Quantitative studies on T cell diversity. II. Determination of the frequencies and Lyt phenotypes of two types of precursor cells for alloreactive cytotoxic T cells in polyclonally and specifically activated splenic T cells

Human CD4(+)CD25(+) cells: a naturally occurring population of regulatory T cells

Despite thymic deletion of cells with specificity for self-antigens, autoreactive T cells are readily detectable in the normal T-cell repertoire. In recent years, a population of CD4(+) T cells that constitutively express the interleukin-2 receptor-alpha chain, CD25, has been shown to play a pivotal role in the maintenance of self-tolerance in rodent models. This study investigated whether such a regulatory population exists in humans. A population of CD4(+)CD25(+) T cells, taken from the peripheral blood of healthy individuals and phenotypically distinct from recently activated CD4(+) T cells, was characterized. These cells were hyporesponsive to conventional T-cell stimuli and capable of suppressing the responses of CD4(+)CD25(-) T cells in vitro. Addition of exogenous interleukin-2 abrogated the hyporesponsiveness and suppressive effects of CD4(+)CD25(+) cells. Suppression required cell-to-cell contact but did not appear to be via the inhibition of antigen-presenting cells. In addition, there were marked changes in the expression of Notch pathway molecules and their downstream signaling products at the transcriptional level, specifically in CD4(+)CD25(+) cells, suggesting that this family of molecules plays a role in the regulatory function of CD4(+)CD25(+) cells. Cells with similar phenotype and function were detected in umbilical venous blood from healthy newborn infants. These results suggest that CD4(+)CD25(+) cells represent a population of regulatory T cells that arise during fetal life. Comparison with rodent CD4(+)CD25(+) cells suggests that this population may play a key role in the prevention of autoimmune diseases in humans.

Quantifying the frequency of alloreactive T cells in vivo: new answers to an old question

Alloreactive T cell precursor frequency was measured in vivo using fluorescent dye labeling in combination with novel models based on lymphocyte activation and recovery. CFSE-labeled C57BL/6 (H-2(b)) spleen and lymph node cells were adoptively transferred to C57BL/6xDBA F(1) (H-2(b/d)) recipients, a parent-->F(1) MHC mismatch in which only donor cells respond. Recipients were sacrificed at serial time points to assess engraftment efficiency, and the extent of donor cell activation and proliferation. These data were used to calculate alloreactive T cell frequencies that varied 30-fold (0.71 +/- 0.31% to 21.05 +/- 3.62%), depending upon whether it was assumed that all donor cells injected became established and were capable of responding, or that only those present at later time points (24-72 h) were available to respond. By measuring the number of cells established in the recipient 24 h after transfer, before proliferation, we calculated an in vivo alloreactive frequency of approximately 7%. Using CD69 expression at 48 h to quantify activation, we found that 40-50% of the alloactivated CD4(+) donor T cells do not divide. Studies of cotransferred congenic and allogeneic cells demonstrated that bystander proliferation does not occur. We conclude that accurate calculations of alloreactive precursor frequency must account for both proliferation and cell engraftment. When this is done, a high percentage of alloreactive T cells exists across an MHC mismatch, but not all alloreactive cells proliferate in vivo. Bystander proliferation is negligible, revealing exquisite specificity to the alloresponse. These data provide a novel approach to quantify alloreactive T cell responses during specific immunomodulatory strategies in vivo.

Analysis of cellular interactions in limiting dilution cultures

Limiting dilution (LD) cultures are often used to study cellular heterogeneity in responses of murine splenocytes to specific or polyclonal activation. LD titration curves often reveal a nonlinear dependence of response on input cell dose. Although 'zigzag' shaped curves of this kind are often interpreted and analyzed as resulting from interactions among three distinct cell types, we observe that a more parsimonious two cell model, including a cell type that can generate both positive and negative effects, provides better fit to a wide range of experimental data. We have developed mathematical models for the accurate estimation of the frequencies of both interacting cell types and of the parameters for their multi-hit interaction. We show examples of LD cultures in which specific experimental manipulations alter the frequency of only one of the two cell types, or alter the interaction parameters without a change in responder frequency. We also provide a simplified method for approximation of the model parameters using graphical approaches and simple algebra. Lastly, we present an improved method for calculation of the effect generated per responder cell in microclonal cultures.

Molecular detection and in vivo analysis of the specific T cell response to a protein antigen

We have analyzed in detail the repertoire of transcripts encoding the V beta chains of the T cell receptor and investigated the T cell response of B10.A mice to pigeon cytochrome c. We were thus able to follow the specific T cell response in vivo after immunization with this protein antigen. The response is first detectable in the draining lymph nodes, then in the spleen and in the blood. It is qualitatively similar in individual animals. It is dominated by a major category of specific T cells harboring a V beta 3-J beta 1.2 rearrangement, and a limited and well-defined set of nucleotide sequences, previously found in several specific T cell hybridomas and clones. This predominance is observed from the onset of the immune response strongly suggesting the notion that there is no variation and, therefore, no maturation of the T cell response in the course of immunization.

