Cardiac rehabilitation and survival in patients with left ventricular systolic dysfunction

A Detailed Analysis of Cardiac Rehabilitation on 180-Day All-Cause Hospital Readmission and Mortality

PURPOSE

Cardiac rehabilitation (CR) is endorsed for coronary artery disease (CAD), but studies report inconsistent findings regarding efficacy. The objective of this study was to determine whether confounding factors, potentially contributing to these heterogeneous findings, impact the effect of CR on all-cause readmission and mortality.

METHODS

Patients (n = 2641) with CAD, CR eligible, and physically able were identified. Electronic medical records were inspected individually for each patient to extract demographic, clinical characteristic, readmission, and mortality information. Patients (n = 214) attended ≥1 CR session (CR group). Survival was considered free from: all-cause readmission; or composite outcome of all-cause readmission or death. Cox proportional hazards models, adjusting for demographics, comorbidities, and discharge criteria, were used to determine HR with 95% CI and to compare 180-d survival rates between the CR and no-CR groups.

RESULTS

During 180 d of follow-up, 12.1% and 18.7% of the CR and non-CR patients were readmitted to the hospital. There was one death (0.5%) in the CR group, while 98 deaths (4.0%) occurred in the non-CR group. After adjustment for age, sex, race, depression, anxiety, dyslipidemia, hypertension, obesity, smoking, type 2 diabetes, and discharge criteria, the final model revealed a significant 42.7% reduction in readmission or mortality risk for patients who attended CR (HR = 0.57: 95% CI, 0.33-0.98; P = .043).

CONCLUSIONS

Regardless of demographic characteristics, comorbidities, and cardiovascular discharge criteria, the risk of 180-d all-cause readmission or death was markedly decreased in patients who attended CR compared with those who did not.

Impact of Early COVID-19 Waves on Cardiac Rehabilitation Delivery in Australia: A National Survey

BACKGROUND

The novel coronavirus disease of 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic significantly disrupted health care, especially outpatient services such as cardiac rehabilitation (CR). We investigated the impact of early COVID-19 waves on the delivery of Australian CR programs, comparing this time period with usual practice prior to the pandemic (2019) and current practice (2021) once the early waves had subsided. Specifically, we aimed to understand how the delivery of programs during COVID-19 compared to usual practice.

METHODS

An anonymous online cross-sectional survey of Australian CR program staff was conducted, comprising three sections: program and respondent characteristics, COVID-19 impact on program delivery, and barriers to, and enablers of, program delivery. Respondents were asked to consider three key timepoints: 1) Pre-COVID-19 (i.e. usual practice in 2019), 2) Early COVID-19 waves (March-December 2020), and 3) Currently, at time of survey completion post early COVID-19 waves (May-July 2021).

RESULTS

Of the 314 Australian CR programs, 115 responses were received, of which 105 had complete data, representing a 33% response rate. All states and territories were represented. During early COVID-19 waves programs had periods of closure (40%) or reduced delivery (70%). The majority of programs reported decreased CR referrals (51.5%) and decreased participation (77.5%). The two core components of CR-exercise and education-were significantly impacted during early COVID-19 waves, affecting both the number and duration of sessions provided. Exercise session duration did not return to pre-pandemic levels (53.5 min compared to 57.7 min, p=0.02). The majority of respondents (77%) reported their CR program was inferior in quality to pre-pandemic and more organisational support was required across information technology, staffing, administration and staff emotional and social support.

CONCLUSION

Australian CR programs underwent significant change during the early COVID-19 waves, consistent with international CR reports. Fewer patients were referred and attended CR and those who did attend received a lower dose of exercise and education. It will be important to continue to monitor the long-term impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic to ensure CR programs return to pre-pandemic functioning and continue to deliver services in line with best practice and evidence-based recommendations.

Dose of Cardiac Rehabilitation to Reduce Mortality and Morbidity: A Population-Based Study

Background

There is wide variability in cardiac rehabilitation (CR) dose (ie, number of sessions) delivered, and no evidence‐based recommendations regarding what dose to prescribe. We aimed to test what CR dose impacts major adverse cardiovascular events (MACEs).

