Relation of spontaneous transformation in cell culture to adaptive growth and clonal heterogeneity

β-Hydroxybutyrate Effects on Bovine Caruncular Epithelial Cells: A Model for Investigating the Peri-Implantation Period Disruption in Ketotic Dairy Cows

Ketosis is a metabolic disorder arising from a negative energy balance (NEB). It is characterized by high β-Hydroxybutyrate (BHBA) blood levels and associated with reduced fertility in dairy cows. To investigate the impact of BHBA on bovine caruncular epithelial cells (BCEC) in vitro, these cells were stimulated with different concentrations of BHBA. Cell metabolism and motility were examined using an MTT assay and Live-cell imaging. RT-qPCR was used to examine mRNA expressions of TNF, IL6, RELA, prostaglandin E2 synthase (PTGES2) and receptor (PTGER2) as well as integrin subunits ITGAV, ITGA6, ITGB1 and ITGB3. Stimulation with 1.8 and 2.4 mM of BHBA negatively affected cell metabolism and motility. TNF showed increased mRNA expression related to rising BHBA concentrations. IL6, RELA, ITGAV, ITGA6, ITGB1 and ITGB3 as well as PTGER2 showed no changes in mRNA expression. Stimulation with 0.6 and 1.2 mM of BHBA significantly increased the mRNA expression of PTGES2. This does not indicate a negative effect on reproductive performance because low BHBA concentrations are found in steady-state conditions. However, the results of the study show negative effects of high BHBA concentrations on the function of BCECs as well as an inflammatory response. This could negatively affect the feto-maternal communication during the peri-implantation period in ketotic dairy cows.

Phenotypic selection as the biological mode of epigenetic conversion and reversion in cell transformation

Exposure of certain cell lines to methylcholanthrene, X-rays, or physiological growth constraint leads to preneoplastic transformation in all or most of the treated cells. After attaining confluence, a fraction in those cells progress to full transformation, as evidenced by their ability to form discrete foci distinguishable from the surrounding cells by virtue of their higher density. Transformation induced by suspension in agar, an even stronger growth-selective condition than confluence, is reminiscent of all but the final differentiated stage of a normal developmental process, epithelial-mesenchymal transition. Changes associated with transformation are not restricted to focus-forming cells, as the permissiveness for focus formation provided by confluent cells surrounding transformed foci is greater than that of nonselected cells. The neoplastic process can also be reversed in culture. Transformed cells passaged at low density in high serum revert to normal morphology and growth behavior in vitro and lose the capacity for tumor formation in vivo. We propose that transformation and its reversal are driven by a process of phenotypic selection that involves entire heterogeneous populations of cells responding to microenvironmental changes. Because of the involvement of whole cell populations, we view this process as fundamentally adaptive and epigenetic in nature.

Dynamics of cell transformation in culture and its significance for tumor development in animals

NIH 3T3 cells grown in conventional Dulbecco's modification of Eagle's basal medium (DME) produce no transformed foci when grown to confluence in 10% calf serum (CS). A few cultures were transformed by ras oncogenes when transfected with DNA from neoplastic cells, but they failed to do so in 80 to 90% of the transfections. However, when they were grown in a medium [molecular, cellular, and developmental biology 402 (MCDB 402)] optimized for their clonal growth in minimal serum, they produced transformed foci without transfection in 10% CS, but not in 2% CS. The first response to growth in MCDB 402 in 2% CS in successive rounds of contact inhibition was uniform increases in saturation density of the population. This was followed by the appearance of transformed foci. A systematic study was made of the dynamics of neoplastic progression in various concentrations of CS in a single round of confluence at 2 and 3 wk, followed by three sequential rounds of confluence in 2% CS for 2 wk. There was a linear relationship between CS concentration and saturation density in the first-round cultures and continuing differences in subsequent cultures. The hyperplastic field of normal-looking cells surrounding transformed foci became increasingly permissive for transformation with serial culture. The dynamics show that epigenetic selection is the major driving force of neoplastic development. Cells from dense foci produced malignant fibrosarcomas in mice, thereby exhibiting a positive relationship between transformation in culture and the development of tumors.

Viruses and human cancers: a long road of discovery of molecular paradigms

About a fifth of all human cancers worldwide are caused by infectious agents. In 12% of cancers, seven different viruses have been causally linked to human oncogenesis: Epstein-Barr virus, hepatitis B virus, human papillomavirus, human T-cell lymphotropic virus, hepatitis C virus, Kaposi's sarcoma herpesvirus, and Merkel cell polyomavirus. Here, we review the many molecular mechanisms of oncogenesis that have been discovered over the decades of study of these viruses. We discuss how viruses can act at different stages in the complex multistep process of carcinogenesis. Early events include their involvement in mutagenic events associated with tumor initiation such as viral integration and insertional mutagenesis as well as viral promotion of DNA damage. Also involved in tumor progression is the dysregulation of cellular processes by viral proteins, and we describe how this has been investigated by studies in cell culture and in experimental animals and by molecular cellular approaches. Also important are the molecular mechanisms whereby viruses interact with the immune system and the immune evasion strategies that have evolved.

Promotion and selection by serum growth factors drive field cancerization, which is anticipated in vivo by type 2 diabetes and obesity

Individuals suffering from type 2 diabetes or obesity exhibit a significant increase in the incidence of various types of cancer. It is generally accepted that those conditions arise from overnutrition and a sedentary lifestyle, which lead to insulin resistance characterized by overproduction of insulin acting as a growth factor. There is a consensus based largely on epidemiological data that chronic overproduction of insulin is responsible for the increased incidence of cancer. A model system in culture of NIH 3T3 cells induces the collective effects of serum growth factors on progression through the stages of field cancerization. It shows that the driving force of progression is promotion of cell growth under selection at high cell density, with no requirement for exogenous carcinogenic agents. The early effect is gradual selection among many preexisting, low-penetrance preneoplastic mutations or stable epigenetic variants, followed by sporadic, high-penetrance transforming variants, all dependent on endogenous processes. The significance of the results for cancer in diabetic and obese individuals is that the initial stages of the process involve multiorgan metabolic interactions that produce a systemic insulin resistance with chronic overproduction of insulin and localized field cancerization. Hypomagnesemia is prevalent in the foregoing metabalo/systemic disorders, and may also provide a selective microenvironment for tumor development.

