Evidence that long-term survival of concordant xenografts is achieved by inhibition of antispecies antibody production

The free radical scavenger S-PBN significantly prolongs DSG-mediated graft survival in experimental xenotransplantation

BACKGROUND

Nitrones such as 2-sulfo-phenyl-N-tert-butyl nitrone (S-PBN) are known to trap and stabilize free radicals and to reduce inflammation. Recently, S-PBN was shown to reduce infiltration of T lymphocytes and the expression of adhesion molecules on the endothelium in experimental traumatic brain injury. We hypothesized that S-PBN could reduce infiltration of T lymphocytes during cell-mediated xenograft rejection and thereby increase graft survival. The concordant mouse-to-rat heart transplantation model was used to test the hypothesis. In this model, grafts undergo acute humoral xenograft rejection (AHXR) almost invariably on day 3 and succumb to cell-mediated rejection on approximately day 8 if AHXR is inhibited by treatment with 15-deoxyspergualin (DSG).

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Hearts from Naval Medical Research Institute (NMRI) mice were transplanted to the neck vessels of Lewis rats. Recipients were treated with S-PBN (n=9), DSG (n=9), S-PBN and DSG in combination (n=10) or left untreated (n=9) for survival studies. S-PBN was given daily intraperitoneally at a dose of 150 mg/kg body weight (BW) on day -1 to 30, and DSG was given daily intraperitoneally at a dose of 10 mg/kg BW on day -1 to 4 and 5 mg/kg BW on day 5 to 21. Nine additional recipients were given S-PBN only on days -1 and 0 in combination with continuous DSG treatment. Grafts were monitored until they stopped beating. Additional recipients were treated with S-PBN (n=5), DSG (n=5), S-PBN and DSG in combination (n=6) or left untreated (n=5) for morphological, immunohistochemical and flow cytometry analyses on days 2 and 6 after transplantation.

RESULTS

S-PBN treatment in combination with DSG resulted in increased median graft survival compared to DSG treatment alone (14 vs. 7 days; P=0.019). Lower number of T lymphocytes on day 6 (P=0.019) was observed by ex vivo propagation and flow cytometry when combining S-PBN with DSG, whereas immunohistochemical analyses demonstrated a significant reduction in the number of infiltrated CD4+, but not TCR+, cells. S-PBN treatment alone had no impact on graft survival compared to untreated rats (3 vs. 3 days). No differences were seen in ICAM-1 and VCAM-1 expression or in morphology between the groups.

CONCLUSION

The combination of S-PBN and DSG treatment increases xenograft survival. The main effect of S-PBN appears to be in direct connection with the transplantation. Because of its low toxicity, S-PBN could become useful in combination with other immunosuppressants to reduce cell-mediated xenograft rejection.

Intrasplenic preconditioning: a model for the study of xenostimuli accommodation

BACKGROUND

Discordant xenotransplantation, the grafting of organs from one phylogenic species to another, results in hyper-acute rejection (HAR). HAR is associated with the deposition of recipient preformed xenoreactive natural antibodies and complement on the endothelium of the donor organ, leading to activation and apoptosis of the endothelium, an event associated with xenograft rejection. Endothelial resistance to HAR, termed "accommodation," an active protection of graft endothelium, may be achieved by previous stimulation of endothelial cells by discordant xenoantibodies.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Forty-eight male Wistar rats were used to evaluate HAR induction in an isolated, dually perfused in-situ rat liver transfused with human blood. This ex-vivo model served to mimic rat-to-human liver xenotransplantation. Preconditioning of the liver endothelium was induced by rat intrasplenic injection of human blood (n=8) or effluent of previously xenotransfused rat liver (n=8), i.e., high versus low xenoantibody solution, each undertaken 1d before liver xenotransfusion. Two other groups were not preconditioned. Preconditioned and non-preconditioned rats were perfused directly with human blood, and eight rats were used as controls (non-preconditioned Krebs-perfused). Eight rats were perfused directly with human blood, and eight rats were used as controls. The effluent that exited these first-line livers was used to perfuse the second-line livers.

RESULTS

Portal and hepatic artery perfusion pressures, resistances, rates of oxygen extraction, lactic acid and pH, and wet-to-dry weight ratio values were significantly increased in livers xenotransfused with blood indicating HAR, compared with unchanged values in livers perfused with Krebs solution. Portal pressure and resistance were best protected from HAR by the blood preconditioning in the blood perfused group, while the hepatic artery perfusion system was better protected by the perfusate precondition-blood perfused group. The physiologic effects of HAR were attenuated in most second-line livers.

CONCLUSIONS

Attenuation of HAR in rats' livers is achieved by preconditioning with xenoantibodies and/or by "filtering out" xenoantibodies present in the circulation, and is suggestive of accommodation. This novel method may be useful in future studies aimed at refining methods for accommodating xenotransplantation.

Accommodation and antibodies

Accommodation refers to the condition in which an organ transplant functions normally by acquiring resistance to immune-mediated injury (especially), despite the presence of anti-transplant antibodies in the recipient. This status is associated with several modifications in the recipient as well as in the graft, such as previous depletion of anti-graft antibodies and their slow return once the graft is placed; expression of several protective genes in the graft; a Th2 immune response in the recipient; and inhibition of the membrane attack complex of complement.

Antibody responses to xenogenic antigens?a study in the mouse-to-rat system

Antibodies play a crucial role in the rejection of an organ that has been transplanted between different animal species, i.e. xenotransplantation. In previous work, we have induced a state of humoral tolerance where mouse-to-rat heart grafts continued to beat under ciclosporine A monotherapy. Initially, a combined treatment with ciclosporine A and 15-deoxyspergualin was given. This state of tolerance could not be reproduced when the vascularised heart graft was replaced with a free tissue graft or xenogeneic blood transfusions. To gain further insight into the humoral response against mouse antigens, we studied the antibody production in naive rats and rats challenged with heart transplants, heart cells, mononuclear cells (MNC) and erythrocytes from mice. Rats not challenged with any mouse cells or organs had a moderate amount of antibodies targeted against mouse MNC as well as rosette-forming cells in the spleen targeted against mouse erythrocytes. A challenge with either mouse MNC or erythrocytes lead to immunisation with antibodies of both IgM and IgG subtype directed against both MNC and erythrocytes. Antibody titres against mouse erythrocytes in animals challenged with MNC were not detectable until day 7, whereas antibody titres against mouse MNC in animals challenged with erythrocytes were detected on day 1. Immunisation with mouse erythrocytes raised the titre of rosette-forming cells in the spleen compared with naive rats (P < 0.05). Our data indicate that different xenogeneic antigens in the mouse-to-rat system are shared between heart cells, MNC and erythrocytes; however, the immunisation patterns differ regarding the time when antibodies are first detected.

Monocyte adhesion to xenogeneic endothelium during laminar flow is dependent on alpha-Gal-mediated monocyte activation

Monocytes are the predominant inflammatory cell recruited to xenografts and participate in delayed xenograft rejection. In contrast to allogeneic leukocytes that require up-regulation of endothelial adhesion molecules to adhere and emigrate into effector tissues, we demonstrate that human monocytes adhere rapidly to unstimulated xenogeneic endothelial cells. The major xenoantigen galactosealpha(1,3)galactosebeta(1,4)GlcNAc-R (alpha-gal) is abundantly expressed on xenogeneic endothelium. We have identified a putative receptor for alpha-gal on human monocytes that is a member of the C-type family of lectin receptors. Monocyte arrest under physiological flow conditions is regulated by alpha-gal, because cleavage or blockade results in a dramatic reduction in monocyte adhesion. Recruitment of human monocytes to unactivated xenogeneic endothelial cells requires both alpha(4) and beta(2) integrins on the monocyte; binding of alpha-gal to monocytes results in rapid activation of beta(2), but not alpha(4), integrins. Thus, activation of monocyte beta(2) integrins by alpha-gal expressed on xenogeneic endothelium provides a mechanism that may explain the dramatic accumulation of monocytes in vivo.

Early onset of rejection in concordant hamster xeno hearts display signs of necrosis, but not apoptosis, correlating to the phosphocreatine concentration

BACKGROUND

The importance of apoptosis contra necrosis for ischemia/reperfusion (RP) and acute rejection in concordant rodent xenotransplantation is largely unknown. We explored this question by comparing rodent allo and concordant xenotransplants with different morphological methods to detect apoptosis and biochemical data on the levels of high-energy phosphates obtained with in vitro 31Phosphorous Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy (31P MRS). More specifically, we applied a hitherto unused method in transplantation research, apoptosis specific biotin labeled oligonucleotides designed with a 10 base pair stem region and a 20 nucleotides large loop that form a hairpin like shape. The results obtained with this method were compared to results obtained with the more widely used in situ 3'-end labeling of DNA (TUNEL) assay and extraction and gel electrophoresis of labeled DNA (DNA laddering).

