Methylphosphonate mapping of phosphate contacts critical for RNA recognition by the human immunodeficiency virus tat and rev proteins

Enantiodivergent Formation of C-P Bonds: Synthesis of P-Chiral Phosphines and Methylphosphonate Oligonucleotides

Phosphorus Incorporation (PI, abbreviated Π) reagents for the modular, scalable, and stereospecific synthesis of chiral phosphines and methylphosphonate nucleotides are reported. Synthesized from trans-limonene oxide, this reagent class displays an unexpected reactivity profile and enables access to chemical space distinct from that of the Phosphorus-Sulfur Incorporation reagents previously disclosed. Here, the adaptable phosphorus(V) scaffold enables sequential addition of carbon nucleophiles to produce a variety of enantiopure C-P building blocks. Addition of three carbon nucleophiles to Π, followed by stereospecific reduction, affords useful P-chiral phosphines; introduction instead of a single methyl group reveals the first stereospecific synthesis of methylphosphonate oligonucleotide precursors. While both Π enantiomers are available, only one isomer is required-the order of nucleophile addition controls the absolute stereochemistry of the final product through a unique enantiodivergent design.

Ultraslow Domain Motions in HIV-1 TAR RNA Revealed by Solid-State Deuterium NMR

Intrinsic motions may allow HIV-1 transactivation response (TAR) RNA to change its conformation to form a functional complex with the Tat protein, which is essential for viral replication. Understanding the dynamic properties of TAR necessitates determining motion on the intermediate nanosecond-to-microsecond time scale. To this end, we performed solid-state deuterium NMR line-shape and T_1Z relaxation-time experiments to measure intermediate motions for two uridine residues, U40 and U42, within the lower helix of TAR. We infer global motions at rates of ∼10⁵ s^-1 in the lower helix, which are much slower than those in the upper helix (∼10⁶ s^-1), indicating that the two helical domains reorient independently of one another in the solid-state sample. These results contribute to the aim of fully describing the properties of functional motions in TAR RNA.

Chemical synthesis of RNA with site-specific methylphosphonate modifications

Methylphosphonate(mP)-modified RNA serves as valuable probe to evaluate biomolecular interactions between the nucleic acid backbone and binding partners, such as proteins or small molecules. Here, we describe an efficient workflow for the synthesis of RNA with a single mP modification in diastereomerically pure form. While the automated assembly of mP-modified RNA is straightforward, its deprotection under basic conditions is challenging; a carefully optimized step-by-step procedure is provided. In addition, we demonstrate purification and separation strategies for the R_P and S_P-configurated RNA diastereomers using a combination of anion-exchange and reversed-phase HPLC, and comment on troubleshooting if their separation appears difficult. Furthermore, we demonstrate the stereochemical assignment of short R_P and S_P mP-modified RNA diastereomers based on 2D ROESY NMR spectroscopy and we report on the impact of the mP modification on thermal and thermodynamic stabilities of RNA-DNA hybrid and RNA-RNA duplexes.

Role of a ribosomal RNA phosphate oxygen during the EF-G-triggered GTP hydrolysis

Elongation factor-catalyzed GTP hydrolysis is a key reaction during the ribosomal elongation cycle. Recent crystal structures of G proteins, such as elongation factor G (EF-G) bound to the ribosome, as well as many biochemical studies, provide evidence that the direct interaction of translational GTPases (trGTPases) with the sarcin-ricin loop (SRL) of ribosomal RNA (rRNA) is pivotal for hydrolysis. However, the precise mechanism remains elusive and is intensively debated. Based on the close proximity of the phosphate oxygen of A2662 of the SRL to the supposedly catalytic histidine of EF-G (His87), we probed this interaction by an atomic mutagenesis approach. We individually replaced either of the two nonbridging phosphate oxygens at A2662 with a methyl group by the introduction of a methylphosphonate instead of the natural phosphate in fully functional, reconstituted bacterial ribosomes. Our major finding was that only one of the two resulting diastereomers, the SP methylphosphonate, was compatible with efficient GTPase activation on EF-G. The same trend was observed for a second trGTPase, namely EF4 (LepA). In addition, we provide evidence that the negative charge of the A2662 phosphate group must be retained for uncompromised activity in GTP hydrolysis. In summary, our data strongly corroborate that the nonbridging proSP phosphate oxygen at the A2662 of the SRL is critically involved in the activation of GTP hydrolysis. A mechanistic scenario is supported in which positioning of the catalytically active, protonated His87 through electrostatic interactions with the A2662 phosphate group and H-bond networks are key features of ribosome-triggered activation of trGTPases.

Identification of c-di-GMP derivatives resistant to an EAL domain phosphodiesterase

The bacterial second messenger signaling molecule bis-(3'-5')-cyclic dimeric guanosine monophosphate (c-di-GMP) controls important biological processes such as biofilm formation, virulence response, and motility. This second messenger is sensed by macromolecular targets inside the cell, both protein and RNA, which induce specific phenotypic responses critical for bacterial survival. One class of enzymes responsible for regulating the intracellular concentration of c-di-GMP, and therefore the physiological behavior of the cell, consists of the EAL domain phosphodiesterases, which degrade the second messenger to its linear form, pGpG. Here, we investigate how base and backbone modifications of c-di-GMP affect the rate of cyclic dinucleotide degradation by an EAL domain protein (CC3396 from Caulobacter crescentus). The doubly substituted thiophosphate analogue is highly resistant to hydrolysis by this metabolizing enzyme but can still bind c-di-GMP riboswitch targets. We used these findings to develop a novel ribosyl phosphate-modified derivative of c-di-GMP containing 2'-deoxy and methylphosphonate substitutions that is charge neutral and demonstrate that this analogue is also resistant to EAL domain-catalyzed degradation. This suggests a general strategy for designing c-di-GMP derivatives with increased enzymatic stability that also possess desirable properties for development as chemical probes of c-di-GMP signaling.