Transposable elements – Is there a link between evolution and cancer?

Currently, the most predominant theory concerning the formation of cancer is that it is a genetic accident. Accordingly, various agents are thought to cause DNA damage which then subsequently activates oncogenes and inactivates tumor suppressor genes. This article, however, describes a theory that interprets cancer as a misguided adaptation. Stressors, which cannot be compensated for with the usual cell possibilities might arouse evolutionary mechanisms intended to create new protein variants. One of these is the activation of transposable elements which leads to a reformatting of the genome. The result of this process is either a cell that survives very well under stress (and will, therefore, never be detected), a dead cell (in case the process is ineffective), or a more or less abnormal and harmful cell that builds up a new but cancerous organ. This theory explains the complex genetic alterations which are present in almost all cancer cells. It also explains the action of non-mutagenic carcinogens. As part of the reformatting process of the cancer cell genome, activation of oncogenes and inactivation of tumor suppressor genes are not stochastic events but the result of an unlucky genomic composition.

Degrees and kinds of selection in spontaneous neoplastic transformation: an operational analysis

Spontaneous neoplastic transformation develops within days in the NIH 3T3 line of cells through differential inhibition of their proliferation under contact inhibition. A small fraction of the population continues to multiply after saturation density is reached and is selected to progressively increase saturation density in successive rounds of confluence. The degree of selection at confluence depends on the extent of proliferation of some cells in a heterogeneous population. The development of transformed foci is an extension of the same selective process that increases saturation density. The expression of the foci is enhanced with increases in the saturation density of the surrounding cells. Transformation is also induced by moderately reducing the concentration of calf serum in the medium during low-density passages, which allows selection of cells that require less growth factor. Further stepwise reductions in serum increase the degree of transformation. Contact inhibition and reduction in serum concentration select for the same phenotype of cell that increases saturation density and generates transformed foci. There is mounting evidence that selection is a major factor in the development of common epithelial tumors of humans, but it extends over decades rather than days, and the in vivo microenvironment selects from more stable populations of cells than those in culture. The many progressive levels of increased saturation density and transformed focus formation suggest that a very large number of genes participate in neoplastic development. The operational model of variation and selection presented here may aid in understanding chemical carcinogenesis and cancer recurrence after chemotherapy.

Mutation hotspots in the p53 gene in tumors of different origin: correlation with evolutionary conservation and signs of positive selection

We present a classification analysis of the mutation spectra of the p53 gene and construct maps of hotspots for the germline (Li-Fraumein syndrome), different types of tumors and their derived cell lines. While spectra from solid tumors share common hotspots with the germline spectrum, they also contain unique sets of somatic hotspots that are not observed in the germline. All these hotspots correspond to amino acid replacements in the DNA-binding interface of p53. The mutation spectra of lymphomas and cell lines derived from lymphomas and lung cancers contained few hotspots compared to solid tumors. Thus, the distribution of hotspots in the p53 gene appears to depend on the tumor type and cell growth conditions; this specificity is missed by the bulk hotspot analysis. A negative correlation was detected between the amino acid replacement propensity in tumors and evolutionary variability: the hotspots are located in the positions that are highly conserved in p53 and its paralogs, p63 and p73. In all the mutation spectra, substitutions leading to amino acid replacements strongly dominate over silent substitutions, indicating that functional sites evolving under strong purifying selection are subject to intensive positive selection in p53-dependent tumors. These results are compatible with the gain-of-function concept of the role of p53 in tumorigenesis.

The role of phosphometabolites in cell proliferation, energy metabolism, and tumor therapy

A common characteristic of tumor cells is the constant overexpression of glycolytic and glutaminolytic enzymes. In tumor cells the hyperactive hexokinase and the partly inactive pyruvate kinase lead to an expansion of all phosphometabolites from glucose 6-phosphate to phosphoenolpyruvate. In addition to the glycolytic phosphometabolites, synthesis of their metabolic derivatives such as P-ribose-PP, NADH, NADPH, UTP, CTP, and UDP-N-acetyl glucosamine is also enhanced during cell proliferation. Another phosphometabolite derived from P-ribose-PP, AMP, inhibits cell proliferation. The accumulation of AMP inhibits both P-ribose-PP-synthetase and the increase in concentration of phosphometabolites derived from P-ribose-PP. In cells with low glycerol 3-phosphate and malate-aspartate shuttle capacities the inhibition of the lactate dehydrogenase by low NADH levels leads to an inhibition of glycolytic ATP production. Several tumor-therapeutic drugs reduce NAD and NADH levels, thereby inhibiting glycolytic energy production. The role of AMP, NADH, and NADPH levels in the success of chemotherapeutic treatment is discussed.

Relaxation of insulin-like growth factor-2 imprinting in rat cultured cells

The parental-specific expression of the insulin-like growth factor-2 (Igf-2) and H19 genes was studied in rat fibroblast cells derived from a 3 day-old first-generation hybrid animal obtained by crossing Fisher and Wistar strains (F x W cells). Results showed that the reciprocal imprinting of the Igf-2 and H19 genes was conserved in the rat tissues and in the derived F x W cells when cultured with frequent transfer. Igf-2 and H19 gene expression was coordinately up-regulated upon reaching confluence, but Igf-2 RNA levels were further increased in a time-dependent manner and the repressed state of the maternal Igf-2 allele was progressively relaxed in cultures held in the confluent state and in the presence of low serum for more than 3 days. The active expression and relaxed imprinting status of the Igf-2 gene persisted over cell generations when the growth-constraining conditions were released by trypsinization and dilution. On the contrary, the imprinting of the H19 gene appeared to be unaffected by changes in growth conditions and its expression was down-regulated when the confluent cells were passaged. Methylation of the H19 promoter and Igf-2 coding regions was increased in the F x W cells extensively held under confluence and in the derived 'post-confluent' cultures. The heritable changes in the expression, and imprinting status of the Igf-2 and H19 genes observed in the F x W cells closely resembles events described in human embryonal cancers and cancer-predisposing syndromes. The occurrence of imprinting relaxation under strong growth-inhibitory conditions supports the hypothesis that it is an epigenetic change.

