The relevance of proficiency testing for laboratories involved in cadaveric organ transplantation and its consequences for graft survival

Organ exchange organizations such as Eurotransplant allocate organs on the basis of histocompatibility testing results. For this reason it is essential that all data reported by the affiliated laboratories are accurate and reliable. The Eurotransplant Reference Laboratory (ETRL) organizes proficiency testing schemes for the tissue-typing centers of the respective renal transplantation units participating in Eurotransplant. Each year, the ETRL sends out 8 peripheral blood samples of healthy blood donors for serological typing and crossmatching, 16 sera to screen for the presence and definition of HLA alloantibodies and 20 DNA samples for molecular typing to the 49 participating centers. The results are collected centrally and reported back to the participants in an open way. These exercises show that the quality of HLA typing, screening and crossmatching improved significantly over the years. In particular, the introduction of molecular typing for HLA-DR resulted in an increase of reliability. The clinical relevance of a reliable HLA typing was demonstrated in a selected group of transplants, the zero HLA-A,-B,-DR- mismatched group. After retyping the donors, 146 of the 3,458 matched transplants appeared to have a mismatch and those transplants had a significantly lower graft survival rate. A continuing problem, however, is the result of screening for panel reactive antibodies (PRA), where the percentage PRA reported for each serum varies significantly from center to center. The results indicate that the use of a PRA value for classification of patients and allocation of organs should be revisited.

Permissible and immunogenic HLA-A mismatches: cytotoxic T-cell precursor frequencies reflect graft survival data

Analysis of the in vivo immunogenicity of single HLA mismatches, in the context of a patient's own human leukocyte antigen (HLA) phenotype, has been used to define permissible and immunogenic HLA mismatches. Kidney graft survival in the case of permissible mismatches was similar to that of completely HLA matched combinations, whereas immunogenic mismatches lead to a significantly poorer graft survival. The present study tested whether such permissible and immunogenic HLA mismatches are reflected in the in vitro cytotoxic T-lymphocyte (CTL) allorepertoire. Limiting dilution experiments were performed to analyze the number of precursor CTL directed against individual HLA class I antigens. In general, the frequency of CTLp directed against permissible HLA-A antigens (n = 70, mean frequency 27 CTLp per million peripheral blood lymphocytes [PBL]) was found to be significantly lower compared with the CTLp directed against immunogenic HLA-A antigens (n = 73, mean frequency 59 CTLp per million PBL). The difference was found both in healthy individuals and a population of renal transplant candidates. These results were confirmed by a retrospective analysis of CTLp frequencies performed between partly mismatched unrelated bone marrow donors and their potential recipients. In conclusion, on the population level the permissible and immunogenic HLA-A mismatches are indeed reflected in the CTL allorepertoire. However, due to the big overlap of the CTLp frequencies in these populations, the permissible or immunogenic nature of a mismatch for a particular patient should be determined on an individual basis.

Determination of the frequency of HLA antibody secreting B-lymphocytes in alloantigen sensitized individuals

Sera from prospective transplant patients are usually screened for HLA antibodies prior to transplantation, but presently available tests do not permit quantification of the humoral alloantigen directed response. We adapted a culture system for isolated human B-lymphocytes to assay the secretion of HLA-antibodies on a single cell basis. B-cell supernatants were screened for HLA antibodies by complement dependent cytotoxicity. The assay assigns precursor frequencies for HLA-alloantibody secreting B-lymphocytes (BCPFs), and simultaneously allows for dissection of the humoral alloantigen directed response into its monoclonal components. The lymphocytes of 15 HLA-seropositive multiparous women that were used to validate the assay, were found to contain HLA-BCPFs ranging from 0 to 123 per 10(6) B-lymphocytes (mean: 43 +/- 45 per 10(6) B-lymphocytes). The HLA-specificities of antibodies in the B-cell supernatants were in agreement with serum specificities. Genuine HLA reactivity of B-cell supernatants was confirmed using an ELISA with purified HLA class I antigens. When applied to lymphocytes of patients on transplant waiting lists, the present assay may enable the unraveling of serum specificities in their components, thus supplementing HLA antibody serum screening data.

