Rapid determination and quantitation of the accessibility to native RNAs by antisense oligodeoxynucleotides in murine cell extracts

Systematic Screening, Rational Development, and Initial Optimization of Efficacious RNA Silencing Agents for Human Rod Opsin Therapeutics

Purpose

To systematically evaluate human rod opsin (hRHO) mRNA for potential target sites sensitive to posttranscriptional gene silencing (PTGS) by hammerhead ribozyme (hhRz) or RNA interference (RNAi) in human cells. To develop a comprehensive strategy to identify and optimize lead candidate agents for PTGS gene therapeutics.

Methods

In multidisciplinary RNA drug discovery, computational mRNA accessibility and in vitro experimental methods using reverse transcription–polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) were used to map accessibility in full-length hRHO transcripts. HhRzs targeted predicted accessible and inaccessible sites and were screened for cellular knockdown using a bicistronic reporter construct. Lead hhRz and RNAi PTGS agents were rationally optimized for target knockdown in human cells.

Results

Systematic screening of hRHO mRNA targeting agents resulted in lead candidate identification of a novel hhRz embedded in an RNA scaffold. Rational optimization strategies identified a minimal 725 hhRz as the most active agent. Recently identified tertiary accessory elements did not enhance activity. A 725-short-hairpin RNA (shRNA) agent exerts log-order knockdown. Silent modulation of the 725-hhRz target site in hRHO mRNA resulted in resistance to knockdown.

Conclusions

Combining rational RNA drug design with cell-based screening allowed rapid identification of lead agents targeting hRHO. Optimization strategies identified the agent with highest intracellular activity. These agents have therapeutic potential in a mutation-independent strategy for adRP, or other degenerations where hRHO is a target. This approach can be broadly applied to any validated target mRNA, regardless of the disease.

Translational Relevance

This work establishes a platform approach to develop RNA biologicals for the treatment of human disease.

A cellular high-throughput screening approach for therapeutic trans-cleaving ribozymes and RNAi against arbitrary mRNA disease targets

Major bottlenecks in development of therapeutic post transcriptional gene silencing (PTGS) agents (e.g. ribozymes, RNA interference, antisense) include the challenge of mapping rare accessible regions of the mRNA target that are open for annealing and cleavage, testing and optimization of agents in human cells to identify lead agents, testing for cellular toxicity, and preclinical evaluation in appropriate animal models of disease. Methods for rapid and reliable cellular testing of PTGS agents are needed to identify potent lead candidates for optimization. Our goal was to develop a means of rapid assessment of many RNA agents to identify a lead candidate for a given mRNA associated with a disease state. We developed a rapid human cell-based screening platform to test efficacy of hammerhead ribozyme (hhRz) or RNA interference (RNAi) constructs, using a model retinal degeneration target, human rod opsin (RHO) mRNA. The focus is on RNA Drug Discovery for diverse retinal degeneration targets. To validate the approach, candidate hhRzs were tested against NUH↓ cleavage sites (N = G,C,A,U; H = C,A,U) within the target mRNA of secreted alkaline phosphatase (SEAP), a model gene expression reporter, based upon in silico predictions of mRNA accessibility. HhRzs were embedded in a larger stable adenoviral VAI RNA scaffold for high cellular expression, cytoplasmic trafficking, and stability. Most hhRz expression plasmids exerted statistically significant knockdown of extracellular SEAP enzyme activity when readily assayed by a fluorescence enzyme assay intended for high throughput screening (HTS). Kinetics of PTGS knockdown of cellular targets is measureable in live cells with the SEAP reporter. The validated SEAP HTS platform was transposed to identify lead PTGS agents against a model hereditary retinal degeneration target, RHO mRNA. Two approaches were used to physically fuse the model retinal gene target mRNA to the SEAP reporter mRNA. The most expedient way to evaluate a large set of potential VAI-hhRz expression plasmids against diverse NUH↓ cleavage sites uses cultured human HEK293S cells stably expressing a dicistronic Target-IRES-SEAP target fusion mRNA. Broad utility of this rational RNA drug discovery approach is feasible for any ophthalmological disease-relevant mRNA targets and any disease mRNA targets in general. The approach will permit rank ordering of PTGS agents based on potency to identify a lead therapeutic compound for further optimization.

A computational approach to predict suitable target sites for trans-acting minimal hammerhead ribozymes

Trans-acting hammerhead ribozymes are challenging tools for diagnostic, therapeutic, and biosensoristic purposes, owing to their specificity, efficiency, and great flexibility of use. One of the main problems in their application is related to the difficulties in the design of active molecules and identification of suitable target sites.The aim of this chapter is to describe ALADDIN, "SeArch computing tooL for hAmmerheaD ribozyme DesIgN," an open-access tool able to automatically identify suitable cleavage sites and provide a set of hammerhead ribozymes putatively active against the selected target.ALADDIN is a fast, cheap, helpful, and accurate tool designed to overcome the problems in the design of trans-acting minimal hammerhead ribozymes.

Variables and strategies in development of therapeutic post-transcriptional gene silencing agents

Post-transcriptional gene silencing (PTGS) agents such as ribozymes, RNAi and antisense have substantial potential for gene therapy of human retinal degenerations. These technologies are used to knockdown a specific target RNA and its cognate protein. The disease target mRNA may be a mutant mRNA causing an autosomal dominant retinal degeneration or a normal mRNA that is overexpressed in certain diseases. All PTGS technologies depend upon the initial critical annealing event of the PTGS ligand to the target RNA. This event requires that the PTGS agent is in a conformational state able to support hybridization and that the target have a large and accessible single-stranded platform to allow rapid annealing, although such platforms are rare. We address the biocomplexity that currently limits PTGS therapeutic development with particular emphasis on biophysical variables that influence cellular performance. We address the different strategies that can be used for development of PTGS agents intended for therapeutic translation. These issues apply generally to the development of PTGS agents for retinal, ocular, or systemic diseases. This review should assist the interested reader to rapidly appreciate critical variables in PTGS development and facilitate initial design and testing of such agents against new targets of clinical interest.

Improvement of RNA secondary structure prediction using RNase H cleavage and randomized oligonucleotides

RNA secondary structure prediction using free energy minimization is one method to gain an approximation of structure. Constraints generated by enzymatic mapping or chemical modification can improve the accuracy of secondary structure prediction. We report a facile method that identifies single-stranded regions in RNA using short, randomized DNA oligonucleotides and RNase H cleavage. These regions are then used as constraints in secondary structure prediction. This method was used to improve the secondary structure prediction of Escherichia coli 5S rRNA. The lowest free energy structure without constraints has only 27% of the base pairs present in the phylogenetic structure. The addition of constraints from RNase H cleavage improves the prediction to 100% of base pairs. The same method was used to generate secondary structure constraints for yeast tRNA^Phe, which is accurately predicted in the absence of constraints (95%). Although RNase H mapping does not improve secondary structure prediction, it does eliminate all other suboptimal structures predicted within 10% of the lowest free energy structure. The method is advantageous over other single-stranded nucleases since RNase H is functional in physiological conditions. Moreover, it can be used for any RNA to identify accessible binding sites for oligonucleotides or small molecules.