Methods and Results

This is an historical cohort study of all patients who had coronary artery disease and who initiated supervised CR between 2002 and 2012 from a single major CR center. CR dose was defined as number of visits including exercise and patient education. Follow‐up was performed using record linkage from the Rochester Epidemiology Project. MACEs included acute myocardial infarction, unstable angina, ventricular arrhythmias, stroke, revascularization, or all‐cause mortality. Dose was analyzed in several ways, including tertiles, categories, and as a continuous variable. Cox models were adjusted for factors associated with dose and MACE. The cohort consisted of 2345 patients, who attended a mean of 12.5±11.1 of 36 prescribed sessions. After a mean follow‐up of 6 years, 695 (29.65%) patients had a MACE, including 231 who died. CR dose was inversely associated with MACE (hazard ratio, 0.66 [95% CI]; 0.55–0.91) in those completing ≥20 sessions, when compared with those not exposed to formal exercise sessions (≤1 session; log‐rank P=0.007). We did not find evidence of nonlinearity (P≥0.050), suggesting no minimal threshold nor ceiling. Each additional session was associated with a lower rate of MACE (fully adjusted hazard ratio, 0.98 [95% CI, 0.97–0.99]). Greater session frequency was also associated with lower MACE risk (fully adjusted hazard ratio, 0.74 [95% CI, 0.58–0.94]).

Conclusions

CR reduces MACEs, but the benefit appears to be linear, with greater risk reduction with higher doses, and no upper threshold.

Patients with Heart Failure During and After Inpatient Cardiac Rehabilitation

Background

Heart failure is the third most fatal disease in Germany and generates considerable treatment costs. The multimodal program of inpatient rehabilitation can improve the symptoms and prognosis of these patients. At the present time, however, only few data are available on the effectiveness of rehabilitation for heart failure patients.

Methods

After receiving study approval from the ethics committee of the Saxony–Anhalt Medical Association, 200 patients with a primary or secondary diagnosis of heart failure were prospectively included in the study at Paracelsus-Harz-Clinic Bad Suderode, Quedlinburg, Germany. Baseline parameters such as age, gender, and BMI were documented. Outcome variables included NYHA classifications, quality of life, and mortality. For follow-up, the patients were contacted again by mail or phone after three and 12 months and, data on symptoms and serious events were recorded.

Results

The proportion of patients with a highly reduced ejection fraction (HFrEF) was 13.5%, with a midrange reduced ejection fraction (HFmrEF) 33%, and with preserved ejection fraction (HFpEF) 53.5%. The mean age was 64 ± 11.9 years, the proportion of women 24.1%. The effects of rehabilitation were documented by low overall mortality (no patient died during the stay, only 4% of the patients died in the 12-month follow-up) and an improvement in NYHA classification during and after the inpatient rehabilitation.

Conclusion

This monocentric study showed effects both for symptoms (improvement in NYHA classifications) and prognosis (overall mortality) after rehabilitation. These data reflect the effectiveness of multimodal rehabilitation and underscore the need for rehabilitation in patients diagnosed with heart failure after an acute event and hospital stay or who present with chronic deterioration.

Cardiac Rehabilitation Dose Around the World: Variation and Correlates

BACKGROUND

Cardiac rehabilitation (CR) is recommended in clinical practice guidelines, but dose prescribed varies highly by country. This study characterized the dose offered in supervised CR programs and alternative models worldwide and their potential correlates.

METHODS AND RESULTS

In this cross-sectional study, an online survey was administered to CR programs globally. Cardiac associations and local champions facilitated program identification. Countries were classified based on region and income categories. Dose was operationalized as program duration×sessions per week. Generalized linear mixed models were performed to assess correlates. Of 203 countries in the world, 111 (54.7%) offered CR; data were collected in 93 (83.8% country response rate; n=1082 surveys, 32.1% program response rate). Globally, supervised CR programs were a median of 24 sessions (n=619, 57.3% programs ≥12 sessions); home-based and community-based programs offered 6 and 20 sessions, respectively. There was significant variation in supervised CR dose by region (P≤0.001), with the Americas (median, 36 sessions) offering a significantly greater dose than several other regions; there was also a trend for variation by country income classification. There was no difference in home-based dose by region (P=0.43) but there was for community-based programs (P<0.05; Americas offering greater dose). There was a significant dose variation in both home- and community-based programs by income classification (P=0.002 and P<0.001, respectively), with higher doses offered by upper-middle-income than high-income countries. Correlates of supervised CR dose included more involvement of physicians (P=0.026), proximity to other programs (P=0.002), and accepting patients with noncardiac indications (P=0.037).