METHODS

Cervical heart transplantations were performed between inbred Lewis (L) (RT1l) to L, L to DA (RT1a) rats, hamster (H) to H and H to L (X) (n=5 for all groups except for X, n=9). All hearts were subjected to 30 min of cold ischemia (+4 degrees C) and 6 h of RP before explantation. In vitro 31P MRS was used to determine the phosphocreatine (PCr), beta-adenosine triphosphate (beta-ATP) concentrations and the PCr/beta-ATP ratio of the transplants. We correlated the biochemical data to haematoxylin and eosin (H & E) stained tissue slides scored for rejection, infiltration of antibodies and complement depositions, DNA extraction and gel electrophoresis of labeled DNA (DNA laddering), in situ 3'-end labeling of DNA (TUNEL) and the apoptosis specific hairpin probe assays scoring.

RESULTS

The rejection score of the xeno grafts differed significantly compared to their syngeneic hamster to hamster controls (2.40 +/- 0.25 vs. 1.20 +/- 0.20; P=0.005) and they had a significantly higher TUNEL score, 228 +/- 15 vs. 2.44 +/- 0.32 (P=0.009), that correlated to changes in PCr concentration (P<0.001) and to the PCr/beta-ATP ratio (P=0.01). The uptake was mainly (90-95%) located to 1-2 microm large extra cellular 'granule'. A picture resembling early necrosis was seen on the H & E stainings and reflected in the Billingham rejection score above.

CONCLUSIONS

After 6 h of RP the onset of acute rejection in the concordant hamster xeno hearts displayed features of early, possibly mitochondrial, necrosis, but not apoptosis, which correlated to changes in the PCr concentration and the PCr/beta-ATP ratio. The mechanism for the early rejection observed is unclear and might be caused by other factors in the sera apart from cellular components, antibodies and complement factors. Identification of the underlying mechanisms could enable us to design rational therapies that prevent activation of the recipient's innate immune response.

Histological and immunological characteristics of, and the effect of immunosuppressive treatment on, xenograft vasculopathy

Like allografts, vascularized xenografts are susceptible to a process of chronic rejection. We have used the hamster-to-rat aortic transplant model to study characteristics of this phenomenon and to determine whether it could be controlled or prevented by immunosuppressive therapy. Golden Syrian hamster aortas were transplanted into untreated Lewis rats, athymic rats, and Lewis rats receiving cyclosporin (10 mg/kg), leflunomide (5, 10 or 15 mg/kg), or 10 mg/kg of both drugs. Grafts were harvested on days 2, 7, 14, 28 and 56. Grafts and recipient spleens were analysed using computerized morphometry, immunohistochemistry and immunofluorescence. Blood was taken on various days for the measurement of anti-hamster antibodies (flow cytometry) and of the leflunomide metabolite A77 127. In untreated rats, by day 56, transplanted aortas developed a cell-free media with a mature neointimal lesion consisting of actin-positive cells, CD4 T cells, and macrophages. There were large increases in anti-hamster immunoglobulin M (IgM) and IgG, collections of proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA)-positive cells in splenic germinal centres, and IgM, C3 and C5a deposition in aortas. In athymic recipients, the media architecture was preserved, and the changes in the neointima and in anti-hamster IgM and IgG were markedly abrogated, but not prevented. In Lewis rats receiving leflunomide, absence of circulating or deposited IgM did not prevent neointimal formation by day 14. Combination treatment was the most effective at preventing neointimal formation and humoral changes. Leflunomide monotherapy was the least effective. There were no changes in peak concentrations of the main metabolite of leflunomide over 8 weeks. The hamster-to-rat aortic transplant model is suitable for the study of xenograft vasculopathy, the histological and serological changes of which are predominantly T-cell dependent. Combination treatment with 10 mg/kg of cyclosporin and 10 mg/kg of leflunomide was most effective in preventing xenograft vasculopathy.

The long-term survival of baboon-to-monkey kidney and liver xenografts

The present study was undertaken to develop an optimum immunosuppressive regimen in baboon-to-monkey life-supporting kidney xenografts. Baseline therapy for all groups include cyclosporine (CsA) and steroids. We compared adding (1) cyclophosphamide (CyP) at dose of 20 mg/kg/day given on post-operative day (POD) 0, 2, 5 and 7; (2) mycophenolic mofetil (MMF) at a dose of 40 mg/kg/day by daily gavage; or (3) CyP + rapamycin (Rap). The latter group was divided into high and low dose subgroups. Untreated xenografts were rejected on POD 6, CsA alone treated xenografts survived for 35 days and CsA + CyP treated xenografts survived for 45 days. Adding MMF significantly prolonged mean survival to 111 +/- 53 days, but the xenografts eventually developed rejection. Combination therapy including CsA, CyP and Rap reliably prevented xenogenic rejection and achieved a mean survival of 290 +/- 30 days. However, high dose CyP + Rap led to high incidence of post-transplant lymphoproliferation disorders (PTLD), while the incidence of PTLD was significantly less in the low dose subgroup (P < 0.01). Four animals in this subgroup survived for more than 300 days with normal renal function and histology. In addition, two liver recipients treated with CsA + CyP survived for 91 and 1,076 days. We conclude that long-term survival of kidney or liver xenografts can be achieved in a non-human concordant xenograft model using currently available immunosuppressive agents.

Maintenance triple immunosuppression with cyclosporin A, mycophenolate sodium and steroids allows prolonged survival of primate recipients of hDAF porcine renal xenografts

To date, the best results in life-supporting pig-to-primate renal xenotransplantation have been obtained in recipients exposed to long-term immunosuppression with cyclophosphamide. As this agent is frequently associated with side-effects, we have explored the potential of a mycophenolate sodium-based maintenance immunosuppression in this model. Human decay-accelerating factor (hDAF) transgenic kidneys were transplanted into splenectomized and bilaterally nephrectomized cynomolgus monkeys immunosuppressed with mycophenolate sodium, cyclosporin A and steroids, and exposed to a brief induction course with cyclophosphamide (up to four doses). After transplantation, the primates were monitored daily for biochemical and haematological evaluations and for the measurements of haemolytic anti-pig antibodies (APA). A detailed histological analysis of each explanted graft was also performed. All the animals showed very poor initial graft function but survived for up to 51 days. In contrast to our previous studies in xenograft recipients on long-term immunosuppression with cyclophosphamide, minimal or no circulating xeno-directed antibodies, as measured by the evaluation of APA titres, were detected in this series although some degree of acute humoral rejection was observed in all the explanted grafts and was the primary cause of graft failure. Furthermore, in addition to areas of humorally mediated graft damage, we have observed for the first time areas with exclusive and prominent infiltration by CD2+ and CD8+ mononuclear cells presenting patterns compatible with tubulitis, glomerulitis and arteritis, which we have called acute cellular xenograft rejection (ACXR). In addition, CD68+ infiltrating macrophages and CD20+ B-cells were also present. This study demonstrates that a triple maintenance immunosuppression with mycophenolate sodium, cyclosporin A and steroids is a viable alternative to a cyclophosphamide-based immunosuppression to obtain prolonged survival of porcine organs transplanted into primates. However, a more stringent control of antibody forming cells remains essential to further extend the survival of xenografts in this model. In addition, the use of the immunosuppressive regimen reported here in the primate is associated with the occurrence of a new category of cell-mediated xenograft injury (ACXR) whose significance has yet to be clarified.

Acute xenograft rejection, late xenograft rejection and long term survival xenografts in the hamster-to-rat heart transplantation model: histological characterisation under low-dose of FK506

BACKGROUND

Long-term survival studies have been conducted in hamster-to-rat cardiac models with a range of immunosuppressive treatments, but the histological pattern of Late Xenograft Rejection (LXR) has not been outlined. This study offers a detailed description of the histological changes in cardiac xenografts under three different immunological responses.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Heterotopic hamster-to-Lewis rat cardiac transplant. Recipients were administered an antiproliferative drug (MMF, 25 mg/kg, or CyP, 10 mg/kg, from day -7 to +7 or from day 0 to +7, according to group) and FK506 (0.2 mg/kg; from day 0 to +30 or continuously). Unmodified recipients were used as controls. Conventional histology and indirect immunofluorescence of IgM, IgG and C3 deposits were performed.

