The danger hypothesis applied to idiosyncratic drug reactions

Drug hypersensitivity reactions: review of the state of the science for prediction and diagnosis

Drug hypersensitivity reactions (DHRs) are a type of adverse drug reaction that can occur with different classes of drugs and affect multiple organ systems and patient populations. DHRs can be classified as allergic or non-allergic based on the cellular mechanisms involved. Whereas nonallergic reactions rely mainly on the innate immune system, allergic reactions involve the generation of an adaptive immune response. Consequently, drug allergies are DHRs for which an immunological mechanism, with antibody and/or T cell, is demonstrated. Despite decades of research, methods to predict the potential for a new chemical entity to cause DHRs or to correctly attribute DHRs to a specific mechanism and a specific molecule are not well-established. This review will focus on allergic reactions induced by systemically administered low-molecular weight drugs with an emphasis on drug- and patient-specific factors that could influence the development of DHRs. Strategies for predicting and diagnosing DHRs, including potential tools based on the current state of the science, will also be discussed.

Development of mouse models with restricted HLA-B∗57:01 presentation for the study of flucloxacillin-driven T-cell activation and tolerance in liver injury

BACKGROUND

Flucloxacillin (FLX)-induced liver injury is immune-mediated and highly associated to HLA-B∗57:01 expression. Host factors leading to drug-induced liver injury are not yet well understood.

OBJECTIVE

Characterize in vivo immune mechanisms determining the development of CD8+ T cells reactive to FLX in animals expressing the risk human leukocyte antigen (HLA) allotype.

METHODS

HLA-B∗57:01 transgenic mice (Tg) or Tg strains with H2-KbDb knockout (Tg/KO) or H2-KbDb/PD-1 double knockout (Tg/DKO) were treated with drug and/or anti-CD4 antibody. Drug-induced liver injury was evaluated on the basis of liver enzyme and histologic changes at day 10 of treatment. FLX-reactive CD8+ T cells were characterized in vitro by release of effector molecules on drug restimulation, gene expression, and flow cytometry analysis, and functionality tested for hepatic cytotoxicity.

RESULTS

CD8+ T-cell responses to FLX in Tg were dependent on both HLA and mouse major histocompatibility complex I presentation and in vivo priming. Eliminating H2-KbDb in Tg/KO to allow exclusive presentation of FLX by HLA resulted in a less robust drug-specific CD8+T-cell response unless CD4+ cells, including regulatory T cells, were depleted. Treatment of Tg/KO with anti-CD4 antibody and FLX led to subclinical liver inflammation associated with an increase in PD1+CD8+ T cells in the lymphoid organs and liver. Impaired PD-1 expression in Tg/DKO led to liver histopathologic and transcriptional alterations but without hepatic enzyme elevations. Moreover, effector lymphocytes accumulated in the liver and showed FLX-dependent hepatic cytotoxicity in vitro when tolerogenic liver cells were depleted.

CONCLUSIONS

In our in vivo models, FLX primes CD8+ T cells to recognize drug presented by HLA-B∗57:01 and murine major histocompatibility complex I. HLA-B∗57:01-dependent CD8+ T-cell reaction to FLX is limited by the presence of CD4+ cells, presumably regulatory T cells, and PD-1 expression. Tolerogenic hepatic cells limit clinical disease through PD-L1 or additional unexplored mechanisms.

Drug-Induced Idiosyncratic Agranulocytosis - Infrequent but Dangerous

Drug-induced agranulocytosis is a life-threatening side effect that usually manifests as a severe form of neutropenia associated with fever or signs of sepsis. It can occur as a problem in the context of therapy with a wide variety of drug classes. Numerous drugs are capable of triggering the rare idiosyncratic form of agranulocytosis, which, unlike agranulocytosis induced by cytotoxic drugs in cancer chemotherapy, is characterised by “bizzare” type B or hypersensitivity reactions, poor predictability and a mainly low incidence. The idiosyncratic reactions are thought to be initiated by chemically reactive drugs or reactive metabolites that react with proteins and may subsequently elicit an immune response, particularly directed against neutrophils and their precursors. Cells or organs that exhibit specific metabolic and biotransformation activity are therefore frequently affected. In this review, we provide an update on the understanding of drug-induced idiosyncratic agranulocytosis. Using important triggering drugs as examples, we will summarise and discuss the chemical, the biotransformation-related, the mechanistic and the therapeutic basis of this clinically relevant and undesirable side effect.

[Once upon a time the hepatotoxicity…]

The liver ensures a large part of xenobiotics metabolism thanks to its sizeable enzymatic equipment, its anatomical localization and its abundant vascularization. However, these various characteristics also make it a privileged target for toxic compounds, particularly in the case of a toxic metabolism. Xenobiotics-induced hepatotoxicity is a major cause of liver damage and a real challenge for clinicians, pharmaceutical industry, and health agencies. Intrinsic, i.e. predictable and reproducible hepatotoxicities occurring at threshold doses are distinguished from idiosyncratic hepatotoxicities, occurring in an unpredictable manner in people with individual susceptibilities. Among them, idiosyncratic immune-mediated hepatotoxicity pathophysiology is still unclear. However, the development of tools to improve the prediction and understanding of these disorders may open avenues to the identification of risk factors and new mechanisms of toxicity.

Sodium valproate induced acute pancreatitis in a bipolar disorder patient: a case report

Background

Sodium valproate is one of the most widely used antiepileptics and mood stabilizers. However, this drug may induce acute pancreatitis. Few cases have been reported so far, mainly on the pediatric patients who underwent antiepileptic treatment. Hereby, we present a case of bipolar disorder with sodium valproate-induced acute pancreatitis.

Case presentation

The patient is a 54-year-old Chinese male. He was diagnosed with bipolar disorder for more than 39 years. Since the first onset of the disease, he had several relapses. The patient had had sodium valproate to stabilize mood swings for a year before the occurrence of acute pancreatitis. But he did vomit once during the inpatient care period. Then he was referred to another hospital following a notably high level of amylase. The results of computed tomography demonstrated an increased pancreatic volume and swollen peripancreatic fat tissue. As a result, the patient was diagnosed with acute pancreatitis. Unlike other cases reported in literatures, the high amylase level did not revert to normal after the withdrawal of medications. The patient was discharged from hospital with a high level of amylase, and was placed under follow-up observations.