Macrophage regulation of immune responses of spleen cells from mice infected with Trypanosoma cruzi

Mice infected with the protozoan parasite, Trypanosoma cruzi, are known to be immunosuppressed in responsiveness to heterologous antigens and parasite-specific antigens. This suppression is mediated by suppressor macrophages and is exemplified by deficient T cell activity and abnormal cytokine production. Neither the mechanism by which suppressor macrophages effect suppression nor the characteristics of these suppressor macrophages is known. In the present study, we analyzed the regulatory cell populations in splenocytes of infected mice (SCinf) and their interactions by limiting dilution-partition analysis, an approach which allows the functional separation of multiple regulatory cell subpopulations within cell mixtures. Our results demonstrate the presence of a complex immunoregulatory circuit in SCinf affecting the generation of anti-sheep erythrocyte antibody responses in vitro. Titration of SCinf (but not peritoneal exudate or lymph node cells) into Mishell-Dutton microcultures of normal spleen cells generated complex dose-response curves with two zones of suppressed responses following the addition of either low or high doses of SCinf to the cultures. Addition of intermediate doses of SCinf to the microcultures restored responsiveness. Both the low- and high-dose zones of suppression were shown to be mediated by macrophages, whereas T cells were responsible for the restored responsiveness at intermediate doses of SCinf. Examination of the development of this complex regulatory pattern during the course of the acute phase of infection indicated the sequential development of one suppressor macrophage population, followed by the development of the beneficial T cell population, and finally the expression of the second suppressive macrophage population.

Cytotoxic T lymphocytes reactive against a syngeneic murine tumor and their specific suppressor T cells are both elicited by in vitro allosensitization

Sensitization of C57BL/6 (B6, H-2b) splenocytes against normal BALB/c (H-2d) leukocytes (B6 a/BALB) in bulk MLC induced CTL reactive against the syngeneic (H-2b) nonimmunogenic lymphoma PIR-2, in addition to the CTL directed against the corresponding (H-2d) allotargets. However, MLC-derived lymphocytes did not directly exhibit anti-PIR-2 cytotoxicity in spite of the high anti-PIR-2 CTL frequency (up to 1/20) among them, as demonstrated by the limiting dilution culture (LDC) technique. The present study was undertaken to resolve this contradiction. We found that anti-PIR-2 cytotoxicity could be detected only when B6 a/BALB MLC-derived responding cells were plated in LDC at low numbers (less than 200) of cells/well. In contrast, increasing the number of the plated cells to 500-5,000 resulted in a gradual decrease in the percentage of wells cytotoxically reactive against PIR-2, whereas the percentage of wells exhibiting cytotoxicity against the allotargets remained unchanged (100%). This decrease of anti-PIR-2 cytotoxicity in LDC and the lack of anti-PIR-2 reactivity among MLC-derived lymphocytes were shown by mixing experiments to result from the activity of radioresistant Thy-1+, Lyt-2+, L3T4- suppressor cells, blocking the anti-PIR-2 cytotoxicity at the effector phase. The suppression was specific as indicated by the following observations: (a) freshly obtained B6 splenocytes, cultured unsensitized B6 splenocytes, mitogen-induced B6 lymphoblasts, B6 LAK cells, or B6 a/B6 MLC-derived lymphocytes were not suppressive; (b) anti-PIR-2 cytotoxicity elicited in B6 a/BALB LDC was suppressed only by lymphocytes derived from B6 a/BALB MLC and not from B6 a/C3H (H-2k) MLC; and (c) B6 a/BALB MLC-induced suppressor cells could be adsorbed on monolayers of BALB/c but not of C3H lymphoblasts. Since both syngeneic tumor and allogeneic target cells were lysed by the same clonal cell population but only the antisyngeneic activity was suppressed, we suggest that a single CTL can exhibit two cytotoxic activities that are differentially affected by the described suppressor cells. This mode of suppression may play a role in controlling autoimmune reactivity.

Immune status of a mu, kappa transgenic mouse line. Deficient response to bacterially related antigens

We have examined the immune repertoire and immune response of a mouse that carries transgenes for a mu heavy chain and kappa light chain. The expression of these genes is under the regulation of their own controlling elements. The transgenes are expressed early in ontogeny and are easily detectable from day 13 of gestation onwards. The pre-B cells seem to function normally as they generate IgM-secreting colonies at normal frequencies. Colonies show predominantly the transgenic specificity. Expression of the transgenes is not limited to B cells since around 10%-20% of peripheral T cells and 50% of thymocytes express the mu transgene as an intracellular protein. Ectopic expression of kappa was not seen. The spleen size of the transgenic mouse is decreased by around 20%; this reduction is largely caused by a reduction of the B cell pool. Almost all B cells express the transgenes, only 30% co-express endogenous heavy chain genes and all co-express endogenous light chain genes. Serum Ig levels for IgM and IgA were normal, 20% of the IgM consist of the transgenic product. Serum IgG levels were decreased. T cell functions (helper and cytotoxic) were normal. Immune responses to conventional antigens were impaired, especially in the early phases of the immune response, but after boosting they were virtually normal, except for IgG3 which remained low. Primary antibody responses to T cell-independent antigens of the class II type (bacterially related antigens) were absent, although precursor frequencies for these antigens were within the expected range. The significance of this finding, as it relates to allelic exclusion of Ig genes, is discussed.

Alloreactive immune responses of transgenic mice expressing a foreign transplantation antigen in a soluble form

Transfection of cells with the H-2Kk gene lacking the transmembrane and cytoplasmic segments resulted in secretion of the H-2Kk protein, as determined by immunoprecipitation with monoclonal anti-H-2Kk antibodies. Transgenic (H-2b X H-2d)F1 mice were established carrying integrated copies of the modified H-2Kk gene. Expression of the soluble H-2Kk antigen in the transgenic mice was demonstrated in cell supernatants of biosynthetically labeled splenic and thymic Con A blasts as well as bone marrow-derived macrophages. Soluble H-2Kk molecules were also present in the sera of the transgenic animals. No cell-surface expression of the H-2Kk antigen could be observed. In spite of the presence of the soluble H-2Kk molecules in the transgenic mice, the animals were able to generate H-2Kk-specific cytolytic T cells as well as antibody responses when stimulated with cell-surface-bound H-2Kk antigens. These responses were indistinguishable from those of the nontransgenic littermates. Possible explanations for the observed lack of tolerance are discussed.

