Bisphenols alter thermal responses and performance in zebrafish (Danio rerio)

Warming and pollution interact to alter energy transfer efficiency, performance and fitness across generations in zebrafish (Danio rerio)

Energy transfer efficiency across different trophic levels, from food to new biomass, can determine population dynamics and food-web function. Here we show that the energy needed to produce a unit of new biomass increases with warming and exposure to bisphenol A (BPA), an endocrine disrupting compound. These environmental effects are at least partially transmitted across generations via DNA methylation. We raised parental (F0) and their offspring (F1) zebrafish (Danio rerio) of two genotypes (DNA methyltransferase 3a knock-out [DNMT3a-/-] and wild type [DNMT3a+/+]) at different temperatures (24 and 30 °C), with and without BPA (0 and 10 μg l-1) to test whether the effects of BPA are i) temperature specific, ii) mediated by DNA methylation, and iii) transmitted across generations even if offspring are not exposed. All experimental factors interacted to influence growth in length and mass, and metabolic rates with the result that wild-type F0 and F1 fish experienced the greatest energetic cost of growth under warm conditions in the presence of BPA. However, this response was not observed in DNMT3a-/- fish, indicating that DNA methylation is at least partly responsible for mediating these effects. Under the same conditions (warm + BPA) wild-type parents had reduced swimming performance, and reduced fecundity, and offspring embryonic survival was reduced significantly; genotype affected these responses significantly. Our results indicate that the conditions that are becoming increasingly common globally - warming and endocrine disrupting compounds from plastic pollution and production - can have detrimental effects on energy transfer efficiency and thereby potentially on food-web structure. These effects can be transmitted across generations even if offspring are not exposed to the pollutant, and are likely to have ramifications for conservation and fisheries.

Feeding frequency does not interact with BPA exposure to influence metabolism or behaviour in zebrafish (Danio rerio)

Resource limitation can constrain energy (ATP) production, and thereby affect locomotion and behaviour such as exploration of novel environments and boldness. Consequently, ecological processes such as dispersal and interactions within and between species may be influenced by food availability. Energy metabolism, and behaviour are regulated by endocrine signalling, and may therefore be impacted by endocrine disrupting compounds (EDCs) including bisphenol A (BPA) derived from plastic manufacture and pollution. It is important to determine the impacts of these novel environmental contexts to understand how human activity alters individual physiology and behaviour and thereby populations. Our aim was to determine whether BPA exposure interacts with feeding frequency to alter metabolism and behaviour. In a fully factorial experiment, we show that low feeding frequency reduced zebrafish (Danio rerio) mass, condition, resting metabolic rates, total distance moved and speed in a novel arena, as well as anxiety indicated by the number of times fish returned to a dark shelter. However, feeding frequency did not significantly affect maximal metabolic rates, aerobic scope, swimming performance, latency to leave a shelter, or metabolic enzyme activities (citrate synthase and lactate dehydrogenase). Natural or anthropogenic fluctuation in food resources can therefore impact energetics and movement of animals with repercussions for ecological processes such as dispersal. BPA exposure reduced LDH activity and body mass, but did not interact with feeding frequency. Hence, behaviour of adult fish is relatively insensitive to disruption by BPA. However, alteration of LDH activity by BPA could disrupt lactate metabolism and signalling and together with reduction in body mass could affect size-dependent reproductive output. BPA released by plastic manufacture and pollution can thereby impact conservation and management of natural resources.

Combined threats of climate change and contaminant exposure through the lens of bioenergetics

Organisms face energetic challenges of climate change in combination with suites of natural and anthropogenic stressors. In particular, chemical contaminant exposure has neurotoxic, endocrine-disrupting, and behavioral effects which may additively or interactively combine with challenges associated with climate change. We used a literature review across animal taxa and contaminant classes, but focused on Arctic endotherms and contaminants important in Arctic ecosystems, to demonstrate potential for interactive effects across five bioenergetic domains: (1) energy supply, (2) energy demand, (3) energy storage, (4) energy allocation tradeoffs, and (5) energy management strategies; and involving four climate change-sensitive environmental stressors: changes in resource availability, temperature, predation risk, and parasitism. Identified examples included relatively equal numbers of synergistic and antagonistic interactions. Synergies are often suggested to be particularly problematic, since they magnify biological effects. However, we emphasize that antagonistic effects on bioenergetic traits can be equally problematic, since they can reflect dampening of beneficial responses and result in negative synergistic effects on fitness. Our review also highlights that empirical demonstrations remain limited, especially in endotherms. Elucidating the nature of climate change-by-contaminant interactive effects on bioenergetic traits will build toward determining overall outcomes for energy balance and fitness. Progressing to determine critical species, life stages, and target areas in which transformative effects arise will aid in forecasting broad-scale bioenergetic outcomes under global change scenarios.