Hammerhead ribozymes in therapeutic target discovery and validation

Gene function assessment is a main task in biological networking investigations and system biology. High throughput technologies provide an impressive body of data that enables the design of hypotheses linking genes to phenotypes. When a putative scenario is depicted, gene knockdown technologies and RNA-dependent gene silencing are the most frequent approaches to assess the role of key effectors. In this paper, we discuss the relevance of hammerhead ribozymes in target discovery and validation, describing their properties and applications and highlighting their selectivity. In particular, similarities with siRNAs are presented and advantages and drawbacks are discussed. A description of the perspectives of ribozyme application in wide range studies is also provided, strengthening the value of these inhibitors for target validation purposes.

Filling the gap in LNA antisense oligo gapmers: the effects of unlocked nucleic acid (UNA) and 4'-C-hydroxymethyl-DNA modifications on RNase H recruitment and efficacy of an LNA gapmer

Stability against nucleases, affinity for the targeted mRNA and the ability to recruit RNase H are prerequisites for antisense oligonucleotide (AON) applications where gene expression knockdown is required. Typically chimeric gapmer AON designs are used with a central continuous stretch of RNase H recruiting nucleotides (e.g. phosphorothioate DNA), flanked by affinity and stability-enhancing modified nucleotides. However, many types of nucleotide modifications in the central DNA gap can disturb RNase H function. Here we present studies into two different types of nucleotide modifications, a flexible acyclic RNA analog named unlocked nucleic acid (UNA) and 4'-C-hydroxymethyl-DNA in the gap of an LNA (locked nucleic acid) flanked gapmer. We compared the efficacy of mRNA degradation by the gap modified LNA antisense gapmers in cell-free assays and cultured cells. This study shows that both UNA and 4'-C-hydroxymethyl-DNA gap insertions are compatible with RNase H activity when used sparingly. However, multiple 4'-C-hydroxymethyl-DNA modifications are better tolerated by RNase H than multiple UNA modifications in the gap. Furthermore, this report shows that LNA gapmer AONs with multiple 4'-C-hydroxymethyl-DNA moieties in the gap can mediate target knockdown in vivo.

Development of lead hammerhead ribozyme candidates against human rod opsin mRNA for retinal degeneration therapy

To identify lead candidate allele-independent hammerhead ribozymes (hhRz) for the treatment of autosomal dominant mutations in the human rod opsin (RHO) gene, we tested a series of hhRzs for potential to significantly knockdown human RHO gene expression in a human cell expression system. Multiple computational criteria were used to select target mRNA regions likely to be single stranded and accessible to hhRz annealing and cleavage. Target regions are tested for accessibility in a human cell culture expression system where the hhRz RNA and target mRNA and protein are coexpressed. The hhRz RNA is embedded in an adenoviral VAI RNA chimeric RNA of established structure and properties which are critical to the experimental paradigm. The chimeric hhRz-VAI RNA is abundantly transcribed so that the hhRzs are expected to be in great excess over substrate mRNA. HhRz-VAI traffics predominantly to the cytoplasm to colocalize with the RHO mRNA target. Colocalization is essential for second-order annealing reactions. The VAI chimera protects the hhRz RNA from degradation and provides for a long half-life. With cell lines chosen for high transfection efficiency and a molar excess of hhRz plasmid over target plasmid, the conditions of this experimental paradigm are specifically designed to evaluate for regions of accessibility of the target mRNA in cellulo. Western analysis was used to measure the impact of hhRz expression on RHO protein expression. Three lead candidate hhRz designs were identified that significantly knockdown target protein expression relative to control (p<0.05). Successful lead candidates (hhRz CUC [see in text downward arrow] 266, hhRz CUC [see in text downward arrow] 1411, hhRz AUA [see in text downward arrow] 1414) targeted regions of human RHO mRNA that were predicted to be accessible by a bioinformatics approach, whereas regions predicted to be inaccessible supported no knockdown. The maximum opsin protein level knockdown is approximately 30% over a 48h paradigm of testing. These results validate a rigorous computational bioinformatics approach to detect accessible regions of target mRNAs in cellulo. The opsin knockdown effect could prove to be clinically significant when integrated over longer periods in photoreceptors. Further optimization and animal testing are the next step in this stratified RNA drug discovery program. A recently developed novel and efficient screening assay based upon expression of a dicistronic mRNA (RHO-IRES-SEAP) containing both RHO and reporter (SEAP) cDNAs was used to compare the hhRz 266 lead candidate to another agent (Rz525/hhRz485) already known to partially rescue retinal degeneration in a rodent model. Lead hhRz 266 CUC [see in text downward arrow] proved more efficacious than Rz525/hhRz485 which infers viability for rescue of retinal degeneration in appropriate preclinical models of disease.

Bottlenecks in development of retinal therapeutic post-transcriptional gene silencing agents

Development of post-transcriptional gene silencing (PTGS) agents for therapeutic purposes is an immense challenge in modern biology. Established technologies used to knockdown a specific target RNA and its cognate protein: antisense, ribozyme, RNAi, all conditionally depend upon an initial, critical annealing event of the PTGS ligand to a target RNA. In this review we address the nature of the bottlenecks, emphasizing the biocomplexity of target RNA structure, that currently limit PTGS therapeutic development. We briefly review existing and emerging technologies designed to release these constraints to realize the potential of PTGS agents in gene based therapies.

Hitting bacteria at the heart of the central dogma: sequence-specific inhibition

An important objective in developing new drugs is the achievement of high specificity to maximize curing effect and minimize side-effects, and high specificity is an integral part of the antisense approach. The antisense techniques have been extensively developed from the application of simple long, regular antisense RNA (asRNA) molecules to highly modified versions conferring resistance to nucleases, stability of hybrid formation and other beneficial characteristics, though still preserving the specificity of the original nucleic acids. These new and improved second- and third-generation antisense molecules have shown promising results. The first antisense drug has been approved and more are in clinical trials. However, these antisense drugs are mainly designed for the treatment of different human cancers and other human diseases. Applying antisense gene silencing and exploiting RNA interference (RNAi) are highly developed approaches in many eukaryotic systems. But in bacteria RNAi is absent, and gene silencing by antisense compounds is not nearly as well developed, despite its great potential and the intriguing possibility of applying antisense molecules in the fight against multiresistant bacteria. Recent breakthrough and current status on the development of antisense gene silencing in bacteria including especially phosphorothioate oligonucleotides (PS-ODNs), peptide nucleic acids (PNAs) and phosphorodiamidate morpholino oligomers (PMOs) will be presented in this review.

Ribozyme technology for cancer gene target identification and validation

Ribozymes are naturally occurring RNAs with catalytic activities including cis- or trans- cleavage of RNA at predefined sequence sites. This activity has been exploited for specific gene inactivation in cells during the last two decades, and ribozymes have been important functional genomics tools, especially in the pre-RNAi era. It has also been broadly applied in drug target identification and validation in pharmaceutical R&D. This chapter covers many application principles and case studies of ribozyme technology in the areas of cancer research. We also described RNAi applications in some of the same studies for comparison. Although RNAi may be more effective than ribozymes in many respects, they are nonetheless built on many of the same principles.

