Selective reduction of donor-specific cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursors in patients with a well-functioning kidney allograft

Predicting alloreactivity in transplantation

Human leukocyte Antigen (HLA) mismatching leads to severe complications after solid-organ transplantation and hematopoietic stem-cell transplantation. The alloreactive responses underlying the posttransplantation complications include both direct recognition of allogeneic HLA by HLA-specific alloantibodies and T cells and indirect T-cell recognition. However, the immunogenicity of HLA mismatches is highly variable; some HLA mismatches lead to severe clinical B-cell- and T-cell-mediated alloreactivity, whereas others are well tolerated. Definition of the permissibility of HLA mismatches prior to transplantation allows selection of donor-recipient combinations that will have a reduced chance to develop deleterious host-versus-graft responses after solid-organ transplantation and graft-versus-host responses after hematopoietic stem-cell transplantation. Therefore, several methods have been developed to predict permissible HLA-mismatch combinations. In this review we aim to give a comprehensive overview about the current knowledge regarding HLA-directed alloreactivity and several developed in vitro and in silico tools that aim to predict direct and indirect alloreactivity.

Calculated withdrawal of low-dose immunosuppression based on a detailed immunological monitoring after kidney transplantation between monocygotic twins

BACKGROUND

Pretransplant screening in living donor kidney transplantation includes human leukocyte antigen matching, and panel reactive antibody analysis, whereas T cell mediated anti-donor reactivity is not assessed routinely. We investigated T cell reactivity after living related kidney transplantation between two monocygotic twins and in consequence correlated the withdrawal of individual immunosuppressive medication with immunological findings.

METHODS

Immunosuppression consisted of mycophenolate mofetil, glucocorticoid single shot, and induction therapy with antithymocyte immunoglobulin.

RESULTS

FACS analysis of recipient peripheral blood cells revealed a normal haemogram after transplantation, showing non-activated CD4 and CD8 cells. Mixed lymphocyte reaction did not reveal donor-specific T cell activity. IFN-gamma and IL-10 ELISA of supernatants of recipient cells cocultivated with donor cells support the lack of Th1 and Th2 cell differentiation.

CONCLUSION

Based on immunological findings on days 5 and 20 MMF-therapy was reduced and stopped. Immunological monitoring on day 90 confirmed the absence of immune reactions directed against donor tissue.

Strategies for Tolerance Induction in Nonhuman Primates

Recent advances in the field of reconstructive surgery and immunology resulted in increased interest in composite tissue allograft (CTA) transplantation. Up to date, more than 50 CTA transplants have been reported in humans. A significant number of experimental studies on CTA transplants under different protocols of tolerance-inducting strategies have been reported in small-animal models. There is however, a limited number of CTA transplants performed in nonhuman primates. To reach the ultimate clinical success in CTA transplantation, more experimental studies on tolerance induction in nonhuman primates are needed to apply these immunomodulatory protocols to CTA transplants in humans. In this review, strategies for tolerance induction in the nonhuman primate model in solid organ and CTA transplants are presented in 3 major categories: chimerism induction, T-cell depletion, and costimulatory receptor blockade.

Calcineurin Inhibitor Withdrawal in Stable Kidney Transplant Patients Decreases the Donor-Specific Cytotoxic T Lymphocyte Precursor Frequency

BACKGROUND

In a prospective study, calcineurin inhibitors (CNI) were withdrawn in patients two years after kidney transplantation. We questioned whether stopping CNI had an effect on the donor-specific reactivity, as CNI might hinder immune responses leading to graft acceptance.

METHODS

We measured the donor-specific cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) precursor frequency (CTLpf) in 54 patients before and after withdrawal of CNI. In addition, the T-cell reactivity of PBMC to donor and third-party antigens was tested in MLR, and in IFNgamma-Elispot. Reactivity to tetanus toxoid (TET) was studied as well.

RESULTS

Donor-specific CTLpf significantly decreased after CNI withdrawal (P=0.0001). In contrast, no difference was observed in third-party reactive CTLpf, donor and third-party reactive MLR and IFNgamma-Elispot. Proliferative responses and the number of IFNgamma-producing cells to TET also decreased after CNI withdrawal. The decrease in CTLpf correlated with the time between the two blood samples (before and after stopping CNI, P=0.05). This decrease was caused by stopping CNI, because there was no correlation between CTLpf and the duration of the CNI treatment after transplantation. Moreover, the percentage of regulatory T cells in the peripheral blood increased after CNI withdrawal.

CONCLUSIONS

We report here that after withdrawal of CNI the donor-specific CTLpf decreases. We hypothesize that CNI suppress regulatory mechanisms that have the potential to down-regulate donor-specific CTL responses and reactivity to TET.

Rapid identification of preformed alloreactive T cells for use in a clinical setting

BACKGROUND

In clinical practice, HLA matching is generally applied to minimize the incidence of graft rejection after transplantation. Recently, graft rejection has been directly associated with the presence of preformed alloreactive T cells before transplantation. Despite this knowledge, assays to rapidly quantify preformed alloreactivity are not available for use in a clinical setting. In this study, such an assay was developed and evaluated in a large cohort to correlate alloreactive T-cell reactivity with HLA matching.

METHODS

Stimulator peripheral blood mononuclear cells were prestained with CD45-fluorescein isothiocyanate antibody and mixed with responder peripheral blood mononuclear cells. Activation-induced cytokine secretion was blocked using brefeldin A. After 6 hr, functionally active alloreactive responder CD4 and CD8 T cells were quantified among fluorescein isothiocyanate-negative cells by their expression of interferon-gamma on flow cytometry.

RESULTS

Directly alloreactive CD4 and CD8 T cells among both stimulators and responders were easily distinguished after 6 hr of stimulation without being affected by bystander activation. Among 128 paired combinations, 23.4% of individuals had alloreactive CD8 T cells, 15.7% had alloreactive CD4 T cells, and 12.5% had alloreactivity in both T-cell subpopulations. Alloreactive T cells decreased from circulation within a few days after transplantation. In line with well-known clinical observations that associate HLA matching with graft outcome, the number of HLA-A and -B mismatches correlated with alloreactive CD8 T-cell frequencies in the whole study population, whereas it did not predict alloreactivity on an individual basis.

CONCLUSION

Alloreactive T cells may rapidly be quantified after 6 hr of stimulation. Thus, the flow cytometric approach may be applied in a clinical setting to facilitate the individualization of immunosuppressive therapy and studies on the identification of patients who are at increased risk to develop graft rejection.

Donor-lymphocyte infusion induces transplantation tolerance by activating systemic and graft-infiltrating double-negative regulatory T cells

Donor-lymphocyte infusion (DLI) before transplantation can lead to specific tolerance to allografts in mice, nonhuman primates, and humans. We and others have demonstrated a role for regulatory T cells in DLI-induced, donor-specific transplantation tolerance, but it is not known how regulatory T cells are activated and where they execute their function. In this study, we observed, in both transgenic and normal mice, that DLI before transplantation is required for activation of alphabeta-T-cell-receptor-positive, CD3(+)CD4(-)CD8(-) double-negative (DN) regulatory T cells in the periphery of recipient mice. More interestingly, DLI induced DN regulatory T cells to migrate preferentially to donor-specific allogeneic skin grafts and to form a majority of graft-infiltrating T cells in accepted skin allografts. Furthermore, both recipient-derived peripheral and graft-infiltrating DN T cells were able to suppress and kill antidonor CD8(+) T cells in an antigen-specific manner. These data indicate that DLI may induce donor-specific transplantation tolerance by activating recipient DN regulatory T cells in the periphery and by promoting migration of regulatory T cells to donor-specific allogeneic skin grafts. Our results also show that DN regulatory T cells can eliminate antidonor T cells both systemically and locally, a finding suggesting that graft-infiltrating T cells can be beneficial to graft survival.

