Mice whose B cells cannot produce the T15 idiotype also lack an antigen-specific helper T cell required for T15 expression

The mechanism underlying T cell help for induction of an antigen-specific in vivo humoral immune response to intact Streptococcus pneumoniae is dependent on the type of antigen

Little is known concerning the role of T cells in regulating an anti-polysaccharide Ig response to an intact pathogen. We previously reported that the in vivo Ig responses to Streptococcus pneumoniae (strain R36A), specific for pneumococcal surface protein A (PspA) and for the phosphorylcholine (PC) determinant of C-polysaccharide, were both dependent on TCR-alphabeta(+) T cells and B7-dependent costimulation, although only PspA-specific memory was generated. In this report, we show that the T cell help underlying these two Ag-specific Ig responses is distinct. Using H-Y-specific T cell transgenic mice made "nonleaky" by crossing with mice genetically deficient for TCR-alpha, we demonstrate that the T cell help for the anti-PC, in contrast to the anti-PspA, response is TCR-nonspecific and occurs normally in the absence of germinal center formation, although it is still dependent on B7-dependent costimulation. Consistent with these data, we demonstrate, using cathepsin S(-/-) mice, that although the anti-PC response is largely dependent on CD4(+) T cells, there is a reduced (or lack of) dependence, relative to the anti-PspA response, on the generation of new peptide-MHC class II complexes. In this regard, the T cell help for an optimal anti-PC response is delivered more rapidly than that required for an optimal anti-PspA response. Collectively, these data demonstrate a novel accelerated TCR-nonspecific B7-dependent form of T cell help for augmenting a polysaccharide-specific Ig response to an intact bacterium without the generation of memory.

Generation of helper T cells that recognize a cross-reactive idiotype through a network mechanism

T cells that recognize the cross-reactive idiotype expressed on the heavy (H) chain of M104E (IgM, lambda 1) were induced in BALB/c mice by immunization with Dextran B-1355. T cells derived from mice immunized with 1 mg of Dextran B-1355 showed a marked proliferative response against M104E, whereas T cells from mice immunized with Ficoll or lesser amounts of Dextran B-1355 did not. BCL1Id, which had an immunoglobulin isotype identical to M104E, did not induce proliferation of the T cells. These T cells also proliferated against J558 (IgA, lambda 1) which shared the cross-reactive idiotype of the anti-alpha (1----3) glucosidic linkage antibody with M104E on the H chain. The T cells proliferated more efficiently against F(ab')2-104E, Fab-104E and H104E, the H chain of M104E, than against intact M104E. The T cell proliferative response against the idiotype on M104E or even H104E required macrophages as antigen-presenting cells (APC) and the response was inhibited when APC were treated with NH4Cl or chloroquine, inhibitors of antigen processing. Moreover, anti-CD4 antibody or anti-Ia antibody inhibited the proliferative response. These results indicated that anti-idiotypic T cells of the helper type, which recognized a cross-reactive idiotype associated with Ia molecules in processed form, could be induced physiologically through a network mechanism.

Donor Igh-linked genetic control of allotype-specific antibody response

Immunogenicity of allogeneic immunoglobulins in mice were studied, measuring the allotype-specific antibody activity by agglutination of allogeneic antibody-coated red blood cells. It was found that the serum from C.B-20 mice (Ighb, BALB/c-congenic) was uniquely immunogenic in BALB/c mice for allotype antibody response. Whereas the C57BL/6 (Ighb) serum was immunogenic only when heat aggregated and/or combined with adjuvant, the ultracentrifugation-deaggregated C.B-20 serum was definitely immunogenic when administered in a moderate dose (100 microliters/mouse). Even more surprising was the fast that very low doses (0.01-0.1 microliter) of soluble C.B-20 serum, but not C57BL/6 serum, down regulated the allotype-specific response effectively. Genetic analysis on congenic mice suggested that the immunogenicity is controlled by donor Igh or Igh-V (Id-C.B) inasmuch as the serum from BALB/c-congenic C.B-20 (Igh-VbCb), but not BALB/c-congenic BAB/14 (Igh-VaCb), mice was active in BALB/c mice in soluble form. Further studies showed that the Id-C.B was dominantly expressed on the immunoglobulins of (BALB/c x C.B-20)F1 and (C56BL/6 X C.B-20)F1 strains, and was originally derived from the C57BL/Ka strain. The major determinant for the antibody production was encoded in Igh-C, but not in Igh-V. It is suggested that Id-C.B controls the allotype-specific antibody response in an unusual manner, possibly acting as a unique determinant activating helper T cells.

The immune response to bacterial dextrans. VI. No correlation between the frequency of cells expressing a major anti-dextran idiotype and the idiotype profiles of specific antibody responses

C57BL/6 mice respond to Dextran B512 (Dex) with a predominant idiotype (Id) (17-9) while no such Id-positive antibodies are identified in the specific antibody response of BALB/c mice. We used limiting dilution systems to determine the absolute frequencies of clonal B-cell precursors producing the 17-9 Id in these two mouse strains and analysed the correlation between Id-expression and antibody activity at the clonal level. The results show very similar frequencies of anti-Dex and Id-positive B cells in both strains, but C57BL/6 mice contained fourfold higher frequencies of Dex-specific clonal precursors which are Id-positive. This kind of clone, although not used in the specific response of BALB/c mice, constitute roughly 20% of their anti-Dex repertoire and they are readily induced in this strain. Thus, immunization of both strains with anti-idiotypic antibodies results in the production of Id-positive anti-Dex antibodies with serum titres that directly correlate with precursor frequencies. The results show, therefore, that the section of clonal repertoires utilized in a primary immune response varies with the immunogen, even if thymus-independent. These observations are discussed in the context of the genetic controls of anti-Dex antibody responses and on the general question of the utilization of available antibody repertoires in immune responses.