The cellular basis of tumor progression

Variability in disease presentation and course is a hallmark of cancer. Variability is seen among similarly diagnosed cancers in different patients or animal hosts and in the same cancer at different periods of time. This latter type of variability, termed "tumor progression," was defined by Foulds in a series of six rules that describe the independent behavior of individual cancers and the independent evolution of different cancer characteristics. Tumor progression is believed to result from variability among subpopulations of tumor cells within individual cancers and from selection of these subpopulations by conditions within the cancer environment, such that different subpopulations come to prominence over the course of cancer development and growth. Interactions among subpopulations, however, modulate tumor behavior as well as tumor evolution. The leading hypothesis for the origin of tumor subpopulations is the genetic instability of cancer cells. There are a number of possible mechanisms of genetic instability, some internal to cancer cells (mutation, amplification, mutator phenotypes, DNA repair deficiencies) and some present in the tumor microenvironment (endogenous mutagens). There are also potential epigenetic mechanisms of variability, including alterations in gene regulation, differentiation, adaptation, and cell fusion. Regardless of mechanism, the heterogeneity of tumor subpopulations poses a number of challenges to the practice of cancer research, including the design of reproducible and meaningful experiments. Tumor heterogeneity also has significant consequences for the clinical assessment of tumor prognosis and the development of effective treatment regimens.

The role of phosphometabolites in cell proliferation, energy metabolism, and tumor therapy

A common characteristic of tumor cells is the constant overexpression of glycolytic and glutaminolytic enzymes. In tumor cells the hyperactive hexokinase and the partly inactive pyruvate kinase lead to an expansion of all phosphometabolites from glucose 6-phosphate to phosphoenolpyruvate. In addition to the glycolytic phosphometabolites, synthesis of their metabolic derivatives such as P-ribose-PP, NADH, NADPH, UTP, CTP, and UDP-N-acetyl glucosamine is also enhanced during cell proliferation. Another phosphometabolite derived from P-ribose-PP, AMP, inhibits cell proliferation. The accumulation of AMP inhibits both P-ribose-PP-synthetase and the increase in concentration of phosphometabolites derived from P-ribose-PP. In cells with low glycerol 3-phosphate and malate-aspartate shuttle capacities the inhibition of the lactate dehydrogenase by low NADH levels leads to an inhibition of glycolytic ATP production. Several tumor-therapeutic drugs reduce NAD and NADH levels, thereby inhibiting glycolytic energy production. The role of AMP, NADH, and NADPH levels in the success of chemotherapeutic treatment is discussed.

Hormone-defined cell system for studying G-protein coupled receptor agonist-activated growth modulation: delta-opioid and serotonin-5HT2C receptor activation show opposite mitogenic effects

G-protein-coupled receptor (GPCR) agonist-activated transformation of NIH/3T3 fibroblast cells has been documented by many workers. Our present interest is in the growth control exerted by these agonists. The mechanisms involved in GPCR agonist-activated growth regulation are not known and investigations using existing cell lines are complicated by the endogenous expression of numerous different GPCRs as well as by the fact that these cell lines are cultured in serum that contains naturally occurring agonists for these receptors. To study the agonist induced growth response of cells transfected with either delta-opioid or serotonin-5HT2C neurotransmitter receptor genes, we have developed new clonal cell lines derived from NIH/3T3 mouse fibroblast cells. These new cell lines, designated with the suffix 3T3DA, can be cultured stably in serum-free, hormone-defined medium: insulin is the only exogenous growth factor added to the culture medium of proliferating 3T3DA cell lines, and their proliferation can be stopped and started by the respective removal or addition of insulin. Micromolar concentrations of agonists were used to activate the corresponding opioid and serotonin receptors over periods extending to 6 days. We observed distinct patterns of GPCR-specific, agonist-activated growth regulation in serum-free cultures, but not in serum-supplemented cultures. At concentrations > 10 microM, morphine inhibits growth of delta-opioid receptor-expressing cells by 40% with respect to normal 3T3DA cells. Opioid agonist induced inhibition of cyclic AMP (cAMP) production as well as growth down-regulation are pertussis toxin sensitive indicating that the exogenously expressed delta-opioid receptors demonstrate classical opioid receptor signaling. The presence of 1 microM serotonin stimulates growth of serotonin-5HT2C receptor- expressing cells by approximately 100% with respect to normal 3T3DA cells. Neither the untreated nor the agonist-treated cells form colonies in soft agar, indicating that they retain anchorage-dependent growth control. These cell lines provide a simple system that could be used as a tool for probing the complex molecular mechanisms associated with GPCR agonist-activated growth control.