RESULTS

In our study, xenografted rats that did not receive treatment developed a pattern of Acute Xenograft Rejection (AXR), with substantial tissue breakdown. Pretreated and treated animals until day 30 post-transplant developed LXR that may present two different histological patterns: one with vascular damage and predominant interstitial haemorrhage, and the other with extensive myocardial fibrosis. Long-term surviving rats (LTS) showed a morphology that was almost normal, with mild fibrosis and vascular endothelium preserved.

CONCLUSIONS

AXR, LXR and LTS in the hamster-to-rat heart transplantation model present a common humoral mechanism although their histopathological patterns are different depending on the length of immunosuppressive treatment but not on the type of antiproliferative drug administered. Pretreatment exerts an effect on fibrosis formation.

Hamster cardiac xenografts are protected against antibody mediated damage, early after transplantation to Lewis rats

Antibodies play a crucial role in the rejection of xenografts. We tested the hypothesis that xenografts are protected against antibody-mediated attack early after transplantation in a concordant model. We investigated the role of xenoreactive antibodies as a stimulus for protection and the effects of a total blockade of the antibody response by the leflunomide analog malononitrilamide 279. Hamster cardiac xenografts were transplanted to Lewis rat recipients. Second transplants and retransplants of xenografts were performed to untreated rats that had a xenograft in place for 3 d. Untreated rats rejected hamster cardiac xenografts after 4.0 +/- 0.0 d. Significant levels of anti-donor IgM, as measured by flowcytometry, were present on day 3 after transplantation (11.2% +/- 2.8 vs. 1.2% +/- 0.0 on day 0, P < 0.001). 'Fresh' second xenografts transplanted to rats that had a first xenograft in place for 3 d and had anti-hamster antibodies, underwent hyperacute rejection. The first xenografts remained functioning. Xenografts that were removed on day 3 from untreated rats and then retransplanted remained functioning. Xenografts that were removed on d 3 from rats that had been treated with malononitrilamide 279, 15 mg/kg/d and were retransplanted underwent hyperacute rejection. IgM levels at the time of removal were 1.1% +/- 0.5 in these rats and not different from baseline (P = 0.96). We conclude that xenografts are protected against antibody-mediated damage early after transplantation. The presence of anti-donor antibodies might be an essential stimulus for the induction of protection. There seems to be a delicate balance between the injurious and protective effects of antibodies. Treatment strategies that are designed to block antibody formation completely might prevent the induction of protection.

Pre-transplant blood transfusion induces tolerance to hamster cardiac xenografts in athymic nude rats

The effects of pre-transplant blood transfusion vary from induction of antibodies and accelerated graft rejection, to prolonged survival and even tolerance. The beneficial 'transfusion effect' in allotransplantation is believed to be merely T-cell mediated. In xenotransplantation, T-cell independent mechanisms form a major hurdle. In this study we investigated the effects of pre-transplant hamster blood transfusion on the survival of hamster cardiac xenografts in T-cell deficient athymic nude rats. Nude rats rejected xenografts after 3.8 +/- 0.5 d (n = 8), and immunocompetent Lewis rats after 4.0 +/- 0.5 d (n = 8), following a similar IgM response (P = NS). Hamster blood transfusion 3 d before transplantation in nude rats led to an IgM response and long-term xenograft survival in 17/20. Timing was of importance: blood transfusion 7 d before transplantation resulted in 45% long-term xenograft survival (n = 20). Injection of purified hamster erythrocytes, leukocytes or minced heart also led to survival of xenografts for > 100 d in nude rats, but not in all cases. Second xenografts transplanted to long-term survivors did not provoke an IigM response, and were accepted for > 100 d (n = 4). Transfer of serum from long-term survivors to untreated nude rats resulted in survival of xenografts for > 100 d (n = 4). In Lewis rats pre-transplant blood transfusion induced hyperacute rejection of xenografts after 158 +/- 128 min (n = 8, P < 0.01). We conclude that pre-transplant hamster blood transfusion can induce long-term survival of hamster cardiac xenografts in T-cell deficient athymic nude rats. This blood transfusion effect is mediated by humoral factors and can be transferred by serum. Elucidation of underlying mechanisms might provide some insight into xenotransplantation nonresponsiveness of T-cell independent immunefactors.

Maturation of xenoantibody gene expression during the humoral immune response of rats to hamster xenografts

Immunoglobulin isotype switching represents an important component of antibody maturation in the development of humoral immune responses. We have recently conducted a series of studies in a nonimmunosuppressed rodent model to define the kinetics of xenoantibody production and seek evidence for the maturation of xenoantibody Ig gene expression by xenograft recipients. LEW rats were transplanted with hamster cardiac xenografts and the grafts were allowed to remain in situ for prolonged immune stimulation of the host. Anti-hamster antibodies were examined at days 4, 8, 21, 28 and 40 post-transplantation. cDNA libraries specific for rat mu or gamma heavy chains were constructed from B lymphocytes of the xenograft recipients at day 4 and day 21 post-transplantation. Selected cDNA clones encoding the Ig V(H)HAR family of genes from each group were sequenced and analyzed for the presence of somatic mutations. We found that the reactivity of xenoantibodies examined with flow cytometry underwent sequential changes in which IgM titers peaked at day 8 post-transplantation (PTx) and returned to low levels after 21 days. IgG titers started to increase at about one week PTx and peaked at 21-28 days. All the IgG isotypes (IgG1, 2a, 2b and 2c) were differentially involved in the IgG responses. Serum passive transfer experiments demonstrated that IgM antibody fractions separated from sera at day 4 post-transplantation were capable of causing hyperacute rejection (HAR) of hamster xenografts, whereas IgM fractions from days 21-40 failed to cause HAR (N = 7, MST = 4 days), a pattern that was consistent with a rise in total xenoreactive IgM levels at days 4-8 and a fall to low levels at 21 days post-transplantation. IgG-containing fractions separated from day 21-40 antisera caused HAR (N = 7, MST = 36 min) whereas IgG fractions from day 8 sera failed to induce graft rejection. Genetic analysis of the rearranged VH genes from 10 cDNA clones demonstrated that the Ig mu (n = 5) and gamma (n = 5) chain clones used the same family of VH genes (V(H)HAR family) to encode their antibody binding activity. The majority (80%) of the IgM clones were present in their original germline configuration. In contrast, the nucleotide sequences from IgG clones manifested an increase in the numbers of replacement mutations in the CDR region of the Ig heavy chain genes, providing evidence for a potential role for somatic mutation in the maturation of IgG xenoantibody responses as the humoral response matures with time post-transplantation.

Role of CD4+ T cells in the rat to mouse cardiac xenotransplantation

T cell subsets involved in rejection of xenografts were analyzed using a rat to mouse cardiac xenotransplant model. Proliferating response and interleulin-2 (IL-2) production in recipients' spleen cells were almost completely abrogated by elimination of L3T4+ T cells, but not by elimination of Lyt2.1+ T cells. Cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) activities were mediated by both L3T4+ and Lyt2.1+ T cells with the help of IL-2-producing L3T4+ T cells. Administration of anti-L3T4 monoclonal antibody (mAb) into recipient mice resulted in a significant prolongation of graft survival (mean graft survival was 29.2 days). Moreover, anti-L3T4 mAb treatment plus thymectomy led to indefinite graft survival. Anti-rat endothelial cell (EC) antibody production in the grafted mice was remarkably suppressed by anti-L3T4 mAb treatment. In contrast, Lyt2.1 mAb treatment did not prolong the graft survival and did not suppress anti-EC antibody production. These results indicated the absolute requirement of L3T4+ T cells in the rejection of rat to mouse cardiac xenografts.

Xenogeneic transplantation

This review summarizes the clinical history and rationale for xenotransplantation; recent progress in understanding the physiologic, immunologic, and infectious obstacles to the procedure's success; and some of the strategies being pursued to overcome these obstacles. The problems of xenotransplantation are complex, and a combination of approaches is required. The earliest and most striking immunologic obstacle, that of hyperacute rejection, appears to be the closest to being solved. This phenomenon depends on the binding of natural antibody to the vascular endothelium, fixation of complement by that antibody, and finally, activation of the endothelium and initiation of coagulation. Therefore, these three pathways have been targeted as sites for intervention in the process. The mechanisms responsible for the next immunologic barrier, that of delayed xenograft/acute vascular rejection, remain to be fully elucidated. They probably also involve multiple pathways, including antibody and/or immune cell binding and endothelial cell activation. The final immunologic barrier, that of the cellular immune response, involves mechanisms that are similar to those involved in allograft rejection. However, the strength of the cellular immune response to xenografts is so great that it is unlikely to be controlled by the types of nonspecific immunosuppression used routinely to prevent allograft rejection. For this reason, it may be essential to induce specific immunologic unresponsiveness to at least some of the most antigenic xenogeneic molecules.