Prospects for the treatment of B cell tumors using idiotypic vaccination

Manipulation of the immune system in order specifically to attack autologous tumor cell has been a distant goal, largely due to the poor definition of tumor-associated antigens. By focussing on B cell lymphomas which express a molecularly defined clonal marker, the idiotypic immunoglobulin, it has been possible to generate autologous anti-idiotypic responses which suppress individual tumors. Studies of the components of these responses are providing insight into host effector mechanisms which can be activated against tumors, and also into the many strategies adopted by the target cells in order to avoid such attack. Promising results in various animal models where tumor bearers can be treated by idiotypic immunization have led to the point where application of this approach to the treatment of certain categories of human B cell lymphoma can be considered.

Development of Ly-1+ B cells in immunodeficient CBA/N mice

Spleen cells from CBA/N mice developing a systemic autoimmune disease after daily injection of CsA during an autologous bone marrow reconstitution were transferred into unmanipulated syngeneic recipients. Adoptive transfer allowed the development of Ly-1+ B cells, which shared Mac-1 differentiation antigen expression with the myelomonocytic lineage. Interestingly, expansion of formerly absent Ly-1+ B cells was paralleled by a severe reduction in common, Ly-1-, B cell development in the recipient. We conclude that precursors for Ly-1+ B lineage do exist in CBA/N mice.

The induction of helper and suppressor cells with secondary anti-hen egg-white lysozyme B hybridoma cells in the absence of antigen

The results presented in this report define a dominant T cell-recognized public idiotype (SRId) expressed on monoclonal anti-chicken egg-white lysozyme (HEL) antibodies produced by hybridomas derived from secondary response lymphocytes. This Id mediates interactions between SRId+ B cells and SRId-recognizing T cells. In the absence of exogenous antigen, irradiated secondary anti-HEL B hybridoma cells (B-Hyb) of nonoverlapping specificity can be used to induce a helper T cell population capable of specifically stimulating an in vitro anti-HEL plaque-forming cell (PFC) response. Importantly, similar immunizations using carbodiimide-treated secondary anti-HEL B-Hyb cross-primed for a suppressor T cell population capable of suppressing this in vitro anti-HEL PFC response. That is, suppression was seen not only to the response induced by the homologous B-Hyb but to other B-Hyb which express anti-HEL monoclonal antibody of nonoverlapping specificity. This evidence is consistent with the presence of a pre-existent regulatory Id network involving SRId in antigennaive animals. After immunization with HEL, regulatory cells exert a strong selective pressure which leads to a secondary anti-HEL B population, of varying fine specificity, but uniformly positive for SRId.

Shared idiotopes between anti-class II monoclonal antibodies and major histocompatibility complex recognition site of T cells

We have raised a number of monoclonal antibodies (mAb) against idiotopes (Id) on monoclonal anti-murine class II (anti-Ak or Ek) antibodies. Two anti-Id mAb among 31 were found to cross-react with some T cells but not with macrophages and B cells of H-2k animals. They were able to block syngeneic mixed lymphocyte reaction (SMLR) and antigen-induced major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-restricted T cell proliferation of H-2k but not of other haplotypes. These results indicated that antibodies were recognizing Id associated with the MHC restriction site of T cells. The injection of these anti-Id mAb into H-2k mice resulted in the stimulation of self-class II-reactive T cell clones as determined by SMLR. They were also able to stimulate in non-H-2k strains to prime H-2k alloreactive T cell clones. Some animals developed anti-class II (anti-Iak) antibodies by the injection of anti-Id. These results indicated that certain anti-Id (anti-anti-class II) antibodies cross-reacted with T cell receptors which carried class II restriction specificity and were involved in allorecognition. These antibodies were found to have an ability to alter the T cell repertoire in vivo by stimulating such MHC-restricted clones.

Carrier-specific T cells sufficient for the expression of multiple isotypes in B cell cultures

A modified splenic fragment assay was used to assess the role of antigen-specific helper T cells in B cell isotype expression. Limiting numbers of carrier-specific helper T cells from lines or clones were injected along with a source of B cells into lethally irradiated unprimed recipients. The incidence of lodging of the T cell lines in recipient spleens at 18 h was determined by autoradiography to be 1.5 to 4.3% of the injected cells. These T cells were necessary and sufficient for the generation of T-dependent B cell responses within splenic fragments cultured in vitro with specific antigen. A comparison of isotypic responses from splenic and Peyer's patch B cells generated with the same T cell population revealed that a high proportion of the response from Peyer's patch B cells consisted of IgA antibody exclusively (46-57%) while the percentage of such responses from splenic B cells was much lower (7-10%). Thus, the isotype pattern of the response reflected the B cell source. Experiments in which cloned hemocyanin-specific T cells provided help to T-depleted spleen cells within splenic fragments from athymic recipients indicated that a single specificity of helper T cell is both necessary and sufficient to support the generation of antibody responses consisting of multiple isotypes. Isotype-specific T cells do not appear to be required in this system.

Idiotope-specific T cell clones that recognize syngeneic immunoglobulin fragments in the context of class II molecules

We have established idiotope (Id)-specific T cell lines and clones derived from at least 4 different BALB/c mice immunized with the light chain (lambda 2(315] of the BALB/c myeloma protein M315 (alpha, lambda 2). Independently derived clones were indistinguishable in that they reacted to V lambda 2(315), one or more of the amino acids corresponding to somatically mutated codons 94, 95 and 96 of the third hypervariable region being essential for expression of the Id. While the Id was efficiently expressed on V lambda 2(315), Fv315 and lambda 2(315) fragments, about a 100-1000-fold higher molar concentration of Fab315 and M315 was needed to induce equivalent responses. Thus, Ig quaternary structure heavily influenced the availability of the Id for T cells. The V lambda 2(315)-specific T cells were Thy-1.2+, L3T4+, Ly-2.2- and I-Ed restricted. Some of the T cell clones produced interleukin 2 (IL2), IL3 and B cell growth and differentiation factors upon activation. In addition, T cells were cytotoxic in long-term assays for Ed beta Ek alpha-, but not Ek beta Ek alpha- transfected L cells in the presence of Id. The cytotoxic effect was the basis for an L cell growth inhibition assay for T cell activation that was at least 10-fold more sensitive than ordinary proliferation assays.

