material. Since surfaces are the interface between a material and its environment, they play an important role in how a material interacts with its environment. Thus, it is essential to characterize, in as much detail as possible, the surface structure and composition of a material. However, this can be challenging since the surface region typically is only minute portion of the entire material, requiring specialized techniques to selectively probe the surface region. This tutorial will provide a brief review of several techniques used to characterize the surface and interface regions of biological materials. For each technique we provide a description of the key underlying physics and chemistry principles, the information provided, strengths and weaknesses, the types of samples that can be analyzed, and an example application. Given the surface analysis challenges for biological materials, typically there is never just one technique that can provide a complete surface characterization. Thus, a multi-technique approach to biological surface analysis is always required.

Corn Oil-Water Separation: Interactions of Proteins and Surfactants at Corn Oil/Water Interfaces

Purification and collection of industrial products from oil-water mixtures are commonly implemented processes. However, the efficiencies of such processes can be severely influenced by the presence of emulsifiers that induce the formation of small oil droplets dispersed in the mixtures. Understanding of this emulsifying effect and its counteractions which occur at the oil/water interface is therefore necessary for the improvement of designs of these processes. In this paper, we investigated the interfacial mechanisms of protein-induced emulsification and the opposing surfactant-induced demulsification related to corn oil refinement. At corn oil/water interfaces, the pH-dependent emulsifying function of zein protein, which is the major storage protein of corn, was elucidated by the surface/interface-sensitive sum frequency generation (SFG) vibrational spectroscopy technique. The effective stabilization of corn oil droplets by zein protein was illustrated and correlated to its ordered amide I group at the oil/water interface. Substantial decrease of this ordering with the addition of three industrial surfactants to corn oil-zein solution mixtures was also observed using SFG, which explains the surfactant-induced destabilization and coalescence of small oil droplets. Surfactant-protein interaction was then demonstrated to be the driving force for the disordering of interfacial proteins, either by disrupting protein layers or partially excluding protein molecules from the interface. The ordered zein proteins at the interface were therefore revealed to be the critical factor for the formation of corn oil-water emulsion.

Probing the Interfacial Interactions of Monoclonal and Bispecific Antibodies at the Silicone Oil-Aqueous Solution Interface by Using Sum Frequency Generation Vibrational Spectroscopy

Silicone oil has been widely utilized in the pharmaceutical industry especially as a lubricant coating commonly used in syringes for the smooth delivery of drugs. Protein structure perturbation and aggregation have been reported upon protein contacting silicone oil by using indirect methods and ex-situ techniques. The conclusions derived from such indirect and ex-situ methods may not truly reflect the exact nature of the protein-silicone oil interfacial interactions. Recently, we have successfully demonstrated that sum frequency generation (SFG) vibrational spectroscopy can be used as a powerful and direct method of studying the fusion protein-silicone oil interfacial interactions in situ and in real time. In this article, we studied monoclonal and bispecific antibody interactions with the silicone oil surface by using SFG spectroscopy. Being structurally and functionally different in the nature of fusion proteins and antibodies, this study is important in enhancing our current understanding of protein-silicone oil interfacial interactions. Both types of antibodies investigated here readily and strongly adsorb onto the silicone oil surface and remain stable at least for 10 h. SFG spectra in the amide I region for monoclonal and bispecific antibodies centered at 1660 and 1665 cm^-1, respectively, suggest the difference in their molecular structures. The absence of the antibody signals in the amide I region of time-dependent and static SFG spectra obtained for preadsorbed antibodies onto silicone oil after contacting polysorbate 80 (PS-80) surfactant suggests that PS-80 can effectively remove both types of antibodies from the silicone oil surface. This study demonstrated the feasibility of using SFG spectroscopy as a powerful tool for probing the antibody-interfacial interactions in situ and in real time.

Both Poly(ethylene glycol) and Poly(methyl ethylene phosphate) Guide Oriented Adsorption of Specific Proteins

Developing new functional biomaterials requires the ability to simultaneously repel unwanted and guide wanted protein adsorption. Here, we systematically interrogate the factors determining the protein adsorption by comparing the behaviors of different polymeric surfaces, poly(ethylene glycol) and a poly(phosphoester), and five different natural proteins. Interestingly we observe that, at densities comparable to those used in nanocarrier functionalization, the same proteins are either adsorbed (fibrinogen, human serum albumin, and transferrin) or repelled (immunoglobulin G and lysozyme) by both polymers. However, when adsorption takes place, the specific surface dictates the amount and orientation of each protein.