Heart and liver xenotransplantation under low-dose tacrolimus: graft survival after withdrawal of immunosuppression

BACKGROUND

The hamster-to-rat xenotransplantation model is a useful model to investigate the features of extended host response to long-surviving xenografts. Early xenoantibody responses are T-cell independent and resistant to tacrolimus. Treatment with the combination of mofetil mycophenolate plus FK506 avoids acute xenograft rejection completely, but after withdrawal of immunosuppression hamster grafts are rejected by a process called late xenograft rejection (LXR).

METHODS

Hamster hearts and livers were transplanted into Lewis rats. Grafted rats were treated with mofetil mycophenolate (25 mg/kg/day) for 8 days and FK506 (0.2 mg/kg/day) for 31 days. Serum IgM and IgG levels were determined by flow cytometry and interferon-gamma levels by ELISA. IgM, IgG, and C3 deposits were measured in tissue by immunofluorescence, and leukocyte infiltration was measured by immunoperoxidase staining. Results. Survival of heart and liver xenografts in the rats was 48+/-4 days and 63+/-8 days, respectively. After cessation of all immunosuppression, hearts were rejected in 18+/-4 days and livers in 33+/-8 days. Production sequences of xenoantibodies in the two organs differed substantially, especially 7 days after transplantation and at the moment of rejection. Quantification of interferon-gamma levels indicated that there were no significant changes after transplantation. Histological and immunohistochemical studies showed signs of humoral mechanism of LXR in rats undergoing heart transplantation and cellular mechanism of LXR in those that received a liver transplant. Conclusions. These observations suggest that rejection in the hamster-to-rat heart xenotransplantation model is mediated by a T cell-independent B-cell response to which a T cell-dependent B-cell response is added in LXR. In the liver xenotransplantation model, our hypothesis is that LXR is mediated by a mixed cell mechanism, involving lymphocytes CD4+ CD45RC+, macrophages, and cytotoxic T lymphocytes. In summary, we have demonstrated and compared the peculiar features of LXR in two different organs.

Animal models in xenotransplantation

The severe shortage of donor organs has provided a strong impetus to push the investigation into the use of animal organs for humans. Xenotransplantation will not only benefit patients, but also represents a unique and potentially profitable business opportunity. However, there are many barriers to successful clinical xenotransplantation, including immunological barriers, physiological incompatibility, zoonosis and ethical concerns. This overview will focus on currently available animal models used in attempts to break through the immunological barriers to xenotransplantation. There are many advantages to using small animal, namely rodent, models in xenotransplantation research. For example, the use of the mouse model allows the use of knockout mice and careful dissection of rejection mechanisms at the molecular level. The following models can be used to study hyperacute rejection (HAR): guinea-pig-to-rat, mouse-to-rabbit, guinea-pig-to-mouse, rat-to-presensitised mouse and rat-to-alpha-Gal knockout mouse. The hamster-to-rat, mouse-to-rat and rat-to-mouse models are commonly used to study acute vascular rejection. Large animal models are complex and expensive, but they are more relevant to clinical xenotransplantation. Based on experiments using transgenic pig-to-primate models, HAR can be overcome. However, acute vascular rejection remains a major barrier at the present time. A pig cartilage-to-monkey model has been developed to study chronic rejection. Other novel models such as pig venous segment-to-monkey model and rat-to-primate model may represent viable options to study immunological barriers following xenotransplantation. Like many other medical breakthroughs, animal research will continue to make enormous contributions towards the eventual success of xenotransplantation.

Immunosuppressive activity of the Chinese medicinal plant Tripterygium wilfordii. II. Prolongation of hamster-to-rat cardiac xenograft survival by combination therapy with the PG27 extract and cyclosporine

BACKGROUND

PG27 is an immunosuppressive fraction purified from an extract of a Chinese medicinal plant Tripterygium wilfordii, which we investigated alone and in combination with cyclosporine (CsA) in a concordant, hamster-to-rat cardiac xenotransplantation model.

METHODS

Golden Syrian hamster hearts were heterotopically transplanted into the abdomen of Lewis rat recipients, which were treated intraperitoneally or orally with PG27, CsA, or both.

RESULTS

Combination therapy with 30 mg/kg(day of PG27 and CsA at 10 mg/kg/day successfully suppressed acute hamster-to-rat cardiac xenograft rejection. Treatment with PG27 or CsA alone was ineffective. Among several effective combinations, the best regimen involved PG27 at 30 mg/kg/day and CsA at 5 mg/ kg/day from days 8 to 35 and then CsA at 5 mg/kg/day from days 36 to 100, which produced 100% survival beyond 100 days. CsA suppressed the heterospecific lymphocytotoxic antibody response and inhibited IgG but not IgM xenoantibody production (which led to xenograft rejection), whereas PG27 alone did not prevent antibody production. The PG27/CsA combination blocked the lymphocytotoxic antibody response and IgG and IgM xenoantibody production induced by cardiac xenotransplantation.

CONCLUSIONS

PG27 combined with CsA substantially prolonged hamster-to-rat cardiac xenograft survival, as well as completely inhibiting xenoantibody production.

Synergistic effect of anti-T cell receptor monoclonal antibody and 15-deoxyspergualin on cardiac xenograft survival in a mouse-to-rat model

BACKGROUND

Successful xenograft transplantation faces several obstacles including the presence of xenoantibodies, natural killer cell- and macrophage-mediated rejection, and T lymphocyte activation.

METHODS

A mouse-to-rat cardiac xenograft model was used to examine the synergistic effect of anti-T cell receptor (TCR) monoclonal antibodies (mAb) and 15-deoxyspergualin (DSG) on graft survival.

RESULTS

Pretransplantation injections (days -5, -3, and -1) of anti-TCR mAb (500 microg/kg/day) combined with continuous i.p. infusion of DSG (5 mg/kg/day) from day -7 to 28 significantly prolonged graft survival compared to untreated controls (3.3+/-0.5 vs. 44.2+/-5.6 days, P<0.001). Postoperative splenectomy combined with discontinuation of all other treatment on day 28 enhanced graft survival in rats treated with anti-TCR mAb and DSG to 71.0+/-2.5 days. Histological examination of grafts showed characteristic signs of vascular rejection: interstitial edema and hemorrhage, and polymorphonuclear cell infiltration. Antimouse antibody titers in recipients were increased upon rejection in each group that received a xenograft. Flow cytometry analysis showed a markedly decreased T cell population and a relatively increased mature B cell population (IgM(bright)/IgD(dull)) in spleens of rats treated with anti-TCR mAb and DSG on day 28.

CONCLUSIONS

The mechanism of prolonged xenograft survival in this model may include inhibition of antibody production by arrest of B-cell maturation during development from IgM(dull)/IgD(bright) mature B cells to antibody producing cells, and inhibition of T cell activation. The rejection seen in our model may be caused by xenoreactive antibodies and may be associated with T cells, natural killer cells, and macrophages.

Review of significant microvascular surgical breakthroughs involving the heart and lungs in rats

Models of transplantation of the heart and lung in the rat have been important in determining the mechanisms of rejection and their treatment. Reviewed here are several important milestones contributing to the current state of the art of clinical heart and lung transplantation.

Long-term survival of hamster hearts in presensitized rats

We transplanted hamster hearts into rats that had been sensitized to hamster cardiac grafts 5 days earlier as a model for discordant xenotransplantation. Sensitized rats had high serum levels of elicited anti-donor IgM and IgG that caused hyperacute rejection. Transient complement inhibition with cobra venom factor (CVF) plus daily and continuing cyclosporin A (CyA) prevented hyperacute rejection. However, grafts underwent delayed xenograft rejection (DXR). DXR involved IgG and associated Ab-dependent cell-mediated rejection, because depletion of IgG or Ab-dependent cell-mediated rejection-associated effector cells prolonged graft survival and the serum-mediated Ab-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity in vitro. Blood exchange in combination with CVF/CyA treatment dramatically decreased the level of preexisting Abs, but DXR still occurred in association with the return of Abs. Splenectomy and cyclophosphamide acted synergistically to delay Ab return, and when combined with blood exchange/CVF/CyA facilitated long-term survival of grafts. These grafts survived in the presence of anti-donor IgM, IgG, and complement that precipitated rejection of naive hearts, indicating that accommodation (survival in the presence of anti-graft Abs and complement) had occurred. We attribute the long-term survival to the removal of preexisting anti-donor Abs and therapy that attenuated the rate of Ab return. Under such conditions, the surviving hearts showed expression in endothelial cells and smooth muscle cells of protective genes and an intragraft Th2 immune response. Th2 responses and protective genes are associated with resistance to IgM- and IgG-mediated, complement-dependent and -independent forms of rejection.