Effective activation of resting mouse T lymphocytes by cross-linking submitogenic concentrations of the T cell antigen receptor with either Lyt-2 or L3T4

We studied the activation of small resting mouse T lymphocytes by antibodies to the T cell antigen receptor in combination with antibodies to other T cell surface antigens. Solid-phase but not soluble antibodies KJ16-133 and F23.1, both directed to beta chains of the V beta 8 family, activate T cells to proliferate in the presence of growth factors, in a dose-dependent fashion. Antibodies to Lyt-2 and to L3T4 had no activating effect at any concentration. However, submitogenic concentrations of KJ16-133 and of F23.1 synergized with a wide range of concentrations of anti-Lyt-2 and anti-L3T4 to cause T cell proliferation similar or greater in magnitude to that caused by high concentrations of anti-T cell receptor antibody. Synergistic activation was also observed with antibodies to Lyt-1, LFA-1 and H-2 class I antigens but to a significantly lower degree. This was particularly clear in limiting dilution experiments in which the corrected frequencies of T cells proliferating in response to low amounts of anti-T cell receptor antibody together with anti-Lyt-2 were 1/4 to 1/7 for BALB/c T cells. The frequencies of BALB/c T cells responding to high concentrations of anti-T cell receptor antibody alone were between 1/14 and 1/126 and still lower frequencies of T cells proliferated in synergistic responses with anti-LFA-1 or anti-Lyt-1. Synergistic activation leads to the induction of functional cytotoxic cells. We interpret these data as suggestive that cross-linking of the T cell antigen receptor with either Lyt-2 (CD8) or L3T4 (CD4) represents an optimal activating signal for resting T cells. We think that, in physiological T cell activation, cross-linking of the T cell receptor to CD8 or CD4 is induced by their simultaneous binding to major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I (for CD8) or MHC class II (for CD4) molecules on stimulator cells. We consider the possibility that similar cross-linking requirements may also exist during T cell repertoire selection in ontogeny, thus accounting for the strict coexpression of MHC class I and class II-restricted T cell receptors with CD8 and CD4 molecules, respectively.

Degeneracy of H-2 recognition by cytotoxic T lymphocytes: 10% of the total repertoire is "specific" for a given haplotype and up to 1% is self-H-2 reactive

The frequency of specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) precursors in the total CTL pool was analyzed in a lectin-driven limiting dilution system. We found that up to 10% of the expressed CTL repertoire in a normal mouse is "specific" for a given allogeneic H-2 haplotype. Split-well analysis under clonal conditions demonstrates that the antigens recognized by the effector CTL are H-2 encoded. A high frequency of CTL "specific" for self-H-2 antigens was revealed in all the experiments, accounting for about 1% of the total inducible pool of CTL. These results suggest a high degree of degeneracy of H-2 recognition by CTL and the immunocompetence of self-H-2-reactive CTL precursors in normal individuals.

Postnatal development of functional T cell subsets in the mouse: a frequency analysis of mitogen reactive precursors of proliferating, of cytotoxic and of IL 2 producing T cells

In order to study the postnatal development of functional T cell subsets in the mouse, a mitogen-driven limiting dilution culture system was used for a precursor frequency analysis of proliferating, of cytolytic and of IL 2-producing T cells, respectively, present in spleen and thymus of mice from neonatal to adult age. In adult mice, the majority (up to 100%) of splenic T cells was capable to respond to Concanavalin A. In contrast, an up to tenfold lower frequency of mitogen-reactive precursors was found within positively selected Thy-1+ spleen cells of neonatal mice. Within this fraction of Con A reactive neonatal T cells, there was an apparent imbalance in the CTLp/PTLp ratio within the first to second week after birth. Accordingly, significant numbers of immunocompetent precursors of HTLp were detected in the spleen shortly after birth, while the vast majority of CTLp developed later on. This differential development of CTLp and PTLp was not seen with thymocytes of the same mice, where from the age of two to three days on up to the adult age the frequency of both CTLp and PTLp remained largely unchanged. Analysis of the Lyt-antigen expression, in addition, revealed phenotypical differences between neonatal and adult Thy-1+ spleen cells, such that Lyt-2 antigen density but not the proportion of Lyt-2 positive T cells, was considerably lower in newborn mice. An age related increase in both Lyt-2 antigen density and CTLp frequency was parallelled by the rapid increase in the total number of splenic T cells during the second and third postnatal week, reaching 60-70% of adult values. At this time, a normalisation of the CTLp/PTLp ratio at approximately 0.4 had occurred.

A method for analysing the clonal precursors of concanavalin A-induced suppressor cells

Spleen cells from 3 different strains of mice (C57 (H-2b), CBA (H-2k) and BALB/c (H-2d] were stimulated in vitro with different concentrations of concanavalin A (CA) for 48 h. This resulted in the production of cells capable of inhibiting the generation of alloantigen-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) in a mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC). 1 microgram/ml was an effective concentration of CA to induce C57 and BALB/c suppressor cells (SC), but 5 micrograms/ml CA was required to induce CBA SC. SC precursors (SC-P) were shown to be radiosensitive and the results suggest that SC themselves may be radiosensitive. SC were effective in the presence of added interleukin-2 (IL-2). SC were then induced at limit dilution in microwells in a volume of 25 microliter. A MIC (200 microliter) was then (after 48 h) added to each microwell. This resulted in a dilution of the concentration of CA to a level below which it was effective at inducing suppression. Cytotoxicity was then assessed 7 days later. It was thus possible to analyse SC-P at the clonal level and estimate their frequency. The frequency of C57 splenic SC-P (active against a C57 anti-BALB/c MLC) was 14.4 X 10(-6), the frequency of CBA splenic SC-P (active against a CBA anti-BALB/c MLC) was 92.3 X 10(-6), and the frequency of BALB/c splenic SC-P (active against a BALB/c anti-CBA MLC) was 15.8 X 10(-6). It was possible to analyse SC-P at a clonal level whether or not the MLC contained added IL-2. SC and SC-P were shown to be sensitive to anti-Thy-1 and complement.

