Comparative studies of specific acquired systemic tolerance induced by intrathymic inoculation of a single synthetic Wistar-Furth (RT1U) allo-MHC class I (RT1.AU) peptide or WAG (RT1U)-derived class I peptide

Introducing thymus for promoting transplantation tolerance

Establishing tolerance remains a central, if elusive, goal of transplantation. In solid-organ transplantation, one strategy for inducing tolerance has been cotransplantation of various forms of thymic tissue along with another organ. As one of the biological foundations of central tolerance, thymic tissue carries with it the ability to induce tolerance to any other organ or tissue from the same donor (or another donor tissue-matched to the thymic tissue) if successfully transplanted. In this review, we outline the history of this approach as well as work to date on its application in organ transplantation, concluding with future directions. We also review our experience with allogeneic processed thymus tissue for the treatment of congenital athymia, encompassing complete DiGeorge syndrome and other rare genetic disorders, and consider whether allogeneic processed thymic tissue implantation may offer a novel method for future experimentation with tolerance induction in organ transplantation.

New strategies in immune tolerance induction

Induction of tolerance in clinical organ transplantation that will obviate the use of chronic immunosuppression and preserve host immune response to other antigens remains the goal of transplant research. The thymus plays a critical role in the ability of the immune system to discriminate between self- and nonself-antigens or harmful and harmless alloantigens. We now know that multiple factors determine how the immune system responds to a self-antigen or foreign antigen. These determinants include developmental stage of the host, stage of T-cell maturity, site of antigen encounter, type and maturity of antigen-presenting cells, and presence and type of costimulatory molecules. Our understanding of the mechanisms of T-cell interactions with peptide/ major histocompatibility complex in peripheral lymphoid organs has led to experiments that translate into peripheral T-cell tolerance. The induction of high-avidity peripheral alloreactive T cells in the early phase of organ transplantation makes it difficult to achieve long-term alloantigen-specific tolerance without the use of transient perioperative immunosuppression. Therefore, protocols that induce robust tolerance in rodent and nonhuman primate models involve the use of donor antigen combined with a short course of perioperative immunosuppression. These studies suggest that the underlying mechanisms of peripheral tolerance include deletion, anergy, immune deviation, and regulatory T cells. This review focuses on recent advances in tolerance induction in experimental animal models and discusses their relevance to the development of protocols for the induction and maintenance of clinical transplant tolerance.

Inhibitory effects of rat bone marrow-derived dendritic cells on naïve and alloantigen-specific CD4+ T cells: a comparison between dendritic cells generated with GM-CSF plus IL-4 and dendritic cells generated with GM-CSF plus IL-10

Background

Unlike mouse immature bone marrow (BM)-derived dendritic cells (DC), rat immature BMDC have not been thoroughly characterised in vitro for the mechanisms underlying their suppressive effect. To better characterise these mechanisms we therefore analysed the phenotypes and immune inhibitory properties of rat BMDC generated with GM-CSF plus IL-4 (= IL-4 DC) and with GM-CSF plus IL-10 (= IL-10 DC).

Results

Both IL-4 DC and IL-10 DC exhibited lower surface expression of MHC class II and costimulatory molecules than mature splenic DC. They had a strong inhibitory effect on responsive T cells in vitro and despite their weak function as antigen-presenting cells they induced anergic T cells. However, only anergic T cells induced by IL-4 DC had a suppressive effect on responsive T cells. Induction of suppressive/tolerogenic T cells by IL-4 DC required direct contact between antigen-specific T cells and IL-4 DC. In addition, IL-4 DC and IL-10 DC prolonged allograft survival in an antigen-specific manner.

Conclusion

A unique phenotype of immature BMDC was isolated from the cultures. The mechanisms underlying the suppressive effect may be caused by their inability to deliver adequate costimulatory signals for T-cell activation. In addition, IL-4 DC but not IL-10 DC induce anergic T cells with suppressive function. This indicates that IL-4 DC and IL-10 DC may differ in the quality of their costimulation although no differences in the surface expression of costimulatory molecules were found.

Indirect recognition of T-cell epitopes derived from the alpha 3 and transmembrane domain of HLA-A2

Indirect allorecognition has been implicated in the mechanism of chronic rejection and alloantibody formation but precise definition of the epitopes involved has been limited. We have undertaken a detailed assessment of the antigenic properties of peptides derived from HLA-A2. Candidate epitopes were identified in vitro by assessment of MHC class II binding. The immune response to these epitopes was determined in patients awaiting a renal transplant by the assessment of PBMC activation using gamma-interferon ELISPOT. Twenty-two of fifty-five patients responded to peptides from HLA-A2 and this was associated with but not confined to those who had made antibody to HLA-A2 (14/18). Nineteen of twenty-two patients responded to peptides derived from the hypervariable alpha1 and alpha2 domains and 18/22 responded to peptides from the alpha 3 and transmembrane domain, the sequences of which show little polymorphism. In six patients, the sequence of these peptides was identical to self, that is, the response was autoimmune. The finding of indirect epitopes derived from regions of MHC class I that exhibit little polymorphism provides a novel perspective on the immune response to alloantigen and has potential implications for the development of specific therapies.

Allopeptide-pulsed dendritic cells and composite tissue allograft survival

Composite tissue allografts (CTAs) contain their own reservoir of vascularized bone marrow, offering novel aspects for the induction of donor-specific tolerance. Additionally, the manipulation of recipient dendritic cells, pulsed with donor allopeptide, has been shown to engender solid organ allograft survival. To exploit these modalities, we have developed a protocol utilizing injection of recipient bone marrow-derived dendritic cells (BMDCs) pulsed with a donor-derived peptide for use in CTA transplantation. Six days prior to orthotopic hind-limb transplantation, Lewis rats received IV injection of donor allopeptide-pulsed, recipient BMDCs, in conjunction with a single dose of anti-lymphocyte serum. Control groups displayed signs of allograft rejection within 5 days postoperatively. Animals within the primary experimental cohort demonstrated prolongation of graft survival to an average of 8 days, and exhibited low numbers of donor T cells. The use of BMDCs in conjunction with transient immunosuppression has potential therapeutic application for induction of donor-antigen-specific tolerance to hind limb allografts.