Natural antibodies and the host immune responses to xenografts

Natural antibodies are present in the serum of individuals in the absence of known antigenic stimulation. These antibodies are primarily IgM, polyreactive, and encoded by immunoglobulin V genes in germline configuration. Natural antibodies are produced by B-1 lymphocytes, cells that form the primary cell of the fetal and newborn B cell repertoire and may represent the basic foundation upon which the adult repertoire of B cell antibodies is based. Natural antibodies react with a variety of endogenous and exogenous antigens, including xenoantigens expressed by tissues between unrelated species. These antibodies are capable of causing the immediate rejection of grafts exchanged across species barriers. One of the central issues related to our understanding of the immunopathologic mechanisms responsible for rejection of xenografts is whether pre-formed natural antibodies and new antibodies induced following xenotransplantation are produced by the same pathways of B cell antibody production. We have established in studies conducted in rodents and humans that the initial phases of antibody production xenogeneic tissues involves the use of a restricted population of Ig germline genes to encode xenoantibody binding. As the humoral xenoantibody response matures, the same closely-related groups of Ig V genes are used to encode antibody binding and there is evidence for an isotype switch to IgG antibody production and the appearance of somatic mutations consistent with antigen-driven affinity maturation. Our findings in both rodent and human studies form the basis for our proposal that the xenograft response reflects the use of B cell natural antibody repertoires originally intended to provide protection against infection. The host humoral response is inadvertently recruited to mount antibody responses against foreign grafts because they display carbohydrate antigens that are shared by common environmental microbes. This model of xenoantibody responses is being tested in our laboratory through the analysis of the binding of xenoantibodies in their original non-mutated configuration, and the examination of the effect of specific point mutations and gene shuffling have on xenoantibody binding activity. Establishment of the relationships between Ig structural changes and subsequent changes in binding affinity should provide important insights into the role that, natural antibodies and the cells that produce them play in the evolution of the host's humoral responses to xenografts.

Prolongation of xenograft survival using monoclonal antibody CD45RB and cyclophosphamide in rat-to-mouse kidney and heart transplant models

BACKGROUND

Intrigued by the finding that a monoclonal antibody (mAb) directed against the B exon of restricted CD45 (CD45RB mAb) induced renal allograft tolerance in the mouse model, we hypothesized that CD45RB mAb may prevent xenograft rejection. We explored the role of CD45RB mAb in preventing xenograft rejection in rat-to-mouse kidney and heart transplant models.

METHODS

Mice with rat kidney and heart xenografts were treated with a short course of mAb, cyclosporine, cyclophosphamide, or mAb + cyclophosphamide combination therapy. Untreated heart and kidney xenografts served as controls.

RESULTS

Untreated controls developed acute vascular and cellular rejection rapidly with a median survival time of only 6 days. Long-term kidney (median survival time = 70 days) and heart xenograft survival (median survival time = 65 days) was achieved using the combination therapy of mAb + cyclophosphamide. One-third of the kidney recipients with combination therapy survived 100 days. Immunohistochemistry and xenospecific-antibody analysis demonstrated that combination therapy remarkably reduced IgG and IgM deposition and also inhibited CD4+, CD8+, and Mac-1+ cell infiltration at early stages. This therapy, however, did not induce tolerance in this model as evoked xenoreactive antibodies and cellular responses may be the cause of late xenograft failure.

CONCLUSION

A short course of CD45RB mAb combined with cyclophosphamide effectively inhibits cellular and humoral immunoresponses and remarkably prolongs xenograft survival in rat-to-mouse heart and kidney transplant models.

Xenotransplantation

BACKGROUND

The success of clinical transplantation has led to a large discrepancy between donor organ availability and demand; considerable pressure exists to develop an alternative source of organs. The use of animal organs for donation is a possible solution that is not yet clinically applicable.

METHODS AND RESULTS

A literature review was performed based on a Medline search to find articles on xenotransplantation. Keywords included hyperacute, acute vascular, xenograft rejection combined with concordant and discordant. Additional references cited in these articles from journals not included in Medline were obtained from the British Library. Limited information on unpublished, preliminary work has been included from sources known to the authors, based on their research work in the field. One hundred and forty-six references and four personal communications have been included in this review article.

CONCLUSION

A greater understanding of the pathogenesis of xenograft rejection is developing rapidly. Strategies to abrogate hyperacute rejection have proved successful, but control of antibody-driven acute vascular rejection has not yet been achieved. The safety and viability of xenotransplantation as a therapeutic modality are still unproven.

Suppression of delayed xenograft rejection by specific depletion of elicited antibodies of the IgM isotype

BACKGROUND

Hamster hearts transplanted into untreated rats undergo delayed xenograft rejection (DXR). This acute inflammatory response is associated with the deposition of anti-graft antibodies of the immunoglobulin (Ig)M isotype in the vasculature. We have previously shown that these antibodies are generated in a T cell-independent manner. In this study, we tested whether the generation of anti-graft IgM antibodies is involved in the pathogenesis of DXR. In addition, we tested whether the suppression of this antibody response would overcome DXR.

METHODS

Hamster hearts were transplanted into rats treated with an anti-mu monoclonal antibodies (mAb) to deplete circulating IgM or with an isotype-matched control mAb recognizing the dinitrophenyl epitope. T cell immunosuppression was achieved with cyclosporin A (CsA).

RESULTS

Depletion of circulating IgM by anti-mu mAb inhibited DXR, whereas the control mAb had no effect on DXR. In anti-mu-treated rats, xenografts were rejected 5-7 days after transplantation through a T cell-dependent mechanism associated with the generation of antibodies of the IgG isotype. Combination of anti-mu with CsA suppressed the anti-graft IgM and IgG response and resulted in long-term xenograft survival (> 50 days). Xenograft long term survival occurred despite the return of anti-graft IgM antibodies to the circulation, a phenomenon referred to as accommodation.

CONCLUSION

This study demonstrates that the pathogenesis of DXR can be initiated by anti-graft antibodies of the IgM isotype, which are generated in a T-cell independent manner. In addition, we show that under T cell immunosuppression, specific depletion of this IgM response by anti-mu mAb administration results in xenograft long-term survival and accommodation.

Anti-major histocompatibility complex class II treatment prevents graft rejection in the hamster-to-rat cardiac xenograft

BACKGROUND

Several groups have achieved graft acceptance in the concordant hamster to rat model by using a combination of anti-proliferative drugs and conventional immunosuppressive therapy. However, such aggressive treatment often leads to the recipient dying with a functional xenograft, as a result of opportunistic infections. This study aimed to investigate the effects of a short course of therapy with an anti-MHC class II monoclonal antibody treatment (chimeric OX6 [cOX6]) in combination with cyclosporin A (CyA) in a concordant hamster-to-rat xenograft model.

METHODS

Rats receiving hamster cardiac xenografts were given CyA or cOX6 alone or in combination and were monitored daily to assess the effect of treatment on graft survival. Additional studies monitored the effect of treatment on the production of cytolytic anti-hamster antibodies by the recipient and the deposition of immunoglobulin (Ig)M and complement factors within the xenograft.

RESULTS

Treatment with CyA only had no effect on graft survival, whereas treatment with cOX6 increased graft survival time by 2 days. The median graft survival time for cOX6+CyA was 76 days. cOX6 treatment of rats having undergone transplants inhibited the rise in cytotoxic anti-hamster antibodies in peripheral blood until day 5, whereas combination therapy completely inhibited anti-hamster antibody formation. Fluorescence-activated cell sorter analysis showed treatment with cOX6 significantly reduced circulating B cell numbers until day 5. Anti-MHC class II treatment also markedly reduced the deposition of both IgM and C3. Anti-MHC class II treatment with CyA gives long term survival in concordant xenografts without severe side effects.

CONCLUSIONS

The mechanism of action of this combination is complex and could be caused by an initial inhibition of B cell function by the anti-MHC class II treatment and the subsequent inhibition of T cell dependent pathways by CyA.