Immunofluorescent flow cytometry in N dimensions. The multiplex labeling approach

The problem of the simultaneous use in flow cytometry of N greater than 2 antibodies in conjunction with two fluorochromes was investigated. Theoretical analysis led to a labeling procedure and reconstruction formula that allow N-dimensional labeling distributions to be obtained from two-dimensional fluorescence distributions. The general problem of M greater than or equal to 2 fluorochromes and N greater than M antibodies was shown to be reducible to the case of two fluorochromes. The method was tested by a triple labeling analysis of murine thymocytes.

Rapid changes in specificity within single clones of cytolytic effector cells

We find rapid changes in the specificity of the cytolytic effector cells in a mixed lymphocyte culture. The lysis patterns produced by cytolytic effector cells generated near limiting dilution in murine mixed lymphocyte reactions of three types, F1 anti-parent (F1(A X B) anti-A), allogeneic (C anti-F1(A X B)), and F1 antimodified parent (F1(A X B) anti-A-TNP), were investigated. Cultures were characterized by their ability or inability to lyse a panel of target cells (e.g., A, B, F1). When individual cultures were tested at two different times, changes in lytic pattern were routinely seen, with some patterns reproducibly increasing in frequency and others reproducibly decreasing (e.g., patterns involving lysis of F1 decreased in an F1 anti-A response but increased in a C anti-F1 response). X-linked isoenzyme analysis showed that changes can occur within a single clone of effector cells. These results imply that the T cell specificity repertoire continues to evolve during an ongoing immune response, a conclusion incompatible with clonal selection theory.

Hyperthermia and the generation and activity of murine influenza-immune cytotoxic T cells in vitro

The rate of generation of murine secondary influenza virus-immune cytotoxic T cells in vitro is enhanced under limiting dilution conditions at hyperthermal temperatures (39 versus 37 degrees C). Increased mean values of cytotoxic activity were observed in the presence as well as absence of exogenous helper factors. Elevated cytotoxic activity at 39 degrees C was observed after day 3 to day 5 of culture. The number of autoreactive cytotoxic cells observed was not greater at 39 degrees C than at 37 degrees C. Elevated temperature did not influence target cell lysis or release of isotopes from killed target cells. The results are discussed with a view to the role of fever in augmenting the cellular immune response responsible for the host defense against primary viral infection.

High frequency of precursors of anomalous killer cells in human peripheral blood: evidence for T-cell regulation

The frequency of precursors (P) of the anomalous killer (AK) cells able to kill a melanoma target cell line without prior sensitization was determined by limiting dilution analysis. The frequencies obtained from the peripheral blood mononuclear cells of six healthy individuals ranged from 1/250 to 1/750, which was considerably higher than those of alloreactive cytolytic T-lymphocyte (CTL) precursors induced in the same cultures (range 1/900 to 1/7500). The presence of phytohemagglutinin (PHA) inhibited the appearance of both CTL and AK in bulk cocultures, and in limiting dilution analysis the presence of the lectin resulted in multiphasic cell dose-response curves rather than linear single hit responses for both types of precursor cells. The results suggest that AK-P are under the same type of regulation as are CTL-P.

The growth of concanavalin-A activated, Lyt selected subsets in IL-2 containing supernatants

The growth properties of Con A activated, Lyt selected splenic T lymphocytes were examined by limiting dilution analysis and clonally by single cell picking. Under the conditions used, a comparable frequency of Lyt 1+ and Lyt 2+ cells grew after Con A activation in the presence of Con A rat spleen supernatant. At a clonal level, however, the growth of these subsets differed qualitatively and quantitatively. While Lyt 2+ cells obtained clone sizes of several hundred cells, Lyt 1+ clone sizes were usually less than 100 cells, and many clones aborted their growth after a few days. Morphologically, the Lyt 1+ cell was smaller and usually showed fewer pseudopodial protusions as compared to the Lyt 2+ cell.

Quantitative studies on T-cell functions in MRL/MP-Lpr/Lpr mice. I. Frequency analysis of precursor cells of proliferating, cytotoxic, and T-cell growth factor-secreting T lymphocytes reveals an increase in absolute numbers, with a concomitant decrease in percentage of immunocompetent cells

A limiting dilution system has been applied to compare precursor frequencies of proliferating T lymphocytes (PTL-P), of T-cell growth factor-secreting T cells (TTCGF-P), and of cytotoxic T cells (CTL-P) in lymphocyte populations of aged, MRL/MP-lpr/lpr (MRL-lpr) mice and the congeneic strain MRL/MP- +/+ (MRL-n,), or the H-2k-compatible strains AKR/N and B10.BR responding to the mitogen concanavalin (ConA), to alloantigens (H-2) or to trinitrophenol (TNP)-modified syngeneic cells. In lymph node and spleen populations of 3- to 8-month-old MRL-lpr mice, the frequencies of H-2d- or ConA-reactive PTL-P and TTCGF-P, and of CTL-P sensitive to either H-2d, TNP, or ConA stimuli were between 5 to 30 times lower than in the corresponding populations of the other three strains. Furthermore, the frequencies of CTL-P progressively decreased in MRL-lpr mice from 3 to 8 months of age. In contrast, the absolute numbers of immunologically competent precursor T cells (PTL-P, TTCGF-P, CTL-P) was in general approximately 2- to 5-fold higher in MRL-lpr than in the control mice. However, these normal T cells do not seem to expand proportionally with the progressive lymphadenopathy in MRL-lpr mice since the number of T lymphocytes recovered from lymph nodes of the individual animals tested exceeded those of tissues from control mice by 30- to 300-fold. The results therefore suggest that mature T cells are progressively diluted out by abnormal lymphocytes in lymphocyte populations of aging MRL-lpr mice, thus causing a decrease of immune responses in vitro and possibly also affecting optimal cellular interactions in vivo.