Vibrational Sum-Frequency Scattering as a Sensitive Approach to Detect Structural Changes in Collagen Fibers Treated with Surfactants

Optimizing protocols so that the structure of the collagen fibers in the extracellular matrix remains intact during the decellularization process requires techniques with high structural sensitivity, especially for the surface region of the collagen fibers. Here, we demonstrate that vibrational sum-frequency scattering (SFS) spectroscopy in the protein-specific amide I region provides vibrational spectra and scattering patterns characteristic of protein fiber networks self-assembled in vitro from collagen type I, which are kept in aqueous environments during the analysis. At scattering angles away from the phase-matched direction, the relative strengths of various polarization combinations are highly reproducible, and changes in their ratios can be followed in real time during exposure to sodium dodecyl sulfate surfactant solutions. For the fibers in this work, a scattering angle of about 22° provided specificity for the surface region of the fibers, as it allowed monitoring of immediate structural changes during the surfactant exposure. With further development, we hypothesize that the information from the SFS characterization of collagen fibers may complement information from other techniques with sensitivity to the overall structure, such as second-harmonic generation imaging and infrared spectroscopy, and provide a more complete understanding of fiber molecular structures and interactions during exposure to various environments and conditions.

Interfacial Conformation of Hydrophilic Polyphosphoesters Affects Blood Protein Adsorption

Synthetic polymers are commonly used as protein repelling materials for a variety of biomedical applications. Despite their widespread use, the fundamental mechanism underlying protein repellence is often elusive. Such insights are essential for improving existing and developing new materials. Here, we investigate how subtle differences in the chemistry of hydrophilic polyphosphoesters influence the adsorption of the human blood proteins serum albumin and fibrinogen. Using thermodynamic measurements, surface-specific vibrational spectroscopy, and Brewster angle microscopy, we investigate protein adsorption, hydration, and steric repulsion properties of the polyphosphoester polymers. Whereas both surface hydration and polymer conformation of the polymers vary substantially as a consequence of the chemical differences in the polymer structure, the protein repellency ability of these hydrophilic materials appears to be dominated by steric repulsion.

Surface Analysis: From Single Crystals to Biomaterials

Surfaces and interfaces play a critical role in material performance in many applications including catalysis, biomaterials, microelectronics, tribology and adhesion. Characterizing the important surfaces and interfaces involved in each application may present different challenges, but the approach to investigating them often is rather similar. Specialized instrumentation is typically used to probe the surface region of a material and often times it is required to develop new instrumentation and data analysis methods to obtain the desired information. It usually best to use multiple experimental techniques, often coupled with theoretical calculations and simulations, to gain a more complete understanding of the surface and interface regions. Careful handling and preparation of the samples is required so the surface is not altered during these processes as well as during analysis. Using model samples with well-defined surface structures and compositions can provide information about fundamental processes as well as help develop the analytical tools and methodology needed to characterize complex surfaces and interfaces. Thus, the expertise and experience a surface analyst acquires in one field can be readily applied to other fields, even when those fields are significantly differently (e.g., biomaterials and microelectronics). This has resulted in surface analysts moving rather easily between different research and application areas. As one example my career path of small molecule chemisorption and reactivity on single crystals to industrial catalysis to biomedical surface science is presented in this manuscript.