Interactions of protein side chains with RNA defined with REDOR solid state NMR

Formation of the complex between human immunodeficiency virus type-1 Tat protein and the transactivation response region (TAR) RNA is vital for transcriptional elongation, yet the structure of the Tat-TAR complex remains to be established. The NMR structures of free TAR, and TAR bound to Tat-derived peptides have been obtained by solution NMR, but only a small number of intermolecular NOEs could be identified unambiguously, preventing the determination of a complete structure. Here we show that a combination of multiple solid state NMR REDOR experiments can be used to obtain multiple distance constraints from (15)N to (13)C spins within the backbone and side chain guanidinium groups of arginine in a Tat-derived peptide, using (19)F spins incorporated into the base of U23 in TAR and (31)P spins in the P22 and P23 phosphate groups. Distances between the side chain of Arg52 and the base and phosphodiester backbone near U23 measured by REDOR NMR are comparable to distances observed in solution NMR-derived structural models, indicating that interactions of TAR RNA with key amino acid side chains in Tat are the same in the amorphous solid state as in solution. This method is generally applicable to other protein-RNA complexes where crystallization or solution NMR has failed to provide high resolution structural information.

Analysis of RNA binding by the dengue virus NS5 RNA capping enzyme

Flaviviruses are small, capped positive sense RNA viruses that replicate in the cytoplasm of infected cells. Dengue virus and other related flaviviruses have evolved RNA capping enzymes to form the viral RNA cap structure that protects the viral genome and directs efficient viral polyprotein translation. The N-terminal domain of NS5 possesses the methyltransferase and guanylyltransferase activities necessary for forming mature RNA cap structures. The mechanism for flavivirus guanylyltransferase activity is currently unknown, and how the capping enzyme binds its diphosphorylated RNA substrate is important for deciphering how the flavivirus guanylyltransferase functions. In this report we examine how flavivirus NS5 N-terminal capping enzymes bind to the 5′ end of the viral RNA using a fluorescence polarization-based RNA binding assay. We observed that the K_D for RNA binding is approximately 200 nM Dengue, Yellow Fever, and West Nile virus capping enzymes. Removal of one or both of the 5′ phosphates reduces binding affinity, indicating that the terminal phosphates contribute significantly to binding. RNA binding affinity is negatively affected by the presence of GTP or ATP and positively affected by S-adensyl methoninine (SAM). Structural superpositioning of the dengue virus capping enzyme with the Vaccinia virus VP39 protein bound to RNA suggests how the flavivirus capping enzyme may bind RNA, and mutagenesis analysis of residues in the putative RNA binding site demonstrate that several basic residues are critical for RNA binding. Several mutants show differential binding to 5′ di-, mono-, and un-phosphorylated RNAs. The mode of RNA binding appears similar to that found with other methyltransferase enzymes, and a discussion of diphosphorylated RNA binding is presented.

Reactions of Cre with methylphosphonate DNA: similarities and contrasts with Flp and vaccinia topoisomerase

BACKGROUND

Reactions of vaccinia topoisomerase and the tyrosine site-specific recombinase Flp with methylphosphonate (MeP) substituted DNA substrates, have provided important insights into the electrostatic features of the strand cleavage and strand joining steps catalyzed by them. A conserved arginine residue in the catalytic pentad, Arg-223 in topoisomerase and Arg-308 in Flp, is not essential for stabilizing the MeP transition state. Topoisomerase or its R223A variant promotes cleavage of the MeP bond by the active site nucleophile Tyr-274, followed by the rapid hydrolysis of the MeP-tyrosyl intermediate. Flp(R308A), but not wild type Flp, mediates direct hydrolysis of the activated MeP bond. These findings are consistent with a potential role for phosphate electrostatics and active site electrostatics in protecting DNA relaxation and site-specific recombination, respectively, against abortive hydrolysis.

METHODOLOGY/PRINCIPAL FINDINGS

We have examined the effects of DNA containing MeP substitution in the Flp related Cre recombination system. Neutralizing the negative charge at the scissile position does not render the tyrosyl intermediate formed by Cre susceptible to rapid hydrolysis. Furthermore, combining the active site R292A mutation in Cre (equivalent to the R223A and R308A mutations in topoisomerase and Flp, respectively) with MeP substitution does not lead to direct hydrolysis of the scissile MeP bond in DNA. Whereas Cre follows the topoisomerase paradigm during the strand cleavage step, it follows the Flp paradigm during the strand joining step.

CONCLUSIONS/SIGNIFICANCE

Collectively, the Cre, Flp and topoisomerase results highlight the contribution of conserved electrostatic complementarity between substrate and active site towards transition state stabilization during site-specific recombination and DNA relaxation. They have potential implications for how transesterification reactions in nucleic acids are protected against undesirable abortive side reactions. Such protective mechanisms are significant, given the very real threat of hydrolytic genome damage or disruption of RNA processing due to the cellular abundance and nucleophilicity of water.

Evolution of acceptor stem tRNA recognition by class II prolyl-tRNA synthetase

Aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (AARS) are an essential family of enzymes that catalyze the attachment of amino acids to specific tRNAs during translation. Previously, we showed that base-specific recognition of the tRNA(Pro) acceptor stem is critical for recognition by Escherichia coli prolyl-tRNA synthetase (ProRS), but not for human ProRS. To further delineate species-specific differences in acceptor stem recognition, atomic group mutagenesis was used to probe the role of sugar-phosphate backbone interactions in recognition of human tRNA(Pro). Incorporation of site-specific 2'-deoxynucleotides, as well as phosphorothioate and methylphosphonate modifications within the tRNA acceptor stem revealed an extensive network of interactions with specific functional groups proximal to the first base pair and the discriminator base. Backbone functional groups located at the base of the acceptor stem, especially the 2'-hydroxyl of A66, are also critical for aminoacylation catalytic efficiency by human ProRS. Therefore, in contrast to the bacterial system, backbone-specific interactions contribute significantly more to tRNA recognition by the human enzyme than base-specific interactions. Taken together with previous studies, these data show that ProRS-tRNA acceptor stem interactions have co-adapted through evolution from a mechanism involving 'direct readout' of nucleotide bases to one relying primarily on backbone-specific 'indirect readout'.