Can animals tune tissue mechanics in response to changing environments caused by anthropogenic impacts?

Anthropogenic climate change and pollution are impacting environments across the globe. This Review summarises the potential impact of such anthropogenic effects on animal tissue mechanics, given the consequences for animal locomotor performance and behaviour. More specifically, in light of current literature, this Review focuses on evaluating the acute and chronic effects of temperature on the mechanical function of muscle tissues. For ectotherms, maximal muscle performance typically occurs at temperatures approximating the natural environment of the species. However, species vary in their ability to acclimate to chronic changes in temperature, which is likely to have longer-term effects on species range. Some species undergo periods of dormancy to avoid extreme temperature or drought. Whilst the skeletal muscle of such species generally appears to be adapted to minimise muscle atrophy and maintain performance for emergence from dormancy, the increased occurrence of extreme climatic conditions may reduce the survival of individuals in such environments. This Review also considers the likely impact of anthropogenic pollutants, such as hormones and heavy metals, on animal tissue mechanics, noting the relative paucity of literature directly investigating this key area. Future work needs to determine the direct effects of anthropogenic environmental changes on animal tissues and related changes in locomotor performance and behaviour, including accounting for currently unknown interactions between environmental factors, e.g. temperature and pollutants.

Bisphenol S reduces locomotor performance and modifies muscle protein levels but not mitochondrial bioenergetics in adult zebrafish

Human activity has now introduced novel chemicals into most aquatic ecosystems. Endocrine-disrupting compounds originating from plastic pollution and manufacture can have pronounced biological effects by disrupting hormone-mediated processes. Bisphenol A (BPA) is one of the most commonly produced endocrine-disrupting compounds, which interferes with signalling by a broad range of hormones. In recognition of its potentially harmful effects, BPA is being replaced by substitutes such as bisphenol S (BPS). However, toxicological studies revealed that BPS too can bind to hormone receptors and disrupt signalling, particularly of thyroid hormone. The aim of this study was to test whether BPS exposure impacts locomotor performance and muscle function in zebrafish (Danio rerio). Locomotor performance depends on thyroid hormone signalling, and it is closely related to fitness so that its disruption can have negative ecological and evolutionary consequences. BPS exposure of 15 μg l^-1 [∼60 nM] and 30 μg l^-1 (but not 60 μg l^-1) decreased sustained swimming performance (U_crit), but not sprint speed. In a fully factorial design, we show that living in flowing water increased U_crit compared to a still water control, and that BPS reduced U_crit under both conditions but did not eliminate the training effect. In a second factorial experiment, we show that BPS did not affect mitochondrial bioenergetics in skeletal muscle (state 3 and 4 rates, respiratory control ratios, ROS production), but that induced hypothyroidism decreased state 3 and 4 rates of respiration. However, both hypothyroidism and BPS exposure decreased activity of AMP-activated protein kinase (pAMPK:total AMPK) but increased protein levels of myocyte enhancer factor 2, and slow and fast myosin heavy chains. Our data indicate that BPS is not a safe alternative for BPA and that exposure to BPS can have ecological consequences, which are likely to be at least partly mediated via thyroid hormone disruption.

Interactive effects of temperature and bisphenol A on phytoplankton growth and community structure

Environmental contamination of bisphenol A (BPA) is a widespread and multifaceted issue with vast ecological, social and economic consequences. Thus, understanding how local environmental conditions, such as temperature, interact with BPA to affect populations and community dynamics remain important areas of research. Here, we conduct laboratory experiments aimed at understanding how environmental gradients of both temperature and BPA concentration influence freshwater phytoplankton population growth and community structure. We exposed phytoplankton assemblages comprised of three common species of green algae (Chlorella vulgaris, Ankistrodesmus braunii and Scenedesmus quadricauda) as well as isolates of each individual species to three BPA concentrations (0, 2, 13 mg/L BPA) and three temperatures (18, 23, 27°C) monitoring population growth and community structure (via biovolume). We observed antagonistic interactions between BPA and warmer temperatures, such that when warmer temperatures decreased growth (observed with A. braunii), high concentrations of BPA elevated growth at these warm temperatures; however, when warmer temperatures increased growth (C. vulgaris, S. quadricauda), high BPA concentrations diminished these gains. Although BPA exposure inhibited the growth of most C. vulgaris populations, growth was not reduced in A. braunii or S. quadricauda populations exposed to 2 mg/L BPA. Phytoplankton assemblage evenness (Pielou evenness index) decreased as BPA concentration increased and was consistently lowest under 27°C. Community composition was similar in assemblages cultured under 0 and 2 mg/L BPA under 18 and 23°C but was most similar between assemblages cultured under 2 and 13 mg/L BPA under 27°C. These results indicate that local environmental temperatures can mediate the consequences of BPA for freshwater phytoplankton growth rates and community structure and that BPA can diminish potential gains of increased growth rate for warm-adapted phytoplankton species at high environmental temperatures.

