Differential DNA methylation and gene expression in reciprocal hybrids between Solanum lycopersicum and S. pimpinellifolium

DNA Methylation and Subgenome Dominance Reveal the Role of Lipid Metabolism in Jinhu Grouper Heterosis

Heterosis of growth traits in economic fish has benefited the production of aquaculture for many years, yet its genetic and molecular basis has remained obscure. Nowadays, a new germplasm of hybrid Jinhu grouper (Epinephelus fuscoguttatus ♀ × E. tukula ♂), abbreviated as EFT, exhibiting paternal-biased growth heterosis, has provided an excellent model for investigating the potential regulatory mechanisms of heterosis. We integrated transcriptome and methylome to unravel the changes of gene expression, epigenetic modification, and subgenome dominance in EFT compared with maternal E. fuscoguttatus. Integration analyses showed that the heterotic hybrids showed lower genomic DNA methylation levels than the purebred parent, and the up-regulated genes were mostly DNA hypomethylation. Furthermore, allele-specific expression (ASE) detected paternal subgenome dominance-regulated paternal-biased heterosis, and paternal bias differentially expressed genes (DEGs) were wholly up-regulated in the muscle. Multi-omics results highlighted the role of lipid metabolism, particularly "Fatty acid synthesis", "EPA biosynthesis", and "Signaling lipids", in EFT heterosis formation. Coherently, our studies have proved that the eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) of EFT was greater than that of maternal E. fuscoguttatus (8.46% vs. 7.46%). Finally, we constructed a potential regulatory network for control of the heterosis formation in EFT. Among them, fasn, pparg, dgat1, igf1, pomca, fgf8a, and fgfr4 were identified as key genes. Our results provide new and valuable clues for understanding paternal-biased growth heterosis in EFT, taking a significant step towards the molecular basis of heterosis.

The Genomic Shock Hypothesis: Genetic and Epigenetic Alterations of Transposable Elements after Interspecific Hybridization in Plants

Transposable elements (TEs) are major components of plant genomes with the ability to change their position in the genome or to create new copies of themselves in other positions in the genome. These can cause gene disruption and large-scale genomic alterations, including inversions, deletions, and duplications. Host organisms have evolved a set of mechanisms to suppress TE activity and counter the threat that they pose to genome integrity. These includes the epigenetic silencing of TEs mediated by a process of RNA-directed DNA methylation (RdDM). In most cases, the silencing machinery is very efficient for the vast majority of TEs. However, there are specific circumstances in which TEs can evade such silencing mechanisms, for example, a variety of biotic and abiotic stresses or in vitro culture. Hybridization is also proposed as an inductor of TE proliferation. In fact, the discoverer of the transposons, Barbara McClintock, first hypothesized that interspecific hybridization provides a "genomic shock" that inhibits the TE control mechanisms leading to the mobilization of TEs. However, the studies carried out on this topic have yielded diverse results, showing in some cases a total absence of mobilization or being limited to only some TE families. Here, we review the current knowledge about the impact of interspecific hybridization on TEs in plants and the possible implications of changes in the epigenetic mechanisms.

Captive rearing effects on the methylome of Atlantic salmon after oceanic migration: Sex-specificity and intergenerational stability

Captive rearing in salmon hatcheries can have considerable impacts on both fish phenotype and fitness within a single generation, even in the absence of genetic change. Evidence for hatchery-induced changes in DNA methylation is becoming abundant, though questions remain on the sex-specificity of these effects, their persistence until spawning and potential for transmission to future generations. Here we performed whole genome methylation sequencing of fin tissue for 16 hatchery and 16 wild Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) returning to spawn in the Rimouski River, Québec, Canada. We identified two cohorts of hatchery-reared salmon through methylation analysis, one of which was epigenetically similar to wild fish, suggesting that supplementation efforts may be able to minimize the epigenetic effects of hatchery rearing. We found considerable sex-specific effects of hatchery rearing, with few genomic regions being affected in both males and females. We also analysed the methylome of 32 F1 offspring from four groups (pure wild, pure hatchery origin and reciprocal hybrids). We found that few epigenetic changes due to parental hatchery rearing persisted in the F1 offspring though the patterns of inheritance appear to be complex, involving nonadditive effects. Our results suggest that the epigenetic effects of hatchery rearing can be minimal in F0 . There may also be minimal epigenetic inheritance and rapid loss of epigenetic changes associated with hatchery rearing. However, due to sex-specificity and nonadditive patterns of inheritance, methylation changes due to captive rearing are rather complex and the field would benefit from further research on minimizing the epigenetic effects of captive rearing in conservation efforts.

