Processing of the mother-cell sigma factor, sigma K, may depend on events occurring in the forespore during Bacillus subtilis development

Inhibitory proteins block substrate access by occupying the active site cleft of Bacillus subtilis intramembrane protease SpoIVFB

Intramembrane proteases (IPs) function in numerous signaling pathways that impact health, but elucidating the regulation of membrane-embedded proteases is challenging. We examined inhibition of intramembrane metalloprotease SpoIVFB by proteins BofA and SpoIVFA. We found that SpoIVFB inhibition requires BofA residues in and near a predicted transmembrane segment (TMS). This segment of BofA occupies the SpoIVFB active site cleft based on cross-linking experiments. SpoIVFB inhibition also requires SpoIVFA. The inhibitory proteins block access of the substrate N-terminal region to the membrane-embedded SpoIVFB active site, based on additional cross-linking experiments; however, the inhibitory proteins did not prevent interaction between the substrate C-terminal region and the SpoIVFB soluble domain. We built a structural model of SpoIVFB in complex with BofA and parts of SpoIVFA and substrate, using partial homology and constraints from cross-linking and co-evolutionary analyses. The model predicts that conserved BofA residues interact to stabilize a TMS and a membrane-embedded C-terminal region. The model also predicts that SpoIVFA bridges the BofA C-terminal region and SpoIVFB, forming a membrane-embedded inhibition complex. Our results reveal a novel mechanism of IP inhibition with clear implications for relief from inhibition in vivo and design of inhibitors as potential therapeutics.

Conserved Proline Residues of Bacillus subtilis Intramembrane Metalloprotease SpoIVFB Are Important for Substrate Interaction and Cleavage

Intramembrane metalloproteases (IMMPs) regulate diverse biological processes by cleaving membrane-associated substrates within the membrane or near its surface. SpoIVFB is an intramembrane metalloprotease of Bacillus subtilis that cleaves Pro-σK during endosporulation. Intramembrane metalloproteases have a broadly conserved NPDG motif, which in the structure of an archaeal enzyme is located in a short loop that interrupts a transmembrane segment facing the active site. The aspartate residue of the NPDG motif acts as a ligand of the zinc ion involved in catalysis. The functions of other residues in the short loop are less well understood. We found that the predicted short loop of SpoIVFB contains two highly conserved proline residues, P132 of the NPDG motif and P135. Mutational analysis revealed that both proline residues are important for Pro-σK cleavage in Escherichia coli engineered to synthesize the proteins. Substitutions for either residue also impaired the Pro-σK interaction with SpoIVFB in copurification assays. Disulfide cross-linking experiments showed that the predicted short loop of SpoIVFB is in proximity to the N-terminal pro-sequence region (Proregion) of Pro-σK. Alanine substitutions for N129 and P132 of the SpoIVFB NPDG motif reduced cross-linking between its predicted short loop and the Proregion more than a P135A substitution. Conversely, the SpoIVFB P135A substitution reduced Pro-σK cleavage more than the N129A and P132A substitutions during sporulation of B. subtilis. We conclude that all three conserved residues of SpoIVFB are important for substrate interaction and cleavage, and we propose that P135 is necessary to position D137 to act as a zinc ligand. IMPORTANCE Intramembrane metalloproteases (IMMPs) function in numerous signaling pathways. Bacterial IMMPs govern stress responses, including the sporulation of some species, thus enhancing the virulence and persistence of pathogens. Knowledge of IMMP-substrate interactions could aid therapeutic design, but structures of IMMP·substrate complexes are unknown. We examined the interaction of the IMMP SpoIVFB with its substrate Pro-σK, whose cleavage is required for Bacillus subtilis endosporulation. We found that conserved proline residues in a short loop predicted to interrupt a SpoIVFB transmembrane segment are important for Pro-σK binding and cleavage. The corresponding residues of the Escherichia coli IMMP RseP have also been shown to be important for substrate interaction and cleavage, suggesting that this is a broadly conserved feature of IMMPs, potentially suitable as a therapeutic target.

Regulation of pro-σK activation: a key checkpoint in Bacillus subtilis sporulation

The Gram-positive bacterium Bacillus subtilis initiates the sporulation process under conditions of nutrient limitation. Here, we review related work in this field, focusing on the protein processing of the pro-σ^K activation. The purpose of this review is to illustrate the mechanism of pro-σ^K activation and provide structural insights into the regulation of spore production. Sporulation is not only important in basic science but also provides mechanistic insight for bacterial control in applications in, e.g., food industry.

Channels modestly impact compartment-specific ATP levels during Bacillus subtilis sporulation and a rise in the mother cell ATP level is not necessary for Pro-σK cleavage

Starvation of Bacillus subtilis initiates endosporulation involving formation of mother cell (MC) and forespore (FS) compartments. During engulfment, the MC membrane migrates around the FS and protein channels connect the two compartments. The channels are necessary for postengulfment FS gene expression, which relieves inhibition of SpoIVFB, an intramembrane protease that cleaves Pro-σ^K , releasing σ^K into the MC. SpoIVFB has an ATP-binding domain exposed to the MC cytoplasm, but the role of ATP in regulating Pro-σ^K cleavage has been unclear, as has the impact of the channels on MC and FS ATP levels. Using luciferase produced separately in each compartment to measure relative ATP concentrations during sporulation, we found that the MC ATP concentration rises about twofold coincident with increasing cleavage of Pro-σ^K , and the FS ATP concentration does not decline. Mutants lacking a channel protein or defective in channel protein turnover exhibited modest and varied effects on ATP levels, which suggested that low ATP concentration does not explain the lack of postengulfment FS gene expression in channel mutants. Furthermore, a rise in the MC ATP level was not necessary for Pro-σ^K cleavage by SpoIVFB, based on analysis of mutants that bypass the need for relief of SpoIVFB inhibition.

Interaction of intramembrane metalloprotease SpoIVFB with substrate Pro-σK

Intramembrane proteases (IPs) cleave membrane-associated substrates in nearly all organisms and regulate diverse processes. A better understanding of how these enzymes interact with their substrates is necessary for rational design of IP modulators. We show that interaction of Bacillus subtilis IP SpoIVFB with its substrate Pro-σ^K depends on particular residues in the interdomain linker of SpoIVFB. The linker plus either the N-terminal membrane domain or the C-terminal cystathione-β-synthase (CBS) domain of SpoIVFB was sufficient for the interaction but not for cleavage of Pro-σ^K Chemical cross-linking and mass spectrometry of purified, inactive SpoIVFB-Pro-σ^K complex indicated residues of the two proteins in proximity. A structural model of the complex was built via partial homology and by using constraints based on cross-linking data. In the model, the Proregion of Pro-σ^K loops into the membrane domain of SpoIVFB, and the rest of Pro-σ^K interacts extensively with the linker and the CBS domain of SpoIVFB. The extensive interaction is proposed to allow coordination between ATP binding by the CBS domain and Pro-σ^K cleavage by the membrane domain.

SpoIIID-mediated regulation of σK function during Clostridium difficile sporulation

The spore-forming bacterial pathogen Clostridium difficile is a leading cause of health-care-associated diarrhea worldwide. Although C. difficile spore formation is essential for disease transmission, the regulatory pathways that control this developmental process have only been partially characterized. In the well-studied spore-former Bacillus subtilis, the highly conserved σ(E) , SpoIIID and σ(K) regulatory proteins control gene expression in the mother cell to ensure proper spore formation. To define the precise requirement for SpoIIID and σ(K) during C. difficile sporulation, we analyzed spoIIID and sigK mutants using heterologous expression systems and RNA-Seq transcriptional profiling. These analyses revealed that expression of sigK from a SpoIIID-independent promoter largely bypasses the need for SpoIIID to produce heat-resistant spores. We also observed that σ(K) is active upon translation, suggesting that SpoIIID primarily functions to activate sigK. SpoIIID nevertheless plays auxiliary roles during sporulation, as it enhances levels of the exosporium morphogenetic protein CdeC in a σ(K) -dependent manner. Analyses of purified spores further revealed that SpoIIID and σ(K) control the adherence of the CotB coat protein to C. difficile spores, indicating that these proteins regulate multiple stages of spore formation. Collectively, these results highlight that diverse mechanisms control spore formation in the Firmicutes.

Developmentally-regulated excision of the SPβ prophage reconstitutes a gene required for spore envelope maturation in Bacillus subtilis

Temperate phages infect bacteria by injecting their DNA into bacterial cells, where it becomes incorporated into the host genome as a prophage. In the genome of Bacillus subtilis 168, an active prophage, SPβ, is inserted into a polysaccharide synthesis gene, spsM. Here, we show that a rearrangement occurs during sporulation to reconstitute a functional composite spsM gene by precise excision of SPβ from the chromosome. SPβ excision requires a putative site-specific recombinase, SprA, and an accessory protein, SprB. A minimized SPβ, where all the SPβ genes were deleted, except sprA and sprB, retained the SPβ excision activity during sporulation, demonstrating that sprA and sprB are necessary and sufficient for the excision. While expression of sprA was observed during vegetative growth, sprB was induced during sporulation and upon mitomycin C treatment, which triggers the phage lytic cycle. We also demonstrated that overexpression of sprB (but not of sprA) resulted in SPβ prophage excision without triggering the lytic cycle. These results suggest that sprB is the factor that controls the timing of phage excision. Furthermore, we provide evidence that spsM is essential for the addition of polysaccharides to the spore envelope. The presence of polysaccharides on the spore surface renders the spore hydrophilic in water. This property may be beneficial in allowing spores to disperse in natural environments via water flow. A similar rearrangement occurs in Bacillus amyloliquefaciens FZB42, where a SPβ-like element is excised during sporulation to reconstitute a polysaccharide synthesis gene, suggesting that this type of gene rearrangement is common in spore-forming bacteria because it can be spread by phage infection.

