Discussing Benefits and Risks of Tracheostomy: What Physicians Actually Say

Candidacy Decisions for Long-term Ventilation

Decisions to initiate long-term ventilation (LTV) in children with severe neurologic impairment have recently been subject to candidacy determinations by home ventilation teams that exclude patients based on their neurologic status alone. Determinations of whether decisions are inappropriate require careful analysis of specific clinical circumstances and attention to the family's values. In this Ethics Rounds, we present a case of a previously healthy child who sustained an acute severe anoxic brain injury and was assessed by the medical team to have a high likelihood of remaining minimally conscious or unconscious. It was determined that he was not a candidate for LTV based on the severity of neurologic impairment. The family disagreed and declined withdrawal of ventilatory support. Drawing upon our backgrounds in intensive care, pulmonology, and bioethics, we offer commentary on utilizing a candidacy-based approach for LTV decisions in children with severe neurologic impairment from variable perspectives, including clinical determinations of inappropriate care, ablest biases and discrimination, and obligations to maintain a just process.

Tracheostomy Decision Making and Counseling: Comparing Providers' and Caregivers' Perspectives and Perceptions

Background: The decision to place a tracheostomy in children is complex and involves factors beyond the medical procedure, including quality of life, values, and goals. Providers play an important role in counseling caregivers and guiding them through the decision-making process. There are no established guidelines for tracheostomy counseling, leading to variations in practice. Additionally, how caregivers receive information differs from how providers believe they deliver it. Although studies have explored caregivers' and providers' viewpoints, none have examined them concurrently. Background: The primary aim of this exploratory study is to investigate differences between providers' and caregivers' perceptions of tracheostomy counseling and their perspectives regarding the decision-making process. Design: Semi-structured interviews were conducted with both caregivers and providers for children being evaluated for a tracheostomy. Qualitative analysis was applied to the interview transcripts to identify emergent themes. Subsequently, a comparative analysis was performed to compare these themes between caregivers and healthcare providers. Results: A total of 33 interviews were conducted, involving 16 caregivers and 17 providers. Notably, caregivers provided personal descriptions of their children in 81% of cases, whereas only 35% of providers did so. Concerns and fears for the children were expressed by 69% of caregivers and 59% of providers. In contrast, 75% of caregivers discussed their hopes and dreams for their children, compared with only 29% of providers. When it came to priorities, 69% of caregivers emphasized growth and development, and 38% mentioned discharge home, as opposed to 29% and 47% among providers, respectively. Conclusion: In conclusion, our study highlights a disconnect between caregivers and healthcare providers regarding tracheostomy counseling. These differing perspectives underscore the need for improved communication and understanding between the two groups. Recognizing these differences can help providers tailor their counseling approaches to better align with the values and priorities of families when making decisions about tracheostomy.

Evaluating caregiver-clinician communication for tracheostomy placement in the neonatal intensive care unit: a qualitative inquiry

OBJECTIVE

Identify stakeholders' tracheostomy decision-making information priorities in the Neonatal Intensive Care Unit (NICU).

STUDY DESIGN

English-speaking caregivers and clinicians who participated in NICU tracheostomy discussions between January 2017 and December 2021 were eligible. They reviewed a pediatric tracheostomy communication guide prior to meeting. Interviews focused on tracheostomy decision-making experiences, communication preferences, and guide perceptions. Interviews were recorded, transcribed, and analyzed using iterative inductive/deductive coding to inform thematic analysis.

RESULTS

Ten caregivers and nine clinicians were interviewed. Caregivers were surprised by the severity of their child's diagnosis and the intensive home care required, but proceeded with tracheostomy because it was the only chance for survival. All recommended that tracheostomy information be introduced early and in phases. Inadequate communication limited caregivers' understanding of post-surgical care and discharge requirements. All felt a guide could standardize communication.

CONCLUSIONS

Caregivers seek detailed information regarding expectations after tracheostomy placement in the NICU and at home.

Palliative Care in the Pediatric Intensive Care Unit

The purposes of this review are to describe differences between palliative care for adult patients and palliative care for pediatric patients, both generally and in the intensive care unit; to highlight ethical considerations for pediatric intensive care unit patients by using illustrative cases; and to examine the impact of these ethical considerations on decision-making for children and their families.

Tracheostomy and long-term invasive ventilation decision-making in children: A scoping review

An increasing number of children are surviving critical illnesses requiring tracheostomy/long-term ventilation (LTV). This scoping review seeks to collate the available evidence on decision-making for tracheostomy/LTV in children. Systematic searches of electronic databases and websites were conducted for articles and reports. Inclusion criteria included: (1) children 0-18 years old; (2) described use of tracheostomy or tracheostomy/LTV; and (3) information on recommendations for tracheostomy decision-making or decision-making experiences of family-caregivers or health care providers. Articles not written in English were excluded. Of the 4463 records identified through database search and other methods, a total of 84 articles, 2 dissertations, 1 book chapter, 3 consensus statement/society guidelines, and 8 pieces of grey literature were included. Main thematic domains identified were: (1) legal and moral standards for decision-making; (2) decision-making models, roles of decision-makers, and decisional aids towards a shared decision-making model; (3) experiences and perspectives of decision-makers; (4) health system and society considerations; and (5) conflict resolution and legal considerations. A high degree of uncertainty and complexity is involved in tracheostomy/LTV decision-making. There is a need for a standardized decision-support process that is consistent with a child's best interests and shared decision-making. Strategies for optimizing communication and mechanism for managing disputes are needed.

Establishing Goals of Care in Serious and Complex Pediatric Illness

An increasing number of children are living for months and years with serious/complex illness characterized by long-term prognostic uncertainty, intensive interactions with medical systems, functional limitations, and often home medical technologies that shape the child's and family's quality of life. These families face many medical decision points that require intentional and iterative discussions about goals of care. Threats to cohesive goals of care include prognostic uncertainty, diffusion of medical responsibility, individual family context, and blended goals of care. This article offers strategies for addressing each of these challenges.

"What choice do you have knowing your child can't breathe?!": Adaptation to Parenthood for Children Who Have Received a Tracheostomy

Introduction

A growing number of parents are navigating parenthood influenced by medical complexity and technological dependency as the group of children with long-term tracheostomy grows. However, little is known regarding the parental experiences of parenthood for this heterogeneous group of children now surviving through infancy and intensive care.

Objective

This study aimed to analyze how parents of children who have received a tracheostomy adapted to parenthood.

Methods

Interviews were conducted and analyzed following a constructivist grounded theory approach. Ten parents of seven children living with a tracheostomy in Sweden were recruited via the long-term intensive care unit (ICU).