Surface Water as a Mediator and Reporter of Adhesion at Aqueous Interfaces

Understanding the adsorption of molecules onto surfaces is integral to a wide variety of fields with scientific, engineering, and industrial applications. The surface-adsorbed structure is governed by the nature of the molecule, surface characteristics, and solution environment. There are therefore three critical interactions that govern adhesion: solvent-analyte, substrate-analyte, and substrate-solvent. The last two interactions require a surface-specific probe restricted to a few nanometers or less. This is particularly true of efforts to probe polymer surface structure without being overwhelmed by bulk polymer signal or interfacial water structure in the presence of bulk water. Second-order nonlinear optical techniques are ideal probes of such interactions, as their reporting depth is determined by the polar arrangement of molecules (a break in the macroscopic inversion symmetry) rather than the penetration of the optical fields. This Account begins with an introduction of surface water structure from the perspective of a nonlinear probe. Details about the unique view of the water orientation distribution are discussed and contrasted with information obtained from conventional vibrational techniques. The salient features of water next to model hydrophobic and hydrophilic surfaces are discussed, in preparation for a discussion of solute interactions that follows. We then present three examples using a combination of linear and nonlinear vibrational spectroscopy and molecular dynamics simulations to illustrate how water is both a mediator and a marker of adhesion. The first is a study of amphipathic peptide adhesion onto hydrophobic and hydrophilic surfaces, characterizing the adsorbed structure in relation to the water surrounding the molecule and trapped near the surface. Water is found to be especially important in mediating adhesion to hydrophilic surfaces, where it aids in solvating the peptide as well as facilitating interactions with the surface. In the second example, we look at adhesion of a multicomponent polymer adhesive using surface-bulk heterospectral correlation analysis, in which surface vibrational spectroscopy is combined with bulk infrared absorption to determine interfacial structure development during the evaporation of water. When acrylic acid is added to the polymer, there is a change in orientation of the polymer before an increase in population. This is opposite to what is observed when no additive is present. In our third example, we show how interfacial water provides a unique window into the surface microenvironment during bacterial adhesion, highlighting the role of solution conditions at the surface in cell attachment and biofilm growth. Changes in the nonlinear vibrational response of interfacial water reflect changes occurring in the pH and ionic strength only at the surface, due to the presence of polymeric adhesives secreted by the bacteria. These studies underline the importance of surface water in governing the structure of adhered molecules and in mediating changes in the interfacial environment as a result of adhesion and provide insight into a nanoscale region that is otherwise difficult to query. They also illustrate the importance of combining surface-sensitive and bulk spectroscopic probes with computer modeling to gain a better understanding of the interplay between water and adsorbate structure.

Engineering Proteins at Interfaces: From Complementary Characterization to Material Surfaces with Designed Functions

Once materials come into contact with a biological fluid containing proteins, proteins are generally—whether desired or not—attracted by the material's surface and adsorb onto it. The aim of this Review is to give an overview of the most commonly used characterization methods employed to gain a better understanding of the adsorption processes on either planar or curved surfaces. We continue to illustrate the benefit of combining different methods to different surface geometries of the material. The thus obtained insight ideally paves the way for engineering functional materials that interact with proteins in a predetermined manner.

Simultaneous Observation of the Orientation and Activity of Surface-Immobilized Enzymes

Surface immobilized enzymes have been widely used in many applications such as biosensors, biochips, biofuel production, and biofuel cell construction. Many factors dictate how enzymes' structure, activity, and stability may change when immobilized, including surface functionalization, immobilization chemistry, nature of the solid support, and enzyme surface density. To better understand how immobilization affects enzyme structure and activity, we have developed a method to measure both surface-sensitive protein vibrational spectra and enzymatic activity simultaneously. To accomplish this, an optical/fluorescence microscope was incorporated into a sum frequency generation (SFG) spectrometer. Using β-glucosidase (β-Glu) as a model system, enzymes were covalently tethered to a self-assembled monolayer surface using cysteine-maleimide chemistry. Their orientations were determined by SFG spectroscopy, with a single native cysteine residue oriented toward the functionalized surface, and activity measured simultaneously using a fluorogenic substrate resorufin β-d-glucopyranoside, with a loss of activity of 53% as compared to comparable solution measurements. Measuring β-Glu activity and orientation simultaneously provides more accurate information for designing and further improving enzymatic activity of surface-bound enzymes.

Nonlinear Optical Methods for Characterization of Molecular Structure and Surface Chemistry

The principles, strengths and limitations of several nonlinear optical (NLO) methods for characterizing biological systems are reviewed. NLO methods encompass a wide range of approaches that can be used for real-time, in-situ characterization of biological systems, typically in a label-free mode. Multiphoton excitation fluorescence (MPEF) is widely used for high-quality imaging based on electronic transitions, but lacks interface specificity. Second harmonic generation (SHG) is a parametric process that has all the virtues of the two-photon version of MPEF, yielding a signal at twice the frequency of the excitation light, which provides interface specificity. Both SHG and MPEF can provide images with high structural contrast, but they typically lack molecular or chemical specificity. Other NLO methods such as coherent anti-Stokes Raman scattering (CARS) and stimulated Raman scattering (SRS) can provide high-sensitivity imaging with chemical information since Raman active vibrations are probed. However, CARS and SRS lack interface and surface specificity. A NLO method that provides both interface/surface specificity as well as molecular specificity is vibrational sum frequency generation (SFG) spectroscopy. Vibration modes that are both Raman and IR active are probed in the SFG process, providing the molecular specificity. SFG, like SHG, is a parametric process, which provides the interface and surface specificity. SFG is typically done in the reflection mode from planar samples. This has yielded rich and detailed information about the molecular structure of biomaterial interfaces and biomolecules interacting with their surfaces. However, 2-D systems have limitations for understanding the interactions of biomolecules and interfaces in the 3-D biological environment. The recent advances made in instrumentation and analysis methods for sum frequency scattering (SFS) now present the opportunity for SFS to be used to directly study biological solutions. By detecting the scattering at angles away from the phase-matched direction even centrosymmetric structures that are isotropic (e.g., spherical nanoparticles functionalized with self-assembled monolayers or biomolecules) can be probed. Often a combination of multiple NLO methods or a combination of a NLO method with other spectroscopic methods is required to obtain a full understanding of the molecular structure and surface chemistry of biomaterials and the biomolecules that interact with them. Using the right combination methods provides a powerful approach for characterizing biological materials.