Mechanism of action and neurotoxic effects of chronic exposure to bisphenol F in adult zebrafish

Although bisphenol F (BPF), the main replacement for bisphenol A, has been commonly used in polycarbonate production, its neurotoxicity and the underlying mechanisms remain poorly understood. To address this knowledge gap, this study aimed to assess the neurotoxicity caused by chronic exposure to BPF and to identify its underlying mechanisms. We exposed adult zebrafish chronically to BPF at environmentally relevant concentrations (0.001, 0.01, and 0.1 mg/L) for 4 weeks. The results revealed that with BPF crossing the blood-brain barrier and bioaccumulating in brain tissues, chronic exposure to BPF resulted in anxiety-like behaviors and disruptions in learning and memory function in adult zebrafish. Furthermore, BPF toxicity in the zebrafish brain involved the dysregulation of metabolic pathways for choline and kynurenine in neurotransmitter systems and for 17β-estradiol, cortisol, pregnenolone-sulfate, and Dehydroepiandrosterone (DHEA)-sulfate in neurosteroid systems. RNA-seq analysis revealed that BPF exposure affected metabolic pathways, calcium signaling pathways, neuroactive ligand-receptor interactions, tight junctions, gap junctions, and the gonadotropin-releasing hormone signaling pathway. Our results indicate that chronic exposure to BPF alters the neurochemical profile of the brain and causes neurobehavioral effects, such as anxiety and cognitive decline. Overall, the multimodal approach, including behavioral and neurochemical profiling technologies, has great potential for the comprehensive assessment of potential risks posed by environmental pollutants to human and ecosystem health.

Bisphenols impact hormone levels in animals: A meta-analysis

Bisphenols are used in the manufacture of plastics and are endocrine disrupting compounds detectable in free living organisms and environments globally. The original bisphenol, bisphenol A (BPA), is best known as a xenoestrogen, but it also disrupts other steroid hormones and other classes of hormones including thyroid and pituitary hormones. When its toxicity became better known, BPA was replaced by presumably less toxic alternatives, including bisphenols S, F, and AF. However, recent data suggest that all bisphenols can have endocrine disrupting effects, although their impacts remain unresolved particularly in non-human animals. Our aim was to establish the current state-of-knowledge of the effects of different bisphenols on circulating hormone levels in non-human animals. Our meta-analysis showed that a diverse range of hormones (including thyroid hormones, corticosterone, follicle stimulating hormone, luteinizing hormone, and estradiol) are strongly impacted by exposure to any bisphenol type, and that in laboratory rats (Rattus norvegicus) the effect was modified by life-stage. Although there were qualitative differences, BPA alternatives had as great or greater effects on hormone levels as BPA. However, data coverage across hormones was uneven, and most studies measured the effects of BPA on vertebrate reproductive hormones. Similarly, taxonomic coverage was poor. Over 80% of data originated from laboratory rats and zebrafish (Danio rerio) and there are no data for whole classes of invertebrates and vertebrates (e.g., amphibians). Our results show that all bisphenols alter circulating levels of a broad range of hormones. However, the current state-of-knowledge is incomplete so that the ecological impacts of bisphenols are difficult to gauge, although based on the available data bisphenols are likely to be detrimental to a broad range of taxa and ecosystems.

Critical review of the toxicity mechanisms of bisphenol F in zebrafish (Danio rerio): Knowledge gaps and future directions