Biological and Biomaterial Approaches for Improved Islet Transplantation

Islet transplantation may be used to treat type I diabetes. Despite tremendous progress in islet isolation, culture, and preservation, the clinical use of this modality of treatment is limited due to post-transplantation challenges to the islets such as the failure to revascularize and immune destruction of the islet graft. In addition, the need for lifelong strong immunosuppressing agents restricts the use of this option to a limited subset of patients, which is further restricted by the unmet need for large numbers of islets. Inadequate islet supply issues are being addressed by regeneration therapy and xenotransplantation. Various strategies are being tried to prevent beta-cell death, including immunoisolation using semipermeable biocompatible polymeric capsules and induction of immune tolerance. Genetic modification of islets promises to complement all these strategies toward the success of islet transplantation. Furthermore, synergistic application of more than one strategy is required for improving the success of islet transplantation. This review will critically address various insights developed in each individual strategy and for multipronged approaches, which will be helpful in achieving better outcomes.

Intrathymic inoculation of donor HLA class I-derived peptide generates donor-specific CD4+CD25+ regulatory T cells

CD4(+)CD25(+) regulatory T cells are selected in the thymus to control autoreactive thymic escapees preventing autoimmunity that cannot be achieved by negative selection or deletion alone, thus playing an important role in the maintenance of immunological homeostasis. Not only significant in preventing autoimmunity, CD4(+)CD25(+) regulatory T cells have also been shown to be involved in allograft tolerance in organ transplantation. We have formerly introduced two lines of HLA class I transgenic mice to elucidate the role of HLA class I molecules in transplantation biology. Using a heterotopic cardiac transplantation model, we show herein that intrathymic inoculation of donor HLA class I-derived synthetic peptide results in the generation of CD4(+)CD25(+) regulatory T cells, which induce graft specific tolerance without any preconditioning of the recipient or use of immunosuppressive drugs. This study provides evidence of the novel therapeutic potential of CD4(+)CD25(+) regulatory T cells for clinical transplantation.

Recombinant dimeric MHC antigens protect cardiac allografts from rejection and visualize alloreactive T cells

Monomeric and dimeric soluble major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules down-regulate activated T cells in an antigen-specific manner in vitro. This property could be exploited to modulate alloresponses in vivo but has remained difficult to demonstrate. Here, intraperitoneal infusion of a Lewis-derived rat MHC class I molecule, RT1.A(l)-Fc, in Dark Agouti (RT1.A(a)) recipient rats prolonged cardiac graft survival, which led to permanent engraftment. This effect was mediated by T cell impairment of target cell lysis by CD8+ T cells and down-regulation of interferon-gamma production by CD4+ T cells. The binding of the dimeric MHC allowed ex vivo visualization of alloreactive T cells in peripheral blood, splenocytes, and allografts, revealing low frequency of alloreactive CD8+ T cells after establishment of permanent engraftment of cardiac allografts. Thus, these data show the potential of dimeric MHC molecules to promote graft survival and allow visualization of alloreactive T cells.

Allogeneic core amino acids of an immunodominant allopeptide are important for MHC binding and TCR recognition

The indirect alloimmune response seems to be restricted to a few dominant major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-derived peptides responsible for T-cell activation in allograft rejection. The molecular mechanisms of indirect T-cell activation have been studied using peptide analogues derived from the dominant allopeptide in vitro, whereas the in vivo effects of peptide analogues have not been well characterized yet. In the present study, we generated allochimeric peptide analogues by replacing the three allogeneic amino acids 5L, 9L, and 10T in the sequence of the dominant MHC class I allopeptide P1. These allochimeric peptide analogues were used to define the allogeneic amino acids critical for the MHC binding and TCR recognition. We found that position 5 (5L) of the dominant allopeptide acts as an MHC-binding residue, while the other two allogeneic positions, 9 and 10, are important for the T-cell receptor (TCR) recognition. A peptide containing the MHC-binding residue 5L, as the only different amino acid between donor (RT1.A(u)) and recipient (RT1.A(l)) sequences, did not induce proliferation of lymph node cells primed with the dominant peptide and prevented dominant peptide-induced acceleration of allograft rejection. Identification of MHC and TCR contact residues should facilitate the development of antigen-specific therapies to inhibit or regulate the indirect alloimmune response.

Blockade of indirect recognition mediated by CD4+ T cells leads to prolonged cardiac xenograft survival

The T-cell response to xenografts is induced by direct and indirect recognition of xenoantigens. Although the importance of indirect recognition is well established in vitro, the contribution of this pathway to xenograft rejection in vivo remains to be fully elucidated. We herein investigated the direct contribution of indirect recognition to cardiac xenograft rejection in the rat-to-mouse (PVG.R8-to-C57BL/10) concordant model. Rat xenoantigens invoked a vigorous proliferative response in mouse T cells harvested from naïve or graft recipients at rejection. Indirect recognition predominated the response, as antibodies against mouse class II I-A(b), CD80, or CD86 molecules significantly (45 to 60%) blocked the proliferative response. Importantly, the blockade of indirect recognition in vivo by treating the graft recipients with a monoclonal antibody (mAb) against class II I-A(b) molecule on days 0, 1, and 3 post-transplantation resulted in significant (P < 0.009) prolongation of cardiac xenograft survival (Mean Survival Time (MST) >94 +/- 55 days vs. 7 +/- 0.8 days for controls). In contrast, treatment of recipients with a mAb against mouse class I H-2K(b)/D(b) molecules did not significantly affect graft rejection (MST = 8 +/- 1 days). These results demonstrate that indirect recognition mediated by CD4(+) T cells plays a critical role in the rejection of cardiac grafts in the rat-to-mouse xenogeneic model.