Adaptive mutations in Escherichia coli as a model for the multiple mutational origins of tumors

The cells in most tumors are found to carry multiple mutations; however, based upon mutation rates determined by fluctuation tests, the frequency of such multiple mutations should be so low that tumors are never detected within human populations. Fluctuation tests, which determine the cell-division-dependent mutation rate per cell generation in growing cells, may not be appropriate for estimating mutation rates in nondividing or very slowly dividing cells. Recent studies of time-dependent, "adaptive" mutations in nondividing populations of microorganisms suggest that similar measurements may be more appropriate to understanding the mutation origins of tumors. Here I use the ebgR and ebgA genes of Escherichia coli to measure adaptive mutation rates where multiple mutations are required for rapid growth. Mutations in either ebgA or ebgR allow very slow growth on lactulose (4-O-beta-D-galactosyl-D-fructose), with doubling times of 3.2 and 17.3 days, respectively. However, when both mutations are present, cells can grow rapidly with doubling times of 2.7 hr. I show that during prolonged (28-day) selection for growth on lactulose, the number of lactulose-utilizing mutants that accumulate is 40,000 times greater than can be accounted for on the basis of mutation rates measured by fluctuation tests, but is entirely consistent with the time-dependent adaptive mutation rates measured under the same conditions of prolonged selection.

Heritable, population-wide damage to cells as the driving force of neoplastic transformation

Prolonged incubation of NIH 3T3 cells under the growth constraint of confluence results in the death of some cells in a manner suggestive of apoptosis. Successive rounds of prolonged incubation at confluence of the surviving cells produce increasing neoplastic transformation in the form of increments in saturation density and transformed focus formation. Cells from the postconfluent cultures are given a recovery period of various lengths to remove the direct inhibitory effect of confluence before their growth properties are studied. It is found that with each round of confluence the exponential growth rate of the cells at low densities gets lower and the size of isolated colonies of the same cells shows a similar progressive reduction. The decreased growth rate of cells from the third round of confluence persists for > 60 generations of growth at low density. The proportion of colonies containing giant cells is much higher after a 2-day recovery from confluence than after a 7-day recovery. Retardation of growth at low density and increased saturation density appear to be two sides of the same coin: both occur in the entire population of cells and precede the formation of transformed foci. We propose that the slowdown in growth and the formation of giant cells result from heritable damage to the cells, which in turn drives their transformation. Similar results have been reported for the survivors of x-irradiation and of treatment with chemical carcinogens and are associated with the aging process in animals. We suggest that these changes result from free radical damage to membrane lipids with particular damage to lysosomes. Proteases and nucleases would then be released to progressively modify the growth behavior and genetic stability of the cells toward autonomous proliferation.

Induction of pseudofoci and inhibition of density-mediated neoplastic transformation by PMA in NIH 3T3 cells after short-term exposures

Depending on the precise conditions and cellular starting material, phorbol-13-myristate-12-acetate (PMA) can induce or suppress the transformation of NIH 3T3 cells. In sublines that do not undergo rapid transformation, exposure to PMA over the course of several weeks accelerated the process, while sublines that are primed for density-mediated transformation respond to PMA with a suppression of the process. This study examines the latter phenomenon. Within 1 h of exposure to 0.02 microgram/ml PMA, sparse cultures had undergone a morphological transition after which the cells appeared smaller and the processes thinner. These sublines exhibited a two- to sixfold increase in the saturation density achieved in 2% calf serum (CS). Phorbol ester analogs with hydrocarbon substitutions of 4 or more carbons at positions 12 and 13 of the phorbol nucleus had a similar effect as PMA on the saturation density. High concentrations of PMA (1 microgram/ml) induced the formation of cell aggregates (pseudofoci) that resembled transformed foci in their high local density, but unlike transformed foci, did not reinitiate focus formation if the cells were diluted and replated without PMA as secondary cultures. PMA inhibited the processes of neoplastic transformation and progression that occur readily in these NIH 3T3 sublines when they reach high cell density. I suggest that such changes occur because PMA abolishes the selection pressure at high densities that favors the transformation of some cells in heterogeneous populations. Induction of transformation by PMA (reported previously) occurs after much longer exposures in sublines that are relatively resistant to rapid density-mediated transformation.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Selective interactions between mammary epithelial cells and fibroblasts in co-culture

Paracrine interactions between breast-cancer cells (MCF7) and stromal fibroblasts were studied in relation to the presence of steroid hormones, using co-cultures in which the 2 populations were separated by a microporous membrane. Densities and DNA-synthesis rates of the co-existing populations were interrelated. Proliferation was, therefore, viewed as the cumulative result of several factors, some of which are non-specific, e.g., are density-dependent, and some are specifically related to the feeders' origin and/or to culture conditions. Specific effects were measured and evaluated by stepwise analysis of covariance. MCF7 stimulated proliferation of fibroblasts differentially. Malignant-tumour fibroblasts were stimulated more than non-pathological ones. The magnitude of these effects was dependent on the presence of steroids. A similar analytical method was used for evaluating differential stromal influences on 4 epithelial phenotypic characters commonly used as prognostic markers. The estrogen-receptor, progesterone-receptor, pS2 and cathepsine-D phenotypes of MCF7, as well as their interrelations, were dependent on the origin of the fibroblasts, i.e., embryonic or adult, normal or tumoral.

A critical test of the role of population density in producing transformation

Cells of the NIH 3T3 line gain the capacity to produce neoplastically transformed foci when they are maintained at high density for more than 1 week and transferred in a standard assay for focus formation. This change in cell behavior has been variously attributed to an adaptive response to the constraint of the high population density or to a spontaneous genetic change that increases in probability for a culture with the increase in the total number of cell divisions. To distinguish between these alternatives, 200 cells of the 28H subline were seeded in many culture dishes of two size classes differing 6-fold in surface area and allowed to multiply for 1, 2, and 3 weeks. At each weekly interval, 18 dishes of each class were assayed for focus formation, and two of the original dishes were stained for focus formation. The cells in the small (S) and large (L) dishes multiplied to the same extent at 1 week and produced only a few small light foci in some of the assay dishes. At 2 weeks, cells in the S dishes had become confluent and had only one-third the number of cells as those in the nonconfluent L dishes. Upon assay, 14 of the 18 S cultures produced some foci whereas only 9 of the L cultures did so. In addition, 4 of the S cultures produced large dense foci while none of the L cultures did. By 3 weeks, the L cultures were confluent and had four times as many cells as the S cultures. When assayed at this time, both sets produced dense foci in many of the cultures and light foci in the remaining ones, indicating a narrowing of the differences between the S and L cultures between 2 and 3 weeks of incubation. There were differences in the morphology of the foci produced in parallel assays from different cultures. The results showed that transformation is a diverse graded response to the growth constraint of high population density and not a spontaneous event dependent on the number of cell divisions in a cell culture. Transformation thus is basically an epigenetic process since it represents a response to physiological restraint, but the final form of response may be modulated by genetic alterations.

