New protective ligands for atomically precise silver nanoclusters

Chemical Flexibility of Atomically Precise Metal Clusters

Ligand-protected metal clusters possess hybrid properties that seamlessly combine an inorganic core with an organic ligand shell, imparting them exceptional chemical flexibility and unlocking remarkable application potential in diverse fields. Leveraging chemical flexibility to expand the library of available materials and stimulate the development of new functionalities is becoming an increasingly pressing requirement. This Review focuses on the origin of chemical flexibility from the structural analysis, including intra-cluster bonding, inter-cluster interactions, cluster-environments interactions, metal-to-ligand ratios, and thermodynamic effects. In the introduction, we briefly outline the development of metal clusters and explain the differences and commonalities of M(I)/M(I/0) coinage metal clusters. Additionally, we distinguish the bonding characteristics of metal atoms in the inorganic core, which give rise to their distinct chemical flexibility. Section 2 delves into the structural analysis, bonding categories, and thermodynamic theories related to metal clusters. In the following sections 3 to 7, we primarily elucidate the mechanisms that trigger chemical flexibility, the dynamic processes in transformation, the resultant alterations in structure, and the ensuing modifications in physical-chemical properties. Section 8 presents the notable applications that have emerged from utilizing metal clusters and their assemblies. Finally, in section 9, we discuss future challenges and opportunities within this area.

Surface-exposed silver nanoclusters inside molecular metal oxide cavities

The surfaces of metal nanoclusters, including their interface with metal oxides, exhibit a high reactivity that is attractive for practical purposes. This high reactivity, however, has also hindered the synthesis of structurally well-defined hybrids of metal nanoclusters and metal oxides with exposed surfaces and/or interfaces. Here we report the sequential synthesis of structurally well-defined {Ag₃₀} nanoclusters in the cavity of ring-shaped molecular metal oxides known as polyoxometalates. The {Ag₃₀} nanoclusters possess exposed silver surfaces yet are stabilized both in solution and the solid state by the surrounding ring-shaped polyoxometalate species. The clusters underwent a redox-induced structural transformation without undesirable agglomeration or decomposition. Furthermore, {Ag₃₀} nanoclusters showed high catalytic activity for the selective reduction of several organic functional groups using H₂ under mild reaction conditions. We believe that these findings will serve for the discrete synthesis of surface-exposed metal nanoclusters stabilized by molecular metal oxides, which may in turn find applications in, for example, the fields of catalysis and energy conversion.

Secondary hierarchical complexity in double-stranded cluster helicates covered by NNNNN type pincer ligands

We designed and synthesized a new tripyridine dipyrrolide pincer ligand, which could be doubly deprotonated to provide five-nitrogen-donor sites and then utilized to prepare a subnanometric chiral silver cluster. The cluster belongs to an S₄ point group and shows a double-stranded helicate. DFT calculations were performed to analyze the electronic structure of the cluster. Interestingly, through hierarchical intercluster interactions, the cluster helicates evolve into complex secondary structures including a right-handed helix and a folded sheet, both of which are reminiscent of secondary structures of proteins, i.e., an α-helix and an antiparallel β-sheet.

The first polyoxoniobate-templated silver cluster with temperature-dependent luminescent emission

The compound [(Nb₆O₁₉)@Ag₃₄(^tBuCC)₂₄(CH₃COO)₂] (Ag₃₄) was synthesized using the solvothermal method combined with volatilization. This was the first case, to the best of our knowledge, of isolating a silver cluster containing a polyoxoniobate (PONb) template. The luminescence, solution behavior and solid-state stability of Ag₃₄ were studied in detail. Electrospray ionization mass spectrometry indicated that Ag₃₄ can maintain the integrity of its skeleton in solution. Detection of temperature could be a potential application of its unique luminescent behavior. We expect this work to inspire further fabrications of PONb-templated high-nuclearity silver clusters.