Acceptable HLA mismatches for highly immunized patients

Highly sensitized patients have developed antibodies against many different HLA antigens due to previous pregnancies, blood transfusions or failed transplants. These antibodies cause a positive crossmatch with almost all potential organ donors. As a positive crossmatch is a contra-indication for transplantation, highly sensitized patients have a low chance of transplantation unless special strategies are introduced. One such strategy is the acceptable mismatch program, which has led to transplantation of more than 300 of these highly sensitized patients within Eurotransplant. Centers are participating in the program on a voluntary basis. Before a patient can be included in this program, extensive antibody screening is necessary to define those HLA-A and -B antigens towards which the patient has never formed antibodies. Organ donor selection is based on complete compatibility with the patients own HLA antigens in combination with the acceptable mismatches. If such a combination is identified, mandatory exchange takes place. Despite the success of the acceptable mismatch program, about 25% of the patients will never receive a donor offer. These are patients with rare HLA antigens or rare combinations of HLA antigens. In the last few years, this group of patients has had the advantage of two additional programs running within Eurotransplant. In the HIT (highly immunized tray) program, sera of highly sensitized patients are sent to the different centers and crossmatched with all ABO compatible donors. In the case of a negative crossmatch, mandatory exchange takes place. Secondly, these patients can benefit from the extra points they receive for their waiting time, high antibody reactivity and rare HLA type in the standard Eurotransplant allocation system. We conclude that the application of these three strategies will lead to a significantly increased transplantation rate of highly sensitized patients.

Protective and susceptible HLA polymorphisms in IgA nephropathy patients with end-stage renal failure

Idiopathic immunoglobulin A (IgA) nephropathy is characterised by an extreme variability in clinical course, leading to end-stage renal failure in 15-20% of adults. This subgroup of patients with IgA nephropathy is usually included in the waiting lists of organ exchange organisations. The frequency of HLA-A,B,DR antigens of this subset of IgA nephropathy patients was calculated and compared to controls. The antigens HLA-B35 and DR5 were significantly increased in the patients with relative risk values of 1.385 and 1.487, respectively. The antigens HLA-B7, B8, DR2, and DR3 were found in a significantly lower frequency in the patients as compared to the controls. The relative risk (RR) values ranged between 0.695 and 0.727. Consequently, the haplotypes HLA-A1, B8, DR3, HLA-A3, B7, DR2, HLA-A2, B7, DR2 together with HLA-A1, B15, DR4, HLA-A9, B12, DR7, and HLA-A10, B18, DR2 were found to be protective with RR values ranging from 0.309 to 0.587. The only susceptible haplotype observed was HLA-A2-B5, DR5 (RR=2.990).

HLA-C expression on platelets: studies with an HLA-Cw1-specific human monoclonal antibody

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

The expression of HLA-C on the surface of platelets is rarely studied due to the lack of proper alloantisera. We addressed this question using an IgM human monoclonal antibody directed against HLA-Cw1 (VP6G3).

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Both flow cytometry and complement dependent cytotoxicity studies were used in the current analysis.

RESULTS

The expression of the HLA-Cw1 antigen on platelets is lower than on peripheral blood lymphocytes as shown by flow cytometry. Variation in expression levels between individuals is also observed. Using this antibody in a complement-dependent cytotoxicity assay, we did not observe lysis using platelets as targets, whereas peripheral blood lymphocytes of the same blood donors were adequately lysed.

CONCLUSIONS

These results confirm that platelets indeed express HLA-C. Furthermore, the results support the insignificant role of HLA-C in immunological platelet refractoriness.

In vitro CTL precursor frequencies do not reflect a beneficial effect of cross-reactive group (CREG) matching

Adjustment of histocompatibility-based allocation criteria in kidney transplantation from HLA matching to matching on the basis of cross-reactive groups (CREG), was recently suggested to be a good alternative to transplant with more "well-matched" kidneys, without negatively influencing graft survival. Because graft rejection is often mediated by cytotoxic T cells (CTLs), we investigated whether a beneficial effect of CREG matching is reflected in vitro by lower CTL precursor frequencies (CTLpf). Therefore, CTLpf were determined in a group of healthy individuals and analyzed with respect to the number of HLA and CREG mismatches. A clear correlation was found between the number of HLA mismatches and the CTLpf, that is, the lowest mean frequency in case of 0 HLA-A, B mismatches (66 CTL precursors per 10(6) cells) and the highest in combinations with 4 HLA mismatches (mean = 303 CTLp/10(6) cells). The situation was different in the case of CREG mismatches. Although the highest frequency was found in the group of 4 CREG mismatches, no significant differences were observed between 0, 1, and 2 CREG mismatches. High CTLpf, up to 430/10(6), were even seen in the case of 0 CREG mismatches. Also within a well-defined group of single HLA-A or HLA-B mismatches no difference in CTLpf were observed between the subgroups with 0 vs. 1 CREG mismatches. The present study showed that in vitro the CTLpf correlates better with HLA than with CREG matching. These data are consistent with findings reported by several groups that matching for the CREG does not benefit transplant outcome.