Potent knock down of HIV-1 replication by targeting HIV-1 Tat/Rev RNA sequences synergistically with catalytic RNA and DNA

OBJECTIVE

Ribozymes (Rzs) and DNA-enzymes (Dzs) possess the ability to prevent gene expression by cleaving target RNA in a catalytic and sequence-specific manner. Although Rzs or Dzs have been used earlier for HIV-1 gene suppression, the present study explored the possibility of using catalytic RNA and DNA simultaneously in a synergistic manner with the hope that this novel approach will allow more potent inhibition for a longer duration.

METHODS

In order to achieve long-term inhibition of HIV-1 replication, a novel non-GUX hammerhead Rz was designed by standard recombinant DNA technology and cloned it under the powerful CMV promoter containing expression vector. A 10-23 catalytic motif containing Dz that was targeted against the conserved second exon of HIV-1 Tat/Rev region was also assembled.

RESULTS

Both Rz and Dz possessed sequence-specific cleavage activities individually and simultaneously cleaved target RNA in a synergistic manner under the same in vitro cleavage conditions. These catalytic molecules inhibited HIV-1 replication in macrophages individually and exhibited potent inhibitory effects when used in combination.

CONCLUSIONS

The combination strategy described here can be widely used against any target RNA to achieve more effective gene inhibition that exploits the simultaneous sequence-specific cleavage potentials of catalytic RNA and DNA.

Lentiviral-mediated delivery of siRNAs for antiviral therapy

Lentiviral vectors portend a promising system to deliver antiviral genes for treating viral infections such as HIV-1 as they are capable of stably transducing both dividing and nondividing cells. Recently, small interfering RNAs (siRNAs) have been shown to be quite efficacious in silencing target genes. RNA interference is a natural mechanism, conserved in nature from Yeast to Humans, by which siRNAs operate to specifically and potently down regulate the expression of a target gene either transcriptionally (targeted to DNA) or post-transcriptionally (targeted to mRNA). The specificity and relative simplicity of siRNA design insinuate that siRNAs will prove to be favorable therapeutic agents. Since siRNAs are a small nucleic acid reagents, they are unlikely to elicit an immune response and genes encoding these siRNAs can be easily manipulated and delivered by lentiviral vectors to target cells. As such, lentiviral vectors expressing siRNAs represent a potential therapeutic approach for the treatment of viral infections such as HIV-1. This review will focus on the development, lentiviral based delivery, and the potential therapeutic use of siRNAs in treating viral infections.

[Antisense therapy in oncology: present situation]

The purpose of antisense therapy is to control the regulation of genes contributing to cancer progression while sparing normal cell growth, which represents a novel alternative with fewer side effects when compared to conventional chemotherapy. Antisense oligonucleotides control cell proliferation by specifically blocking the expression of selected genes, and hence they are being developed as molecular drugs with potential activity for cancer treatment. Extensive clinical information and a number of clinical trials show encouraging results. This review discusses the most significant aspects of this new therapeutic alternative in oncology. Clinical trials performed thus far have demonstrated their short- to mid-term efficacy and safety; however, long-term studies are needed to definitely define their clinical effectiveness and true toxic profile.

Strategies to identify potential therapeutic target sites in RNA

Antisense agents are powerful tools to inhibit gene expression in a sequence-specific manner. They are used for functional genomics, as diagnostic tools and for therapeutic purposes. Three classes of antisense agents can be distinguished by their mode of action: single-stranded antisense oligodeoxynucleotides; catalytic active RNA/DNA such as ribozymes, DNA- or locked nucleic acid (LNA)zymes; and small interfering RNA molecules known as siRNA. The selection of target sites in highly structured RNA molecules is crucial for their successful application. This is a difficult task, since RNA is assembled into nucleoprotein complexes and forms stable secondary structures in vivo, rendering most of the molecule inaccessible to intermolecular base pairing with complementary nucleic acids. In this review, we discuss several selection strategies to identify potential target sites in RNA molecules. In particular, we focus on combinatorial library approaches that allow high throughput screening of sequences for the design of antisense agents.

Antiviral Applications of RNAi

RNA interference is a natural mechanism by which small interfering (si)RNA operates to specifically and potently down-regulate the expression of a target gene. This down-regulation has been thought to predominantly function at the level of the messenger (m)RNA, post-transcriptional gene silencing (PTGS). Recently, the discovery that siRNAs can function to suppress a gene's expression at the level of transcription, i.e., transcriptional gene silencing (TGS), has created a major paradigm shift in mammalian RNAi. These recent findings significantly broaden the role RNA, specifically siRNAs and potentially microRNAs, plays in the regulation of gene expression as well as the breadth of potential siRNA target sites. Indeed, the specificity and simplicity of design makes the use of siRNAs to target and suppress virtually any gene or gene promoter of interest a realized technology. Furthermore, since siRNAs are a small nucleic acid reagent, they are unlikely to elicit an immune response, making them a theoretically good future therapeutic. This review will focus on the development, delivery, and potential therapeutic use of antiviral siRNAs in treating viral infections as well as emerging viral threats.

A novel chimeric ribozyme vector produces potent inhibition of ICAM-1 expression on ischemic vascular endothelium

BACKGROUND

Inhibition of intercellular adhesion molecule-1 (ICAM-1) expression can ameliorate the inflammation induced by ischemia-reperfusion injury (IRI) in animal models. However, current strategies to reduce ICAM-1 expression have been limited by the lack of stability, poor specificity, and the transient nature of synthesized regulatory molecules (antisense/ribozyme).

METHODS

A chimeric expression vector was generated by fusing a ribozyme targeting sequence against ICAM-1 to stabilizing stem-loop structures and nuclear localization signals that are components of endogenous U1 small nuclear RNA. Oligonucleotide scanning was used to predict accessible sites for targeting within the rat ICAM-1 transcript. Efficacy of the chimeric ribozyme vector was tested by transfection of rat aortic endothelial (RAE) cells (in vitro) and intraportal delivery in a rat hepatic IRI model (in vivo).

RESULTS

Transfection of RAE cells with the chimeric ribozyme vector produced potent and specific inhibition of ICAM-1 mRNA and protein levels by >65%. This reduction in ICAM-1 expression was accompanied by a proportional decrease in neutrophil adhesion to RAE cells. In vivo intraportal delivery of the chimeric targeting vector to rats sustaining hepatic IRI produced a marked reduction in ICAM-1 expression on liver endothelium after reperfusion.

CONCLUSIONS

A chimeric ribozyme vector effectively inhibited ICAM-1 expression in vascular endothelial cells and in rat liver following IRI, demonstrating a novel gene targeting technique that may be ideally suited to clinical applications aimed at ameliorating IRI.