Results

The core variable of parenthood "Stuck in survival" was explained by two categories and six subcategories. The category "Unaddressed previous history" describes the experiences from being in the ICU environment and how the parents are not able, due to insufficient time and resources, to address these stressful experiences. The category "Falling through the cracks of a rigid system" describes how the parents found themselves and their children to be continuously ill-fitted in a medical system impossible to adapt to their needs and situation. Parents placed the starting point of parenthood with the birth of the child, whilst the tracheotomy only constituted a turning point and would lead to the loss of any previously held expectations regarding parenthood.

Conclusion

This study identified a previously undescribed period prior to tracheostomy placement, which may have long-lasting effects on these families. The care provided in ICUs following the birth of a child who will require tracheostomy may not be tailored or adapted to accommodate the needs of these families leading to long-lasting effects on parenthood.

Home values and experiences navigation track (HomeVENT): Supporting decisions about pediatric home ventilation

Objective

To pilot feasibility and acceptability of HomeVENT, a systematic approach to family-clinician decision-making about pediatric home ventilation.

Methods

Parents and clinicians of children facing home ventilation decisions were enrolled at 3 centers using a pre/post cohort design. Family interventions included: 1) a website describing the experiences of families who previously chose for and against home ventilation 2) a Question Prompt List (QPL); 3) in-depth interviews exploring home life and values. Clinician HomeVENT intervention included a structured team meeting reviewing treatment options in light of the family's home life and values. All participants were interviewed one month after the decision.

Results

We enrolled 30 families and 34 clinicians. Most Usual Care (14/15) but fewer Intervention (10/15) families elected for home ventilation. Families reported the website helped them consider different treatment options, the QPL promoted discussion within the family and with the team, and the interview helped them realize how home ventilation might change their daily life. Clinicians reported the team meeting helped clarify prognosis and prioritize treatment options.

Conclusions

The HomeVENT pilot was feasible and acceptable.

Innovation

This systematic approach to pediatric home ventilation decisions prioritizes family values and is a novel method to increase the rigor of shared decision-making in a rushed clinical environment.

Parent Perspectives on the Child Experience of Pediatric Home Ventilation via Tracheostomy

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

Parents facing the decision of whether to initiate pediatric mechanical ventilation via tracheostomy ("home ventilation") report wanting information about what to expect for life at home for their child. The study objective is to explore parent descriptions of the child experience of home ventilation to increase awareness for clinicians in the inpatient setting caring for these children.

METHODS

Semistructured interviews were conducted using purposive sampling of parents with children who initiated home ventilation within the previous 5 years from 3 geographically diverse academic medical centers.

RESULTS

We interviewed 21 families from 3 geographic regions in the United States. About 75% of children had respiratory failure in the first year of life, 80% had medical complexity, and half had severe neurologic impairment. Five domains emerged regarding parent perceptions of their child's experience of home ventilation: (1) health and well-being; (2) development; (3) adaptation; (4) mobility and travel; and (5) relationships. Within each domain, several themes were identified. For each theme, there was a positive and negative subtheme to illustrate how the child's experience was modified by home ventilation. Parent descriptions were generally positive, however, in all domains and to varying degrees, parents expressed negative aspects of home ventilation.

CONCLUSIONS

By providing information about the realistic experiences of children using home ventilation, clinicians can support families in the inpatient setting as they face this complex decision. Balanced information about home ventilation is critical to enhancing clinician counseling so that families may benefit from the perspectives of experienced parents.

Tracheostomy Timing During Pediatric Cardiac Intensive Care: Single Referral Center Retrospective Cohort

OBJECTIVES

To describe associations between the timing of tracheostomy and patient characteristics or outcomes in the cardiac ICU (CICU).

DESIGN

Single-institution retrospective cohort study.

SETTING

Freestanding academic children's hospital.

PATIENTS

CICU patients with tracheostomy placed between July 1, 2011, and July 1, 2020.

INTERVENTIONS

We compared patient characteristics and outcomes between early and late tracheostomy based on the duration of positive pressure ventilation (PPV) before tracheostomy placement, fitting a receiver operating characteristic curve for current survival to define a cutoff.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

Sixty-one patients underwent tracheostomy placement (0.5% of CICU admissions). Median age was 7.8 months. Eighteen patients (30%) had single ventricle physiology and 13 patients (21%) had pulmonary vein stenosis (PVS). Primary indications for tracheostomy were pulmonary/lower airway (41%), upper airway obstruction (UAO) (31%), cardiac (15%), neuromuscular (4%), or neurologic (4%). In-hospital mortality was 26% with 41% survival at the current follow-up (median 7.8 [interquartile range, IQR 2.6-30.0] mo). Late tracheostomy was defined as greater than or equal to 7 weeks of PPV which was equivalent to the median PPV duration pre-tracheostomy. Patients with late tracheostomy were more likely to be younger, have single ventricle physiology, and have greater respiratory severity. Patients with early tracheostomy were more likely to have UAO or genetic comorbidities. In multivariable analysis, late tracheostomy was associated with 4.2 times greater mortality (95% CI, 1.9-9.0). PVS was associated with higher mortality (adjusted hazard ratio [HR] 5.2; 95% CI, 2.5-10.9). UAO was associated with lower mortality (adjusted HR 0.2; 95% CI, 0.1-0.5). Late tracheostomy was also associated with greater cumulative opioid exposure.

CONCLUSIONS

CICU patients who underwent tracheostomy had high in-hospital and longer-term mortality rates. Tracheostomy timing decisions are influenced by indication, disease, genetic comorbidities, illness severity, and age. Earlier tracheostomy was associated with lower sedative use and improved adjusted survival. Tracheostomy placement is a complex decision demanding individualized consideration of risk-benefit profiles and thoughtful family counseling.

Family-Reflections.com: Creating a parent-to-parent web-based tool regarding pediatric home ventilation

BACKGROUND

The decision to initiate pediatric mechanical ventilation via tracheostomy ("home ventilation") is complex and parents often desire information from other parents who have faced this decision. However, parent-to-parent communication is challenging as it is difficult to connect new families to experienced families in ways that optimize informed, balanced decision-making.

OBJECTIVE

Create a parent-to-parent web-based tool to support decision-making about pediatric home ventilation.

PATIENT INVOLVEMENT

The tool was created based on interviews and feedback from parents.

METHODS

We interviewed parents who previously chose for, or against, home ventilation for their child. Interview themes and family comments guided website development. Viewer feedback was solicited via an embedded survey in the tool.