Integration of prophages into protein-coding sequences of the host chromosome generally results in loss of function of the interrupted gene. In the endospore-forming organism Bacillus subtilis strain 168, the SPβ prophage is inserted into a previously-uncharacterized spore polysaccharide synthesis gene, spsM. In vegetative cells, the lytic cycle is induced in response to DNA damage. In the process, SPβ is excised from the genome to form phage particles. Here, we demonstrate that SPβ excision is also a developmentally-regulated event that occurs systematically during sporulation to reconstitute a functional spsM gene. Following asymmetric division of the sporulating cell, two cellular compartments are generated, the forespore, which will mature into a spore, and the mother cell, which is essential to the process of spore maturation. Because phage excision is limited to the mother cell genome, and does not occur in the forespore genome, SPβ is an integral part of the spore genome. Thus, after the spores germinate, the vegetative cells resume growth and the SPβ prophage is propagated vertically to the progeny along with the rest of the host genome. Our results suggest that the two pathways of SPβ excision support both the phage life cycle and normal sporulation of the host cells.

Regulated proteolysis in bacterial development

Bacteria use proteases to control three types of events temporally and spatially during the processes of morphological development. These events are the destruction of regulatory proteins, activation of regulatory proteins, and production of signals. While some of these events are entirely cytoplasmic, others involve intramembrane proteolysis of a substrate, transmembrane signaling, or secretion. In some cases, multiple proteolytic events are organized into pathways, for example turnover of a regulatory protein activates a protease that generates a signal. We review well-studied and emerging examples and identify recurring themes and important questions for future research. We focus primarily on paradigms learned from studies of model organisms, but we note connections to regulated proteolytic events that govern bacterial adaptation, biofilm formation and disassembly, and pathogenesis.

Heat shock transcription factor σ32 co-opts the signal recognition particle to regulate protein homeostasis in E. coli

The bacterial heat shock transcription factor, σ32, maintains proper protein homeostasis only after it is targeted to the inner membrane by the signal recognition particle (SRP), thereby enabling integration of protein folding information from both the cytoplasm and cell membrane.

All cells must adapt to rapidly changing conditions. The heat shock response (HSR) is an intracellular signaling pathway that maintains proteostasis (protein folding homeostasis), a process critical for survival in all organisms exposed to heat stress or other conditions that alter the folding of the proteome. Yet despite decades of study, the circuitry described for responding to altered protein status in the best-studied bacterium, E. coli, does not faithfully recapitulate the range of cellular responses in response to this stress. Here, we report the discovery of the missing link. Surprisingly, we found that σ³², the central transcription factor driving the HSR, must be localized to the membrane rather than dispersed in the cytoplasm as previously assumed. Genetic analyses indicate that σ³² localization results from a protein targeting reaction facilitated by the signal recognition particle (SRP) and its receptor (SR), which together comprise a conserved protein targeting machine and mediate the cotranslational targeting of inner membrane proteins to the membrane. SRP interacts with σ³² directly and transports it to the inner membrane. Our results show that σ³² must be membrane-associated to be properly regulated in response to the protein folding status in the cell, explaining how the HSR integrates information from both the cytoplasm and bacterial cell membrane.

All cells have to adjust to frequent changes in their environmental conditions. The heat shock response is a signaling pathway critical for survival of all organisms exposed to elevated temperatures. Under such conditions, the heat shock response maintains enzymes and other proteins in a properly folded state. The mechanisms for sensing temperature and the subsequent induction of the appropriate transcriptional response have been extensively studied. Prior to this work, however, the circuitry described in the best studied bacterium E. coli could not fully explain the range of cellular responses that are observed following heat shock. We report the discovery of this missing link. Surprisingly, we find that σ³², a transcription factor that induces gene expression during heat shock, needs to be localized to the membrane, rather than being active as a soluble cytoplasmic protein as previously thought. We show that, equally surprisingly, σ³² is targeted to the membrane by the signal recognition particle (SRP) and its receptor (SR). SRP and SR constitute a conserved protein targeting machine that normally only operates on membrane and periplasmic proteins that contain identifiable signal sequences. Intriguingly, σ³² does not have any canonical signal sequence for export or membrane-integration. Our results indicate that membrane-associated σ³², not soluble cytoplasmic σ³², is the preferred target of regulatory control in response to heat shock. Our new model thus explains how protein folding status from both the cytoplasm and bacterial cell membrane can be integrated to control the heat shock response.

The spore differentiation pathway in the enteric pathogen Clostridium difficile

Endosporulation is an ancient bacterial developmental program that culminates with the differentiation of a highly resistant endospore. In the model organism Bacillus subtilis, gene expression in the forespore and in the mother cell, the two cells that participate in endospore development, is governed by cell type-specific RNA polymerase sigma subunits. σ(F) in the forespore, and σ(E) in the mother cell control early stages of development and are replaced, at later stages, by σ(G) and σ(K), respectively. Starting with σ(F), the activation of the sigma factors is sequential, requires the preceding factor, and involves cell-cell signaling pathways that operate at key morphological stages. Here, we have studied the function and regulation of the sporulation sigma factors in the intestinal pathogen Clostridium difficile, an obligate anaerobe in which the endospores are central to the infectious cycle. The morphological characterization of mutants for the sporulation sigma factors, in parallel with use of a fluorescence reporter for single cell analysis of gene expression, unraveled important deviations from the B. subtilis paradigm. While the main periods of activity of the sigma factors are conserved, we show that the activity of σ(E) is partially independent of σ(F), that σ(G) activity is not dependent on σ(E), and that the activity of σ(K) does not require σ(G). We also show that σ(K) is not strictly required for heat resistant spore formation. In all, our results indicate reduced temporal segregation between the activities of the early and late sigma factors, and reduced requirement for the σ(F)-to-σ(E), σ(E)-to-σ(G), and σ(G)-to-σ(K) cell-cell signaling pathways. Nevertheless, our results support the view that the top level of the endosporulation network is conserved in evolution, with the sigma factors acting as the key regulators of the pathway, established some 2.5 billion years ago upon its emergence at the base of the Firmicutes Phylum.

Effects of supplementary butyrate on butanol production and the metabolic switch in Clostridium beijerinckii NCIMB 8052: genome-wide transcriptional analysis with RNA-Seq

BACKGROUND

Butanol (n-butanol) has high values as a promising fuel source and chemical feedstock. Biobutanol is usually produced by the solventogenic clostridia through a typical biphasic (acidogenesis and solventogenesis phases) acetone-butanol-ethanol (ABE) fermentation process. It is well known that the acids produced in the acidogenic phase are significant and play important roles in the switch to solventogenesis. However, the mechanism that triggers the metabolic switch is still not clear.

RESULTS

Sodium butyrate (40 mM) was supplemented into the medium for the ABE fermentation with Clostridium beijerinckii NCIMB 8052. With butyrate addition (reactor R1), solvent production was triggered early in the mid-exponential phase and completed quickly in < 50 h, while in the control (reactor R2), solventogenesis was initiated during the late exponential phase and took > 90 h to complete. Butyrate supplementation led to 31% improvement in final butanol titer, 58% improvement in sugar-based yield, and 133% improvement in butanol productivity, respectively. The butanol/acetone ratio was 2.4 versus 1.8 in the control, indicating a metabolic shift towards butanol production due to butyrate addition. Genome-wide transcriptional dynamics was investigated with RNA-Seq analysis. In reactor R1, gene expression related to solventogenesis was induced about 10 hours earlier when compared to that in reactor R2. Although the early sporulation genes were induced after the onset of solventogenesis in reactor R1 (mid-exponential phase), the sporulation events were delayed and uncoupled from the solventogenesis. In contrast, in reactor R2, sporulation genes were induced at the onset of solventogenesis, and highly expressed through the solventogenesis phase. The motility genes were generally down-regulated to lower levels prior to stationary phase in both reactors. However, in reactor R2 this took much longer and gene expression was maintained at comparatively higher levels after entering stationary phase.

CONCLUSIONS

Supplemented butyrate provided feedback inhibition to butyrate formation and may be re-assimilated through the reversed butyrate formation pathway, thus resulting in an elevated level of intracellular butyryl phosphate, which may act as a phosphate donor to Spo0A and then trigger solventogenesis and sporulation events. High-resolution genome-wide transcriptional analysis with RNA-Seq revealed detailed insights into the biochemical effects of butyrate on solventogenesis related-events at the gene regulation level.