The regulation of HIV-1 transcription: molecular targets for chemotherapeutic intervention

The regulation of transcription of the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) is a complex event that requires the cooperative action of both viral and cellular components. In latently infected resting CD4(+) T cells HIV-1 transcription seems to be repressed by deacetylation events mediated by histone deacetylases (HDACs). Upon reactivation of HIV-1 from latency, HDACs are displaced in response to the recruitment of histone acetyltransferases (HATs) by NF-kappaB or the viral transcriptional activator Tat and result in multiple acetylation events. Following chromatin remodeling of the viral promoter region, transcription is initiated and leads to the formation of the TAR element. The complex of Tat with p-TEFb then binds the loop structures of TAR RNA thereby positioning CDK9 to phosphorylate the cellular RNA polymerase II. The Tat-TAR-dependent phosphorylation of RNA polymerase II plays an important role in transcriptional elongation as well as in other post-transcriptional events. As such, targeting of Tat protein (and/or cellular cofactors) provide an interesting perspective for therapeutic intervention in the HIV replicative cycle and may afford lifetime control of the HIV infection.

Remote phosphate contacts trigger assembly of the active site of DNA topoisomerase IB

Vaccinia topoisomerase IB forms a covalent DNA-(3'-phosphotyrosyl)-enzyme intermediate at its target site 5'-CCCTTp downward arrow in duplex DNA. The contributions of backbone electrostatics and individual phosphate oxygens to the transesterification reaction were probed by introducing 22 single Rp and Sp methylphosphonate diastereomers at 11 positions flanking the cleavage site. Methyl groups at eight positions (four on the scissile strand and four on the nonscissile strand) inhibited the rate of single-turnover cleavage by factors of 50-50,000. Stereospecific interference was observed at several phosphates, thereby distinguishing simple electrostatic contributions from putative specific polar contacts to either the pro-Sp or pro-Rp oxygens. The functionally relevant phosphate oxygens are located on the minor groove face of the helix on which the scissile phosphodiester resides. Our findings, combined with available crystal structures of vaccinia and human topoisomerase IB, show how specific phosphate contacts remote from where chemistry occurs are critical for assembly of the active site.

Structure-based drug design targeting an inactive RNA conformation: exploiting the flexibility of HIV-1 TAR RNA

The targeting of RNA for the design of novel anti-viral compounds represents an area of vast potential. We have used NMR and computational methods to model the interaction of a series of synthetic inhibitors of the in vitro RNA binding activities of a peptide derived from the transcriptional activator protein, Tat, from human immunodeficiency virus type 1. Inhibition has been measured through the monitering of fluorescence resonance energy transfer between fluorescently labeled peptide and RNA components. A series of compounds containing a bi-aryl heterocycle as one of the three substituents on a benzylic scaffold, induce a novel, inactive TAR conformation by stacking between base-pairs at the site of a three-base bulge within TAR. The development of this series resulted in an enhancement in potency (with Ki < 100 nM in an in vitro assay) and the removal of problematic guanidinium moieties. Ligands from this series can act as inhibitors of Tat-induced transcription in a cell-free system. This study validates the drug design strategy of using a ligand to target the RNA receptor in a non-functional conformation.

Polyamidoamine dendrimers inhibit binding of Tat peptide to TAR RNA

The binding of polyamidoamine (PAMAM) dendrimer or Tat peptide to trans-acting responsive element (TAR) RNA has been studied using microgravimetric quartz crystal microbalance (QCM). Experimental results showed that PAMAM dendrimer could form complexes with TAR RNA. Especially, PAMAM dendrimer could disrupt the interaction of Tat peptide with TAR RNA, which is essential for HIV-1 virus replication, suggesting that QCM is a powerful tool for studying the binding processes of Tat peptide-TAR RNA and drug-TAR RNA and has great significance for the design of new drugs. An equation to measure the binding ability between TAR RNA and other species has been proposed.

Rational design of inhibitors of HIV-1 TAR RNA through the stabilisation of electrostatic "hot spots"

The targeting of RNA for the design of novel anti-viral compounds has until now proceeded largely without incorporating direct input from structure-based design methodology, partly because of lack of structural data, and complications arising from substrate flexibility. We propose a paradigm to explain the physical mechanism for ligand-induced refolding of trans-activation response element (TAR RNA) from human immunodeficiency virus 1 (HIV-1). Based upon Poisson-Boltzmann analysis of the TAR structure, as bound by a peptide derived from the transcriptional activator protein, Tat, our hypothesis shows that two specific electrostatic interactions are necessary to stabilise the conformation. This result contradicts the belief that a single argininamide residue is responsible for stabilising the TAR fold, as well as the conventional wisdom that electrostatic interactions with RNA are non-specific or dominated by phosphates. We test this hypothesis by using NMR and computational methods to model the interaction of a series of novel inhibitors of the in vitro RNA-binding activities for a peptide derived from Tat. A subset of inhibitors, including the bis-guanidine compound rbt203 and its analogues, induce a conformation in TAR similar to that brought about by the protein. Comparison of the interactions of two of these ligands with the RNA and structure-activity relationships observed within the compound series, confirm the importance of the two specific electrostatic interactions in the stabilisation of the Tat-bound RNA conformation. This work illustrates how the use of medicinal chemistry and structural analysis can provide a rational basis for prediction of ligand-induced conformational change, a necessary step towards the application of structure-based methods in the design of novel RNA or protein-binding drugs.

Guarding the genome: electrostatic repulsion of water by DNA suppresses a potent nuclease activity of topoisomerase IB

Type IB topoisomerases cleave and rejoin DNA strands through a stable covalent DNA-(3'-phosphotyrosyl)-enzyme intermediate. The stability of the intermediate is a two-edged sword; it preserves genome integrity during supercoil relaxation, but it also reinforces the toxicity of drugs and lesions that interfere with the DNA rejoining step. Here, we identify a key determinant of the stability of the complex by showing that introduction of an Sp or Rp methylphosphonate linkage at the cleavage site transforms topoisomerase IB into a potent endonuclease. The nuclease reaction entails formation and surprisingly rapid hydrolysis of a covalent enzyme-DNA methylphosphonate intermediate. The approximately 30,000-fold acceleration in the rate of hydrolysis of a methylphosphonate versus phosphodiester suggests that repulsion of water by the DNA phosphate anion suppresses the latent nuclease function of topoisomerase IB. These findings expose an Achilles' heel of topoisomerases as guardians of the genome, and they have broad implications for understanding enzymatic phosphoryl transfer.