Conclusion

Acute pancreatitis is considered as one of the idiosyncratic adverse reactions to antiepileptic drugs. Previous reports were mainly on the pediatric patients with increased propensity to idiosyncratic drug effects, or the adult chronic renal failure patients with sodium valproate-induced pancreatitis due to the retention of intermediate metabolites in their bodies. In this study, even though our patient exhibited no high risk of developing pancreatitis, he was treated for drug-induced acute pancreatitis in three hospitals. As rare as drug-induced acute pancreatitis can be, it should not be overlooked, Moreover, the mechanism of how sodium valproate induces acute pancreatitis remains unknown. Therefore, physicians need to consider the medical history of patients before prescribing this medication.

Nontargeted Identification of Reactive Metabolite Protein Adducts

Metabolic bioactivation of many different chemicals results in the formation of highly reactive compounds (chemically reactive metabolites, CRMs) that can lead to toxicity via binding to macromolecular targets (e.g., proteins or DNA). There is a need to develop robust, rapid, and nontargeted analytical techniques to determine the identity of the protein targets of CRMs and their sites of modification. Here, we introduce a nontargeted methodology capable of determining both the identity of a CRM formed from an administered compound as well as the protein targets modified by the reactive metabolite in a single experiment without prior information. Acetaminophen (N-acetyl-p-aminophenol, APAP) and ¹³C₆-APAP were incubated with rat liver microsomes, which are known to bioactivate APAP to the reactive metabolite N-acetyl-p-benzoquinone imine (NAPQI). Global tryptic digestion followed by liquid chromatographic/mass spectrometric (LC/MS) analysis was used to locate "twin" ion peaks of peptides adducted by NAPQI and for shotgun proteomics via tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS). By the development of blended data analytics software called Xenophile, the identity of the amino acid residue that was adducted can be established, which eliminates the need for specific parametrization of protein database search algorithms. This combination of experimental design and data analysis software allows the identity of a CRM, the protein target, and the amino acid residues that are modified to be rapidly established directly from experimental data. Xenophile is freely available from https://github.com/mgleeming/Xenophile .

Gene Expression Analysis of Troglitazone Reveals Its Impact on Multiple Pathways in Cell Culture: A Case for In Vitro Platforms Combined with Gene Expression Analysis for Early (Idiosyncratic) Toxicity Screening

Peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor gamma (PPAR γ) agonists of the thiazolidinedione family are used for the treatment of type 2 diabetes mellitus due to their ability to reduce glucose and lipid levels in patients with this disease. Three thiazolidinediones that were approved for treatment are Rezulin (troglitazone), Avandia (rosiglitazone), and Actos (pioglitazone). Troglitazone was withdrawn from the market due to idiosyncratic drug toxicity. Rosiglitazone and pioglitazone are still on the market for the treatment of type 2 diabetes. The authors present data from a gene expression screen that compares the impact these three compounds have in rats, in rat hepatocytes, and in the clone 9 rat liver cell line. The authors monitored the changes in expression in multiple genes, including those related to xenobiotic metabolism, proliferation, DNA damage, oxidative stress, apoptosis, and inflammation. Compared to the other two compounds, troglitazone had a significant impact on many of the pathways monitored in vitro although no major perturbation was detected in vivo. The changes detected predict not only general toxicity but potential mechanisms of toxicity. Based on gene expression analysis, the authors propose there is not just one but multiple ways troglitazone could be toxic, depending on a patient’s environment and genetic makeup, including immune response-related toxicity.

Oral exposure to immunostimulating drugs results in early changes in innate immune parameters in the spleen

The development of immune-dependent drug hypersensitivity reactions (IDHR) is likely to involve activation of the innate immune system to stimulate neo-antigen specific T-cells. Previously it has been shown that, upon oral exposure to several drugs with immune-adjuvant capacity, mice developed T-cell-dependent responses to TNP-OVA. These results were indicative of the adjuvant potential of these drugs. The present study set out to evaluate the nature of this adjuvant potential by focusing on early immune changes in the spleen, by testing several drugs in the same experimental model. Mice were exposed to one or multiple oral doses of previously-tested drugs: the non-steroidal-anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID) diclofenac (DF), the analgesic acetaminophen (APAP), the anti-epileptic drug carbamazepine (CMZ) or the antibiotic ofloxacin (OFLX). Within 24 h after the final dosing, early innate and also adaptive immune parameters in the spleen were examined. In addition, liver tissue was also evaluated for damage. Exposure to APAP resulted in severe liver damage, increased levels of serum alanine aminotransferase (ALT) and local MIP-2 expression. DF exposure did not cause visible liver damage, but did increase liver weight. DF also elicited clear effects on splenic innate and adaptive immune cells, i.e. increased levels of NK cells and memory T-cells. Furthermore, an increase in plasma MIP-2 levels combined with an influx of neutrophils into the spleen was observed. OFLX and CMZ exposure resulted in increased liver weights, MIP-2 expression and up-regulation of co-stimulatory molecules on antigen-presenting cells (APC). The data suggested that multiple immune parameters were altered upon exposure to drugs known to elicit immunosensitization and that broad evaluation of immune changes in straightforward short-term animal models is needed to determine whether a drug may harbor the hazard to induce IDHR. The oral exposure approach as used here may be applied in the future as an immunotoxicological research tool in this type of evaluation.

The role of intrahepatic CD3+/CD4-/CD8- double negative T (DN T) cells in enhanced acetaminophen toxicity

The role of the immune system, specifically NK, NKT and CD3 cells, in acetaminophen (APAP) induced liver injury remains inconsistently defined. In the present study, wild type (C57BL/6J) mice and granzyme B deficient (GrB -/-) mice were treated with acetaminophen to assess the role of the immune system in acute liver injury. Doses of acetaminophen that induced sub lethal liver injury in wild type mice unexpectedly produced fatal hepatotoxicity in granzyme B deficient (GrB -/-) mice. Analysis revealed that GrB -/- mice had an increased population of intrahepatic CD3 (+), CD4 (-), and CD8 (-) lymphocytes expressing the CD69 activation marker and Fas ligand. Depletion of these cells in the GrB -/- and wild type mice made them less susceptible to APAP injury, while depletion of NK1.1 (+) cells or both CD4 (+) and CD8 (+) T cells failed to provide the same hepatoprotection. Transfer of the GrB -/- IHLs further exacerbated liver injury and increased mortality in wild type mice but not in LRP/LPR mice, lacking fas expression.