Regulation of cytotoxic lymphocyte precursors: I. Interactions between concanavalin A and T cell growth factors

The induction of cytotoxic T lymphocytes by concanavalin A has been analyzed under conditions of limit dilution. The dose-response curves deviate from linearity in a way that has been interpreted as revealing successive zones of suppression as the cell concentration was increased. The magnitude of suppression was influenced by both the concentration of concanavalin A and the amount of T cell growth factors added to the culture. These regulatory events involve the cytotoxic T cell clones produced by (CBA X DBA)F1 spleen cells which are detected by DBA mastocytoma (P815) targets at a maximum detectable frequency of 1 in 2000 cells. Similar multiphase dose-response data were also obtained with syngeneic and allogeneic combinations with the same target cell. It is suggested that the successive zones of suppression and activation are a consequence of the relative frequencies of CTL-P, suppressive and helper cells, and the ease with which the cells are activated in limit dilution cultures. The experimental approach illustrates how CTL production can be manipulated to study the balance of signals required to control effector cell production.

Lysis of tumor biopsy cells by blood lymphocyte subsets of various densities. Autologous and allogeneic studies

Blood lymphocyte subsets of various densities from 14 healthy donors and 25 patients with solid tumors were used in tests for cytotoxicity against allogeneic or autologous tumor cells. The allogeneic combinations comprised 36 tests on 28 tumors. In these the unmanipulated total lymphocyte population was cytotoxic in one experiment. In tests with density-separated subsets, 16 experiments were positive. The lytic effect resided in the light subsets. Auto-tumor lysis was detected in 7 of 25 cases, when the total lymphocyte population was used. Eleven additional tests showed cytotoxicity with the separated subsets. The autologous tumor cells were damaged by the light lymphocytes of 15 patients. Of these patients, 6 had cytotoxic cells also in the high-density subset. In seven cases auto-tumor lysis was exerted only by the dense lymphocytes. Thus, in 13 cases the profile of auto-tumor lysis differed from that observed with the allogeneic combinations and against K562. Pretreatment of the effectors with Hu-IFN-alpha enhanced or induced cytotoxicity in the light lymphocytes, against both allogeneic and autologous tumors, while the dense subset was rarely potentiated. The autologous system may represent an immune situation and therefore it is not unexpected that the active cells should have different phenotypic characteristics from those of the operationally natural killer system.

The sensitization of mice with a wild-type and cold-adapted variant of influenza A virus. II. Secondary cytotoxic T cell responses

Reductions in virus titres and the generation of enhanced cytotoxic T cell (Tc) activity in the lungs of mice primed either with a wild-type, parental (H2N2) influenza virus, A/AA/6/60, or a cold-adapted variant A/AA/6/60-ca and challenged 6 weeks later with a H1N1 A/WSN virus showed that both H2N2 viruses could sensitize the mice. A comparison of graded sensitizing doses of each virus showed that inocula of 10(6) tissue culture infective doses (TCID50) of the ca-variant or 10(3) TCID50 of the wild-type virus gave similar results. The spleens and lungs of normal mice were found to contain similar levels (circa 1/10(5) cells) of precursor Tc cells and the level in the lung did not increase 2 days after intranasal (i.n.) inoculation of A/WSN virus. Two and 6 weeks after priming mice with 10(5) TCID50 of either virus, the lungs contained about a 20-fold increase in the precursor Tc cell frequency. In contrast, sensitization with a sub-lethal dose of a mouse-adapted A/WSN virus caused a 100-fold or greater increase. Sensitization of mice with the parental but not the ca-variant virus caused an increase in frequency of precursor Tc cells in the spleens of the sensitized mice and this might reflect the very low level of replication of the ca-variant virus in the mouse lung.

Two distinct cytotoxic T lymphocyte subpopulations in patients with Vogt-Koyanagi-Harada disease that recognize human melanoma cells

The functional properties of cytotoxic lymphocytes from patients with Vogt-Koyanagi-Harada disease ( VKH ) specific for human melanoma cells (P-36 melanoma cell line established from a patient with malignant melanoma) were investigated by using monoclonal antibodies specific for human T cell subsets. Peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) from patients with VKH showed significant cytotoxic activity against the P-36 (SK-MEL-28) human melanoma cell line, but not against a human cervical carcinoma of the uterus cell line (HeLa-S3 cell line) or against a mouse melanoma cell line (B-16 cell line) originating from a C57BL/6 strain mouse or against the EL-4 mouse lymphoma cell line from a C57BL/6 mouse. The cytotoxic activity of the patients' PBL against the P-36 melanoma cell line was markedly reduced by pretreatment of the PBL with monoclonal anti-human Leu-1 antibody plus rabbit complement, but it was reduced to much less extent by pretreatment with either monoclonal anti-human Leu-2a or Leu-3a antibody plus rabbit complement. The specific cytotoxic activity of the patients' PBL against the P-36 human melanoma cell line is, therefore, mediated by T cells bearing Leu-1+ Leu-2a+ or Leu-1+ Leu-3a+ antigens. Furthermore, the cytotoxic activity was shown to be blocked not only by anti-Leu-2a antibody specific to human cytotoxic/suppressor T cells but also unexpectedly by anti-Leu-3a antibody which has previously been considered to be specific to human inducer/helper T cells. The results of this study suggest that at least two distinct subpopulations of cytotoxic T cells specific for P-36 human melanoma cells are present in the peripheral blood of VKH patients. These cytotoxic T cells have different surface antigens, Leu-2a and Leu-3a.