Modeling of flap endonuclease interactions with DNA substrate

Structure-specific 5' nucleases play an important role in DNA replication and repair uniquely recognizing an overlap flap DNA substrate and processing it into a DNA nick. However, in the absence of a high-resolution structure of the enzyme/DNA complex, the mechanism underlying this recognition and substrate specificity, which is key to the enzyme's function, remains unclear. Here, we propose a three-dimensional model of the structure-specific 5' flap endonuclease from Pyrococcus furiosus in its complex with DNA. The model is based on the known X-ray structure of the enzyme and a variety of biochemical and molecular dynamics (MD) data utilized in the form of distance restraints between the enzyme and the DNA. Contacts between the 5' flap endonuclease and the sugar-phosphate backbone of the overlap flap substrate were identified using enzyme activity assays on substrates with methylphosphonate or 2'-O-methyl substitutions. The enzyme footprint extends two to four base-pairs upstream and eight to nine base-pairs downstream of the cleavage site, thus covering 10-13 base-pairs of duplex DNA. The footprint data are consistent with a model in which the substrate is bound in the DNA-binding groove such that the downstream duplex interacts with the helix-hairpin-helix motif of the enzyme. MD simulations to identify the substrate orientation in this model are consistent with the results of the enzyme activity assays on the methylphosphonate and 2'-O-methyl-modified substrates. To further refine the model, 5' flap endonuclease variants with alanine point substitutions at amino acid residues expected to contact phosphates in the substrate and one deletion mutant were tested in enzyme activity assays on the methylphosphonate-modified substrates. Changes in the enzyme footprint observed for two point mutants, R64A and R94A, and for the deletion mutant in the enzyme's beta(A)/beta(B) region, were interpreted as being the result of specific interactions in the enzyme/DNA complex and were used as distance restraints in MD simulations. The final structure suggests that the substrate's 5' flap interacts with the enzyme's helical arch and that the helix-hairpin-helix motif interacts with the template strand in the downstream duplex eight base-pairs from the cleavage site. This model suggests specific interactions between the 3' end of the upstream oligonucleotide and the enzyme. The proposed structure presents the first detailed description of substrate recognition by structure-specific 5' nucleases.

Merged screening for human immunodeficiency virus Tat and Rev inhibitors

In addition to "conventional" drug discovery targets used in modern strategies, mainly focusing on proteins, recent insights into gene regulation as a novel drug concept have begun to invite the targeting of biomolecular interactions between proteins and RNA. Because two protein-RNA interactions (Tat and trans-activation-responsive element, Rev and Rev-responsive element) are essential for any productive replication of human immunodeficiency virus, this important human pathogen was used as a model system for our studies. The design of a fluorescence-based high throughput assay, in which both targets were presented in the same vessel, enabled us to simultaneously interrogate two characteristics of a potential inhibitor: potency of interference and selectivity toward each of the interactions. Although related systems have been reported for several DNA binders, an extension into interference with transcription events would open a new dimension of cellular regulation. Here we describe the setup of the screening assay for over 110,000 compounds as well as a primary characterization of identified hits. The assay's characteristics demonstrate that a microwell-based dual screening system for RNA binders may add a powerful tool to modern drug discovery.

Evaluation of methylphosphonates as analogs for detecting phosphate contacts in RNA-protein complexes

The well-studied interaction between the MS2 coat protein and its cognate hairpin was used to test the utility of the methylphosphonate linkage as a phosphate analog. A nitrocellulose filter binding assay was used to measure the change in binding affinity upon introduction of a single methylphosphonate stereoisomer at 13 different positions in the RNA hairpin. Comparing these data to the available crystal structure of the complex shows that all phosphates that are in proximity to the protein show a weaker binding affinity when substituted with a phosphorothioate and control positions show no change. However, in two cases, a methylphosphonate isomer either increased or decreased the binding affinity where no interaction can be detected in the crystal structure. It is possible that methylphosphonate substitutions at these positions affect the structure or flexibility of the hairpin. The utility of the methylphosphonate substitution is compared to phosphate ethylation and phosphorothioate substitution experiments previously performed on the same system.

Template-directed interference footprinting of protein-phosphate contacts in DNA

[figure: see text] We have developed a method for interference footprinting of contacted phosphates in protein-DNA complexes. Template-directed enzymatic polymerization using a synthetic triphosphate analogue (alpha Me-dTTP) generates a product having a modified Internucleotide linkage, which perturbs protein-phosphate contacts. We found that treatment of the methylphosphonodiester-substituted extension product under nonaqueous conditions (MeO-/MeOH) led to the formation of a single cleavage product at each T residue but to two cleavage products when treated under the standard aqueous piperidine cleavage protocol.

Molecular dynamics studies of the HIV-1 TAR and its complex with argininamide

The dynamic behavior of HIV-1 TAR and its complex with argininamide is investigated by means of molecular dynamics simulations starting from NMR structures, with explicit inclusion of water and periodic boundary conditions particle mesh Ewald representation of the electrostatic energy. During simulations of free and argininamide-bound TAR, local structural patterns, as determined by NMR experiments, were reproduced. An interdomain motion was observed in the simulations of free TAR, which is absent in the case of bound TAR, leading to the conclusion that the free conformation of TAR is intrinsically more flexible than the bound conformation. In particular, in the bound conformation the TAR-argininamide interface is very well ordered, as a result of the formation of a U.A.U base triple, which imposes structural constraints on the global conformation of the molecule. Free energy analysis, which includes solvation contributions, was used to evaluate the influence of van der Waals and electrostatic terms on formation of the complex and on the conformational rearrangement from free to bound TAR.

Arginine side-chain dynamics in the HIV-1 rev-RRE complex

The binding of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) Rev protein to its viral RNA target, stem-loop IIB (SLIIB) within the Rev Response element (RRE), mediates the export of singly-spliced and unspliced viral mRNA from the nucleus to the cytoplasm of infected cells; this Rev-mediated transport of viral RNA is absolutely required for the replication of infectious virus. To identify important features that influence the binding affinity and specificity of this Rev-RRE interaction, we have characterized the arginine side-chain dynamics of the Rev arginine-rich motif (ARM) while bound to a 34 nt RNA oligomer that corresponds to SLIIB. As the specificity of the Rev-RRE interaction varies with salt concentration, arginine side-chain dynamics were characterized at two different salt conditions. Following NMR measurements of (15)N spin relaxation parameters for the arginine (15)N(epsilon) nuclei, the dynamics of the corresponding N(epsilon)-H(epsilon) bond vectors were interpreted in terms of Lipari-Szabo model-free parameters using anisotropic expressions for the spectral density functions. Results from these analyses indicate that a number of arginine side-chains display a surprising degree of conformational freedom when bound to RNA, and that arginine residues having known importance for specific RRE recognition show striking differences in side-chain mobility. The (15)N relaxation measurements at different salt conditions suggest that the previously reported increase in Rev-RRE specificity at elevated salt concentrations is likely due to reduced affinity of non-specific Rev-RNA interactions. The observed dynamical behavior of the arginine side-chains at this protein-RNA interface likely plays an important role in the specificity and affinity of Rev-SLIIB complex formation.

