Nerve growth factor-induced differentiation does not alter the biochemical properties of a mutant prion protein expressed in PC12 cells

A tetracationic porphyrin with dual anti-prion activity

Prions are deadly infectious agents made of PrPSc, a misfolded variant of the cellular prion protein (PrPC) which self-propagates by inducing misfolding of native PrPC. PrPSc can adopt different pathogenic conformations (prion strains), which can be resistant to potential drugs, or acquire drug resistance, hampering the development of effective therapies. We identified Zn(II)-BnPyP, a tetracationic porphyrin that binds to distinct domains of native PrPC, eliciting a dual anti-prion effect. Zn(II)-BnPyP binding to a C-terminal pocket destabilizes the native PrPC fold, hindering conversion to PrPSc; Zn(II)-BnPyP binding to the flexible N-terminal tail disrupts N- to C-terminal interactions, triggering PrPC endocytosis and lysosomal degradation, thus reducing the substrate for PrPSc generation. Zn(II)-BnPyP inhibits propagation of different prion strains in vitro, in neuronal cells and organotypic brain cultures. These results identify a PrPC-targeting compound with an unprecedented dual mechanism of action which might be exploited to achieve anti-prion effects without engendering drug resistance.

Expression of mutant or cytosolic PrP in transgenic mice and cells is not associated with endoplasmic reticulum stress or proteasome dysfunction

The cellular pathways activated by mutant prion protein (PrP) in genetic prion diseases, ultimately leading to neuronal dysfunction and degeneration, are not known. Several mutant PrPs misfold in the early secretory pathway and reside longer in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) possibly stimulating ER stress-related pathogenic mechanisms. To investigate whether mutant PrP induced maladaptive responses, we checked key elements of the unfolded protein response (UPR) in transgenic mice, primary neurons and transfected cells expressing two different mutant PrPs. Because ER stress favors the formation of untranslocated PrP that might aggregate in the cytosol and impair proteasome function, we also measured the activity of the ubiquitin proteasome system (UPS). Molecular, biochemical and immunohistochemical analyses found no increase in the expression of UPR-regulated genes, such as Grp78/Bip, CHOP/GADD153, or ER stress-dependent splicing of the mRNA encoding the X-box-binding protein 1. No alterations in UPS activity were detected in mutant mouse brains and primary neurons using the Ub^G76V-GFP reporter and a new fluorogenic peptide for monitoring proteasomal proteolytic activity in vivo. Finally, there was no loss of proteasome function in neurons in which endogenous PrP was forced to accumulate in the cytosol by inhibiting cotranslational translocation. These results indicate that neither ER stress, nor perturbation of proteasome activity plays a major pathogenic role in prion diseases.

The hydrophobic core region governs mutant prion protein aggregation and intracellular retention

Approx. 15% of human prion diseases have a pattern of autosomal dominant inheritance, and are linked to mutations in the gene encoding PrP (prion protein), a GPI (glycosylphosphatidylinositol)-anchored protein whose function is not clear. The cellular mechanisms by which PrP mutations cause disease are also not known. Soon after synthesis in the ER (endoplasmic reticulum), several mutant PrPs misfold and become resistant to phospholipase cleavage of their GPI anchor. The biosynthetic maturation of the misfolded molecules in the ER is delayed and, during transit in the secretory pathway, they form detergent-insoluble and protease-resistant aggregates, suggesting that intracellular PrP aggregation may play a pathogenic role. We have investigated the consequence of deleting residues 114–121 within the hydrophobic core of PrP on the aggregation and cellular localization of two pathogenic mutants that accumulate in the ER and Golgi apparatus. Compared with their full-length counterparts, the deleted molecules formed smaller protease-sensitive aggregates and were more efficiently transported to the cell surface and released by phospholipase cleavage. These results indicate that mutant PrP aggregation and intracellular retention are closely related and depend critically on the integrity of the hydrophobic core. The discovery that Δ114–121 counteracts misfolding and improves the cellular trafficking of mutant PrP provides an unprecedented model for assessing the role of intracellular aggregation in the pathogenesis of prion diseases.