Quantitative representation of all T cells committed to develop into cytotoxic effector cells and/or interleukin 2 activity-producing helper cells within murine T lymphocyte subsets

A limiting dilution culture system based on stimulation with concanavalin A (Con A) has been used to study the quantitative distribution of helper and of cytotoxic precursor cells in Lyt-2-defined subpopulations of murine T cells. Virtually all of the selected Lyt-2+ and Lyt-2-T cells grow and expand to large clonal colonies within an 8-9-day culture period. Our data show that upon stimulation with Con A, 90% of the Lyt-2-T cells were capable to produce interleukin 2 (IL 2) activity. In addition, IL 2 activity is produced by 8-10% of Lyt-2+ T cells. However, at the clonal level, the average of the IL2 activity produced by Lyt-2+ T cells is about 8-fold less as compared to Lyt-2-T cells. Precursors of cytotoxic T cells were almost exclusively found in the Lyt-2+ population, of which about 70% displayed lytic activity in a lectin-dependent cytolysis test. For the vast majority of clones analyzed the capacity to produce IL 2 activity and the capacity to express lytic activity, was found to be mutually exclusive. A minority of clones (less than 3%) was found to simultaneously produce IL 2 activity and to express cytotoxicity. These latter cells are therefore considered as bifunctional T cells.

Cytotoxic T-cell precursors revealed in neonatally tolerant mice

Induction of neonatal tolerance leads to a profound reduction in cytotoxic T-lymphocyte precursor frequencies against the tolerated alloantigen ("tolerogen") as evaluated by limiting-dilution analysis. The curves obtained were linear within the range tested and, thus, did not yield evidence for any dissociation of cytotoxic precursors from regulatory cell populations. However, it could be shown that cytotoxic T-lymphocyte precursor frequencies against the tolerogen increased drastically if the tolerant spleen cells were adsorbed, prior to limiting-dilution culture, on monolayers of syngeneic blasts expressing receptors for the tolerogen but not if they were adsorbed on syngeneic blasts against third-party antigens. This finding implies that cytotoxic precursor cells against the tolerogen are not clonally deleted in tolerant animals but rather are suppressed by a regulatory cell population that is present at high frequency and presumably acts in an anti-idiotypic fashion.

Frequency of herpes simplex virus-specific cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursors in lymph node cells of infected mice

The limiting dilution technique was used to estimate the frequency of cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursors (CTL-P) specific to herpes simplex virus (HSV)-infected syngeneic cells in draining lymph nodes from CBA mice infected 5 days previously with HSV. Significant numbers of virus specific CTL-P were found with infected mice whereas such cells were usually undetectable in uninfected mice. On the basis of MHC restriction and Lyt phenotype, the cells were identified as T lymphocytes. Two subsets of HSV-specific CTL-P could be defined; an infrequent one (1/12,500-1/30,000) which grew in the presence of growth promoting factors present in concanavalin A-conditioned medium, and a frequent population (f = 1/1200-1/4750) which in addition required exposure to antigen. In some experiments, the frequent subset of HSV-specific CTL-P was only detectable at low cell number inputs. Similar results in other systems have been explained by active suppression.

The analysis of an anti-fluorescein cytotoxic response

The detailed kinetics of the appearance of clones of anti-fluorescein cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) in a primary limiting dilution response have been examined. The addition of factors from the supernatants of concanavalin A-stimulated rat spleen cell cultures was necessary to obtain linear dose-response curves and strong primary responses. In a standard primary response the maximum detectable number of specific clones was found, on day 5, to be derived from precursors having a frequency of 1 in 10 000 spleen cells. When limiting dilution cultures were restimulated on day 3, responses on day 5 were unaffected but new clones appeared on day 7 with a frequency of 1 in 1000. The emergence of the day-7 response depends on the addition of factor(s) on day 3. It is proposed that the early low frequency precursors detected on day 5 and the high frequency precursors detected on days 7-9 are derived from two stages in the differentiation lineage of CTL precursors. Restimulation of limiting dilution cultures involves not only the continued clonal expansion of primary responses but also the emergence of new "clones" of specific CTL.

Quantitative studies on T cell diversity. IV. Mathematical analysis of multiple limiting populations of effector and suppressor T cells

Limiting dilution (LD) analyses of polyclonally activated T cells yielded results suggesting the existence of multiple paired populations of effector and suppressor precursors for a number of different T cell functions and specificities analyzed. These populations occur at graded frequencies and suppression occurs within a pair but not between pairs. In this paper, we establish the mathematical basis for the interpretation of these multi-component limiting dilution results. First, we derive equations for a number of mathematical models and identify one model that both makes biological sense and can be used to reproduce experimental data. Second, within this model, we identify parameters such as the frequency of suppressive cells and the number of suppressive cells required for suppression. The results suggest that within each paired population, suppressor precursors are 20 times more frequent that effector precursors. Furthermore, a similar but variable excess of suppressor cells is required for suppression to become effective. Together with the high frequency (1/50-1/500) of most effector T cell precursors previously reported, the results suggest that up to 40% of the T cells can become involved in suppression of an antigen-specific effector T cell population. These studies may provide exact estimates for predictions to be tested in experiments on immune regulation.

T-cell hyperreactivity of NZB mice against H-2 identical cells. Equal cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursor frequency against H-2 allogeneic and H-2 syngeneic target cells in NZB

NZB mice serve as a model for human systemic lupus erythematodes. T-cell abnormalities in this strain have previously been described. In this paper the cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursor (CTL-p) frequencies of NZB mice against H-2 allogeneic and H-2 syngeneic cells are investigated and compared with those of the normal strain BALB/c. The CTL-p frequency in NZB lymphocytes against H-2 allogeneic cells equals that in normal mouse strains (i.e. 1/7500). The NZB anti BALB/c response is in the same order of magnitude. No corresponding BALB/c anti NZB response was elicited. The results suggest abnormally high sensitivity of NZB CTL-p to helper signals.