Two crystal forms of helix II of Xenopus laevis 5S rRNA with a cytosine bulge

The crystal structure of r(GCCACCCUG).r(CAGGGUCGGC), helix II of the Xenopus laevis 5S rRNA with a cytosine bulge (underlined), has been determined in two forms at 2.2 A (Form I, space group P4(2)2(1)2, a = b = 57.15 A and c = 43.54 A) and 1.7 A (Form II, space group P4(3)2(1)2, a = b = 32.78 A and c = 102.5 A). The helical regions of the nonamers are found in the standard A-RNA conformations and the two forms have an RMS deviation of 0.75 A. However, the cytosine bulge adopts two significantly different conformations with an RMS deviation of 3.9 A. In Form I, the cytosine bulge forms an intermolecular C+*G.C triple in the major groove of a symmetry-related duplex with intermolecular hydrogen bonds between N4C and O6G, and between protonated N3+C and N7G. In contrast, a minor groove C*G.C triple is formed in Form II with intermolecular hydrogen bonds between O2C and N2G, and between N3C and N3G with a water bridge. A partial major groove opening was observed in Form I structure at the bulge site. Two Ca2+ ions were found in Form I helix whereas there were none in Form II. The structural comparison of these two forms indicates that bulged residues can adopt a variety of conformations with little perturbation to the global helix structure. This suggests that bulged residues could function as flexible latches in bridging double helical motifs and facilitate the folding of large RNA molecules.

Blocking HIV replication by targeting Tat protein

BACKGROUND

A rapid development of viral drug resistance poses a serious limitation in the current drug development programs against HIV. In turn, this obstacle forms the basis for new efforts, which utilize alternative viral targets.

RESULTS

By aiming at the Tat-driven process of HIV gene regulation, we discovered a new class of compounds as well as a novel target. The candidate compound acts on the one hand by classically inhibiting Tat/TAR complexation, however, without binding to nucleic acids.

CONCLUSIONS

Structure and molecular modeling/dynamics suggest that the stilbene derivative CGA137053 directly binds to Tat protein but not TAR RNA. As a completely new, second property, the compound also antagonizes a TAR-independent activity of free Tat protein by preventing the recently described upregulation of the HIV coreceptor CXCR4. With the stilbene CGA137053, we have identified a potent, double-hitting and chemically feasible Tat antagonist. The compound possesses high target specificity and low cytotoxicity, is not restricted to the Tat/TAR axis of HIV inhibition and highly active on HIV-infected, primary human cells.

Transfer RNA recognition by aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases

The aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases are an ancient group of enzymes that catalyze the covalent attachment of an amino acid to its cognate transfer RNA. The question of specificity, that is, how each synthetase selects the correct individual or isoacceptor set of tRNAs for each amino acid, has been referred to as the second genetic code. A wealth of structural, biochemical, and genetic data on this subject has accumulated over the past 40 years. Although there are now crystal structures of sixteen of the twenty synthetases from various species, there are only a few high resolution structures of synthetases complexed with cognate tRNAs. Here we review briefly the structural information available for synthetases, and focus on the structural features of tRNA that may be used for recognition. Finally, we explore in detail the insights into specific recognition gained from classical and atomic group mutagenesis experiments performed with tRNAs, tRNA fragments, and small RNAs mimicking portions of tRNAs.

A novel RNA motif that binds efficiently and specifically to the Ttat protein of HIV and inhibits the trans-activation by Tat of transcription in vitro and in vivo

BACKGROUND

To find a novel RNA that would bind efficiently and specifically to Tat protein but not to other cellular factors, we used an in vitro selection method and isolated a novel aptamer RNATat, a 37-mer RNA oligomer, that binds efficiently to the Tat protein of HIV-1. In the present study, we analysed various properties of aptamer RNATat, including binding kinetics, identification of functional groups for Tat binding, and inhibition of Tat function.

RESULTS

The binding affinity of the isolated aptamer RNATat to Tat-1 was 133 times higher than that of authentic TAR-1 RNA. RNATat is composed of inverted repeats of two TAR-like motifs, and even though RNATat had two Tat-binding core elements, the interaction with Tat took place at a molar ratio of 1 : 1. Several functional groups of aptamer RNATat responsible for Tat binding were identified. The selected aptamer RNATat competed effectively for binding to Tat even in the presence of a large excess of TAR-1 or TAR-2 RNA in vitro, and specifically prevented Tat-dependent trans-activation both in vitro and in vivo.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results indicate that a novel aptamer, RNATat, retained strong affinity for Tat even in the presence of a large excess of HIV TAR. RNATat binds efficiently to Tat proteins or peptides derived from either HIV-1 or HIV-2. Unlike TAR RNA, RNATat affinity does not depend upon cellular proteins such as cyclin T1, thus RNATat has the potential for use as a molecular recognition element in biosensors.

The structure of the HIV-1 RRE high affinity rev binding site at 1.6 A resolution

The crystal structure of a 28 nt RNA fragment containing the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) Rev response element high affinity binding site for Rev protein has been solved at 1.6 A resolution. The overall structure of the RRE helix is greatly distorted from A-form geometry by the presence of two purine-purine base-pairs and two single nucleotide bulges. G48 and G71 form a Hoogsteen-type asymmetric base-pair with G71 adopting a syn conformation. The non-canonical regions in the unliganded Rev response element molecule narrow the major groove width with respect to standard A-RNA. The Rev response element structure observed here represents a closed form of the Rev binding site and differs from conformations of the RNA observed previously by solution NMR studies.

