To be, or not to be two sites: that is the question about LeuT substrate binding

Identification of a New Allosteric Binding Site for Cocaine in Dopamine Transporter

Dopamine (DA) transporter (DAT) is a major target for psychostimulant drugs of abuse such as cocaine that competitively binds to DAT, inhibits DA reuptake, and consequently increases synaptic DA levels. In addition to the central binding site inside DAT, the available experimental evidence suggests the existence of alternative binding sites on DAT, but detection and characterization of these sites are challenging by experiments alone. Here, we integrate multiple computational approaches to probe the potential binding sites on the wild-type Drosophila melanogaster DAT and identify a new allosteric site that displays high affinity for cocaine. This site is located on the surface of DAT, and binding of cocaine is primarily dominated by interactions with hydrophobic residues surrounding the site. We show that cocaine binding to this new site allosterically reduces the binding of DA/cocaine to the central binding pocket, and simultaneous binding of two cocaine molecules to a single DAT seems infeasible. Furthermore, we find that binding of cocaine to this site stabilizes the conformation of DAT but alters the conformational population and thereby reduces the accessibility by DA, providing molecular insights into the inhibitory mechanism of cocaine. In addition, our results indicate that the conformations induced by cocaine binding to this site may be relevant to the oligomerization of DAT, highlighting a potential role of this new site in modulating the function of DAT.

Toward a Systematic Structural and Functional Annotation of Solute Carriers Transporters-Example of the SLC6 and SLC7 Families

SLC transporters are emerging key drug targets. One important step for drug development is the profound understanding of the structural determinants defining the substrate selectivity of each transporter. Recently, the improvement of computational power and experimental methods such as X-ray and cryo-EM crystallography permitted to conduct structure-based studies on specific transporters having important pharmacological impact. However, a lot remains to be discovered regarding their dynamics, transport modulation and ligand recognition. A detailed functional characterization of transporters would provide opportunities to develop new compounds targeting these key drug targets. Here, we are giving an overview of two major human LeuT-fold families, SLC6 and SLC7, with an emphasis on the most relevant members of each family for drug development. We gather the most recent understanding on the structural determinants of selectivity within and across the two families. We then use this information to discuss the benefits of a more generalized structural and functional annotation of the LeuT fold and the implications of such mapping for drug discovery.

Mapping of Ion and Substrate Binding Sites in Human Sodium Iodide Symporter (hNIS)

The human sodium iodide symporter (hNIS) is a theranostic reporter gene which concentrates several clinically approved SPECT and PET radiotracers and plays an essential role for the synthesis of thyroid hormones as an iodide transporter in the thyroid gland. Development of hNIS mutants which could enhance translocation of the desired imaging ions is currently underway. Unfortunately, it is hindered by lack of understanding of the 3D organization of hNIS and its relation to anion transport. There are no known crystal structures of hNIS in any of its conformational states. Homology modeling can be very effective in such situations; however, the low sequence identity between hNIS and relevant secondary transporters with available experimental structures makes the choice of a template and the generation of 3D models nontrivial. Here, we report a combined application of homology modeling and molecular dynamics refining of the hNIS structure in its semioccluded state. The modeling was based on templates from the LeuT-fold protein family and was done with emphasis on the refinement of the substrate-ion binding pocket. The consensus model developed in this work is compared to available biophysical and biochemical experimental data for a number of different LeuT-fold proteins. Some functionally important residues contributing to the formation of putative binding sites and permeation pathways for the cotransported Na⁺ ions and I^- substrate were identified. The model predictions were experimentally tested by generation of mutant versions of hNIS and measurement of relative (to WT hNIS) ¹²⁵I^- uptake of 35 hNIS variants.