T cell development in B cell-deficient mice. V. Stopping anti-mu treatment results in Igh-restricted expansion of the T suppressor cell repertoire concomitant with the development of normal immunoglobulin levels

B cell-deficient (anti-mu-treated) mice have proven to be a valuable tool with which to examine the influence of Ig idiotypic determinants upon the development of the Ts repertoire. We have previously reported that ABA-specific Ts repertoires matured in normal and Ig-deficient environments differ from one another in their composition, and consequently, their functionally expressed Igh restrictions. The present report characterizes the impact of natural development of mature B cell activity upon the composition of the Ts repertoire. After stopping anti-mu treatment of C.AL-20 mice, ABA-specific Ts repertoires undergo a defined expansion shown by their acquisition of an additional Ts network that displays Igh restrictions characteristic of normal C.AL-20 mice. This Igh-1d-restricted repertoire can be readily shown within 2 wk of major increases in surface Ig spleen cells and total serum Ig levels in these mice. At the same time, the original Ts restriction specificity (Igh-1a-restricted) generated in the Ig-deficient environment of anti-mu. C.AL-20 mice, is not lost for at least 20 wk. The resulting dual Ts repertoire, characterized by expression of parallel, idiotypically restricted Ts networks, is demonstrable for at least 13 wk. These findings favor an important role for Ig determinants in determining the makeup of the T cell repertoire, and ultimately, the composition of immunologic networks as a whole.

Analysis of immunoglobulins expressing the V kappa 21E and V kappa 21D gene products. Evidence for multigenic control of the expression of VH-VL combinations

The aim of this work was to study the genetic control of VH-VL combined expression. To this end immunoglobulins expressing the V kappa 21E and V kappa 21D gene products were isolated from the normal sera of several inbred strains of mice using a monoclonal antibody that selectively reacts with V kappa 21E and V kappa 21D subgroups. Analysis of the isoelectric focusing (IEF) pattern of the IgG heavy chains of these immunoglobulins obtained from H-2-congeneic mice revealed as expected that Igh-linked loci strongly influence VH-VL combined expression. The IEF pattern of V kappa 21D and V kappa 21E-associated heavy chains isolated from recombinant inbred mouse strains, however, revealed different phenotypes from either parental strains in strains in which both H-2 and Igh loci segregated from the same parent. These data, therefore, strongly suggest that the expression of VH-VL combinations is controlled in part by genetic loci which segregate independently from those linked to H-2 and Igh.

Influence of helper T cells on the expression of a murine intrastrain crossreactive idiotype

The requirement for idiotype-specific helper T (Th) cells in the generation of a major intrastrain crossreactive idiotype was investigated. This idiotype, designated CRIA, is associated with a large proportion of anti-p-azobenzenearsonate (anti-Ar) antibodies in A/J mice. Secondary in vitro responses were studied. Using carrier-primed heterogeneous Th-cell populations, it was found that CRIA expression is determined by the mouse strain that provides the responding B cells and is independent of the strain of the Th cells functioning in vitro. Thus, A/J or A.BY (Ighe) B-plus-accessory-cell populations, primed in vivo to keyhole limpet hemocyanin-Ar (KLH-Ar), generated CRIA-dominant responses in vitro in the presence of KLH-Ar regardless of whether the KLH-primed Th cells were derived from CRIA+ strains (A/J or A.BY, Ighe) or CRIA- strains (B10.A or C57BL/10, Ighb). Further, when major histocompatibility complex-restricted, KLH-specific Th-cell clones were used, the CRIA dominance of the Ar-specific responses was again determined by the strain providing B plus accessory cells. Similar levels of expression of CRIA in Ar-specific antibodies were generated in the presence of heterogeneous or cloned Th cells. The results suggest that there is no absolute requirement for idiotype-specific Th cells in generating an Ar-specific secondary antibody response in vitro.

The antibody response to specific immune complexes is under genetic control and correlates with the expression of a recurrent idiotype

The primary antigen-specific antibody response of various strains of mice to TEPC-15/PnC immune complexes has been examined. We found that both BALB/c and C3H mice were good responders to the PnC antigen; however, C3H mice were low responders, whereas BALB/c mice were high responders to the TEPC-15/PnC complexes. Using congenic strains on the C3H and BALB/c background, we have shown that the response to the complexes is not restricted by gene products of the H-2 complex or by the Igh (allotype) locus. However, responsiveness may be controlled by genes linked to the Igh locus, since we have shown that strains that are Ighj, Ighd, and Ighf are low responders, whereas strains that are Igha, Ighb, and Ighe are high responders to the immune complex. Moreover, responsiveness correlates with the expression of the T15 Id as measured using the anti-T15 monoclonal antibody, AB1-2. Thus, strains such as BALB/c, BALB.B, BALB.K, and CB-20, which express high levels of T15 (AB1-2) Id in their PFC response to PnC are relatively high responders to TEPC-15/PnC complexes, whereas C3H, C3H.SW, and C3H-OH, which express low levels of the T15 (AB1-2) Id, are low responders to the complexes. Finally, we found that BALB/c mice are high responders to complexes formed with T15+ antibodies, whereas they are low responders to complexes formed using T15- antibodies. The results suggest that the antigen-specific response to these immune complexes is Id-restricted.

Distinct functional phenotypes of cloned Ia-restricted helper T cells

Analysis of activation of phosphorylcholine (PC)-specific B cells by a large number of different cloned, self Ia-specific helper T cell (Th) clones has permitted the classification of such T cells into four distinct functional types. Types 1 and 2 induce B cells to secrete anti-PC antibody in an antigen-specific, Ia-restricted fashion. Type 3 cells induce antigen-specific, Ia-restricted B cell proliferation, but do not lead to specific antibody formation, and have been shown previously to have suppressor functions. Type 4 cells are autoreactive, and induce antigen-independent B cell activation and antibody secretion. The distinction between type 1 and type 2 Th clones was analyzed in detail. In bulk cultures, type 1 cloned lines generate an idiotypically heterogeneous anti-PC antibody response, whereas type 2 cloned lines induce a larger response that is dominated by the T15 idiotype. In limiting-dilution analyses, type 2 cells induce fourfold more T15+, PC-specific precursor B cells than do type 1 cells, and in addition, induce larger burst sizes for T15+, PC-specific B cells. Type 4 clones can also be subdivided into cells that are type 1-like, and cells that are type 2-like. These differences in functional phenotype are seen over a broad range of antigen and cell doses. Detailed analysis of the behavior of these distinct functional types of Th should allow a better understanding of the functional properties of mixed populations of antigen-primed, Ia-restricted Th cells.