The nature and mechanisms of DN regulatory T-cell mediated suppression

Regulatory T cells have been reported to enhance survival of transplanted allografts. We have recently identified and cloned a novel CD3(+)CD4(-)CD8(-) (double negative, DN) regulatory T cell from mice that were given a single class I mismatched donor lymphocyte infusion and permanently accepted donor-specific skin allografts. When infused into naïve syngeneic mice, these DN T cells prolonged the survival of class I mismatched donor skin allografts. Here we further characterize the nature and mechanism of DN T-cell mediated suppression. This present study reveals that DN T cells are able to specifically eliminate activated syngeneic CD8(+) T cells that share the same T cell receptor (TCR) specificity as DN T cells in vitro. Similarly, we found that, along with an increase of recipient DN T cells in the peripheral blood, anti-donor CD8(+) T cells were also eliminated in vivo following a donor lymphocyte infusion. We further demonstrate that DN T regulatory cells do not mediate suppression by competition for growth factors or antigen presenting cells (APC) nor by modulation of APC, but require cell contact with the activated target CD8(+) T cells. This contact can be mediated either by the TCR on CD8(+) T cells that recognize constitutively expressed or acquired MHC molecules on DN T cells, or by the TCR on DN T cells that recognize constitutively expressed MHC molecules on CD8(+) T cells. Together, these data extend our previous findings, and expand the conditions in which DN T cells can potentially be used to specifically suppress allogeneic immune responses.

Predictive parameters for in vivo alloreactivity

Despite optimal HLA matching and a negative serological crossmatch, confrontation with allogeneic cells by organ- or stem-cell transplantation or platelet transfusion, can lead to an alloimmune response resulting in graft rejection, graft vs. host disease or platelet refractoriness. It would be attractive to be able to select beforehand those donor/recipient combinations, that do not lead to a destructive alloimmune response and exclude transplantation or transfusion with donors, that induce a strong alloimmune reaction. Many predictive parameters have been identified on the basis of retrospective analysis of graft survival data, and the results of in vitro tests to measure T and B cell alloreactivity. However, most of these parameters have shown to be relevant when a statistical analysis is performed on the population level but do not have a direct impact for the individual patient. An exception is a molecularly based algorithm, called HLA matchmaker, which seems to predict which HLA mismatches do not lead to alloantibody formation in a particular individual. Prediction of T cell alloreactivity is more difficult and will need the development of additional in vitro tools or adaptation of the HLA matchmaker program. Although the direct clinical implication of NK cell mediated allorecognition is not clear yet, this may be a complicating factor when establishing solid parameters for the prediction of an alloimmune reaction in vivo.

Down-regulated donor-specific T-cell reactivity during successful tapering of immunosuppression after kidney transplantation

Stable cadaveric renal transplant patients were routinely converted from cyclosporin A (CsA) to either azathioprine (AZA) or mycophenolate mofetil (MMF) 1 year after transplantation to reduce the side effects of long-term immunosuppressive therapy. Thereafter, the AZA and MMF dose was gradually tapered to 50% at 2 years after transplantation. We questioned whether a reduction of immunosuppressive treatment results in a rise of donor-specific T-cell reactivity. Before transplantation (no immunosuppression), 1 year (high dose immunosuppression) and 2 years (low dose immunosuppression) after transplantation, the T-cell reactivity of peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) against donor and third-party spleen cells was tested in mixed lymphocyte cultures (MLC) and against tetanus toxoid (TET) to test the general immune response. We also measured the frequency of donor and third-party reactive helper (HTLpf) and cytotoxic (CTLpf) T-lymphocyte precursors in a limiting dilution assay. Donor-specific responses, calculated by relative responses (RR = donor/third-party reactivity), were determined. Comparing responses after transplantation during high dose immunosuppression with responses before transplantation (no immmunosuppression), the donor-specific MLC-RR (P = 0.04), HTLp-RR (P = 0.04) and CTLp-RR (P = 0.09) decreased, while the TET-reactivity did not change. Comparing the responses during low dose with high dose immunosuppression, no donor- specific differences were found in the MLC-RR, HTLp-RR and CTLp-RR, although TET-reactivity increased considerably (P = 0.0005). We observed a reduction in donor-specific T-cell reactivity in stable patients after renal transplantation during in vivo high dose immunosuppression. Tapering of the immunosuppressive load had no rebound effect on the donor-specific reactivity, while it allowed recovery of the response to nominal antigens.

Pretransplant donor-specific helper T cell reactivity as a tool for tailoring the individual need for immunosuppression

BACKGROUND

A reliable immunological assay for quantification of donor-specific alloreactivity to identify patients at risk for future allograft rejection would be a helpful tool in organ transplantation. Therefore, we questioned whether the T cell reactivity in patients measured before transplantation was predictive for the occurrence of acute rejection during the first year after kidney transplantation.

METHODS

The pretransplant T cell reactivity of peripheral blood mononuclear cells to donor and third-party antigens was tested in mixed lymphocyte cultures, and to tetanus toxoid. In addition, we measured the frequency of donor and third-party reactive helper T lymphocyte precursor and cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursors using limiting dilution analysis.

RESULTS

Patients who experienced acute rejection had significantly higher donor-specific mixed lymphocyte cultures responses (n=38; median stimulation index): 113 vs. 15, P=0.005) and helper T lymphocyte precursor frequency (n=37; median 194/106 vs. 62/106, P=0.009) measured before transplantation compared to patients without acute rejection. All patients with a low mixed lymphocyte culture response (stimulation index</=20; 13/13 vs. 12/25, P=0.001) and an undetectable helper T lymphocyte precursor frequency (<10/106 peripheral blood mononuclear cells; 7/7 vs. 17/30, P=0.04) before transplantation did not experience acute rejection. The donor-specific cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursor frequency (n=34; median 53/106 vs. 28/106, P=0.58) and tetanus toxoid-reactivity (n=38; median stimulation index: 53 vs.16, P=0.56) measured before transplantation did not correlate with acute rejection. No correlation between third-party reactivity and acute rejection was observed.

CONCLUSIONS

From these results we conclude that despite the current HLA matching criteria, undetectable helper T lymphocyte precursor frequency and low mixed lymphocyte culture responses against donor antigens measured before transplantation are predictive for a rejection-free first posttransplant year. These in vitro assays can be used to identify patients who require less immunosuppression after transplantation.

