One gene, multiple ecological strategies: A biofilm regulator is a capacitor for sustainable diversity

Cyclic Diguanylate in the Wild: Roles During Plant and Animal Colonization

Cyclic diguanylate (c-di-GMP) is a near-ubiquitous signaling molecule that regulates the motility-to-sessility transition in many bacterial species. Among the phenotypes influenced by c-di-GMP are biofilm formation, motility, cell cycle, and virulence. The hallmark phenotypes regulated by c-di-GMP-biofilm formation and motility-are key determinants of host-bacterial interactions. A large body of research has identified the roles of c-di-GMP in regulating phenotypes in culture. While numerous studies have investigated roles for c-di-GMP during the establishment and maintenance of pathogenic host-bacterial associations, considerably less attention has been devoted to defining the roles of c-di-GMP during beneficial and commensal associations. This review describes the known roles of c-di-GMP in regulating phenotypes that contribute to host colonization, with a focus on knowledge gaps and future prospects for examining c-di-GMP during beneficial colonization.

Mechanisms of antimicrobial resistance in biofilms

Most bacteria in nature exist in aggregated communities known as biofilms, and cells within a biofilm demonstrate major physiological changes compared to their planktonic counterparts. Biofilms are associated with many different types of infections which can have severe impacts on patients. Infections involving a biofilm component are often chronic and highly recalcitrant to antibiotic therapy as a result of intrinsic physical factors including extracellular matrix production, low growth rates, altered antibiotic target production and efficient exchange of resistance genes. This review describes the biofilm lifecycle, phenotypic characteristics of a biofilm, and contribution of matrix and persister cells to biofilms intrinsic tolerance to antimicrobials. We also describe how biofilms can evolve antibiotic resistance and transfer resistance genes within biofilms. Multispecies biofilms and the impacts of various interactions, including cooperation and competition, between species on tolerance to antimicrobials in polymicrobial biofilm communities are also discussed.

Adaptation to Overflow Metabolism by Mutations That Impair tRNA Modification in Experimentally Evolved Bacteria

When microbes grow in foreign nutritional environments, selection may enrich mutations in unexpected pathways connecting growth and homeostasis. An evolution experiment designed to identify beneficial mutations in Burkholderia cenocepacia captured six independent nonsynonymous substitutions in the essential gene tilS, which modifies tRNA^Ile2 by adding a lysine to the anticodon for faithful AUA recognition. Further, five additional mutants acquired mutations in tRNA^Ile2, which strongly suggests that disrupting the TilS-tRNA^Ile2 interaction was subject to strong positive selection. Mutated TilS incurred greatly reduced enzymatic function but retained capacity for tRNA^Ile2 binding. However, both mutant sets outcompeted the wild type by decreasing the lag phase duration by ~3.5 h. We hypothesized that lysine demand could underlie fitness in the experimental conditions. As predicted, supplemental lysine complemented the ancestral fitness deficit, but so did the additions of several other amino acids. Mutant fitness advantages were also specific to rapid growth on galactose using oxidative overflow metabolism that generates redox imbalance, not resources favoring more balanced metabolism. Remarkably, 13 tilS mutations also evolved in the long-term evolution experiment with Escherichia coli, including four fixed mutations. These results suggest that TilS or unknown binding partners contribute to improved growth under conditions of rapid sugar oxidation at the predicted expense of translational accuracy. IMPORTANCE There is growing evidence that the fundamental components of protein translation can play multiple roles in maintaining cellular homeostasis. Enzymes that interact with transfer RNAs not only ensure faithful decoding of the genetic code but also help signal the metabolic state by reacting to imbalances in essential building blocks like free amino acids and cofactors. Here, we present evidence of a secondary function for the essential enzyme TilS, whose only prior known function is to modify tRNA^Ile(CAU) to ensure accurate translation. Multiple nonsynonymous substitutions in tilS, as well as its cognate tRNA, were selected in evolution experiments favoring rapid, redox-imbalanced growth. These mutations alone decreased lag phase and created a competitive advantage, but at the expense of most primary enzyme function. These results imply that TilS interacts with other factors related to the timing of exponential growth and that tRNA-modifying enzymes may serve multiple roles in monitoring metabolic health.