CONCLUSIONS

CR programs in many countries may need to increase their dose, which could be supported through physician champions.

Coronary artery bypass graft readmission rates and risk factors - A retrospective cohort study

BACKGROUND

Hospital readmissions contribute substantially to the overall healthcare cost. Coronary artery bypass graft (CABG) is of particular interest due to its relatively high short-term readmission rates and mean hospital charges.

METHODS

A retrospective review was performed on 2007-2011 data from California, Florida, and New York from the State Inpatient Databases, Healthcare Cost and Utilization Project. All patients ≥18 years of age who underwent isolated CABG and met inclusion/exclusion criteria were included. Insurance status was categorized by Medicaid, Medicare, Private Insurance, Uninsured, and Other. Primary outcomes were unadjusted rates and adjusted odds of readmission at 30- and 90-days. Secondary outcomes included diagnosis at readmission.

RESULTS

A total of 177,229 were included in the analyses after assessing for exclusion criteria. Overall 30-day readmission rate was 16.1%; rates were highest within Medicare (18.4%) and Medicaid (20.2%) groups and lowest in the private insurance group (11.7%; p < 0.0001). Similarly, 90-day rates were highest in Medicare (27.3%) and Medicaid (29.8%) groups and lowest in the private insurance group (17.6%), with an overall 90-day rate of 24.0% (p < 0.0001). The most common 30-day readmission diagnoses were atrial fibrillation (26.7%), pleural effusion (22.5%), and wound infection (17.7%). Medicare patients had the highest proportion of readmissions with atrial fibrillation (31.7%) and pleural effusions (23.3%), while Medicaid patients had the highest proportion of readmissions with wound infections (21.8%). Similar results were found at 90 days. Risk factors for readmission included non-private insurance, age, female sex, non-white race, low median household income, non-routine discharge, length of stay, and certain comorbidities and complications.

CONCLUSIONS

CABG readmission rates remain high and are associated with insurance status and racial and socioeconomic markers. Further investigation is necessary to better delineate the underlying factors that relate racial and socioeconomic disparities to CABG readmissions. Understanding these factors will be key to improving healthcare outcomes and expenditure.

Effect of Cardiac Rehabilitation Dose on Mortality and Morbidity: A Systematic Review and Meta-regression Analysis

OBJECTIVE

To ascertain the effect of cardiac rehabilitation (CR) dose (ie, duration × frequency/wk; categorized as low [<12 sessions], medium [12-35 sessions], or high [≥36 sessions]) on mortality and morbidity.

METHODS

The Cochrane, CINAHL, EMBASE, PsycINFO, and MEDLINE databases were systematically searched from inception through November 30, 2015. Inclusion criteria included randomized or nonrandomized studies with a minimum CR dose of 4 or higher and presence of a control/comparison group. Citations were considered for inclusion, and data were extracted in included studies independently by 2 investigators. Studies were pooled using random-effects meta-analysis and meta-regression where warranted (covariates included study quality, country, publication year, and diagnosis).

RESULTS

Of 4630 unique citations, 33 trials were included comparing CR to usual care (ie, no dose). In meta-regression, greater dose was significantly related to lower all-cause mortality (high: -0.77; SE, 0.22; P<.001; medium: -0.80; SE, 0.21; P<.001) when compared with low dose. With regard to morbidity, meta-analysis revealed that dose was significantly associated with fewer percutaneous coronary interventions (high: relative risk, 0.65; 95% CI, 0.50-0.84; medium/low: relative risk, 1.04; 95% CI, 0.74-1.48; between subgroup difference P=.03). This reduction was also significant in meta-regression (high vs medium/low: -0.73; SE, 0.20; P<.001). Publication bias was not evident. No dose-response association was found for cardiovascular mortality, all-cause hospitalization, coronary artery bypass graft surgery, or myocardial infarction.

CONCLUSION

A minimum of 36 CR sessions may be needed to reduce percutaneous coronary interventions. Future studies should examine the effect of actual dose of CR, and trials are needed comparing different doses.

PROSPERO REGISTRATION

CRD42016036029.