T15-specific helper T cells: analysis of idiotype specificity by competitive inhibition analysis

Optimal activation of T15 idiotype-bearing B cells has been shown previously to be influenced by two subsets of Thy-1+, Ly-1+,2-sIg- helper T cells. One of the helper T cell sets appears to be T15 specific in that its presence results in a selective augmentation of T15-bearing anti-phosphorylcholine (PC) plaque-forming cell responses. To determine the precise specificity of the idiotype-specific helper T cell (ThId), Ly-1 T cells were tested in an in vitro anti-PC response for their ability to bind directly to T15 myeloma protein-coated plastic plates. Specificity of this binding was ascertained by competitive inhibition of plate binding using idiotypically related myeloma or hybridoma proteins. These data suggest that the Ly-1 T cells which augment T15-bearing plaque-forming cell responses can bind to T15-coated plates and are T15 idiotype specific. This approach is being used currently to attempt to clone ThId cells to further analyze their activation requirements and specificities.

Molecular analysis of induced idiotypes associated with autoanti-thyroglobulin

Idiotype (Id) and autoanti-thyroglobulin were induced in different strains of mice by priming with anti-Id to monoclonal anti-thyroglobulins (D8 and G4) and challenged with a subimmunogenic dose of thyroglobulin (Tg). Both D8.Id and G4.Id were induced in CBA mice by priming with the appropriate anti-Id, but only priming with anti-D8.Id also induced an increase in anti-Tg. D8.Id was induced in other strains by the same schedule but it only appeared to be associated with anti-Tg in 129 and, to a lesser extent, BALB/c mice, both of which have the allotype Iga. The extent of the overlap between the D8 Id and the anti-Tg was estimated and shown to be greatest in the CBA strain from which the D8 clone was originally derived. Spectrotypic analysis of the induced Ids in CBA mice showed that some of the D8.Id, but none of the G4.Id, was identical to the original clonotype, implying that CBA mice normally have cells which can be induced to produce D8.Id-positive autoanti-Tg, which are normally weakly expressed or regulated. The observation that anti-D8.Id priming in some strains increased D8.Id-negative anti-Tg responses suggests that the D8.Id may also be associated with anti-Tg T-cells.

Idiotype connectance in the immune system. II. A heavy chain variable region idiotope that dominates the antibody response to the p-azobenzenearsonate group is a minor idiotope in the response to trinitrophenyl group

We describe the recurrence of a cross-reactive idiotope (CRIAD8) in antibody responses to different epitopes, and explore factors leading to its dominance in some responses, but not others. Serological and genomic DNA analyses showed that CRIAD8 is a marker of the CRIa heavy chain variable region (VH) that encodes the majority of anti-p-azobenzenearsonate (anti-ABA) antibodies. The independence of CRIAD8 from any particular light chain or antigen specificity was underscored by the fact that we could isolate hybridomas that secrete antitrinitrophenyl (TNP) antibodies expressing CRIAD8, with lambda 1 light chains. CRIAD8 is dominant in anti-ABA responses, recurrent but nondominant in anti-TNP and anti-chicken gammaglobulin responses, and is virtually absent in other antihapten responses, including that to p-azobenzenephosphonate (ABP), which contains an ABA-cross-reactive component (approximately 5-40%). Dominance in the anti-TNP response could not be achieved by immunization with doubly haptenated TNP-ABA-KLH (keyhole limpet hemocyanin), where the anti-ABA response was dominated by CRIAD8. These observations suggest that, while the CRIAD8 VH region is necessary for idiotypic dominance, it is not sufficient. Apparently, an additional specificity is required. Since immunization with ABA calls up anti-ABP antibodies that express CRIAD8, but not vice versa, it is possible that the additional specificity is ABA itself. This possibility imposes a new constraint on the specificity of the putative idiotype-specific regulation that may establish dominance in the CRIa system.

1984: all idiotypes are equal, but some are more equal than others

Our analysis of idiotypic dominance suggests that 3 elements play an important role. The first is the genetic material that encodes the dominant idiotype. As dominant idiotypes appear to reflect germ-line-encoded sequences, one can not express a particular idiotype unless that sequence is present in the germ line. The germ-line-encoded sequences, in turn, would, I predict, be specific for commonly encountered or former environmental pathogens. The second element is the environmental antigens themselves. These antigens will induce the production of idiotype, and will prime idiotype-bearing B cells, such that idiotypic dominance emerges. In the absence of such influences, the pattern of idiotypic expression appears to differ. The third influence is regulatory. My own studies have shown that idiotype found in normal serum plays an important role in the maturation and/or function of one such cell, an idiotype-specific helper T cell. It is my working hypothesis that such cells play several roles in idiotypic dominance, but that this is the least of their important roles. Rather, such cells, being specific for idiotopes associated with antibodies specific for environmentally encountered pathogens, would be important in the priming and rapid reactivation of B cells bearing such idiotopes. As such, they speak to the basic role of the immune system, the protection of the organism from infection.

T-cell helper circuits

T helper cells specific for trinitrophenylated PC-binding myeloma and hybridoma antibodies are induced by priming with PC antigen, idiotype or anti-idiotypic antibody. These T helper cells are specific for a shared idiotope present on T15 and M167. Priming with the isolated heavy chains of T15 or M167, or the light chain of anti-T15 hybridoma antibody is equally effective in generating T helper cells. Evidently, the idiotope that is recognized by T cells is not dependent upon the conformation of the 7s Ig molecule. Collectively, these and other findings indicate the existence of a TH1-TH2-B cellular circuit which is based on the recognition of idiotopic determinants on T cell receptors. The implications of these findings in terms of network theory are explored.