The BDSF quorum sensing receptor RpfR regulates Bep exopolysaccharide synthesis in Burkholderia cenocepacia via interaction with the transcriptional regulator BerB

The polysaccharide Bep is essential for in vitro biofilm formation of the opportunistic pathogen Burkholderia cenocepacia. We found that the Burkholderia diffusible signaling factor (BDSF) quorum sensing receptor RpfR is a negative regulator of the bep gene cluster in B. cenocepacia. An rpfR mutant formed wrinkled colonies, whereas additional mutations in the bep genes or known bep regulators like berA and berB restored the wild-type smooth colony morphology. We found that there is a good correlation between intracellular c-di-GMP levels and bep expression when the c-di-GMP level is increased or decreased through ectopic expression of a diguanylate cyclase or a c-di-GMP phosphodiesterase, respectively. However, when the intracellular c-di-GMP level is changed by site directed mutagenesis of the EAL or GGDEF domain of RpfR there is no correlation between intracellular c-di-GMP levels and bep expression. Except for rpfR, deletion mutants of all 25 c-di-GMP phosphodiesterase and diguanylate cyclase genes encoded by B. cenocepacia showed no change to berA and bep gene expression. Moreover, bacterial two-hybrid assays provided evidence that RpfR and BerB physically interact and give specificity to the regulation of the bep genes. We suggest a model where RpfR binds BerB at low c-di-GMP levels to sequester this RpoN-dependent activator to an RpfR/RpfF complex. If the c-di-GMP levels rise, possibly by the enzymatic action of RpfR, BerB binds c-di-GMP and is released from the RpfR/RpfF complex and associates with RpoN to activate transcription of berA, and the BerA protein subsequently activates transcription of the bep genes.

Toward a unified nomenclature for strains with hyper-biofilm phenotypes

Hyper-biofilm strains form robust biofilms, are highly adaptable, and form highly tolerant subpopulations in biofilms grown in vivo and in vitro. Such subpopulations are formed by a wide range of bacteria and thus have been given different names in different species. This situation calls for the establishment of a unified nomenclature for strains with hyper-biofilm phenotypes.

Biofilm cultivation facilitates coexistence and adaptive evolution in an industrial bacterial community

The majority of ecological, industrial and medical impacts of bacteria result from diverse communities containing multiple species. This diversity presents a significant challenge as co-cultivation of multiple bacterial species frequently leads to species being outcompeted and, with this, the possibility to manipulate, evolve and improve bacterial communities is lost. Ecological theory predicts that a solution to this problem will be to grow species in structured environments, which reduces the likelihood of competitive exclusion. Here, we explored the ability of cultivation in a structured environment to facilitate coexistence, evolution, and adaptation in an industrially important community: Lactococcus lactis and Leuconostoc mesenteroides frequently used as dairy starter cultures. As commonly occurs, passaging of these two species together in a liquid culture model led to the loss of one species in 6 of 20 lineages (30%). By contrast, when we co-cultured the two species as biofilms on beads, a stable coexistence was observed in all lineages studied for over 100 generations. Moreover, we show that the co-culture drove evolution of new high-yield variants, which compared to the ancestor grew more slowly, yielded more cells and had enhanced capability of biofilm formation. Importantly, we also show that these high-yield biofilm strains did not evolve when each species was passaged in monoculture in the biofilm model. Therefore, both co-culture and the biofilm model were conditional for these high-yield strains to evolve. Our study underlines the power of ecological thinking—namely, the importance of structured environments for coexistence—to facilitate cultivation, evolution, and adaptation of industrially important bacterial communities.