RESULTS

We created 6 composite character families to communicate 6 themes about home ventilation: 1) Considering treatment options, 2) Talking with medical team, 3) Impact on life at home, 4) Impact on relationships, 5) Experience for the child, and 6) If the child's life is short. Nine families who reviewed the draft tool felt it would have helped with their decision about home ventilation. Specifically, it supported families in thinking through what was "most important about their child's breathing problems" (7 of 9 parents) and feeling "more at peace with the decision" (8 of 9 parents). Between 6/1/20-12/31/22, nearly 5500 viewers have accessed the tool and 56 viewers completed the survey (including 13 families and 39 clinicians). Feedback from experienced families and clinicians reported the tool taught them something new.

DISCUSSION

This novel parent-to-parent tool shows promise for expanding access to balanced, family-centered information about pediatric home ventilation.

PRACTICAL VALUE

The diverse stories and decisions let parents access multiple family perspectives. The tool's focus is on family-centric information that parents reported was usually missing from clinician counseling.

FUNDING

This work was supported by the National Palliative Care Research Center.

Palliative care for NICU survivors with chronic critical illness

The sickest of NICU survivors develop chronic critical illness (CCI). Most infants with CCI will leave the NICU using chronic medical technology and will experience repeated rehospitalizations. The unique issues for these NICU graduates- escalating chronic medical technologies, fractured post-NICU healthcare, gaps in home health services, and family strain-are common and predictable. This means that raising family and NICU team awareness of these issues, and putting plans in place to address them, should occur for every NICU infant with CCI. Pediatric palliative care is one resource that can be engaged within the NICU to support the child and family through NICU discharge and beyond. This review examines what is known about the unique needs of infants who leave the NICU with CCI and the role that NICU-initiated palliative care involvement can play for these patients, families, clinicians, and the health care system.

Evaluating Caregiver-Clinician Communication for Tracheostomy Placement in the Neonatal Intensive Care Unit: A Qualitative Inquiry

Objective

Identify stakeholders' tracheostomy decision-making information priorities in the Neonatal Intensive Care Unit (NICU).

Study Design

English-speaking caregivers and clinicians who participated in NICU tracheostomy discussions between January 2017 and December 2021 were eligible. They reviewed a pediatric tracheostomy communication guide prior to meeting. Interviews focused on tracheostomy decision-making experiences, communication preferences, and guide perceptions. Interviews were recorded, transcribed, and analyzed using iterative inductive/deductive coding to inform thematic analysis.

Results

Ten caregivers and nine clinicians were interviewed. Caregivers were surprised by the severity of their child's diagnosis and the intensive home care required, but proceeded with tracheostomy because it was the only chance for survival. All recommended that tracheostomy information be introduced early and in phases. Inadequate communication limited caregivers' understanding of post-surgical care and discharge requirements. All felt a guide could standardize communication.

Conclusions

Caregivers seek detailed information regarding expectations after tracheostomy placement in the NICU and at home.

Variation in tracheostomy placement and outcomes following pediatric trauma among adult, pediatric, and combined trauma centers

BACKGROUND

Tracheostomy placement is much more common in adults than children following severe trauma. We evaluated whether tracheostomy rates and outcomes differ for pediatric patients treated at trauma centers that primarily care for children versus adults.

METHODS

We conducted a retrospective cohort study of patients younger than 18 years in the National Trauma Data Bank from 2007 to 2016 treated at a Level I/II pediatric, adult, or combined adult/pediatric trauma center, ventilated >24 hours, and who survived to discharge. We used multivariable logistic regression adjusted for age, insurance, injury mechanism and body region, and Injury Severity Score to estimate the association between the three trauma center types and tracheostomy. We used augmented inverse probability weighting to model the likelihood of tracheostomy based on the propensity for treatment at a pediatric, adult, or combined trauma center, and estimated associations between trauma center type with length of stay and postdischarge care.

RESULTS

Among 33,602 children, tracheostomies were performed in 4.2% of children in pediatric centers, 7.8% in combined centers (adjusted odds ratio [aOR], 1.47; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.20-1.81), and 11.2% in adult centers (aOR, 1.81; 95% CI, 1.48-2.22). After propensity matching, the estimated average tracheostomy rate would be 62.9% higher (95% CI, 37.7-88.1%) at combined centers and 85.3% higher (56.6-113.9%) at adult centers relative to pediatric centers. Tracheostomy patients had longer hospital stay in pediatric centers than combined (-4.4 days, -7.4 to -1.3 days) or adult (-4.0 days, -7.2 to -0.9 days) centers, but fewer children required postdischarge inpatient care (70.1% pediatric vs. 81.3% combined [aOR, 2.11; 95% CI, 1.03-4.31] and 82.4% adult centers [aOR, 2.51; 95% CI, 1.31-4.83]).

CONCLUSION

Children treated at pediatric trauma centers have lower likelihood of tracheostomy than children treated at combined adult/pediatric or adult centers independent of patient or injury characteristics. Better understanding of optimal indications for tracheostomy is necessary to improve processes of care for children treated throughout the pediatric trauma system.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Prognostic and Epidemiological; Level III.

Timing of Tracheostomy in Critically Ill Infants and Children With Respiratory Failure: A Pediatric Health Information System Study

OBJECTIVES

Tracheostomy placement in infants and children with respiratory failure has steadily increased over time, yet there is no consensus for optimal timing. We sought to: 1) describe tracheostomy timing and associated demographic and clinical characteristics in a large ICU cohort and 2) compare clinical outcomes between subgroups based on tracheostomy timing.

DESIGN

Retrospective observational study using the Pediatric Health Information System (PHIS).

SETTING

Neonatal ICUs and PICUs in the United States.

PATIENTS

PHIS was queried for patients less than 18 years who underwent tracheostomy from 2010 to 2020. Patients were included if admitted to an ICU with need for mechanical ventilation (MV) prior to tracheostomy in the same hospitalization. Patients were categorized as early tracheostomy (ET) (placement at MV day ≤ 14), late tracheostomy (LT) (MV days 15-60), and extended tracheostomy (ExT) (MV day > 60). Primary endpoints included demographic and clinical characteristics. Secondary endpoints included patient outcomes: in-hospital mortality, length of stay (LOS), hospital-acquired pneumonia (HAP), and hospital costs.

INTERVENTIONS

None.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

Sixteen thousand one hundred twenty-one patients underwent tracheostomy at 52 children's hospitals. Ten thousand two hundred ninety-five had complete data and were included in the analysis. Thirty-nine percent (4,006/10,295) underwent ET, 40% (4,159/10,295) underwent LT, and 21% (2,130/10,295) underwent ExT. Majority of patients in all subgroups had complex chronic conditions. Median age was significantly different between subgroups with ET being the oldest ( p < 0.001). A multivariable regression analysis showed that ET was associated with lower in-hospital mortality ( p < 0.001), shorter hospital LOS ( p < 0.001), shorter ICU LOS ( p < 0.001), shorter post-tracheostomy LOS ( p < 0.001), decreased HAP ( p < 0.001), and lower hospital costs ( p < 0.001) compared with those who underwent LT or ExT.