Structural Engineering toward Gold Nanocluster Catalysis

Atomically precise gold nanoclusters provide great opportunities to explore the relationship between the structure and properties of nanogold catalysts. A nanocluster consists of a metal core and a surface ligand shell, and both the core and shell have significant effects on the catalytic properties. Thanks to their precise structures, the active metal site of the clusters can be readily identified and the effects of ligands on catalysis can be disclosed. In this Minireview, we summarize recent advances in catalytic research of gold nanoclusters, emphasizing four strategies for constructing open metal sites, including by post-treatment, the bulky ligands strategy, the surface geometric mismatch method, and heteroatom doping procedures. We also discuss the effects of ligands on the catalytic activity, selectivity, and stability of gold cluster catalysts. Finally, we present future challenges relating to gold cluster catalysis.

Synthesis of silica-stabilized Ag44 clusters aided by a designed mercaptosilane ligand

The novel and precise design of both a microscopic ligand and macroscopic structure has been demonstrated to improve the stability and potential optical applications of Ag₄₄ clusters. The ligand with designed silane substituents on its thiophenol enabled the synthesized [Ag₄₄(SPhSi(OEt)₃)₃₀](PPh₄)₄ clusters to maintain UV-vis absorption for 13 h when heated at 60 °C in air and be readily coated with silica shells via a one-pot reverse microemulsion method. This composite structure overcomes the issue that non-luminescent Ag₄₄ clusters cannot be applied in photothermal and photoacoustic imaging due to their instability.

Alkynyl and halogen co-protected (AuAg)44 nanoclusters: a comparative study on their optical absorbance, structure, and hydrogen evolution performance

We report the synthesis, structure, and electrochemical hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) performance of two alkynyl and halogen coprotected AuAg alloy nanoclusters, namely Au₂₄Ag₂₀(^tBuPh-CC)₂₄Cl₂ (NC 1 for short) and Au₂₂Ag₂₂(^tBuCC)₁₆Br_3.28Cl_2.72 (NC 2 for short). Single crystal X-ray structural analysis revealed that the two nanoclusters possess a rather similar core@shell@shell keplerate metal core configuration to M₁₂@M₂₀@M₁₂ with the main difference in the outermost shell (Au₁₂vs. Au₁₀Ag₂). Interestingly, such a subtle difference in the two-metal-atoms results in different optical absorbance features and drastically different HER performances. Both NCs have excellent long-term stability for the HER, but NC 1 possesses superior activity to NC 2, and density functional theory calculations disclosed that the binding energy of hydrogen to form the key *H intermediate for NC 1 is much lower and hence it adopts a more energetically feasible HER pathway.

Variable control of the electronic states of a silver nanocluster via protonation/deprotonation of polyoxometalate ligands

The properties of metal nanoclusters depend on both their structures and electronic states. However, in contrast to the significant advances achieved in the synthesis of structurally well-defined metal nanoclusters, systematic control of their electronic states is still challenging. In particular, stimuli-responsive and reversible control of the electronic states of metal nanoclusters is attractive from the viewpoint of their practical applications. Recently, we developed a synthesis method for atomically precise Ag nanoclusters using polyoxometalates (POMs) as inorganic ligands. Herein, we exploited the acid/base nature of POMs to reversibly change the electronic states of an atomically precise {Ag₂₇} nanocluster via protonation/deprotonation of the surrounding POM ligands. We succeeded in systematically controlling the electronic states of the {Ag₂₇} nanocluster by adding an acid or a base (0–6 equivalents), which was accompanied by drastic changes in the ultraviolet-visible absorption spectra of the nanocluster solutions. These results demonstrate the great potential of Ag nanoclusters for unprecedented applications in various fields such as sensing, biolabeling, electronics, and catalysis.

The electronic states of Ag nanoclusters were reversibly controlled driven by protonation/deprotonation of polyoxometalate ligands.

Interstitial hydrides in nanoclusters can reduce M(I) (M = Cu, Ag, Au) to M(0) and form stable superatoms

High-nuclearity clusters resemble the closest model between the determination of atomically precise chemical species and the bulk metallic version thereof, and both impacts on a variety of applications, including catalysis, optics, sensors, and new energy sources.  Our interest lies with the nanoclusters of the Group 11 (Cu, Ag, Au) metals stabilized by dichalcogenido and hydrido ligands.  Herein, we describe superatoms formed by the clusters and their relationship with precursor hydrido clusters.  Specifically, our concept seeks to demonstrate a possible correlation that exist between hydrido clusters (and nanoalloys) and the formation of superatoms, with the loss of hydrides and typically with release of H 2 gas.  These reactions appear to be internal self-redox reactions and require no additional reducing agent, but does seem to require a similar core structure.  Knowledge of such processes could provide insight into how clusters grow and an understanding in bridging the atomically precise cluster - metal nanoparticle mechanism.