[Effects of long-term exercise training on left ventricular function and remodeling in patients with anterior wall myocardial infarction]

OBJECTIVE

To assess the effects of long-term exercise training on the function and remodeling of the left ventricle after myocardial infarction.

METHODS

We studied 90 patients with a first acute anterior-wall myocardial infarction, all received conventional medical treatment. Symptom-limited maximal exercise stress tests, echocardiograms and effort-rest isotopic ventriculographies at 2, 6 and 12 months after myocardial infarction were performed; the follow-up time averaged 36.3±17 months. All patients joined a cardiac rehabilitation program with moderate or intense exercise training lasting at least a year. Of all patients, 41.1% suffered severe left ventricle dysfunction.

RESULTS

Ergometric parameters that expressed functional capacity increased significantly (P<.0005) at the sixth month evaluation and remained unchanged after a year. There was significant decrease (P<.01) of exercise myocardial ischemia at 6 months. The variables that measured size and function of left ventricle did not change during evolution. Morbidity amounted to 16.7% and total mortality of the series was 13.3%, with 8.9% of cardiovascular cause.

CONCLUSIONS

Long-term exercise training showed no deleterious effects on left ventricle function or remodeling and beneficial functional and clinical effects were obtained in these rehabilitated postinfarction patients.

Cardiac rehabilitation in patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus and coronary disease: a comparative study

INTRODUCTION AND AIMS

Diabetic patients have a 2-4 times higher risk of cardiovascular disease than non-diabetic individuals. The aims of this study are to evaluate the effects of a cardiac rehabilitation program (phase II) in patients with diabetes and coronary disease and to compare the results with regard to control of cardiovascular risk factors and improvement in functional capacity with coronary patients without diabetes.

METHODS

This was a prospective study of patients diagnosed with ischemic heart disease referred for a cardiac rehabilitation program between January 2009 and June 2013. The population was divided into two groups: diabetic and non-diabetic. Patients were assessed at the beginning of phase II and three months later and the following parameters were recorded: body mass index, waist circumference, lipid profile, blood glucose and glycated hemoglobin in diabetic patients, blood pressure, smoking, physical activity level (using the International Physical Activity Questionnaire) and functional capacity (on treadmill stress testing).

RESULTS

The study population consisted of 682 patients (253 diabetic and 429 non-diabetic). Diabetic patients were significantly older, had a worse cardiovascular risk profile (higher prevalence of overweight, dyslipidemia, hypertension and sedentary lifestyle) and lower functional capacity. At the end of phase II, there was a statistically significant improvement (p<0.05) in all risk factors and functional capacity, which was similar in both groups, except for body mass index, triglycerides and functional capacity.

CONCLUSIONS

Diabetic patients may benefit from a cardiac rehabilitation program and achieve comparable results to non-diabetic patients.

Current concepts underlying benefits of exercise training in congestive heart failure patients

The pathophysiology of several conditions including heart failure is partly attributable to a failure of the cell energy metabolism. Studies have shown that exercise training (ET) improves quality of life (QOL) and is beneficial in terms of reduction of symptoms, mortality and duration of hospitalization. Increasingly, ET is now achieving acceptance as complimentary therapy in addition to routine clinical practice in patients with chronic heart failure (CHF). However, the mechanisms underlying the beneficial effects of ET are far less understood and need further evaluation. Evidence suggests that while CHF induces generalized metabolic energy depletion, ET largely enhances the overall function of the heart muscle. Hence, research efforts are now aiming to uncover why ET is beneficial as a complimentary treatment of CHF in the context of improving endothelial function and coronary perfusion, decreasing peripheral resistance, induction of cardiac and skeletal muscle cells remodeling, increasing oxygen uptake, substrate oxidation, and resistance to fatigue. Here we discuss the current evidence that suggest that there are beneficial effects of ET on cardiac and skeletal muscle cells oxidative metabolism and intracellular energy transfer in patients with CHF.

Absence of Exercise Capacity Improvement After Exercise Training Program

Background— Exercise training is established as adjuvant therapy for chronic heart failure, but the prognostic value of improvement in exercise capacity after exercise training has never been evaluated.