Role of UW solution and sodium nitroprusside in reperfusion of liver xenografts from guinea-pig to rat

Guinea-pig livers are poorly reperfused when transplanted into rats. We have observed that, in contrast to that of the rat, the guinea-pig intrahepatic portal vein (PV) has a thick layer of smooth muscle. It is possible that, after perfusion of the liver with ice-cold saline, this could go into spasm, resulting in poor reperfusion. To test this hypothesis, guinea-pig livers were perfused with different solutions stored at varying temperatures and transplanted into LEW rats. To prevent xenograft hyperacute rejection, all xenograft recipients were treated with 80 U/kg cobra venom factor (CVF) i.v. on days -1 and 0. In addition to the percentage reperfusion, PV resistance and recipient survival were also monitored. In group I, liver xenografts perfused with ice-cold saline (4 degrees C) reperfused poorly (20-30%), resulting in the development of portal hypertension (16.5 cmH2O vs. 12 cmH2O in naive LEW rats) and shortened mean survival time (11.7 +/- 4.2 h). In contrast, group II livers perfused with saline at room temperature (23 degrees C) underwent homogeneous reperfusion (98-100%) with no increase in portal vein resistance, indicating that low temperature was the main trigger for the spasm of the PV. Moreover, recipient survival in this group was significantly prolonged to a mean of 22 + 2.6 h (P < 0.01). Although UW solution (group III) and the vasodilator sodium nitroprusside (NP) (group IV) when used alone improved the degree of hepatic reperfusion, it was still not optimal. The supplementation, however, of UW solution with NP in group V animals resulted in homogeneous reperfusion (98%) with no portal hypertension and consistent prolonged graft survival of 21.0 +/- 1.7 h. Therefore, this study has determined that the riddle of the abnormal reperfusion of guinea-pig liver xenografts by rat blood is nonimmune mediated and is due to the spasm of the strong smooth muscle in the PV tree produced by cold perfusates.

T Cell Repertoire Alterations of Vascularized Xenografts

The role of T cells in the rejection of vascularized xenografts has been little explored. Because of the high potential diversity of xenoantigens, it has been suggested that xenotransplantation could induce a strong cellular response that could contribute to delayed rejection. Alternatively, alterations in molecular interactions could impair the T cell response. Because the analysis of TCR repertoire in vivo indirectly reflects the nature and the magnitude of T cell xenorecognition, we took advantage of the possibility of obtaining long term survival of hamster heart xenografts in rat recipients treated with a combination of cobra venom factor and cyclosporin A (CsA), to analyze T cell infiltration and, for the first time, Vβ TCR usage, at the complementarity-determining region 3 level, in accommodated and rejected xenografts, compared with allografts. After withdrawal of CsA (on day 40), the analysis of Vβ family expression and corresponding complementarity-determining region 3 lengths in rejected xenografts revealed a Gaussian pattern, in contrast to a much more restricted pattern in rejected allografts (p = 0.002), suggesting that, after withdrawal of CsA, all the underrepresented T cell clones are rapidly expanded in xenografts. These results correlate with the rapid kinetics of rejection (4 ± 1 days), the high number of T cells, the rapid expression of markers of activation (IL-2 receptor α-chain and class II receptor), and the strong deposit of IgG Abs in rejected xenografts. Taken together, these results suggest that the intensity and diversity of the T cell response to xenografts could be stronger than the response to allografts in vivo.

A morphological sequential study of mouse-to-rat cardiac xenografts

Long-term survival of a concordant xenograft can be achieved by using cyclosporine (CyA) and deoxyspergualin (DSG) for immunosuppression. We have demonstrated in a mouse-to-rat heterotopic heart transplantation model that DSG treatment can be stopped after 4 weeks with the grafts remaining beating. In this investigation we have sequentially characterized the morphological changes and infiltrating cells in the transplanted hearts. Graft recipients were killed 9 days, 28 days and 56 days after transplantation. At days 9 and 28, the grafts exhibited a well-preserved morphology, with infiltrating cells restricted only to the periphery. These cells stained positive for rat MHC class II antigens, the ED1-macrophage marker and the CD4 antigen, and were thus considered to be macrophages. In comparison, grafts harvested at day 56 had signs of interstitial fibrosis and some arteries showed pronounced intimal thickening. There was a moderate infiltrate of cells both in the peripheral and central parts of the graft, consisting mainly of MHC class II+/ CD4+/ED1+ macrophages. Very few T cells and NK cells were noticed. Termination of DSG after 28 days does not trigger a humoral rejection. However, the grafts exhibit morphological changes equivalent to those seen in chronic allograft rejection. In addition, the characteristics of the infiltrating cells conformed with cellular infiltrates associated with chronic allograft rejection. Hence, this model could in the future prove to be useful for studies of mechanisms involved in chronic xenograft rejection.

Expression of heme oxygenase-1 can determine cardiac xenograft survival

The rejection of concordant xenografts, such as mouse-to-rat cardiac xenografts, is very similar to the delayed rejection of porcine-to-primate discordant xenografts. In concordant models, this type of rejection is prevented by brief complement inhibition by cobra venom factor (CVF) and sustained T-cell immunosuppression by cyclosporin A (CyA). Mouse hearts that survive indefinitely in rats treated with CVF plus CyA express the anti-inflammatory gene heme oxygenase-1 (HO-1) in their endothelial cells and smooth muscle cells. The anti-inflammatory properties of HO-1 are thought to rely on the ability of this enzyme to degrade heme and generate bilirubin, free iron and carbon monoxide. Bilirubin is a potent anti-oxidant, free iron upregulates the transcription of the cytoprotective gene, ferritin, and carbon monoxide is thought to be essential in regulating vascular relaxation in a manner similar to nitric oxide. We show here that the expression of the HO-1 gene is functionally associated with xenograft survival, and that rapid expression of HO-1 in cardiac xenografts can be essential to ensure long-term xenograft survival.

Induction of Species-Specific Host Accommodation in the Hamster-to-Rat Xenotransplantation Model

The combination of two immunosuppressants, leflunomide and cyclosporin A (CsA), completely inhibits immune xenoreactions in the hamster-to-Lewis rat xenotransplantation model. In addition, the control of acute xenograft rejection with this combination of immunosuppressants subdues early T-independent xenoreactivity and uncovers a late immune response that can be controlled by CsA alone. We attribute this acquired responsiveness to CsA to a modification in the recipient’s humoral response to the xenograft, and refer to this change as host accommodation. Host accommodation can be induced in Lewis rats receiving hamster hearts by the combination of leflunomide and CsA. A 7-day treatment with leflunomide and CsA was able to convert xenoreactivity from one that was resistant to CsA treatment into one that was controlled by CsA. The presence of the hamster xenograft was critical for the induction of host accommodation since the immunosuppressive regimen, either alone or in combination with a transfusion with donor-specific spleen cells, was unable to modify the anti-hamster reactivity in Lewis rats. When accommodation was induced in the presence of hamster hearts, these accommodated rats were able to acutely reject third-party mouse hearts while under CsA therapy, thus indicating that the host accommodation is species specific. Finally, we demonstrate that host accommodation is associated with a loss in the ability to produce species-specific, T-independent xenoantibodies. These novel observations suggest that xenoreactive T-independent humoral responses can be deleted selectively without significant loss of other innate, Ag-specific T-independent humoral responses.

Long-term survival of hamster-to-rat cardiac xenografts in the absence of a Th2 shift

BACKGROUND

In hamster-to-rat cardiac xenografts, long-term survival (LTS) is obtained in 60% of recipients if vascular rejection is overcome by cobra venom factor and cyclosporine (CsA). It has been suggested that this accommodation state could be due to the Th2 response.

METHODS

We examined the infiltrate by using immunostaining and the accumulation of cytokine mRNA (interferon-gamma [IFN-gamma], interleukin [IL]-4, IL-10, IL-13, and transforming growth factor-betal [TGF-beta1]) by using competitive reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction, in hamster hearts grafted into LEW.1A rat.

RESULTS

Hearts from untreated and treated (cobra venom factor and CsA) but rejecting recipients presented a rapid and severe vascular rejection. In contrast, hearts from long-surviving treated animals had subnormal cardiac muscle with a mild infiltrate, principally macrophages, which peaked on day 15. T lymphocytes were also maximal on day 15 (12% of the infiltrate). Rejected grafts from untreated recipients showed accumulation of IFN-gamma mRNA but low levels of IL-10, TGF-beta, and IL-13. In hearts rejected by treated recipients, IFN-gamma mRNA did not increase and TGF-beta mRNA was higher. In LTS, IL-10, TGF-beta, and IL-13 transcripts were up-regulated (P<0.001), while IFN-gamma mRNA decreased (P<0.001). In both groups, IL-4 expression remained at a nonsignificant level.