CONCLUSIONS

In a large cohort of pediatric patients with respiratory failure, tracheostomy placement within 14 days of MV was associated with improved in-hospital outcomes. ET was independently associated with decreased mortality, LOS, HAP, and hospital costs.

Providing care for children with tracheostomies: a qualitative interview study with parents and health professionals

OBJECTIVES

To explore the experience of caring for children with tracheostomies from the perspectives of parents and health professional caregivers.

DESIGN

Qualitative semistructured interview study.

SETTING

One region in England covered by a tertiary care centre that includes urban and remote rural areas and has a high level of deprivation.

PARTICIPANTS

A purposive sample of health professionals and parents who care for children who have, or have had, tracheostomies and who received care at the tertiary care centre.

INTERVENTION

Interviews undertaken by telephone or video link.

PRIMARY AND SECONDARY OUTCOME MEASURES

Qualitative reflexive thematic analysis with QSR Nvivo 12.

RESULTS

This paper outlines key determinants and mediators of the experiences of caregiving and the impact on psychological and physical health and quality of life of parents and their families, confidence of healthcare providers and perceived quality of care. For parents, access to care packages and respite care at home as well as communication and relationships with healthcare providers are key mediators of their experience of caregiving, whereas for health professionals, an essential influence is multidisciplinary team working and support. We also highlight a range of challenges focused on the shared care space, including: a lack of standardisation in access to different support teams, care packages and respite care, irregular training and updates, and differences in health provider expertise and experiences across departments and shift patterns, exacerbated in some settings by limited contact with children with tracheostomies.

CONCLUSIONS

Understanding the experiences of caregiving can help inform measures to support caregivers and improve quality standards. Our findings suggest there is a need to facilitate further standardisation of care and support available for parent caregivers and that this may be transferable to other regions. Potential solutions to be explored could include the development of a paediatric tracheostomy service specification, increasing use of paediatric tracheostomy specialist nurse roles, and addressing the emotional and psychological support needs of caregivers.

"What Would Give Her the Best Life?": Understanding Why Families Decline Pediatric Home Ventilation

Background: Families who must decide about pediatric home ventilation rely on the clinicians who counsel them for guidance. Most studies about pediatric home ventilation decisions focus on families who opt for this intervention, leaving much unknown about the families who decline. Objective: To describe the rationales of families who decline home ventilation. Design: Semi-structured interview study. Setting/Subjects: We interviewed 16 families in hospitals across 3 U.S. states, identified by their clinicians as previously deciding to not pursue home ventilation via tracheostomy within the past five years. Measurements: Targeted content and narrative analyses were used to understand family intentions and reasons for declining. Results: The clinical and social context varied among the 16 families in this study. Families' intentions in saying "no" fell into two categories: (1) definitive "No": Families who stood firm on in their decision and (2) contingent "No": Families who may consider this in the future. Families described four reasons why their child did not receive home ventilation: (1) concern about medical impacts, (2) concern about physical and/or communication restrictions, (3) concern that there would be no clear health benefit, and (4) concern about no clear meaningful life. Most families mentioned all four reasons, but concern about no clear meaningful life predominated. Conclusions: Though these families did not see home ventilation as an appropriate option, each reported a complex interplay of intentions behind and reasons for declining. Clinicians who counsel families about home ventilation could share the reasons that families commonly decline this intervention to facilitate a balanced discussion.

Characteristics of Prognostic Statements During Family Conferences of Critically Ill Children

OBJECTIVES

Discussion of prognosis is an essential component of decision-making family conferences in critical care. We do not know how clinicians convey prognosis to families of critically ill children. We, therefore, aimed to evaluate the frequency of prognostic statements and the message and meaning conveyed through each statement during PICU family conferences.

DESIGN

Retrospective, mixed-methods study.

SETTING

PICU of a single quaternary medical center.

PATIENTS

Critically ill children and their families participating in PICU family conferences of critical medical decision-making.

INTERVENTIONS

None.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

We analyzed 72 transcripts from audio-recorded PICU family conferences to identify prognostic statements. Descriptive, thematic content analysis was used to elucidate the message and meaning of each prognostic statement. Prognosis was not discussed in 26% (19/72) of family conferences. Of the other (53/72) conferences where prognostic statements were made, 60% (67/112) of statements conveyed a message (i.e., prognostic medical information) and a meaning (i.e., anticipated impact on patient/family). "Messages" of prognostic statements fell within eight themes: uncertain recovery, delayed recovery, progressive decline, escalation of support, attributable complications, no progress, irreversible, and probability of death. "Meanings" of prognostic statements fell within six themes: restoration of health, activities of daily living, additional equipment, prolonged care needs, brain dysfunction, and death. Broadly, clinicians discussed prognostic information in three categories: loss of Time (i.e., prolonged care needs), Function (i.e., additional medical equipment), or Cure (i.e., death).

CONCLUSIONS

Nearly in half of discussions (32/72, 44%) where families were asked to make critical medical decisions, clinicians did not provide a prognostic statement including a message and meaning. When discussed, prognostic information was conveyed in three categories: loss of time, function, or cure. Providing families context in this framework, particularly in times of uncertainty, may improve the family's ability to make informed, value-driven medical decisions for their child.

Adapting user-centered design principles to improve communication of peer parent narratives on pediatric tracheostomy

BACKGROUND

Parents who have to make tracheostomy decisions for their critically ill child may face forecasting errors and wish to learn from peer parents. We sought to develop an intervention with peer parent narratives to help parents anticipate and prepare for future challenges before making a decision.

METHODS

To ensure that the intervention reflects parents' needs (rather than experts' opinions), we adapted a user-centered design (UCD) process to identify decision-critical information and refine the presentation format by interviewing parents who had tracheostomy decision making experience. Phase 1 (n = 10) presented 15 possible forecasting errors and asked participants to prioritize and justify the problematic ones. It also asked participants to comment on the draft narratives and preferred delivery mode and time of the intervention. Phase 2 (n = 9 additional parents and 1 previous parent) iteratively collected feedback over four waves of user interviews to guide revisions to the informational booklet.

RESULTS

Phase 1 revealed that parents wanted information to address all forecasting errors as soon as tracheostomy becomes an option. They also highlighted diverse family situations and the importance of offering management strategies. The resulting prototype booklet contained five sections: introduction, child's quality of life, home care, practical challenges, and resources. Feedback from Phase 2 focused on emphasizing individualized situations, personal choice, seriousness of the decision, and caregiver health as well as presenting concrete illustrations of future challenges with acknowledgement of positive outcomes and advice. We also learned that parents preferred to use the booklet with support from the care team rather than read it alone.