Homoleptic Alkynyl-Protected Ag15 Nanocluster with Atomic Precision: Structural Analysis and Electrocatalytic Performance toward CO2 Reduction

We report the fabrication of homoleptic alkynyl-protected Ag₁₅ (C≡C-^t Bu)₁₂ ⁺ (abbreviated as Ag₁₅ ) nanocluster and its electrocatalytic properties toward CO₂ reduction reaction. Crystal structure analysis reveals that Ag₁₅ possesses a body-centered-cubic (BCC) structure with an Ag@Ag₈ @Ag₆ metal core configuration. Interestingly, we found that Ag₁₅ can adsorb CO₂ in the air and spontaneously self-assembled into one-dimensional linear material during the crystal growth process. Furthermore, Ag₁₅ can convert CO₂ into CO with a faradaic efficiency of ca. 95.0 % at -0.6 V and a maximal turnover frequency of 6.37 s^-1 at -1.1 V along with excellent long-term stability. Finally, density functional theory (DFT) calculations disclosed that Ag₁₅ (C≡C-^t Bu)₁₁ ⁺ with one alkynyl ligand stripping off from the intact cluster can expose the uncoordinated Ag atom as the catalytically active site for CO formation.

Observation of a bcc-like framework in polyhydrido copper nanoclusters

Cu is well-known to adopt a face-centered cubic (fcc) structure in the bulk phase. Ligand-stabilized Cu nanoclusters (NCs) with atomically precise structures are an emerging class of nanomaterials. However, it remains a great challenge to have non-fcc structured Cu NCs. In this contribution, we report the syntheses and total structure determination of six 28-nuclearity polyhydrido Cu NCs: [Cu₂₈H₁₆(dppp)₄(RS)₄(CF₃CO₂)₈] (dppp = 1,3-bis(diphenylphosphino)propane, RSH = cyclohexylthiol, 1; tert-butylthiol, 3; and 2-thiophenethiol, 4) and [Cu₂₈H₁₆(dppe)₄(RS)₄(CH₃CO₂)₆Cl₂] (dppe = 1,2-bis(diphenylphosphino)ethane, RSH = (4-isopropyl)thiophenol, 2; 4-tert-butylbenzenethiol, 5; and 4-tert-butylbenzylmercaptan, 6). Their well-defined structures solved by X-ray single crystal diffraction reveal that these 28-Cu NCs are isostructural, and the overall metal framework is arranged as a sandwich structure with a core-shell Cu₂@Cu₁₆ unit held by two Cu₅ fragments. One significant finding is that the organization of 18 Cu atoms in the Cu₂@Cu₁₆ could be regarded as an incomplete and distorted version of 3 × 2 × 2 "cutout" of the body-centered cubic (bcc) bulk phase, which was strikingly different to the fcc structure of bulk Cu. The bcc framework came as a surprise, as no bcc structures have been previously observed in Cu NCs. A comparison with the ideal bcc arrangement of 18 Cu atoms in the bcc lattice suggests that the distortion of the bcc structure results from the insertion of interstitial hydrides. The existence, number, and location of hydrides in these polyhydrido Cu NCs are established by combined experimental and DFT results. These results have significant implications for the development of high-nuclearity Cu hydride NCs with a non-fcc architecture.