Molecular Determinants for Substrate Interactions with the Glycine Transporter GlyT2

Transporters in the SLC6 family play key roles in regulating neurotransmission and are the targets for a wide range of therapeutics. Important insights into the transport mechanisms and the specificity of drug interactions of SLC6 transporters have been obtained from the crystal structures of a bacterial homologue of the family, LeuT_Aa, and more recently the Drosophila dopamine transporter and the human serotonin transporter. However, there is disputed evidence that the bacterial leucine transporter, LeuT_Aa, contains two substrate binding sites that work cooperatively in the mechanism of transport, with the binding of a second substrate being required for the release of the substrate from the primary site. An alternate proposal is that there may be low affinity binding sites that serve to direct the flow of substrates to the primary site. We have used a combination of molecular dynamics simulations of substrate interactions with a homology model of GlyT2, together with radiolabeled amino acid uptake assays and electrophysiological analysis of wild-type and mutant transporters, to provide evidence that substrate selectivity of GlyT2 is determined entirely by the primary substrate binding site and, furthermore, if a secondary site exists then it is a low affinity nonselective amino acid binding site.

Ligand Binding in the Extracellular Vestibule of the Neurotransmitter Transporter Homologue LeuT

The human monoamine transporters (MATs) facilitate the reuptake of monoamine neurotransmitters from the synaptic cleft. MATs are linked to a number of neurological diseases and are the targets of both therapeutic and illicit drugs. Until recently, no high-resolution structures of the human MATs existed, and therefore, studies of this transporter family have relied on investigations of the homologues bacterial transporters such as the leucine transporter LeuT, which has been crystallized in several conformational states. A two-substrate transport mechanism has been suggested for this transporter family, which entails that high-affinity binding of a second substrate in an extracellular site is necessary for the substrate in the central binding site to be transported. Compelling evidence for this mechanism has been presented, however, a number of equally compelling accounts suggest that the transporters function through a mechanism involving only a single substrate and a single high-affinity site. To shed light on this apparent contradiction, we have performed extensive molecular dynamics simulations of LeuT in the outward-occluded conformation with either one or two substrates bound to the transporter. We have also calculated the substrate binding affinity in each of the two proposed binding sites through rigorous free energy simulations. Results show that substrate binding is unstable in the extracellular vestibule and the substrate binding affinity within the suggested extracellular site is very low (0.2 and 3.3 M for the two dominant binding modes) compared to the central substrate binding site (14 nM). This suggests that for LeuT in the outward-occluded conformation only a single high-affinity substrate binding site exists.

Direct assessment of substrate binding to the Neurotransmitter:Sodium Symporter LeuT by solid state NMR

The Neurotransmitter:Sodium Symporters (NSSs) represent an important class of proteins mediating sodium-dependent uptake of neurotransmitters from the extracellular space. The substrate binding stoichiometry of the bacterial NSS protein, LeuT, and thus the principal transport mechanism, has been heavily debated. Here we used solid state NMR to specifically characterize the bound leucine ligand and probe the number of binding sites in LeuT. We were able to produce high-quality NMR spectra of substrate bound to microcrystalline LeuT samples and identify one set of sodium-dependent substrate-specific chemical shifts. Furthermore, our data show that the binding site mutants F253A and L400S, which probe the major S1 binding site and the proposed S2 binding site, respectively, retain sodium-dependent substrate binding in the S1 site similar to the wild-type protein. We conclude that under our experimental conditions there is only one detectable leucine molecule bound to LeuT.

DOI:http://dx.doi.org/10.7554/eLife.19314.001

All living cells need amino acids – the building blocks of proteins – in order to survive, yet few cells can make all the amino acids that they need. Instead, transporter proteins in cell membranes must take these molecules from the outside of the cell and release them to the inside. Some cells, including those in the brain, also release amino acids and molecules derived from them into the spaces outside of the cell to send signals to other nearby cells. Again, transporter proteins must move these signaling molecules back inside cells, to stop the signaling and to allow the molecules to be recycled. Importantly, problems with these uptake mechanisms have been linked to disorders such as depression, epilepsy and Parkinson’s disease.

One family of transporters involved in the uptake of amino acids are the “Neurotransmitter:Sodium Symporters”. Though these proteins are involved in processes that are fundamental to life, it remains unclear exactly how they work. Specifically, it has been heavily debated whether this family of transporters require one or two amino acid molecules to bind at the same time in order to help transport them across the membrane.