Residues in conserved loops of intramembrane metalloprotease SpoIVFB interact with residues near the cleavage site in pro-σK

Intramembrane metalloproteases (IMMPs) control critical biological processes by cleaving membrane-associated proteins within a transmembrane segment or at a site near the membrane surface. Phylogenetic analysis divides IMMPs into four groups. SpoIVFB is a group III IMMP that regulates Bacillus subtilis endospore formation by cleaving Pro-σ(K) and releasing the active sigma factor from a membrane. To elucidate the enzyme-substrate interaction, single-cysteine versions of catalytically inactive SpoIVFB and C-terminally truncated Pro-σ(K)(1-126) (which can be cleaved by active SpoIVFB) were coexpressed in Escherichia coli, and proximity was tested by disulfide cross-linking in vivo. As expected, the results provided evidence that catalytic residue Glu-44 of SpoIVFB is near the cleavage site in the substrate. Also near the cleavage site were two residues of SpoIVFB in predicted conserved loops; Pro-135 in a short loop and Val-70 in a longer loop. Pro-135 corresponds to Pro-399 of RseP, a group I IMMP, and Pro-399 was reported previously to interact with substrate near the cleavage site, suggesting a conserved interaction across IMMP subfamilies. Val-70 follows a newly recognized conserved motif, PXGG (X is a large hydrophobic residue), which is in a hydrophobic region predicted to be a membrane reentrant loop. Following the hydrophobic region is a negatively charged region that is conserved in IMMPs of groups I and III. At least two residues with a negatively charged side chain are required in this region for activity of SpoIVFB. The region exhibits other features in IMMPs of groups II and IV. Its possible roles, as well as that of the short loop, are discussed. New insights into IMMP-substrate interaction build toward understanding how IMMPs function and may facilitate manipulation of their activity.

Features of Pro-σK important for cleavage by SpoIVFB, an intramembrane metalloprotease

Intramembrane proteases regulate diverse processes by cleaving substrates within a transmembrane segment or near the membrane surface. Bacillus subtilis SpoIVFB is an intramembrane metalloprotease that cleaves Pro-σ(K) during sporulation. To elucidate features of Pro-σ(K) important for cleavage by SpoIVFB, coexpression of the two proteins in Escherichia coli was used along with cell fractionation. In the absence of SpoIVFB, a portion of the Pro-σ(K) was peripherally membrane associated. This portion was not observed in the presence of SpoIVFB, suggesting that it serves as the substrate. Deletion of Pro-σ(K) residues 2 to 8, addition of residues at its N terminus, or certain single-residue substitutions near the cleavage site impaired cleavage. Certain multiresidue substitutions near the cleavage site changed the position of cleavage, revealing preferences for a small residue preceding the cleavage site N-terminally (i.e., at the P1 position) and a hydrophobic residue at the second position following the cleavage site C-terminally (i.e., P2'). These features appear to be conserved among Pro-σ(K) orthologs. SpoIVFB did not tolerate an aromatic residue at P1 or P2' of Pro-σ(K). A Lys residue at P3' of Pro-σ(K) could not be replaced with Ala unless a Lys was provided farther C-terminally (e.g., at P9'). α-Helix-destabilizing residues near the cleavage site were not crucial for SpoIVFB to cleave Pro-σ(K). The preferences and tolerances of SpoIVFB are somewhat different from those of other intramembrane metalloproteases, perhaps reflecting differences in the interaction of the substrate with the membrane and the enzyme.

Extracytoplasmic function σ factors of the widely distributed group ECF41 contain a fused regulatory domain

Bacteria need signal transducing systems to respond to environmental changes. Next to one- and two-component systems, alternative σ factors of the extra-cytoplasmic function (ECF) protein family represent the third fundamental mechanism of bacterial signal transduction. A comprehensive classification of these proteins identified more than 40 phylogenetically distinct groups, most of which are not experimentally investigated. Here, we present the characterization of such a group with unique features, termed ECF41. Among analyzed bacterial genomes, ECF41 σ factors are widely distributed with about 400 proteins from 10 different phyla. They lack obvious anti-σ factors that typically control activity of other ECF σ factors, but their structural genes are often predicted to be cotranscribed with carboxymuconolactone decarboxylases, oxidoreductases, or epimerases based on genomic context conservation. We demonstrate for Bacillus licheniformis and Rhodobacter sphaeroides that the corresponding genes are preceded by a highly conserved promoter motif and are the only detectable targets of ECF41-dependent gene regulation. In contrast to other ECF σ factors, proteins of group ECF41 contain a large C-terminal extension, which is crucial for σ factor activity. Our data demonstrate that ECF41 σ factors are regulated by a novel mechanism based on the presence of a fused regulatory domain.

Genome-wide dynamic transcriptional profiling in Clostridium beijerinckii NCIMB 8052 using single-nucleotide resolution RNA-Seq

Background

Clostridium beijerinckii is a prominent solvent-producing microbe that has great potential for biofuel and chemical industries. Although transcriptional analysis is essential to understand gene functions and regulation and thus elucidate proper strategies for further strain improvement, limited information is available on the genome-wide transcriptional analysis for C. beijerinckii.

Results

The genome-wide transcriptional dynamics of C. beijerinckii NCIMB 8052 over a batch fermentation process was investigated using high-throughput RNA-Seq technology. The gene expression profiles indicated that the glycolysis genes were highly expressed throughout the fermentation, with comparatively more active expression during acidogenesis phase. The expression of acid formation genes was down-regulated at the onset of solvent formation, in accordance with the metabolic pathway shift from acidogenesis to solventogenesis. The acetone formation gene (adc), as a part of the sol operon, exhibited highly-coordinated expression with the other sol genes. Out of the > 20 genes encoding alcohol dehydrogenase in C. beijerinckii, Cbei_1722 and Cbei_2181 were highly up-regulated at the onset of solventogenesis, corresponding to their key roles in primary alcohol production. Most sporulation genes in C. beijerinckii 8052 demonstrated similar temporal expression patterns to those observed in B. subtilis and C. acetobutylicum, while sporulation sigma factor genes sigE and sigG exhibited accelerated and stronger expression in C. beijerinckii 8052, which is consistent with the more rapid forespore and endspore development in this strain. Global expression patterns for specific gene functional classes were examined using self-organizing map analysis. The genes associated with specific functional classes demonstrated global expression profiles corresponding to the cell physiological variation and metabolic pathway switch.

Conclusions

The results from this work provided insights for further C. beijerinckii strain improvement employing system biology-based strategies and metabolic engineering approaches.

Large crystal toxin formation in chromosomally engineered Bacillus thuringiensis subsp. aizawai due to σE accumulation

Seven distinct Bacillus thuringiensis subsp. aizawai integrants were constructed that carried the chitinase (chiBlA) gene from B. licheniformis under the control of the cry11Aa promoter and terminator with and without p19 and p20 genes. The toxicity of B. thuringiensis subsp. aizawai integrants against second-instar Spodoptera litura larvae was increased 1.8- to 4.6-fold compared to that of the wild-type strain (BTA1). Surprisingly, the enhanced toxicity in some strains of B. thuringiensis subsp. aizawai integrants (BtaP19CS, BtaP19CSter, and BtaCAT) correlated with an increase in toxin formation. To investigate the role of these genes in toxin production, the expression profiles of the toxin genes, cry1Aa and chiBlA, as well as their transcriptional regulators (sigK and sigE), were analyzed by quantitative real-time RT-PCR (qPCR) from BTA1, BtaP19CS, and BtaCAT. Expression levels of cry1Aa in these two integrants increased about 2- to 3-fold compared to those of BTA1. The expression of the transcription factor sigK also was prolonged in the integrants compared to that of the wild type; however, sigE expression was unchanged. Western blot analysis of σ(E) and σ(K) showed the prolonged accumulation of σ(E) in the integrants compared to that of BTA1, resulting in the increased synthesis of pro-σ(K) up to T(17) after the onset of sporulation in both BtaP19CS and BtaCAT compared to that of T(13) in BTA1. The results from qPCR indicate clearly that the cry1Aa promoter activity was influenced most strongly by σ(E), whereas cry11Aa depended mostly on σ(K). These results on large-crystal toxin formation with enhanced toxicity should provide useful information for the generation of strains with improved insecticidal activity.

Hierarchical evolution of the bacterial sporulation network

Genome sequencing of multiple species makes it possible to understand the main principles behind the evolution of developmental regulatory networks. It is especially interesting to analyze the evolution of well-defined model systems in which conservation patterns can be directly correlated with the functional roles of various network components. Endospore formation (sporulation), extensively studied in Bacillus subtilis, is driven by such a model bacterial network of cellular development and differentiation. In this review, we analyze the evolution of the sporulation network in multiple endospore-forming bacteria. Importantly, the network evolution is not random but primarily follows the hierarchical organization and functional logic of the sporulation process. Specifically, the sporulation sigma factors and the master regulator of sporulation, Spo0A, are conserved in all considered spore-formers. The sequential activation of these global regulators is also strongly conserved. The feed-forward loops, which are likely used to fine-tune waves of gene expression within regulatory modules, show an intermediate level of conservation. These loops are less conserved than the sigma factors but significantly more than the structural sporulation genes, which form the lowest level in the functional and evolutionary hierarchy of the sporulation network. Interestingly, in spore-forming bacteria, gene regulation is more conserved than gene presence for sporulation genes, while the opposite is true for non-sporulation genes. The observed patterns suggest that, by understanding the functional organization of a developmental network in a model organism, it is possible to understand the logic behind the evolution of this network in multiple related species.