Selective nature of phorbol 12-myristate 13-acetate-induced neoplastic transformation in NIH 3T3 cells

The ability of phorbol 12-myristate 13-acetate (PMA) at 0.02 microgram/ml to induce neoplastic transformation in NIH 3T3 cells is highly dependent on the culture conditions. Optimal transformation, indicated by the saturation density and extent of focus formation in transferred cultures raised under standard conditions, was observed when the original cells were grown in 2% calf serum (CS) and exposed continually to PMA for at least 4 weeks before transfer into the assay. Transformation of stationary cultures in 10% CS occurred later and to a lesser degree than in 2% CS. The same cells subjected to thrice-weekly transfer in 2% or 10% CS at low cell density so that they were in a constant state of exponential growth exhibited no evidence of transformation in response to PMA. This strong condition-dependence of PMA-enhanced transformation is indicative of a selection process similar to that described for spontaneous transformation. In both cases, transformation is promoted by inhibiting multiplication and prevented by maximizing multiplication. Therefore, it has the earmarks of an epigenetic rather than a mutational process and requires phenotypic rather than genotypic variation to supply the states for selection. The concept of "progressive state selection," originally proposed to account for spontaneous transformation, can also account for PMA-enhanced transformation.

Cellular epigenetics: control of the size, shape, and spatial distribution of transformed foci by interactions between the transformed and nontransformed cells

NIH 3T3 cells that are passaged frequently at low density in high (10%) calf serum lose their original capacity to produce transformed foci on a monolayer of nontransformed cells. They can then be used to form a monolayered background for the assay of the number of focus-forming cells from a transformed population. Continuation of the low-density passages for many weeks gives rise to a population that can suppress the full development of foci by a transformed line. The suppression appears to occur only after the background cells have become confluent and contact inhibited. It can also cause the disappearance of light foci that had developed before suppression began. Another subline of cells that were passaged at cloning density only once a week lose their focus-forming capacity more slowly than those passaged thrice weekly. When used as a background for the assay of a transformed line, they permit continuous expansion of the foci, with no sign of suppression. Not only the number and size of foci but also their detailed morphology is influenced by the background on which they are formed. A suppressive background can also determine the spatial distribution of foci, presumably as a result of gradients in local cell density of the background. The permissiveness of a nontransformed cell population for focus formation by transformed cells appears to be related to the capacity of the nontransformed population itself to undergo transformation when exposed to the constraints used to induce transformation. These findings indicate there are many degrees of capacity to suppress focus formation and to overcome suppression. They have significance for tumor development and for the epigenetic interactions of normal development.

Cellular epigenetics: topochronology of progressive "spontaneous" transformation of cells under growth constraint

Early passages of NIH 3T3 cells yield about 10 transformed foci for every 10(5) cells seeded after the cells multiply to confluence in a standardized 2-week assay. The question arose whether more cells would give rise to foci if given more time for their development. This question could not be answered simply by extending the incubation period, since the original foci spread to cover much of the area of the culture dish. Transformed cells can also detach into the medium from the original foci to initiate new foci by reattaching at a distance. These problems were averted by growing cells in multiwell plates which in effect simulated partitioned culture dishes. All the wells in a given plate were assayed for focus formation at successive intervals up to 14 weeks. The results indicated the spatial pattern and sequence of transformation on different parts of the "partitioned" dish. The number of multiwells containing focus-forming cells increased steadily with time, indicating that all parts of a dish eventually undergo transformation. Also, most of the transformations were recorded long after confluence in the multiwells was reached. Hence such a transformation is much more likely to occur in the nondividing state rather than in the dividing state of the cells and is thus inconsistent with a mutational basis. The results suggest that "spontaneous" transformation is a population-wide, epigenetic phenomenon. This agrees with the results from clonal analysis and other studies and is well described by the concept of progressive state selection, in which "spontaneous" transformation represents a heterogeneous, adaptive response of competent cells to moderate constraints on cell growth.

Automatic enumeration and characterization of heterogeneous clonal progression in cell transformation

Most human tumors are clonal in origin, although the cells may be diverse in their properties. Since the tumors evolve through progressive stages over decades of time, it is possible that the conditions that induced the tumor transform many cells, but that selective overgrowth of the fastest growing lead to a clonal population of identified tumor cells. We studied the progression of neoplastic transformation in clones from a population in which about 10% of the cells formed well-defined transformed foci. A few of the clones produced many large foci, but most of the clones produced no foci or only one focus. Maintenance of the nonproducing and low-producing clones under the growth constraint of confluence and low serum concentration, which promotes transformation, led to the production of large numbers of small foci by all of them. Visual inspection revealed considerable heterogeneity in size and density among the foci from each clone, and this was quantitated by computer scanning. Subclonal analysis of focus formation was done on one of the clones after it had undergone further growth constraint to promote transformation. As in the original cloning, some of the subclones produced many large foci, but most produced none. Another round of growth constraint was imposed on the nonproducing subclones, which then became producers of many small foci varying in size and density. The results indicate that most if not all cells in the population respond to growth constraint by undergoing transformation. Though there is wide variation in the degree of transformation, the results are consistent with the view that an entire field of cells exposed to carcinogenic conditions in an animal undergoes some progression toward neoplasia but that heterogeneity of the response followed by selective neoplastic growth may lead to a clonal origin of the clinically detected tumor.