Now Erlendsson, Gotfryd et al. have analyzed a bacterial protein in the Neurotransmitter:Sodium Symporter family. This transporter takes up an amino acid called leucine into cells, and is commonly used as a model to understand this family of transporter proteins more generally. Using a technique called solid state nuclear magnetic resonance, Erlendsson, Gotfryd et al. could detect a single molecule of leucine bound to each transporter, but not a second one. This technique could also pinpoint that the leucine was located at the transporter’s central binding site. Leucine was never found at the proposed secondary binding site. Together these findings suggest that only one molecule of leucine binds to the transporter at any one time, and that it binds to the transporter’s central binding site.

Erlendsson, Gotfryd et al. have shown now how solid state nuclear magnetic resonance can be used to explore in detail how Neurotransmitter:Sodium Symporters move molecules across cell membranes. The next challenge is to use the same experimental setup to characterize other Neurotransmitter:Sodium Symporters. Doing so could potentially lay the groundwork for designing more specific and improved drugs to treat disorders like depression and Parkinson’s disease.

DOI:http://dx.doi.org/10.7554/eLife.19314.002

Allosteric Mechanisms of Molecular Machines at the Membrane: Transport by Sodium-Coupled Symporters

Solute transport across cell membranes is ubiquitous in biology as an essential physiological process. Secondary active transporters couple the unfavorable process of solute transport against its concentration gradient to the energetically favorable transport of one or several ions. The study of such transporters over several decades indicates that their function involves complex allosteric mechanisms that are progressively being revealed in atomistic detail. We focus on two well-characterized sodium-coupled symporters: the bacterial amino acid transporter LeuT, which is the prototype for the "gated pore" mechanism in the mammalian synaptic monoamine transporters, and the archaeal GltPh, which is the prototype for the "elevator" mechanism in the mammalian excitatory amino acid transporters. We present the evidence for the role of allostery in the context of a quantitative formalism that can reconcile biochemical and biophysical data and thereby connects directly to recent insights into the molecular structure and dynamics of these proteins. We demonstrate that, while the structures and mechanisms of these transporters are very different, the available data suggest a common role of specific models of allostery in their functions. We argue that such allosteric mechanisms appear essential not only for sodium-coupled symport in general but also for the function of other types of molecular machines in the membrane.

Monoamine transporters: insights from molecular dynamics simulations

The human monoamine transporters (MATs) facilitate the reuptake of the neurotransmitters serotonin, dopamine, and norepinephrine from the synaptic cleft. Imbalance in monoaminergic neurotransmission is linked to various diseases including major depression, attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, schizophrenia, and Parkinson's disease. Inhibition of the MATs is thus an important strategy for treatment of such diseases. The MATs are sodium-coupled transport proteins belonging to the neurotransmitter/Na(+) symporter (NSS) family, and the publication of the first high-resolution structure of a NSS family member, the bacterial leucine transporter LeuT, in 2005, proved to be a major stepping stone for understanding this family of transporters. Structural data allows for the use of computational methods to study the MATs, which in turn has led to a number of important discoveries. The process of substrate translocation across the membrane is an intrinsically dynamic process. Molecular dynamics simulations, which can provide atomistic details of molecular motion on ns to ms timescales, are therefore well-suited for studying transport processes. In this review, we outline how molecular dynamics simulations have provided insight into the large scale motions associated with transport of the neurotransmitters, as well as the presence of external and internal gates, the coupling between ion and substrate transport, and differences in the conformational changes induced by substrates and inhibitors.