Limiting dilution analysis of alloreactive T helper cells: precursor frequencies similar to that of alloreactive cytotoxic T cells

Precursor frequencies for alloreactive T helper cells involved in the generation of primary cytotoxic responses from thymocytes were determined in splenic T cells and selected Lyt-1 lymphocytes by limiting dilution analysis. T helper precursors at frequencies ranging from 1/5000 to 1/13,500 were found in individual experiments in unsensitized selected Lyt-1 populations reacting to H-2 alloantigens. After preactivation of Lyt-1 lymphocytes with antigen in limiting dilution, the frequencies of T helper cells were increased 2-3 fold when cultured in the absence and 10-50-fold when cultured in the presence of T cell growth factor. The frequencies for T helper precursors found in Lyt-1 cells were comparable to those of unselected T cells, indicating that a significant portion of T helper cells resides in the Lyt-123 population. Activation of T helper precursors with H-2 antigens or with H-2 and non-MHC (plus MLs) antigens resulted in similar frequencies, suggesting that the same T cell can respond to H-2 and non-MHC determinants. The data suggest that alloreactive T helper precursors exist at frequencies similar to that of CTL precursors. In addition, the results indicate that the induction of CTL by T helper cells is subject to regulation presumably by suppressive cells and that Lyt-1 inducer cells may be involved in the development of suppression for CTL responses.

Regulatory interactions between macrophages and T-cell subsets in Listeria monocytogenes-specific T-cell activation

Peritoneal exudate T lymphocytes from Listeria monocytogenes-immune mice in the presence of the homologous antigen (heat-killed L. monocytogenes) and normal macrophages showed L. monocytogenes-specific proliferative responses. Proliferation was inhibited by macrophages from L. monocytogenes- or Corynebacterium parvum-pretreated mice as well as by exogenous prostaglandin E(2). Macrophage-dependent inhibition of T-cell proliferation-at least in part-could be reversed by addition of indomethacin. When selected L. monocytogenes-immune Lyt T-cell subsets were cultured in the presence of inhibitory macrophages, pretreatment with anti-Lyt 1 antiserum plus complement completely abrogated proliferation and pretreatment with anti-Lyt 2 and anti-Lyt 3 antisera plus complement markedly reduced proliferation. However, a mixture (1:1) of the two preselected Lyt T-cell subsets resulted in complete reconstitution of proliferative responses. In contrast, when L. monocytogenes-immune peritoneal exudate T lymphocytes were treated with anti-Lyt antisera plus complement after culture, only treatment with anti-Lyt 1 antiserum plus complement affected proliferation, suggesting regulatory interactions between Lyt 1(+)23(-) and Lyt 1(-)23(+) T cells during in vitro culture which result in proliferation within the Lyt 1(+)23(-) T-cell subset. After rigorous depletion of residual macrophages and in the presence of indomethacin, pretreatment with anti-Lyt 1 antiserum plus complement, but not with anti-Lyt 2 and 3 antisera plus complement, eliminated proliferation. The data presented indicate that interactions between macrophages and Lyt T-cell subsets regulate L. monocytogenes-specific T-cell activation.

Quantitative studies on T cell diversity. III. Limiting dilution analysis of precursor cells for T helper cells reactive to xenogeneic erythrocytes

Splenic T cells exposed to concanavalin A (Con A), and subsequently to factors produced by rat spleen cells in response to Con A (Con A sup), acquire the ability to function as helper T (TH) cells in response to xenogeneic erythrocytes (RBC). Help is measured as the reconstitution of the plaque-forming cell response of a spleen cell population depleted of T cells by treatment with anti-Thy-1 serum and complement. We propose that precursor TH cells differentiate during the in vitro treatment into mature TH cells. As differentiation occurs under limiting dilution conditions, an estimation of the precursor frequency should in principle be possible. However, a single-hit Poisson distribution does not fit our data. Instead, we observe, dependent on the T cell concentration, three separate "peaks" of response. In many experiments, using sheep, horse, and chicken RBC as antigens, we reproducibly find these "peaks" at 40-190, 600-3,000, and 20,000-100,000 T cells, placed into limiting dilution cultures, respectively. By various experiments we can show that the helper activity is not due to passively transferred rat factors, but to the titrated cells themselves. The active cell is a T cell that appears to function in an antigen-specific way and to require direct cell contact to do so. It thus resembles the classical helper T cell. As we find precursor TH cells already at very low concentrations of T cells, we titrated the range between 0 and 100 T cells/well carefully. The bent shape of the titration curves does not always allow a statistically satisfying regression analysis, and we therefore cannot estimate precise precursor frequencies from every experiment. However, a common sense argument can be made that these frequencies must be on the order of 1/10-1/100 T cells. We propose that the limiting dilution curves obtained in this system most likely reflect fundamentally important cellular interactions that regulate immunological effector functions. We favor a concept of independently interacting sets of helper and suppressor T cells of various frequencies, but other models are possible.

A method for the accurate determination of anti-hapten cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursors: correction for apparent 'anti-self' reactivity

A method is described for accurately determining the frequency of precursors of hapten specific cytotoxic T cells. The method is based on a standard Poisson analysis of limit dilution cultures, but makes a correction of 'anti-self' reacting clones and for spontaneously arising clones that recognise modified self. These corrections are shown to be especially important when low hapten densities are used, where there may be more than a 10-fold difference between the corrected and uncorrected frequency estimates. Determined levels of antigen specificity and of H-2 restriction are significantly enhanced by application of this method.