Pellicle Biofilm Formation in Burkholderia cenocepacia J2315 is Epigenetically Regulated through WspH, a Hybrid Two-Component System Kinase-Response Regulator

The chemosensory signal transduction system Wsp regulates biofilm formation and related phenotypes by influencing cyclic-di-GMP (c-di-GMP) levels in bacterial cells. This is typically achieved by activation of the diguanylate cyclase WspR, through phosphorylation of its phosphoreceiver domain. The Wsp system of Burkholderia cenocepacia J2315 is in one operon with the hybrid response regulator/histidine kinase wspH, but lacks the diguanylate cyclase wspR which is located in a different operon. The expression of wspH, the first gene in the B. cenocepacia Wsp operon as well as pellicle biofilm formation are epigenetically regulated in B. cenocepacia J2315. To investigate whether WspH regulates pellicle biofilm formation, several mutants with altered expression of wspH were constructed. Mutants with increased expression of wspH showed accelerated pellicle biofilm formation, reduced swimming motility and increased c-di-GMP levels. This was independent of WspR phosphorylation, showing that WspR is not the cognate response receiver for histidine kinase WspH. IMPORTANCE Biofilms are surface-attached or suspended aggregates of cells, that are problematic in the context of bacterial infections, as they provide protection from antibiotic treatment. Burkholderia cenocepacia can colonize the lung of immunocompromised patients and forms biofilms that increase its recalcitrance to antibiotic treatment. Pellicles are biofilms which form at an air-liquid interface to take advantage of the higher oxygen concentrations in this environment. How quickly pellicles are formed is crucial for the fitness of obligate aerobic bacteria such as B. cenocepacia. Cyclic-di-GMP (c-di-GMP) levels determine the transition between planktonic and biofilm lifestyle, and WspH controls c-di-GMP production. WspH is therefore important for the fitness of B. cenocepacia in environments with gradients in oxygen concentration, such as the human lung.

Adaptation and phenotypic diversification of Bacillus thuringiensis biofilm are accompanied by fuzzy spreader morphotypes

Bacillus cereus group (Bacillus cereus sensu lato) has a diverse ecology, including various species that produce biofilms on abiotic and biotic surfaces. While genetic and morphological diversification enables the adaptation of multicellular communities, this area remains largely unknown in the Bacillus cereus group. In this work, we dissected the experimental evolution of Bacillus thuringiensis 407 Cry- during continuous recolonization of plastic beads. We observed the evolution of a distinct colony morphotype that we named fuzzy spreader (FS) variant. Most multicellular traits of the FS variant displayed higher competitive ability versus the ancestral strain, suggesting an important role for diversification in the adaptation of B. thuringiensis to the biofilm lifestyle. Further genetic characterization of FS variant revealed the disruption of a guanylyltransferase gene by an insertion sequence (IS) element, which could be similarly observed in the genome of a natural isolate. The evolved FS and the deletion mutant in the guanylyltransferase gene (Bt407ΔrfbM) displayed similarly altered aggregation and hydrophobicity compared to the ancestor strain, suggesting that the adaptation process highly depends on the physical adhesive forces.

A c-di-GMP Signaling Cascade Controls Motility, Biofilm Formation, and Virulence in Burkholderia thailandensis

As a key bacterial second messenger, cyclic di-GMP (c-di-GMP) regulates various physiological processes, such as motility, biofilm formation, and virulence. Cellular c-di-GMP levels are regulated by the opposing activities of diguanylate cyclases (DGCs) and phosphodiesterases (PDEs). Beyond that, the enzymatic activities of c-di-GMP metabolizing proteins are controlled by a variety of extracellular signals and intracellular physiological conditions. Here, we report that pdcA (BTH_II2363), pdcB (BTH_II2364), and pdcC (BTH_II2365) are cotranscribed in the same operon and are involved in a regulatory cascade controlling the cellular level of c-di-GMP in Burkholderia thailandensis. The GGDEF domain-containing protein PdcA was found to be a DGC that modulates biofilm formation, motility, and virulence in B. thailandensis. Moreover, the DGC activity of PdcA was inhibited by phosphorylated PdcC, a single-domain response regulator composed of only the phosphoryl-accepting REC domain. The phosphatase PdcB affects the function of PdcA by dephosphorylating PdcC. The observation that homologous operons of pdcABC are widespread among betaproteobacteria and gammaproteobacteria suggests a general mechanism by which the intracellular concentration of c-di-GMP is modulated to coordinate bacterial behavior and virulence. IMPORTANCE The transition from planktonic cells to biofilm cells is a successful strategy adopted by bacteria to survive in diverse environments, while the second messenger c-di-GMP plays an important role in this process. Cellular c-di-GMP levels are mainly controlled by modulating the activity of c-di-GMP-metabolizing proteins via the sensory domains adjacent to their enzymatic domains. However, in most cases how c-di-GMP-metabolizing enzymes are modulated by their sensory domains remains unclear. Here, we reveal a new c-di-GMP signaling cascade that regulates motility, biofilm formation, and virulence in B. thailandensis. While pdcA, pdcB, and pdcC constitute an operon, the phosphorylated PdcC binds the PAS sensory domain of PdcA to inhibit its DGC activity, with PdcB dephosphorylating PdcC to derepress the activity of PdcA. We also show this c-di-GMP regulatory model is widespread in the phylum Proteobacteria. Our study expands the current knowledge of how bacteria regulate intracellular c-di-GMP levels.