CONCLUSIONS

Acetaminophen toxicity is enhanced by the presence of activated, FasL expressing intrahepatic CD3 (+), CD4 (-), CD8 (-), NK1.1 (-) T cells. Depletion of these cells from GrB -/- mice and wild type mice greatly reduces mortality and improves the course of liver injury recovery.

The effect of 'allergenic' and 'nonallergenic' antibiotics on dog keratinocyte viability in vitro

BACKGROUND

Immune-mediated adverse drug reactions (drug hypersensitivity) are relatively common in veterinary medicine, but their pathogenesis is not well understood. For an unknown reason, delayed drug hypersensitivity often targets the skin. Antibiotics, especially β-lactams and sulfonamides, are commonly associated with these adverse events. The 'danger theory' hypothesizes that 'danger' signals, such as drug-induced cell death, might be part of the pathogenesis of drug hypersensitivity reactions.

HYPOTHESIS/OBJECTIVES

The goal of this study was to determine whether antibiotics that are commonly associated with cutaneous drug hypersensitivity (allergenic) decrease canine keratinocyte viability in vitro more than antibiotics that rarely cause such reactions (nonallergenic).

METHODS

Immortalized canine keratinocytes (CPEK cells) were exposed to a therapeutic range of drug concentrations of four 'allergenic' antibiotics (two β-lactams, i.e. amoxicillin and cefalexin, and two sulfonamides, i.e. sulfamethoxazole and sulfadimethoxine) or two 'nonallergenic' antibiotics (enrofloxacin and amikacin) over 48 h (2, 4, 8, 24 and 48 h). The reactive nitroso metabolite of sulfamethoxazole was also tested.

RESULTS

Cefalexin (2 mmol/L) significantly decreased cell viability after 48 h (28 ± 7%; P = 0.035). The nitroso metabolite of sulfamethoxazole (100 μmol/L) decreased cell viability after 2 h (21 ± 7%; P = 0.049), but cell numbers were increased after 8 h (22 ± 6%; P = 0.018). In addition, enrofloxacin (500 μmol/L) also significantly decreased cell viability by 37% (±6%; P = 0.0035) at 24 h and by 70% (±8%; P < 0.001) at 48 h.

CONCLUSION

It appears that the effect of drugs on the in vitro viability of dog keratinocytes is not a good predictor of the 'allergenic' potential of an antibiotic. Further work is required to investigate other drug-induced 'danger' signals in dog keratinocytes exposed to 'allergenic' antibiotics in vitro.

Drug hypersensitivity reactions targeting the skin in dogs and cats

Adverse drug reactions (ADRs) can be dose dependent or idiosyncratic. Most idiosyncratic reactions are believed to be immune-mediated; such drug hypersensitivities and allergies are unpredictable. Cutaneous reactions are the most common presentation of drug allergies. In veterinary medicine it can be difficult to assess the true prevalence of adverse drug reactions, although reports available suggest that they occur quite commonly. There are multiple theories that attempt to explain how drug allergies occur, because the pathogenesis is not yet well understood. These include the (pro)-hapten hypothesis, the Danger Theory, the pi concept, and the viral reactivation theory. Cutaneous drug allergies in veterinary medicine can have a variety of clinical manifestations, ranging from pruritus to often fatal toxic epidermal necrolysis. Diagnosis can be challenging, as the reactions are highly pleomorphic and may be mistaken for other dermatologic diseases. One must rely heavily on history and physical examination to rule out other possibilities. Dechallenge of the drug, histopathology, and other diagnostic tests can help to confirm the diagnosis. New diagnostic tools are beginning to be used, such as antibody or cellular testing, and may be used more in the future. There is much yet to learn about drug allergies, which makes future research vitally important. Treatment of drug allergies involves supportive care, and additional treatments, such as immunosuppressive medications, depend on the manifestation of the disease. Of utmost importance is to avoid the use of the incriminating drug in future treatment of the patient, as subsequent reactions can be worse, and ultimately can prove fatal.

In vitro evaluation of the potential for drug-induced toxicity based on 35S-labeled glutathione adduct formation and daily dose

Background: Drug-induced toxicity such as idiosyncratic drug toxicity is believed to be reduced when either reactive metabolite formation or exposure to a drug is minimized. The objective of the present study was therefore to clarify the relationship between the daily doses, the formation rates of reactive metabolite adduct with 35S-glutathione (RM–GS) and the safety profiles of compounds. Results: The RM–GS formation rates for 113 test compounds were determined by incubation with human liver microsomes, and the test compounds were classified into three categories of safe, warning and withdrawn/black box warning. A total of 23 out of 28 withdrawn/black box warning drugs showed both a RM–GS formation rate of over 1 pmol/30 min/mg protein and a dose of over 100 mg. Conclusion: These results suggest that when compounds are plotted in this region, the compounds would have a relatively high idiosyncratic drug toxicity potential.

Role of dendritic cells in drug allergy

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Immune reactions to drugs can cause a variety of diseases involving organs such as the skin, liver, kidney, and lung. Although the role of T cells in hypersensitivity reactions to drugs (HDRs) have been demonstrated by several studies, little is known about the role of the innate immune system, served mainly by dendritic cells, in the hypersensitivity response.

RECENT FINDINGS

Our knowledge about the mechanisms of HDRs is very superficial, and the hypotheses for the involvement of reactive metabolites in many cases are circumstantial and with no evidence. It is not clear which group of HDRs is due to reactive metabolites, nor is it clear the mechanisms by which reactive metabolites can cause allergic reactions. Several studies support the hypothesis that drugs interact differently with dendritic cells from drug-allergic and nonallergic patients, modifying their maturation level. Dendritic cells are also able to metabolize drugs and to present their metabolites to T lymphocytes eliciting a hypersensitivity response. All these findings show that the innate immune system and mainly dendritic cells might play a critical role in drug allergy.

SUMMARY

The interaction of drugs with dendritic cells is an emerging area of research which can bring new insights in order to have a better understanding about the physiopathology of HDRs.