Cross-reactive group matching does not lead to a better allocation and survival of donor kidneys

BACKGROUND

In cadaveric renal transplantation HLA-A, -B, -DR matching of donor and recipient is beneficial for graft survival. However, allocation based on HLA matching seems to favor recipients with more frequently occurring HLA antigens. In this study we investigated whether matching on the basis of cross-reactive groups (CREGs), defined according to the United Network for Organ Sharing (UNOS), would be a good alternative for the allocation of kidneys without negatively influencing graft survival. Theoretically, this approach would provide more recipients with an immunologically well-matched donor organ.

METHODS

The influence of CREG matching on graft survival was studied in univariate analyses using the Eurotransplant database.

RESULTS

No beneficial effect of CREG matching was observed, whereas a significant HLA matching effect was observed in the 0 CREG mismatched donor/ recipient combinations. Only in the small subgroup with 1 MM for HLA-A, -B and 0 MM for HLA-DR, a significantly better survival was observed, when this mismatch belonged to the 0 or 1 MM CREG group versus two or more MM CREG group. However, this subgroup concerns only 8% of the transplants performed.

CONCLUSIONS

In contrast to other reports, our study showed that HLA matching is by far more beneficial than CREG matching. In the homogenous Eurotransplant population, adjusting the matching criteria toward CREG matching would not lead to an improved graft survival.

Identification of two new alleles HLA-DRB1*0312, DRB1*0432 and of a DRB3-negative DRB1*1313-positive haplotype

Two new HLA-DRB1 alleles were identified in the course of routine class II molecular typing in Dutch Caucasoid. HLA-DRB1*0312 is similar to *03011 except for codon 57 (GAT-->AGC). DRB1*0432 is similar to *0413 but with a mutation at position 215, changing codon 72 (CGG-->CAG; Arg-->Gln). This sequence has never before been identified at this position. A DRB3-negative DRB1*1313 haplotype was identified in an individual from Indonesia. Monoclonal antibodies against DR52 were nonreactive with lymphocytes of this individual. The DRB1*1313-DRB3-negative haplotype probably represents a recombination of DRB1*13 and *08 haplotypes where the sequences telomeric of HV1 are derived from the DRB3-negative DRB1*0803 haplotype.

Eurotransplant randomized multicenter kidney graft preservation study comparing HTK with UW and Euro-Collins

The aim was to evaluate the effect of HTK compared to UW and Euro-Collins (EC) on the initial graft function and long term graft survival in two prospective randomized studies. Only kidneys from heart-beating, kidney-only or kidney + heart donors were eligible for entry. Initial non-function (INF) was defined as the absence of life-sustaining renal function, requiring dialysis treatment on two or more occasions, during the first week after transplantation. To evaluate the contribution of the preservation solutions on INF in relation to other factors, a multivariate, 2-step logistic regression model was used. Randomization was performed between July 1990 and September 1992. The UW-HTK study comprised 342 donors and 611 transplants (UW: 168 donors and 297 transplants, HTK: 174 donors and 314 transplants). In the EC-HTK study 317 donors and 569 transplants were included (EC: 155 donors and 277 transplants, HTK: 162 donors and 292 transplants). INF occurred in 33% of either HTK-(n = 105) or UW-(n = 99) preserved kidneys (P = NS), and in 29% of the HTK-(n = 85) and in 43% of the EC-(n = 119) preserved kidneys (P = 0.001). Multivariate analysis showed no significant influence of the preservation solution on the incidence of INF in the UW-HTK study, but factors contributing to INF were donor age, cause of death, retransplantation, and cold ischemic period. The EC-HTK study showed a significantly higher risk of INF, using EC as preservation, in addition to cold ischemic period and donor quality. The 3-year graft survival of HTK-preserved kidneys was 73%, compared to 68% for UW-preserved kidneys in the UW-HTK study (P = NS); while the 3-year graft survival of HTK preserved kidneys was 70% compared to 67% for EC-preserved kidneys in the EC-HTK study (P = NS). We can conclude that HTK is comparable to UW in its preservative abilities, using kidneys from heart-beating kidney-only donors, whereas EC as renal preservation solution should be avoided.