A previously unidentified sigma factor and two accessory proteins regulate oxalate decarboxylase expression in Bacillus subtilis

We have investigated the function of a cell envelope stress-inducible gene, yvrI, which encodes a 22.5 kDa protein that includes a predicted sigma(70) region 4 domain, but lacks an apparent region 2 domain. YvrI interacts with RNA polymerase and overexpression of YvrI results in induction of OxdC, an oxalate decarboxylase maximally expressed under low-pH conditions. We have used microarray-based analyses to define the YvrI regulon. YvrI is required for the transcription of three operons (oxdC-yvrL, yvrJ and yvrI-yvrHa) each of which is preceded by a highly similar promoter sequence. Activation of these promoters requires both YvrI and the product of the second gene in the yvrI-yvrHa operon, YvrHa. YvrI and YvrHa together allow recognition of the oxdC promoter, stimulate DNA melting and activate transcription by core RNA polymerase. Together, these results suggest that YvrI is a previously unrecognized sigma factor in Bacillus subtilis and that the 9.5 kDa YvrHa protein acts as a required co-activator of transcription. A yvrL deletion results in the upregulation of YvrI activity suggesting that YvrL is a negative regulator of YvrI-dependent transcription, possibly functioning as an anti-sigma factor.

One perturbation of the mother cell gene regulatory network suppresses the effects of another during sporulation of Bacillus subtilis

In the mother cell of sporulating Bacillus subtilis, a regulatory network functions to control gene expression. Four transcription factors act sequentially in the order sigma(E), SpoIIID, sigma(K), GerE. sigma(E) and sigma(K) direct RNA polymerase to transcribe different regulons. SpoIIID and GerE are DNA-binding proteins that activate or repress transcription of many genes. Several negative regulatory loops add complexity to the network. First, transcriptionally active sigma(K) RNA polymerase inhibits early sporulation gene expression, resulting in reduced accumulation of sigma(E) and SpoIIID late during sporulation. Second, GerE represses sigK transcription, reducing sigma(K) accumulation about twofold. Third, SpoIIID represses cotC, which encodes a spore coat protein, delaying its transcription by sigma(K) RNA polymerase. Partially circumventing the first feedback loop, by engineering cells to maintain the SpoIIID level late during sporulation, causes spore defects. Here, the effects of circumventing the second feedback loop, by mutating the GerE binding sites in the sigK promoter region, are reported. Accumulation of pro-sigma(K) and sigma(K) was increased, but no spore defects were detected. Expression of sigma(K)-dependent reporter fusions was altered, increasing the expression of gerE-lacZ and cotC-lacZ and decreasing the expression of cotD-lacZ. Because these effects on gene expression were opposite those observed when the SpoIIID level was maintained late during sporulation, cells were engineered to both maintain the SpoIIID level and have elevated sigK expression late during sporulation. This restored the expression of sigma(K)-dependent reporters to wild-type levels, and no spore defects were observed. Hence, circumventing the second feedback loop suppressed the effects of perturbing the first feedback loop. By feeding information back into the network, these two loops appear to optimize target gene expression and increase network robustness. Circumventing the third regulatory loop, by engineering cells to express cotC about 2 h earlier than normal, did not cause a detectable spore defect.

Maintaining the transcription factor SpoIIID level late during sporulation causes spore defects in Bacillus subtilis

During sporulation of Bacillus subtilis, four regulatory proteins act in the order sigma(E), SpoIIID, sigma(K), and GerE to temporally control gene expression in the mother cell. sigma(E) and sigma(K) work sequentially with core RNA polymerase to transcribe different sets of genes. SpoIIID and GerE are small, sequence-specific DNA-binding proteins that activate or repress transcription of many genes. Previous studies showed that transcriptionally active sigma(K) RNA polymerase inhibits early mother cell gene expression, reducing accumulation of SpoIIID late in sporulation. Here, the effects of perturbing the mother cell gene regulatory network by maintaining the SpoIIID level late during sporulation are reported. Persistent expression was obtained by fusing spoIIID to the sigma(K)-controlled gerE promoter on a multicopy plasmid. Fewer heat- and lysozyme-resistant spores were produced by the strain with persistent spoIIID expression, but the number of spores resistant to organic solvents was unchanged, as was their germination ability. Transmission electron microscopy showed structural defects in the spore coat. Reporter fusions to sigma(K)-dependent promoters showed lower expression of gerE and cotC and higher expression of cotD. Altered expression of cot genes, which encode spore coat proteins, may account for the spore structural defects. These results suggest that one role of negative feedback by sigma(K) RNA polymerase on early mother cell gene expression is to lower the level of SpoIIID late during sporulation in order to allow normal expression of genes in the sigma(K) regulon.

Bacillus subtilis aconitase is required for efficient late-sporulation gene expression

Bacillus subtilis aconitase, encoded by the citB gene, is homologous to the bifunctional eukaryotic protein IRP-1 (iron regulatory protein 1). Like IRP-1, B. subtilis aconitase is both an enzyme and an RNA binding protein. In an attempt to separate the two activities of aconitase, the C-terminal region of the B. subtilis citB gene product was mutagenized. The resulting strain had high catalytic activity but was defective in sporulation. The defect was at a late stage of sporulation, specifically affecting expression of sigmaK-dependent genes, many of which are important for spore coat assembly and require transcriptional activation by GerE. Accumulation of gerE mRNA and GerE protein was delayed in the aconitase mutant strain. Pure B. subtilis aconitase bound to the 3' untranslated region of gerE mRNA in in vitro gel mobility shift assays, strongly suggesting that aconitase RNA binding activity may stabilize gerE mRNA in order to allow efficient GerE synthesis and proper timing of spore coat assembly.

Engulfment-regulated proteolysis of SpoIIQ: evidence that dual checkpoints control sigma activity

During Bacillus subtilis sporulation, the engulfment checkpoint is thought to directly regulate late forespore transcription but to indirectly regulate late mother cell transcription, via the sigmaG-produced protease SpoIVB. We here demonstrate that SpoIIQ is subject to sigmaG-independent, but engulfment-dependent, proteolysis that depends on SpoIVB. Thus, SpoIVB produced before engulfment supports some SpoIVB-dependent events, suggesting that its activity or access to substrates must be regulated by engulfment. Furthermore, a mutation (bofA) that allows sigmaK to be active without sigmaG does not allow sigmaK activity in engulfment mutants, although the pro-sigmaK processing enzyme (SpoIVFB) is localized to the septum in engulfment mutants, suggesting that engulfment comprises a second checkpoint for sigmaK Finally, we find that SpoIIQ and another protein required for sigmaG activity (SpoIIIAH), which directly interact and assemble helical structures around the forespore, recruit the sigmaK-processing enzyme SpoIVFB to the forespore and these structures. We suggest that these foci serve a synapse-like role, allowing engulfment to simultaneously control both sigmaG and sigmaK, and integrating multiple checkpoints and signalling pathways.

Serine proteases from two cell types target different components of a complex that governs regulated intramembrane proteolysis of pro-sigmaK during Bacillus subtilis development

Upon starvation Bacillus subtilis undergoes a developmental process involving creation of two cell types, the mother cell and forespore. A signal in the form of a serine protease, SpoIVB, is secreted from the forespore and leads to regulated intramembrane proteolysis (RIP) of pro-sigmaK, releasing active sigmaK into the mother cell. RIP of pro-sigmaK is carried out by a membrane-embedded metalloprotease, SpoIVFB, which is inactive when bound by BofA and SpoIVFA. We have investigated the mechanism by which this complex is activated. By expressing components of the signalling pathway in Escherichia coli, we reconstructed complete inhibition of pro-sigmaK RIP by BofA and SpoIVFA, and found that SpoIVB serine protease activity could partially restore RIP, apparently by targeting SpoIVFA. Pulse-chase experiments demonstrated that SpoIVFA synthesized early during B. subtilis sporulation is lost in a SpoIVB-dependent fashion, coincident with the onset of pro-sigmaK RIP, supporting the idea that SpoIVB targets SpoIVFA to trigger RIP of pro-sigmaK. Loss of BofA depended not only on SpoIVB, but also on CtpB, a serine protease secreted from the mother cell. CtpB appeared to cleave BofA near its C-terminus upon coexpression in E. coli, and purified CtpB degraded BofA. We propose that RIP of pro-sigmaK involves a three-step proteolytic cascade in which SpoIVB first cleaves SpoIVFA, CtpB then cleaves BofA and finally SpoIVFB cleaves pro-sigmaK.

The Structure of Bypass of Forespore C, an Intercompartmental Signaling Factor during Sporulation in Bacillus

Sporulation in Bacillus subtilis begins with an asymmetric cell division giving rise to smaller forespore and larger mother cell compartments. Different programs of gene expression are subsequently directed by compartment-specific RNA polymerase sigma-factors. In the final stages, spore coat proteins are synthesized in the mother cell under the control of RNA polymerase containing sigma(K), (Esigma(K)). sigma(K) is synthesized as an inactive zymogen, pro-sigma(K), which is activated by proteolytic cleavage. Processing of pro-sigma(K) is performed by SpoIVFB, a metalloprotease that resides in a complex with SpoIVFA and bypass of forespore (Bof)A in the outer forespore membrane. Ensuring coordination of events taking place in the two compartments, pro-sigma(K) processing in the mother cell is delayed until appropriate signals are received from the forespore. Cell-cell signaling is mediated by SpoIVB and BofC, which are expressed in the forespore and secreted to the intercompartmental space where they regulate pro-sigma(K) processing by mechanisms that are not yet fully understood. Here we present the three-dimensional structure of BofC determined by solution state NMR. BofC is a monomer made up of two domains. The N-terminal domain, containing a four-stranded beta-sheet onto one face of which an alpha-helix is packed, closely resembles the third immunoglobulin-binding domain of protein G from Streptococcus. The C-terminal domain contains a three-stranded beta-sheet and three alpha-helices in a novel domain topology. The sequence connecting the domains contains a conserved DISP motif to which mutations that affect BofC activity map. Possible roles for BofC in the sigma(K) checkpoint are discussed in the light of sequence and structure comparisons.