CONCLUSIONS

The profile of cytokine mRNAs in LTS could result in part from CsA, known to up-regulate TGF-beta and to down-regulate IFN-gamma. Moreover, CsA does not inhibit IL-10 production by monocyte/macrophages, the major infiltrating cells (60%). Lastly, LTS is induced in the absence of IL-4, which suggests that the high IL-4 production could simply be correlated with LTS without being a condition for it.

Survival of accommodated cardiac xenografts upon retransplantation into cyclosporine-treated recipients

BACKGROUND

Accommodation designates the survival of vascularized grafts in the presence of circulating antigraft antibodies and complement. In the hamster-to-rat model, accommodation is associated with an ongoing T helper (Th)2 cytokine response and the expression of "protective genes" by the graft endothelial cells and smooth muscle cells. In this report, we tested whether accommodated xenografts would be protected from rejection upon retransplantation into second recipients treated with cyclosporine (CsA), a treatment that does not prolong survival of a fresh hamster heart.

METHODS

Long-term survival of hamster-to-rat cardiac xenografts was achieved using either CsA plus cobra venom factor (CVF) or CsA plus rapamycin. Xenografts that survived long term in their first recipients were retransplanted into second recipients treated with CsA.

RESULTS

Long-term xenograft survival in CsA/CVF-treated recipients was associated with an ongoing Th2 response, expression of protective genes, and deposition of elicited xenoreactive antibodies and complement on the graft endothelium. In CsA/rapamycin-treated recipients, long-term xenograft survival occurred in the presence of basal levels of antigraft antibodies and was not associated with a Th2 cytokine response or the expression of protective genes. Xenografts from CsA/CVF-treated rats survived significantly longer upon retransplantation into second recipients treated with CsA (77.3% >10 days) as compared with xenografts from CsA/rapamycin-treated rats (4-11 days) or naive hearts (3-4 days). Moreover, 30-35% of xenografts from CsA/CVF rats survived long term and accommodated in the second recipient.

CONCLUSIONS

Accommodated xenografts can have significantly prolonged acceptance when retransplanted into second recipients treated with CsA alone; in contrast, naive hearts or hearts that survived long term in first recipients, but did not accommodate, did not survive long term in the second recipients. We suggest that prolonged survival of accommodated xenografts is due to the expression of the protective genes A20, bcl-2 bcl-xL, and heme oxygenase-1 in the xenograft endothelium and possibly smooth muscle cells.

Transient complement inhibition plus T-cell immunosuppression induces long-term survival of mouse-to-rat cardiac xenografts

BACKGROUND

The use of anti-B-cell and T-cell immunosuppressive agents leads to only a few weeks' survival of mouse-to-rat cardiac xenografts.

METHODS

BALB/c cardiac xenografts were transplanted to Lewis rats treated with cyclosporine (CsA) and/or cobra venom factor (CVF).

RESULTS

CsA alone did not prolong xenograft survival (2.2+/-0.4 days), whereas CVF alone led to minimal prolongation of survival (5.6+/-0.8 days) as compared with nontreated recipients (2.4+/-0.5 days). The combination of CsA plus CVF, the latter given for either 2 days or 11 days, resulted in long-term survival of 14/16 hearts (> 100 days). Production of IgM elicited xenoreactive antibodies (EXA) peaked on day 4 after transplantation and decreased thereafter. Production of IgG EXA occurred only in the control group, whereas, in the CsA/CVF-treated group, IgG EXA were totally suppressed. Long-term surviving grafts showed (i) excellent preservation of morphology and minimal leukocyte infiltration, (ii) deposition of IgM, IgG and weak C3 deposition on the graft endothelium, (iii) low level infiltration by rat macrophages, (iv) replacement of mouse dendritic cells by class II+ rat macrophages, and (v) expression within endothelial and smooth muscle cells, macrophages, and myocytes of HO-1, a "protective gene" not seen in the rejected hearts.

CONCLUSIONS

Our present findings suggest that long-term mouse-to-rat cardiac xenograft survival is induced by temporary suppression of C activation and sustained T-cell suppression leading to inhibition of IgG EXA production. Florid expression of a protective gene (HO-1) may contribute to survival.

Complement-Fixing Elicited Antibodies Are a Major Component in the Pathogenesis of Xenograft Rejection

Hamster to rat cardiac xenografts undergo delayed rejection as compared with the hyperacute rejection of discordant xenografts. Elicited xenoreactive Abs (EXA) are thought to initiate hamster to rat cardiac xenograft rejection. In this study, we demonstrate that following transplantation of a hamster heart, rats generated high levels of EXA. Adoptive transfer into naive recipients of purified IgM, IgG2b, or IgG2c, but not IgG1 or IgG2a EXA, induced xenograft rejection in a complement-dependent manner. Ability of EXA to cause rejection correlated with complement activation, platelet aggregation, and P-selectin expression in the xenograft endothelium. Cyclosporin A (CyA) administration, after transplantation, totally suppressed IgG1, IgG2a, IgG2b, and IgG2c EXA, and inhibited IgM EXA production, but failed to overcome rejection. Administration of cobra venom factor (CVF), 1 day before and at the time of transplantation, resulted in complement inhibition during 3 days after transplantation, which failed to overcome rejection. Combination of CyA and CVF, which we have previously shown to overcome rejection, resulted in suppression of IgG EXA production and in the return of IgM XNA to preimmunization serum levels, 3 to 7 days after xenotransplantation, while complement remained inhibited. Thus, under CyA/CVF treatment, complement activation by hamster cells was suppressed following xenotransplantation, and presumably for this reason xenograft rejection did not occur. In conclusion, our data demonstrate that EXA play a pivotal role in the pathogenesis of xenograft rejection and that CyA and CVF suppress xenograft rejection by preventing exposure of xenograft endothelial cells to complement activation by EXA.

A crucial role of host CD80 and CD86 in rat cardiac xenograft rejection in mice

BACKGROUND

Graft rejection can be initiated by two primary pathways of antigen presentation: (a) direct activation of host T cells by donor-derived antigen presenting cells (APC) and (b) indirect presentation of processed graft antigens by host APC.

METHODS

We investigated the differential roles for direct and indirect antigen presentation by preventing the CD28 costimulatory pathway with monoclonal antibodies to rat or mouse CD80 and CD86 in a rat-to-mouse cardiac transplantation model.

RESULTS

Although the mouse anti-rat monoclonal antibodies to CD80 and CD86 did not significantly prolong the survival of rat cardiac xenografts in mice, the rat anti-mouse monoclonal antibodies to CD80 and CD86 did prolong the survival. Development of the anti-donor antibodies was inhibited, and the deposition of C3, IgM, and IgG on endothelium in the xenografts was mild in the anti-mouse CD80/CD86-treated mice. Infiltration of macrophages, neutrophils, and lymphocytes expressing perforin and interferon-gamma was decreased by the anti-mouse CD80/CD86 treatment.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings suggest that the indirect antigen presentation, which is mediated by CD80 and CD86 pathway on host APC, plays a crucial role in concordant cardiac xenograft rejection.

Immunology of xenotransplantation

The transplantation of tissues and organs between individuals of different species, that is, xenotransplantation, engenders a variety of immune responses. Xenogeneic immune responses mediated by naturally-occurring antibodies and complement lead to hyperacute and acute vascular rejection of vascularized organ grafts and may also cause vascular rejection of cell and tissue grafts. Under some circumstances, however, a vascularized organ graft may evade humoral rejection despite the presence of anti-donor antibodies in the circulation of the recipient; this condition is called accommodation. Xenogeneic immune responses mediated by T lymphocytes and natural killer cells may cause acute cellular rejection. The extent to which cellular rejection of xenografts resembles cellular rejection of allografts remains to be determined. New insights into the molecular mechanisms underlying the immune responses to xenotransplantation has shed light on the pathogenesis of immunological disease and has allowed the development of specific immunomodulatory strategies that may facilitate clinical application of xenotransplantation.

Modification of humoral responses by the combination of leflunomide and cyclosporine in Lewis rats transplanted with hamster hearts

BACKGROUND

Vigorous antibody-mediated responses prevent the successful engraftment of hamster hearts transplanted into Lewis rats. Early antibody responses mediating acute rejection of the xenograft are T cell-independent and resistant to the T-cell immunosuppressant, cyclosporine (CsA). Immunosuppression with the combination of leflunomide plus CsA completely prevents xenograft rejection, but when such immunosuppression is stopped the hamster heart is rejected by a process that we term late xenograft rejection. We report here on some of the immunological features of late xenograft rejection.