Donor-derived soluble HLA plasma levels can not be used to monitor graft rejection in heart transplant recipients

OBJECTIVE

Increased levels of both donor- and recipient-derived HLA class I molecules (sHLA-I) can be found in serum or plasma of transplanted patients during rejection. Earlier data indicate that levels of donor-derived sHLA-I (dsHLA-I) correlate better with graft rejection than total sHLA Class I (Zavazava N, Kraatz E, Gassel AM, Muller-Ruchholtz W. Plasma MHC class I expression in cardiac graft patients: donor-specific soluble antigen in a pre-sensitized graft patient. Transplant Proc 1991;23:2258-2260; Claas FHJ, Jankowska-Gan E, DeVito LD, et al. Monitoring of heart transplant rejection using a donor-specific soluble HLA class I ELISA. Hum Immunol 1993;37:121). Therefore, quantifying donor-derived soluble counterparts of HLA Class I (sHLA-I) in the plasma of the recipient may offer a new possibility for non-invasive monitoring of rejection after organ transplantation.

METHODS

In an extended study with 34 heart transplant recipients, we used sHLA-I specific ELISAs to monitor donor-derived soluble sHLA-A2, -A3, -A9, -B7, -B12 and B51.

RESULTS

The assays were sensitive enough to detect dsHLA Class I in plasma of the recipients. However, the levels of sHLA were not found to be a useful tool for monitoring rejection. Rejection was often associated with low levels of donor sHLA. The recent finding that antibodies can inhibit the detection of sHLA molecules might explain this discrepancy. In order to test this hypothesis, patient sera were screened for the presence of anti-HLA antibodies and the results were related to the donor-derived sHLA levels. Only in four out of 34 patients HLA Class I specific antibodies could explain the low sHLA levels during rejection.

CONCLUSIONS

In heart transplantation increased donor-derived sHLA levels are not a suitable marker for rejection and that antibody formation can not explain these results. Therefore, monitoring rejection episodes on the basis of donor-derived soluble HLA molecules is not a realistic approach to decrease the number of biopsies after heart transplantation.

Correlation between oral sex and a low incidence of preeclampsia: a role for soluble HLA in seminal fluid?

The involvement of immune mechanisms in the aetiology of preeclampsia is often suggested. Normal pregnancy is thought to be associated with a state of tolerance to the foreign antigens of the fetus, whereas in preeclamptic women this immunological tolerance might be hampered. The present study shows that oral sex and swallowing sperm is correlated with a diminished occurrence of preeclampsia which fits in the existing idea that a paternal factor is involved in the occurrence of preeclampsia. Because pregnancy has many similarities with transplantation, we hypothesize that induction of allogeneic tolerance to the paternal HLA molecules of the fetus may be crucial. Recent data suggest that exposure, and especially oral exposure to soluble HLA (sHLA) or HLA derived peptides can lead to transplantation tolerance. Similarly, sHLA antigens, that are present in the seminal plasma, might cause tolerance in the mother to paternal antigens. In order to test whether this indeed may be the case, we investigated whether sHLA antigens are present in seminal plasma. Using a specific ELISA we detected sHLA class I molecules in seminal plasma. The level varied between individuals and was related to the level in plasma. Further studies showed that these sHLA class I molecules included classical HLA class I alleles, such as sHLA-A2, -B7, -B51, -B35 and sHLA-A9. Preliminary data show lower levels of sHLA in seminal plasma in the preeclampsia group, although not significantly different from the control group. An extension of the present study is necessary to verify this hypothesis.