Involvement of the immune system in idiosyncratic drug reactions

There is strong evidence that most idiosyncratic drug reactions (IDRs) are immune-mediated and are caused by reactive metabolites of a drug rather than by the drug itself. Several hypotheses have been proposed by which a drug could induce an immune response. The major hypotheses are the hapten hypothesis and the danger hypothesis; however, the characteristics and spectrum of IDRs are different with different drugs, and this likely reflects mechanistic differences; therefore, no one hypothesis is likely to explain all IDRs. Some IDRs appear to involve epigenetic effects, direct activation of antigen-presenting cells, or disturbing the normal balance of the immune system. It has been suggested that many cases of idiosyncratic liver injury are not immune-mediated, and other mechanisms such as mitochondrial injury may be involved. It is essential that any hypothesis be consistent with the clinical characteristics of the IDR. Although the characteristics of most idiosyncratic liver injury do not suggest that mitochondria are the major target, it is quite possible that milder mitochondrial injury could stimulate an immune-mediated reaction. The observation that IDRs can vary widely among different drugs and different patients is most easily explained by an immune mechanism in which the target of the immune response is different.

Pharmacogenetics of drug-induced liver injury

Recent progress in research on drug-induced liver injury (DILI) has been determined by key developments in two areas. First, new technologies allow the identification of genetic risk factors with improved sensitivity, specificity, and efficiency. Second, new mechanistic concepts of DILI emphasize the importance of unspecific "downstream" events following drug-specific initial "upstream" hepatocyte injury and of complex interactions between environmental and genetic risk factors. The integration of genetic and mechanistic concepts is essential for current research approaches, and genetic studies of DILI now focus on targets that affect the function and transcriptional regulation of genes relating not only to drug metabolism but also to human leukocyte antigens (HLAs), cytokines, oxidative stress, and hepatobiliary transporters. Risk factors affecting unspecific downstream mechanisms may be identified using pooled DILI cases caused by various drugs. The power to detect variants that confer a low risk can be increased by recruitment of strictly selected cases through large networks, whereas controls may also be obtained from genotyped reference populations. The first genomewide studies of DILI identified HLA variants as risk factors for hepatotoxicity associated with flucloxacillin and ximelagatran, and their design has defined a new standard for pharmacogenetic studies. From a clinical and regulatory point of view, there is a need for genetic tests that identify patients at increased hepatotoxic risk. However, DILI is a rare complex disease, and pharmacogenetic studies have so far not been able to identify interactions of several risk factors defining a high population-attributable risk and clinically relevant absolute risk for DILI.

Idiosyncratic drug-induced liver injury and the role of inflammatory stress with an emphasis on an animal model of trovafloxacin hepatotoxicity

Idiosyncratic adverse drug reactions (IADRs) occur in a minority of patients yet account for the majority of postmarketing use restrictions by the Food and Drug Administration. Despite the impact of these toxicities, the underlying mechanisms are still poorly understood. Animal models of IADRs would be beneficial in understanding mechanisms and in developing assays with predictive potential. Recent work exploring the interactions between inflammatory stress and drugs associated with human idiosyncratic drug-induced liver injury (IDILI) has led to the development of the first animal models that apply to a range of drugs. Here, we discuss hypotheses for the mechanisms of IDILI and focus on a murine model of trovafloxacin-induced hepatotoxicity as an example related to the inflammatory stress hypothesis.

Immune mediation of hypersensitivity adverse drug reactions: implications for therapy

Adverse drug reactions are among the top causes of death in the developed world, and among the spectrum of adverse drug reactions, drug hypersensitivity is a principal contributor to serious adverse drug events. The pathophysiology of drug hypersensitivity remains incompletely understood, but seems to involve the initial recognition of a drug or metabolite by the immune system followed by an immune response that determines the clinical manifestations. At present, there are two competing theories for how immune recognition occurs: the Hapten Hypothesis in which drug hapten-carrier association is the key driver for immune recognition and the Pharmacological Interference Concept that postulates direct recognition of drugs by low affinity association with the T cell receptor. The Danger Hypothesis provides a potentially important addition to the Hapten Hypothesis. Therapy for drug hypersensitivity has traditionally involved excellent supportive care. Although corticosteroids and intravenous immunoglobulin have both been used as immunomodulatory therapy, there is no robust evidence supporting the efficacy of their therapy for drug hypersensitivity. Recent advances in molecular biology and genomic pharmacology offer previously unappreciated opportunities to clarify the controversies surrounding drug hypersensitivity and to better diagnose, treat and, it is hoped, prevent drug hypersensitivity in the future.

Inflammatory stress and idiosyncratic hepatotoxicity: hints from animal models

Adverse drug reactions (ADRs) present a serious human health problem. They are major contributors to hospitalization and mortality throughout the world (Lazarou et al., 1998; Pirmohamed et al., 2004). A small fraction (less than 5%) of ADRs can be classified as "idiosyncratic." Idiosyncratic ADRs (IADRs) are caused by drugs with diverse pharmacological effects and occur at various times during drug therapy. Although IADRs affect a number of organs, liver toxicity occurs frequently and is the primary focus of this review. Because of the inconsistency of clinical data and the lack of experimental animal models, how IADRs arise is largely undefined. Generation of toxic drug metabolites and induction of specific immunity are frequently cited as causes of IADRs, but definitive evidence supporting either mechanism is lacking for most drugs. Among the more recent hypotheses for causation of IADRs is that inflammatory stress induced by exogenous or endogenous inflammagens is a susceptibility factor. In this review, we give a brief overview of idiosyncratic hepatotoxicity and the inflammatory response induced by bacterial lipopolysaccharide. We discuss the inflammatory stress hypothesis and use as examples two drugs that have caused IADRs in human patients: ranitidine and diclofenac. The review focuses on experimental animal models that support the inflammatory stress hypothesis and on the mechanisms of hepatotoxic response in these models. The need for design of epidemiological studies and the potential for implementation of inflammation interaction studies in preclinical toxicity screening are also discussed briefly.