Identification of the First Highly Subtype-Selective Inhibitor of Human GABA Transporter GAT3

Screening a library of small-molecule compounds using a cell line expressing human GABA transporter 3 (hGAT3) in a [(3)H]GABA uptake assay identified isatin derivatives as a new class of hGAT3 inhibitors. A subsequent structure-activity relationship (SAR) study led to the identification of hGAT3-selective inhibitors (i.e., compounds 20 and 34) that were superior to the reference hGAT3 inhibitor, (S)-SNAP-5114, in terms of potency (low micromolar IC50 values) and selectivity (>30-fold selective for hGAT3 over hGAT1/hGAT2/hBGT1). Further pharmacological characterization of compound 20 (5-(thiophen-2-yl)indoline-2,3-dione) revealed a noncompetitive mode of inhibition at hGAT3. This suggests that this compound class, which has no structural resemblance to GABA, has a binding site different from the substrate, GABA. This was supported by a molecular modeling study that suggested a unique binding site that matched the observed selectivity, inhibition kinetics, and SAR of the compound series. These compounds are the most potent GAT3 inhibitors reported to date that provide selectivity for GAT3 over other GABA transporter subtypes.

Structural insights into functional lipid-protein interactions in secondary transporters

BACKGROUND

Structural evidences with functional corroborations have revealed distinct features of lipid-protein interactions especially in channels and receptors. Many membrane embedded transporters are also known to require specific lipids for their functions and for some of them cellular and biochemical data suggest tight regulation by the lipid bilayer. However, molecular details on lipid-protein interactions in transporters are sparse since lipids are either depleted from the detergent solubilized transporters in three-dimensional crystals or not readily resolved in crystal structures. Nevertheless the steady increase in the progress of transporter structure determination contributed more examples of structures with resolved lipids.

SCOPE OF REVIEW

This review gives an overview on transporter structures in complex with lipids reported to date and discusses commonly encountered difficulties in the identification of functionally significant lipid-protein interactions based on those structures and functional in vitro data. Recent structures provided molecular details into regulation mechanism of transporters by specific lipids. The review highlights common findings and conserved patterns for distantly related transporter families to draw a more general picture on the regulatory role of lipid-protein interactions.

MAJOR CONCLUSIONS

Several common themes of the manner in which lipids directly influence membrane-mediated folding, oligomerization and structure stability can be found. Especially for LeuT-like fold transporters similarities in structurally resolved lipid-protein interactions suggest a common way in which transporter conformations are affected by lipids even in evolutionarily distinct transporters. Lipids appear to play an additional role as joints mechanically reinforcing the inverted repeat topology, which is a major determinant in the alternating access mechanism of secondary transporters.

GENERAL SIGNIFICANCE

This review brings together and adds to the repertoire of knowledge on lipid-protein interactions of functional significance presented in structures of membrane transporters. Knowledge of specific lipid-binding sites and modes of lipid influence on these proteins not only accomplishes the molecular description of transport cycle further, but also sheds light into localization dependent differences of transporter function. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled Structural biochemistry and biophysics of membrane proteins.

SLC6 transporters: structure, function, regulation, disease association and therapeutics

The SLC6 family of secondary active transporters are integral membrane solute carrier proteins characterized by the Na(+)-dependent translocation of small amino acid or amino acid-like substrates. SLC6 transporters, which include the serotonin, dopamine, norepinephrine, GABA, taurine, creatine, as well as amino acid transporters, are associated with a number of human diseases and disorders making this family a critical target for therapeutic development. In addition, several members of this family are directly involved in the action of drugs of abuse such as cocaine, amphetamines, and ecstasy. Recent advances providing structural insight into this family have vastly accelerated our ability to study these proteins and their involvement in complex biological processes.

Nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs and other anthranilic acids inhibit the Na(+)/dicarboxylate symporter from Staphylococcus aureus

The Na(+)/dicarboxylate symporter from Staphylococcus aureus, named SdcS, is a member of the divalent anion sodium symporter (DASS) family that also includes the mammalian SLC13 Na(+)/dicarboxylate cotransporters, NaDC1 and NaCT. The mammalian members of the family are sensitive to inhibition by anthranilic acid derivatives such as N-(p-amylcinnamoyl)anthranilic acid (ACA), which act as slow inhibitors. This study shows that SdcS is inhibited by ACA as well as the fenamate nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, flufenamate and niflumate. The inhibition was rapid and reversible. The IC(50) for ACA was approximately 55 μM. Succinate kinetics by SdcS were sigmoidal, with a K(0.5) of 9 μM and a Hill coefficient of 1.5. Addition of ACA decreased the V(max) and increased the Hill coefficient without affecting the K(0.5), consistent with its activity as a negative modulator of SdcS activity. ACA inhibition was not correlated with the K(0.5) for succinate in SdcS mutants, and ACA did not affect the reactivity of the N108C mutant to the cysteine reagent, MTSET. We conclude that ACA and other anthranilic acid derivatives are effective allosteric inhibitors of SdcS. Furthermore, the mechanism of inhibition appears to be distinct from the mechanism observed in human NaDC1.