Substrate requirements for regulated intramembrane proteolysis of Bacillus subtilis pro-sigmaK

During sporulation of Bacillus subtilis, pro-sigmaK is activated by regulated intramembrane proteolysis (RIP) in response to a signal from the forespore. RIP of pro-sigmaK removes its prosequence (amino acids 1 to 20), releasing sigmaK from the outer forespore membrane into the mother cell cytoplasm, in a reaction catalyzed by SpoIVFB, a metalloprotease in the S2P family of intramembrane-cleaving proteases. The requirements for pro-sigmaK to serve as a substrate for RIP were investigated by producing C-terminally truncated pro-sigmaK fused at different points to the green fluorescent protein (GFP) or hexahistidine in sporulating B. subtilis or in Escherichia coli engineered to coexpress SpoIVFB. Nearly half of pro-sigmaK (amino acids 1 to 117), including part of sigma factor region 2.4, was required for RIP of pro-sigmaK-GFP chimeras in sporulating B. subtilis. Likewise, pro-sigmaK-hexahistidine chimeras demonstrated that the N-terminal 117 amino acids of pro-sigma(K) are sufficient for RIP, although the N-terminal 126 amino acids, which includes all of region 2.4, allowed much better accumulation of the chimeric protein in sporulating B. subtilis and more efficient processing by SpoIVFB in E. coli. In contrast to the requirements for RIP, a much smaller N-terminal segment (amino acids 1 to 27) was sufficient for membrane localization of a pro-sigmaK-GFP chimera. Addition or deletion of five amino acids near the N terminus allowed accurate processing of pro-sigmaK, ruling out a mechanism in which SpoIVFB measures the distance from the N terminus to the cleavage site. A charge reversal at position 13 (substituting glutamate for lysine) reduced accumulation of pro-sigmaK and prevented detectable RIP by SpoIVFB. These results elucidate substrate requirements for RIP of pro-sigmaK by SpoIVFB and may have implications for substrate recognition by other S2P family members.

The program of gene transcription for a single differentiating cell type during sporulation in Bacillus subtilis

Asymmetric division during sporulation by Bacillus subtilis generates a mother cell that undergoes a 5-h program of differentiation. The program is governed by a hierarchical cascade consisting of the transcription factors: σ^E, σ^K, GerE, GerR, and SpoIIID. The program consists of the activation and repression of 383 genes. The σ^E factor turns on 262 genes, including those for GerR and SpoIIID. These DNA-binding proteins downregulate almost half of the genes in the σ^E regulon. In addition, SpoIIID turns on ten genes, including genes involved in the appearance of σ^K_. Next, σ^K activates 75 additional genes, including that for GerE. This DNA-binding protein, in turn, represses half of the genes that had been activated by σ^K while switching on a final set of 36 genes. Evidence is presented that repression and activation contribute to proper morphogenesis. The program of gene expression is driven forward by its hierarchical organization and by the repressive effects of the DNA-binding proteins. The logic of the program is that of a linked series of feed-forward loops, which generate successive pulses of gene transcription. Similar regulatory circuits could be a common feature of other systems of cellular differentiation.

A comprehensive genomic analysis of sporulation in Bacillus subtilis reveals a coordinated program of gene activation and repression, which involves 383 genes

spoIVH (ykvV), a requisite cortex formation gene, is expressed in both sporulating compartments of Bacillus subtilis

It is well known that the ykvU-ykvV operon is under the regulation of the sigma(E)-associated RNA polymerase (Esigma(E)). In our study, we observed that ykvV is transcribed together with the upstream ykvU gene by Esigma(E) in the mother cell and monocistronically under Esigma(G) control in the forespore. Interestingly, alternatively expressed ykvV in either the forespore or the mother cell increased the sporulation efficiency in the ykvV background. Studies show that the YkvV protein is a member of the thioredoxin superfamily and also contains a putative Sec-type secretion signal at the N terminus. We observed efficient sporulation in a mutant strain obtained by replacing the putative signal peptide of YkvV with the secretion signal sequence of SleB, indicating that the putative signal sequence is essential for spore formation. These results suggest that YkvV is capable of being transported by the putative Sec-type signal sequence into the space between the double membranes surrounding the forespore. The ability of ykvV expression in either compartment to complement is indeed intriguing and further introduces a new dimension to the genetics of B. subtilis spore formation. Furthermore, electron microscopic observation revealed a defective cortex in the ykvV disruptant. In addition, the expression levels of sigma(K)-directed genes significantly decreased despite normal sigma(G) activity in the ykvV mutant. However, immunoblotting with the anti-sigma(K) antibody showed that pro-sigma(K) was normally processed in the ykvV mutant, indicating that YkvV plays an important role in cortex formation, consistent with recent reports. We therefore propose that ykvV should be renamed spoIVH.

The PDZ domain of the SpoIVB transmembrane signaling protein enables cis-trans interactions involving multiple partners leading to the activation of the pro-sigmaK processing complex in Bacillus subtilis

In sporulating cells of Bacillus subtilis, the serine peptidase SpoIVB is the essential component of a transmembrane signaling cascade between the two intracellular compartments (forespore and mother cell) that leads to activation of the sigmaK transcription factor in the mother cell chamber. This regulatory process, referred to as the sigmaK checkpoint, is essential for ensuring proper development of the spore and introduces an appropriate level of fidelity to the developmental process. This work unravels the signaling process and establishes how SpoIVB interacts with other protein partners in the sigmaK checkpoint. SpoIVB is synthesized as a zymogen that is autoproteolytically activated and carries a PDZ domain that is responsible for at least three distinct binding reactions, a phenomenon not previously demonstrated for an individual PDZ domain. First, binding to the SpoIVB NH2 terminus to maintain the protein in its zymogen form. Second, following secretion across a spore membrane, binding in trans to the COOH terminus of another SpoIVB molecule. Binding in trans facilitates the first cleavage event of SpoIVB near the NH2 terminus releasing it from the inner forespore membrane. We show that at least two further cis cleavage events occur at specific sites near the NH2 terminus after which the PDZ domain targets SpoIVB to the pro-sigmaK processing complex in the outer forespore membrane. Specifically, SpoIVB binds to the COOH terminus of BofA. In turn, this allows SpoIVB to cleave the COOH terminus of SpoIVFA an event pivotal to activating the SpoIVFB zinc metalloprotease by disruption of the heteroligomeric pro-sigmaK complex.

Compartmentalization of gene expression during Bacillus subtilis spore formation

Gene expression in members of the family Bacillaceae becomes compartmentalized after the distinctive, asymmetrically located sporulation division. It involves complete compartmentalization of the activities of sporulation-specific sigma factors, sigma(F) in the prespore and then sigma(E) in the mother cell, and then later, following engulfment, sigma(G) in the prespore and then sigma(K) in the mother cell. The coupling of the activation of sigma(F) to septation and sigma(G) to engulfment is clear; the mechanisms are not. The sigma factors provide the bare framework of compartment-specific gene expression. Within each sigma regulon are several temporal classes of genes, and for key regulators, timing is critical. There are also complex intercompartmental regulatory signals. The determinants for sigma(F) regulation are assembled before septation, but activation follows septation. Reversal of the anti-sigma(F) activity of SpoIIAB is critical. Only the origin-proximal 30% of a chromosome is present in the prespore when first formed; it takes approximately 15 min for the rest to be transferred. This transient genetic asymmetry is important for prespore-specific sigma(F) activation. Activation of sigma(E) requires sigma(F) activity and occurs by cleavage of a prosequence. It must occur rapidly to prevent the formation of a second septum. sigma(G) is formed only in the prespore. SpoIIAB can block sigma(G) activity, but SpoIIAB control does not explain why sigma(G) is activated only after engulfment. There is mother cell-specific excision of an insertion element in sigK and sigma(E)-directed transcription of sigK, which encodes pro-sigma(K). Activation requires removal of the prosequence following a sigma(G)-directed signal from the prespore.