The nutritional environment is sufficient to select coexisting biofilm and quorum-sensing mutants of Pseudomonas aeruginosa

The evolution of bacterial populations during infections can be influenced by various factors including available nutrients, the immune system, and competing microbes, rendering it difficult to identify the specific forces that select on evolved traits. The genomes of Pseudomonas aeruginosa isolated from the airway of patients with cystic fibrosis (CF), for example, have revealed commonly mutated genes, but which phenotypes led to their prevalence is often uncertain. Here, we focus on effects of nutritional components of the CF airway on genetic adaptations by P. aeruginosa grown in either well-mixed (planktonic) or biofilm-associated conditions. After only 80 generations of experimental evolution in a simple medium with glucose, lactate, and amino acids, all planktonic populations diversified into lineages with mutated genes common to CF infections: morA, encoding a regulator of biofilm formation, or lasR, encoding a quorum sensing regulator that modulates the expression of virulence factors. Although mutated quorum sensing is often thought to be selected in vivo due to altered virulence phenotypes or social cheating, isolates with lasR mutations demonstrated increased fitness when grown alone and outcompeted the ancestral PA14 strain. Nonsynonymous SNPs in morA increased fitness in a nutrient concentration-dependent manner during planktonic growth and surprisingly also increased biofilm production. Populations propagated in biofilm conditions also acquired mutations in loci associated with chronic infections, including lasR and cyclic-di-GMP regulators roeA and wspF. These findings demonstrate that nutrient conditions and biofilm selection are sufficient to select mutants with problematic clinical phenotypes including increased biofilm and altered quorum sensing. Importance Pseudomonas aeruginosa produces dangerous chronic infections that are known for their rapid diversification and recalcitrance to treatment. We performed evolution experiments to identify adaptations selected by two specific aspects of the CF respiratory environment: nutrient levels and surface attachment. Propagation of P. aeruginosa in nutrients present within the CF airway was sufficient to drive diversification into subpopulations with identical mutations in regulators of biofilm and quorum sensing to those arising during infection. Thus, the adaptation of opportunistic pathogens to nutrients found in the host may select mutants with phenotypes that complicate treatment and clearance of infection.

Polygenic Adaptation and Clonal Interference Enable Sustained Diversity in Experimental Pseudomonas aeruginosa Populations

How biodiversity arises and can be maintained in asexual microbial populations growing on a single resource remains unclear. Many models presume that beneficial genotypes will outgrow others and purge variation via selective sweeps. Environmental structure like that found in biofilms, which are associated with persistence during infection and other stressful conditions, may oppose this process and preserve variation. We tested this hypothesis by evolving Pseudomonas aeruginosa populations in biofilm-promoting arginine media for 3 months, using both a bead model of the biofilm life cycle and planktonic serial transfer. Surprisingly, adaptation and diversification were mostly uninterrupted by fixation events that eliminate diversity, with hundreds of mutations maintained at intermediate frequencies. The exceptions included genotypes with mutator alleles that also accelerated genetic diversification. Despite the rarity of hard sweeps, a remarkable 40 genes acquired parallel mutations in both treatments and often among competing genotypes within a population. These incomplete soft sweeps include several transporters (including pitA, pntB, nosD, and pchF) suggesting adaptation to the growth media that becomes highly alkaline during growth. Further, genes involved in signal transduction (including gacS, aer2, bdlA, and PA14_71750) reflect likely adaptations to biofilm-inducing conditions. Contrary to evolution experiments that select mutations in a few genes, these results suggest that some environments may expose a larger fraction of the genome and select for many adaptations at once. Thus, even growth on a sole carbon source can lead to persistent genetic and phenotypic variation despite strong selection that would normally purge diversity.