Warming-induced changes of broccoli head to cauliflower-like curd in Brassica oleracea are regulated by DNA methylation as revealed by methylome and transcriptome co-profiling

Increasingly warming temperature impacts on all aspects of growth and development in plants. Flower development is a complex process that is very sensitive to ambient temperature, and warming temperatures often lead to abnormal flower development and remarkably reduce the quality and yield of inflorescent vegetables and many other crops, which can be exemplified by Brassica oleracea cv. Green Harmony F1, a broccoli cultivar, whose floral development is ceased at inflorescence meristem (at 28 °C) or floral primordium stage (at 22 °C), forming a cauliflower-like curd (28 °C) or intermediate curd (22 °C) instead of normal broccoli head at 16 °C. However, the underlying molecular regulatory mechanisms are not well understood. Here we report that warming temperature (28 °C or 22 °C) induced hypermethylation of the genome, especially the promoter regions of such sets of genes as ribosome biogenesis-related and others, leading to the suppression of the apex-highly-expressed distinctive genes, subsequently resulting in the abnormal floral development, as revealed by methylome and transcriptome co-profiling. The regulation of warming-induced abnormal floral development in broccoli was further verified by the fact that the DNA methylation inhibitor 5-azacytidine (5-azaC) released the expression of genes from the warming temperature-induced suppression, and restored the broccoli development to normalcy at warming temperature. The research provided new approaches to breeding broccoli and other crops for growing in wider or warmer temperature zones. Graphical Abstract.

Integrated analysis of DNA methylation, transcriptome, and global metabolites in interspecific heterotic Capsicum F1 hybrid

Hybrid breeding is one of the efficacious methods of crop improvement. Here, we report our work towards understanding the molecular basis of F1 hybrid heterosis from Capsicum chinense and C. frutescens cross. Bisulfite sequencing identified a total of 70597 CG, 108797 CHG, and 38418 CHH differentially methylated regions (DMRs) across F₁ hybrid and parents, and of these, 4891 DMRs showed higher methylation in F₁ compared to the mid-parental methylation values (MPMV). Transcriptome analysis showed higher expression of 46–55% differentially expressed genes (DE-Gs) in the F₁ hybrid. The qRT-PCR analysis of 24 DE-Gs with negative promoter methylation revealed 91.66% expression similarity with the transcriptome data. A few metabolites and 65–72% enriched genes in metabolite biosynthetic pathways showed overall increased expression in the F₁ hybrid compared to parents. These findings, taken together, provided insights into the integrated role of DNA methylation, and genes and metabolites expression in the manifestation of heterosis in Capsicum.

•

Global methylation identified significantly different proportions of mCs in hybrid

•

Of common DMRs, 33.08% showed different methylation in hybrid from the mid-parental value

•

Negatively correlated DEG pDMR-genes were enriched in metabolic pathways

•

Significant higher expression of metabolites and DE-Gs were identified in the F₁ hybrid

Evolutionary fates of gene-body methylation and its divergent association with gene expression in pigeonpea

Pigeonpea (Cajanus cajan L. Huth) is an agronomically important legume cultivated worldwide. In this study, we extensively analyzed gene-body methylation (GbM) patterns in pigeonpea. We found a bimodal distribution of CG and CHG methylation patterns. GbM features- slow evolution rate and increased length remained conserved. Genes with moderate CG body methylation showed highest expression where as highly-methylated genes showed lowest expression. Transposable element (TE)-related genes were methylated in multiple contexts and hence classified as C-methylated genes. A low expression among C-methylated genes was associated with transposons insertion in gene-body and upstream regulatory regions. The CG methylation patterns were found to be conserved in orthologs compared with non-CG methylation. By comparing methylation patterns between differentially methylated regions (DMRs) of the three genotypes, we found that variably methylated marks are less likely to target evolutionary conserved sequences. Finally, our analysis showed enrichment of nitrogen-related genes in GbM orthologs of legumes, which could be promising candidates for generating epialleles for crop improvement.

Epigenetic inheritance and reproductive mode in plants and animals

Epigenetic inheritance is another piece of the puzzle of nongenetic inheritance, although the prevalence, sources, persistence, and phenotypic consequences of heritable epigenetic marks across taxa remain unclear. We systematically reviewed over 500 studies from the past 5 years to identify trends in the frequency of epigenetic inheritance due to differences in reproductive mode and germline development. Genetic, intrinsic (e.g., disease), and extrinsic (e.g., environmental) factors were identified as sources of epigenetic inheritance, with impacts on phenotype and adaptation depending on environmental predictability. Our review shows that multigenerational persistence of epigenomic patterns is common in both plants and animals, but also highlights many knowledge gaps that remain to be filled. We provide a framework to guide future studies towards understanding the generational persistence and eco-evolutionary significance of epigenomic patterns.