Mutant prion protein expression is associated with an alteration of the Rab GDP dissociation inhibitor alpha (GDI)/Rab11 pathway

The prion protein (PrP) is a glycosylphosphatidylinositol-anchored membrane glycoprotein that plays a vital role in prion diseases, a class of fatal neurodegenerative disorders of humans and animals. Approximately 20% of human prion diseases display autosomal dominant inheritance and are linked to mutations in the PrP gene on chromosome 20. PrP mutations are thought to favor the conformational conversion of PrP into a misfolded isoform that causes disease by an unknown mechanism. The PrP mutation D178N/Met-129 is linked to fatal familial insomnia, which causes severe sleep abnormalities and autonomic dysfunction. We showed by immunoelectron microscopy that this mutant PrP accumulates abnormally in the endoplasmic reticulum and Golgi of transfected neuroblastoma N2a cells. To investigate the impact of intracellular PrP accumulation on cellular homeostasis, we did a two-dimensional gel-based differential proteomics analysis. We used wide range immobilized pH gradient strips, pH 4-7 and 6-11, to analyze a large number of proteins. We found changes in proteins involved in energy metabolism, redox regulation, and vesicular transport. Rab GDP dissociation inhibitor alpha (GDI) was one of the proteins that changed most. GDI regulates vesicular protein trafficking by acting on the activity of several Rab proteins. We found a specific reduction in the level of functional Rab11 in mutant PrP-expressing cells associated with impaired post-Golgi trafficking. Our data are consistent with a model by which mutant PrP induces overexpression of GDI, activating a cytotoxic feedback loop that leads to protein accumulation in the secretory pathway.

Progress in prion vaccines and immunotherapies

The transmissible spongiform encephalopathies have presented a challenge to physicians and scientists attempting to develop immunologically-based treatments. Self-tolerance has been one of the major obstacles to successfully raising antibodies against the prion protein (PrP), the host-encoded protein whose misfolded form (PrPSc) is linked to the protein-only infectious agent responsible for these disorders. Recently, it has been shown that antibodies directed against the normal cellular isoform of PrP (PrPC) can reduce or eliminate PrP isoform conversion in both in vitro and in vivo model systems. Similar studies with a PrPSc-specific epitope target are in progress. There is now rational hope that this devastating group of diseases may soon be amenable to immunotherapy and immunoprophylaxis.

Cytosolic prion protein (PrP) is not toxic in N2a cells and primary neurons expressing pathogenic PrP mutations

Inherited prion diseases are linked to mutations in the prion protein (PrP) gene, which favor conversion of PrP into a conformationally altered, pathogenic isoform. The cellular mechanism by which this process causes neurological dysfunction is unknown. It has been proposed that neuronal death can be triggered by accumulation of PrP in the cytosol because of impairment of proteasomal degradation of misfolded PrP molecules retrotranslocated from the endoplasmic reticulum (Ma, J., Wollmann, R., and Lindquist, S. (2002) Science 298, 1781-1785). To test whether this neurotoxic mechanism is operative in inherited prion diseases, we evaluated the effect of proteasome inhibitors on the viability of transfected N2a cells and primary neurons expressing mouse PrP homologues of the D178N and nine octapeptide mutations. We found that the inhibitors caused accumulation of an unglycosylated, aggregated form of PrP exclusively in transfected N2a expressing PrP from the cytomegalovirus promoter. This form contained an uncleaved signal peptide, indicating that it represented polypeptide chains that had failed to translocate into the ER lumen during synthesis, rather than retrogradely translocated PrP. Quantification of N2a viability in the presence of proteasome inhibitors demonstrated that accumulation of this form was not toxic. No evidence of cytosolic PrP was found in cerebellar granule neurons from transgenic mice expressing wild-type or mutant PrPs from the endogenous promoter, nor were these neurons more susceptible to proteasome inhibitor toxicity than neurons from PrP knock-out mice. Our analysis fails to confirm the previous observation that mislocation of PrP in the cytosol is neurotoxic, and argues against the hypothesis that perturbation of PrP metabolism through the proteasomal pathway plays a pathogenic role in prion diseases.