Methods and Results— In this prospective bicentric study, all chronic heart failure patients with left ventricular ejection fraction <45% who underwent an exercise training program in a cardiac rehabilitation center between January 2004 and September 2006 were consecutively included. Improvement in exercise capacity was assessed by change in peak oxygen consumption (δPV o 2 ) and in PV o 2 expressed as a percentage of predicted PV o 2 (δ%PPV o 2 ) measured before and after the training program. We included 155 patients (54�12 years old, male 81%, left ventricular ejection fraction=29.5�7.1%). Patients underwent 20 (10–30) training sessions. PV o 2 and %PPV o 2 were significantly increased after the training program (14% and 13%, respectively, P <0.001 for both). After 16�6 months follow-up, 27 patients had a cardiac event (death [n=12], cardiac transplantation [n=5], hospitalization for acute heart failure [n=10]). Univariate analysis revealed that among 17 significant predictors of cardiac events, the 2 more powerful ones were level of B-type natriuretic peptide at baseline ( P <0.0001) and improvement in exercise capacity as assessed by δPV o 2 and δ%PPV o 2 ( P <0.0001). Multivariate analysis revealed B-type natriuretic peptide level and δ%PPV o 2 as only independent predictive factors of outcome ( P =0.01). The risk ratio of cardiac events for nonresponse versus response to the training program (defined as median δ%PPV o 2 <6%) was 8.2 ( P =0.0006).

Conclusions— Among patients with chronic heart failure, the lack of improvement in exercise capacity after an exercise training program has strong prognostic value for adverse cardiac events independent of classical predictive factors such as left ventricular ejection fraction, New York Heart Association class, and B-type natriuretic peptide level.

Patient and hospital differences underlying racial variation in outcomes after coronary artery bypass graft surgery

BACKGROUND

Few studies have examined the association of race and outcomes after coronary artery bypass graft (CABG) surgery while controlling for both patient and hospital effects.

METHODS AND RESULTS

We retrospectively analyzed data on a cohort of 566,785 white and 24,354 black Medicare beneficiaries 65 years old and older undergoing CABG in 1091 US hospitals from 1997 to 2000. Mortality and repeat revascularization rates were examined after sequential adjustment for patient and hospital differences by use of generalized estimating equations. Unadjusted mortality was higher (P<0.001) in black than in white patients at 30 (6.4% versus 5.2%), 90 (8.3% versus 6.6%), and 365 days (13.5% versus 9.8%) after surgery. Black patients were more likely (P<0.001) to undergo CABG at hospitals with the highest mortality (56% versus 47%) and at hospitals in the lowest volume quintile (24% versus 20%). Adjusted only for patient characteristics, mortality was 8%, 11%, and 25% higher in black patients at 30, 90, and 365 days. After adjustment for hospital effects, 30 and 90 day mortality was similar but 17% higher in black patients at 365 days. Racial differences in mortality were greater in men than in women. On adjustment for patient and hospital effects, repeat revascularization rates were similar in black and white patients.

CONCLUSIONS

Racial disparities in CABG outcomes are sensitive to the effects of sex and duration of postsurgical follow-up. The increasing disparity in outcomes as follow-up increased is consistent with the hypothesis that black patients have less access to secondary prevention and rehabilitation services after surgery.

Exercise training for patients with heart failure: a systematic review of factors that improve mortality and morbidity

PURPOSE

To determine the efficacy of exercise training and its effects on outcomes in patients with heart failure.

METHODS

MEDLINE, Medscape, and the Cochrane Controlled Trials Registry were searched for trials of exercise training in heart failure patients. Data relating to training protocol, exercise capacity, and outcome measures were extracted and reviewed.

RESULTS

A total of 81 studies were identified: 30 randomized controlled trials, five nonrandomized controlled trials, nine randomized crossover trials, and 37 longitudinal cohort studies. Exercise training was performed in 2387 patients. The average increment in peak oxygen consumption was 17% in 57 studies that measured oxygen consumption directly, 17% in 40 studies of aerobic training, 9% in three studies that only used strength training, 15% in 13 studies of combined aerobic and strength training, and 16% in the one study on inspiratory training. There were no reports of deaths that were directly related to exercise during more than 60,000 patient-hours of exercise training. During the training and follow-up periods of the randomized controlled trials, there were 56 combined (deaths or adverse events) events in the exercise groups and 75 combined events in the control groups (odds ratio [OR] = 0.98; 95% confidence interval [CI]: 0.61 to 1.32; P = 0.60). During this same period, 26 exercising and 41 nonexercising subjects died (OR = 0.71; 95% CI: 0.37 to 1.02; P = 0.06).