Fruit quality and DNA methylation are affected by parental order in reciprocal crosses of tomato

Reciprocal effects were found for tomato fruit quality and DNA methylation. The epigenetic identity of reciprocal hybrids indicates that DNA methylation might be one of the mechanisms involved in POEs. Crosses between different genotypes and even between different species are commonly used in plant breeding programs. Reciprocal hybrids are obtained by changing the cross direction (or the sexual role) of parental genotypes in a cross. Phenotypic differences between these hybrids constitute reciprocal effects (REs). The aim of this study was to evaluate phenotypic differences in tomato fruit traits and DNA methylation profiles in three inter- and intraspecific reciprocal crosses. REs were detected for 13 of the 16 fruit traits analyzed. The number of traits with REs was the lowest in the interspecific cross, whereas the highest was found in the cross between recombinant inbred lines (RILs) derived from the same interspecific cross. An extension of gene action analysis was proposed to incorporate parent-of-origin effects (POEs). Maternal and paternal dominance were found in four fruit traits. REs and paternal inheritance were found for epiloci located at coding and non-coding regions. The epigenetic identity displayed by the reciprocal hybrids accounts for the phenotypic differences among them, indicating that DNA methylation might be one of the mechanisms involved in POEs.

Identification of HPV16-p16INK4a mediated methylation in oral potentially malignant disorder

To evaluate the possible involvement of epigenetic modulation by HPV16-p16^INK4a in oral potentially malignant disorder (OPMD). We generated DNA-methylation profiles, according to p16^INK4a expression and HPV16 genotype (positive or negative), of OPMD samples and p16^INK4a-HPV16 negative samples (used as control), using reduced-representation bisulphite sequencing (RRBS-Seq- Illumina) technology. Twelve samples, four for each group, as follows: 1) p16^INK4a+ HPV16+; 2) p16^INK4a+ HPV16-; 3) p16^INK4a- HPV16-, were analysed in triplicate for DNA-methylation profiles. Fifty-four per cent of DMRs were hypermethylated and 46% were hypomethylated. An increase in methylation of loci in OPMD was independent of the presence of HPV. The hypermethylated genes in HPV+ samples were associated with signalling pathways such as NICD traffics to nucleus, signalling by NOTCH1 (p = 0.008), Interferon-gamma (p = 0.008) and Interleukin-6 signalling (p = 0.027). The hypomethylated genes in HPV infection were associated with TRAF3-dependent IRF activation pathway (p = 0.002), RIG-I/MDA5 mediated induction of IFN-alpha/beta pathways (p = 0.005), TRAF6 mediated IRF7 activation (p = 0.009), TRIF-mediated TLR3/TLR4 signalling (p = 0.011) and MyD88-independent cascade release of apoptotic factors (p = 0.011). Protein association analysis of DMRs in OPMD revealed 19 genes involved in the cell cycle regulation, immune system, and focal adhesion. Aberrantly methylated loci in OPMD were observed in p16^INK4a positive samples which suggests that a shift in global methylation status may be important for cancer progression. The results suggest that HPV infection in OPMD induces modulation of genes related to the immune system and regulation of the cellular cycle.

Regulation of Leaf Longevity by DML3-Mediated DNA Demethylation

Leaf senescence is driven by the expression of senescence-associated genes (SAGs). Development-specific genes often undergo DNA demethylation in their promoter and other regions, which regulates gene expression. Whether and how DNA demethylation regulates the expression of SAGs and thus leaf senescence remain elusive. Whole-genome bisulfite sequencing (WGBS) analyses of wild-type (WT) and demeter-like 3 (dml3) Arabidopsis leaves at three developmental stages revealed hypermethylation during leaf senescence in dml3 compared with WT, and 20 556 differentially methylated regions (DMRs) were identified by comparing the methylomes of dml3 and WT in the CG, CHG, and CHH contexts. Furthermore, we identified that 335 DMR-associated genes (DMGs), such as NAC016 and SEN1, are upregulated during leaf senescence, and found an inverse correlation between the DNA methylation levels (especially in the promoter regions) and the transcript abundances of the related SAGs in WT. In contrast, in dml3 the promoters of SAGs were hypermethylated and their transcript levels were remarkably reduced, and leaf senescence was significantly delayed. Collectively, our study unraveled a novel epigenetic regulatory mechanism underlying leaf senescence in which DML3 is expressed at the onset of and during senescence to demethylate promoter, gene body or 3' UTR regions to activate a set of SAGs.