Heterogeneous and monoclonal helper T cells induce similar anti-(4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl)acetyl (NP) antibody populations in the primary adoptive response. II. Lambda light chain dominance and idiotope expression

When the hapten (4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl)acetyl (NP) is presented on different carrier molecules, different anti-NP antibody responses are stimulated. On stimulation with NP-lipopolysaccharide (LPS) [T-independent type 1 (TI-1) antigen] kappa + antibodies are the major population, whereas on stimulation with NP-Ficoll [T-independent type 2 (TI-2) antigen], NP-keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) or NP-chicken gamma globulin (CG) [T-dependent (TD) antigens], lambda 1+ antibodies dominate. The relative contribution of idiotopes Ac38 or Ac146 to the lambda 1+ anti-NP response was also different on comparison of TI-1 with TI-2 or TD anti-NP responses. We investigated whether light chain- or idiotype-specific T cells are responsible for these differences. Analysis of the anti-NP response of nude mice after immunization with NP-Ficoll showed lambda 1 dominance. Likewise primary adoptive transfer experiments using carrier-specific T cell lines to reconstitute the TD anti-NP response to NP-KLH or NP-CG, showed that help from carrier-specific T cells alone is capable of stimulating the characteristic lambda 1 dominant response. No significant difference could be found in the levels of Ac38 and Ac146 idiotope expression between mice reconstituted with splenic T cells and those reconstituted with T cell lines. These results suggest that light chain- or idiotype-specific T cells are required neither for the production of lambda 1 light chain dominance, nor for the appearance of idiotopes characteristic of the primary anti-NP response. The possible reasons for differences seen in both light chain and idiotope expression between primary anti-NP responses to the TI-1 antigen NP-LPS and those to TD or TI-2 antigens are discussed.

Non-dinitrophenyl-binding immunoglobulin that bears a dominant idiotype (Id460) associated with antidinitrophenyl antibody is specific for an antigen on Pasteurella pneumotropica

We have previously described an idiotype (Id460) that transiently dominates anti-2,4-dinitrophenyl (DNP) antibody responses of mice that possess the appropriate Igh-V and V kappa genotypes. Normal serum has significant levels of Id460 that does not bind DNP, and hybridomas derived from spleen cell fusions that produce monoclonal antibodies with these characteristics have been generated. Many of these monoclonal, Id460-positive antibodies bind the opportunistic mouse pathogen Pasteurella pneumotropica. P. pneumotropica induces a marked increase in serum Id460 titers without significantly increasing serum anti-DNP titers. Both normal serum and P. pneumotropica-induced Ig460-positive immunoglobulin specifically bind to P. pneumotropica. These results suggest that the normal serum Id460-positive immunoglobulin is induced by environmentally encountered antigens on P. pneumotropica. We propose that this naturally occurring Id460 activates antiidiotypic regulatory cells that in turn promote production of Id460-positive anti-DNP antibody following DNP-ovalbumin immunization. These data are compatible with those obtained in several other idiotypic systems that suggest that dominant idiotypes may be associated with antibodies that have been evolutionarily selected for expression because of their specificity for antigens on environmentally encountered pathogens.

Idiotype-specific T-helper cells

In the present study we investigated the induction and fine specificity of T-helper cells that recognize idiotypes. The data presented show that both low-dose priming with anti-T15 antiserum and priming with PC-Hy are effective in stimulating T15-specific T help. Phosphorylcholine-hemocyanin priming can generate these T cells in either PC-responding or nonresponding strains of mice. Furthermore, the PC-primed T-helper cells can also recognize another anti-PC myeloma, M167, that is idiotypically different from T15. The fine specificity of the anti-PC-idiotype recognizing T-helper cells was examined by studying the effect of in vitro inhibitors on the T-cell help. Both PC and PC-BSA as well as T15 and M167 had an inhibitory effect on the T help. Free T15 and M167 heavy chains also blocked the helper activity for T15; T15 and M167 light chains had no effect, however. Viewed collectively, these results show that PC-Hy priming induces T-helper cells that recognize idiotypic determinants common to both T15 and M167, and that the proteins' H chain is the major structural component of the determinant. Finally, the generation of these idiotype-recognizing T cells was found to occur by way of a T-T interaction loop, based on the finding that T-helper cells are induced by PC-Hy priming in animals that lack PC-responding B cells.

Role of variable region gene expression and environmental selection in determining the antiphosphorylcholine B cell repertoire

To evaluate the role of environmental selective processes, as opposed to variable region gene expression, in the determination of B cell repertoire expression, we have assessed the phosphorylcholine (PC)-specific repertoire of precursor cells that remain in bone marrow cell populations after the removal of surface immunoglobulin (sIg)-bearing cells. Such cells are assumed to represent a stage in B cell maturation before the expression of sIg, and thus at a time when they have not as yet interfaced with environmental influences that operate through sIg receptors such as antigenic stimulation, tolerance, or antiidiotypic regulation. The repertoire as expressed in these cells, therefore, should reflect the readout of immunoglobulin variable region genes as they are expressed in progenitors to B cells. The results of these studies indicate that, as in mature primary B cell pools of BALB/c mice, the majority of PC-responsive sIg- bone marrow cells are of the T15 clonotype. Thus, environmental selective mechanisms would not appear to be required for the high frequency of B cells of the T15 idiotype in the primary B cell repertoire of BALB/c mice. Analysis of the sIg- bone marrow cells in (CBA/N X BALB/c)F1 male mice demonstrated that the deficit of PC-responsive mature B cells, which is a characteristic of this murine strain, must occur after receptor expression, since a normal frequency of PC-responsive and T15-expressing cells is present in their sIg- bone marrow population. Finally, these same mice were used to obtain bone marrow cell preparations from individual leg bones, so as to permit an analysis of the occurrence of T15+ and T15- clonotypes within individual bone marrow populations. The findings from these studies indicate that T15+ B cells occur as a high frequency event within bone marrow generative cell pools. Furthermore, bone marrow populations that are positive for PC-responsive precursor cells often display multiple copies of such precursor cells that are exclusively either T15+ or T15-. This finding indicates that clonal expansion of cells within the B cell lineage apparently occurs before immunoglobulin receptor acquisition.