Determination of acceptable HLA mismatches in highly sensitized patients by soluble HLA class I ELISA inhibition

BACKGROUND

Acceptable HLA mismatches for highly sensitized patients are determined so as to increase their chances of receiving transplants. The disadvantage of the current procedures is that the antibody reactivity of the patients' sera is tested against HLA antigens expressed on cells or HLA antigens isolated from cell lysates. Therefore, two (homozygous for HLA-A and -B) to four (heterozygous for HLA-A and -B) different HLA class I antigens are present in the test. This might cause reactivity toward nonacceptable mismatches to mask the determination of acceptable mismatches.

METHODS

Recently we observed that the detection of soluble HLA class I antigens is inhibited by HLA-specific antibodies. In the present study, inhibition of soluble HLA-specific ELISAs (anti-soluble HLA-A2, -B7, -B12) was evaluated as a tool used to determine acceptable mismatches. The results were compared with current determination of acceptable mismatches (which is by complement-dependent cytotoxicity and/or fluorescence-activated cell sorter analysis).

RESULTS

In the case of acceptable mismatches determined by conventional methods, sera from the patients were not interfering in these ELISAs, whereas in the case of nonacceptable mismatches (thus specific antibodies), significant inhibition was observed in most instances. Among the nonacceptable mismatches, the test showed significant inhibition in 20 of 24 cases, whereas among acceptable mismatches, no inhibition was observed (in eight of eight), indicating the lack of specific antibodies.

CONCLUSIONS

In highly sensitized patients, the introduction of soluble HLA-specific ELISAs is of additional and confirmatory value for the determination of acceptable mismatches. The major advantage of this approach is that antibody reactivity is tested against single antigens only.

In vitro reactivity of allospecific cytotoxic T lymphocytes does not explain the taboo phenomenon

Matching for human leucocyte antigens (HLA) is important for graft survival in kidney transplantation. Nevertheless, most patients receive a kidney graft with multiple HLA mismatches. Some of these mismatches seem to be more harmful than others. By studying the effect of single HLA mismatches in the context of the patients' own HLA, we have previously identified donor/recipient combinations with a significantly higher incidence of early graft failure, the so-called taboo combinations. In the present study we investigated whether a higher cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) response towards taboo mismatches may be involved in this phenomenon. CTL reactivity was determined both in taboo and control combinations by in vitro CTL precursor assays, using peripheral blood mononuclear cells and proximal tubular epithelial cells as target cells. Inhibition studies with CD8-antibody as well as Cyclosporin A were performed to identify high avidity and primed CTLs. Furthermore, in committed CTLp assays indirect recognition of the taboo mismatch was tested using synthetic peptides. The CTL precursor frequencies in taboo combinations were always lower than the CTL precursor frequencies in control combinations. No difference in avidity and activation status of the CTLs could be detected when taboo combinations were compared with the controls. In the committed CTLp assays no reactivity towards any of the synthetic peptides was observed. The significantly poorer graft survival of taboo combinations cannot be explained by a higher number of donor-specific CTLs. Furthermore, the avidity or activation status of these CTLs does not provide a clue to the taboo phenomenon.

Sharing cross-reactive groups of MHC class I improves long-term graft survival

BACKGROUND

Renal transplant loss from chronic rejection remains substantial. To increase our understanding of this syndrome, we identified risk factors predicting late graft loss, with a special emphasis on the impact of human lymphocyte antigen (HLA) matching.

METHODS

We studied all 654 cadaveric kidney transplants performed in our center between 1983 and 1996 that had survived for more than six months. Eighty-two transplants, lost because of chronic rejection, were used as the outcome variable. The influence of HLA mismatches and shares on long-term graft survival was evaluated at the level of private antigens and cross-reactive groups (CREG) of multiple histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I. HLA and other recipient, donors and transplant parameters were studied using univariate and multivariate Cox regression analysis.

RESULTS

The cohort had a mean number of 1.9 HLA mismatches. Because of the homozygosity of HLA antigens, HLA mismatches were not reciprocal to shares. CREG and HLA-A-B mismatches had a relative risk for graft loss of 1.19 (95% CI, 0.97 to 1.45) and 1.05 (0.84 to 1.32) per mismatch. In contrast, the relative risk per shared CREG and broad HLA-A-B antigen was 0.76 (0.63 to 0.92) and 0.79 (0.61 to 1.03). Multivariate analysis revealed that individuals sharing less than four CREGs had a relative risk of 2.13 (1.29 to 3.75) for late graft loss. Other independent predictors were a recipient age of less than 50 years, relative risk 1.95 (1.02 to 3.71); a donor age of more than 50 years, relative risk 1.68 (1.01 to 2.80); acute rejection (vascular vs. no rejection), relative risk 3.52 (1.72 to 7.18); proteinuria (dipstick > 1+ vs. negative), relative risk 2.86 (1.29 to 6.35); and a serum creatinine concentration of more than 150 micromol/liter at six months, relative risk 3.41 (1.96 to 5.94).