Signal transduction pathways involved in drug-induced liver injury

Hepatocyte death following drug intake is the critical event in the clinical manifestation of drug-induced liver injury (DILI). Traditionally, hepatocyte death caused by drugs had been attributed to overwhelming oxidative stress and mitochondria dysfunction caused by reactive metabolites formed during drug metabolism. However, recent studies have also shown that signal transduction pathways activated/inhibited during oxidative stress play a key role in DILI. In acetaminophen (APAP)-induced liver injury, hepatocyte death requires the sustained activation of c-Jun kinase (JNK), a kinase important in mediating apoptotic and necrotic death. Inhibition of JNK using chemical inhibitors or knocking down JNK can prevent hepatocyte death even in the presence of extensive glutathione (GSH) depletion, covalent binding, and oxidative stress. Once activated, JNK translocates to mitochondria, to induce mitochondria permeability transition and trigger hepatocyte death. Mitochondria are central targets where prodeath kinases such as JNK, prosurvival death proteins such as bcl-xl, and oxidative damage converge to determine hepatocyte survival. The importance of mitochondria in DILI is also observed in the Mn-SOD heterozygous (+/-) model, where mice with less mitochondrial Mn-SOD are sensitized to liver injury caused by certain drugs. An extensive body of research is accumulating suggesting a central role of mitochondria in DILI. Drugs can also cause redox changes that inhibit important prosurvival pathways such as NF-kappaB. The inhibition of NF-kappaB by subtoxic doses of APAP sensitizes hepatocyte to the cytotoxic actions of tumor necrosis factor (TNF). Many drugs will induce liver injury if simultaneously treated with LPS, which promotes inflammation and cytokine release. Drugs may be sensitizing hepatocytes to the cytotoxic effects of cytokines such as TNF, or vice versa. Overall many signaling pathways are important in regulating DILI, and represent potential therapeutic targets to reduce liver injury caused by drugs.

The danger hypothesis applied to idiosyncratic drug reactions

The danger hypothesis has had a profound effect on the way immunologists view the immune response. This hypothesis proposes that the major determinant of whether an immune response is mounted against some agent is determined by whether that agent causes some type of cell damage. Assuming that most idiosyncratic drug reactions (IDRs) are immune-mediated, this hypothesis also has the potential to explain many aspects of the mechanism of these adverse drug reactions. For example, most IDRs appear to be caused by chemical metabolites rather than the parent drug, but not all drugs that form reactive metabolites are associated with a significant incidence of IDRs. Therefore, using the danger hypothesis, one feature of a drug candidate that may predict whether it causes an IDR is whether the drug, or more likely its reactive metabolites, cause cell damage. Although the range of molecules that can act as danger signals is unknown, the most attractive candidates are high mobility group box 1 protein (HMGB1), heat shock proteins, and S100 proteins. These molecules act through the same receptors (toll-like receptors) as pathogen-associated molecules that stimulate the immune system. Therefore, other environmental factors such as infections or trauma might determine which patients would be at increased risk for IDRs. Although there are examples where this appears to be the case, in most cases there are no obvious environmental factors that determine IDR risk. In addition, in animal models of immune-mediated reactions, stimulation of toll-like receptors often does not increase the immune response, and depending on the timing, it can actually be protective. Therefore, there may be additional unknown control mechanisms that are involved. A better understanding of these fundamental immune mechanisms has the potential to have a significant impact on many areas of medicine.

Susceptibility to acetaminophen (APAP) toxicity unexpectedly is decreased during acute viral hepatitis in mice

Acetaminophen (APAP) hepatotoxicity results from cytochrome P450 metabolism of APAP to the toxic metabolite, n-acetyl-benzoquinone imine (NAPQI), which reacts with cysteinyl residues to form APAP adducts and initiates cell injury. As APAP is commonly used during viral illnesses there has been concern that APAP injury may be additive to that of viral hepatitis, leading physicians to advise against its use in such patients; this has not been investigated experimentally. We infected C57BL/6 male mice with replication-deficient adenovirus to produce moderately severe acute viral hepatitis and observed that APAP doses that were hepatotoxic or lethal in control mice produced neither death nor additional increase in serum ALT when administered to infected mice at the peak of virus-induced liver injury. Moreover, the concentration of hepatic APAP-protein adducts formed in these mice was only 10% that in control mice. Protection from APAP hepatotoxicity also was observed earlier in the course of infection, prior to the peak virus-induced ALT rise. Hepatic glutathione limits APAP-protein adduct formation but glutathione levels were similar in control and infected mice. Cyp1a2 (E.C. 1.14.14.1) and Cyp2e1 (E.C. 1.14.13.n7) mRNA expression decreased by 3 days post-infection and hepatic Cyp2e1 protein levels were reduced almost 90% at 7 days, when adduct formation was maximally inhibited. In vitro, hepatocytes from virally infected mice also were resistant to APAP-induced injury but sensitive to NAPQI. Rather than potentiating APAP-induced liver injury, acute viral hepatitis in this model resulted in selective down-regulation of APAP metabolizing P450s in liver and decreased the risk of APAP hepatotoxicity.

Drug-induced liver injury: insights from genetic studies

Drug-induced liver injury (DILI) is an increasing health problem and a challenge for physicians, regulatory bodies and the pharmaceutical industry, not only because of its potential severity and elusive pathogenesis but also because it is often inaccurately diagnosed, commonly missed entirely and more often not reported. The general view is that idiosyncratic DILI, which is not predictable whether based on the pharmacology of the drug or on the dose administered, is determined by the presence in the recipient of variants in, or expression of, genes coding for key metabolic pathways and/or the immune response, and the interaction of these genetic variants with environmental variables. Furthermore, idiosyncratic DILI is an example of a complex-trait disease with two or more susceptibility loci, as reflected by the frequency of genetic variants in the population often being higher than the occurrence of significant liver injury. Polymorphisms of bioactivation/toxification pathways via the CYP450 enzymes (Phase I), detoxification reactions (Phase II) and excretion/transport (Phase III), together with immunological factors that might determine DILI are reviewed. Challenges such as gene-trait association studies and whole-genome studies, and future approaches to the study of DILI are explored. Better knowledge of the candidate genes involved could provide further insight for the prospective identification of susceptible patients at risk of developing drug-induced hepatotoxicity, development of new diagnostic tools and new treatment strategies with safer drugs.