Substrate binds in the S1 site of the F253A mutant of LeuT, a neurotransmitter sodium symporter homologue

LeuT serves as the model protein for understanding the relationships between structure, mechanism and pharmacology in neurotransmitter sodium symporters (NSSs). At the present time, however, there is a vigorous debate over whether there is a single high-affinity substrate site (S1) located at the original, crystallographically determined substrate site or whether there are two high-affinity substrates sites, one at the primary or S1 site and the other at a second site (S2) located at the base of the extracellular vestibule. In an effort to address the controversy over the number of high-affinity substrate sites in LeuT, one group studied the F253A mutant of LeuT and asserted that in this mutant substrate binds exclusively to the S2 site and that 1 mM clomipramine entirely ablates substrate binding to the S2 site. Here we study the binding of substrate to the F253A mutant of LeuT using ligand binding and X-ray crystallographic methods. Both experimental methods unambiguously show that substrate binds to the S1 site of the F253A mutant and that binding is retained in the presence of 1 mM clomipramine. These studies, in combination with previous work, are consistent with a mechanism for LeuT that involves a single high-affinity substrate binding site.

Insights from molecular dynamics: the binding site of cocaine in the dopamine transporter and permeation pathways of substrates in the leucine and dopamine transporters

The dopamine transporter (DAT) facilitates the regulation of synaptic neurotransmitter levels. As a target for therapeutic and illicit psycho-stimulant drugs like antidepressants and cocaine, DAT has been studied intensively. Despite a wealth of mutational and physiological data regarding DAT, the structure remains unsolved and details of the transport mechanism, binding sites and conformational changes remain debated. A bacterial homolog of DAT, the leucine transporter (LeuT(Aa)) has been used as a template and framework for modeling and understanding DAT. Free energy profiles obtained from Multi-Configuration Thermodynamic Integration simulations allowed us to correctly identify the primary and secondary binding pockets of LeuT(Aa). A comparison of free energy profiles for dopamine and cocaine in DAT suggests that the binding site of cocaine is located in a secondary pocket, not the primary substrate site. Two recurring primary pathways for intracellular substrate release from the primary pocket are identified in both transporters using the Random Acceleration Molecular Dynamics method. One pathway appears to follow transmembranes (TMs) 1a and 6b while the other pathway follows along TMs 6b and 8. Interestingly, we observe that a single sodium ion is co-transported with leucine during both simulation types.

Structures of LeuT in bicelles define conformation and substrate binding in a membrane-like context

Neurotransmitter sodium symporters (NSSs) catalyze the uptake of neurotransmitters into cells, terminating neurotransmission at chemical synapses. Consistent with the role of NSSs in the central nervous system, they are implicated in multiple diseases and disorders. LeuT, from Aquifex aeolicus, is a prokaryotic ortholog of the NSS family and has contributed to our understanding of the structure, mechanism and pharmacology of NSSs. At present, however, the functional state of LeuT in crystals grown in the presence of n-octyl-β-D-glucopyranoside (β-OG) and the number of substrate binding sites are controversial issues. Here we present crystal structures of LeuT grown in DMPC-CHAPSO bicelles and demonstrate that the conformations of LeuT-substrate complexes in lipid bicelles and in β-OG detergent micelles are nearly identical. Furthermore, using crystals grown in bicelles and the substrate leucine or the substrate analog selenomethionine, we find only a single substrate molecule in the primary binding site.