Functional gene-discovery systems based on libraries of hammerhead and hairpin ribozymes and short hairpin RNAs

Abundant information about the nucleotide sequence of the human genome has become readily available and it is now necessary to develop methods for the identification of genes that are involved in important cellular, developmental and disease-related processes. Identification methods based on the activities of hammerhead and hairpin ribozymes and of short hairpin RNAs (shRNAs), whose target specificities are coupled with loss-of-function phenotypes, have received increasing attention as possible tools for the rapid identification of key genes involved in such processes. We describe here recent advances that have been made with libraries of ribozymes and shRNAs and compare the advantages of the different types of library. The use of such libraries has already revealed new details of several important physiological phenomena.

Knockdown of the Dnmt1s transcript using small interfering RNA in primary murine and bovine fibroblast cells

RNA interference (RNAi) has rapidly developed into one of the most widely applied technologies in molecular and cellular research, and although young, is now an essential experimental tool. The versatility of RNAi, especially in mammalian species, lends to its potential applications in a wide array of fields. Without having to genetically manipulate the genome, the ability to selectively reduce the level of a specific transcript using small interfering RNA (siRNA) molecules has great appeal in studying reprogramming issues in somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT) embryos. In such embryos, the aberrant expression of the somatic isoform of Dnmt1 (Dnmt1s), the enzyme responsible for maintaining DNA methylation in all somatic cells, has been implicated as one factor in the improper reprogramming of the donor genome. In the present study, the ability to develop a method allowing for the knockdown, or reduction, of Dnmt1s in primary fibroblast cells, like those commonly used as karyoplast donors in SCNT studies, was investigated in primary murine and bovine fibroblast cells as well as in a compromised cell line (NIH/3T3). Two Dnmt1s-specific siRNA candidates were designed and tested. Using optimized conditions, these siRNAs were transiently transfected into the cells with total RNA and nuclear protein being collected. A 56.5% knockdown in Dnmt1s was achieved in the compromised and primary murine cells whereas Dnmt1s was reduced by 15.4% in the primary bovine cells. A reduction in Dnmt1s mRNA did not correspond to a reduction in protein as determined by immunodetection of Western blots. Overall, this study demonstrated the ability of siRNA to knockdown Dnmt1s mRNA in primary fibroblast donor cells. In order to substantially increase the efficiency while decreasing the anomalies seen in SCNT, novel techniques, like the one proposed, are needed to assist the oocyte's ability to reprogram a differentiated genome.

Antisense-mediated VEGF suppression in bladder and breast cancer cells

Angiogenesis plays a key role in tumor growth and metastasis. Vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) is one of the major angiogenic factors. In the study we have evaluated the efficiency of antisense oligodeoxynucleotides (AS-ODN) against VEGF selected from computational prediction of VEGF mRNA structure. Twenty-five different AS-ODN in two different tumor cell lines were investigated. Treatment of cell line EJ28 by VEGF723 resulted in a 83.5% suppression of VEGF protein when compared with control-ODN. Three further AS-ODN reduced VEGF protein more than 45% in comparison to control-ODN. This was caused by an antisense-specific downregulation of the VEGF transcript determined by real-time PCR. Furthermore, antisense-mediated inhibition of VEGF was associated by a reduced cell viability. In MCF-7 cells VEGF protein was inhibited more than 45% by two AS-ODN. In conclusion, we found that computational prediction of potential single strand mRNA motifs is a well suitable method to elect effective AS-ODN.

Rapid Assessment of Anti-HIV siRNA Efficacy Using PCR-Derived Pol III shRNA Cassettes

Identification of sequences within a target mRNA that are susceptible to potent siRNA knockdown often requires testing several independent siRNAs or shRNA expression cassettes. Using RNAi against HIV RNAs is further complicated by the length of the viral genome, the complexity of splicing patterns, and the propensity for genetic heterogeneity; consequently, it is most important to identify a number of siRNA targets that potently block viral replication. We previously described a facile PCR-based strategy for rapid synthesis of si/shRNA expression units and their testing in mammalian cells. Using this approach, which is rapid and inexpensive, it is possible to screen a number of potential RNAi targets in HIV to identify those that are most susceptible to RNAi. We report that shRNA expression cassettes constructed by PCR and cotransfected directly into mammalian cells with HIV proviral DNA express shRNAs that are inhibitory to HIV-1 replication. Our results also demonstrate that there is a wide range of efficacies among shRNAs targeting different sites throughout the HIV genome. By screening several different targets we were able to identify a sequence in a common tat/rev exon that is exquisitely sensitive to RNAi. Furthermore we relate the efficacies of our PCR product expressed shRNAs to the relative stabilities of the siRNA duplexes and the accessibilities of the target sites to antisense base pairing in cell extracts.

Identification of Flk-1 target genes in vasculogenesis: Pim-1 is required for endothelial and mural cell differentiation in vitro

The tyrosine kinase receptor fetal liver kinase 1 (Flk-1) plays a crucial role in vasculogenesis and angiogenesis, but its target genes remain elusive. Comparing Flk-1(+/+) with Flk-1(-/-) embryonic stem (ES) cells, we identified transcripts regulated by the vascular endothelial growth factor A (VEGF-A)/Flk-1 pathway at an early stage of their differentiation to endothelial and mural precursors. Further analysis of a number of these genes (Nm23-M1, Nm23-M2, Slug, Set, pp32, Cbp, Ship-1, Btk, and Pim-1) showed that their products were transiently up-regulated in vivo in endothelial cells (ECs) during angiogenesis of the ovary, and their mRNA was rapidly induced in vitro by VEGF-A in human umbilical cord vein endothelial cells (HUVECs). Functional analysis by RNA interference (RNAi) in ES cells induced to differentiate demonstrated that Pim-1 is required for their differentiation into ECs and smooth muscle cells (SMCs). In HUVECs, RNAi showed that Pim-1 is required in ECs for VEGF-A-dependent proliferation and migration. The identification of Flk-1 target genes should help in elucidating the molecular pathways that govern the vasculogenesis and angiogenesis processes.

A Multi-Model Approach to Nucleic Acid-Based Drug Development

With the advent of functional genomics and the shift of interest towards sequence-based therapeutics, the past decades have witnessed intense research efforts on nucleic acid-mediated gene regulation technologies. Today, RNA interference is emerging as a groundbreaking discovery, holding promise for development of genetic modulators of unprecedented potency. Twenty-five years after the discovery of antisense RNA and ribozymes, gene control therapeutics are still facing developmental difficulties, with only one US FDA-approved antisense drug currently available in the clinic. Limited predictability of target site selection models is recognized as one major stumbling block that is shared by all of the so-called complementary technologies, slowing the progress towards a commercial product. Currently employed in vitro systems for target site selection include RNAse H-based mapping, antisense oligonucleotide microarrays, and functional screening approaches using libraries of catalysts with randomized target-binding arms to identify optimal ribozyme/DNAzyme cleavage sites. Individually, each strategy has its drawbacks from a drug development perspective. Utilization of message-modulating sequences as therapeutic agents requires that their action on a given target transcript meets criteria of potency and selectivity in the natural physiological environment. In addition to sequence-dependent characteristics, other factors will influence annealing reactions and duplex stability, as well as nucleic acid-mediated catalysis. Parallel consideration of physiological selection systems thus appears essential for screening for nucleic acid compounds proposed for therapeutic applications. Cellular message-targeting studies face issues relating to efficient nucleic acid delivery and appropriate analysis of response. For reliability and simplicity, prokaryotic systems can provide a rapid and cost-effective means of studying message targeting under pseudo-cellular conditions, but such approaches also have limitations. To streamline nucleic acid drug discovery, we propose a multi-model strategy integrating high-throughput-adapted bacterial screening, followed by reporter-based and/or natural cellular models and potentially also in vitro assays for characterization of the most promising candidate sequences, before final in vivo testing.