Repelling and ordering: the influence of poly(ethylene glycol) on protein adsorption

Development of new materials for drug delivery and biosensing requires the fine-tuning of interfacial properties. We report here the influence of the poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) grafting density in model phospholipid monolayers on the adsorption behavior of bovine serum albumin and human fibrinogen, not only with respect to the amount of adsorbed protein, but also its orientational ordering on the surface. As expected, with increasing interfacial PEG density, the amount of adsorbed protein decreases up to the point where complete protein repellency is reached. However, at intermediate concentrations, the net orientation of adsorbed fibrinogen is highest. The different proteins respond differently to PEG, not only in the amount of protein adsorbed, but also in the manner that proteins adsorb. The results show that for specific cases, tuning the interfacial PEG concentration allows to guide the protein adsorption configuration, a feature sought after in materials for both biosensing and biomedical applications.

Effect of immobilization site on the orientation and activity of surface-tethered enzymes

Tethering peptides and proteins to abiotic surfaces has the potential to create biomolecule-functionalized surfaces with useful properties.

Determination of Absolute Orientation of Protein α-Helices at Interfaces Using Phase-Resolved Sum Frequency Generation Spectroscopy

Understanding the structure of proteins at surfaces is key in fields such as biomaterials research, biosensor design, membrane biophysics, and drug design. A particularly important factor is the orientation of proteins when bound to a particular surface. The orientation of the active site of enzymes or protein sensors and the availability of binding pockets within membrane proteins are important design parameters for engineers developing new sensors, surfaces, and drugs. Recently developed methods to probe protein orientation, including immunoessays and mass spectrometry, either lack structural resolution or require harsh experimental conditions. We here report a new method to track the absolute orientation of interfacial proteins using phase-resolved sum frequency generation spectroscopy in combination with molecular dynamics simulations and theoretical spectral calculations. As a model system we have determined the orientation of a helical lysine-leucine peptide at the air-water interface. The data show that the absolute orientation of the helix can be reliably determined even for orientations almost parallel to the surface.

Direct Imaging of Protein Stability and Folding Kinetics in Hydrogels

We apply fast relaxation imaging (FReI) as a novel technique for investigating the folding stability and dynamics of proteins within polyacrylamide hydrogels, which have diverse and widespread uses in biotechnology. FReI detects protein unfolding in situ by imaging changes in fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) after temperature jump perturbations. Unlike bulk measurements, diffraction-limited epifluorescence imaging combined with fast temperature perturbations reveals the impact of local environment effects on protein-biomaterial compatibility. Our experiments investigated a crowding sensor protein (CrH2) and phosphoglycerate kinase (PGK), which undergoes cooperative unfolding. The crowding sensor quantifies the confinement effect of the cross-linked hydrogel: the 4% polyacrylamide hydrogel is similar to aqueous solution (no confinement), while the 10% hydrogel is strongly confining. FRAP measurements and protein concentration gradients in the 4% and 10% hydrogels further support this observation. PGK reveals that noncovalent interactions of the protein with the polymer surface are more important than confinement for determining protein properties in the gel: the mere presence of hydrogel increases protein stability, speeds up folding relaxation, and promotes irreversible binding to the polymer even at the solution-gel interface, whereas the difference between the 4% and the 10% hydrogels is negligible despite their large difference in confinement. The imaging capabilities of FReI, demonstrated to be diffraction limited, further revealed spatially homogeneous protein unfolding across the hydrogels at 500 nm length scales and revealed differences in protein properties at the gel-solution boundary.