Clinical islet transplant: current and future directions towards tolerance

The ultimate goal of islet transplantation is to completely correct the diabetic state from an unlimited donor source, without the need for chronic immunosuppressive drug therapy. Although islet transplantation provides an opportunity to develop innovative strategies for tolerance in the clinic, both alloimmune and autoimmune barriers must be controlled, if stable graft function is to be maintained long-term. After islet extraction from the pancreas, the cellular graft may be stored in tissue culture or cryopreserved for banking, providing an opportunity not only to optimally condition the recipient but also to allow in vitro immunologic manipulation of the graft before transplantation, unlike solid organ grafts. As such, islets may be considered a "special case." Remarkable progress has occurred in the last three years, with dramatic improvements in outcomes after clinical islet transplantation. The introduction of a steroid-free, sirolimus-based, anti-rejection protocol and islets prepared from two (or rarely three) donors led to high rates of insulin independence. The "Edmonton Protocol" has been successfully replicated by other centers in an international multicenter trial. A number of key refinements in pancreas transportation, processing, purification on non-ficoll-based media, storage of islets in culture for two days and newer immunological conditioning and induction therapies have led to continued advancement through extensive collaboration between key centers. This review outlines the historical development of islet transplantation over the past 30 years, provides an update on current clinical outcomes, and summarizes a series of unique opportunities for development and early testing of tolerance protocols in patients.

Immunotolerance of liver allotransplantation induced by intrathymic inoculation of donor soluble liver specific antigen

AIM: To study the effects of liver specific antigen (LSA) on the immunoreaction of liver allotransplantation and its significance.

METHODS: Orthotopic liver transplantation was used in this study. Group I: syngeneic control (Wistar-to-Wistar); Group II: acute rejection (SD-to-Wistar). Group III: acute rejection treated by intramuscular injection of cyclosporine A (CsA) (SD-to-Wistar + CsA). Group IV: Intrathymic inoculation of SD rat LSA one week before transplantation (LSA + SD-to-Wistar). The common situation and survival time, rejection grades, NF-κB activity of splenocytes and intragraft cytokine gene expression were observed to analyze the acute rejection severity and immune state of animals.

RESULTS: The common situation of Wistar-to-Wistar group was very good after the transplantation and no signs of rejection were found. Recipients of SD-to-Wistar group lost body weight progressively. All died within 9 to 13 d after transplantation with the median survival time of 10.7 ± 0.51 d. It was an optimal control for acute rejection. The common situation of SD-to-Wistar + CsA group was bad during CsA medication but only with mild rejection. As for LSA + SD-to-Wistar group, 5 of 6 recipients survived for a long time and common situation was remarkably better than that of SD-to-Wistar group and SD-to-Wistar + CsA group. Its rejection grades were significantly lower than that of SD-to-Wistar group (P = 0.026). Furthermore, no significant discrepancies of rejection were found between SD-to-Wistar group and LSA + SD-to-Wistar group at day 7 and day 12 (P = 0.067). NF-κB activity, IFN-γ and IL-2mRNA expression were significantly inhibited in LSA + SD-to-Wistar group compared with that of SD-to-Wistar group (P < 0.05).

CONCLUSION: LSA is an important transplantation antigen which involves in the immunorejection of liver transplantation directly. We reported for the first time that intrathymic inoculation of LSA can induce immnotolerance of liver allotransplantation and grafts can survive for a long time thereby, thus leading to a novel way to liver transplantation immunotolerance.

CD25+ immunoregulatory CD4 T cells mediate acquired central transplantation tolerance

Transplantation tolerance is induced reliably in experimental animals following intrathymic inoculation with the relevant donor strain Ags; however, the immunological mechanisms responsible for the induction and maintenance of the tolerant state remain unknown. We investigated these mechanisms using TCR transgenic mice (TS1) that carry T cells specific for an immunodominant, MHC class II-restricted peptide (S1) of the influenza PR8 hemagglutinin (HA) molecule. We demonstrated that TS1 mice reject skin grafts that have transgene-encoded HA molecules (HA104) as their sole antigenic disparity and that intrathymic but not i.v. inoculation of TS1 mice with S1 peptide induces tolerance to HA-expressing skin grafts. Intrathymic peptide inoculation was associated with a dose-dependent reduction in T cells bearing high levels of TCR specific for HA. However, this reduction was both incomplete and transient, with a full recovery of S1-specific thymocytes by 4 wk. Peptide inoculation into the thymus also resulted in the generation of immunoregulatory T cells (CD4+CD25+) that migrated to the peripheral lymphoid organs. Adoptive transfer experiments using FACS sorted CD4+CD25- and CD4+CD25+ T cells from tolerant mice revealed that the former but not the latter maintain the capacity to induce rejection of HA bearing skin allografts in syngeneic hosts. Our results suggest that both clonal frequency reduction in the thymus and immunoregulatory T cells exported from the thymus are critical to transplantation tolerance induced by intrathymic Ag inoculation.