Cellular epigenetics: effects of passage history on competence of cells for "spontaneous" transformation

"Spontaneous" neoplastic transformation of cells in culture has been shown to be an adaptive response to moderate physiological constraints such as contact inhibition and lowered concentrations of serum. These are the same constraints that promote normal differentiation of a variety of cell types. Because both normal and neoplastic development represent enduring changes in response to constraint, spontaneous transformation can be considered a form of epigenesis. This phenomenon permits the use of established cell lines in developing general epigenetic principles with all of the advantages of manipulation, efficient cloning, and quantification afforded by such systems. Being environmentally sensitive, however, the responsive capacity of cell lines is subject to fluctuation and long-term modification. I therefore set out to define the conditions used in maintaining cells that influence their competence to undergo transformation with the aim of controlling that competence. It proved to be sensitive to both the population density and frequency of three different repetitive passage regimens. Both the saturation density of the cells and their capacity to produce transformed foci varied initially in different ways within the same regimen in two consecutive passage series starting from the same frozen stock, but both parameters eventually settled down to values characteristic of each of the three regimens. As a result, three sublines were developed of high, intermediate, and low competence for transformation. Each of the sublines has special advantages for studying different aspects of epigenetic change. In the process of developing the sublines, a number of observations were made that reinforce the epigenetic nature of neoplastic transformation and are consistent with the concept of progressive state selection as the basis of the change. That concept can be considered a first step in the formal analysis of epigenesis.

Metastatic conversion of cells by expression of human papillomavirus type 16 E6 and E7 genes

The human papillomavirus type 16 (HPV-16) is a DNA tumor virus highly associated with cervical carcinoma. Viral DNA from HPV-16 is found in primary tumors and their metastatic lesions. To investigate the role of HPV-16 oncoproteins in the development of cancer metastasis, the E6 and E7 genes from HPV-16 were inserted into retrovirus and introduced into nonmetastatic mouse cell lines. Expression of either of the viral genes from HPV-16 made the cells metastatic in nude mice. In contrast, expression of the E6 and E7 genes of HPV type 6 (HPV-6b), which is frequently found in nonmalignant HPV-associated diseases, did not. The metastatic ability of cells transduced with viral genes of HPV-16 did not correlate with their growth rate or sensitivity to destruction by natural killer cells. Our results demonstrate that expression of oncogenic proteins of HPV-16 can cause tumor metastasis and implicate HPV-16 in an important role regarding the progression of HPV-associated human cancers.

'Spontaneous' transformation as aberrant epigenesis

The NIH 3T3 line of cells has particular advantages for studying the dynamics of change in cellular phenotype in response to environmental conditions. Similar to stem cell growth during development, the cell line changes its phenotype under growth constraints that elicit differentiation or, alternatively, it maintains its original state over many replication cycles when grown without constraint. Unlike many cell types which respond by undergoing terminal differentiation, the NIH 3T3 cells continue to multiply indefinitely following an induced alteration in phenotype; the heritability of this change may thus be analyzed under stringent conditions of cell culture. During the course of over two years of frequent passage at low density in high calf serum (CS) concentration, a new subline developed which exhibited a consistent capacity to respond quickly and pervasively to growth constraints with an increase in saturation density, development of transformed foci in confluent cultures and altered appearance of isolated colonies. A retrospective study was undertaken, with cells from cryopreserved samples, of the course of changes in responsiveness of the cells to growth constraint leading up to the highly responsive state. Three stages were discerned, the first with an initially high capacity of a small fraction of cells to produce diffuse foci, but with a rapid decline in this capacity with frequent low density passages; the second stage, extending over more than 200 passages, of refractoriness to transformation; and the third stage (which probably arose by mutation) in which there is a consistent transformation-related response by the entire population to growth constraint, a response which has remained relatively constant over some 100 passages. A striking and novel feature of the third stage is seen on cloning the cells. Almost all the colonies obtained by cloning cells from post-confluent, growth-inhibited cultures are distinctly different in morphology from those obtained by cloning cells from the frequent low density passages. The pervasiveness of this morphological change among the clones is unmistakable evidence for a heritable adaptive response to growth constraint by most if not all of the cells in the population. The population-wide response of the cells of the third stage offers the opportunity for a rigorous, quantitative analysis of the nature of this type of persistent cellular change. Although cells of the third stage may be of mutational origin, their pervasive heritable response once the variant population is established supports the concept of progressive state selection which postulates that transformation can arise by the continuous fluctuation of growth states within cells, accompanied by the progressive selection of those states best suited to function under the selecting constraint. Relevance of the concept to the process of differentiation under growth constraint is considered.

Oscillations: a key event in transformed renal epithelial cells

Intracellular pH (pHi) plays a critical role in the entry of cells into the DNA-synthesis phase of the cell cycle. Alterations in pHi may contribute to abnormal proliferative responses such as those seen in tumorigenic cells. We observed that alkaline stress leads to genomic transformation of Madin-Darby canine kidney (MDCK) cells. Transformed cells (F cells) form "foci" in culture, lack contact inhibition, and are able to migrate, typical characteristics of dedifferentiated tumorigenic cells. F cells exhibit spontaneous biorhythmicity. Rhythmic transmembrane Ca2+ flux activates plasma membrane K+ channels and Na+/H+ exchange. This leads to periodic changes of membrane voltage and pHi at about one cycle per minute. We conclude that endogenous oscillatory activity could be a trigger mechanism for DNA synthesis, proliferation, and abnormal growth of renal epithelial cells in culture.