Regulation of in vitro cytotoxic T lymphocyte generation. I. Evidence that killer cell precursors differentiate to effector cells in two steps

The differentiation of cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursor cells (CTL-P) into CTL effector cells is a two-step process. In the first step, naïve CTL-P (CTL-PN) become activated (CTL-PA) but do not yet have the capacity to kill target cells. CTL-PA can be distinguished from CTL-PN because the former are far less sensitive than the latter to the effects of in vitro-generated suppressor cells. Thus, the addition of suppressor T cells (Ts) to a fresh MLC can totally inhibit the production of CTL from CTL-PN, whereas the same Ts only minimally affect the generation of CTL from CTL-PA. It is not known whether these Ts act directly on CTL-PN or on a helper cell needed for activation to CTL-PA. The production of CTL-PA can take place in allogeneic mixed leukocyte cultures (MLC) treated with the drug pyrilamine, or when heat-inactivated stimulator cells are used. Each of these treatments inhibits the differentiation of CTL-PA to CTL. However, if pyrilamine is removed, a nonspecific MLC-derived signal can induce these CTL-PA to become CTL, even in the presence of significant numbers of Ts. This two step process of differentiation of CTL-P to CTL may be analogous to the way naïve B cells become antibody-producing cells.

Heterogeneity of soluble T cell products. I. Precursor frequency and correlation analysis of cytotoxic and immune interferon (IFN-gamma)-producing spleen cells in the mouse

In this study, the precursor frequency, relationship and activity of murine splenic cytotoxic and immune interferon (IFN-gamma)-producing cells has been determined. C57BL/6 spleen cells were activated by concanavalin A (Con A) and subsequently grown in microcultures under limiting dilution conditions. The progeny of cells plated in microcultures was divided and tested for (a) total cytotoxic activity on EL4 (H-2b) tumor target cells in the presence of Con A to nonspecifically attach the killer to the target cells, and (b) the quantity of IFN-gamma released by Con A stimulation. Cytotoxic T lymphocytes and IFN-gamma-producing cells were present in Con A-activated C57BL/6 spleen cells at a high frequency of approximately 1 out of 3 and 1 out of 2 cells, respectively. IFN-gamma could be released from both noncytotoxic and a large fraction of cytotoxic T cells and the cytotoxic activity was not necessarily associated with IFN-gamma release. In a few selected cultures with a progeny of cells plated at a low cell number (up to 10/well) very high IFN-gamma titers (greater than 10 000 U/ml) could be found. These results provide the first frequency estimate of IFN-producing cells and are discussed with respect to the physiological role of IFN-gamma release from T cells.

Expression of Qat-4 and Qat-5 alloantigens on cytotoxic precursor and effector cells: different surface phenotypes of alloreactive and H-2 restricted cytotoxic T cells

Monoclonal anti-Qat-4 and anti-Qat-5 antibodies, which define antigens expressed on peripheral T cell subsets, have been used to study the phenotypes of alloreactive and H-2-restricted cytotoxic effector cells and their precursors. Depletion of Qat-4+ or Qat-5% cells from the T cell pool prior to their sensitization in bulk cultures prevented the development of alloreactive and H-2-restricted cytotoxic activities in the selected populations. No reconstitution of cytolytic activities to normal levels was obtained when mixtures of Qat-4- and Qat-5- cells were sensitized in bulk cultures to H-2 or non-H-2 antigens. Sensitization of limiting numbers of Qat-4- or Qat-5- lymphocytes under optimal conditions for help (interleukin 2), with the appropriated antigens (H-2 or H-Y) did not result in the generation of cytotoxic T cells, indicating that the majority of all cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) precursors are Qat-4+, Qat-5+. When CTL effector populations were treated with the antisera and complement (C) at their maximum CTL activity, it was found that H-2-restricted CTL were totally eliminated by anti-Qat-4 and considerably reduced by anti-Qat-5 antisera and C. In contrast, alloreactive CTL effector cells were insensitive to anti-Qat-4 and to anti-Qat-5 plus C. Although alloreactive CTL effector populations regained some Qat-4 antigens during further in vitro culture, it was shown that H-2-restricted CTL were at all times more sensitive to anti-Qat-4 than were alloreactive CTL. The findings suggest that during maturation of alloreactive and H-2-restricted CTL from their precursors, both alloantigens undergo differential quantitative variations in their expression that lead to different Qat-4,5 phenotypes of alloreactive and H-2-restricted CTL.

Recognition of polymorphic H-2 domains by T lymphocytes. I. Functional role of different H-2 domains for the generation of alloreactive cytotoxic T lymphocytes and determination of precursor frequencies

In the present communication, the repertoire of alloreactive cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) clones was quantitatively investigated by limiting dilution analysis and by target inhibition with a panel of monoclonal antibodies (mAb). These mAb have previously been shown to define two distinct alloantigenic domains, A and B, on the H-2Kk molecule. The Poisson distribution analysis of H-2Kk-specific CTL clones generated in a limiting dilution system revealed three CTL populations with different precursor frequencies. The high frequent population is suppressed by an unknown suppressive mechanism that allows less frequent CTL populations to become visible. Target inhibition studies with a panel of Kk-specific mAb showed that these CTL populations differ not only in their precursor frequency but also in their specificity for different H-2 epitopes on the Kk molecule. Thus clones of the high frequency population are almost exclusively specific for determinants within domain A. In contrast, the low frequency population displays predominant specificity for determinants of domain B, while the population with medium frequency is blocked equally well by mAb against either domains A or B. Each mAb blocked only a fraction of clones indicating that each CTL subpopulation may consist of a large number of clonotypes with specificity for different H-2 epitopes. The data suggest that CTL recognize basically the same polymorphic domains on the H-2Kk molecule defined by antibodies, and they show that regulatory mechanisms determine the expressed repertoire in CTL populations.