Hierarchical immunogenicity of donor MHC class I peptides in allotransplantation

The recognition of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) allopeptides by recipient MHC class II-restricted CD4(+) T cells via indirect pathway is a prerequisite for the generation of an immune response to the allograft. We tested 13-mer to 24-mer peptides from the MHC class I molecule for their possible immunogenicity in a fully MHC-mismatched rat strain combination. Our results confirm the hierarchical distribution of the immunogenicity of donor MHC class I peptides in the T cell alloactivation via indirect pathway. In addition, we show that allopeptide-induced immune response is critical for acute rejection of heart allografts. Among the seven allopeptides tested, peptide P1 was identified as immunodominant; it induced the greatest T cell proliferation and cytokine production in vitro as well as a significant reduction in allograft survival time. The TCR repertoire of T cells involved in the in vitro and in vivo responses induced by the dominant allopeptide P1 was found to be limited to the Vbeta10 and Vbeta 19 gene families. The identification of dominant allopeptides should greatly facilitate characterization of the specific T cell population responsible for allograft rejection and may be used to modulate the alloimmune response through antigen-specific therapy.

Proposition of treatment to improve the immune response: possible application to AIDS

The molecular similarity between certain human antigenic determinants with those of HIV has been already described. In this matter, we have previously demonstrated, by a chromatographic method, the cross reactivity of human serum albumin with HIV gp 120. The hypothesis that this similarity could be one of the reasons why the virus escapes to the immune system is presented in this paper and a treatment is proposed to enhance the efficiency of the immune response: it is based on the blocking of the determinants of the self, expressed in the thymus, which are in common with the virus. Repeated injections within the thymus of neutralizing antibodies against the pathogen, obtained from a sufficiently distant animal species and purified by affinity chromatography, would prevent the T cells of the host recognizing these epitopes, common to the host and to the virus, from clonal deletion and would improve the immune response.

Donor-derived soluble MHC antigens plus low-dose cyclosporine induce transplantation unresponsiveness independent of the thymus by down-regulating T cell-mediated alloresponses in a rat transplantation model

BACKGROUND

In vitro, soluble MHC (sMHC) antigens modulate and induce apoptosis in alloreactive and antigen-specific T cells, demonstrating their potency to regulate T cell-mediated immune responses. However, their efficacy to regulate immunological responses in vivo remains unclear. Here, we report that repetitive intraperitoneal injection of recombinant Lewis rat-derived MHC class I antigens in Dark Agouti (DA) rats modulates alloreactivity.

METHODS

RT1.A1 (Lewis derived) genes were cloned into mammalian expression vectors, and RT1.Aa (DA derived) genes were used to transfect a rat myeloma cell line. RT1.A1 molecules were injected intraperitoneally in DA recipients that subsequently underwent transplantation with Lewis-derived cardiac allografts.

RESULTS

Soluble class I antigens were secreted by the transfected cells and were shown to be heterodimeric, peptide-loaded, and conformationally folded. Injection of donor-derived soluble MHC significantly reduced the ability of recipient animals to mount a cytotoxic T-cell response to donor-derived tissue. More interestingly, this treatment significantly prolonged donor-graft survival and allowed 60% of treated animals to develop graft tolerance (>120 days), when donor sMHC were combined with a single subtherapeutic dosage of cyclosporine. Thymectomy of recipient animals before transplantation did not interfere with induction of peripheral tolerance.

CONCLUSIONS

Donor-derived sMHC are potential tolerogens for down-regulating the cytotoxic T-cell response of animals that undergo transplantation. Thus, these data provide for the first time a rationale for the application of directly injected sMHC in vivo to down-regulate immunological responses and aid the induction of graft tolerance.

Role of reentry of in vivo alloMHC peptide-activated T cells into the adult thymus in acquired systemic tolerance

BACKGROUND

T cell recognition of alloMHC peptide presented by self dendritic cells via the indirect pathway of allorecognition in the thymus induces T cell tolerance. Most recently we have shown that the i.v. administration of immunodominant Wistar Furth MHC class I (RT1.Au) peptide 5- (P5) pulsed myeloid or lymphoid dendritic cells induces operational tolerance to a fully MHC-mismatched cardiac allograft. This finding led us to hypothesize that circulation of peripheral P5-activated T cells to the thymus plays an important role in the induction of acquired tolerance.

METHODS

We used the adoptive transfer of 111Indium-oxine- (111In-oxine) labeled P5-pulsed syngeneic dendritic cells and in vivo P5-activated syngeneic T cells to study the role of their circulation to the thymus in the induction of transplantation tolerance.

RESULTS

Intravenously administered 111In-oxine-labeled naïve DC actively migrated to and localized in the liver and spleen but did not enter the lymph nodes, bone marrow, and thymus. In vitro peptide-pulsed dendritic cells had a similar pattern of tissue localization except for a modest number of myeloid but not lymphoid DC entering the thymus. The demonstration that adoptive transfer of in vivo peptide-primed T cells induces permanent graft survival in antilymphocyte serum transiently immunosuppressed syngeneic secondary hosts led us to examine the traffic of in vivo activated T cells. Whereas naïve syngeneic T cells preferentially homed to the peripheral lymphoid organs, they did not reenter the thymus. In contrast, in vivo peptide-activated peripheral T cells migrated to and accumulated in the thymus, thus confirming that reentry of T cells to the thymus is restricted to in vivo activated T cells. Although antilymphocyte serum immunosuppression significantly reduced circulation of primed T cells to the thymus, it did not completely abolish it, as seen with gamma-irradiated primed T cells.

CONCLUSION

These findings provide the first formal evidence directly linking reentry of in vivo alloMHC peptide-activated T cells to the thymus with the induction and possibly maintenance of acquired antigen-specific tolerance. Our results suggest that the thymus is open to a two-way traffic with the periphery and may function as a repository of immunological memory.