Orientation and conformation of osteocalcin adsorbed onto calcium phosphate and silica surfaces

Adsorption isotherms, circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy, x-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), and time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry (ToF-SIMS) were used to investigate the adsorption of human osteocalcin (hOC) and decarboxylated (i.e., Gla converted back to Glu) hOC (dhOC) onto various calcium phosphate surfaces as well as silica surfaces. The adsorption isotherms and XPS nitrogen signals were used to track the amount of adsorbed hOC and dhOC. The intensities of key ToF-SIMS amino acid fragments were used to assess changes in the structure of adsorbed hOC and dhOC. CD spectra were used to investigate the secondary structure of OC. The largest differences were observed when the proteins were adsorbed onto silica versus calcium phosphate surfaces. Similar amounts (3-4 at. % N) of hOC and dhOC were adsorbed onto the silica surface. Higher amounts of hOC and dhOC were adsorbed on all the calcium phosphate surfaces. The ToF-SIMS data showed that the intensity of the Cys amino acid fragment, normalized to intensity of all amino acid fragments, was significantly higher (∼×10) when the proteins were adsorbed onto silica. Since in the native OC structure the cysteines are located in the center of three α-helices, this indicates both hOC and dhOC are more denatured on the silica surface. As hOC and dhOC denature upon adsorption to the silica surface, the cysteines become more exposed and are more readily detected by ToF-SIMS. No significant differences were detected between hOC and dhOC adsorbed onto the silica surface, but small differences were observed between hOC and dhOC adsorbed onto the calcium phosphate surfaces. In the OC structure, the α-3 helix is located above the α-1 and α-2 helices. Small differences in the ToF-SIMS intensities from amino acid fragments characteristic of each helical unit (Asn for α-1; His for α-2; and Phe for α-3) suggests either slight changes in the orientation or a slight uncovering of the α-1 and α-2 for adsorbed dhOC. XPS showed that similar amounts of hOC and dhOC were absorbed onto hydroxyapaptite and octacalcium phosphate surfaces, but ToF-SIMS detected some small differences in the amino acid fragment intensities on these surfaces for adsorbed hOC and dhOC.

Interplay between adsorbed peptide structure, trapped water, and surface hydrophobicity

Atomistic molecular dynamics simulations were used to study the influence of interfacial water on the orientation and conformation of a facewise amphipathic α-helical peptide adsorbed to hydrophilic and hydrophobic substrates. Water behavior beneath the peptide adsorbed to a hydrophilic surface was observed to vary with the height of the peptide above the surface. In general, the orientation of water close to the peptide (with the oxygen atom pointing up toward the peptide) was complementary to that observed near the hydrophilic surface in the absence of peptide. That is, no change in orientation of water trapped between the peptide and a hydrophilic surface is required as the peptide approaches the surface. The adsorption of the peptide to the hydrophilic surface was observed to be mediated by a layer of ordered water. Water was found to be largely excluded on adsorption to the hydrophobic surface. However, the small amount of water present was observed to be highly ordered. At the closest point of contact to the hydrophobic surface, the peptide was observed to make direct contact. These findings shed light on the fundamental driving forces of peptide adsorption to hydrophobic and hydrophilic surfaces in aqueous environments.

Molecular Interactions between Graphene and Biological Molecules

Applications of graphene have extended into areas of nanobio-technology such as nanobio-medicine, nanobio-sensing, as well as nanoelectronics with biomolecules. These applications involve interactions between proteins, peptides, DNA, RNA etc. and graphene, therefore understanding such molecular interactions is essential. For example, many applications based on using graphene and peptides require peptides to interact with (e.g., noncovalently bind to) graphene at one end, while simultaneously exposing the other end to the surrounding medium (e.g., to detect analytes in solution). To control and characterize peptide behavior on a graphene surface in solution is difficult. Here we successfully probed the molecular interactions between two peptides (cecropin P1 and MSI-78(C1)) and graphene in situ and in real-time using sum frequency generation (SFG) vibrational spectroscopy and molecular dynamics (MD) simulation. We demonstrated that the distribution of various planar (including aromatic (Phe, Trp, Tyr, and His)/amide (Asn and Gln)/Guanidine (Arg)) side-chains and charged hydrophilic (such as Lys) side-chains in a peptide sequence determines the orientation of the peptide adsorbed on a graphene surface. It was found that peptide interactions with graphene depend on the competition between both planar and hydrophilic residues in the peptide. Our results indicated that part of cecropin P1 stands up on graphene due to an unbalanced distribution of planar and hydrophilic residues, whereas MSI-78(C1) lies down on graphene due to an even distribution of Phe residues and hydrophilic residues. With such knowledge, we could rationally design peptides with desired residues to manipulate peptide-graphene interactions, which allows peptides to adopt optimized structure and exhibit excellent activity for nanobio-technological applications. This research again demonstrates the power to combine SFG vibrational spectroscopy and MD simulation in studying interfacial biological molecules.