Determination of the frequency of HLA antibody secreting B-lymphocytes in alloantigen sensitized individuals

Sera from prospective transplant patients are usually screened for HLA antibodies prior to transplantation, but presently available tests do not permit quantification of the humoral alloantigen directed response. We adapted a culture system for isolated human B-lymphocytes to assay the secretion of HLA-antibodies on a single cell basis. B-cell supernatants were screened for HLA antibodies by complement dependent cytotoxicity. The assay assigns precursor frequencies for HLA-alloantibody secreting B-lymphocytes (BCPFs), and simultaneously allows for dissection of the humoral alloantigen directed response into its monoclonal components. The lymphocytes of 15 HLA-seropositive multiparous women that were used to validate the assay, were found to contain HLA-BCPFs ranging from 0 to 123 per 10(6) B-lymphocytes (mean: 43 +/- 45 per 10(6) B-lymphocytes). The HLA-specificities of antibodies in the B-cell supernatants were in agreement with serum specificities. Genuine HLA reactivity of B-cell supernatants was confirmed using an ELISA with purified HLA class I antigens. When applied to lymphocytes of patients on transplant waiting lists, the present assay may enable the unraveling of serum specificities in their components, thus supplementing HLA antibody serum screening data.

Long-term survival of heart grafts in the presence of donor-specific cytotoxic T-cell precursors (CTLp) in the peripheral blood

To monitor their immunological status we determined donor and third-party-specific cytotoxic T-cell precursor frequencies (CTLpf) in the peripheral blood of 15 heart transplant recipients. PBL samples were obtained at different time points before and after transplantation. Donor-specific CTLpf and third-party-specific CTLpf were within the same range for all samples (1-1489/10(6) cells). The donor-specific CTLpf were not different between patients who had never had an acute rejection (AR) and patients who had an acute rejection as diagnosed by endomyocardial biopsy (EMB). No difference was observed between donor-specific CTLpf of samples taken on the day of transplantation and those obtained between 3 months and 3 years after transplantation. There was also no relationship between the donor-specific CTLpf in the PBL and the culturing success of lymphocytes from EMB taken at the same time. CTLpf were in the same range both when cultures could be propagated from the graft and when no cells grew out. We conclude that long-term graft survival is possible in the presence of CTLpf in peripheral blood.

Inhibition of IL-2 synthesis by donor-specific suppressor T cells in a renal transplant recipient

A study was conducted to elucidate the mechanism of donor-specific Mixed Lymphocyte Reaction (MLR and Cell Mediated Lymphotoxicity (CML) unresponsiveness in a renal transplant recipient with a long-term well-functioning kidney. The peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) of the recipient, who had not shown rejection since his transplantation 5 years previously, and those of his mother (donor), his father and two healthy third parties were examined. MLR, CML, semimicro MLR in a double chamber, interleukin-2 (IL-2) synthesis assay and limiting dilution assay were performed. This recipient showed donor-specific MLR and CML unresponsiveness. IL-2 assay showed that the PBL of the recipient produced less IL-2 against the donor than against the father and the third parties. The addition of exogenous recombinant IL-2 (rIL-2; Takeda Co.) to the priming MLR caused a recovery of CML against the donor. A limiting dilution assay indicated that cytotoxic T cell precursor (CTLp) frequencies against the donor and father did not differ. The suppressor assay in a double chamber indicated that the PBL of the recipient stimulated by the donor PBL had a non-specific suppressive effect on MLR, CML and IL-2 synthesis of the PBL across the Major Histocompatibility Complex (MHC) barrier. This suppressive effect was abolished by OKT3 or OKT8 monoclonal antibody and complement. Thus, the recipient had donor-specific suppressor T cells that produced a humoral non-specific suppressive factor only when stimulated by the donor PBL, and this factor suppressed MLR and CML by inhibiting IL-2 synthesis of the PBL.

Rapid decreases in donor-specific cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursor frequencies and graft outcome after liver and lung transplantation

BACKGROUND

A decrease in donor-specific T cell precursor frequencies as seen late, one or more years, after transplantation is assumed to reflect transplantation tolerance, a condition important for long term acceptance of the allograft. However, such late decreases also occur in recipients that developed chronic transplant dysfunction questioning its relevance in transplantation tolerance. We investigated whether early, i.e., the first 6 months, decreases in donor-specific T cell precursor frequencies reflect transplantation tolerance and predict graft outcome after liver and lung transplantation.

METHODS

Donor and third party specific cytotoxic (CTLp) and helper T lymphocyte precursor (HTLp) frequencies were analyzed in pretransplant and 1 (or 2) and 6-month blood samples taken from liver and lung recipients and were correlated with graft outcome.

RESULTS

In liver allograft recipients with good graft function (n=7), mean donor-specific CTLp frequencies decreased as early as 1 month after transplantation and remained low thereafter. In contrast, mean CTLp frequencies did not decrease in liver allograft recipients with chronic transplant dysfunction (n=6). In lung allograft recipients, donor-specific CTLp frequencies remained relatively high and frequencies were not different between recipients without (n=6) or with (n=6) chronic transplant dysfunction. Donor-specific HTLp frequencies did not change significantly after liver or lung transplantation and did not differ between recipients without or with chronic transplant dysfunction.

CONCLUSIONS

An early decrease in donor-specific CTLp correlates with good graft outcome after liver transplantation. Such rapid decreases in alloreactivity do not occur after lung transplantation illustrating the unique capacity of liver allografts to induce transplantation tolerance.

Decreased donor-specific cytotoxic T cell precursor frequencies one year after clinical lung transplantation do not reflect transplantation tolerance: a comparison of lung transplant recipients with or without bronchiolitis obliterans syndrome

BACKGROUND

Decreased in vitro T cell alloreactivity, demonstrated by decreased frequencies of peripheral blood donor-specific T cell precursors, may reflect a tolerant state after transplantation and lower the risk for development of chronic graft dysfunction. It is unknown whether a decrease in donor-specific T cell frequencies also occurs after clinical lung transplantation and if such a decrease lowers the risk for bronchiolitis obliterans syndrome (BOS), a hallmark of chronic graft dysfunction. Therefore, we compared changes in posttransplant donor-specific cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTLp) and helper T lymphocyte precursor (HTLp) frequencies in lung allograft recipients with good graft function and in recipients with BOS.

METHODS

Donor and third party specific CTLp and HTLp frequencies were determined by limiting dilution assay in pre- and posttransplant (1 year) peripheral blood samples of lung allograft recipients with good graft function (n = 13) and BOS (n = 10).

RESULTS

In recipients with good graft function, mean donor-specific CTLp frequencies decreased after transplantation (183 vs. 16 precursors before and after transplantation, respectively). Additionally, HTLp frequencies decreased but this was not specific for donor alloantigens because third party-specific HTLp frequencies decreased also. Surprisingly, recipients with BOS also showed a decrease in mean donor-specific CTLp frequencies after transplantation (332 vs. 49 precursors before and after transplantation, respectively). Again, HTLp frequencies decreased nonspecifically.

CONCLUSIONS

We conclude that donor-specific CTLp frequencies decrease after lung transplantation, but that this does not result in transplantation tolerance protecting the lung against the development of chronic graft dysfunction.