Indirect allorecognition of donor class I and II major histocompatibility complex peptides promotes the development of transplant vasculopathy

Recent clinical and experimental evidence suggests that indirect allorecognition may promote the development of chronic rejection, but definitive experimental studies are lacking. To study the contribution of indirect allorecognition to chronic rejection, naïve Lewis (RT1(1)) rats were immunized with synthetic Wistar Furth (WF) class II-RT1(u).D (HLA-DR-like) or -RT1(u).B (HLA-DQ-like) or class I-RT1(u).A (HLA-A-like) peptides emulsified in complete Freund's adjuvant 7 d before transplantation (n = 5 to 7/group). Experimental and control animals then acted as recipients of fully mismatched WF vascularized cardiac allografts. Recipients received immunosuppression in the form of cyclosporine at a tapering dose that allows for long-term allograft survival. Animals were sacrificed at either 3 or 6 mo, with allograft arterial luminal occlusion scored on elastin stains by a blinded observer. At 3 mo, mean vessel scores were significantly higher in the RT1(u).A-immunized versus class II-immunized and control groups (P < 0.05). By 6 mo, there was progression of chronic allograft vasculopathy and a significantly higher mean vessel score in the RT1(u).A- and RT1(u).D-immunized versus RT1(u).B and control groups (P < 0.05). In vitro studies show evidence of shifting MHC allopeptide immunogenicity. It was concluded that T cells primed by specific donor class I and II MHC allopeptides promote the development of chronic vascularized allograft rejection. These novel observations provide definitive evidence of a link between indirect allorecognition and the development and progression of chronic rejection.

Tolerance and pancreatic islet transplantation

Islet transplantation holds renewed promise as a cure for type I diabetes mellitus. Results of recent clinical trials have shown remarkable success, and have reignited universal optimism for this procedure. In spite of this success, the need for life-long immunosuppression of the recipient still limits islet transplantation to patients with poorly controlled diabetes or to those requiring kidney transplantation. It is obvious that the achievement of immunological tolerance would broaden the indication for islet transplantation to a much larger cohort of patients with type I diabetes mellitus, most likely preventing long-term complications and contributing to a much improved quality of life. Increased understanding of the basic mechanisms of tolerance induction has resulted in the implementation of numerous experimental approaches to achieve long-term survival of islet grafts in the absence of chronic immunosuppression. In this brief review we will attempt to summarize the current status of research and knowledge.

Indirect allorecognition in acquired thymic tolerance: induction of donor-specific permanent acceptance of rat islets by adoptive transfer of allopeptide-pulsed host myeloid and thymic dendritic cells

Pancreatic islet transplantation remains a promising approach to the treatment of type 1 diabetes. Unfortunately, graft failure continues to occur because of immunologic rejection, despite the use of potent immunosuppressive agents. It is therefore reasoned that induction of peripheral tolerance by the use of self-dendritic cells (DCs) as a vehicle to deliver specific target antigens to self-T-cells without ex vivo manipulation of the recipient is an attractive strategy in the treatment of type 1 diabetes. The finding that intrathymic inoculation of an immunodominant WF major histocompatibility complex (MHC) Class I (RT1.A(u)) peptide five (P5) or P5-pulsed host myeloid DCs induces acquired thymic tolerance raises the possibility that adoptive transfer of allopeptide-primed host myeloid or lymphoid DCs might induce transplant tolerance. To address this hypothesis, we studied the effects of intravenous transfer of in vitro P5-pulsed syngeneic myeloid DCs or in vivo P5-primed syngeneic lymphoid (thymic) DCs on islet survival in the WF-to-ACI rat combination. In vivo primed thymic DCs isolated from ACI rats given intrathymic inoculation of P5 for 2 days were capable of in vitro restimulation of in vivo P5-primed T-cells (memory cells). In the first series of studies, we showed that intravenous-like intrathymic-inoculation of in vitro P5-pulsed host myeloid DCs induced donor-specific permanent acceptance of islets in recipients transiently immunosuppressed with antilymphocyte serum (ALS). We next examined whether thymic DCs isolated from animals that had been previously intrathymically inoculated with P5 could induce T-cell tolerance. The results showed that intravenous adoptive transfer of in vivo P5-primed thymic DCs led to donor-specific permanent acceptance of islets in recipients transiently immunosuppressed with ALS. This finding suggested that the thymic DCs take up and present P5 to developing T-cells to induce T-cell tolerance, thus providing evidence of a direct link between indirect allorecognition and acquired thymic tolerance. The second series of studies examined the mechanisms involved in this model by exploring whether in vivo generation of peptide-specific alloreactive peripheral T-cells by intravenous inoculation of P5-pulsed self-DCs was responsible for the induction of T-cell tolerance. Intrathymic inoculation of splenic T-cells obtained from syngeneic ACI rats primed with intravenous injection of P5-pulsed DCs with a high in vitro proliferative response to P5 in the context of self-MHC induced donor-specific permanent acceptance of islets from WF donors. In addition, the clinically relevant model of intravenous injection of P5-activated T-cells combined with transient ALS immunosuppression similarly induced transplant tolerance, which was then abrogated by thymectomy of the recipient before intravenous injection of the activated T-cells. These data raise the possibility that circulation of peptide-activated T-cells to the host thymus plays a role in the induction and possibly the maintenance of T-cell tolerance in this model. Our findings suggest that intravenous administration of genetically engineered host DCs expressing alloMHC peptides might have therapeutic potential in clinical islet transplantation for the treatment of autoimmune diabetes.

Mechanisms of acquired thymic tolerance: induction of transplant tolerance by adoptive transfer of in vivo allomhc peptide activated syngeneic T cells

BACKGROUND

Our most recent observation that i.v. injection of Wistar-Furth (WF) major histocompatibility complex Class I peptide 5 (P5)-pulsed self-myeloid or lymphoid dendritic cells (DC) induces transplantation tolerance suggests that adoptive transfer of in vivo allopeptide-primed host T cells might induce acquired tolerance through their interaction with thymic DC.

METHODS

To examine this hypothesis, host myeloid DC cultured in rat granulocyte/macrophage colony stimulating factor and interleukin 4 were pulsed in vitro with P5 and injected intravenously into syngeneic ACI rats. The T cells primed to P5 via the indirect pathway of allorecognition were harvested 7 days later and administered by either intravenously or intrathymically into syngeneic ACI recipients of WF cardiac allografts.