CONCLUSION

We identified several coexisting recipient-, donor-, and transplant-related risk factors for graft loss from chronic rejection. In this well-matched group of renal transplants, HLA mismatches and shares had a nonreciprocal relationship. Sharing of HLA antigens, especially CREG of MHC class I, was associated with improved long-term survival.

The impact of special programs for kidney transplantation of highly sensitized patients in Eurotransplant

Highly immunized patients will continue to accumulate on the waiting list of many registries unless special allocation programs are introduced. In Eurotransplant such patients can benefit from 2 programs, the Acceptable Mismatch (AM) and the Highly Immunized Tray (HIT) programs. Kidney exchange is mandatory in these programs. In addition, highly immunized patients who do not participate in these programs profit from additional points in the allocation procedure (ET-HI). In the past 18 months the 3 programs have run in parallel. Here, we show that the AM and HIT programs are highly effective with respect to increasing the patient's chance of finding a crossmatch negative donor in an adequate time course. Furthermore, the transplantation results of AM and HIT are at least comparable to those of the ET-HI. The main gain at present seems to be the significantly shorter waiting time in the AM and HIT programs.

Anti-HLA antibodies interfere in the detection of soluble HLA class I molecules

Heart transplant rejection is routinely defined by histological evaluation of endomyocardial biopsies (EMB). As elevated levels of donor derived sHLA (dsHLA) can be detected in the serum of transplanted patients just before or during rejection, quantification of donor specific soluble counterparts of HLA Class I (sHLA-I) in the serum of the recipient may be a new way for non-invasive monitoring of graft rejection. However, not all patients show an increase of dsHLA at time of rejection. A reason for this might be that anti-donor-HLA antibodies, which are formed by the patient, form complexes with donor sHLA-I molecules. This masking or blocking of sHLA-I binding sites might cause false-negative results of tests detecting donor specific sHLA. Using HLA-antigen specific ELISA tests we could demonstrate that most anti-HLA antibodies block the detection of sHLA antigens in plasma, even in high dilutions of the antibody when the antibodies were not detectable in a CDC test. In general, HLA-antigen specific antibodies block the detection of sHLA molecules, while broadly-reactive antibodies, recognizing another epitope on the molecule, do not. The implication of these findings is that more than one dsHLA allotype within one patient should be tested to monitor graft rejection. In addition, sHLA monitoring must be combined with an HLA-antibody screening.

Characterization of the ABO blood group genes in macaques: evidence for convergent evolution

The ABO blood group system is known to act as a major transplantation barrier in primates. Different primate species share the presence of A and B antigens. The polymorphism of the macaque ABO blood group genes was analyzed by cloning and sequencing the exon 7 region. In the case of the rhesus macaque (Macaca mulatta) and cynomolgus monkey (Macaca fascicularis) we were able to identify ABO blood group gene segments which cluster into two lineages, namely: *A/*O1 and *B. In addition allelic variation was observed. The 2 amino acid replacements at positions 266 and 268, which are thought to be crucial for A or B transferase activity, could be confirmed for both macaque species. Comparison of primate sequences shows that A and B reactivity was generated independently from each other in the hominoids and Old World monkey lineages. Hence, the primate A and B blood group genes are subject to convergent evolution.