T helper frequencies in peripheral blood reflect donor-directed reactivity in the graft after clinical heart transplantation

We describe the usefulness of a fast (48-h) limiting dilution assay (LDA) for the enumeration of human alloreactive helper T lymphocytes (HTL) in the peripheral blood, in relation to histologically defined rejection grades after heart transplantation. HTL frequencies (HTLf) in pretransplant samples varied from patient to patient, ranging from 106 to 625 HTL/106 peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC). In the first week after heart transplantation (HTx), when immunosuppression was instituted, HTLf were significant lower (range 30-190 HTL/106). The level of HTL in the first week after HTx when rejection grade was 0 or 1A (ISHLT score) was considered to be the baseline frequency. This frequency did not correlate with the number of subsequent rejection episodes. During rejection (grade 3), donor-specific HTLf were increased above their baseline frequencies (P = 0.01). Expressed as percentage of baseline frequencies, HTLf increased significantly during acute rejection (AR) compared with 1-2 weeks before rejection (P = 0.003). The increase was specific, since viral infections did not result in a rise of donor-specific HTL, while also HTLf specific for third party HLA antigens were not elevated during rejection. Monitoring HTLf in peripheral blood with a shortened (48-h) assay may serve as a non-invasive method for detecting intragraft immunological reactivity. Demonstrating absence of donor-specific reactivity may limit the number of invasive endomyocardial biopsy (EMB) procedures and allow tapering of immunosuppressive treatment.

Analysis of post-transplant immune status in recipients of liver/bone marrow allografts

The aims of this study were to assess the effect of donor bone marrow infusion on the reactivity of recipient peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) to mitogen and to donor and third-party cells after primary liver allotransplantation and to identify any correlation between altered immunoreactivity and HLA mismatches, occurrence of rejection, and immunosuppression. The immunoreactivity of recipient PBL toward frozen donor splenocytes was evaluated in mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) (n = 29) and cell-mediated lympholysis (CML) (n = 27) assays in time intervals ranging from 0.7 to 27 months after transplant. Overall, the mean anti-donor MLC stimulation index (SI) fell from 25.6 +/- 5.2 preoperatively to 4.8 +/- 1.7 after transplantation (p < 0.002), with 14 out of 29 (48.3%) patients developing donor-specific MLC hyporeactivity. HLA class II mismatches were significantly associated with recipient post-transplant immune profile (p < 0.05): MLC donor specific hyporesponsiveness was observed in 70%, versus 37% of patients who shared a class II antigen, versus those that did not. Of the control group, 61.1% developed donor-specific nonreactivity versus 27.2% in the donor bone marrow cells (DBMC) group (p = 0.02). Donor-specific CML hyporeactivity was observed after transplantation, independent of DBMC infusion, with mean percentage values of pre- and post-transplant donor-specific lysis of 22.4% +/- 4.1% versus 3.1% +/- 1.6%, p = 0.0004, respectively. Our results suggest that DBMC infusion favors development of nonspecific MLC hyporesponsiveness to donor and third-party alloantigen, with maintenance of reactivity to mitogen and no additional effect on T-cell cytotoxicity.

Kinetics of circulating cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursors that have a high avidity for donor antigens: correlation with the rejection status of the human cardiac allograft

Studies on graft infiltrating cells demonstrated that accumulation of cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) with high avidity for donor antigens (Ag) coincided with acute cardiac rejection. In the present study, we analyse whether such high-avidity CTL are present within the peripheral blood of cardiac transplant recipients and whether their kinetics correspond with the rejection status of the allograft. Using limiting dilution analysis (LDA), donor-specific CTL were enumerated in serial blood samples of seven patients. From each patient, 7-11 samples were obtained during the first year after transplantation and up to three samples were obtained at a later date. Enumerated donor-specific CTL were divided into CTL with high or low avidity for donor Ag, depending on their sensitivity to CD8-blocking. In contrast to the situation in the graft, the donor-specific CTL present within the peripheral blood were CTL precursors (pCTL) and not fully mature CTL (cCTL). The number of donor-specific pCTL among peripheral blood cells fluctuated irrespective of the rejection grade of the allograft, indicating that the frequency of circulating donor-specific CTL does not reflect the immunological status of the allograft. During acute cardiac rejection, 66% (median) of the circulating donor-specific pCTL had a high avidity for donor Ag. This percentage significantly exceeded pre- and postrejection values obtained during the first year post-transplantation (median, 39% and 37%, respectively). The disparity in avidity increased even further more than 1 year after transplantation, when stable engraftment was achieved. Among donor-specific pCTL in peripheral blood, those with a high avidity were absent (median, 0%). Hence the avidity of circulating donor-specific CTL might inform us about the immune status of the cardiac allograft.

Peripheral blood mononuclear cell sonicates as an alternative to irradiated allogeneic cells to stimulate a mixed lymphocyte reaction and to enumerate CD69+ alloreactive T cells

An alloreactive reaction similar to that occurring during GvHD can be generated in a mixed lymphocyte culture. The presence of both stimulator and responder cells in these cultures makes the identification and enumeration of alloreactive cells difficult and unreliable. We describe the use of PBMC sonicates as an alternative to the standard MLC method to stimulate an allogeneic reaction. Using combinations of autologous or allogeneic PBMC sonicates, we showed that the lymphocyte proliferative response to cell sonicates was comparable to the response using irradiated cells. The proliferative response was concentration dependent and reached maximum levels at day 6. Both irradiated cells and PBMC sonicates induced significantly lower responses when the stimulating cells were partially HLA-DR matched rather than completely mismatched. Alloreactive T cells stimulated with sonicates were enumerated by the flow cytometric detection of CD69 or CD25. In HLA-mismatched cultures, approximately 7% of CD3+ T cells were CD69+ or CD25+, suggesting alloreactivity. Although there was a significant correlation between the expression of these activation markers and lymphocyte proliferative responses, significant individual variations in the results of these two assays were observed. The results in this study demonstrate the potential of using PBMC sonicates instead of irradiated lymphocytes for the study and identification of alloreactive cells at the cellular and molecular level.

Clinical significance of selective decline of donor-reactive IL-2-producing T lymphocytes after renal transplantation

Limiting dilution analysis technique was used to enumerate the circulating precursor frequency of donor and third-party-reactive helper T lymphocytes (HTLpf) in 28 renal allograft recipients before (pre-tx) and at three intervals (T1: 60-90 days, T2: 120-180 days, T3: 360-1620 days) after transplantation (post-tx). Two patterns of responses were identified, in group 1 (n = 12), a five to 31-fold reduction of donor-reactive HTLpf (ranging from 1/19231-1/62500) occurred within 90-1620 days post-tx, while in group 2(n = 16), no significant changes of donor-reactive HTLpf were seen. In both groups, the third-party-reactive HTLpf in most of these patients remained largely unchanged throughout the study period. The number of HLA-DR mismatches, total number of rejection episodes, serum creatinine levels, and biopsy findings at T3 were compared in both groups using Fisher's exact probability, and the Mann-Whitney test. We found that 11 patients (92%) in group 1 were HLA-DR compatible with donors, while nine (56%) patients in group 2 were HLA-DR compatible with donors, p = 0.04. In group 1 eight rejection episodes occurred in five (41.6%) patients during the study period, compared to 33 in 13 (81%) patients in group 2, p = 0.03. Group 1 had a significantly lower serum creatinine level (at T3); median: 136 vs 165 mumol/l for group 2, p = 0.03. Biopsy indicated no rejection (at T3) in eight (66%) patients in group 1 as compared to three (18%) patients in group 2, p = 0.03. Taken together, these results indicate that the frequency of circulating HTLpf correlate with the clinical status of the graft. Therefore monitoring of HTLpf in the peripheral blood could be useful in predicting graft outcome and selecting patients for reducing immunosuppression.