Tackling Tat

Activation of cellular genes typically involves control of transcription initiation by DNA-binding regulatory proteins. The human immunodeficiency virus transactivator protein, Tat, provides the first example of the regulation of viral gene expression through control of elongation by RNA polymerase II. In the absence of Tat, initiation from the long terminal repeat is efficient, but transcription is impaired because the promoter engages poorly processive polymerases that disengage from the DNA template prematurely. Activation of transcriptional elongation occurs following the recruitment of Tat to the transcription machinery via a specific interaction with an RNA regulatory element called TAR, a 59-residue RNA leader sequence that folds into a specific stem-loop structure. After binding to TAR RNA, Tat stimulates a specific protein kinase called TAK (Tat-associated kinase). This results in hyperphosphorylation of the large subunit of the RNA polymerase II carboxyl- terminal domain. The kinase subunit of TAK, CDK9, is analogous to a component of a positive acting elongation factor isolated from Drosophila called pTEFb. Direct evidence for the role of TAK in transcriptional regulation of the HIV long terminal repeat comes from experiments using inactive mutants of the CDK9 kinase expressed in trans to inhibit transcription. A critical role for TAK in HIV transcription is also demonstrated by selective inhibition of Tat activity by low molecular mass kinase inhibitors. A second link between TAK and transactivation is the observation that the cyclin component of TAK, cyclin T1, also participates in TAR RNA recognition. It has been known for several years that mutations in the apical loop region of TAR RNA abolish Tat activity, yet this region of TAR is not required for binding by recombinant Tat protein in vitro, suggesting that the loop region acts as a binding site for essential cellular co-factors. Tat is able to form a ternary complex with TAR RNA and cyclin T1 only when a functional loop sequence is present on TAR.

Sensitive in vitro analysis of HIV-1 Rev multimerization

Oligomerization of the Rev protein of human immuno-deficiency virus type 1 on its cognate response element is essential for export of the late viral mRNAs from the nucleus. Two regions of the protein, flanking the RNA binding site, have been defined as oligomerization sites after mutants (M4 and M7) had been reported to bind specifically to the response element but not to oligomerize in vivo or in vitro. These mutants are often used as paradigms for studies of Rev multimerization. We have re-examined the in vitro binding of these mutants to model Rev response elements, using improved gel mobility assays. We find that both mutants will form oligomers on the Rev response element, but have somewhat lower affinities for RNA than the wild-type protein. M7 has lower specific affinity, but shows little deficiency in oligomerization once binding starts. In contrast, M4 is multimerization deficient, as previously reported. Therefore, whilethe sites are correctly defined, it is inappropriate to employ the original M7 deletion mutant to study Rev oligomerization.

Docking of cationic antibiotics to negatively charged pockets in RNA folds

The binding of aminoglycosides to RNA provides a paradigm system for the analysis of RNA-drug interactions. The electrostatic field around three-dimensional RNA folds creates localized and defined negatively charged regions which are potential docking sites for the cationic ammonium groups of aminoglycosides. To explore in RNA folds the electronegative pockets suitable for aminoglycoside binding, we used calculations of the electrostatic field and Brownian dynamics simulations of cation diffusion. We applied the technique on those RNA molecules experimentally known to bind aminoglycosides, namely, two tobramycin aptamers (Wang, Y.; Rando, R. R. Chem. Biol. 1995, 2, 281-290): the aminoglycoside-binding region in 16S ribosomal RNA (Moazed, S.; Noller, H. F. Nature 1987, 327, 389-394) and the TAR RNA from human immunodeficiency virus (Mei, H.-Y.; et al. Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 1995, 5, 2755-2760). For the aptamers and ribosomal RNA, for which the binding sites of the aminoglycosides are known, a good agreement between negatively charged pockets and the binding positions of the drugs was found. On the basis of variations between neomycin-like and kanamycin-like aminoglycosides in the interaction with the electrostatic field of ribosomal RNA, we propose a model for the different binding specificities of these two classes of drugs. The spatial congruence between the electronegative pockets in RNA folds and binding positions of aminoglycosides was used to dock aminoglycosides to ribosomal and TAR RNAs. Molecular dynamics simulations were used to analyze possible RNA-drug interactions. Aminoglycosides inhibit the binding of the viral Tat protein to TAR RNA; however, the drug-binding sites are still unknown. Thus, our docking approach provides first structural models for TAR-aminoglycoside complexes. The RNA-drug interactions observed in the modeled complexes support the view that the antibiotics might lock TAR in a conformation with low affinity for the Tat protein, explaining the experimentally found aminoglycoside inhibition of the Tat-TAR interaction (Mei, H.-Y.; et al. Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 1995, 5, 2755-2760).

A 1.3-A resolution crystal structure of the HIV-1 trans-activation response region RNA stem reveals a metal ion-dependent bulge conformation

The crystal structure of an HIV-1 trans-activation response region (TAR) RNA fragment containing the binding site for the trans-activation protein Tat has been determined to 1.3-A resolution. In this crystal structure, the characteristic UCU bulge of TAR adopts a conformation that is stabilized by three divalent calcium ions and differs from those determined previously by solution NMR. One metal ion, crucial to the loop conformation, binds directly to three phosphates in the loop region. The structure emphasizes the influence of metal ion binding on RNA structure and, given the abundance of divalent metal ion in the cell, raises the question of whether metal ions play a role in the conformation of TAR RNA and the interaction of TAR with Tat and cyclin T in vivo.

A thermodynamic analysis of the sequence-specific binding of RNA by bacteriophage MS2 coat protein

Most mutations in the sequence of the RNA hairpin that specifically binds MS2 coat protein either reduce the binding affinity or have no effect. However, one RNA mutation, a uracil to cytosine change in the loop, has the unusual property of increasing the binding affinity to the protein by nearly 100-fold. Guided by the structure of the protein-RNA complex, we used a series of protein mutations and RNA modifications to evaluate the thermodynamic basis for the improved affinity: The tight binding of the cytosine mutation is due to (i) the amino group of the cytosine residue making an intra-RNA hydrogen bond that increases the propensity of the free RNA to adopt the structure seen in the complex and (ii) the increased affinity of hydrogen bonds between the protein and a phosphate two bases away from the cytosine residue. The data are in good agreement with a recent comparison of the cocrystal structures of the two complexes, where small differences in the two structures are seen at the thermodynamically important sites.