Sensitivity of transformation to small differences in population density during serial passage of NIH 3T3 cells

Early passages of the NIH 3T3 mouse cell line undergo spontaneous neoplastic transformation leading to the development of transformed foci if grown to confluence in 2% (vol/vol) calf serum (CS) and left there for more than a week. Transfer of the postconfluent cultures results in the appearance of large numbers of transformed foci; many of them are larger and denser than those in the original culture. If the cells are continually kept at low population densities by frequent passages in 10% CS, they lose the capacity to undergo spontaneous transformation. If however the low-density passages are made in 2% CS or in 10% (vol/vol) fetal bovine serum, both of which support lower growth rates and saturation densities than does 10% CS, they gain the capacities to grow to high saturation densities and produce more foci when grown to confluence in 2% CS. These increases are proportional to the population densities used in the frequent passages, although the densities are all kept well below confluence. We conclude that the combined constraints of submaximal serum plus those of the limited cell contacts of the low cell densities used here elicit an adaptive response that endows the entire population with increased growth capacity. The increased growth capacity of the heterogeneous population in turn increases the capacity of a fraction of the population to initiate distinctive transformed foci. Similar studies have indicated that the capacity of cells to produce tumors and metastases in mice and rats is enhanced by prior maintenance at high density in culture. We propose the concept of progressive state selection to account for the general increase in the growth capacity of cells that is elicited by moderate constraints on their growth and metabolism.

Malignant transformation of NIH-3T3 cells after subcutaneous co-injection with a reconstituted basement membrane (matrigel)

NIH-3T3 cells are non-tumorigenic when injected into athymic mice. If these cells are mixed with an extract of basement-membrane proteins (matrigel) and injected s.c., they form locally invasive and highly vascularized tumors. Cells cultured from the NIH-3T3-matrigel-induced tumors showed a transformed phenotype and lacked contact inhibition. When cultured in a gel of matrigel, they proliferated and formed branched and invasive colonies. In contrast, the parental NIH-3T3 cells cultured on matrigel remained as cell aggregates and were not invasive. I.V. injections of the tumor-derived NIH-3T3 cells produced many colonies on the surface of the lungs, whereas the parental NIH-3T3 cells were not metastatic. Zymographic analysis of the conditioned media obtained from both the tumor-derived and parental NIH-3T3 cells demonstrated higher amounts of the 72-kDa gelatinase (type-IV collagenase) enzyme in the tumor-derived cells. Also, tumor-derived NIH-3T3 cells, but not parental NIH-3T3 cells, secreted the 92-kDa type-IV collagenase. These studies suggest that the interaction of pre-malignant NIH-3T3 cells with extracellular matrix components may contribute to the process of tumor progression.

High rate of diversification and reversal among subclones of neoplastically transformed NIH 3T3 clones

NIH 3T3 cells undergo neoplastic transformation when exposed to conditions of moderate physiological growth constraint. One of several characteristics of this transformation that indicates its adaptational nature is its gradual reversibility under conditions of unconstrained growth. We explored the origins of reversibility by isolating cells from each of three highly transformed foci and comparing their focus-forming capacity with that of derivative clones and subclones. A high proportion of the parental cells made dense foci. Six of the nine clones obtained from the three foci produced foci, though the percentage varied widely. The other three clones produced no foci at all. The transformed clones were subcloned and analyzed to evaluate the possibility that the negative clones were genuine revertants, rather than being derived from a small minority of nontransformed cells surrounding or underlying the original foci. In each case the subclones varied widely in the percentage of focus-forming cells and the average was much lower than the parental clone from which they were derived. Indeed, 15 of the 53 subclonal populations produced no foci. The high degree of heterogeneity, including complete reversal of focus-forming capacity, provides additional support for the hypothesis that "spontaneous" transformation is driven by an adaptive response to moderate growth constraint rather than by one or more effectively irreversible mutations.

Adaptive evolution of degrees and kinds of neoplastic transformation in cell culture

Human cancers undergo protracted complex development from benign to malignant states, as most thoroughly documented in the mole-to-melanoma sequence. The early stages of the sequence tend to redifferentiate into normal tissues; the later stages progress to ever increasing multiplication and malignancy. When placed under the growth constraint of either crowding or low serum concentrations, the NIH 3T3 line of mouse cells readily undergoes transformation, expressed in the development of foci of cells that continue to multiply at confluence when the rest of the population has stopped. If the nontransformed cells are maintained for 3 months by frequent low-density passages in high concentrations of calf serum, they gradually lose the capacity to undergo transformation when the constraints are applied. The same conditions of passage have been used to reverse the transformation, both processes resembling in principle the reversal of the early stages of the mole-to-melanoma sequence. When the frequent low-density passages are made in high concentrations of fetal bovine serum, which supports a slightly lower growth rate than an equal concentration of calf serum, the degree of transformation is gradually increased, so that the foci become more numerous, broader, and thicker, reaching a maximum in successive assays at about 3 months of passaging. A diversity of focal morphologies is sporadically generated in the calf serum passage by exposing the cells to various concentrations of calf serum for 14 days of growth and confluency before assaying them. The dependence of the number, density, and morphology of foci on the environment in which the cells had been grown before assay reinforces the evidence that the transformation is an epigenetic process. The fact that these effects develop in culture gradually over an extended period of time suggests parallels to the characteristically long-term early regression and later progression, as well as the diversity of the mole-to-melanoma sequence, and may also be representative of other cancers.

Role of transfection and clonal selection in mediating radioresistance

Transfected oncogenes have been reported to increase the radioresistance of rodent cells. Whether transfected nononcogenic DNA sequences and subsequent clonal selection can result in radioresistant cell populations is unknown. The present set of experiments describe the in vitro radiosensitivity and tumorigenicity of selected clones of primary rat embryo cells and human glioblastoma cells, after transfection with a neomycin-resistance marker (pSV2neo or pCMVneo) and clonal selection. Radiobiological data comparing the surviving fraction at 2 Gy (SF2) and the mean inactivation dose show the induction of radioresistance in two rat embryo cell clones and one glioblastoma clone, as compared to untransfected cells. Wild-type and transfectant clones were injected into three strains of immune-deficient mice (scid, NIH, and nu/nu) to assay for tumorigenicity and metastatic potential. Only the glioblastoma parent line and its transfectant clones were tumorigenic. None of the cells produced spontaneous or experimentally induced metastases. Flow cytometric analyses indicated that the induction of radioresistance could not be attributed to changes in cell kinetics at the time of irradiation. Our results show that transfection of a neomycin-resistance marker and clonal selection can impart radioresistance on both normal and tumor cells. The work also indicates that altered radiation sensitivity does not necessarily correlate with changes in cell-cycle kinetics at the time of irradiation, tumorigenicity, or altered metastatic potential. Our findings have critical implications for transfection studies investigating determinants of cellular radiosensitivity.