The use of computer-assisted video image analysis for the quantification of CD8+ T lymphocytes producing tumor necrosis factor alpha spots in response to peptide antigens

Enzyme-linked immunospot (ELISPOT) analysis is a sensitive technique for the detection and quantification of single T lymphocytes forming cytokine spots after antigen contact in vitro. Herein computer-assisted video image analysis (CVIA) was applied to automatically determine the number and size of tumor necrosis factor alpha (TNF-alpha) spots formed by single blood-derived CD8+ T cells after contact with peptide-loaded target cells. With CVIA and TNF-alpha ELISPOT analysis we quantified CD8+ T cells responsive to HLA-A2.1-binding tyrosinase and influenza matrix peptides in healthy donors. We followed the course of the virus-specific T cell response in two HLA-A2-positive patients with reactivation of latent cytomegalovirus (CMV) infection during immunosuppressive therapy. The test proved sufficiently sensitive to detect in the blood of both patients a temporary expansion of CD8+ T lymphocytes reactive with a known immunogenic HLA-A2.1-binding peptide from glycoprotein B of CMV. Reactivity to peptide antigens was not only reflected by numeric increases of spot formation, but also by the appearance of larger spot areas, presumably formed by strongly peptide-reactive CD8+ T cells. We conclude that the combined use of the TNF-alpha ELISPOT assay and CVIA allows reliable monitoring of the T cell responsiveness to peptide antigens in peripheral blood.

Pretransplant CD4 helper function and interleukin 10 response predict risk of acute kidney graft rejection

In a prospective study of 80 patients, we investigated the association of acute kidney graft rejection with pretransplant T helper/suppressor activity, B-cell responses, and in vitro cytokine secretion. Patients' CD4+ or CD8+ T cells were cocultured with control B cells and pokeweed mitogen for 6 days. SAC I was used for T cell- and monocyte-independent B-cell stimulation and pokeweed mitogen was used for T cell-dependent B-cell stimulation. B-cell differentiation was assessed in a reverse hemolytic plaque assay. Cytokine responses of T cells (interleukin [IL]-2, IL-10, gamma-interferon) and B cells/monocytes (IL-6, IL-8, tumor necrosis factor-alpha, granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor) were determined in culture supernatants using ELISA. Subsets of CD4+ T cells, CD8+ T cells, and B cells were assessed by flow cytometry. None of 12 patients with pretransplant CD4 helper defects (CD4 helper activity < 10%) had acute rejection episodes, in contrast to 32 of 68 (47%) patients with normal pretransplant CD4 helper function (P = 0.001). Patients with pretransplant CD4 helper defects also had better 1-year graft function than patients without CD4 helper defects (serum creatinine 1.2 +/- 0.1 mg/dl and 1.7 +/- 0.1 mg/dl, respectively, P < 0.05). Pretransplant IL-10 responses were significantly associated with the occurrence of acute rejection episodes (P = 0.001) and impaired 1-year graft function (P < 0.001). All 14 patients with low pretransplant IL-10 responses (< 100 pg/ml) had 1-year serum creatinine values of < 1.5 mg/dl. Pretransplant B-cell defects and B cell/monocyte-derived cytokine secretion were not related to the incidence of graft rejection or infectious complications. Pretransplant CD8 suppressor-effector (CD11b+), cell counts were significantly associated with the occurrence of infections (P < 0.05). These results show that pretransplant CD4 helper defects and low IL-10 responses predict a low risk of graft rejection, whereas Th1 (IL-2, gamma-interferon) and B-cell/monocyte responses are not of predictive value.

Comparison of T cell responses in patients with a long-term surviving renal allograft versus a long-term surviving liver allograft. It's a different world

The aim of the present study was to analyze whether acquired transplantation tolerance had developed in patients with a long-term surviving renal or liver allograft. Analysis of antidonor cytotoxic T cell precursor frequencies was performed in 31 renal allograft recipients and 9 liver allograft recipients with good graft function 2 years after transplantation. The results demonstrated that, before transplantation, normal antidonor T cell responses were generated in both groups of patients. Two years after transplantation, donor-specific CTL nonresponsiveness had developed in a minority of the renal transplant recipients. In contrast, 8 out of 9 liver transplant recipients showed donor-specific mixed lymphocyte culture and CTL nonresponsiveness. These findings indicate that development of donor-specific T cell nonresponsiveness is not a common event after kidney transplantation, whereas liver transplantation seems to induce, at least in vitro, a state of donor-specific T cell nonresponsiveness.

Donor-specific transfusion and donor bone marrow infusion in renal transplantation tolerance: a review of efficacy and mechanisms

The ultimate goal in transplantation is modulation of the immune response to produce tolerance without immunosuppression. To date only a state of pseudotolerance for the allograft has been achieved through the use of potent pharmacologic and biologic manipulations. Despite these manipulations to prevent acute rejection, chronic rejection eventually results in graft failure. Thus, different strategies have been sought to induce tolerance and prevent acute and chronic rejection. Historically, donor-specific transfusion (DST) was one such strategy attempted. Donor-specific transfusion has been used primarily in living donor organ transplantation. With the concern that DST may sensitize patients, thereby preventing transplantation and introduction of cyclosporine, the use of DST was curtailed. More recently, donor bone marrow (DBM) infusion at the time of cadaveric transplantation has been used to facilitate development of microchimerism and tolerance to abrogate acute and chronic rejection. However, DBM infusion may predispose the recipient to graft-versus-host disease and is not easily accomplished in living donor organ transplantation. The potentially immunomodulating and tolerizing mechanisms of DST and DBM infusion are similar and include induction of anergy, stimulation of anti-anti-HLA antibodies, provision of soluble HLA antigen, suppressor cell and/or veto cell activity, clonal deletion, regulation of cell surface molecules, regulation of cytokines, promotion of microchimerism, or a combination of these. Of these mechanisms, microchimerism with the concomitant persistence of soluble donor HLA antigen is felt by many to be the most important. Although microchimerism is detectable in many patients who are tolerant of their grafts, there is no clear evidence that chimerism is responsible for the induction or maintenance of tolerance.

Correlation of donor antigen-specific hyporeactivity with allogeneic microchimerism in kidney and lung recipients

Our previous studies indicate donor antigen-specific hyporeactivity is a useful marker for identifying solid organ transplant recipients at low risk for immunological complications; the hyporeactive subgroup experiences a lower incidence of chronic rejection. One purpose of the current study was to determine whether hyporeactivity could be identified in pediatric kidney recipients and whether it correlated with improved graft outcome. Of 18 pediatric kidney recipients tested, 6 (33%) had developed donor antigen-specific hyporeactivity. All 18 experienced good graft outcome. Second, we determined whether donor antigen-specific hyporeactivity correlates with peripheral blood microchimerism and outcome in adult kidney recipients. Our previous studies of lung recipients demonstrated development of obliterative bronchiolitis in recipients with microchimerism who remain responsive, but not in recipients who had become hyporesponsive to donor antigen. Preliminary results in our current study of 23 adult kidney recipients indicate microchimerism for 6 (26%): 4 hyporesponsive and 2 responsive to donor antigen. Microchimerism was not detected for 17 recipients: 6 hyporesponsive and 11 responsive to donor antigen. One hyporesponsive/chimeric patient and 4 recipients negative for both parameters have been diagnosed with biopsy-proven chronic rejection. In summary, both hyporeactivity and chimerism are found at a higher frequency in lung than kidney recipients. Unlike lung recipients, not all hyporesponsive kidney recipients had peripheral blood chimerism. Additional numbers are needed to determine if microchimerism correlates with donor antigen-specific hyporeactivity or graft outcome.