A Molecular Hybrid of an Atomically Precise Silver Nanocluster and Polyoxometalates for H2 Cleavage into Protons and Electrons

Atomically precise silver (Ag) nanoclusters are promising materials as catalysts, photocatalysts, and sensors because of their unique structures and mixed-valence states (Ag⁺ /Ag⁰ ). However, their low stability hinders the in-depth study of their intrinsic reactivity and catalytic property accompanying their redox processes. Herein, we demonstrate that a molecular hybrid of an atomically precise {Ag₂₇ }¹⁷⁺ nanocluster and polyoxometalates (POMs) can efficiently cleave H₂ into protons and electrons. The Ag nanocluster accommodates electrons through the redox reaction from {Ag₂₇ }¹⁷⁺ to {Ag₂₇ }¹³⁺ , and the POM ligands play the following important roles: (i) a significant stabilization of the typically unstable Ag nanocluster to preserve its structure during the redox reaction with H₂ , (ii) formation of a unique interface between the Ag nanocluster and metal oxides for efficient H₂ cleavage, and (iii) storage of the generated protons on the negatively charged basic surface.

Stable supercapacitor electrode based on two-dimensional high nucleus silver nano-clusters as a green energy source

Atomically precise silver nanoclusters (Ag-NCs) are known as a hot research area owing to their brilliant features and they have attracted an immense amount of research attention over the last year. There is a lack of sufficient understanding about the Ag-NC synthesis mechanisms that result in optimal silver nanoclusters with an appropriate size, shape, and morphology. In addition, the coexisting flexible coordination of silver ions, the argentophilic interactions, and coordination bonds result in a high level of sophistication in the self-assembly process. Furthermore, the expansion of clusters by the organic ligand to form a high dimensional structure could be very interesting and useful for novel applications in particular. In this study, a novel two-dimensional 14-nucleus silver poly-cluster was designed and synthesized by the combination of two synthetic methods. The high nucleus silver cluster units are connected together via tetradecafluoroazelaic acid (CF₂) and this leads to the high stability of the polymer. This highly stable conductive poly-cluster, with bridging groups of difluoromethylene, displays a high energy density (372 F g^-1 at 4.5 A g^-1), excellent cycling stability, and great capacity. This nanocluster shows a high power density and long cycle life over 6000 cycles (95%) and can also tolerate a wide range of scan rates (5 mV s^-1 to 1 V s^-1), meaning it could act as a green energy source.

Controllable synthesis and formation mechanism study of homoleptic alkynyl-protected Au nanoclusters: recent advances, grand challenges, and great opportunities

In the past decade, atomically precise coinage metal nanoclusters have been a subject of major interest in nanoscience and nanotechnology because of their determined compositions and well-defined molecular structures, which are beneficial for establishing structure-property relationships. Recently ligand engineering has been extended to alkynyl molecules. Homoleptic alkynyl-protected Au nanoclusters (Au NCs) have emerged as a hotspot of research interest, mainly due to their unique optical properties, molecular configuration, and catalytic functionalities, and more importantly, they are used as a counterpart object for fundamental study to compare with the well-established thiolate Au NCs. In this review, we first summarize the recently reported various controllable synthetic strategies for atomically precise homoleptic-alkynyl-protected Au NCs, with particular emphasis on the ligand exchange method, direct reduction of the precursor, one-pot synthesis, and the synchronous nucleation and passivation strategy. After that, we switch our focus to the formation mechanism and structure evolution process of homoleptic alkynyl-protected Au NCs, where Au144(PA)60 and Au36(PA)24 (PA = phenylacetylide) are given as examples, along with the prediction of the possible formation mechanism of some other cluster molecules. In the end of this review, the outlook and perspective of this rapidly developing field including grand challenges and great opportunities are discussed. This review can stimulate more research efforts towards developing new synthetic strategies to enrich the limited examples and unravel the formation/growth mechanism of homoleptic alkynyl-protected Au NCs.

Selective Anion Binding Drives the Formation of AgI8L6 and AgI12L6 Six-Stranded Helicates

Here we describe the formation of an unexpected and unique family of hollow six-stranded helicates. The formation of these structures depends on the coordinative flexibility of silver and the 2-formyl-1,8-napthyridine subcomponent. Crystal structures show that these assemblies are held together by Ag4I, Ag4Br, or Ag6(SO4)2 clusters, where the templating anion plays an integral structure-defining role. Prior to the addition of the anionic template, no six-stranded helicate was observed to form, with the system instead consisting of a dynamic mixture of triple helicate and tetrahedron. Six-stranded helicate formation was highly sensitive to the structure of the ligand, with minor modifications inhibiting its formation. This work provides an unusual example of mutual stabilization between metal clusters and a self-assembled metal-organic cage. The selective preparation of this anisotropic host demonstrates new modes of guiding selective self-assembly using silver(I), whose many stable coordination geometries render design difficult.