CONCLUSIONS

A UCD process enabled inclusion of parental perspectives that were initially overlooked and tailoring of the intervention to meet parental expectations. Similar UCD-based approaches may be valuable in the design of other types of patient communications (e.g., decision aids).

Clinical Proof of Concept for Stabilization of Tracheostomy Tubes Using Novel DYNAtraq Device

Introduction

Tracheostomy is one of the most common surgical strategies in intensive care units (ICU) and provides relevant clinical benefit for multiple indications. However, the complications associated with its use range from 5 to 40% according to different series. The risk of these complications could be reduced if fixation strategies and alignment of the tracheostomy tube with respect to the tracheal axis are improved.

Aim

To build a functional device of technological innovation in respiratory medicine for the fixation and alignment of tracheostomy cannula (acronym DYNAtraq) and to evaluate its feasibility and safety in a pilot study in mechanically ventilated patients.

Methods

Study carried out in four phases: (1) design engineering and functional prototyping of the device; (2) study of cytotoxicity and tolerance to the force of traction and push; (3) pilot study of feasibility and safety of its use in tracheostomized and mechanically ventilated patients; and (4) health workers satisfaction study.

Results

The design of the innovative DYNAtraq device included, on the one hand, a connector with very little additional dead space to be inserted between the cannula and the ventilation tubes, and, on the other hand, a shaft with two supports for adhesion to the skin of the thorax with very high tolerance (several kilograms) to pull and push. In patients, the device corrected the malpositioned tracheostomy tubes for the latero-lateral (p < 0.001) and cephalo-caudal angles (p < 0.001). Its effect was maintained throughout the follow-up time (p < 0.001). The use of DYNAtraq did not induce serious adverse events and showed a 70% protective effect for complications (RR = 0.3, p < 0.001) in patients.

Conclusion

DYNAtraq is a new device for respiratory medicine that allows the stabilization, alignment and fixation of tracheostomy tubes in mechanically ventilated patients. Its use provides additional benefits to traditional forms of support as it corrects misalignment and increases tolerance to habitual or forced movements. DYNAtraq is a safe element and can reduce the complications of tracheostomy tubes.

Development and implementation of a pre-tracheostomy multidisciplinary conference: An initiative to improve patient selection

OBJECTIVE

To describe our institutional experience in implementing a pre-tracheostomy multidisciplinary conference and assess its effects on patient selection and communication between team members and with families.

METHODS

Descriptive study and retrospective review of patient outcomes in a period prior to (4/2016-1/2018) and following (2/2018-11/2019) implementation of the conference and conference participant survey.

RESULTS

In the 21 months prior to the conference, 53 patients out of 67 consults (79%) went on to have a tracheostomy. After implementation, 96 patients, 42 females and 54 males, between 2 weeks and 22 years of age were discussed. 58 (60%) of patients referred for tracheostomy ultimately underwent surgery. Of those managed without tracheostomy, 16% were extubated, 11% were managed with noninvasive respiratory support, and 13% of families chose to redirect care. There was no difference in time between consultation and surgery (p = 0.9), or post-surgical length of stay after the conference was implemented (p = 0.9). Survey responses were gathered from 34 conference participants. Respondents agreed that the conference was useful in facilitating communication among the care team (91%), promoting understanding of the patient's treatment options (85%), promoting understanding about long-term outcomes and progression of underlying disease process (79%), clarifying risks, benefits, and alternatives of treatment options (82%), and informing discussions with the family (70%).

DISCUSSION

Potential benefits of a multidisciplinary pre-tracheostomy conference include improved provider communication and shared decision making between the medical team and family. We found a reduction in the proportion of patients who ultimately underwent tracheostomy as a result of a formal multidisciplinary discussion, but did not find either any delays in care, or reduction in post-operative length of stay.

IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE

A multidisciplinary team approach to patient selection can foster communication between team members, identify barriers to discharge and quality care at home, and provide caregivers with information necessary to make an informed decision about their child's care.

Tracheostomy Practices and Outcomes in Children During Respiratory Extracorporeal Membrane Oxygenation

OBJECTIVES

Children receiving prolonged extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO) support may benefit from tracheostomy during ECMO by facilitating rehabilitation; however, the procedure carries risks, especially hemorrhagic complications. Knowledge of tracheostomy practices and outcomes of ECMO-supported children who undergo tracheostomy on ECMO may inform decision-making.

DESIGN

Retrospective cohort study.

SETTING

ECMO centers contributing to the Extracorporeal Life Support Organization registry.

PATIENTS

Children from birth to 18 years who received ECMO support for greater than or equal to 7 days for respiratory failure from January 1, 2015, to December 31, 2019.

INTERVENTIONS

None.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

Three thousand six hundred eighty-five children received at least 7 days of ECMO support for respiratory failure. The median duration of ECMO support was 13.0 days (interquartile range [IQR], 9.3-19.9 d), and inhospital mortality was 38.7% (1,426/3,685). A tracheostomy was placed during ECMO support in 94/3,685 (2.6%). Of those who received a tracheostomy on ECMO, the procedure was performed at a median 13.2 days (IQR, 6.3-25.9 d) after initiation of ECMO. Surgical site bleeding was documented in 26% of children who received a tracheostomy (12% after tracheostomy placement). Among children who received a tracheostomy, the median duration of ECMO support was 24.2 days (IQR, 13.0-58.7 d); inhospital mortality was 30/94 (32%). Those that received a tracheostomy before 14 days on ECMO were older (median age, 15.8 yr [IQR, 4.7-15.5] vs 11.7 yr [IQR, 11.5-17.3 yr]; p =0.002) and more likely to have been supported on venovenous-ECMO (84% vs 52%; p = 0.001). Twenty-two percent (11/50) of those who received a tracheostomy before 14 days died in the hospital, compared with 19/44 (43%) of those who received a tracheostomy at 14 days or later (p = 0.03).

CONCLUSIONS

Tracheostomies during ECMO were uncommon in children. One in four patients who received a tracheostomy on ECMO had surgical site bleeding. Children who had tracheostomies placed after 14 days were younger and had worse outcomes, potentially representing tracheostomy as a "secondary" strategy for prolonged ECMO support.

The Changing Landscape in Pediatric Hospitals: A Multicenter Study of How Pediatric Chronic Critical Illness Impacts NICU Throughput

OBJECTIVE

Pediatric inpatient bed availability is increasingly constrained by the prolonged hospitalizations of children with medical complexity. The sickest of these patients are chronic critically ill and often have protracted intensive care unit (ICU) stays. Numbers and characteristics of infants with chronic critical illness are unclear, which undermines resource planning in ICU's and general pediatric wards. The goal of this study was to describe infants with chronic critical illness at six academic institutions in the United States.