The application of human monoclonal antibodies for monitoring donor derived soluble HLA class I molecules in the serum of heart transplant recipients

Increased levels of both donor and recipient derived HLA molecules can be found in serum and plasma of transplanted patients during rejection. Recent data suggest that levels of donor specific soluble HLA Class I (sHLA-1) correlate better with graft rejection than total sHLA Class I [1, 2]. Therefore, quantification of donor specific soluble counterparts of HLA Class I in the serum of the recipient may be a new way for non-invasive monitoring of rejection after organ transplantation. Up to now, only a limited number of mouse monoclonal antibodies (alpha HLA-A2, and alpha HLA-B7) has been used in enzyme linked immunosorbent assays (ELISAs) to detect donor specific HLA molecules in the plasma of transplant recipients. To monitor other donor-recipient combinations, we tested some of our HLA Class I specific human monoclonal antibodies, routinely used in complement dependent cytotoxicity, for their suitability in ELISA based assays. In the present model system, we used alpha HLA-A9 (BvK5C4) or alpha HLA-A3 (OK2F3) hybridoma-supernatant to set up a sHLA-A9 and sHLA-A3 specific ELISA. In a pilot study we show that these assays were sensitive enough to detect an increase of donor specific sHLA-I during rejection in the plasma of two heart transplant recipients. Use of a large set of human hybridoma's will enable monitoring most recipient/donor combinations in the near future.

Elevated serum HLA class I levels coincide with acute and chronic graft-versus-host disease

The ability to predict the likely occurrence of graft-versus-host-disease (GVHD) after BMT would be extremely valuable. We performed a retrospective study on the correlation between soluble HLA class I (sHLA-I) levels and GVHD in the sera of 34 patients receiving an allogeneic BMT and in the sera of 12 patients receiving an autologous BMT. sHLA-I levels measured pre- and at different times post-BMT were correlated with the occurrence of post-BMT complications, ie acute graft-versus-host disease (aGVHD), chronic graft-versus-host disease (cGVHD), infections and relapse. No changes in sHLA-I levels (delta sHLA-I) occurred in autologous and allogeneic BMT patients without GVHD. In contrast, sHLA-I reached high levels in patients suffering from GVHD. Increased sHLA-I levels correlated strongly with episodes of both acute and chronic GVHD (P = 0.004 and P = 0.005, respectively). Also during relapse increased sHLA-I levels were found (P = 0.032). During infections sHLA-I levels increased, although not significantly. Kinetic studies gave no evidence that the increase in sHLA-I levels preceded the clinical occurrence of aGVHD or of cGVHD. A slight, but significant correlation was found between total blood bilirubin levels and sHLA-I levels in patients suffering from GVHD (P = 0.037), indicating the contribution of the liver as a source of sHLA-I. We conclude that measurements of sHLA-I levels do not function as a predictive parameter for GVHD, but can be valuable for the monitoring of GVHD after BMT.

Association between specific HLA combinations and probability of kidney allograft loss: the taboo concept

BACKGROUND

HLA matching improves the outcome of cadaveric renal transplantation. However, many allografts function well even in the presence of one or more HLA mismatches, which raises the question of whether some mismatches are better recognised by the recipient's immune system than others. We aimed to identify mismatched HLA donor-recipient combinations that were associated with increased graft loss.

METHODS

We selected 2877 first, unrelated renal transplants with a single HLA A, B, or DR mismatch, undertaken between 1982 and 1992, from the Eurotransplant database. To enhance statistical power the analysis was restricted to mismatches of an HLA antigen that occurred in 100 or more donors. 1342 transplants met this criterion and were grouped into a definition set (n = 873) and a validation set (n = 469). In the definition set, we studied further only those recipient HLA antigens that occurred in at least 30 cases within each donor antigen mismatch subset. By a Cox proportional hazards model, donor-recipient combinations that led to significantly higher graft loss than in the whole group were defined. Such combinations were classified as taboo; the remaining combinations were classified as indifferent.

FINDINGS

106 individual recipient antigens were found at least 30 times with a corresponding donor mismatch in the definition set; 11 of the 106 had a significant effect on graft survival. Seven combinations were classified as taboo. Taboo combinations, confirmed as such in the validation set, were associated with graft survival of 81% at one year and 50% at 5 years, significantly lower than the rates in the group with indifferent combinations (89% and 69%; p = 0.04) or among 1190 recipients with no mismatches (89% and 72%; p = 0.03). The findings were substantiated by a multivariate analysis that included the effect of patient immunisation, cold ischaemia time, age, and sex.

INTERPRETATION

Mismatched donor antigens are differentially recognised depending on the HLA phenotype of the recipient. The findings may have important clinical consequences for graft survival after transplantation.