Limiting dilution analysis: quantification of IL-2 producing allospecific lymphocytes after renal and cardiac transplantation

A rapid and robust limiting dilution assay was developed to measure the frequency of donor-reactive, IL-2 (interleukin 2) producing, helper T lymphocytes in the peripheral T cell population of organ allograft recipients. The IL-2 bioassay was performed using two methodologies to assess the response of CTLL-2 indicator cells. The first depended on spectrophotometric detection of bioreduced XTT whilst the second involved measurement of [3H]thymidine incorporation. The radioisotopic method was slightly more sensitive but both assays could be used for analysis of limiting dilution culture supernatants after primary incubation of recipient lymphocytes with donor splenic cells for 48 hours. All the assays produced results which conformed to single hit kinetics, indicating that IL-2 was production was dependent on a single limiting cell type. The frequency of allospecific helper lymphocytes in the peripheral T cell population of normal volunteers did not vary significantly during a 28-day period. It was found that immunosuppressed allograft recipients had a significantly reduced proportion of T cells in their peripheral blood mononuclear cell population. However, it was possible to measure the frequency of donor-reactive helper cells in the T cell population of transplant patients. These frequency values were very low in two renal allograft recipients who were HLA-DR matched to their donor organs. Three of four HLA-DR mismatched cardiac recipients showed a significant decrease in the frequency of their donor-reactive helper lymphocytes during the period of monitoring. The fourth patient, who received antilymphocyte antibodies for the first three days after transplantation, showed significant fluctuations in the frequency of these cells. The four cardiac recipients showed little histopathological evidence of acute graft rejection with only one patient experiencing a brief episode of moderate rejection; this patient showed a high frequency of donor-reactive helper cells when assayed immediately after this episode but the frequency subsequently declined.

Frequency analysis of tumor-reactive cytotoxic T lymphocytes in peripheral blood of a melanoma patient vaccinated with autologous tumor cells

A limiting-dilution assay was developed and used to determine the frequency of autologous tumor-reactive cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) in peripheral blood of a melanoma patient MZ2, who has been free of detectable disease since several years. In this patient, the frequencies of tumor-reactive CTL spontaneously varied only by a factor of 1.5. After vaccinations with autologous mutagenized and lethally irradiated tumor cells a two- to tenfold increase in frequencies of tumor-reactive CTL was found within the first 2 weeks. Thereafter, CTL frequencies returned to values measured prior to vaccinations. We conclude, that the limiting-dilution assay applied in this study can detect changes in the T cell response to autologous tumor cells. The frequency of tumor-reactive CTL determined with this approach can serve as an immunological parameter for monitoring the T cell response to autologous tumor cells in individual cancer patients receiving tumor cell vaccinations.

Characteristics of graft-infiltrating lymphocytes after human heart transplantation. HLA mismatches and the cellular immune response within the transplanted heart

The influence of HLA mismatches between donor and recipient on the phenotypes, function, and specificity of T-lymphocyte cultures derived from endomyocardial biopsies was studied in 118 heart transplant recipients. In case of HLA-DR mismatches, the majority of the EMB-derived cultures were dominated by CD4+ T cells while, in patients with HLA-A and -B mismatches but without DR mismatches, CD8+ T cells comprised the predominant T-cell subset. Cytotoxicity against donor antigens was observed in 75% of the cultures. A significantly (p < 0.005) lower proportion of the cultures showed cytotoxicity against HLA-A antigens (36%) when compared with HLA-B (53%) or HLA-DR (49%). An HLA-A2 mismatch elicited a cytotoxic response that was comparable to that found against HLA-B and -DR antigens: 62% of the cultures from HLA-A2 mismatched donor-recipient combinations was reactive against A2. A higher number of A, B, or DR mismatches resulted in a higher number of cytotoxic cultures directed against these antigens. A higher number of HLA-B and -DR mismatches was associated with a lower freedom from rejection. Our data indicate that, despite the use of adequate immunosuppressive therapy, the degree of HLA matching plays a crucial role in the immune response against a transplanted heart, resulting in a significant effect on freedom from rejection.

Development of immunological assays to monitor pulmonary allograft rejection

BACKGROUND

At present the diagnosis of pulmonary allograft rejection is made after examination of transbronchial biopsy specimens; this method is highly invasive. A study was performed to determine whether immunological parameters measured in peripheral blood or bronchoalveolar lavage samples correlate with the histological diagnosis of rejection.

METHODS

Left unilateral pulmonary allotransplantation was performed between dogs. The animals were immunosuppressed with cyclosporin A after transplantation but the dose of this drug was gradually reduced to allow controlled rejection to take place. Rejection was diagnosed histologically. Four immunological parameters were investigated: measurement of lavage derived T cell proliferation in response to limited culture with interleukin 2; measurement of changes in the frequency of donor reactive cytotoxic T lymphocytes; assay of the level of donor cell binding IgG antibody in recipient plasma; and measurement of the antibody dependent cell mediated cytotoxic response to donor cells after labelling with recipient plasma.

RESULTS

Assays based on measurement of the function of T cells produced significant results at a time later than the histological diagnosis of severe rejection. The level of donor reactive IgG antibody increased at a time that corresponded closely with the diagnosis of severe rejection. This IgG did not activate the antibody dependent cell mediated cytotoxic effector mechanism to a significant extent.

CONCLUSIONS

Measurement of parameters of donor specific immunoreactivity can yield data which are indicative of severe pulmonary allograft rejection. These methods make use of samples which can be obtained by minimally invasive methods. Measurement of the plasma level of donor reactive IgG antibody appears to be the most useful assay. However, each of the in vitro assays used during this series of experiments was less sensitive to the onset of rejection than was routine histological examination.

Failure of in vitro T-cell assays to predict clinical outcome after human kidney transplantation

Allotransplant rejection is a T-cell-dependent reaction. Functional in vitro T-cell assays are being used widely for donor-recipient matching in bone marrow transplantation and have recently been used in some centres for transplant monitoring. In order to assess tolerance induction after clinical transplantation, we measured the T-cell response of the host against donor spleen cells of 33 kidney transplant patients before and every 3 months after transplantation over a period of 18 months. The T-cell reactivity before transplantation was not significantly different in any of the assays in rejecting and non-rejecting patients. In the classical mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC), a donor-specific loss of reactivity was seen only in a patient with a CMV-associated irreversible transplant rejection. One patient with chronic rejection acquired a very high MLC response against donor spleen cells and a high response against third-party cells. Little or nonspecific changes were seen in the MLCs of all other patients. Using the method of limiting dilution analysis (LDA), we found a significant reduction of donor-specific cytotoxic T-cell precursors (CTL-p) within the first 3 months after transplantation in most patients with high antidonor CTL-p frequencies before transplantation. The reduction of donor-specific CTL-p was seen in patients with rejection episodes as well as in patients without. Thus we conclude, in contrast to others, that MLC and CTL-p LDA have no predictive value on the outcome of clinical transplantation.