STUDY DESIGN

Infants admitted to six academic medical centers were screened for chronic, critical illness based on a combination of prolonged and repeated hospitalizations, use of medical technology, and chronic multiorgan involvement. Data regarding patient and hospitalization characteristics were collected.

RESULTS

Just over one-third (34.8%) of pediatric inpatients across the six centers who met eligibility criteria for chronic critical illness were <12 months of age. Almost all these infants received medical technology (97.8%) and had multiorgan involvement (94.8%). Eighty-six percent (115/134) had spent time in an ICU during the current hospitalization; 31% were currently in a neonatal ICU, 34% in a pediatric ICU, and 17% in a cardiac ICU. Among infants who had been previously discharged home (n = 55), most had been discharged with medical technology (78.2%) and nearly all were still using that technology during the current readmission. Additional technologies were commonly added during the current hospitalization.

CONCLUSION

Advanced strategies are needed to plan for hospital resource allocation for infants with chronic critical illness. These infants' prolonged hospitalizations begin in the neonatal ICU but often transition to other ICUs and general inpatient wards. They are commonly discharged with medical technology which is rarely weaned but often escalated during subsequent hospitalizations. Identification and tracking of these infants, beginning in the neonatal ICU, will help hospitals anticipate and strategize for inpatient bed management.

KEY POINTS

· 35% of inpatients with chronic critical illness are infants.. · Nearly 90% of these infants spend some time in an intensive care unit.. · 78% are discharged with medical technology..

Parent perspectives on facilitating decision-making around pediatric home ventilation

RATIONALE

Deciding about pediatric home ventilation is exceptionally challenging for parents. Understanding the decision-making needs of parents who made different choices for their children could inform clinician counseling that better supports parents' diverse values and goals.

OBJECTIVES

To determine how clinicians can meet the decisional needs of parents considering home ventilation using a balanced sample of families who chose for or against intervention.

METHODS

We conducted semi-structured interviews of parents who chose for or against home ventilation for their child within the previous 5 years. Parents were recruited from three academic centers across the United States. Interviews focused on parent-clinician communication during decision-making and how clinicians made the process easier or more difficult. Qualitative analysis was used to generate themes and identify key results.

RESULTS

Thirty-eight parents were interviewed; 20 chose for and 18 chose against home ventilation. Five themes described their perspectives on how clinicians can facilitate high-quality decision-making: demonstrating dedication to families, effectively managing the medical team, introducing the concept of home ventilation with intention, facilitating meaningful conversation about the treatment options, and supporting and respecting the family's decision.

CONCLUSIONS

High-quality decision-making around home ventilation depends on individual clinician actions and the complex operations of large academic settings. Strong working relationships with parents, collaborative alliances with colleagues, and appropriate delivery of key content can help meet the needs of parents considering invasive breathing supports for their children.

Shared decision making for children with chronic respiratory failure-It takes a village and a process

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Shared decision making (SDM) before nonurgent tracheostomy in a child with chronic respiratory failure (CRF) is often recommended, but has proven challenging to implement in practice. We hypothesize that utilization of the microsystem model for analysis of the complex ecosystem in which SDM occurs will yield insights that enable formation of a reproducible, measurable SDM process.

METHODS

Retrospective chart review of a case series of children with CRF in whom a SDM process was pursued. The process included a palliative care consult, a validated decision aid and 12 key questions designed to elucidate information integral to an informed decision. Investigators reviewed a single hospital admission for each child, focusing on the 3 core elements of a medical microsystem-the patient, the providers, and information.

RESULTS

Twenty-nine patients who met inclusion criteria ranged in age from 0 to 19.5 years (median 1.7) and remained in the hospital from 10 to 316 days (median 38). Patients were medically complex with multiple and varied respiratory diagnoses, multiple and varied comorbidities, and varying psychosocial environments. 14/29 children received tracheostomies. Each child encountered a mean of 6.2 medical specialties, 1.9 surgical specialties and 8.5 nonphysician led services. Answers to 12 key questions were not documented systematically and often not found in the electronic medical record.

CONCLUSION

A unique SDM microsystem is formed around each child but not optimally utilized. Explicit recognition of these microsystems would enable team formation and an SDM process comprised of measurable steps and communication patterns.

"This Is How Hard It Is". Family Experience of Hospital-to-Home Transition with a Tracheostomy

Rationale: Expansion of chronic ventilation options and shared decision-making have contributed to an increasing population of technology-dependent children. One particularly vulnerable group is children with tracheostomy who depend on technology for basic respiratory functions. Chronic critical care is now provided in the homecare setting with implications for family caregivers.Objectives: This study explores the experience of family caregivers of children and young adults with a tracheostomy during the transition from hospital to home care. We sought to identify the specific unmet needs of families to direct future interventions.Methods: We recruited a convenience sample of families from an established home ventilation program to participate in semistructured interviews. Sessions were conducted in person or via teleconference. A grounded-theory qualitative analysis was performed.Results: Between March 2017 and October 2018, we interviewed 13 individuals representing 12 families of children and/or young adults with tracheostomy. Patients ranged in age from 9 months to 28 years, had a tracheostomy for 8 months to 18 years, and represented a variety of underlying diagnoses. Five key themes emerged: 1) navigating home nursing; 2) care coordination and durable medical equipment (DME) impediments; 3) learning as a process; 4) managing emergencies; and 5) setting expectations.Conclusions: Our findings support the need for family-centered discharge processes including coordination of care and teaching focused on emergency preparedness.

Development and validation of a novel informational booklet for pediatric long-term ventilation decision support

OBJECTIVES

To provide accessible, uniform, comprehensive, and balanced information to families deciding whether to initiate long-term ventilation (LTV) for their child, we sought to develop and validate a novel informational resource.

METHODS

The Ottawa Decision Support Framework was followed. Previous interviews with 44 lay and 15 professional stakeholders and published literature provided content for a booklet. Iterative versions were cognitive tested with six parents facing decisions and five pediatric intensivists. Ten parents facing decisions evaluated the booklet using the Preparation for Decision Making Scale and reported their decisional conflict, which was juxtaposed to the conflict of 21 parents who did not read it, using the Decisional Conflict Scale. Twelve home ventilation program directors evaluated the booklet's clinical sensibility and sensitivity, using a self-designed six-item questionnaire. Data presented using summary statistics.

RESULTS

The illustrated booklet (6th-grade reading level) has nine topical sections on chronic respiratory failure and invasive and noninvasive LTV, including the option to forgo LTV. Ten parents who read the booklet rated it as helping "Quite a bit" or more on all items of the Preparation for Decision Making Scale and had seemingly less decisional conflict than 21 parents who did not. Twelve directors rated it highly for clinical sensibility and sensitivity.