RESULTS

Syngeneic T cells obtained from the spleen of P5-primed rats had a high mixed lymphocyte reaction proliferative response to P5 presented by self-DC. I.v. administration of 2x107 P5-primed alloreactive purified host splenic T cells alone on day -7 significantly (P<0.001) prolonged cardiac allograft survival from 10.5+/-1.0 days to 18.6+/-1.8 days in the WF-to-ACI rat combination. I.v. injection of P5-activated host T cells combined with 0.5 ml antilymphocyte serum (ALS)-transient immunosuppression on day -7 led to 100% donor-specific permanent graft survival (>200 days). Thymectomy before i.v. injection of P5-activated syngeneic T cells led to acute graft rejection, suggesting that the homing of in vivo activated T cells to the host thymus might play a role in the induction of tolerance. To further define the role of the recipient thymus in this model, we examined the effects of intrathymic (i.t.) injection of P5-primed alloreactive T cells on graft survival and found that i.t. administration of the P5-primed T cells on day -7 alone significantly prolonged graft survival (15.0+/-0.7 days) and when combined with 0.5 ml ALS led to donor-specific permanent graft survival. The long-term unresponsive recipients permanently (>100 days) accepted second-set donor-specific cardiac allografts but not third-party (Lewis) grafts.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings demonstrate that the adoptive transfer of splenic T cells primed to an indirectly presented donor peptide induces transplantation tolerance in a transiently immunosuppressed secondary syngeneic recipient. Our data suggest that the interaction of thymic DC with activated peripheral T cells induces alloantigen (Ag)-specific T-cell tolerance by either inactivation or deletion of alloreactive T cells in the thymus. This observation provides the first formal evidence that the interaction between thymic DC and activated peripheral T cells that continuously circulate through the thymus plays an important role in the induction and maintenance of Ag-specific tolerance.

INTRATHYMIC IMMUNE MODULATION PREVENTS ACUTE REJECTION BUT NOT THE DEVELOPMENT OF GRAFT ARTERIOSCLEROSIS (CHRONIC REJECTION)1

BACKGROUND

We showed previously that our intrathymic immune modulation protocol induces virtually permanent graft survival of simultaneously transplanted cardiac allografts in MHC-incompatible rat strain combinations. It is, however, unknown whether this procedure prevents the development of graft arterial disease (GAD).

METHODS

Male AO recipient rats were intrathymically inoculated with 2.5x10(7) PVG splenocytes immediately followed by heterotopic transplantation of a PVG cardiac allograft (day 0). Immunosuppression consisted of 1 ml of antilymphocyte serum i.p. (day 0) and cyclosporine i.m. (15 mg/kg body weight) on days 1, 2, and 3 posttransplantation. Histological analysis, mixed lymphocyte reactions, and intragraft cytokine mRNA expression were performed at several time points after engraftment.

RESULTS

Histological analysis revealed that GAD was already present 14 days after transplantation. At 200 days, virtually all vessels were affected and over 80% of the vessels showed severe intimal lesions. Infiltrate analysis displayed massive parenchymatous infiltrates (CD8+ cells and ED1+ macrophages) 2 weeks after transplantation. At later time points, infiltrates became epicardial and/or blood vessel associated and mainly consisted of CD4+, CD8+, and B cells. Mixed lymphocyte reactions showed nonspecifically decreased responses at 60 days but complete restoration of these responses at later time points (120 to 280 days). Intragraft cytokine mRNA expression showed decreased interleukin-2/interferon-gamma and sustained interleukin-10 expression 2 weeks after transplantation. Transforming growth factor-beta mRNA expression was increased >200 days after transplantation.

CONCLUSIONS

Intrathymic immune modulation does not abolish alloreactivity, and despite induction of long-lasting graft survival, this procedure does not prevent and may even facilitate the development of GAD.

Synthetic HLA-A2 derived peptides are recognized and presented in renal graft recipients

Indirect presentation of allogeneic MHC antigen is an important pathway by which allografts are rejected and tolerance maintained by regulatory CD4(+) T cells. In this study HLA-A2 derived synthetic peptides were used to determine whether T cells of non-HLA-A2 renal graft recipients, which had been HLA-A2 mismatched to their organ donors, recognize some of the HLA-A2-derived peptides. Among the HLA-A2 mismatched patients, 60% recognized residues 56--69, 65--79, and 75--89. Peripheral blood lymphocytes derived from healthy individuals showed low reactivity towards allopeptides, indicating that sensitization towards HLA-A2 induced response towards HLA-A2 derived peptides. The response to the peptides was blocked by antibodies to HLA-DR, -DQ, and CD4. Depletion of antigen presenting cells abrogated response towards the allopeptides, confirming that the observed proliferation was mediated by the indirect pathway. Interestingly, although none of the HLA-A2 mismatched patients had any signs for either acute or chronic rejection, considerable response to allo-derived HLA-A2 was observed.

Intrathymic immunomodulation in sensitized rat recipients of cardiac allografts: requirements for allorecognition pathways

BACKGROUND

Intrathymic injection of alloantigen in the form of donor cells, soluble major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules, or MHC allopeptides induces donor-specific tolerance in a variety of acute allograft rejection models. We have previously shown that a single intrathymic injection of donor spleen cells into pre-sensitized rats abrogates accelerated (circa 24-hour) rejection and prolongs the survival of cardiac allografts to about 7 days. The present study was designed to investigate the mechanisms by which intrathymic administration of donor cells modifies the course of accelerated rejection.