IL-2, IL-3, and IFN-gamma differently affect in vivo frequencies of circulating precursors of cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL-P)

Experimental animal and human in vivo studies have previously demonstrated the impact of exogenous administration of various cytokines on frequencies of circulating myeloid and LAK precursor cells. For the first time we investigated whether exogenous cytokines, in the absence of antigenic challenge, may also influence frequencies of circulating antigen-specific cytotoxic T-lymphocyte precursor cells. We further asked whether triggering of autoimmune pathways as has been reported for several cytokines can be confirmed on the cellular level by demonstration of induction of autoreactive CTL-p. Limiting dilution analysis was used to determine alloreactive CTL-p frequencies in 31 patients with nonhematologic diseases before and after short-term systemic treatment with either rIL-2 (4.8 x 10(6) IU/m2 bid), rIL-3 (2.5, 5.0 or 10.0 micrograms/kg qd), rGM-CSF (5 micrograms/kg qd), rIFN-gamma (200 or 400 micrograms qd), or IFN-alpha (3 or 5 x 10(6) IU qod). Simultaneously, autoreactive CTL-p frequencies were determined by split-well analysis in 25 of these patients. We found that rIL-2 significantly expands the circulating precursor pool of alloreactive CTL (p < 0.05). rIL-3 affected CTL-p frequencies in a dose-dependent fashion. Low and intermediate doses of rIL-3 did not exhibit significant effects, whereas 10 micrograms/kg rIL-3 led to expansion of alloreactive CTL-p in the same order of magnitude as did rIL-2. This effect was statistically significant when compared with rGM-CSF (p < 0.02), which apparently had no influence on alloreactive CTL-p frequencies. In contrast to rIL-2 and rIL-3, exogenous rIFN-gamma markedly reduced the circulating precursor pool of CTL. This again was statistically significant compared with rIFN-alpha (p < 0.03), which, like rGM-CSF, did not exhibit any effects on the level of alloreactive CTL-p. Frequencies of autoreactive CTL-p were invariably below the limit of detection in our system (< 1/300,000). In conclusion, these data demonstrate that (a) short-term systemic administration of rIL-2, rIL-3, and rIFN-gamma differently affects the clone size of circulating precursors of alloreactive CTL in man, while rGM-CSF and rIFN-alpha do not exhibit measurable effects, and (b) none of the cytokines administered is capable of uncovering detectable frequencies of autoreactive CTL-p.

Limiting dilution analysis of the allo-MHC anti-paternal cytotoxic T cell response. I: Normal primigravid and multiparous pregnancies

Anti-paternal cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursor frequencies (CTLpF) were determined by limiting dilution analysis (LDA) in the peripheral blood of eight primigravid and seven multiparous women during the three trimesters of pregnancy. In five of these women the responses to cord blood lymphocytes (CBL) and paternal lymphocytes were also determined at the time of delivery and at 6 weeks post delivery. As controls, CTLpF against unrelated third party donors were determined. A wide range of CTLpF against all three groups of targets was found in both the primigravid and multiparous women, reflecting the wide range of frequencies found in random populations. These frequencies remained fairly constant during and 6 weeks after the pregnancy. Splitwell analysis demonstrated that the responses generated in our culture system were specific to the stimulator. The LDA data conform to single-hit kinetics, indicating that only cytotoxic T cells were limiting in the assay. Proliferative responses of maternal lymphocytes to paternal, cord blood and third party MHC antigens also remained unchanged as determined by time-course mixed lymphocyte reactions (MLR). Our data suggest that there is no significant allo-stimulation or suppression of the maternal immune system during normal pregnancy. The mother remains immunocompetent and is capable of both cytotoxic and proliferative responses to paternally-derived fetal MHC antigens. Our findings confirm that in normal pregnancy the trophoblast, which is devoid of classical MHC antigens, forms an effective immune barrier which prevents interaction of the maternal and fetal immune systems.

Cell-mediated immune responses in renal transplant recipients treated with cyclosporin and prednisolone with or without azathioprine

The cell-mediated immune response was studied, using mixed lymphocyte reactivity (MLR) and cell-mediated lympholysis (CML) tests, in patients with well-functioning kidney grafts from living donors at 6 and 12 months and at 2-5 years after transplantation. The patients were allocated to treatment with cyclosporin A (CyA) and prednisolone (group A) or with CyA, prednisolone and azathioprine (group B). The MLR towards a third party were in the range of that of untreated controls while the anti-donor activities were reduced after 6 months in both groups. The CML activities in group A towards a third party were in the range of that of untreated controls at all times, while the anti-donor activities were decreased. By contrast, the CML activities in group B towards a third party were decreased during the first year and were in the range of that of normal controls at 2-5 years. The anti-donor CML activities were low at all times in group B. In summary, the two CyA protocols allowed the induction of donor-specific unresponsiveness within the first post-transplant year. The anti-third party activities were low during the first post-transplant year in recipients with triple therapy but not in those without azathioprine.

Serum neopterin after lung transplantation

OBJECTIVE

Neopterin (N), a marker for activated cell-mediated immunity, was assayed in the sera of 44 lung recipients early and late after transplantation. The study was a prospective, blind clinical trial designed to evaluate the following: (1) the daily dynamics of the serum neopterin/creatinine (N/C) ratio during the first 3 weeks after transplantation; (2) the correlation between changes in the serum N/C ratio and episodes of rejection or infection; (3) the correlation between the serum N/C ratio and the concentration of serum soluble interleukin 2 receptor (sIL-2R), a marker of T-cell activation; and (4) the potential value of monitoring the serum N/C ratio during noninvasive long-term follow-up of lung recipients.

METHODS

Sera from lung recipients were collected every day or every 2 days for the first 3 weeks after transplantation (22 patients) and before fiberoptic bronchoscopy and routine consultation (44 patients). The N concentrations were determined by radioimmunoassay and sIL-2R levels were measured using a sandwich enzyme immunoassay.

RESULTS

Serum N/C is an early and sensitive marker of immune activation in the 21 days following transplantation. The N/C ratios during early rejections (815 +/- 182 mumol/mol) and infections (677 +/- 75 mumol/mol) were higher than those in patients with no complications (160 +/- 32 mumol/mol). In contrast, the N/C ratio did not increase during rejection later after transplantation. More than 3 weeks after transplantation, an increase in the N/C ratio was specifically correlated with infections, mainly those due to cytomegalovirus (CMV) (control subjects, 132 +/- 12 mumol/mol; rejections, 163 +/- 25 mumol/mol; CMV pneumonia, 786 +/- 103 mumol/mol, p < 0.001). The N/C ratio correlated with sIL-2R serum levels (r = 0.625, p < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

Our results indicate that more than 3 weeks after transplantation, the serum N/C ratio increases only in cases of infection, mostly CMV pneumonia. In contrast, both rejection and infectious complications are associated with an increased N production in the early postoperative period.