BofA protein inhibits intramembrane proteolysis of pro-sigmaK in an intercompartmental signaling pathway during Bacillus subtilis sporulation

Bacillus subtilis is a bacterium that undergoes a developmental program of sporulation in response to starvation. At the core of the program are sigma factors, whose regulated spatiotemporal activation controls much of the gene expression. Activation of pro-sigma(K) in the mother cell compartment involves regulated intramembrane proteolysis (RIP) in response to a signal from the forespore. RIP is a poorly understood process that is conserved in prokaryotes and eukaryotes. Here, we report a powerful system for studying RIP of pro-sigma(K). Escherichia coli was engineered to coexpress the putative membrane-embedded metalloprotease SpoIVFB with pro-sigma(K) and potential inhibitors of RIP. Overproduction of SpoIVFB and pro-sigma(K) in E. coli allowed accurate and abundant proteolytic processing of pro-sigma(K) with the characteristics expected for SpoIVFB acting as an intramembrane-cleaving protease (I-Clip). Coexpression of BofA in this system led to formation of a BofA-SpoIVFB complex and marked inhibition of pro-sigma(K) processing. Mutational analysis identified amino acids in BofA that are necessary for complex formation and inhibition of processing, leading us to propose that BofA inhibits SpoIVFB metalloprotease activity by providing a metal ligand, analogous to the cysteine switch mechanism of matrix metalloprotease regulation. The approach described herein should be applicable to studies of other RIP events and amenable to developing in vitro assays for I-Clips.

SpoIVB-mediated cleavage of SpoIVFA could provide the intercellular signal to activate processing of Pro-sigmaK in Bacillus subtilis

SpoIVB is the critical determinant for intercompartmental signalling of pro-sigmaK processing during sporulation in Bacillus subtilis. We show here that the SpoIVB serine peptidase can cleave the SpoIVFA protein, which is one component of the pro-sigmaK processing complex. SpoIVFA has been shown elsewhere (Rudner, D.Z., and Losick, R., 2002, Genes Dev 16: 1007-1018) to tether BofA and SpoIVFB in a membrane-embedded heteroligomeric complex in which BofA directly inhibits the activity of SpoIVFB. Cleavage of SpoIVFA would provide the necessary signal to dissolve this complex and release BofA-mediated inhibition on the zinc metalloprotease, SpoIVFB, that is responsible for cleaving pro-sigmaK to its mature form. We also show that the SpoIVB PDZ domain is required for self-recognition and trans cleavage of SpoIVB and is probably also used to target an internal motif within the C-terminal region of SpoIVFA exposed in the space between the inner and outer forespore membranes. This work reveals the mechanism of intercompartmental signalling and provides a unified model as to how sigmaK-directed gene expression in the mother cell is co-ordinated with events in the forespore chamber.

Efficient sporulation in Clostridium difficile requires disruption of the sigmaK gene

A 14.6 kb prophage-like insertion, termed skinCd, was found to interrupt the sigK gene, which encodes an RNA polymerase sigma factor essential for sporulation, in six strains of Clostridium difficile. Until now, Bacillus subtilis was the only spore-former shown to carry such an insertion, and the presence of the insertion is not required for efficient sporulation in this organism. The B. subtilis and C. difficile skin elements proved to be divergent in sequence, inserted at different sites within the sigK gene and in opposite orientations. The skinCd element was excised from the chromosome specifically during sporulation, forming a circular molecule. Two natural isolates of C. difficile lacked the skinCd element and were defective in sporulation. When a merodiploid strain was created that carries both interrupted and uninterrupted versions of the sigK gene, the cells became Spo-, showing that the uninterrupted gene is dominant and inhibits sporulation. C. difficile sigK genes, whether skinCd+ or skinCd-, lack the N-terminal pro-sequence found in all other sigK genes studied to date. Thus, regulated excision of skinCd appears to be a critical mechanism for achieving proper temporal activation of sigmaK.

Forespore signaling is necessary for pro-sigmaK processing during Bacillus subtilis sporulation despite the loss of SpoIVFA upon translational arrest

The sigmaK checkpoint coordinates gene expression in the mother cell with signaling from the forespore during Bacillus subtilis sporulation. The signaling pathway involves SpoIVB, a serine peptidase produced in the forespore, which is believed to cross the innermost membrane surrounding the forespore and activate a complex of proteins, including BofA, SpoIVFA, and SpoIVFB, located in the outermost membrane surrounding the forespore. Activation of the complex allows proteolytic processing of pro-sigmaK, and the resulting sigmaK RNA polymerase transcribes genes in the mother cell. To investigate activation of the pro-sigmaK processing complex, the level of SpoIVFA in extracts of sporulating cells was examined by Western blot analysis. The SpoIVFA level decreased when pro-sigmaK processing began during sporulation. In extracts of a spoIVB mutant defective in forespore signaling, the SpoIVFA level failed to decrease normally and no processing of pro-sigmaK was observed. Although these results are consistent with a model in which SpoIVFA inhibits processing until the SpoIVB-mediated signal is received from the forespore, we discovered that loss of SpoIVFA was insufficient to allow processing under certain conditions, including static incubation of the culture and continued shaking after the addition of inhibitors of oxidative phosphorylation or translation. Under these conditions, loss of SpoIVFA was independent of spoIVB. The inability to process pro-sigmaK under these conditions was not due to loss of SpoIVFB, the putative processing enzyme, or to a requirement for ongoing synthesis of pro-sigmaK. Rather, it was found that the requirements for shaking of the culture, for oxidative phosphorylation, and for translation could be bypassed by mutations that uncouple processing from dependence on forespore signaling. This suggests that ongoing translation is normally required for efficient pro-sigmaK processing because synthesis of the SpoIVB signal protein is needed to activate the processing complex. When translation is blocked, synthesis of SpoIVB ceases, and the processing complex remains inactive despite the loss of SpoIVFA. Taken together, the results suggest that SpoIVB signaling activates the processing complex by performing another function in addition to causing loss of SpoIVFA or by causing loss of SpoIVFA in a different way than when translation is blocked. The results also demonstrate that the processing machinery can function in the absence of translation or an electrochemical gradient across membranes.

Morphological coupling in development: lessons from prokaryotes

At certain junctures in development, gene transcription is coupled to the completion of landmark morphological events. We refer to this dependence on morphogenesis for gene expression as "morphological coupling." Three examples of morphological coupling in prokaryotes are reviewed in which the activation of a transcription factor is tied to the assembly of a critically important structure in development.

Amino acids in the Bacillus subtilis morphogenetic protein SpoIVA with roles in spore coat and cortex formation

Bacterial spores are protected from the environment by a proteinaceous coat and a layer of specialized peptidoglycan called the cortex. In Bacillus subtilis, the attachment of the coat to the spore surface and the synthesis of the cortex both depend on the spore protein SpoIVA. To identify functionally important amino acids of SpoIVA, we generated and characterized strains bearing random point mutations of spoIVA that result in defects in coat and cortex formation. One mutant resembles the null mutant, as sporulating cells of this strain lack the cortex and the coat forms a swirl in the surrounding cytoplasm instead of a shell around the spore. We identified a second class of six mutants with a partial defect in spore assembly. In sporulating cells of these strains, we frequently observed swirls of mislocalized coat in addition to a coat surrounding the spore, in the same cell. Using immunofluorescence microscopy, we found that in two of these mutants, SpoIVA fails to localize to the spore, whereas in the remaining strains, localization is largely normal. These mutations identify amino acids involved in targeting of SpoIVA to the spore and in attachment of the coat. We also isolated a large set of mutants producing spores that are unable to maintain the dehydrated state. Analysis of one mutant in this class suggests that spores of this strain accumulate reduced levels of peptidoglycan with an altered structure.

BofC negatively regulates SpoIVB-mediated signalling in the Bacillus subtilis sigmaK-checkpoint

The BofC protein acts negatively on intercompartmental signalling of pro-sigma(K) processing in the sigma(K)-checkpoint of Bacillus subtilis. Signalling is brought about by the SpoIVB protein, which is synthesized in the forespore and initiates proteolytic processing of pro-sigmaK to its mature and active form in the opposed mother cell chamber of the developing cell. We have shown here that BofC, like SpoIVB, is secreted across the inner forespore membrane and, from the analysis of a bofC deletion and insertion mutant, is likely to interact with SpoIVB. In the absence of BofC, the amount of SpoIVB found in sporulating cells is substantially reduced, although SpoIVB is still able to activate proteolysis of pro-sigma(K). Conversely, in the absence of SpoIVB, the levels of BofC accumulate suggesting that the fate of each molecule is dependent upon their mutual interaction. Our results suggest that BofC could maintain SpoIVB in a stable but inactive form. Supporting this, we have shown that overproduction of BofC inhibits SpoIVB autoproteolysis and leads to a delay in proteolytic cleavage of pro-sigma(K). Based on our work here, we have proposed a model for BofC's functional role in intercompartmental signalling.

Evidence that SpoIVFB is a novel type of membrane metalloprotease governing intercompartmental communication during Bacillus subtilis sporulation

Processing of pro-sigma(K) in the mother cell compartment of sporulating Bacillus subtilis involves SpoIVFB and is governed by a signal from the forespore. SpoIVFB has an HEXXH motif characteristic of metalloproteases embedded in one of its transmembrane segments. Several conservative single amino acid changes in the HEXXH motif abolished function. However, changing the glutamic acid residue to aspartic acid, or changing the isoleucine residue that precedes the motif to proline, permitted SpoIVFB function. Only one other putative metalloprotease, site 2 protease has been shown to tolerate aspartic acid rather than glutamic acid in its HEXXH sequence. Site 2 protease and SpoIVFB share a second region of similarity with a family of putative membrane metalloproteases. A conservative change in this region of SpoIVFB abolished function. Interestingly, SpoIVFA increased the accumulation of certain mutant SpoIVFB proteins but was unnecessary for accumulation of wild-type SpoIVFB.