Trapping Prion Protein in the Endoplasmic Reticulum Impairs PrPC Maturation and Prevents PrPSc Accumulation

The conversion of the normal cellular prion protein (PrP(C)) into the abnormal scrapie isoform (PrP(Sc)) is a key feature of prion diseases. The pathogenic mechanisms and the subcellular sites of the conversion are complex and not completely understood. In particular, little is known on the role of the early compartment of the secretory pathway in the processing of PrP(C) and in the pathogenesis of prion diseases. In order to interfere with the intracellular traffic of endogenous PrP(C) we have generated two anti-prion single chain antibody fragments (scFv) directed against different epitopes, each fragment tagged either with a secretory leader or with the ER retention signal KDEL. The stable expression of these constructs in PC12 cells allowed us to study their specific effects on the synthesis, maturation, and processing of endogenous PrP(C) and on PrP(Sc) formation. We found that ER-targeted anti-prion scFvs retain PrP(C) in the ER and inhibit its translocation to the cell surface. Retention in the ER strongly affects the maturation and glycosylation state of PrP(C), with the appearance of a new aberrant endo-H sensitive glycosylated species. Interestingly, ER-trapped PrP(C) acquires detergent insolubility and proteinase K resistance. Furthermore, we show that ER-targeted anti-prion antibodies prevent PrP(Sc) accumulation in nerve growth factor-differentiated PC12 cells, providing a new tool to study the molecular pathology of prion diseases.

The neurotoxicity of prion protein (PrP) peptide 106–126 is independent of the expression level of PrP and is not mediated by abnormal PrP species

A synthetic peptide homologous to region 106-126 of the prion protein (PrP) is toxic to cells expressing PrP, but not to PrP knockout neurons, arguing for a specific role of PrP in mediating the peptide's activity. Whether this is related to a gain of toxicity or a loss of function of PrP is not clear. We explored the possibility that PrP106-126 triggered formation of PrP(Sc) or other neurotoxic PrP species. We found that PrP106-126 did not induce detergent-insoluble and protease-resistant PrP, nor did it alter its membrane topology or cellular distribution. We also found that neurons expressing endogenous or higher level of either wild-type PrP or a nine-octapeptide insertional mutant were equally susceptible to PrP106-126, and that sub-physiological PrP expression was sufficient to restore vulnerability to the peptide. These results indicate that PrP106-126 interferes with a PrP function that requires only low protein levels, and is not impaired by a pathogenic insertion in the octapeptide region.

Heterogeneity and regulation of cellular prion protein glycoforms in neuronal cell lines

The normal cellular prion protein is a small sialoglycoprotein highly expressed in neurons, the physiological function of which is largely unknown. Due to extensive N-glycosylations with a wide range of oligosaccharides, the prion protein displays a complex glycosylation pattern that could be of relevance for its function. The cellular prion protein patterns in adult mouse and rat brain, and in neuronal cell lines, appeared highly heterogeneous, as distinct levels and glycoforms of cellular prion protein were revealed by immunoblotting of corresponding samples. Amongst neuronal cell lines, mouse N2a neuroblastoma cells expressed low levels of endogenous prion protein. Mouse hypothalamic GT1-7 cells and rat pheochromocytoma PC-12 cells expressed highly glycosylated forms of cellular prion protein that were found neither in adult mouse and rat brain, nor in mouse brain during development. In contrast, rat B104 neuroblastoma cells abundantly expressed N-glycosylated cellular prion protein forms similar to those observed in mouse and rat brain. In all these cell lines, the prion protein was normally exported to and expressed at the outer cell membrane. Our results suggest that B104 cells may represent an appropriate cell model to investigate the physiological role of cellular prion protein in further detail as they highly express the normal 'brain-like' cellular prion protein glycoforms. In addition, we observed that the various prion glycoforms in B104 cells were tightly regulated both as a function of cell density and during neuronal differentiation, implying a potential role of cellular prion protein in cell-cell interactions and differentiation.