Genome-wide DNA methylation analysis using next-generation sequencing to reveal candidate genes responsible for boar taint in pigs

Boar taint (BT) is an offensive flavor observed in non-castrated male pigs that reduces the carcass price. Surgical castration effectively avoids the taint but is associated with animal welfare concerns. The functional annotation of farm animal genomes for understanding the biology of complex traits can be used in the selection of breeding animals to achieve favorable phenotypic outcomes. The characterization of pig epigenomes/methylation changes between animals with high and low BT and genome-wide epigenetic markers that can predict BT are lacking. Reduced representation bisulfite sequencing of DNA methylation patterns based on next-generation sequencing is an efficient technology to identify candidate epigenetic biomarkers associated with BT. Three different BT levels were analyzed using reduced representation bisulfite sequencing data to calculate the methylation levels of cytosine and guanine dinucleotide (CpG) sites. The co-analysis of differentially methylated CpG sites identified by this study and differentially expressed genes identified by a previous study found 32 significant co-located genes. The joint analysis of GO terms and pathways revealed that methylation and gene expression of seven candidate genes were associated with BT; in particular, FASN plays a key role in fatty acid biosynthesis, and PEMT might be involved in estrogen regulation and the development of BT. This study is the first to report the genome-wide DNA methylation profiles of BT in pigs using next-generation sequencing and summarize candidate genes associated with epigenetic markers of BT, which could contribute to the understanding of the functional biology of BT traits and selective breeding of pigs against BT based on epigenetic biomarkers.

An Epigenome-Wide DNA Methylation Map of Testis in Pigs for Study of Complex Traits

Epigenetic changes are important for understanding complex trait variation and inheritance in pigs that are also a valuable biomedical model for human health research. Testis is the main organ for reproduction and boar taint in pigs; however, there have been no studies to-date on adult pig testis epigenome. The main objective of this study was to establish a genome-wide DNA methylation map of pig testis that would help identify candidate epigenetic biomarkers and methylated genes for complex traits such as male reproduction, fertility or boar taint. Reduced Representation Bisulfite Sequencing (RRBS) was used to study methylation levels of cytosine in nine pig testis samples. The results showed that genome-wide methylation status of nine samples overlapped greatly and their variation among pigs were low. The methylation levels of promoter, exon, intron, cytosine and guanine dinucleotide (CpG) islands and CpG island shores regions were 0.15, 0.47, 0.55, 0.39, and 0.53, respectively. Cytosines binding to CpG islands showed different methylation levels between exon and intron regions. All methylation levels of CpG islands were lower than CpG island shores in different genic features. The distribution of 12,738 differentially methylated cytosines (DMCs) within CpG islands, CpG island shores and other regions was 36.86, 21.65, and 41.49%, respectively, and was 0.33, 1.71, 5.95, and 92.01% in promoter, exon, intron and intergenic regions, respectively. Methylation levels of DMCs in promoter, exon and intron regions were significantly different between CpG islands and CpG island shores (P < 0.05). A total of 898 genes with 2089 DMCs were enriched in 112 Gene Ontology (GO) terms. Fifteen methylated genes from our study were associated with fertility or boar taint traits. Our analysis revealed the methylation patterns in different genic features and CpG island regions of testis in pigs, and summarized several candidate genes associated with DMCs and the involved GO terms. These findings are helpful to understand the relationship between DNA methylation and genic CpG islands, to provide candidate epigenetic regions or biomarkers for pig production and welfare and for translational epigenomic studies that use pigs as an animal model for human research.

Maintenance of grafting-induced epigenetic variations in the asexual progeny of Brassica oleracea and B. juncea chimera

Grafting-induced variations have been observed in many plant species, but the heritability of variation in progeny is not well understood. In our study, adventitious shoots from the C cell lineage of shoot apical meristem (SAM) grafting chimera TCC (where the origin of the outmost, middle and innermost cell layers, respectively, of SAM is designated by 'T' for tuber mustard and 'C' for red cabbage) were induced and identified as r-CCC (r = regenerated). To investigate the maintenance of grafting variations during cell propagation and regeneration, different generations of asexual progeny (r-CCCn, n = generation) were established through successive regeneration of axillary shoots from r-CCC. The fourth generation of r-CCC (r-CCC4) was selected to perform whole genome bisulfite sequencing for comparative analysis of hetero-grafting-induced global methylation changes relative to r-s-CCC4 (s = self-grafting). Increased CHH methylation levels and proportions were observed in r-CCC4, with substantial changes occurring in the repeat elements. Small RNA sequencing revealed 1135 specific small interfering RNA (siRNA) tags that were typically expressed in r-CCC, r-CCC2 and r-CCC4. Notably, 65% of these specific siRNAs were associated with repeat elements, termed RE siRNAs. Subsequent analysis revealed that the CHH methylation of RE siRNA-overlapping regions was mainly hypermethylation in r-CCC4, indicating that they were responsible for directing and maintaining grafting-induced CHH methylation. Moreover, the expression of 13 differentially methylated genes (DMGs) correlated with the phenotypic variation, showing differential expression levels between r-CCC4 and r-s-CCC4. These DMGs were predominantly CG hypermethylated, their methylation modifications corresponded to the transcription of relative methyltransferase.