Combined action of two transcription factors regulates genes encoding spore coat proteins of Bacillus subtilis

During sporulation of Bacillus subtilis, spore coat proteins encoded by cot genes are expressed in the mother cell and deposited on the forespore. Transcription of the cotB, cotC, and cotX genes by final sigma(K) RNA polymerase is activated by a small, DNA-binding protein called GerE. The promoter region of each of these genes has two GerE binding sites. 5' deletions that eliminated the more upstream GerE site decreased expression of lacZ fused to cotB and cotX by approximately 80% and 60%, respectively but had no effect on cotC-lacZ expression. The cotC-lacZ fusion was expressed later during sporulation than the other two fusions. Primer extension analysis confirmed that cotB mRNA increases first during sporulation, followed by cotX and cotC mRNAs over a 2-h period. In vitro transcription experiments suggest that the differential pattern of cot gene expression results from the combined action of GerE and another transcription factor, SpoIIID. A low concentration of GerE activated cotB transcription by final sigma(K) RNA polymerase, whereas a higher concentration was needed to activate transcription of cotX or cotC. SpoIIID at low concentration repressed cotC transcription, whereas a higher concentration only partially repressed cotX transcription and had little effect on cotB transcription. DNase I footprinting showed that SpoIIID binds strongly to two sites in the cotC promoter region, binds weakly to one site in the cotX promoter, and does not bind specifically to cotB. We propose that late in sporulation the rising level of GerE and the falling level of SpoIIID, together with the position and affinity of binding sites for these transcription factors in cot gene promoters, dictates the timing and level of spore coat protein synthesis, ensuring optimal assembly of the protein shell on the forespore surface.

Membrane topology of the Bacillus subtilis pro-sigma(K) processing complex

Activation of the final sporulation-specific transcription factor, sigma(K), is regulated by a signal emanating from the forespore which interacts with the pro-sigma(K) processing complex, comprising SpoIVFA, BofA, and the pro-sigma(K) processing protease, SpoIVFB. Mature sigma(K) then directs late gene expression in the parental compartment of the developing sporangial cell. The nature of this complex and how it is activated to process pro-sigma(K) are not understood. All three proteins are predicted to be integral membrane proteins. Here, we have analyzed the membrane topology of SpoIVFA and SpoIVFB by constructing chimeric forms of spoIVFA and spoIVFB with the complementary reporters phoA and lacZ and analyzing activity in Escherichia coli. SpoIVFA was found to have a single transmembrane-spanning domain, while SpoIVFB was shown to have six transmembrane-spanning domains (6-transmembrane configuration). Further, SpoIVFA is required to stabilize SpoIVFB in the membrane. SpoIVFB was shown to have a 4-transmembrane configuration when expressed on its own but was found to have a 6-transmembrane configuration when coexpressed with SpoIVFA, while BofA had a positive effect on the assembly of both SpoIVFA and SpoIVFB. The single transmembrane domain of SpoIVFA (approximately residues 73 to 90) was shown to be the principle determinant in stabilizing the 6-transmembrane configuration of SpoIVFB. Although the bofB8 allele, which uncouples the sigma(K) checkpoint, did not appear to promote a conformational change from a 6- to 4-transmembrane configuration of SpoIVFB (apparently ruling out a profound conformational change as the mechanism of activating SpoIVFB proteolytic activity), instability of SpoIVFB may be an important factor in SpoIVFB-mediated processing of pro-sigma(K).

A family of membrane-embedded metalloproteases involved in regulated proteolysis of membrane-associated transcription factors

We present evidence that the sporulation protein SpoIVFB of Bacillus subtilis is a member of a newly recognized family of metalloproteases that have catalytic centers adjacent to or within the membrane. SpoIVFB is required for converting the membrane-associated precursor protein, pro-sigma(K), to the mature and active transcription factor sigma(K) by proteolytic removal of an N-terminal extension of 20 amino acids. SpoIVFB and other family members share the conserved sequence HEXXH, a hallmark of metalloproteases, as well as a second conserved motif NPDG, which is unique to the family. Both motifs, which are expected to form the catalytic center of the protease, overlap hydrophobic segments that are predicted to be separate transmembrane domains. The only other characterized member of this family of membrane-embedded metalloproteases is the mammalian Site-2 protease (S2P), which is required for the intramembrane cleavage of the eukaryotic transcription factor sterol regulatory element binding protein (SREBP). We report that amino acid substitutions in the two conserved motifs of SpoIVFB impair pro-sigma(K) processing and sigma(K)-directed gene expression during sporulation. These results and those from a similar analysis of S2P support the interpretation that both proteins are founding members of a family of metalloproteases involved in the activation of membrane-associated transcription factors. Thus, the pathways that govern the activation of the prokaryotic transcription factor pro-sigma(K) and the mammalian transcription factor SREBP not only are analogous but also use processing enzymes with strikingly homologous features.

Identification of new sigma K-dependent promoters using an in vitro transcription system derived from Bacillus subtilis

In Bacillus subtilis, the genes that depend on sigma K-RNA polymerase for their transcription are expressed in the mother cell compartment at later stages of sporulation. More than a dozen genes belonging to the sigma K regulon have been identified. Here I describe the identification of two additional promoters under the control of sigma K-RNA polymerase. Using a set of histidine-tagged RNA polymerases prepared from cells harvested at various times during the course of growth and sporulation (Fujita, M., Sadaie, Y., 1998. Gene 221, 185-190), transcription initiated from putative promoter sequences on a number of DNA fragments, as inferred from genome sequencing, was examined in vitro. One of these showed sigma K-dependent transcription. For further characterization of transcription initiated from this site, in vitro transcription analysis was performed using RNA polymerase holoenzyme reconstituted from purified sigma K and core RNA polymerase. Two sigma K-dependent promoters, yfhP P1 and yfhP P2, separated by a distance of about 15 bp, were thereby identified. These promoters are located immediately upstream of the yfhP gene that encodes a protein of unknown function consisting of 327 amino acids residues. The promoter strength, the rate of open complex formation and the RNA polymerase binding affinity were examined for these two promoters in comparison with other known sigma K-dependent promoters, gerE and cotD. The promoter strength displayed was in the order of gerE > cotD > yfhP P2 > yfhP P1.

Sigma factor displacement from RNA polymerase during Bacillus subtilis sporulation

As Bacillus subtilis proceeds through sporulation, the principal vegetative cell sigma subunit (sigma(A)) persists in the cell but is replaced in the extractable RNA polymerase (RNAP) by sporulation-specific sigma factors. To explore how this holoenzyme changeover might occur, velocity centrifugation techniques were used in conjunction with Western blot analyses to monitor the associations of RNAP with sigma(A) and two mother cell sigma factors, sigma(E) and sigma(K), which successively replace sigma(A) on RNAP. Although the relative abundance of sigma(A) with respect to RNAP remained virtually unchanged during sporulation, the percentage of the detectable sigma(A) which cosedimented with RNAP fell from approximately 50% at the onset of sporulation (T(0)) to 2 to 8% by 3 h into the process (T(3)). In a strain that failed to synthesize sigma(E), the first of the mother cell-specific sigma factors, approximately 40% of the sigma(A) remained associated with RNAP at T(3). The level of sigma(A)-RNAP cosedimentation dropped to less than 10% in a strain which synthesized a sigma(E) variant (sigma(ECR119)) that could bind to RNAP but was unable to direct sigma(E)-dependent transcription. The E-sigma(E)-to-E-sigma(K) changeover was characterized by both the displacement of sigma(E) from RNAP and the disappearance of sigma(E) from the cell. Analyses of extracts from wild-type and mutant B. subtilis showed that the sigma(K) protein is required for the displacement of sigma(E) from RNAP and also confirmed that sigma(K) is needed for the loss of the sigma(E) protein. The results indicate that the successive appearance of mother cell sigma factors, but not necessarily their activities, is an important element in the displacement of preexisting sigma factors from RNAP. It suggests that competition for RNAP by consecutive sporulation sigma factors may be an important feature of the holoenzyme changeovers that occur during sporulation.

sigmaK can negatively regulate sigE expression by two different mechanisms during sporulation of Bacillus subtilis

Temporal and spatial gene regulation during Bacillus subtilis sporulation involves the activation and inactivation of multiple sigma subunits of RNA polymerase in a cascade. In the mother cell compartment of sporulating cells, expression of the sigE gene, encoding the earlier-acting sigma factor, sigmaE, is negatively regulated by the later-acting sigma factor, sigmaK. Here, it is shown that the negative feedback loop does not require SinR, an inhibitor of sigE transcription. Production of sigmaK about 1 h earlier than normal does affect Spo0A, which when phosphorylated is an activator of sigE transcription. A mutation in the spo0A gene, which bypasses the phosphorelay leading to the phosphorylation of Spo0A, diminished the negative effect of early sigmaK production on sigE expression early in sporulation. Also, early production of sigmaK reduced expression of other Spo0A-dependent genes but not expression of the Spo0A-independent ald gene. In contrast, both sigE and ald were overexpressed late in development of cells that fail to make sigmaK. The ald promoter, like the sigE promoter, is believed to be recognized by sigmaA RNA polymerase, suggesting that sigmaK may inhibit sigmaA activity late in sporulation. To exert this negative effect, sigmaK must be transcriptionally active. A mutant form of sigmaK that associates with core RNA polymerase, but does not direct transcription of a sigmaK-dependent gene, failed to negatively regulate expression of sigE or ald late in development. On the other hand, the negative effect of early sigmaK production on sigE expression early in sporulation did not require transcriptional activity of sigmaK RNA polymerase. These results demonstrate that sigmaK can negatively regulate sigE expression by two different mechanisms, one observed when sigmaK is produced earlier than normal, which does not require sigmaK to be transcriptionally active and affects Spo0A, and the other observed when sigmaK is produced at the normal time, which requires sigmaK RNA polymerase transcriptional activity. The latter mechanism facilitates the switch from sigmaE to sigmaK in the cascade controlling mother cell gene expression.