Determination of cytotoxic T-lymphocyte precursor frequencies using europium labeling as a nonradioactive alternative to labeling with chromium-51

We report on the use of europium (Eu) as a suitable nonradioactive alternative for target cell labeling in limiting dilution analysis (LDA) assays set up to determine cytotoxic T-lymphocyte precursor (CTLp) frequencies. A nonradioactive alternative to the commonly used chromium-51 (51Cr) release assay seems desirable because working with radioisotopes has some major disadvantages concerning possible health risks, environmental load, costs of facilities necessary for working with radioisotopes, and shelf life. Some groups have successfully applied the Eu release assay based on detection by time-resolved fluorometry, to tests in which NK- or LAK-cell activity or cytotoxic T-lymphocyte reactions were measured. This led to the investigation whether this method could also be applicable to the more specific determination of CTLp frequencies in LDA assays. After optimal labeling conditions had been established, the sensitivity of the Eu release assay was determined by performing several LDA assays in which the target cells were labeled with either Eu or radioactive 51Cr. When CTLp frequencies were compared, it was shown that the Eu release assay is at least as sensitive and specific as the 51Cr release assay. Moreover, although the labeling procedure takes longer, sample processing is much faster: only 1 second per sample. The fact that the Eu release assay is not radioactive enables the assay to be performed at any laboratory and even--because the frequency of CTLps may have implications for organ graft survival and for donor selection in bone marrow transplantation--to do so on a routine basis.

Transplantation tolerance in heart transplant recipients as demonstrated by unresponsiveness in cell-mediated lympholysis

Transplantation tolerance or adaptation to an allograft is associated with unresponsiveness to donor-specific transplantation antigens measured in in vitro cell-mediated lympholysis (CML). We here demonstrate in a longitudinal follow-up that CML nonreactivity develops in seven of ten patients following heart transplantation. The first manifestation of this nonreactivity manifested between 3 and 27 months after transplantation. CML nonreactivity correlated with time after transplantation and the percentage of activated lymphocytes in peripheral blood. CML nonreactivity was also associated with good graft function, i.e., in condition of nonresponsiveness patients did not manifest acute rejection. The only exception was seen in one patient in whom the immunosuppressive therapy was strongly reduced. A more detailed evaluation of this patient indicated that the underlying mechanism for CML nonreactivity is clonal anergy or active suppression of the alloreactive cells.

Pretransplantation blood transfusion revisited

BACKGROUND

Blood transfusion before organ transplantation has a beneficial effect on allograft survival; the mechanism of this effect has remained a mystery. In murine models, the presence of common histocompatibility antigens in the blood donor and the recipient favors the induction of allograft tolerance.

METHODS

To investigate the effect of HLA compatibility between blood donor and recipient on the induction of allograft tolerance, we determined the relative frequency of cytotoxic T-lymphocyte precursors specific for donor cells before and at several times after blood transfusion in 23 patients awaiting a first renal transplant. We correlated the results with the presence of shared HLA antigens.

RESULTS

T-cell nonresponsiveness against donor cells developed after blood transfusion in 10 of the 23 patients. Tolerance developed only if the blood donor and the recipient had one HLA haplotype or at least one HLA-B and one HLA-DR antigen in common (as was observed in 9 of these 10 patients). Tolerance developed relatively late after blood transfusion (one to two months) and was long-lasting. No decline in the T-cell response against donor alloantigens was observed in any of the 13 patients who received transfusions without having HLA-antigen compatibility with the donor.

CONCLUSIONS

Blood transfusion in which there is a common HLA haplotype or shared HLA-B and HLA-DR antigens induces tolerance to donor antigens. This finding may lead to the development of new strategies with which to induce tolerance for transplantation after blood transfusion. Perhaps transplant donors will be selected not only by HLA-antigen matching, but also on the basis of acceptable HLA-antigen mismatches associated with T-cell non-responsiveness induced by selected blood transfusion.

Perspectives in transplantation immunology 1991

The clinical success of organ transplantation depends to a large degree on the immunological acceptance of the grafted organ. This paper summarizes from an immunological point of view the recent progress that has been made to improve graft acceptance, and discusses some future aspects in the field. Over the last few years, major emphasis has been put on the development of new immunosuppressive drugs, including FK 506, rapamycin, and Deoxyspergualin. Together with monoclonal antibodies against defined T-cell surface antigens, there are now new and effective means available to prevent or treat rejection episodes. Progress has also been made in the field of HLA typing, where the introduction of molecular biology-based methods significantly increased the accuracy of HLA class II typing. The ultimate goal of transplantation immunology is the induction of (donor-) specific tolerance. While some protocols are effective in inducing peripheral tolerance in experimental animals, these regimens are at present not yet applicable in the clinical situation. To overcome the shortage of donor organs, alternative strategies are currently being considered. Among these, xenotransplantation may eventually prove successful, despite the massive immunological problems such as, e.g., the presence of preformed xenoreactive antibodies.

Comparison of the humoral and cytotoxic T-lymphocyte response to individual HLA class I alloantigens in highly immunized patients

In order to investigate the correlation between activation of cytotoxic T-lymphocyte precursor (CTLp) and the formation of antibodies to alloantigens, we studied 21 highly sensitized patients waiting for a kidney transplantation. Both antibody reactivity and CTLp frequencies of these patients were determined against 88 individual HLA class I alloantigens. A high or low CTLp frequency against a certain HLA-A or -B alloantigen was not correlated with the presence or absence of the antibodies to that antigen. Mismatched antigens, towards which the patient had not formed antibodies, can induce either a higher or a lower frequency of CTLp compared to mismatches towards which the patients had formed antibodies. The possible implications of this lack of correlation between the T- and B-cell allorepertoires with regard to donor selection for (highly immunized) patients is discussed.

Alloreactive lymphoid infiltrates in human heart transplants. Loss of class II-directed cytotoxicity more than 3 months after transplantation

From 535 endomyocardial biopsies (87 heart transplant recipients) 283 cell cultures could be generated. All cultures tested contained T lymphocytes and in most cases CD4 was the predominant phenotype at any time posttransplant. A significantly higher proportion of CD8-dominated cultures was found among cultures from biopsies without myocytolysis. In the first 3 months post transplant 57% of cultures showed cytotoxicity against both class I and class II mismatched donor major histocompatibility complex (MHC) antigens, changing to an incidence of 33% at greater than 90 days. This proved to be due to a significant decrease in the number of cultures with human leukocyte antigen class II-directed cytotoxicity. This study shows that early after transplantation a heart transplant is infiltrated with activated donor-specific cytotoxic T cells which recognize a broad spectrum of mismatched donor MHC antigens, and that in time this spectrum becomes more restricted.

Limiting dilution analysis of human T cells: a useful clinical tool

Limiting dilution analysis (LDA) provides a practical and simple method for determining the frequency of defined clones of lymphocytes responding to a specific antigen or with a particular effector function. The importance of the technique stems from the fact that it is the only way to assess the immune response in humans, at the level of the cell, in a quantitative manner. In this article Claire Sharrock, Edward Kaminski and Stephen Man review the current status of the technique and its applications in human immunology.

The influence of allogeneic cells on the human T and B cell repertoire

Clinical transplantation is often complicated by rejection episodes, in which the immune system of the recipient reacts to the foreign transplantation (HLA) antigens on the graft. This immune response includes humoral and cellular components. In the first, B lymphocytes form antibodies to the HLA alloantigens. In the second, CD8+ T lymphocytes recognize and react to HLA class I antigens, and CD4+ T cells react to HLA class II antigens. The frequency and severity of these rejection episodes can be diminished by immunosuppressive drugs, HLA matching between donor and recipient, and immune modulation by blood transfusion. Effective HLA matching between donor and recipient is not always possible and often not necessary. Insight into the factors that influence the T and B cell repertoire after blood transfusion might lead to new approaches to improve graft survival.