Fast and high-yield synthesis of thiolate Ag44 and Au12Ag32 nanoclusters via the CTAB reverse micelle method

To advance the development of atomically precise Ag and Ag-alloyed nanoclusters, it is critical to develop effective synthetic methods. Herein, we successfully extend the CTAB (cetyl trimethyl ammonium bromide) reverse micelle method to synthesize a high-purity Ag₄₄(p-MBA)₃₀ (p-MBA = para-mercaptobenzoic acid) nanocluster and its corresponding alloy cluster Au₁₂Ag₃₂(p-MBA)₃₀ in a short time (15 min and 5 min), with a high yield of ∼83% and ∼85%, respectively. Furthermore, the mechanism regarding the reverse micelle method has been clearly elucidated. Through characterizing the reaction system by Raman spectroscopy and NMR spectroscopy techniques, it can be revealed that employing CTAB to form reverse micelles to construct a sealed chemical environment is critical for realizing the fast and high-yield synthesis.

Mass spectrometry guided surface modification of a tellurate ion templated 36-nucleus silver alkynyl nanocluster

Under the guidance of the ESI-MS result for [TeO6@Ag36(CCtBu)18(tfa)12] (1, tfa = trifluoroacetate), a new 36-nucleus silver-alkynyl cluster substituted by four pentafluorobenzoates, named as [TeO6@Ag36(CCtBu)18(tfa)8(F5PhCO2)4] (2), has been fabricated.

A construction guide for high-nuclearity (≥50 metal atoms) coinage metal clusters at the nanoscale: bridging molecular precise constructs with the bulk material phase

Synthesis remains a major strength in chemistry and materials science and relies on the formation of new molecules and diverse forms of matter. The construction and identification of large molecules poses specific challenges and has historically lain in the realm of biological (organic)-type molecules with evolved synthesis methods to support such endeavours. But with the development of analytical tools such as X-ray crystallography, new synthesis methods toward large metal-based (inorganic) molecules and clusters have come to the fore, making it possible to accurately determine the precise distribution of hundreds of atoms in large clusters. In this review, we focus on different synthesis protocols used to form new metal clusters such as templating, alloying and size-focusing strategies. A specific focus is on group 11 metals (Cu, Ag, Au) as they currently predominate large metal cluster investigations and related Au and Ag bulk surface phenomena. This review focuses on metal clusters that have very high-nuclearity, i.e. with 50 or more metal centers within the isolated cluster. This size domain, it is believed, will become increasingly important for a variety of applications as these metal clusters are positioned at the interface between the molecular and bulk phases, whilst remaining a classic nanomaterial and retaining unique nano-sized properties.

All-Carboxylate-Protected Superatomic Silver Nanocluster with an Unprecedented Rhombohedral Ag8 Core

We report the synthesis and structure of the first all-carboxylate-protected superatomic silver nanocluster. It was prepared by heating a dimethylformamide solution of perfluoroglutaric acid and AgNO₃ under alkaline conditions, yielding a single crystal of [(CH₃)₂NH₂]₆[Ag₈(pfga)₆]. The [Ag₈(pfga)₆]^6- cluster has a rhombohedral Ag₈⁶⁺ core, with each of its faces protected by one dianionic perfluoroglutarate (pfga) ligand. Electronic-structure analysis from density functional theory confirms the stability of this two-electron cluster due to the shell closing of the superatomic orbital in the (1S)² configuration and explains the optical absorption of the cluster in the visible region as the transition from 1S to 1P orbital. The [Ag₈(pfga)₆]^6- cluster emits bright green-yellow light in THF solution and bright orange light in the solid state. This work opens the door to using the widely available carboxylic acids to synthesize atomically precise Ag clusters of attractive properties.

Silver clusters templated by homo- and hetero-anions

This article highlights the use of homo- and hetero-anion templates for the ordered assembly of high-nuclearity silver clusters.