TAR-RNA binding by HIV-1 Tat protein is selectively inhibited by its L-enantiomer

An oligoribonucleotide, corresponding to the Tat-interactive top half of the HIV-1 TAR RNA stem-loop, was synthesized in both the natural D- and the enantiomeric L-configurations. The affinity of Tat for the two RNAs, assessed by competition binding experiments, was found to be identical and is reduced 10-fold for both, upon replacement of the critical bulge residue U23 with cytidine. It is suggested that this interaction of the flexible Tat protein depends strongly upon the tertiary structure of a binding pocket within TAR, but not upon its handedness, and may be described by a 'hand-in-mitten' model.

RNA determinants of a specific RNA-coat protein peptide interaction in alfalfa mosaic virus: conservation of homologous features in ilarvirus RNAs

Alfalfa mosaic virus (AMV) coat protein and tobacco streak virus (TSV) coat protein bind specifically to the 3' untranslated regions of the viral RNAs and are required with the genomic RNAs to initiate virus replication. A combination of nucleotide substitutions, hydroxyl radical footprinting, and ethylation and chemical modification interference analysis has been used to define the RNA determinants important for the specific binding of the 3'-terminal 39 nucleotides of AMV RNA 3/4 (AMV843-881) to an amino-terminal coat protein peptide (CP26). The results demonstrate that potential phosphate and base-specific contacts as well as ribose moieties protected upon peptide binding cluster in lower hairpin stems and flanking AUGC sequences of the viral RNA, without direct involvement of loop nucleotides. Nucleotides identified in the modification-interference analyses as important for RNA-protein interactions are highly conserved among AMV and the ilarvirus RNAs. This RNA sequence homology, coupled with the recent identification of an RNA binding consensus sequence for AMV and ilarvirus coat proteins, provides a framework for understanding the functional equivalence of AMV and TSV coat proteins in binding RNA and activating virus replication and may explain why heterologous AMV and ilarvirus coat protein-RNA mixtures are infectious.

Design and analysis of molecular motifs for specific recognition of RNA

Selective targeting of RNA has become a recent priority in drug design strategies due to the emergence of retroviruses, the need for new antibiotics to counter drug resistance, and our increased awareness of the essential role RNA and RNA structures play in the progression of disease. Most organic compounds known to specifically target RNA are complex, naturally occurring antibiotics that are difficult to synthesize or derivatize and modification of these compounds to optimize interactions with structurally unique RNAs is difficult. The de novo design of synthetically accessible analogues is one possible alternative; however, little is known about the RNA recognition principles on which to design new compounds and limited information on RNA structure in general is available. To contribute to the growing body of knowledge on RNA recognition principles, we have prepared two series of polycationic RNA-binding agents, one with a linear scaffold, the other with a macrocyclic scaffold. We evaluated these compounds for their ability to bind to DNA and RNA, as well as to a specific RNA, the regulatory sequence, RRE, derived from HIV-1, by using thermal melting, circular dichroism, and electrophoresis gel shift methods. Out results suggest that cationic charge centers of high pKa that are displayed along a scaffold of limited flexibility bind preferentially to RNA, most likely within the major groove. Related derivatives that bind more strongly to DNA more closely mimic classical DNA minor-groove binding agents. Several of the macrocyclic polycations expand on a new binding motif where purine bases in duplex RNA are complexed within the macrocyclic cavity, enhancing base-pair opening processes and ultimately destabilizing the RNA duplex. The results in this report should prove a helpful addition to the growing information on molecular motifs that specifically bind to RNA.

Electrostatics and hydration at the homeodomain-DNA interface: chemical probes of an interfacial water cavity

Electrostatics and hydration of a homeodomain-DNA complex are dissected by chemical modification. Selective neutralization of phosphate charges by methylphosphonate substitution demonstrates the differential importance of short- and long-range electrostatic interactions. Whereas the footprint of direct contacts is in accord with crystal structures, interference is also observed at non-contacted sites. Such sites adjoin a novel interfacial water cavity in the major groove. Non-contacted phosphodiester groups in the cavity are proposed to contribute to long-range ordering of an extended protein-water-DNA interface. Use of isolated S(p) and R(p) methylphosphonate diastereomers demonstrates that interference at this extended interface is stereoselective and charge-independent. Attenuation of protein binding presumably reflects groove-specific reorganization of bound water. Surprisingly, such attenuation can exceed that due to neutralization of a direct phosphate-side-chain salt bridge. These results support the hypothesis that hydration of an interfacial cavity functions as a non-covalent extension of the DNA surface. Stereo-specific interrogation of bound water by chemical synthesis provides a general method to assess the coupling between solvation and DNA recognition.

Potent inhibition of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 in primary T cells and alveolar macrophages by a combination anti-Rev strategy delivered in an adeno-associated virus vector

The rate of viral replication appears to play a pivotal role in human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) pathogenesis and disease progression as it outstrips the capacity of the immune system to respond. Important cellular sites for HIV-1 production include T lymphocytes and tissue macrophages. Antiviral strategies, including newer treatment modalities such as gene therapy of HIV-1-susceptible cell populations, must be capable of engendering durable inhibitory effects to HIV-1 replication in both of these primary cell types in order to be effective. Among the potential genetic targets for intervention in the HIV-1 life cycle, the Rev regulatory system, consisting of Rev and its binding site, the Rev-responsive element (RRE), stands out as particularly attractive. Rev is essential for maintaining the stability of the viral genomic RNA as well as viral mRNAs encoding key structural and regulatory proteins. Moreover, it exhibits favorable threshold kinetics, in that Rev concentrations must rise above a critical level to exert their effect. To disable Rev function, primary T cells or macrophages were transduced with anti-Rev single-chain immunoglobulin (SFv) or RRE decoy genes either singly or in combination by employing adeno-associated virus vectors and then challenged with HIV-1. By directing both a protein and a nucleic acid against the normal interaction between Rev and the RRE, this genetic antiviral strategy effectively inhibited infection by either clinical or laboratory virus isolates. These results provide a framework for novel interventions to reduce virus production in the infected host.