Expression of defined idiotypes throughout the BALB/c anti-fluorescyl antibody response: affinity and idiotype analyses of heterogeneous antibodies

Heterogeneous BALB/c anti-fluorescyl antibodies were shown to display increases (greater than 50-fold) in binding affinity from the primary through the tertiary responses. The structural basis of such affinity maturation and the diversity exhibited by anti-fluorescyl antibodies was examined by idiotypic analysis using a panel of anti-idiotype reagents specific for seven different monoclonal antifluorescyl antibodies. Because these clones exhibited binding affinities characteristic of a secondary or hyperimmune response, it was possible to examine the mechanism of affinity maturation by determining the prevalence of the seven idiotypes (Id-4-4-20, Id-20-19-1, Id-20-20-3, Id-6-10-6, Id-20-4-4, Id-4-6-10 and Id-6-19-1) in specifically purified heterogeneous preparations with low (i.e. primary response) or high (i.e. secondary and tertiary responses) binding affinities. Four of the idiotypes were not detected in heterogeneous preparations and thus each represented less than 0.1% of the total anti-fluorescein repertoire. Although results indicated that each of three other clones expressed unique or private idiotypic determinants not present in the heterogeneous population, these idiotypes (Id-4-4-20, Id-6-10-6, Id-6-19-1) were detected and ranged from approximately 0.2 to 2.0% of the repertoire. However, results indicated that each clone expressed unique or private idiotypic determinants not present in the heterogeneous population. Determinants expressed by such high-affinity monoclonal antibodies were expressed equally in all heterogeneous preparations examined. Because those determinants which were expressed were found in either low- or high-affinity heterogeneous antibodies, it is likely that the higher affinities exhibited by monoclonal antibodies derived from a secondary response are associated with unique idiotypic determinants which were not detected in polyclonal preparations. Hence, the process of affinity maturation may find as its structural correlate a mechanism such as somatic mutation which generates individual or unique idiotypes.

The occurrence of defined idiotypes on autoantibodies to mouse thyroglobulin

Anti-idiotypic antibodies were raised in rabbits to three monoclonal mouse autoanti-thyroglobulins. Of the idiotypes recognized, one was unique to that monoclonal, while the other two showed evidence of sharing idiotopes with other monoclonal anti-thyroglobulin (TG) idiotypes, the IgM idiotype in particular being found on nearly half of the hybridomas studied. Two of the idiotypes could be detected in the sera of mice with experimental allergic thyroiditis (EAT), but they constituted only a very small percentage of the total anti-TG present. In spite of its low levels in EAT mice the D8 idiotype could be induced by injection of anti-idiotype and TG and in this case it constituted up to 20% of the anti-TG activity in individual mice, showing a strain-related association between the idiotype and autoanti-TG.

Lack of a requirement for idiotype matching: T cells from mice which cannot produce idiotype support idiotype-positive antibody response

A requirement for idiotype matching was reported such that carrier-primed T helper cells from mice, which are unable to produce an idiotype (idiotype-negative) because of genetic reasons or adult anti-idiotype or neonatal anti-mu antibody treatment, did not provide helper function for an idiotype-positive antibody response. We have analyzed the requirement for idiotype matching in the response to phosphorylcholine by using mice which are idiotype-negative because they were injected with anti-idiotype antibody shortly after birth. Carrier-primed T cells from such animals supported idiotype-positive responses when mixed with normal or primed B cell populations and challenged with appropriate antigen; these responses were quantitatively and qualitatively similar to those obtained with T cells from idiotype-positive animals. These results demonstrate no requirement for idiotype matching and suggest that the procedure used to establish an idiotype-negative T cell donor may be decisive in showing a requirement for idiotype matching.

Anti-idiotypic regulation of IgA expression in myeloma cells

MOPC-315 (alpha lambda 2) is a BALB/c plasmacytoma that produces an anti-TNP antibody (M315). In addition to being secreted M315 is also expressed on the surface membranes of MOPC-315 cells. In the present studies an in vitro-adapted line of MOPC-315 was used to study the effect of affinity-purified, isologous anti-idiotypic antibodies (a-Id315) and idiotype-specific T cells on M315 expression. We observed that both monoclonal and polyclonal a-Id315 mediated a reversible clearance of surface membrane M315 but did not influence M315 secretion or MOPC-315 growth even when the myeloma cells were cultured in the continuous presence of a-Id315 for three weeks. Clearance of surface M315 was rapid, reversible, and a-Id315 dose-dependent. M315:a-Id315 complexes were shed from MOPC-315 cells in the form of microscopic membranous vesicles and a-Id315 was consumed in the process. Protein synthesis was required for re-expression of surface M315 only if a presynthesized internal pool of M315 had previously been depleted. In contrast, idiotype-specific T cells mediated specific inhibition of M315 secretion without influencing surface M315 expression. Although the anti-idiotypic antibodies and the anti-idiotypic T-cells are both directed to the surface membrane immunoglobulin on the cloned B cell, the anti-idiotypic antibodies regulate surface membrane expression of immunoglobulin while the anti-idiotypic T-cells regulate secretion of immunoglobulin. These observations support the view that in idiotype regulation, surface membrane immunoglobulin molecules function as a focusing device for regulatory effectors which actually determine the quality of the effect achieved.

Unbalanced X chromosome mosaicism in B cells of mice with X-linked immunodeficiency

The immunodeficiency in CBA/N mice is reflected by abnormal development of a subset of B lymphocytes. However, it is not clear how xid, the mutant gene in CBA/N mice, affects the development of this subset. Specifically, it is not known if the xid gene influences the development of the B cell subset directly or indirectly by providing the improper developmental milieu through effects on other cells. We investigated this question using female mice heterozygous for two x chromosomal genes, xid and Pgk-1 (phosphoglycerate kinase-1). Since females are mosaic because of x chromosome inactivation, their lymphocytes can be studied for the choice of the x chromosome, using the two PGK-1 isoenzymes as the cytological marker. We find that B lymphocytes in the spleen prefer the x chromosome without xid while the remaining splenocytes and cells from other tissues do not. This suggests that xid affects B lymphocytes directly and not through their developmental milieu. Furthermore, our data suggest that the precursors for IgG1- and IgG3-producing cells may be both few and different.