Growth in high serum concentrations leads to rapid deadaptation of cells previously adapted to growth in an extremely low concentration of serum

A subline of NIH 3T3 cells adapted to multiply in 0.25% calf serum (CS) by frequent passage (every 2-3 days) at low population density in 0.25% CS was deadapted by frequent successive passages of the cells in 10% CS for 3 weeks. The cells adapted to 0.25% CS multiplied with an average doubling time of 16.9 hr in 10% CS, and cells that had always been kept in 10% CS multiplied with an average doubling time of 14.6 hr, so there was weak selection for the latter in the higher serum concentration. When adapted cells were subjected to two passagers in 10% CS prior to assay of growth in 0.25% CS, a 4-day lag period was evident before commencement of exponential growth, and there was a decrease in saturation density. Further delay of growth in 0.25% CS developed as the number of passages of cells in 10% CS increased. The marked delay of growth in 0.25% CS of the bulk population after a few days in 10% CS argued against selection in 10% CS of rare nonadapted mutants from the adapted population and for an epigenetic origin of the change. Reconstruction experiments utilizing adapted cells mixed with non-adapted cells in 0.25% CS buttressed this explanation. Eight clones of the adapted population exhibited some loss of growth capacity in 0.25% CS after a single passage in 10% CS, though the extent of loss varied from clone to clone. The results support the idea that all cells in the adapted population respond to the lifting of growth constraints with loss of their growth potential under highly constrained conditions. They are consistent with the concept of progressive state selection in which selection operates on fluctuating metabolic states of individual cells rather than on genetic variants.

Expression of growth-regulated genes in normal and SV40 transformed hamster fibroblasts

Transformation by the oncogenic virus SV40 has been shown to alter the expression of cellular genes at the level of RNA abundance. Many of these genes have yet to be identified. We have determined, by Northern blot analysis, the abundance levels of several growth-regulated genes in SV40-transformed cell lines to determine if their expression is altered and correlates with the ability of SV40 transformed cells to grow in low serum containing media. The mRNA abundance levels of the G1-specific genes 2A9/calcyclin, 2F1/translocase, and 4F1/vimentin were determined in the parental hamster fibroblast cell line, tk-ts13, and in two SV40 transformants, HR5 and HR8 cells, grown in medium containing 10% calf serum (normal medium) and in HR5 and HR8 cells adapted to passage in medium containing low serum. A spontaneous transformant of the parental line capable of growth in low serum in the absence of SV40 transformation (tk-ts13/1%), was also included in these studies. The low serum adapted SV40-transformed cells and the spontaneous tk-ts13 transformed cells grew more vigorously than their nonadapted counterparts in medium containing low serum. The low serum adapted cells also grew to higher saturation densities in low serum and to densities comparable to those in high serum, whereas the nonadapted cells grew to low saturation densities in low serum, but not as low as the untransformed parental.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Alkaline stress transforms Madin-Darby canine kidney cells

Similar to growth factors aldosterone stimulates Na+/H+ exchange in renal target cells leading to cytoplasmic alkalinization. An alkaline intracellular pH reduces the H+ bonds between repressor proteins and DNA leading to the destabilization of the nuclear chromatin. We observed that sustained alkaline stress "per se" can lead to malignant transformation of Madin-Darby canine kidney (MDCK) cells. Cells grown for two weeks in alkaline culture medium (pH 7.8) developed multiple "foci" composed of spindle-shaped pleomorphic cells lacking contact inhibition and exhibiting poor adhesion to the culture support, typical characteristics of dedifferentiated tumor cells. "Focus" cells were cloned and grown in standard medium (pH 7.4). Cells maintained their abnormal growth pattern, indicating stable pH-induced genetic transformation. Cells were fused with polyethylene glycol to giant cells and impaled with microelectrodes. In contrast to non-transformed giant MDCK cells the plasma membrane potential showed spontaneous oscillations that could be virtually abolished by the omission of extracellular Ca2+ or by the addition of the K+ channel blocker Ba2+. We conclude that sustained alkaline stress can induce malignant transformation in MDCK cells indicated by an abnormal growth pattern and by membrane potential oscillations most likely due to Ca2+ activated K+ channels in the plasma membrane.

Physiological induction and reversal of focus formation and tumorigenicity in NIH 3T3 cells

NIH 3T3 cells undergo morphological transformation in response to conditions of constrained growth, such as occur in low serum concentrations or at confluence. Transformation is expressed in a small fraction of the cells by the appearance of discrete foci of multiplying cells on a confluent monolayer of quiescent cells. We isolated and expanded cell populations from three dense and three light foci. Cells from each of these populations efficiently reproduced foci of the same morphotype when grown on a background of nontransformed NIH 3T3 cells. Using cultures derived from one of the dense foci (subline D/2), we found that the number of focus-forming units was stable and the cells remained tumorigenic when they were subjected to repeated thrice-weekly passage in 2% calf serum. However, equivalent passage in 10% calf serum eventually rendered the cells incapable of both focus production and tumor formation. The results show that the capacity to produce tumors as well as morphological transformation are produced as a response to physiological constraints of growth and/or metabolism in the absence of carcinogens and that both properties can be reversed by lifting the constraints. This behavior is typical of an adaptational response and, taken together with other supporting evidence, shows that tumorigenesis does not require conventional genetic alteration.