An inhibitor of the Tat/TAR RNA interaction that effectively suppresses HIV-1 replication

One of the first steps in HIV gene expression is the recruitment of Tat protein to the transcription machinery after its binding to the RNA response element TAR. Starting from a pool of 3.2 x 10(6) individual chemical entities, we were able to select a hybrid peptoid/peptide oligomer of 9 residues (CGP64222) that was able to block the formation of the Tat/TAR RNA complex in vitro at nanomolar concentrations. NMR studies demonstrated that the compound binds similarly to polypeptides derived from the Tat protein and induces a conformational change in TAR RNA at the Tat-binding site. In addition, 10-30 microM CGP64222 specifically inhibited Tat activity in a cellular Tat-dependent transactivation assay [fusion-induced gene stimulation (FIGS) assay] and blocked HIV-1 replication in primary human lymphocytes. By contrast, peptides of a comparable size and side-chain composition inhibited cell fusion in the FIGS assay and only partially inhibited HIV-1 replication in primary human lymphocytes. Thus, we have discovered a compound, CGP64222, that specifically inhibits the Tat/TAR RNA interaction, both in vitro and in vivo.

Solution structure of the HIV-2 TAR-argininamide complex

The trans-activating region (TAR) RNA-Tat protein interaction is important for activation of transciption in the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV). A model complex for this interaction composed of the two base bulge HIV-2 TAR and the amide derivative of arginine was studied by multidimensional heteronuclear NMR. Because of the improved spectral properties of the HIV-2 TAR complex, a larger number of NOEs in the bulge region were observed than in earlier studies of the HIV-1 TAR-argininamide complex. A total of 681 NOE distance restraints were collected and used to determine the solution structure of the HIV-2 TAR-argininamide complex. As observed in the previously proposed model from this lab, the two A-form stems co-axially stack and the critical U23 and the argininamide are located in the major groove. Model calculations including non-experimental restraints indicate that U23 is within hydrogen bonding distance to A27 consistent with the formation of a U x A x U base-triple. Base-triple formation helps open the major groove to increase the accessibility of G26 to hydrogen bond donors from the guanidinium group of argininamide. Argininamide binding is stabilized by stacking of the guanidinium group between the bases of A22 and U23, forming an argininamide sandwich.

Interactions between single-stranded DNA binding protein and oligonucleotide analogs with different backbone chemistries

Chemical modification of backbone structures has been an important strategy in designing oligonucleotides capable of improved antisense effects. However, altered backbone chemistry may also affect the binding of oligonucleotides to key cellular proteins, and thus may impact on the overall biological action of antisense agents. In this study we have examined the binding of oligonucleotides having four different backbone chemistries to single-strand binding protein (SSB), a protein having a key role in DNA repair and replication. The oligomers tested had the same sequence, while the internucleoside linkages were phosphodiester (PO), phosphorothioate (PS), phosphorodithioate (PS2), or methylphosphonate (MP). We found that both PS and PS2 oligomers bound to SSB with higher affinity than PO oligonucleotides, while MP oligonucleotides did not bind appreciably at the concentrations tested. Oligonucleotide length was also an important factor in binding to SSB, but sequence was less critical. These observations indicate that backbone chemistry is an important factor in interactions between oligonucleotides and critical cellular proteins, and thus may be a key determinant of the biological effects of antisense oligonucleotides.

Structural change in Rev responsive element RNA of HIV-1 on binding Rev peptide

The HIV-1 Rev responsive element (RRE) high-affinity binding site was studied by homonuclear and heteronuclear NMR. Two Rev binding element (RBE) RNA oligonucleotides were used as model systems in this study: RBE3, which contains the wild-type Rev high-affinity binding site, and RBE3-A which is identical except for the deletion of a bulged A. The temperature dependence of the two-dimensional spectra of the free RNAs indicates that at lower temperatures more than one conformation is present. However, at higher temperatures a single conformation predominates. Model structures of RBE3 and RBE3-A as well as the RBE3-A complexed with a peptide derived from the RNA binding domain of HIV-1 Rev, were calculated using NMR-derived restraints. The Rev high-affinity binding site of the HIV-1 RRE contains a structured internal loop with two purine-purine base-pairs and an extrahelical U. Comparison of the free and bound RNA structures reveals that upon peptide binding there is a distinct change in the backbone at G24, which is involved in a G-G base-pair. In the free RNA, G24 is in the syn conformation, and the backbone is in a relatively normal configuration, antiparallel to the other strand. In the bound RNA, the backbone at G24 has flipped over so that it is parallel to the other strand. G24 in the bound RNA still forms a base-pair with G6, but is now in the anti conformation.

Deep penetration of an alpha-helix into a widened RNA major groove in the HIV-1 rev peptide-RNA aptamer complex

A combined NMR-molecular dynamics approach has been applied to determine the solution structure of a HIV-1 17-mer rev peptide bound to its 35-mer high affinity RNA aptamer binding site. Complex formation involves adaptive binding with the alpha-helical arginine-rich basic rev peptide targeting a widened RNA major groove centred about adjacent G.A and reversed A.A mismatches. We have also identified a U AU triple in the aptamer complex with the Hoogsteen-paired uracil base sandwiched between two arginine side chains. The intermolecular contacts identified in the aptamer complex readily account for the consequences of peptide and RNA mutations, as well as the results of previous in vitro selection experiments. The details of molecular recognition associated with targeting by rev of its high affinity RNA binding sites open new opportunities for structure-based drug design strategies.

Structure of HIV-1 TAR RNA in the absence of ligands reveals a novel conformation of the trinucleotide bulge

Efficient transcription from the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) promoter depends on binding of the viral regulatory protein Tat to a cis-acting RNA regulatory element, TAR. Tat binds at a trinucleotide bulge located near the apex of the TAR stem-loop structure. An essential feature of Tat-TAR interaction is that the protein induces a conformational change in TAR that repositions the functional groups on the bases and the phosphate backbone that are critical for specific intermolecular recognition of TAR RNA. We have previously determined a high resolution structure for the bound form of TAR RNA using heteronuclear NMR. Here, we describe a high resolution structure of the free TAR RNA based on 871 experimentally determined restraints. In the free TAR RNA, bulged residues U23 and C24 are stacked within the helix, while U25 is looped out. This creates a major distortion of the phosphate backbone between C24 and G26. In contrast, in the bound TAR RNA, each of the three residues from the bulge are looped out of the helix and U23 is drawn into proximity with G26 through contacts with an arginine residue that is inserted between the two bases. Thus, TAR RNA undergoes a transition from a structure with an open and accessible major groove to a much more tightly packed structure that is folded around basic side chains emanating from the Tat protein.