Predicting the orientation of protein G B1 on hydrophobic surfaces using Monte Carlo simulations

A Monte Carlo algorithm was developed to predict the most likely orientations of protein G B1, an immunoglobulin G (IgG) antibody-binding domain of protein G, adsorbed onto a hydrophobic surface. At each Monte Carlo step, the protein was rotated and translated as a rigid body. The assumption about rigidity was supported by quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation monitoring experiments, which indicated that protein G B1 adsorbed on a polystyrene surface with its native structure conserved and showed that its IgG antibody-binding activity was retained. The Monte Carlo simulations predicted that protein G B1 is likely adsorbed onto a hydrophobic surface in two different orientations, characterized as two mutually exclusive sets of amino acids contacting the surface. This was consistent with sum frequency generation (SFG) vibrational spectroscopy results. In fact, theoretical SFG spectra calculated from an equal combination of the two predicted orientations exhibited reasonable agreement with measured spectra of protein G B1 on polystyrene surfaces. Also, in explicit solvent molecular dynamics simulations, protein G B1 maintained its predicted orientation in three out of four runs. This work shows that using a Monte Carlo approach can provide an accurate estimate of a protein orientation on a hydrophobic surface, which complements experimental surface analysis techniques and provides an initial system to study the interaction between a protein and a surface in molecular dynamics simulations.

Using Neutron Reflectometry to Discern the Structure of Fibrinogen Adsorption at the Stainless Steel/Aqueous Interface

Neutron reflectometry has been successfully used to study adsorption on a stainless steel surface by means of depositing a thin steel film on silicon. The film was characterized using XPS (X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy), TOF-SIMS (time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry), and GIXRD (grazing incidence X-ray diffraction), demonstrating the retention both of the austenitic phase and of the required composition for 316L stainless steel. The adsorption of fibrinogen from a physiologically-relevant solution onto the steel surface was studied using neutron reflectometry and QCM (quartz crystal microbalance) and compared to that on a deposited chromium oxide surface. It was found that the protein forms an irreversibly bound layer at low concentrations, with maximum protein concentration a distance of around 20 Å from the surface. Evidence for a further diffuse reversibly-bound layer forming at higher concentrations was also observed. Both the structure of the layer revealed by the neutron reflectometry data and the high water retention predicted by the QCM data suggest that there is a significant extent of protein unfolding upon adsorption. A lower extent of adsorption was seen on the chromium surfaces, although the adsorbed layer structures were similar, suggesting comparable adsorption mechanisms.

Differential surface activation of the A1 domain of von Willebrand factor

The clotting protein von Willebrand factor (VWF) binds to platelet receptor glycoprotein Ibα (GPIbα) when VWF is activated by chemicals, high shear stress, or immobilization onto surfaces. Activation of VWF by surface immobilization is an important problem in the failure of cardiovascular implants, but is poorly understood. Here, the authors investigate whether some or all surfaces can activate VWF at least in part by affecting the orientation or conformation of the immobilized GPIbα-binding A1 domain of VWF. Platelets binding to A1 adsorbed onto polystyrene surfaces translocated rapidly at moderate and high flow, but detached at low flow, while platelets binding to A1 adsorbed onto glass or tissue-culture treated polystyrene surfaces translocated slowly, and detached only at high flow. Both x-ray photoelectron spectroscopy and conformation independent antibodies reported comparable A1 amounts on all surfaces. Time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry (ToF-SIMS) and near-edge x-ray absorption fine structure spectra suggested differences in orientation on the three surfaces, but none that could explain the biological data. Instead, ToF-SIMS data and binding of conformation-dependent antibodies were consistent with the stabilization of an alternative more activated conformation of A1 by tissue culture polystyrene and especially glass. These studies demonstrate that different material surfaces differentially affect the conformation of adsorbed A1 domain and its biological activity. This is important when interpreting or designing in vitro experiments with surface-adsorbed A1 domain, and is also of likely relevance for blood-contacting biomaterials.