Replacement chemicals for bisphenol A, such as bisphenol F (BPF), are detected in aquatic environments worldwide and can potentially exert negative effects on aquatic organisms. We synthesized peer-reviewed literature reporting molecular and physiological responses in zebrafish following exposure to BPF, as BPF is closely related to BPA structure and is a dominant replacement chemical in the marketplace. Global concentrations of BPF in aquatic environments were compiled and compared to physiological and behavioral impacts reported in zebrafish (e.g., developmental abnormalities, oxidative stress, immunotoxicity, endocrine disruption, and neurotoxicity). Using computational approaches, we elucidate BPF-mediated molecular networks and reveal novel biomarkers associated with BPF exposure. Functional classes of proteins including inflammatory cytokines, ATPases, peroxidases, and aromatic l-amino decarboxylases represent novel, underexplored targets of toxicity. Most revealing of this critical review is that few studies report biological responses to BPF at levels present in aquatic environments. Recommendations for future investigations based on knowledge gaps include: (1) Mechanistic studies in the central nervous system of zebrafish to address neurotoxicity; (2) Behavioral assays in zebrafish that assess the effects of BPF on anxiolytic, social, and fear-related behaviors; (3) Studies that broaden understanding of potential endocrine disrupting effects of BPF, for example insulin signaling is predicted to be sensitive to BPF exposure; (4) Studies into metabolic disruption with a focus on glutathione and aromatic amino acids, based upon pathway analysis data; (5) Studies utilizing mixture exposures with other BPA analogs to reflect environmental conditions more accurately.

Endocrine disruption from plastic pollution and warming interact to increase the energetic cost of growth in a fish

Energetic cost of growth determines how much food-derived energy is needed to produce a given amount of new biomass and thereby influences energy transduction between trophic levels. Growth and development are regulated by hormones and are therefore sensitive to changes in temperature and environmental endocrine disruption. Here, we show that the endocrine disruptor bisphenol A (BPA) at an environmentally relevant concentration (10 µgl^-1) decreased fish (Danio rerio) size at 30°C water temperature. Under the same conditions, it significantly increased metabolic rates and the energetic cost of growth across development. By contrast, BPA decreased the cost of growth at cooler temperatures (24°C). BPA-mediated changes in cost of growth were not associated with mitochondrial efficiency (P/O ratios (i.e. adenosine diphosphate (ADP) used/oxygen consumed) and respiratory control ratios) although BPA did increase mitochondrial proton leak. In females, BPA decreased age at maturity at 24°C but increased it at 30°C, and it decreased the gonadosomatic index suggesting reduced investment into reproduction. Our data reveal a potentially serious emerging problem: increasing water temperatures resulting from climate warming together with endocrine disruption from plastic pollution can impact animal growth efficiency, and hence the dynamics and resilience of animal populations and the services these provide.

Wild Zebrafish Sentinels: Biological Monitoring of Site Differences Using Behavior and Morphology

Environmental change poses a devastating risk to human and environmental health. Rapid assessment of water conditions is necessary for monitoring, evaluating, and addressing this global health danger. Sentinels or biological monitors can be deployed in the field using minimal resources to detect water quality changes in real time, quickly and cheaply. Zebrafish (Danio rerio) are ideal sentinels for detecting environmental changes due to their biomedical tool kit, widespread geographic distribution, and well-characterized phenotypic responses to environmental disturbances. Here, we demonstrate the utility of zebrafish sentinels by characterizing phenotypic differences in wild zebrafish between two field sites in India. Site 1 was a rural environment with flowing water, low-hypoxic conditions, minimal human-made debris, and high iron and lead concentrations. Site 2 was an urban environment with still water, hypoxic conditions, plastic pollution, and high arsenic, iron, and chromium concentrations. We found that zebrafish from Site 2 were smaller, more cohesive, and less active than Site 1 fish. We also found sexually dimorphic body shapes within the Site 2, but not the Site 1, population. Advancing zebrafish sentinel research and development will enable rapid detection, evaluation, and response to emerging global health threats.

Thyroid hormone regulation of thermal acclimation in ectotherms: Physiological mechanisms and ecoevolutionary implications

The pathways that regulate adaptive thermal plasticity in ectothermic vertebrates have received little attention relative to those in birds and mammals. However, there is increasing evidence that thyroid hormone represents a critical regulator of thermal plasticity in both ectothermic and endothermic vertebrates. In this review, I summarize the evidence for thyroid hormone-mediated thermal compensation responses in ectothermic vertebrates, with specific focus on effects on the whole animal, skeletal muscle, and cardiac muscle. Interestingly, these effects can differ wildly between focal tissues and species. I move on to discuss what the role of thyroid hormone in ectotherm thermal plasticity can reveal about stressor interactions and central vs. peripheral levels of thyroid hormone regulation. Lastly, I focus on the conserved nature of thyroid hormone signaling in animal thermal responses, with specific reference to the ectotherm → endotherm spectrum. I use this framework to highlight research avenues that will further resolve the evolutionary trajectory of thyroid hormone actions across animals. I hope to emphasize what thyroid hormone-mediated cold acclimation in a 3 cm fish can contribute to ongoing debates surrounding the impacts of stressor interactions, the potential costs of plasticity, the evolution of endothermy, and the impacts of global change.