Current concepts of mechanisms in drug-induced hepatotoxicity

Drug-induced liver injury (DILI) has become a leading cause of severe liver disease in Western countries and therefore poses a major clinical and regulatory challenge. Whereas previously drug-specific pathways leading to initial injury of liver cells were the main focus of mechanistic research and classifications, current concepts see these as initial upstream events and appreciate that subsequent common downstream pathways and their attenuation by drugs and other environmental and genetic factors also have a profound impact on the risk of an individual patient to develop overt liver disease. This review summarizes current mechanistic concepts of DILI in a 3-step model that limits its principle mechanisms to three main ways of initial injury, i.e. direct cell stress, direct mitochondrial impairment, and specific immune reactions. Subsequently, initial injury initiates further downstream events, i.e. direct and death receptor-mediated pathways leading to mitochondrial permeability transition, which then results in apoptotic or necrotic cell death. For all mechanisms, mitochondria play a central role in events leading to apoptotic vs. necrotic cell death. New treatment targets consequently focus on interference with downstream pathways that mediate injury and therefore determine the ultimate outcome of DILI. Genome wide and targeted pharmacogenetic as well as metabonomic approaches are now used in order to reach the key goals of a better understanding of mechanisms in hepatotoxicity, and to develop new strategies for its prediction and treatment. However, the complexity of interactions between genetic and environmental risk factors is considerable, and DILI therefore currently remains unpredictable for most hepatotoxins.

Immune-mediated adverse drug reactions

Many adverse drug reactions are mediated by the immune system. This can be because the therapeutic effect of the drug targets the immune system. For example, immunosuppressive drugs increase the risk of infections. It is paradoxical that some immunosuppressive drugs can lead to autoimmune reactions. Another mechanism by which drugs can cause an adverse reaction involves an idiosyncratic response to the drug such as an immune-mediated skin rash. These idiosyncratic drug reactions (IDRs) are difficult to study because of the paucity of valid animal models and their unpredictable nature. Therefore, much of our mechanistic knowledge of IDRs is based on inferences from the clinical characteristics of IDRs rather than on controlled mechanistic studies. In general, IDRs are associated with a delay between starting the drug and the onset of the adverse reaction, and the typical delay is different for different types of IDRs. In contrast, on rechallenge, there is usually a rapid onset of the adverse reaction, which is characteristic of an amnestic immune response. The absence of such a rapid response is usually considered evidence that an IDR is not immune-mediated; yet, there are immune-mediated IDRs that do not have an amnestic response. One possible reason for the lack of an amnestic response is if the IDR has a strong autoimmune component leading to deletion of autoimmune memory cells when the drug is withdrawn. Another interesting characteristic of IDRs is that there are many drugs that can cause different types of IDRs in different patients. A possible explanation is that although the immune response is induced by a drug, it is directed against an autoantigen, and interindividual differences in the immune repertoire determine which autoantigen and target organ are affected. Although testing these hypotheses represents a difficult challenge, the importance of these adverse reactions makes it a high priority.

Toxicological Significance of Mechanism-Based Inactivation of Cytochrome P450 Enzymes by Drugs

Cytochrome P450 (P450) enzymes oxidize xenobiotics into chemically reactive metabolites or intermediates as well as into stable metabolites. If the reactivity of the product is very high, it binds to a catalytic site or sites of the enzyme itself and inactivates it. This phenomenon is referred to as mechanism-based inactivation. Many clinically important drugs are mechanism-based inactivators that include macrolide antibiotics, calcium channel blockers, and selective serotonin uptake inhibitors, but are not always structurally and pharmacologically related. The inactivation of P450s during drug therapy results in serious drug interactions, since irreversibility of the binding allows enzyme inhibition to be prolonged after elimination of the causal drug. The inhibition of the metabolism of drugs with narrow therapeutic indexes, such as terfenadine and astemizole, leads to toxicities. On the other hand, the fate of P450s after the inactivation and the toxicological consequences remains to be elucidated, while it has been suggested that P450s modified and degraded are involved in some forms of tissue toxicity. Porphyrinogenic drugs, such as griseofulvin, cause mechanism-based heme inactivation, leading to formation of ferrochelatase-inhibitory N-alkylated protoporphyrins and resulting in porphyria. Involvement of P450-derived free heme in halothane-induced hepatotoxicity and catalytic iron in cisplatin-induced nephrotoxicity has also been suggested. Autoantibodies against P450s have been found in hepatitis following administration of tienilic acid and dihydralazine. Tienilic acid is activated by and covalently bound to CYP2C9, and the neoantigens thus formed activate immune systems, resulting in the formation of an autoantibodydirected against CYP2C9, named anti-liver/kidney microsomal autoantibody type 2, whereas the pathological role of the autoantibodies in drug-induced hepatitis remains largely unknown.

Evaluation of Which Reactive Metabolite, If Any, Is Responsible for a Specific Idiosyncratic Reaction

Reactive metabolites are believed to be responsible for most idiosyncratic drug reactions. It is often assumed that if a reactive metabolite is found, it must be responsible for the idiosyncratic reactions associated with that drug. However, the evidence linking reactive metabolites and idiosyncratic reactions is circumstantial at best, and in many cases we have virtually no evidence. Furthermore, it is common for a drug to form several reactive metabolites, so it can be difficult to determine which, if any, is responsible for a given idiosyncratic reaction. Although the reactive metabolite hypothesis is logical, it has important implications for drug development, and we need to develop ways to test the hypothesis for specific drugs rigorously. Valid animal models are a powerful tool for testing whether a specific reactive metabolite is responsible for a specific adverse reaction and for studying further the mechanism by which it may induce such reactions; however, such models are rare.

Idiosyncratic drug reactions: past, present, and future

Although the major working hypothesis for the mechanism of idiosyncratic drug reactions (IDRs), the hapten hypothesis, has not changed since 1987, several hypotheses have been added, for example, the danger hypothesis and the pharmaceutical interaction hypothesis. Genetic studies have found that several IDRs are linked to specific HLA genes, providing additional evidence that they are immune-mediated. Evidence that most IDRs are caused by reactive metabolites has led pharmaceutical companies to avoid drug candidates that form significant amounts of reactive metabolites; however, at least one IDR, ximelagatran-induced liver toxicity, does not appear to be caused by a reactive metabolite. It is possible that there are biomarkers such as those related to cell stress that would predict that a drug candidate would cause a significant incidence of IDRs; however, there has been no systematic study of the changes in gene expression induced by drugs known to cause IDRs. A major impediment to the study of the mechanisms of IDRs is the paucity of valid animal models, and if we had a better mechanistic understanding, it should be easier to develop such models. There is growing evidence that these adverse reactions are more varied and complex than previously recognized, and it is unlikely that a quick fix will be achieved. However, IDRs are an important cause of patient morbidity and mortality and markedly increase the uncertainty of drug development; therefore, continued basic research in this area is essential.