CONCLUSIONS

The LTV booklet was rigorously developed and favorably evaluated. It offers a resource to improve patient/family knowledge, supplement shared decision-making, and reduce decisional conflict around LTV decisions. Future studies should validate it in other settings and further study its effectiveness.

In Your Capable Hands: Ethical Practice, Bias Mitigation, and Care for Children Who Rely on Chronic Mechanical Ventilation

Nurses encounter constraints, pressures and complexity in patient care which may increase reliance on implicit bias -- unconscious, mental shortcuts which shape attitudes and behavior (Kahneman, 2011). These cognitive shortcuts save time, but if unexamined, can undermine the ethical commitment to "respect…the inherent dignity, worth, unique attributes, and human rights of all individuals," (ANA Code, 2015, p.1). This is especially concerning when considering vulnerable populations, such as families with children who are dependent on tracheostomy and mechanical ventilation (trach-vent-dependent). Studies of parent caregivers of children who are trach-vent-dependent raise questions of whether implicit bias contributes to the stigmatization these families experience. Practical strategies to activate the Code of Ethics with Interpretive Statements can mitigate the risks of stigmatization and vulnerability, resulting in improved shared decision making and care for these patients and families. An objective tool to guide patient- and family-centered inquiry and care can anchor nurses' ethical practice.

Using Narratives to Correct Forecasting Errors in Pediatric Tracheostomy Decision Making

PURPOSE

Parents who face goals-of-care tracheostomy decisions may lack an understanding of challenges affecting their child's and family's long-term quality of life (QOL) to accurately forecast possible outcomes for decision making. We sought to examine whether and how parents' narratives of the child's and family's long-term QOL influence parental tracheostomy decisions and forecasting.

METHOD

We recruited US adult Amazon Mechanical Turk participants (N = 1966) who self-reported having a child (<6 y old) or planning a pregnancy within 5 y. Participants read a vignette about making a tracheostomy decision for their hypothetical neurologically impaired baby. They were randomized to 1 of the following 4 conditions: 1) Baby QOL narratives, 2) Family QOL narratives, 3) Baby QOL + Family QOL narratives, and 4) control: no narratives. They then made a decision about whether or not to pursue tracheostomy, forecasted their concerns about the baby's and family's QOL, reported their values and social norm beliefs about tracheostomy, comfort care, and parental medical decision making, and completed individual differences scales and demographics.

RESULTS

Controlling for individual characteristics, participants in the Baby QOL and Baby QOL + Family QOL conditions were less likely to choose tracheostomy as compared with the control (odds ratio [OR] = 0.38 and 0.25, respectively, P < 0.001). Fewer participants in the Family QOL condition chose tracheostomy compared with the control, but this difference was not statistically significant (OR = 0.70, P = 0.11). Moreover, narratives increased pessimistic forecasting, which was associated with less interest in tracheostomy.

CONCLUSION

Narratives clarifying long-term implications of pursuing tracheostomy have the potential to influence forecasting and decisions. Narrative-based interventions may be valuable in other situations in which forecasting errors are common.

Family Experiences Deciding For and Against Pediatric Home Ventilation

OBJECTIVE

To understand what considerations drive family decisions for, and against, pediatric home ventilation.

STUDY DESIGN

Qualitative interviews with parents of children who faced a decision about home ventilation in the previous 5 years at 3 geographically dispersed institutions.

RESULTS

In total, 38 families (42 parents) were interviewed; 20 families opted for pediatric home ventilation, and 18 families opted against. Approximately one-quarter of children had isolated chronic lung disease; the remainder had medical complexity that was expected to remain static or decline. Parent perspectives about home ventilation generally reflected whether the child was early, or later, in their disease trajectory. Early on, parents often interpreted prognostic uncertainty as hope and saw home ventilation as a tool permitting time for improvement. For families of children later in their disease course, often already with home technology and home nursing, home ventilation held less possibility for meaningful improvement. Nearly all families experienced the decision as very emotionally distressing. Reflecting back, most families described feeling satisfied with whatever decision they made.

CONCLUSIONS

The 2 principal groups of families in our cohort-those with children whose respiratory insufficiency might improve, and those with children facing chronic decline-warrant targeted counseling approaches about initiating home ventilation. The distressing nature of this decision should be anticipated and family supports reinforced.

Decisions for Long-Term Ventilation for Children. Perspectives of Family Members

Rationale: The decision whether to initiate or forgo long-term ventilation for children can be difficult and impactful. However, little has been published on the informational and decisional needs of families facing this decision.Objectives: To assess what families with children with chronic respiratory failure and life-limiting conditions need and want for informed decision-making.Methods: English- and Spanish-speaking parents who were facing (contemporaneous decision makers) or had previously faced (former decision makers) a decision regarding invasive or noninvasive long-term ventilation for their children were recruited using convenience sampling. Patients who were older and cognitively capable also were invited to participate. We performed semistructured interviews using an open-ended interview guide developed de novo to assess parents' decisional needs and experiences. Qualitative data analysis used a thematic approach based on framework analysis, and thematic saturation was a goal.Results: A sample of 44 parents and 2 patients from 43 families was interviewed. All contemporaneous decision makers (n = 28) favored or believed that they would choose long-term ventilation. Fifteen of 16 former decision makers chose long-term ventilation. Thematic saturation was achieved from the perspective of parents who favored or chose long-term ventilation. Four domains were identified: parents' emotional and psychological experiences with decision-making, parents' informational needs, parents' communication and decision support needs, and parents' views on the option not to initiate long-term ventilation. For most parents, making a decision regarding long-term ventilation was stressful, even though they articulated goals and values that could/did guide their decision-making. In general, parents wanted comprehensive information, including what life would be like at home for the child and the family. They wanted their medical providers to be honest, tactful, patient, and supportive. Parents reported that they felt being presented with the option not to initiate was acceptable.Conclusions: In this study, we identified specific informational and decision-making needs regarding long-term ventilation that parents facing decisions feel are important. These data suggest that providers should present families with comprehensive, balanced information on the impact of long-term ventilation and, when the child has a profoundly serious and life-limiting condition, explore the option not to initiate long-term ventilation.

Educational needs of patients and caregivers living with sickle cell disease results in development of web-based patient decision aid

AIMS

We performed an assessment to understand perceived decisional needs among those living with sickle cell disease. Additionally, we desired understanding of their preferred methods and quality of learning and sought guidance in development of a web-based patient decision aid.