Subpopulations of B cells distinguished by cell surface expression of Ia antigens. Correlation of Ia and idiotype during activation by cloned Ia-restricted T cells

We have investigated in vitro the induction of antibody responses to phosphorylcholine (PC) by cloned T helper (Th) cell lines. The cloned Th cells are antigen specific, in this case ovalbumin (OVA), self-Ia recognizing, and induce antibody secretion only if the hapten, PC, is physically linked to the carrier (OVA) molecule. The plaque-forming cell (PFC) response generated in the presence of cloned Th cells is idiotypically diverse with 5-40% of the secreting B cells bearing the TEPC-15 (T15) idiotype. The interaction of the cloned Th cells and unprimed B cells requires recognition of B cell surface Ia glycoproteins for all B cells activated to secrete anti-PC antibody, whether they be T15-bearing or not. More importantly, however, effective interaction between a cloned Th cell and a B cell is determined by the quantity of B cell surface Ia glycoproteins. Our results indicate that quantitative differences in B cell surface Ia antigens are directly related to B cell activation by the cloned Th cell. The high Ia density B cells are most easily activated by cloned Th cells, and these appear to be mainly non-T15-bearing. These data suggest that the failure of cloned Th cells to effectively activate T15-bearing B cells in vitro may be due to the lower relative Ia density of these B cells and therefore to their inability to interact effectively with cloned Ia-recognizing Th cells. These results imply that monoclonal T cells may distinguish between T15-bearing and non-T15-bearing B cells based on their Ia density.

Idiotype-specific T lymphocytes. II. capability of generation of idiotype-specific T lymphocytes is determined by corresponding VH gene

MOPC-104E (M104E) idiotype-specific and major histocompatibility complex-restricted T lymphocyte activities were investigated in BALB/c (Igh-1a) and its Igh-1-congenic strains of mice, such as C.AL-20 (Igh-1d), BAB-14 (Igh-1b), and CB-20 (Igh-1b). Idiotype-specific T lymphocytes could be induced in BALB/c and BAB-14 by immunization of viable M104E tumor cells followed by surgical removal and in vitro restimulation with the homologous tumor cells. On the other hand, C.AL-20 and CB-20 mice did not show the idiotype-recognizing capacity even though they could mount comparable cytotoxic T lymphocyte activities against M104E to BALB/c and BAB-14. The results strongly suggest that the inducibility of M104E cross-reactive idiotypy closely paralleled the producibility of corresponding idiotype-specific T lymphocytes. Genetically defined VH gene products might act as internal images that construct idiotype network systems.

Thymus-independent induction and antigen-dependent recovery of idiotype-specific suppression

BALB/c nude (nu/nu) mice and euthymic (nu/+) littermates were treated as neonates with anti-T15 antibody and challenged at various ages with either a thymus-independent, PC-Brucella abortus (PC-BA), or thymus-dependent, PC-keyhole limpet hemocyanin (PC-KLH), form of phosphorylcholine (PC). Nu/nu mice challenged with PC-KLH received KLH-primed splenic T cells prior to immunization. Neither neonatally anti-idiotype-treated nu/+ nor nu/nu mice responded with the production of T15-positive anti-PC antibodies after challenge with either form of PC antigen. It is concluded that neither induction nor maintenance of a state of T15-specific suppression requires thymus-matured T cells. Recovery of anti-PC responsiveness in suppressed nu/+ or nu/nu mice was similar and was found to be related to the form of antigen used to elicit the response. Immunization with PC-KLH revealed a long-lasting unresponsiveness (up to 16 weeks). In contrast, immunization with PC-BA elicited a full anti-PC response as early as at 6.5 weeks of age.

Two distinct azobenzenearsonate-specific helper T-cell subpopulations mediate different forms of T-B cooperation

Popliteal lymph node T cells from mice footpad-primed with azobenzenearsonate (ABA)-protein conjugates were able to help the anti-trinitrophenyl (TNP) and anti-ABA plaque-forming cell (PFC) responses of normal syngeneic spleen cells cultured in vitro with TNP-ABA-keyhole limpet haemocyanin. Enrichment in ABA-specific helper cells was obtained by positive selection of ABA-primed T cells on ABA-pulsed syngeneic macrophages. The ABA-specific T cells induced by ABA-protein priming are able to help the anti-TNP PFC response of normal B cells through recognition of the ABA determinant either unlinked to TNP (ABA and TNP separately presented to T and B cells) or linked to TNP (ABA and TNP presented as moieties of the same molecule). These two mechanisms of T-B cooperation are mediated by two different ABA-specific helper T-cell subpopulations, which can be distinguished by their different radiosensitivities: the former mechanism is mediated by radioresistant T cells, whereas the latter is mediated by radiosensitive T cells. Both helper T-cell subpopulations bind the ABA-pulsed syngeneic macrophages, demonstrating the presence of ABA-specific receptors on both cell types.

An example of major histocompatibility complex-linked control of idiotypic interactions

Normal euthymic mice, injected i.v. with low doses of syngeneic monoclonal antibodies carrying "recurrent" idiotypes, develop a specific increase in numbers of splenic IgM plaque-forming cells that are paratopically and idiotypically similar to the injected antibody. We have now studied the responsiveness to a C57BL/6 anti-dextran a(1 leads to 6) and BALB/c anti-TNP (trinitrophenyl) monoclonal antibodies in a variety of strains. It was found that such responses are controlled by two linkage groups, namely major histocompatibility complex (MHC) and Ig-1.

The genetic basis of antibody production: the dominant anti-arsonate idiotype response of the strain A mouse

Immunization of the A strain of mice with the hapten p-azophenylarsonate (Ars) results in an immune response in which approximately 50% of the anti-Ars antibodies share cross-reactive idiotypic determinants (IdCR). A gene or genes linked to the heavy chain constant region locus is required for the production of this idiotype. The expressed VH gene from a hybridoma cell line which expresses the IdCR has been cloned. DNA hybridization studies utilizing the VH gene have revealed that there are many related genes in both idiotype-producing and idiotype-nonproducing strains of mice. However, under stringent hybridization conditions, only a single band of 6.4 kb is present in Eco R1-digested A strain DNA. Strains of mice which are phenotypically idiotype-negative either lack this band completely or possess a much weaker one at this position. Utilizing DNA from Igh recombinant strains of mice, it has been shown that the VH locus controlling idiotype expression contains the structural gene information for the idiotype-positive heavy chains. It has also been shown that DNA at this locus appears to be sufficient for the production of the cross-reactive idiotype. Utilizing a DNA probe derived from regions flanking the structural gene has confirmed the relatedness of V genes in a variety of mouse strains and revealed a significant degree of polymorphism at the Igh locus.