Anti-myeloperoxidase and anti-cathepsin G antibodies in sulphonamide hypersensitivity

BACKGROUND

Anti-neutrophil cytoplasmic antibodies (ANCA) are associated with vasculitis in humans. Sulphonamide antimicrobials cause drug hypersensitivity (HS) reactions with some clinical signs that are suggestive of vasculitis.

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to determine whether sulphonamide HS is associated with anti-neutrophil antibodies, using the dog as a spontaneous clinical model.

METHODS

Thirty-four sulphonamide-HS dogs, 11 sulphonamide-'tolerant' dogs, and nine healthy sulphonamide-naïve dogs were evaluated for anti-neutrophil antibodies using a commercial ELISA against human myeloperoxidase (MPO), a commercial human ANCA Western blot protocol, and immunoblotting against whole canine neutrophils.

RESULTS

Using ELISA, anti-MPO antibodies were found with an apparent higher frequency in HS dogs (50%), compared with 'tolerant' dogs (18%), which also showed significantly lower absorbances. Among HS dogs, anti-MPO antibodies were significantly more common, with significantly higher absorbances, in dogs that did not survive the HS reaction (78%) compared with survivors (35%). Using immunoblotting, ANCA were detected with similar overall frequencies in HS and 'tolerant' dogs. However, one protein targeted by several HS dogs, but no 'tolerant' dogs, was identified as cathepsin G.

CONCLUSION

These data indicate that anti-MPO antibodies and anti-cathepsin G antibodies are associated with sulphonamide HS. Anti-MPO antibodies have been shown to be pathogenic both in vitro and in vivo, leading to vasculitis lesions and vasculitis-like syndromes. The present study therefore suggests that vasculitis might be one mechanism of tissue damage in this sulphonamide HS. Furthermore, the evaluation of ANCA, and its relationship to disease severity and clinical outcome, should be considered in human patients with sulphonamide drug HS.

Comparison of the cytotoxicity of the nitroaromatic drug flutamide to its cyano analogue in the hepatocyte cell line TAMH: evidence for complex I inhibition and mitochondrial dysfunction using toxicogenomic screening

Flutamide (FLU) is an antiandrogen primarily used in the treatment of metastatic prostate cancer. It is an idiosyncratic hepatotoxicant that sometimes results in severe liver toxicity. FLU possesses a nitroaromatic group, which may be a contributor to its mechanism of toxicity. A nitro to cyano analogue of FLU (CYA) was synthesized and used to test this hypothesis in the TGFalpha-transfected mouse hepatocyte cell line (TAMH). MTT cell viability assays and confocal microscopy showed that hepatocytes are more sensitive to cytotoxicity caused by FLU than CYA (LD 50 75 vs 150 microM, respectively). Despite the structural modification, the antiandrogen activity of CYA is comparable to that of FLU. Comparisons of transcriptomic changes caused by FLU with those caused by a panel of known cytotoxicants [acetaminophen, tetrafluoroethylcysteine, diquat, and rotenone (ROT)] indicated that FLU results in a temporal gene expression pattern similar to ROT, a known inhibitor of complex I of the electron transport chain. A subsequent microarray analysis comparing FLU to CYA and ROT revealed many similarities among these three compounds; however, FLU and ROT result in more substantial changes than CYA in the expression of genes associated with oxidative phosphorylation, fatty acid beta-oxidation, antioxidant defense, and cell death pathways. Electron microscopy confirmed that FLU leads to mitochondrial toxicity that has some similarities to the mitochondrial effects of ROT, but the morphologic changes caused by FLU were greater in scope with both intra- and intercellular manifestations. Biochemical studies confirmed that both ROT and FLU deplete cellular ATP levels and inhibit complex I of the electron transport chain to a greater extent than CYA. Thus, as compared to CYA, the nitroaromatic group of FLU enhances cytotoxicity to hepatocytes, likely through mechanisms involving mitochondrial dysfunction and ATP depletion that include complex I inhibition.

Sulfamethoxazole and its metabolite nitroso sulfamethoxazole stimulate dendritic cell costimulatory signaling

Different signals in addition to the antigenic signal are required to initiate an immunological reaction. In the context of sulfamethoxazole allergy, the Ag is thought to be derived from its toxic nitroso metabolite, but little is known about the costimulatory signals, including those associated with dendritic cell maturation. In this study, we demonstrate increased CD40 expression, but not CD80, CD83, or CD86, with dendritic cell surfaces exposed to sulfamethoxazole (250-500 microM) and the protein-reactive metabolite nitroso sulfamethoxazole (1-10 microM). Increased CD40 expression was not associated with apoptosis or necrosis, or glutathione depletion. Covalently modified intracellular proteins were detected when sulfamethoxazole was incubated with dendritic cells. Importantly, the enzyme inhibitor 1-aminobenzotriazole prevented the increase in CD40 expression with sulfamethoxazole, but not with nitroso sulfamethoxazole or LPS. The enzymes CYP2C9, CYP2C8, and myeloperoxidase catalyzed the conversion of sulfamethoxazole to sulfamethoxazole hydroxylamine. Myeloperoxidase was expressed at high levels in dendritic cells. Nitroso sulfamethoxazole immunogenicity was inhibited in mice with a blocking anti-CD40L Ab. In addition, when a primary nitroso sulfamethoxazole-specific T cell response using drug-naive human cells was generated, the magnitude of the response was enhanced when cultures were exposed to a stimulatory anti-CD40 Ab. Finally, increased CD40 expression was 5-fold higher on nitroso sulfamethoxazole-treated dendritic cells from an HIV-positive allergic patient compared with volunteers. These data provide evidence of a link between localized metabolism, dendritic cell activation, and drug immunogenicity.