Evolution towards Virulence in a Burkholderia Two-Component System

Bacteria in the Burkholderia cepacia complex (BCC) are significant pathogens for people with cystic fibrosis (CF) and are often extensively antibiotic resistant. Here, we assess the impacts of clinically observed mutations in fixL, which encodes the sensor histidine kinase FixL. FixL along with FixJ compose a two-component system that regulates multiple phenotypes. Mutations in fixL across two species, B. dolosa and B. multivorans, have shown evidence of positive selection during chronic lung infection in CF. Herein, we find that BCC carrying the conserved, ancestral fixL sequence have lower survival in macrophages and in murine pneumonia models than mutants carrying evolved fixL sequences associated with clinical decline in CF patients. In vitro phosphotransfer experiments found that one evolved FixL protein, W439S, has a reduced ability to autophosphorylate and phosphorylate FixJ, while LacZ reporter experiments demonstrate that B. dolosa carrying evolved fixL alleles has reduced fix pathway activity. Interestingly, B. dolosa carrying evolved fixL alleles was less fit in a soil assay than those strains carrying the ancestral allele, demonstrating that increased survival of these variants in macrophages and the murine lung comes at a potential expense in their environmental reservoir. Thus, modulation of the two-component system encoded by fixLJ by point mutations is one mechanism that allows BCC to adapt to the host infection environment.

Rampant prophage movement among transient competitors drives rapid adaptation during infection

Interactions between bacteria, their close competitors, and viral parasites are common in infections, but understanding of these eco-evolutionary dynamics is limited. Most examples of adaptations caused by phage lysogeny are through the acquisition of new genes. However, integrated prophages can also insert into functional genes and impart a fitness benefit by disrupting their expression, a process called active lysogeny. Here, we show that active lysogeny can fuel rapid, parallel adaptations in establishing a chronic infection. These recombination events repeatedly disrupted genes encoding global regulators, leading to increased cyclic di-GMP levels and elevated biofilm production. The implications of prophage-mediated adaptation are broad, as even transient members of microbial communities can alter the course of evolution and generate persistent phenotypes associated with poor clinical outcomes.

Cryptic surface-associated multicellularity emerges through cell adhesion and its regulation

The repeated evolution of multicellularity led to a wide diversity of organisms, many of which are sessile, including land plants, many fungi, and colonial animals. Sessile organisms adhere to a surface for most of their lives, where they grow and compete for space. Despite the prevalence of surface-associated multicellularity, little is known about its evolutionary origin. Here, we introduce a novel theoretical approach, based on spatial lineage tracking of cells, to study this origin. We show that multicellularity can rapidly evolve from two widespread cellular properties: cell adhesion and the regulatory control of adhesion. By evolving adhesion, cells attach to a surface, where they spontaneously give rise to primitive cell collectives that differ in size, life span, and mode of propagation. Selection in favor of large collectives increases the fraction of adhesive cells until a surface becomes fully occupied. Through kin recognition, collectives then evolve a central-peripheral polarity in cell adhesion that supports a division of labor between cells and profoundly impacts growth. Despite this spatial organization, nascent collectives remain cryptic, lack well-defined boundaries, and would require experimental lineage tracking technologies for their identification. Our results suggest that cryptic multicellularity could readily evolve and originate well before multicellular individuals become morphologically evident.

Bacterial Adaptation in Structured Environments: Lessons from Darwin's Finches

Intricate gene regulatory networks control the transition between the planktonic and biofilm lifestyles in bacteria. New evidence from Mhatre et al. uncovers how various adaptive mutations that arose in a key gene at the nexus of signaling networks in Burkholderia cenocepacia led to the emergence of lineages with different ecological roles, enabling stable coexistence of multiple genotypes and increasing productivity of the community.