mRNA fusion constructs serve in a general cell-based assay to profile oligonucleotide activity

A cellular assay has been developed to allow measurement of the inhibitory activity of large numbers of oligonucleotides at the protein level. The assay is centred on an mRNA fusion transcript construct comprising of a full-length reporter gene with a target region of interest inserted into the 3'-untranslated region. Luciferase and fluorescent reporter genes were used in the constructs. The insert can be from multiple sources (uncharacterised ESTs, partial or full-length genes, genes from alternate species, etc.). Large numbers of oligonucleotides were screened for antisense activity against a number of such constructs bearing different reporters, in different cell lines and the inhibitory profiles obtained were compared with those observed through screening the oligonucleotides against the corresponding endogenous genes assayed at the mRNA level. A high degree of similarity in the profiles was obtained indicating that the fusion constructs are suitable surrogates for the endogenous messages for characterisation of antisense oligonucleotides (ASOs). Furthermore, the results support the hypothesis that the secondary structure of mRNAs are divided into domains, the nature of which is determined by primary nucleotide sequence. Oligonucleotides whose activity is dependent on the local structure of their target mRNAs (e.g. ASOs, short interfering RNAs) can be characterised via such fusion RNA constructs.

Engineered catalytic RNA and DNA : new biochemical tools for drug discovery and design

Since the fundamental discovery that RNA catalyzes critical biological reactions, the conceptual and practical utility of nucleic acid catalysts as molecular therapeutic and diagnostic agents continually develops. RNA and DNA catalysts are particularly attractive tools for drug discovery and design due to their relative ease of synthesis and tractable rational design features. Such catalysts can intervene in cellular or viral gene expression by effectively destroying virtually any target RNA, repairing messenger RNAs derived from mutant genes, or directly disrupting target genes. Consequently, catalytic nucleic acids are apt tools for dissecting gene function and for effecting gene pharmacogenomic strategies. It is in this capacity that RNA and DNA catalysts have been most widely utilized to affect gene expression of medically relevant targets associated with various disease states, where a number of such catalysts are presently being evaluated in clinical trials. Additionally, biotechnological prospects for catalytic nucleic acids are seemingly unlimited. Controllable nucleic acid catalysts, termed allosteric ribozymes or deoxyribozymes, form the basis of effector or ligand-dependent molecular switches and sensors. Allosteric nucleic acid catalysts promise to be useful tools for detecting and scrutinizing the function of specified components of the metabolome, proteome, transcriptome, and genome. The remarkable versatility of nucleic acid catalysis is thus the fountainhead for wide-ranging applications of ribozymes and deoxyribozymes in biomedical and biotechnological research.

Hammerhead ribozyme-mediated destruction of nuclear foci in myotonic dystrophy myoblasts

Myotonic dystrophy type 1 (DM1) is caused by an unstable CTG expansion in the 3' untranslated region (3'UTR) of the myotonic dystrophy protein kinase gene (DMPK). Transcripts from this altered gene harbor large CUG expansions that are retained in the nucleus of DM1 cells and form foci. It is believed that the formation of these foci is closely linked to DM1 muscle pathogenesis. Here we investigated the possibility of using a nuclear-retained hammerhead ribozyme expressed from a modified tRNAmeti promoter to target and cleave mutant transcripts of DMPK. Accessible ribozyme target sites were identified in the 3'UTR of the DMPK mRNA and a hammerhead ribozyme was designed to cut the most accessible site. Utilizing this system, we have achieved 50 and 63% reductions, respectively, of the normal and CUG expanded repeat-containing transcripts. We also observed a significant reduction in the number of DMPK mRNA-containing nuclear foci in human DM1 myoblasts. Reduction of mutant DMPK mRNA and nuclear foci also corroborates with partial restoration of insulin receptor isoform B expression in DM1 myoblasts. These studies demonstrate for the first time intracellular ribozyme-mediated cleavage of nuclear-retained mutant DMPK mRNAs, providing a potential gene therapy agent for the treatment of myotonic dystrophy.

Antisense technologies. Improvement through novel chemical modifications

Antisense agents are valuable tools to inhibit the expression of a target gene in a sequence-specific manner, and may be used for functional genomics, target validation and therapeutic purposes. Three types of anti-mRNA strategies can be distinguished. Firstly, the use of single stranded antisense-oligonucleotides; secondly, the triggering of RNA cleavage through catalytically active oligonucleotides referred to as ribozymes; and thirdly, RNA interference induced by small interfering RNA molecules. Despite the seemingly simple idea to reduce translation by oligonucleotides complementary to an mRNA, several problems have to be overcome for successful application. Accessible sites of the target RNA for oligonucleotide binding have to be identified, antisense agents have to be protected against nucleolytic attack, and their cellular uptake and correct intracellular localization have to be achieved. Major disadvantages of commonly used phosphorothioate DNA oligonucleotides are their low affinity towards target RNA molecules and their toxic side-effects. Some of these problems have been solved in 'second generation' nucleotides with alkyl modifications at the 2' position of the ribose. In recent years valuable progress has been achieved through the development of novel chemically modified nucleotides with improved properties such as enhanced serum stability, higher target affinity and low toxicity. In addition, RNA-cleaving ribozymes and deoxyribozymes, and the use of 21-mer double-stranded RNA molecules for RNA interference applications in mammalian cells offer highly efficient strategies to suppress the expression of a specific gene.

Gene silencing in mammals by small interfering RNAs

Among the 3 billion base pairs of the human genome, there are approximately 30,000-40,000 protein-coding genes, but the function of at least half of them remains unknown. A new tool - short interfering RNAs (siRNAs) - has now been developed for systematically deciphering the functions and interactions of these thousands of genes. siRNAs are an intermediate of RNA interference, the process by which double-stranded RNA silences homologous genes. Although the use of siRNAs to silence genes in vertebrate cells was only reported a year ago, the emerging literature indicates that most vertebrate genes can be studied with this technology.

Secondary structure and hybridization accessibility of hepatitis C virus 3'-terminal sequences

The 3'-terminal sequences of hepatitis C virus (HCV) positive- and negative-strand RNAs contribute cis-acting functions essential for viral replication. The secondary structure and protein-binding properties of these highly conserved regions are of interest not only for the further elucidation of HCV molecular biology, but also for the design of antisense therapeutic constructs. The RNA structure of the positive-strand 3' untranslated region has been shown previously to influence binding by various host and viral proteins and is thus thought to promote HCV RNA synthesis and genome stability. Recent studies have attributed analogous functions to the negative-strand 3' terminus. We evaluated the HCV negative-strand secondary structure by enzymatic probing with single-strand-specific RNases and thermodynamic modeling of RNA folding. The accessibility of both 3'-terminal sequences to hybridization by antisense constructs was evaluated by RNase H cleavage mapping in the presence of combinatorial oligodeoxynucleotide libraries. The mapping results facilitated identification of antisense oligodeoxynucleotides and a 10-23 deoxyribozyme active against the positive-strand 3'-X region RNA in vitro.