Six newly identified HLA-DRB alleles: DRB1*1121, *1419, *1420, *1421, DRB3*0203 and DRB5*0103

Seven samples with irregular PCR-SSO hybridization patterns, observed during routine HLA-DRB typing, were studied in more detail. Group-specific amplification, followed by hybridization with relevant SSOs strengthened the suggestion that these samples contained new DRB alleles. DRB exon 2 segments were amplified, cloned and sequenced and revealed: DRB1*1121 [MUL] is similar to DRB1*1102 in which codon 85 changed from GTT(V) into GTC(A); DRB1*1419 [AKKAL] is similar to DRB1*1402 with codon 71 changed from AGG(R) into AAG(K); DRB1*1420 [OND-52971] is a DRB1*1406 with codon 37 changed from AAC(N) into TTC(F); DRB1*1421 [TGI] is similar to DRB1*1417 with codon 71 changed from AGG(R) into AAG(K); DRB3*0203 [POS] is similar to DRB3*0202 in which codons 37-38 are changed from TAC GCG(YA) into TCC GTC(SV); DRB5*0103 was found in two unrelated individuals of Oriental origin [IND-24 and IND-59] and is similar to DRB5*0102 in which codon 71 AGG(R) changed into ACG(T). This particular sequence variation at position 71 has not yet been described. The new DRB sequences were confirmed using the sequencing based typing technique. Low resolution PCR-SSP typing failed to amplify two of the DRB1*14 variants, whereas high resolution PCR-SSP resulted in aberrant patterns. Class II alloantisera identify the codon 71 changes in DRB1*1419 and *1421 with respect to the MC1 ('DR1+DR4') epitope.

Irregular polymerase chain reaction-sequence-specific oligonucleotide hybridization patterns reveal seven new HLA-DRB1 alleles related to DR2, DR3, DR6, DR8, and DR11. Implications for sequence-specific priming

In the past 3 years we have typed over 7000 individuals for HLA-DRB using a nonradioactive PCR-SSO method. The use of locally developed computer programs simplified data input and the interpretation of the DRB PCR-SSO readings. In this way we detected a number of samples with unexpected hybridization patterns. DRB1 exon 2 segments of these samples were amplified, cloned, and sequenced and appeared to identify seven new DRB alleles: DRB1*0304, a DRB1*0301 variant, was observed in three unrelated Caucasoid individuals; DRB1*1606, which is very similar to *1603; DRB1*1113 is a *1101 variant with some *1401 sequences; DRB1*1310 is *1301-like; DRB1*1311 is similar to *1305 and *1307; DRB1*1416 is a *1401 sequence with a HV3 derived from *1301; DRB1*0808 was found in an Ethiopian individual. Next, we studied the effectiveness of PCR-SSP typing of the newly defined DRB1 alleles. Only two variants were distinguished as odd by PCR-SSP and two were typed as regular specificities. Three alleles were not amplified by the primer sets used. As compared to PCR-SSO, the PCR-SSP typing method using currently available typing kits clearly has limitations as far as the recognition of new and variant alleles is concerned. The products of some of these new alleles may be distinguished using conventional serology.

Biotinylated DRB sequence-specific oligonucleotides. Comparison to serologic HLA-DR typing of organ donors in eurotransplant

A novel HLA-DR typing method was applied using PCR-amplified fragments and biotin-labeled oligonucleotides (PCR-biotin-SSO). The PCR-biotin-SSO method can be used efficiently to perform HLA-DR typing for a large number of individuals when time is not the limiting factor. The reliability of HLA typing of cadaveric organ donors is of vital importance for organ exchange organizations such as ET. Due to lack of time, these typings are usually performed by the complement-dependent cytotoxicity. The individual donor center typings are immediately reported to ET, where the recipient selection procedure is started. DNA isolated from donor spleen material, sent to the ETRL for retyping purposes, was subjected to PCR-biotin-SSO typing. The results were compared with the serological HLA-DR typings as reported to ET. The analysis of 1052 donor samples for the broad DR1-DR10 antigens revealed a concordance rate of over 90% between the donor center and the ETRL. The majority of the discrepancies involved specificities of the HLA-DR5, DR6, and DR8 cross-reacting group, with DR6 as the predominant discordant specificity. The results indicate (a) that PCR-biotin-SSO is a reliable technique for DNA-based HLA-DR typing and (b) that HLA-DR serology is still a useful technique when time is limited, such as for cadaveric donor typing.