CONCLUSION

Exercise training is safe and effective in patients with heart failure. The risk of adverse events may be reduced, but further studies are required to determine whether there is any mortality benefit.

The implications of physical activity in patients with chronic heart failure

The clinical syndrome of chronic heart failure is increasingly prevalent. It can be considered a multiorgan disorder that may exert a negative physical and psychological influence on a patient. Medication and surgical intervention have important roles to play and have certainly improved both morbidity and mortality in this field, but clearly these interventions alone are not enough. Excessive resource utilization for this group of patients has provided added impetus to research into non-pharmacological interventions. These encompass dietary and other lifestyle measures, including smoking cessation and exercise. Exercise has been shown to favourably affect the functional capacity and quality of life. There is also emerging evidence that it reduces mortality. In the absence of contraindications, regular endurance exercise coupled with strength training is undoubtedly beneficial. As with other cardiovascular research, there is a trend towards recruiting middle-aged males. This effectively means that practitioners need to be cautious when evaluating and/or implementing research evidence. By addressing the implications of physical activity for deconditioned patients with chronic heart failure, a holistic therapeutic regimen is fostered. This has been shown to improve the quality of life of patients and to enhance the quality of service delivered to this patient group.

Delivery of Outpatient Cardiac Rehabilitation in a Managed Care Organization

PURPOSE

This study aimed to assess referral and enrollment rates for postdischarge outpatient cardiac rehabilitation in a managed care organization.

METHODS

A prospective cohort study investigated Atlanta area managed care members, age 30 years or older, hospitalized for acute myocardial infarction or coronary revascularization during 1997-1999. Postdischarge cardiology medical records were abstracted for evidence of postdischarge visits; counseling on diet, weight, or exercise; and referral to outpatient cardiac rehabilitation. Enrollment in outpatient cardiac rehabilitation was confirmed by chart abstraction. Referral and enrollment rates were estimated using logistic regression models.

RESULTS

Of the 945 hospitalized patients, 783 remained alive and enrolled in the managed care organization 12 months after discharge. Of these 783 patients, 73.8% had at least one postdischarge cardiologist visit. Among these, 24.4% were referred by a cardiologist to outpatient cardiac rehabilitation, and 7.1% enrolled. Enrollment was significantly higher among patients with a documented referral than among patients not referred (P <.05). Patients 65 years of age or older were significantly less likely than younger patients to be referred to cardiac rehabilitation and enroll (P<.05). Of the patients with a postdischarge cardiologist visit, 31.5% received counseling on diet, weight, or exercise. The men and the patients with a body mass index of at least 30 were more likely to receive this counseling than women and those with body mass index less than 30 (P <.05).

CONCLUSIONS

The low rates of referral and enrollment for postdischarge outpatient cardiac rehabilitation in this managed care population are consistent with rates observed at academic medical centers. Despite demonstrated benefits after acute coronary events, outpatient cardiac rehabilitation remains underused.

Effect of Physical Training on Corrected QT Dispersion in Patients With Nonischemic Heart Failure

BACKGROUND

The effect of physical training (PT) on QTc dispersion and ventricular tachycardia (VT) remains unclear in patients with nonischemic heart failure.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Eight patients with nonischemic heart failure performed PT using a bicycle ergometer and their exercise tolerance increased (4.9+/-1.8 to 7.0+/-2.5 METs, p<0.05) and QTc dispersion decreased (71+/-22 to 48+/-24 ms, p<0.05). However, PT did not change the frequency of VT.

CONCLUSION

Physical training could improve QTc dispersion in patients with nonischemic heart failure, possibly by improving the autonomic nerve system.

Cardiac rehabilitation secondary prevention programs

Contemporary cardiac rehabilitation programs are more accurately described as "secondary prevention centers." They offer comprehensive care for the patient with cardiovascular disease, resulting in decreased mortality, improvement of most cardiac risk factors, and an enhanced quality of life. Although overall participation has increased with enhanced recognition of the importance of secondary prevention, 80% of eligible patients still do not participate, in part due to lack of insurance reimbursement. This rate can be significantly increased by specific endorsement from the physician.