Procathepsin D in breast cancer: what do we know? Effects of ribozymes and other inhibitors

Procathepsin D (pCD) is a major secreted glycoprotein in some human breast and other cancer cell lines. Several groups proposed that pCD served as a growth factor for these cell lines. Secreted pCD has been demonstrated in tissue section, tissue culture supernatants, carcinoma cytosols, and nipple aspirates. Moreover, several clinical studies suggested a potential role for this molecule in metastasis because its concentration in primary tumors correlated with an increased incidence of tumor metastases. In this paper, the effects of pCD were evaluated by proliferation in vitro and by mouse studies in vivo. Subsequent flow cytometry experiments showed the specificity of pCD binding to cancer cells. Cell cultivation showed that addition of either pCD or its activation peptide stimulates growth of cancer cells. These effects can be inhibited both in vitro and in vivo by anti-pCD antibodies. In addition, production of pCD can be inhibited by specifically designed ribozymes. This paper is focused on mitogenic effects of pCD, which seem to involve interaction of the activation peptide with as yet unidentified receptor. Different mechanisms by which pCD could promote development and spread of cancer cells are discussed.

Expression of small interfering RNAs targeted against HIV-1 rev transcripts in human cells

RNA interference (RNAi) is the process of sequence-specific, posttranscriptional gene silencing in animals and plants initiated by double-stranded (ds) RNA that is homologous to the silenced gene. This technology has usually involved injection or transfection of dsRNA in model nonvertebrate organisms. The longer dsRNAs are processed into short (19 25 nucleotides) small interfering RNAs (siRNAs) by a ribonucleotide protein complex that includes an RNAse III related nuclease (Dicer), a helicase family member, and possibly a kinase and an RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRP). In mammalian cells it is known that dsRNA 30 base pairs or longer can trigger interferon responses that are intrinsically sequence-nonspecific, thus limiting the application of RNAi as an experimental and therapeutic agent. Duplexes of 21-nucleotide siRNAs with short 3' overhangs, however, can mediate RNAi in a sequence-specific manner in cultured mammalian cells. One limitation in the use of siRNA as a therapeutic reagent in vertebrate cells is that short, highly defined RNAs need to be delivered to target cells--a feat thus far only accomplished by the use of synthetic, duplex RNAs delivered exogenously to cells. In this report, we describe a mammalian Pol III promoter system capable of expressing functional double-stranded siRNAs following transfection into human cells. In the case of the 293 cells cotransfected with the HIV-1 pNL4-3 proviral DNA and the siRNA-producing constructs, we were able to achieve up to 4 logs of inhibition of expression from the HIV-1 DNA.

Oligodeoxynucleotide-mediated inhibition of c-myb gene expression in autografted bone marrow: a pilot study

Antisense oligodeoxynucleotide (ODN) drugs might be more effective if their delivery was optimized and they were targeted to short-lived proteins encoded by messenger RNA (mRNA) species with equally short half-lives. To test this hypothesis, an ODN targeted to the c-myb proto-oncogene was developed and used to purge marrow autografts administered to allograft-ineligible chronic myelogenous leukemia patients. CD34(+) marrow cells were purged with ODN for either 24 (n = 19) or 72 (n = 5) hours. After purging, Myb mRNA levels declined substantially in approximately 50% of patients. Analysis of bcr/abl expression in long-term culture-initiating cells suggested that purging had been accomplished at a primitive cell level in more than 50% of patients and was ODN dependent. Day-100 cytogenetics were evaluated in surviving patients who engrafted without infusion of unmanipulated "backup" marrow (n = 14). Whereas all patients were approximately 100% Philadelphia chromosome-positive (Ph(+)) before transplantation, 2 patients had complete cytogenetic remissions; 3 patients had fewer than 33% Ph(+) metaphases; and 8 remained 100% Ph(+). One patient's marrow yielded no metaphases, but fluorescent in situ hybridization evaluation approximately 18 months after transplantation revealed approximately 45% bcr/abl(+) cells, suggesting that 6 of 14 patients had originally obtained a major cytogenetic response. Conclusions regarding clinical efficacy of ODN marrow purging cannot be drawn from this small pilot study. Nevertheless, these results lead to the speculation that enhanced delivery of ODN, targeted to critical proteins of short half-life, might lead to the development of more effective nucleic acid drugs and the enhanced clinical utility of these compounds in the future.

The involvement of human ribonucleases H1 and H2 in the variation of response of cells to antisense phosphorothioate oligonucleotides

We have analyzed the response of a number of human cell lines to treatment with antisense oligodeoxynucleotides (ODNs) directed against RNA polymerase II, replication protein A, and Ha-ras. ODN-delivery to the cells was liposome-mediated or via electroporation, which resulted in different intracellular locations of the ODNs. The ODN-mediated target mRNA reduction varied considerably between the cell lines. In view of the essential role of RNase H activity in this response, RNase H was analyzed. The mRNA levels of RNase H1 and RNase H2 varied considerably in the cell lines examined in this study. The intracellular localization of the enzymes, assayed by green-fluorescent protein fusions, showed that RNase H1 was present throughout the whole cell for all cell types analyzed, whereas RNase H2 was restricted to the nucleus in all cells except the prostate cancer line 15PC3 that expressed the protein throughout the cell. Whole cell extracts of the cell lines yielded similar RNase H cleavage activity in an in vitro liquid assay, in contrast to the efficacy of the ODNs in vivo. Overexpression of RNase H2 did not affect the response to ODNs in vivo. Our data imply that in vivo RNase H activity is not only due to the activity assayed in vitro, but also to an intrinsic property of the cells. RNase H1 is not likely to be a major player in the antisense ODN-mediated degradation of target mRNAs. RNase H2 is involved in the activity assayed in vitro. The presence of cell-type specific factors affecting the activity and localization of RNase H2 is strongly suggested.

Functional colocalization of ribozymes and target mRNAs in Drosophila oocytes

The effectiveness of catalytic RNAs (ribozymes) should be increased when they are colocalized to the same intracellular compartment as their RNA targets. We colocalized ribozymes with their mRNA targets in an animal model by using the discrete RNA localization signals present in the 3' untranslated regions (UTRs) of Drosophila bicoid and oskar mRNAs. These signals have been fused to a lacZ mRNA target and hammerhead ribozymes targeted against lacZ. Ribozyme efficacy was first assessed by an oligodeoxyribonucleotide-based assay to identify the most accessible sites for ribozyme interaction on native lacZ transcripts in ovary extracts. The most accessible sequence was used for the design and in vivo testing of a hammerhead ribozyme. When the ribozyme and target with synonymous 3' UTRs were expressed in the same ovaries, colocalization could be indirectly demonstrated by in situ hybridization. Colocalized ribozyme and target mRNAs resulted in a two- to threefold enhancement of ribozyme function compared with noncolocalized transcripts. This study provides the first demonstration of functional ribozyme target colocalization in an animal model.