Regulation of azophenylarsonate-specific repertoire expression. 1. Frequency of cross-reactive idiotype-positive B cells in A/J and BALB/c mice

A large proportion of p-azophenylarsonate (ARS)-specific antibodies from A/J mice share a cross-reactive idiotype (CRIA) that comprises a family of closely related but nonidentical clonotypes. I determined that only 2.6 % (7 out of 267) A/J ARS-specific monoclonal antibodies generated in the splenic focus system possess the predominant CRIA. Because ARS-specific B cells are present at a frequency of 1/68,000 B cells, the frequency of the entire idiotype family is 1 per 2.8 X 10(6) splenic B cells. Thus, there is a striking discrepancy between the representation of this idiotype at the clonal precursor cell level and the serum antibody response. In addition, BALB/c mice have the potential to generate CRIA-positive precursor cells within their nonimmune repertoire. When A/J mice are immunized with ARS-protein conjugates, the serum antibody response and precursor cell population are both dominated by CRIA. The frequency of CRIA-positive B cells increases over 100-fold after immunization, whereas CRIA-negative precursor cells may initially decrease, followed by a later rise in frequency. Finally, although ARS-specific precursor cells are present in high frequency at birth, CRIA-positive monoclonal anti-ARS antibodies are not observed during the early neonatal period. These data provide evidence to suggest that complex regulatory networks influence precursor cell and serum antibody expression.

Study of the idiotypy of lipopolysaccharide-specific polyclonal and monoclonal antibodies

The monoclonal antibodies produced by a variety of hybridomas making antibody specific for E. coli 0113 lipopolysaccharide (LPS) were purified by affinity chromatography and their fine specificity studied. All reacted specifically with the polysaccharide moiety of LPS from E. coli 0113 and from Neisseria lactamica; two reacted with LPS from Pseudomonas aeruginosa and one reacted with LPS from Klebsiella pneumoniae. Polyclonal and monoclonal syngeneic and semi-syngeneic anti-idiotypic antisera were produced to study the idiotypy of LPS-specific monoclonal antibodies which express a complex cross-reactive idiotype (IdX) as well as individual idiotypes. E. coli 0113 LPS-specific antibodies produced by BALB/c mice express this IdX and the kinetics for its expression was examined using mice either primed or hyperimmunized with LPS; idiotypic maturation was observed, but we were unable to detect an auto-anti-idiotypic antibody response. This IdX was expressed on E. coli 0113 LPS-specific antibodies from all strains of mice examined, indicating that its expression is not restricted by genes linked to the IgCH locus.

Anti-phosphorylcholine antibodies of the T15 idiotype are optimally protective against Streptococcus pneumoniae

In the mouse, most anti-PC antibody is found in one of the three murine anti-PC idiotype families: T15, M603, or M511. The antibodies within each of these idiotypic families have characteristic fine specificities for phosphorylcholine (PC)-analogues. In this paper we compare the ability of hybridoma IgM anti-PC antibodies of the three idiotype families to protect mice from fatal infection with S. pneumoniae. Antibody bearing the T15 idiotype was approximately 8 times as effective as antibody with the M603 idiotype and approximately 30 times as protective as antibody with the M511 idiotype. Reports by others have shown that the heavy chains of virtually all mouse anti-PC antibodies are produced by translocation of a single variable region gene and that the direct translation of this gene (in the absence of somatic mutations) results in heavy chains characteristic of the T15 idiotype. Thus, our findings suggest that the T15 germ line heavy chain variable region gene may have been selected through evolution to code for antibody binding PC-containing pathogens such as S. pneumoniae. Our observations may also explain the existence of regulatory mechanisms that result in maintenance of T15 idiotype expression in murine anti-PC immune responses.

Regulatory idiotypes. T helper cells recognize a shared VH idiotope on phosphorylcholine-specific antibodies

Priming of BALB/c mice with phosphorylcholine-hemocyanin (PC-Hy) induces T helper cells that are detected in splenic fragment cultures responding to immunization with trinitrophenylated PC-binding myeloma proteins, TEPC 15 (TNP-T15) and MOPC 167 (TNP-M167). Trinitrophenylation did not alter the binding site, idiotype, or isotype of the antibodies as demonstrated by binding studies. To assay idiotype-recognizing helper cells, Ly-2.2-depleted T cells from PC-Hy-primed donor mice were transferred to syngeneic athymic mice. Splenic anti-trinitrophenol fragment cultures were prepared from the nude recipients, and the response to TNP-T15 and TNP-M167 was measured by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. The number of responding fragments is dependent on the number of transferred primed T cells. The homing efficiency of 51Cr-labeled helper cells into the spleen of nude recipients was determined. The frequencies of T helper cells taken from PC-Hy-primed donors required for a B cell response to TNP-T15 or TNP-M167 were indistinguishable. The fine specificity of the anti-PC idiotype-recognizing T helper cells was studied by adding hapten (PC) or unconjugated myeloma proteins to fragment cultures as inhibitors at the time of immunization. PC and PC-bovine serum albumin, as well as T15 and M167, inhibited the helper function in vitro. Furthermore, free heavy chains of T15 and M167 partially inhibited T help, but free light chains of both idiotypes had no effect. These findings collectively show that T helper cells, induced by priming with antigen, recognize a shared idiotypic determination on T15 and M167 that is part of the PC binding site. The heavy chains of T15 and M167 appears to be the major structural component of this determinant. Evidently, T helper cells can recognize a shared determinant that is present on idiotypically different myeloma proteins. This determinant appears to be conserved throughout evolutionary and somatic mutations. The role of this shared, binding site-related idiotypic determinant as a regulatory idiotype in T-B cell interaction is discussed.