Idiosyncratic drug reactions: current understanding

Clinical characteristics and circumstantial evidence suggest that idiosyncratic drug reactions are caused by reactive metabolites and are immune-mediated; however, there are few definitive data and there are likely exceptions. There are three principal hypotheses for how reactive metabolites might induce an immune-mediated idiosyncratic reaction: the hapten hypothesis, the danger hypothesis, and the PI hypothesis. It has been proposed that some idiosyncratic reactions, especially those involving the liver, represent metabolic idiosyncrasy; however, there are even less data to support this hypothesis. The unpredictable nature of these reactions makes mechanistic studies difficult. There is a very strong association with specific human leukocyte antigen (HLA) genes for certain reactions, but this has only been demonstrated for very few drugs. Animal models represent a very powerful tool for mechanistic studies, but the number of valid models is also limited. There may be biomarkers of risk; however, much more work needs to be done.

Idiosyncratic adverse reactions to antiepileptic drugs

Idiosyncratic drug reactions may be defined as adverse effects that cannot be explained by the known mechanisms of action of the offending agent, do not occur at any dose in most patients, and develop mostly unpredictably in susceptible individuals only. These reactions are generally thought to account for up to 10% of all adverse drug reactions, but their frequency may be higher depending on the definition adopted. Idiosyncratic reactions are a major source of concern because they encompass most life-threatening effects of antiepileptic drugs (AEDs), as well as many other reactions requiring discontinuation of treatment. Based on the underlying mechanisms, idiosyncratic reactions can be differentiated into (1) immune-mediated hypersensitivity reactions, which may range from benign skin rashes to serious conditions such as drug-related rash with eosinophilia and systemic symptoms; (2) reactions involving unusual nonimmune-mediated individual susceptibility, often related to abnormal production or defective detoxification of reactive cytotoxic metabolites (as in valproate-induced liver toxicity); and (3) off-target pharmacology, whereby a drug interacts directly with a system other than that for which it is intended, an example being some types of AED-induced dyskinesias. Although no AED is free from the potential of inducing idiosyncratic reactions, the magnitude of risk and the most common manifestations vary from one drug to another, a consideration that impacts on treatment choices. Serious consequences of idiosyncratic reactions can be minimized by knowledge of risk factors, avoidance of specific AEDs in subpopulations at risk, cautious dose titration, and careful monitoring of clinical response.

Reacciones de hipersensibilidad a antirretrovirales en pacientes con infección por el virus de la inmunodeficiencia humana

Drug hypersensitivity reactions in the HIV-positive patient are a major problem in management of these patients and, nowadays the antiretroviral agents are the main cause of those reactions, exceeding cotrimoxazole. The present review focuses on immunologic reactions that have been reported associated with antiretroviral agents. We have reviewed case reports on Medline(R) to September 2005. Evidence that these reactions are immune mediated is largely based on the typical symptomatology and few studies have been done to determine the pathogenesis mechanisms. The clinical management of this type of reactions is complex because of differential diagnosis and of potential severity. It is essential that research is now carried out into the pathogenic mechanisms and so, we shall be able to offer an efficacious protocol to manage these situations.

Structure-Activity Relationship and Elucidation of the Determinant Factor(s) Responsible for the Mechanism-Based Inactivation of Cytochrome P450 2B6 by Substituted Phenyl Diaziridines

It has been demonstrated previously that several 3-trifluoromethyl-3-(4-alkoxyphenyl)diaziridines inhibit the 7-ethoxy-4-(trifluoroethyl)coumarin (7-EFC) O-deethylation activity of P450 2B6 in a mechanism-based manner. In contrast, 3-trifluoromethyl-3-(4-methylthio)phenyl)diaziridine did not have any effect on the activity of P450 2B6. It is interesting that both the alkoxy and the thiophenyl compounds were metabolized by P450 2B6. In this report, the structure-activity relationships for the mechanism-based inactivation of cytochrome P450 2B6 by a series of aryl diaziridines were investigated. Three diaziridines that did not contain a 4-alkoxy-substituent on their phenyl ring, namely, 3-trifluoromethyl-3-(3-methoxyphenyl)diaziridine, 3-trifluoromethyl-3-phenyl diaziridine, and 3-trifluoromethyl-3-(4-chlorophenyl)diaziridine had no effect on the P450 2B6 7-EFC activity. Another analog that did not contain a diaziridine substructure, 3-trifluoromethyl-3-(4-methoxyphenyl)ethanone, also had no effect on the activity of P450 2B6. Glutathione ethyl ester adducts of the phenyldiaziridine reactive intermediates were isolated from reaction mixtures of the inactivated samples and analyzed by liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry. The structures of the conjugates suggested that the electrophilic reactive intermediate in each case was a quinone methide (quinomethane), 4-ethylidene-cyclohexa-2,5-dienone, generated from the 4-alkoxyphenyldiaziridines by removal of both of the diaziridine and the 4-alkyl groups. In conclusion, the determinant factor for the mechanism-based inactivator activity of the aryl diaziridines seems to be the formation of the reactive quinomethane intermediate, which is generated from the 4-alkoxyphenyl diaziridines by a cytochrome P450-catalyzed metabolic reaction.

Allergic hepatitis induced by drugs

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

To examine recent advances in our understanding of how drugs can trigger a hypersensitivity reaction in the liver, how tolerance is lost, the mechanisms of damage to hepatocytes and the strategies towards a better assessment of an idiosyncratic drug liver reaction.

RECENT FINDINGS

Formation and presentation of drug-protein adducts, or a direct interaction with the major histocompatibility complex/T-cell receptor complex is a necessary but not sufficient stimulus to trigger a hypersensitivity reaction. Liver shows considerable tolerogenic potential towards drug adducts. Recent studies highlight allergic hepatitis as a loss of liver tolerance towards drug antigens, the mechanisms of which are beginning to be unravelled. Cell injury caused by the drug itself, a concomitant inflammatory process, or a coincidental stimulus probably represents the additional signal needed to initiate the allergic process.

SUMMARY

Drug-induced liver injury is of concern due to its unpredictable nature and serious clinical implications. Clinically, both hepatocellular injury and cholestasis can occur and most episodes have good clinical prognoses upon drug discontinuation. In a few cases, damage to the liver cells may continue in the form of an autoimmune hepatitis. The available diagnostic tools to confirm an immune-mediated hepatic injury are still very limited, and rely on the lymphocyte transformation test.