METHODS

Lewis rats transplanted with hamster hearts were treated with leflunomide (5 mg/kg/day by gavage) for 14-21 days and CsA (20 mg/kg/day by gavage) continuously from the day of transplant. Serum was harvested and the functional activities of the xenoreactive antibodies were quantitated by in vivo passive transfer of sera, flow cytometry, in vitro C3 deposition assays, and Western blotting.

RESULTS

CsA alone prevented late xenograft rejection and the accompanying production of xenoreactive antibodies. The xenoreactive antibodies accompanying acute or late xenograft rejection were predominantly IgM, but only serum from rats undergoing acute xenograft rejection was able to induce hyperacute rejection. The ability of serum to induce hyperacute rejection correlated with its ability to induce C3 deposition on hamster lymphocytes in vitro. The repertoire of hamster antigens recognized by IgM in the serum of rats undergoing late xenograft rejection is more restricted than that of IgM in the serum of rats undergoing acute xenograft rejection. We additionally demonstrate that long-term graft survival is not dependent on graft accommodation.

CONCLUSIONS

These studies demonstrate that a brief treatment with the combination of leflunomide and CsA profoundly modifies the humoral xenoreactivity in the recipient, converting it from a T-independent into a T cell-dependent response. Differences in functional activity of sera from acute or late xenograft rejection suggest that antigenic specificity defines the ability of IgM to induce complement activation and hyperacute rejection.

Humoral responses to pig-to-baboon cardiac transplantation: implications for the pathogenesis and treatment of acute vascular rejection and for accommodation

Organs transplanted between phylogenetically-disparate species, such as from the pig into the primate, are subject to hyperacute and acute vascular rejection. Hyperacute rejection of a porcine organ by a primate is thought to be initiated by the binding of xenoreactive natural antibodies to Galalpha1-3Gal expressed on the endothelial lining of blood vessels in the xenograft. The factor(s) which initiates acute vascular rejection is uncertain; however, there is some evidence implicating xenoreactive antibodies. The nature of the humoral response which might contribute to acute vascular rejection of a porcine organ was investigated in baboons which received a porcine cardiac xenograft plus immunosuppression with methylprednisolone, azathioprine, and cyclosporine. Following rejection and surgical removal of the xenografts, the serum concentration of xenoreactive antibodies increased in untreated animals but in immunosuppressed animals was similar to the concentration in preimmune serum. The antibodies in the sensitized recipients were specific for Galalpha1-3Gal (70-95%) and other determinants (5-30%). However, cross-blocking studies showed that, following xenotransplantation, the immunosuppressed baboons had no detectable IgM or IgG directed against "new" endothelial antigens. These results indicate that antibodies made by immunosuppressed individuals in response to xenotransplantation are much like xenoreactive natural antibodies and suggest that acute vascular rejection might in some cases be addressed by therapeutic strategies aimed at those antibodies.

Obliterative airway disease after heterotopic tracheal xenotransplantation: pathogenesis and prevention using new immunosuppressive agents

BACKGROUND

The purpose of this study was to investigate whether obliterative bronchiolitis might occur after xenogenic pulmonary transplantation. A model for obliterative airway disease (OAD) after tracheal allograft transplantation in the rat undergoes tracheal obliteration with histologic features characteristic of obliterative bronchiolitis in human lung transplant recipients. Using this model, the pathogenesis of OAD and its prevention with immunosuppressive drugs was studied in rat recipients of hamster tracheal grafts.

METHODS

Tracheae from 30 hamsters (xenografts) or 23 Brown-Norway rats (allografts) were implanted and wrapped in the greater omentum of untreated Lewis rats. The grafts were removed on day 1, 3, 7, 14, 21, or 28 after transplantation and stained with hematoxylin and eosin and Masson's trichrome and by immunohistochemistry and immunofluorescence (IFL) techniques. In addition, 25 recipients were treated with cyclosporine (CsA, 10 mg/kg p.o.), leflunomide (LFM, 20 mg/kg p.o.), or rapamycin (RPM, 6 mg/kg i.p.) for 14 or 21 days (5 animals per treatment group). Visual and morphometric analyses were used to evaluate the extent of airway obliteration, luminal coverage by respiratory or flattened cuboidal epithelium, and extent and density of peritracheal cellular inflammation.

RESULTS

In all xenografts, a neutrophilic infiltration of the mucosa and submucosa was observed from day 1 until day 14 and was associated with complete loss of tracheal epithelium by day 14. A marked peritracheal mononuclear cellular infiltrate mixed with plasma cells and eosinophils was seen on days 7 and 14. Both the extent of peritracheal inflammation and the density of the mononuclear cell infiltrate were significantly increased in xenograft tracheae when compared with the allografts. Tracheal obliteration began on day 14 and reached a maximum of 43% on day 21 with evidence of intraluminal fibrosis. In contrast to IFL of allografts, IFL of xenografts demonstrated marked deposition of rat immunoglobulin in the peritracheal tissue on days 7 and 14. The effects of treatment with immunosuppressive drugs on tracheal graft narrowing and protection of respiratory epithelium were as follows: After 14 days of treatment, the percentage of tracheal graft narrowing was 12%, 23%, and 19% in the no treatment, CsA, and LFM groups, respectively; the percentage of respiratory epithelium at 14 days was 0%, 21%, and 95%. After 21 days of treatment, the percentage of tracheal graft narrowing was 43%, 49%, 12%, and 5% for the no treatment, CsA, LFM, and RPM groups, respectively; the percentage of respiratory epithelium at 21 days was 0%, 39%, 86%, and 0%. Using computerized morphometry, the extent and densities of the peritracheal cellular infiltrates were significantly reduced in LFM- and CsA-treated groups when compared with untreated xenograft controls. LFM and RPM, but not CsA, significantly reduced the degree of luminal obliteration compared with no treatment (P<0.05). LFM and, to a lesser extent, CsA were able to prevent the loss of normal respiratory epithelium. Analysis by IFL revealed a marked decrease in rat immunoglobulin deposition in xenografts from LFM- and RPM-treated groups compared with xenografts from CsA-treated or untreated rats.

CONCLUSIONS

(1) OAD occurs not only after tracheal allotransplantation but also after xenotransplantation. (2) Subepithelial infiltration of neutrophils and the appearance of plasma cells and eosinophils in the peritracheal infiltrates distinguished the histology of rejected xenografts from allografts. (3) Antibody deposition was detected by IFL only in xenografts. (4) Treatment with LFM or RPM significantly decreased the severity of luminal obliteration. Importantly, LFM also prevented the loss of respiratory epithelium.

Mechanism of concordant corneal xenograft rejection in mice: synergistic effects of anti-leukocyte function-associated antigen-1 monoclonal antibody and FK506

BACKGROUND

The mechanisms of corneal xenogeneic immunoreaction, as well as the potential role of immunosuppressive therapy in the suppression of corneal xenograft rejection, have not been thoroughly explored.

METHODS

BALB/c mice who received orthotopic corneal transplants (Lewis rats donors) were administered intraperitoneally anti-leukocyte function associated antigen-1 (LFA-1) monoclonal antibody (mAb) or FK506 (3 mg/kg/day) or both of these immunosuppressants during a 12-day postoperative period. Histological (hematoxylin-eosin stain) and immunohistochemical evaluations of enucleated eyes were performed. Humoral immune response and delayed-type hypersensitivity (ear-swelling assay) were evaluated.

RESULTS

The mean (+/-SD) graft survival time in the untreated control, FK506-treated, anti-LFA-1 mAb-treated, and combined-treatment groups was 5.8+/-0.8, 9.4+/-4.0, 8.7+/-5.0, and 67.7+/-16.4 days, respectively. In the untreated control group, mouse IgG, IgM, and C3 were expressed on the rat corneal grafts during the early postoperative phase. Flow cytometry studies revealed high titers of xenoreactive IgG and IgM antibodies. T helper 1 cytokines were expressed on xenografted corneal beds, and delayed-type hypersensitivity was induced. However, local expression of IgM, C3 and T helper 1 cytokines, serum antibodies of IgG and IgM, and delayed-type hypersensitivity were suppressed in the anti-LFA-1 mAb- plus FK506-treated group.

CONCLUSIONS

Both humoral and cell-mediated immune reaction play an important role in the initial rejection in rat-to-mouse corneal xenotransplantation. The treatment with anti-LFA-1 mAb in combination with FK506 synergistically suppresses concordant corneal xenogeneic reaction.