Detection of antisense and ribozyme accessible sites on native mRNAs: application to NCOA3 mRNA

The efficacies of antisense oligonucleotides and ribozymes are greatly dependent on the accessibility of their mRNA targets. Target site accessibility is affected by both RNA structure and the proteins associated along the length of the RNA. To mimic the native state of mRNA for site identification, we have previously used endogenous mRNAs in cellular extracts as targets for defined sequence oligodeoxynucleotides (ODNs) designed to identify both antisense pairing and potential ribozyme cleavage sites. The rationale for this approach is that the specific pairing of an ODN with a mRNA forms a DNA:RNA hybrid that is cleaved by the endogenous RNaseH in the cell extract. To extend the usefulness of this basic approach, we report here the use of semi-random ODN libraries to identify hammerhead ribozyme cleavage sites. Thus, the most accessible sites for antisense and ribozyme base pairing are selected by this approach. A novel feature of the approach described here is the use of terminal transferase-dependent PCR (TDPCR) after reverse transcription to estimate the cleavage efficiency and to precisely determine the RNaseH and ribozyme cleavage sites on mRNAs in cell extracts following treatment with ODN or ribozyme libraries. As a model system, we have targeted the NCOA3 (also known as AIB-1) mRNA in cell extracts. The NCOA3 mRNA encodes a nuclear receptor co-activator that is amplified and over-expressed in a high proportion of breast and ovarian cancers. A highly accessible site on this mRNA was identified, and a ribozyme targeted to this site was demonstrated to effectively downregulate NCOA3 function in cells.

A complex duplication created by gene targeting at the imprinted H19 locus results in two classes of methylation and correlated Igf2 expression phenotypes

Imprinting of the mouse H19 and Igf2 genes is dependent on the presence of an intervening imprinting control region (ICR) situated 2 kb upstream of H19 and approximately 70 kb downstream of Igf2. Several recent studies have provided substantial evidence that the unmethylated maternal ICR acts as an insulator that prevents activation of Igf2 by a suite of enhancers downstream of the H19 gene. The methylated paternal ICR and H19 promoter have no activity, allowing sole activation of Igf2 expression. We have produced mice in which a duplication of the H19/Igf2 ICR produces, in each generation, two classes of methylation levels that correlated with two Igf2 imprinting phenotypes. One hypermethylated class also shows activation of the normally silent Igf2 gene, whereas the other hypomethylated class shows only slight activation of Igf2, in agreement with methylation's role in ICR function. This study describes a rare, possibly unique type of mutation that induces two distinct phenotypes in each generation.

A critical survey of the structure-function of the antisense oligo/RNA heteroduplex as substrate for RNase H

The aim of this review is to draw a correlation between the structure of the DNA/RNA hybrid and its properties as a substrate for the RNase H, as well as to point the crucial structural requirements for the modified AONs to preserve their RNase H potency. The review is divided into the following parts: (1) mechanistic considerations, (2) target RNA folding-AON folding-RNase H assistance in AON/RNA hybrid formation, (3) carbohydrate modifications, (4) backbone modifications, (5) base modifications, (6) conjugated AONs, (7) importance of the tethered chromophore in AON for the AON/RNA hybrid interactions with the RNase H. The structural changes in the AON/RNA hybrid duplexes brought by different modifications of the sugar, backbone or base in the antisense strand, and the effect of these changes on the RNase H recognition of the modified substrates have been addressed. Only those AON modifications and the corresponding AON/RNA hybrids, which have been structurally characterized by spectroscopic means and functionally analyzed by their ability to elicit RNase H potency in comparison with the native counterpart have been presented here.

Identifying ribozyme-accessible sites using NUH triplet-targeting gapmers

Accurately identifying accessible sites in RNA is a critical prerequisite for optimising the cleavage efficiency of hammerhead ribozymes and other small nucleozymes. Here we describe a simple RNase H-based procedure to rapidly identify hammerhead ribozyme-accessible sites in gene length RNAS: Twelve semi-randomised RNA-DNA-RNA chimeric oligonucleotide probes, known as 'gapmers', were used to direct RNase H cleavage of transcripts with the specificity expected for hammerhead ribozymes, i.e. after NUH sites (where H is A, C or U). Cleavage sites were identified simply by the mobility of RNase H cleavage products relative to RNA markers in denaturing polyacrylamide gels. Sites were identified in transcripts encoding human interleukin-2 and platelet-derived growth factor. Thirteen minimised hammerhead ribozymes, miniribozymes (Mrz), were synthesised and in vitro cleavage efficiency (37 degrees C, pH 7.6 and 1 mM MgCl2) at each site was analysed. Of the 13 Mrz, five were highly effective, demonstrating good initial rate constants and extents of cleavage. The speed and accuracy of this method commends its use in screening for hammerhead-accessible sites.

The cellular delivery of antisense oligonucleotides and ribozymes

The design and development of antisense oligonucleotides and ribozymes for the treatment of diseases arising from genetic abnormalities has become a real possibility over the past few years. Improvements in oligonucleotide chemistry have led to the synthesis of nucleic acids that are relatively stable in the biological milieu. However, advances in cellular targeting and intracellular delivery will probably lead to more widespread clinical applications. This review looks at recent advances in the in vitro and in vivo delivery of antisense oligodeoxynucleotides and ribozymes.

Secondary structure prediction and in vitro accessibility of mRNA as tools in the selection of target sites for ribozymes

We have investigated the relative merits of two commonly used methods for target site selection for ribozymes: secondary structure prediction (MFold program) and in vitro accessibility assays. A total of eight methylated ribozymes with DNA arms were synthesized and analyzed in a transient co-transfection assay in HeLa cells. Residual expression levels ranging from 23 to 72% were obtained with anti-PSKH1 ribozymes compared to cells transfected with an irrelevant control ribozyme. Ribozyme efficacy depended on both ribozyme concentration and the steady state expression levels of the target mRNA. Allylated ribozymes against a subset of the target sites generally displayed poorer efficacy than their methylated counterparts. This effect appeared to be influenced by in vivo accessibility of the target site. Ribozymes designed on the basis of either selection method displayed a wide range of efficacies with no significant differences in the average activities of the two groups of ribozymes. While in vitro accessibility assays had limited predictive power, there was a significant correlation between certain features of the predicted secondary structure of the target sequence and the efficacy of the corresponding ribozyme. Specifically, ribozyme efficacy appeared to be positively correlated with the presence of short stem regions and helices of low stability within their target sequences. There were no correlations with predicted free energy or loop length.