Mutant PrP is delayed in its exit from the endoplasmic reticulum, but neither wild-type nor mutant PrP undergoes retrotranslocation prior to proteasomal degradation

The cellular mechanisms by which prions cause neurological dysfunction are poorly understood. To address this issue, we have been using cultured cells to analyze the localization, biosynthesis, and metabolism of PrP molecules carrying mutations associated with familial prion diseases. We report here that mutant PrP molecules are delayed in their maturation to an endoglycosidase H-resistant form after biosynthetic labeling, suggesting that they are impaired in their exit from the endoplasmic reticulum (ER). However, we find that proteasome inhibitors have no effect on the maturation or turnover of either mutant or wild-type PrP molecules. Thus, in contrast to recent studies from other laboratories, our work indicates that PrP is not subject to retrotranslocation from the ER into the cytoplasm prior to degradation by the proteasome. We find that in transfected cells, but not in cultured neurons, proteasome inhibitors cause accumulation of an unglycosylated, signal peptide-bearing form of PrP on the cytoplasmic face of the ER membrane. Thus, under conditions of elevated expression, a small fraction of PrP chains is not translocated into the ER lumen during synthesis, and is rapidly degraded in the cytoplasm by the proteasome. Finally, we report a previously unappreciated artifact caused by treatment of cells with proteasome inhibitors: an increase in PrP mRNA level and synthetic rate when the protein is expressed from a vector containing a viral promoter. We suggest that this phenomenon may explain some of the dramatic effects of proteasome inhibitors observed in other studies. Our results clarify the role of the proteasome in the cell biology of PrP, and suggest reasonable hypotheses for the molecular pathology of inherited prion diseases.

A murine model of a familial prion disease

We have produced a mouse model of a familial prion disorder by introduction of a transgene that encodes the moPrP homolog of a nine-octapeptide insertional mutant associated with an inherited form of CJD in humans. These mice develop progressive neurologic symptoms, display neuropathologic changes, and accumulate a form of mutant PrP in their brains and peripheral tissues that displays some of the biochemical properties of PrPSc. These mice have been extremely valuable for analyzing the cellular and biochemical mechanisms involved in inherited prion disorders and correlating the appearance of the PrPSc-like form with clinical and neuropathologic findings. Because the mutant protein in the mice is highly neurotoxic but appears to lack infectivity, further analysis of its properties promises to shed new light on the molecular distinction between pathogenic and infectious forms of PrP.

Trafficking, turnover and membrane topology of PrP

Cell biological studies of PrP have contributed enormously to our understanding of prion diseases. Like other membrane proteins, PrP(C) is post-translationally processed in the endoplasmic reticulum and Golgi on its way to the cell surface after synthesis. Cell surface PrP(C) constitutively cycles between the plasma membrane and early endosomes via a clathrin-dependent mechanism, a pathway consistent with a suggested role for PrP(C) in cellular trafficking of copper ions. PrP molecules carrying mutations linked to inherited prion diseases display several abnormalities in their biochemical properties, maturation, and localisation that may explain their pathogenicity. Recent results have clarified the role of the proteasome in degradation of PrP, and the properties of a transmembrane form of PrP which may play a neurotoxic role in prion diseases.

Mutant prion proteins are partially retained in the endoplasmic reticulum

Familial prion diseases are linked to point and insertional mutations in the prion protein (PrP) gene that are presumed to favor conversion of the cellular isoform of PrP to the infectious isoform. In this report, we have investigated the subcellular localization of PrP molecules carrying pathogenic mutations using immunofluorescence staining, immunogold labeling, and PrP-green fluorescent protein chimeras. To facilitate visualization of the mutant proteins, we have utilized a novel Sindbis viral replicon engineered to produce high protein levels without cytopathology. We demonstrate that several different pathogenic mutations have a common effect on the trafficking of PrP, impairing delivery of the molecules to the cell surface and causing a portion of them to accumulate in the endoplasmic reticulum. These observations suggest that protein quality control in the endoplasmic reticulum may play an important role in prion diseases, as it does in some other inherited human disorders. Our experiments also show that chimeric PrP molecules with the sequence of green fluorescent protein inserted adjacent to the glycolipidation site are post-translationally modified and localized normally, thus documenting the utility of these constructs in cell biological studies of PrP.