METHODS

Lewis RT1(1) (LEW) rats sensitized by transplantation with Wistar-Furth RT1(u) (WF) skin grafts received WF cardiac allografts 7 days later-a classic model of accelerated rejection. At the time of skin challenge, however, certain animals received intrathymic cell suspensions (either allogeneic or syngeneic) or donor-derived class I and/or class II MHC peptides.

RESULTS

Control animals (sensitized by skin grafts but receiving no other treatment) rejected cardiac allografts within 24 hours. Intrathymic injection of WF splenocytes at the time of skin transplantation abrogated rejection at 24 hours and prolonged cardiac allograft survival to 6.6+/-0.6 days (p<0.001), whereas intrathymic administration of syngeneic (LEW) or allogeneic third party Brown Norway RT1(n) cells was ineffective in this regard. Intrathymic injection of gamma-irradiated donor cells marginally extended cardiac allograft survival to 3.0+/-0.9 days (p< 0.001), but the grafts were still rejected in an accelerated fashion. Intrathymic injection of donor-derived class I and/or class II MHC allopeptides at the same time period also failed to prolong cardiac allograft survival beyond 3 days. In the group receiving unmodified donor cells, elevated immunoglobulin M (IgM) and immunoglobulin G (IgG) allo-antibodies were found at the time of cardiac transplantation; this pattern was not observed with any other treatment.

CONCLUSION

The superiority of non-modified donor spleen cells over gamma-irradiated donor cells or donor specific allopeptides in modifying the course of accelerated cardiac rejection suggests that direct allorecognition is the dominant pathway initiating rejection in sensitized transplant recipients. Marked alterations in the antidonor IgM and IgG responses are associated with successful abrogation of accelerated rejection by thymic immunomodulatory mechanisms.

Major histocompatibility complex class I peptide-pulsed host dendritic cells induce antigen-specific acquired thymic tolerance to islet cells

BACKGROUND

As T-cell receptor-major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I/self peptide interaction regulates T-cell development in the thymus, we reasoned that presentation of peptides by self dendritic cells (DC) to developing T cells in the thymus might induce acquired thymic tolerance. This hypothesis is based on the finding that intrathymic injection of allopeptides in the adult animal induces acquired tolerance. To examine this hypothesis, we studied the effects of intrathymic (IT) injection of a single immunodominant Wistar-Furth (WF) MHC class I (RT1.Au) peptide-pulsed host DC on islet allograft survival in the WF-to-ACI rat combination.

METHODS

Bone marrow-derived ACI DC expressing MHC class I and II, OX62, and ED2 present allopeptides to naive and specifically peptide-primed syngeneic T cells in mixed lymphocyte reaction. Host DC pulsed with RT1.Au peptide 5 (residues 93-109) were injected into the thymus of streptozotocin-induced diabetic ACI that were transplanted 7 days later with donor-type (WF) or third-party (Brown Norway [BN]) islets.

RESULTS

Whereas IT injection of 300 microg of peptide 5 alone led to normoglycemia and permanent islet survival in three of six diabetic ACI recipients, similar treatment combined with simultaneous intraperitoneal injection of 0.5 ml of anti-lymphocyte serum (ALS) on day -7 led to 100% permanent islet allograft survival (>200 days) compared to a mean survival time of 15.0+/-2.3 days in controls treated with ALS alone. In contrast, similarly prepared animals rejected the third-party (BN) islets in an acute fashion. To address the question of indirect allorecognition in acquired thymic tolerance, we examined the effect of peptide-pulsed host DC on graft survival. Whereas IT injection of peptide-pulsed host DC alone resulted in permanent islet survival in two of five animals, IT injection of peptide-pulsed host DC combined with 0.5 ml of ALS induced 100% donor-specific permanent islet allograft survival in the WF-to-ACI rat combination. These results suggest that thymic DC take up, process, and present the administered peptide to the developing T cells by the indirect allorecognition pathway in the induction of acquired thymic tolerance.

CONCLUSION

We have demonstrated a novel approach to inducing transplant tolerance to islet allografts with IT injection of allopeptide-pulsed host DC. This finding suggests that immunization strategies using DC expressing MHC allopeptides or peptide analogue might be potentially useful in the treatment of autoimmune diabetes mellitus.

Indirect allorecognition in acquired thymic tolerance: induction of donor-specific tolerance to rat cardiac allografts by allopeptide-pulsed host dendritic cells

BACKGROUND

Presentation of peptides either by recipient or donor MHC molecules displayed on the surface of antigen-presenting cells is an essential element in the induction of T cell responses to transplant antigens. The finding that intrathymic (IT) injection of an immunodominant peptide induces acquired thymic tolerance suggests an indirect pathway of allorecognition in the thymus. To address this theory, we studied the effects of IT injection of host bone marrow (BM)-derived dendritic cells (DC)-pulsed with the immunodominant Wistar Furth (WF) MHC class I (RT1.Au) peptide 5 (93-109) on cardiac allograft survival in the WF-to-ACI rat combination.

METHODS

DC were propagated from cultures of ACI (recipient) bone marrow (BM) maintained in a medium supplemented with granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor and IL-4. The BM-derived DC after 8 days of culture were pulsed in vitro with a single WF MHC class I peptide (Residue 93-109) with the dominant epitope, washed, and injected into the thymus of ACI rats. The ACI recipients received donor-type (WF) or 3rd party (Lewis) cardiac allografts 7 days after IT immunization with peptide-pulsed DC.

RESULTS

BM-derived DC cultured in granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor and interleukin-4 for 8 days have a strong allostimulatory ability and present peptide 5 to naive syngeneic T cells in mixed lymphocyte reaction. IT inoculation of 300 microg RT1.Au peptide 5 combined with transient antilymphocyte serum immunosuppressive therapy induced donor-specific tolerance to cardiac allografts. Extension of this finding to peptide-pulsed self DC showed that IT injection of peptide 5-pulsed host DC consistently led to permanent acceptance (>150 days) of donor-type (WF) cardiac allografts, whereas third-party (Lewis) grafts were acutely rejected. The long-term unresponsive recipients challenged with second-set grafts accepted permanently (>100 days) donor-type(WF) grafts while rejecting third-party (Lewis) grafts without the rejection of the primary WF grafts.