HIV-1 LTR as a target for synthetic ribozyme-mediated inhibition of gene expression: site selection and inhibition in cell culture

A library of three synthetic ribozymes with randomized arms, targeting NUX, GUX and NXG triplets, respectively, were used to identify ribozyme-accessible sites on the HIV-1 LTR transcript comprising positions -533 to 386. Three cleavable sites were identified at positions 109, 115 and 161. Ribozymes were designed against these sites, either unmodified or with 2'-modifications and phosphorothioate groups, and their cleavage activities of the transcript were determined. Their biological activities were assessed in cell culture, using a HIV-1 model assay system where the LTR is a promoter for the expression of the reporter gene luciferase in a transient expression system. Intracellular efficiency of the ribozymes were determined by cotransfection of ribozyme and plasmid DNA, expressing the target RNA. Modified ribozymes, directed against positions 115 and 161, lowered the level of LTR mRNA in the cell resulting in inhibition of expression of the LTR-driven reporter gene luciferase of 87 and 61%, respectively. In the presence of Tat the inhibitions were 43 and 25%. The inactive variants of these ribozymes exhibited a similar inhibitory effect. RNase protection revealed a reduction of RNA which was somewhat stronger for the active than the inactive ribozymes, particularly for ribozyme 115. Unmodified ribozymes showed no inhibition in the cell. The third ribozyme, targeting a GUG-triplet at position 109, possessed only low cleavage activity in vitro and no inhibitory effect in cell culture.

Selecting optimal antisense reagents

Selection of the appropriate target site is crucial to the success of an antisense experiment. The selection is difficult because RNAs fold to form secondary structures, rendering most of the molecule inaccessible to intermolecular base pairing with complementary nucleic acids. Conventional approaches, such as selection by 'sequence-walking' or computer-assisted design, have not brought significant success. Several empirical selection methods have been reported, a number of which are summarised in this review. Of notable significance are the 'global' methods based on mapping of transcripts with the endoribonuclease H (RNase H) and oligonucleotide scanning arrays.

The delivery of antisense therapeutics

Antisense oligonucleotides, ribozymes and DNAzymes have emerged as novel, highly selective inhibitors or modulators of gene expression. Indeed, their use in the treatment of diseases arising from genetic abnormalities has become a real possibility over the past few years. The first antisense drug molecule is now available for clinical use in Europe and USA. However, their successful application in the clinic will require improvements in cellular targeting and intracellular delivery. This review aims to look at recent advances in the in vitro and in vivo delivery of antisense oligodeoxynucleotides and ribozymes.

Suppression of gene expression by targeted disruption of messenger RNA: available options and current strategies

At least three different approaches may be used for gene targeting including: A) gene knockout by homologous recombination; B) employment of synthetic oligonucleotides capable of hybridizing with DNA or RNA, and C) use of polyamides and other natural DNA-bonding molecules called lexitropsins. Targeting mRNA is attractive because mRNA is more accessible than the corresponding gene. Three basic strategies have emerged for this purpose, the most familiar being to introduce antisense nucleic acids into a cell in the hopes that they will form Watson-Crick base pairs with the targeted gene's mRNA. Duplexed mRNA cannot be translated, and almost certainly initiates processes which lead to its destruction. The antisense nucleic acid can take the form of RNA expressed from a vector which has been transfected into the cell, or take the form of a DNA or RNA oligonucleotide which can be introduced into cells through a variety of means. DNA and RNA oligonucleotides can be modified for stability as well as engineered to contain inherent cleaving activity. It has also been proven that because RNA and DNA are very similar chemical compounds, DNA molecules with enzymatic activity could also be developed. This assumption proved correct and led to the development of a "general-purpose" RNA-cleaving DNA enzyme. The attraction of DNAzymes over ribozymes is that they are very inexpensive to make and that because they are composed of DNA and not RNA, they are inherently more stable than ribozymes. Although mRNA targeting is impeccable in theory, many additional considerations must be taken into account in applying these strategies in living cells including mRNA site selection, drug delivery and intracellular localization of the antisense agent. Nevertheless, the ongoing revolution in cell and molecular biology, combined with advances in the emerging disciplines of genomics and informatics, has made the concept of nontoxic, cancer-specific therapies more viable then ever and continues to drive interest in this field.

Enhancing RNA repair efficiency by combining trans-splicing ribozymes that recognize different accessible sites on a target RNA

Recent reports have demonstrated that trans-splicing ribozymes can be employed to repair mutant RNAs. One key factor that influences RNA repair efficiency is the accessibility of the substrate RNA for ribozyme binding, which is complicated by the fact that RNAs may assume multiple conformations and have proteins bound to them in vivo. Here we describe a strategy to map accessible sites on sickle beta-globin (beta(s)-globin) transcripts in vitro and in vivo and to use this information to enhance RNA repair efficiency. Two sites upstream of the sickle mutation were identified as accessible in some fraction of the beta-globin RNA by mapping with a ribozyme library and the accessibility of those sites was assessed by in vitro cleavage analyses. Ribozymes targeting either site could only convert a certain fraction of the beta(s)-globin RNA to product but not drive the reaction to completion. However, cleavage and splicing reactions were driven further toward completion when the two ribozymes were both added to the reactions, suggesting that the substrate RNA is present in multiple conformations in vitro. These two ribozymes were each able to repair beta(s)-globin transcripts in erythrocyte precursors derived from peripheral blood from individuals with sickle cell disease. Moreover, the relative accessibility of the targeted sites in vivo is as predicted by mapping and in vitro analyses. These results demonstrate that this novel RNA mapping strategy represents an effective means to determine the accessible regions of target RNAs and that combinations of trans-splicing ribozymes can be employed to enhance RNA repair efficiency of clinically relevant transcripts such as beta(s)-globin RNA.

Oligonucleotide scanning of native mRNAs in extracts predicts intracellular ribozyme efficiency: ribozyme-mediated reduction of the murine DNA methyltransferase

Modulation of gene expression by catalytic RNA requires accessible ribozyme cleavage sites in the target mRNA, and accessibility is determined by the secondary and tertiary structure of the target RNA, as affected by its interactions with cellular proteins. As we previously reported, an oligonucleotide-scanning approach using antisense oligonucleotides can be used to determine RNA accessibility in cell extracts. To test whether this method can be used to improve selection of ribozyme target sites, we designed ribozymes corresponding to the sites identified by oligonucleotide scanning and have evaluated their catalytic activities, first in cell extracts and then in transduced cell lines. As a target we used the mRNA of murine DNA (cytosine-5)-methyltransferase 1 (MTase). For intracellular studies, the ribozyme genes were inserted downstream of a Pol III tRNAVAL promoter, which in turn was cloned in the U3 region of a retroviral vector. We find that the efficiency of the ribozymes both in cell extracts and in vivo corresponds with the relative effectiveness predicted by the oligonucleotide-scanning assay. The best ribozyme causes a 70-80% reduction in the MTase mRNA levels in NIH 3T3 cells that are stably transduced with the retroviral constructs. This reduction in mRNA levels is accompanied by a small decrease in the methylation of repetitive intercisternal A particle DNA elements. Ribozyme expression also increased several-fold the reactivation frequency of a methylation-silenced green fluorescent protein (GFP) transgene. Both the reduction in methylation and reactivation of GFP were roughly equivalent to the effects obtained by treating NIH 3T3 cells with 2.5 microM 5-azacytidine, which gives an effect of about 10% of maximum. These results confirm the validity of the cell extract approach for ribozyme site selection and provide a potentially useful ribozyme for future study of DNA methyltransferase function.