Prion diseases: what is the neurotoxic molecule?

A great deal of effort has been devoted during the past 20 years to defining the chemical nature of prions, the infectious agents responsible for transmissible spongiform encephalopathies. In contrast, much less attention has been paid to elucidating how prions actually damage the central nervous system. Although it is commonly assumed that PrP(Sc), the protein constituent of infectious prions, is the primary culprit, increasing evidence indicates that this may not be the case. Several alternative molecular forms of PrP are reasonable candidates for the neurotoxic species in prion diseases, although it is still too early to tell whether these or other ones will turn out to be the true instigating factors. The cellular pathways activated by neurotoxic forms of PrP that ultimately result in neuronal death are also being investigated, and several possible mechanisms have been uncovered, including the operation of quality control processes in the endoplasmic reticulum. Elucidating the distinction between the infectious and neurotoxic forms of PrP has important implications for designing therapy of prion diseases, as well as for understanding pathogenic mechanisms operative in other neurodegenerative disorders and the role of prion-like states in biology.

Primary myopathy and accumulation of PrPSc-like molecules in peripheral tissues of transgenic mice expressing a prion protein insertional mutation

A nine-octapeptide insertional mutation in the prion protein (PrP) gene is associated with an inherited variant of Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease in humans. Transgenic mice that express the mouse PrP homologue of this mutation (designated PG14) under control of a PrP promoter display a progressive neurological disorder characterized by ataxia, apoptosis of cerebellar granule cells, and accumulation in the brain of mutant PrP molecules that display the biochemical hallmarks of PrP(Sc), the pathogenic isoform of PrP. In this report, we have investigated the expression of PG14 PrP in the peripheral tissues of these mice. We found highest levels of mutant PrP in the brain and spinal cord, intermediate levels in skeletal muscle, heart, and testis and low levels in kidney, lung, spleen, intestine, and stomach. Up to 70% of the PG14 PrP expressed in peripheral tissues was detergent-insoluble, and digestion with low concentrations of proteinase K yielded a PrP 27-30 fragment. These results suggest that the mutant protein was converted to a physical state reminiscent of PrP(Sc), although its infectivity remains to be determined. Histological analysis of skeletal muscle, one of the peripheral tissues with the highest level of PG14 PrP, revealed features indicative of a progressive, primary myopathy, including central nuclei, necrotic and regenerating fibers, and variable fiber size. These results indicate that the PG14 mutation structurally alters the protein in a way that promotes conversion to a PrP(Sc)-like state, regardless of the tissue context, and suggest that accumulation of PrP(Sc) can have deleterious effects on skeletal muscle cells as well as on neurons.

Most pathogenic mutations do not alter the membrane topology of the prion protein

The prion protein (PrP), a glycolipid-anchored membrane glycoprotein, contains a conserved hydrophobic sequence that can span the lipid bilayer in either direction, resulting in two transmembrane forms designated (Ntm)PrP and (Ctm)PrP. Previous studies have shown that the proportion of (Ctm)PrP is increased by mutations in the membrane-spanning segment, and it has been hypothesized that (Ctm)PrP represents a key intermediate in the pathway of prion-induced neurodegeneration. To further test this idea, we have surveyed a number of mutations associated with familial prion diseases to determine whether they alter the proportions of (Ntm)PrP and (Ctm)PrP produced in vitro, in transfected cells, and in transgenic mice. For the in vitro experiments, PrP mRNA was translated in the presence of murine thymoma microsomes which, in contrast to the canine pancreatic microsomes used in previous studies, are capable of efficient glycolipidation. We confirmed that mutations within or near the transmembrane domain enhance the formation of (Ctm)PrP, and we demonstrate for the first time that this species contains a C-terminal glycolipid anchor, thus exhibiting an unusual, dual mode of membrane attachment. However, we find that pathogenic mutations in other regions of the molecule have no effect on the amounts of (Ctm)PrP and (Ntm)PrP, arguing against the proposition that transmembrane PrP plays an obligate role in the pathogenesis of prion diseases.