CONCLUSION

This novel finding that allopeptide-pulsed host DC induces tolerance to cardiac allografts suggests that the induction of acquired tolerance is dependent on the indirect allorecognition pathway. The results further suggest that genetically engineered DC expressing donor MHC class I or II molecules or a peptide analogue might have therapeutic potential in the induction of transplant tolerance and in the treatment of autoimmune diseases.

Mechanism of acquired thymic tolerance induced by a single major histocompatibility complex class I peptide with the dominant epitope: differential analysis of regulatory cytokines in the lymphoid and intragraft compartments

BACKGROUND

We have recently shown that intrathymic injection of a combination of immunogenic WAG-derived or Wistar-Furth (WF) (RT1.Au) major histocompatibility complex class I peptides induces acquired systemic tolerance to cardiac and islet allografts in the WF-to-ACI rat combination and therefore hypothesized that identification of the class I peptide dominance may play an important role in the induction of antigen (Ag)-specific tolerance. This study defined the peptide with the dominant epitope among the seven synthetic RT1.Au peptides and analyzed the immunoregulatory cytokines within the lymphoid and intragraft compartments associated with acquired thymic tolerance.

METHODS

ACI recipients were pretreated with intrathymic (IT) injection of 300 microg of the individual seven RT1.Au peptides 7 days before WF or Lewis cardiac transplantation. Cytokine profile of mixed lymphocyte reaction supernatants of T cells obtained from the thymus, mesenteric lymph nodes, spleen, peripheral blood leukocytes, and graft infiltrating cells after donor (WF) or third-party (Lewis) Ag stimulation were measured by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay, whereas cytokine gene expression was determined by reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction.

RESULTS

Only IT injection of peptide 5 (93-109) among the seven RT1.Au peptides induced donor-spe cific tolerance to cardiac allografts in the WF-to-ACI rat combination. In addition, intravenous injection of peptide 5 did not prolong WF graft survival in ACI recipients. Analysis of cytokine production by the tolerant recipients showed significant Ag-specific reduction in the production of interleukin (IL)-2 and interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) in the thymus, mesenteric lymph nodes, spleen, and peripheral blood leukocytes, which was not associated with a concomitant Ag-specific increase in IL-4 and IL-10 production. Measurement of cytokine mRNA expression confirmed undetectable

Regulatory T cells maintain peripheral tolerance to islet allografts induced by intrathymic injection of MHC class I allopeptides

Although transplantation remains the treatment of choice for diabetes mellitus, immunological rejection of allografts continues to be a major problem. The search for strategies to prevent graft rejection led us to examine if the fate of developing T cells may be influenced by the presence of allo MHC class I peptides in the thymus because T cell receptor-MHC class I/self-peptide interaction regulates thymocyte development. We studied the effects of intrathymic (IT) injection of a short segment of a synthetic immunogenic MHC class I peptide (peptide 2, residues 67-85) of the hypervariable domain of RT1.A derived from WAG rat (RT1U) on islet graft survival in the WF(RT1U)-to-ACI combination. Adult diabetic male recipients were treated with IT injection of a single WAG-derived MHC class I peptide 7 days before intraportal islet transplantation. Long-term unresponsive islet recipients were examined for the development of alloantigen (Ag)-specific regulatory cells. The results showed that while IT injection of 150 microg peptide 2 on day -7 did not prolong graft survival in naive recipients [median survival time (MST) of 14.0 days vs. 9.6 in controls], IT injection of 300 or 600 microg peptide 2 led to normoglycemia and permanent islet survival (> 200 days) in 4/6 and 3/5 STZ-induced diabetic ACI recipients, respectively. IT injection of 150, 300, or 600 microg peptide 2 combined with 0.5 antilymphocyte serum (ALS) immunosuppression on day -7 led to 100% permanent islet allograft survival (> 200 days) compared to MST of 15.0 +/- 2.3 days in ALS alone-treated controls. Similarly prepared animals rejected third-party Brown Norway (BN) islets in an acute fashion, thus demonstrating donor specificity. Intravenous injection of 300 microg peptide 2 combined with 0.5 ml ALS did not prolong islet allograft survival. The long-term unresponsive islet allograft recipients challenged with second set grafts accepted permanently 100% donor-type cardiac allografts while rejecting third-party (BN) hearts without rejecting the primary Wistar Furth (WF) islets. In analyzing the underlying mechanisms of acquired systemic tolerance, we found no suppressor/regulatory cells in adoptive transfer studies in tolerant animals at 30 days after IT injection of allopeptides. In contrast, adoptive transfer of 5 x 10(7) unseparated spleen cells from tolerant animals at 60 and 100 days after islet transplantation into lightly irradiated [200 rad total body irradiation (TBI)] ACI recipients led to donor-specific permanent islet graft survival in 2/3 and 4/5 secondary recipients, respectively, compared to an MST of 13.8 days in lightly irradiated ACI given unmodified syngeneic spleen cells. In addition, adoptive transfer of 2 x 10(7) purified T cells obtained from long-term functioning islet recipients led to permanent donor-specific islet survival in secondary recipients. The finding that IT injection of a short segment of a synthetic immunodominant MHC class I peptide derived from WAG that shares the RT1.A(U) domain with the graft donor is capable of inducing acquired systemic tolerance to WF islets suggests that linked recognition or epitope suppression may be involved in the induction of unresponsiveness. Generation of peripheral Ag-specific regulatory cells that suppress Ag-specific alloreactive T cells is, in part, responsible for the maintenance of tolerance in this model.