Role of SpoVG in asymmetric septation in Bacillus subtilis

Deletion of the citC gene, coding for isocitrate dehydrogenase, arrests sporulation of Bacillus subtilis at stage I after bipolar localization of the cell division protein FtsZ but before formation of the asymmetric septum. A spontaneous extragenic suppressor mutation that overcame the stage I block was found to map within the spoVG gene. The suppressing mutation and other spoVG loss-of-function mutations enabled citC mutant cells to form asymmetric septa and to activate the forespore-specific sigma factor sigmaF. However, little induction of mother cell-specific, sigmaE-dependent sporulation genes was observed in a citC spoVG double mutant, indicating that there is an additional defect(s) in compartmentalized gene expression in the citC mutant. These other defects could be partially overcome by reducing the synthesis of citrate, by buffering the medium, or by adding excess MnCl2. Overexpression of the spoVG gene in wild-type cells significantly delayed sigmaF activation. Increased expression and stability of SpoVG in citC mutant cells may contribute to the citC mutant phenotype. Inactivation of the spoVG gene caused a population of otherwise wild-type cells to produce a small number of minicells during growth and caused sporulating cells to complete asymmetric septation more rapidly than normal. Unlike the case for inactivation of the cell division inhibitor gene minD, many of these minicells contained DNA and appeared only when the primary sporulation signal transduction pathway, the Spo0A phosphorelay, was active. These results suggest that SpoVG interferes with or is a negative regulator of the pathway leading to asymmetric septation.

Negative regulation by the Bacillus subtilis GerE protein

GerE is a transcription factor produced in the mother cell compartment of sporulating Bacillus subtilis. It is a critical regulator of cot genes encoding proteins that form the spore coat late in development. Most cot genes, and the gerE gene, are transcribed by sigmaK RNA polymerase. Previously, it was shown that the GerE protein inhibits transcription in vitro of the sigK gene encoding sigmaK. Here, we show that GerE binds near the sigK transcriptional start site, to act as a repressor. A sigK-lacZ fusion containing the GerE-binding site in the promoter region was expressed at a 2-fold lower level during sporulation of wild-type cells than gerE mutant cells. Likewise, the level of SigK protein (i. e. pro-sigmaK and sigmaK) was lower in sporulating wild-type cells than in a gerE mutant. These results demonstrate that sigmaK-dependent transcription of gerE initiates a negative feedback loop in which GerE acts as a repressor to limit production of sigmaK. In addition, GerE directly represses transcription of particular cot genes. We show that GerE binds to two sites that span the -35 region of the cotD promoter. A low level of GerE activated transcription of cotD by sigmaK RNA polymerase in vitro, but a higher level of GerE repressed cotD transcription. The upstream GerE-binding site was required for activation but not for repression. These results suggest that a rising level of GerE in sporulating cells may first activate cotD transcription from the upstream site then repress transcription as the downstream site becomes occupied. Negative regulation by GerE, in addition to its positive effects on transcription, presumably ensures that sigmaK and spore coat proteins are synthesized at optimal levels to produce a germination-competent spore.

Bacillus subtilis spore coat

In response to starvation, bacilli and clostridia undergo a specialized program of development that results in the production of a highly resistant dormant cell type known as the spore. A proteinacious shell, called the coat, encases the spore and plays a major role in spore survival. The coat is composed of over 25 polypeptide species, organized into several morphologically distinct layers. The mechanisms that guide coat assembly have been largely unknown until recently. We now know that proper formation of the coat relies on the genetic program that guides the synthesis of spore components during development as well as on morphogenetic proteins dedicated to coat assembly. Over 20 structural and morphogenetic genes have been cloned. In this review, we consider the contributions of the known coat and morphogenetic proteins to coat function and assembly. We present a model that describes how morphogenetic proteins direct coat assembly to the specific subcellular site of the nascent spore surface and how they establish the coat layers. We also discuss the importance of posttranslational processing of coat proteins in coat morphogenesis. Finally, we review some of the major outstanding questions in the field.

Activation of the proprotein transcription factor pro-sigmaE is associated with its progression through three patterns of subcellular localization during sporulation in Bacillus subtilis

The activity of the sporulation transcription factor sigmaE in Bacillus subtilis is governed by an intercellular signal transduction pathway that controls the conversion of the inactive proprotein pro-sigmaE to the mature and active form of the factor. Here I use immunofluorescence microscopy to show that the activation of the proprotein is associated with its progression through three patterns of subcellular localization. In the predivisional sporangium, pro-sigmaE was found to be associated with the cytoplasmic membrane. Next, at the stage of asymmetric division, pro-sigmaE accumulated at the sporulation septum. Finally, after processing, mature sigmaE was found to be distributed throughout the mother cell cytoplasm. The results of subcellular fractionation and sedimentation in density gradients of extracts prepared from postdivisional sporangia confirmed that pro-sigmaE was chiefly present in the membrane fraction and that sigmaE was predominantly cytoplasmic, findings that suggest that the pro-amino acid sequence is responsible for the sequestration of pro-sigmaE to the membrane. The results of chemical cross-linking experiments showed that pro-sigmaE was present in a complex with its putative processing protein, SpoIIGA, or with a protein that depended on SpoIIGA. The membrane association of pro-sigmaE was, however, independent of SpoIIGA and other proteins specific to B. subtilis. Likewise, accumulation of pro-sigmaE at the septum did not depend on its interaction with SpoIIGA. Sequestration of pro-sigmaE to the membrane might serve to facilitate its interaction with SpoIIGA and may be important for preventing its premature association with core RNA polymerase. The implications of these findings for the compartmentalization of sigmaE are discussed.

The prosequence of pro-sigmaK promotes membrane association and inhibits RNA polymerase core binding

Pro-sigmaK is the inactive precursor of sigmaK, a mother cell-specific sigma factor responsible for the transcription of late sporulation genes of Bacillus subtilis. Upon subcellular fractionation, the majority of the pro-sigmaK was present in the membrane fraction. The rest of the pro-sigmaK was in a large complex that did not contain RNA polymerase core subunits. In contrast, the majority of the sigmaK was associated with core RNA polymerase. Virtually identical fractionation properties were observed when pro-sigmaE was analyzed. Pro-sigmaK was completely solubilized from the membrane fraction and the large complex by Triton X-100 and was partially solubilized from the membrane fraction by NaCl and KSCN. The membrane association of pro-sigmaK did not require spoIVF gene products, which appear to be located in the mother cell membrane that surrounds the forespore, and govern pro-sigmaK processing in the mother cell. Furthermore, pro-sigmaK associated with the membrane when overproduced in vegetative cells. Overproduction of pro-sigmaK in sporulating cells resulted in more pro-sigmaK in the membrane fraction. In agreement with the results of cell fractionation experiments, immunofluorescence microscopy showed that pro-sigmaK was localized to the mother cell membranes that surround the mother cell and the forespore in sporulating wild-type cells and mutant cells that do not process pro-sigmaK. Treatment of extracts with 0.6 M KCl appeared to free most of the pro-sigmaK and sigmaK from other cell constituents. After salt removal, sigmaK, but not pro-sigmaK, reassociated with exogenous core RNA polymerase to form holoenzyme. These results suggest that the prosequence inhibits RNA polymerase core binding and targets pro-sigmaK to the membrane, where it may interact with the processing machinery.

Negative regulation of the proteolytic activation of a developmental transcription factor in Bacillus subtilis

The sporulation transcription factor sigmaK of Bacillus subtilis is controlled by a signal transduction pathway that operates at the level of the proteolytic processing of the inactive precursor protein pro-sigmaK. The conversion of pro-sigmaK to sigmaK requires the putative processing enzyme SpoIVFB and is governed by the regulatory proteins SpoIVFA and BofA. We engineered vegetative cells to carry out processing of pro-sigmaK by inducing the synthesis of the proprotein, a modified form of the putative processing enzyme, and its two regulators during growth. The results showed that (i) modified SpoIVFB was the only sporulation protein necessary to achieve processing of pro-sigmaK; (ii) SpoIVFA stimulated processing, apparently by protecting the processing enzyme from degradation; (iii) BofA inhibited processing in a manner that did not involve degradation of SpoIVFB; and (iv) the inhibition of SpoIVFB by BofA was dependent on SpoIVFA. We conclude that BofA and SpoIVFA act synergistically and are the only two sporulation proteins needed to inhibit the function of SpoIVFB. Our results are consistent with the idea that activation of pro-sigmaK occurs by a reversal of the BofA/SpoIVFA-mediated inhibition of the processing enzyme.