DESIGN

The purpose of this qualitative study was to determine ways patients and caregivers receive education about sickle cell disease and available therapies. We sought to understand preferences for education, quality of current knowledge and information they would like to obtain.

METHODS

Recruitment for the initial needs assessment occurred between October 2013 -April 2014. Further recruitment for clarification of internet-based searches occurred between January 2015 -September 2016. We conducted a total of 201 semi-structured qualitative interviews with patients and caregivers.

RESULTS

Six themes emerged: healthcare provider education is good but does not meet all the learning needs of the patient/caregiver; patients/caregivers feel a strong desire to seek information about treatment options on their own; adult patients and parents diverged in their core objectives in seeking information: quality of life (QOL) was the major outcome of interest in considering potential treatment options; experience of peers is preferred source for learning about treatment options; and educational needs may be supplemented with a web-based interactive educational tool.

CONCLUSION

Patients with sickle cell disease and their caregivers are motivated by a desire to improve QOL in seeking treatment options and use many methods to seek education to supplement what they learn from their healthcare providers and may benefit from the use of a web-based decision aid. Impact Educational needs of patients/caregivers with sickle cell disease were identified and provide the basis to inform the design of educational strategies for them. Nurses and others can assist with learning needs by sharing the website and answering questions that arise.

'I'm praying for a miracle': characteristics of spiritual statements in paediatric intensive care unit care conferences

CONTEXT

Supporting spiritual needs is a well-established aspect of palliative care, but no data exist regarding how physicians engage with patients and families around spirituality during care conferences in paediatric intensive care units (PICU).

OBJECTIVES

To assess the frequency and characteristics of family and physician spiritual statements in PICU care conferences.

METHODS

We performed qualitative analysis of 71 transcripts from PICU conferences, audio-recorded at an urban, quaternary medical centre. Transcripts were derived from a single-centre, cross-sectional, qualitative study.

RESULTS

We identified spiritual language in 46% (33/71) of PICU care conferences. Spiritual statements were divided relatively evenly between family member (51%, 67/131) and physician statements (49%, 64/131). Physician responses to families' spiritual statements were coded as supportive (46%, 31/67), deferred (30%, 20/67), indifferent (24%, 16/67) or exploratory (0/67).

CONCLUSIONS

In this single-centre PICU, spiritual statements were present 46% of the time during high stakes decision-making conferences, but there was little evidence of spiritual care best practices, such as offering chaplain support and performing open-ended spiritual assessments. PICU clinicians should expect spiritual statements in care conferences and be prepared to respond.

Parental Conflict, Regret, and Short-term Impact on Quality of Life in Tracheostomy Decision-Making

OBJECTIVES

The prevalence of tracheostomy-dependence in critically ill children is increasing in the United States. We do not know the impact of this decision on parental outcomes. We aimed to determine the prevalence of decisional conflict and regret and explore the impact on quality of life among parents considering tracheostomy placement for their child.

SUBJECTS

Parents facing tracheostomy decision for their child.

DESIGN

Prospective, mixed-methods longitudinal study.

SETTING

PICU, cardiac ICU, and neonatal ICU of a single quaternary medical center.

INTERVENTIONS

None.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

Parents completed a decisional conflict survey at the time of tracheostomy decision and decisional regret and quality of life surveys at 2 weeks and 3 months after the decision regarding tracheostomy placement was made. We enrolled 39 parents, of which 25 completed surveys at all three time points. Thirty-five of 39 (89.7%) reported at least some decisional conflict, most commonly from feeling uninformed and pressured to make a decision. At 2 weeks, 13 of 25 parents (52%) reported regret, which increased to 18 of 25 participants (72%) at 3 months. Regret stemmed from feeling uninformed, ill-chosen timing of placement, and perceptions of inadequate medical care. At 2 weeks, the quality of life score was in the mid-range, 78.8 (SD 13.8) and decreased to 75.5 (SD 14.2) at 3 months. Quality of life was impacted by the overwhelming medical care and complexity of caring for a child with a tracheostomy, financial burden, and effect on parent's psychosocial health.

CONCLUSIONS

The decision to pursue tracheostomy among parents of critically ill children is fraught with conflict with worsening regret and quality of life over time. Strategies to reduce contributing factors may improve parental outcomes after this life-changing decision.

Speech and Safety in Tracheostomy Patients Receiving Mechanical Ventilation: A Systematic Review

OBJECTIVE

To synthesize evidence of the safety and effectiveness of phonation in patients with fenestrated tracheostomy tubes.

METHODS

PubMed, CINAHL, Scopus, Cochrane, and Web of Science databases were searched. The research question was, "Are fenestrated tracheostomy tubes a safe and effective option to facilitate early phonation in patients undergoing tracheostomy?" Studies of fenestrated tracheostomy tubes were assessed for risk of bias and quality of evidence. Data were abstracted, cross-checked for accuracy, and synthesized.

RESULTS

Of the 160 studies identified, 13 met inclusion criteria, including 6 clinical studies (104 patients), 6 case reports (13 patients), and 1 nationwide clinician survey. The primary indications for a tracheostomy were chronic ventilator dependence (83%) and airway protection (17%). Indications for fenestrated tracheostomy included inaudible phonation and poor voice intelligibility. Patients with fenestrated tubes achieved robust voice outcomes. Complications included granulation tissue (6 patients [5%]), malpositioning (1 patient [0.9%]), decreased oxygen saturation (3 patients [2.6%]), increased blood pressure (1 patient [0.9%]), increased peak pressures (2 patients [1.7%]), and air leakage (1 patient [0.9%]); subcutaneous emphysema also occurred frequently. Patient-reported symptoms included shortness of breath (4 patients [3.4%]), anxiety (3 patients [2.6%]), and chest discomfort (1 patient [0.9%]).

CONCLUSIONS

Fenestrated devices afford benefits for speech and decannulation but carry risks of granulation, aberrant airflow, and acclimation challenges. Findings highlight the need for continued innovation, education, and quality improvement around the use of fenestrated devices.

Simulation-Based Palliative Care Communication for Pediatric Critical Care Fellows

BACKGROUND

Pediatric palliative care (PPC) education is lacking in pediatric critical care medicine (PCCM) fellowships, despite the desire of many program directors and fellows to expand difficult conversation training. Simulation-based training is an experiential method for practicing challenging communication skills such as breaking bad news, disclosing medical errors, navigating goals of care, and supporting medical decision-making.

METHODS

We describe a simulation-based PPC communication series for PCCM fellows, including presimulation session, simulation session, debriefing, and evaluation methods. From 2011 to 2017, 28 PCCM fellows participated in a biannual half-day simulation session. Each session included 3 scenarios (allowing for participation in up to 18 scenarios over 3 years). Standardized patients portrayed the child's mother. PCCM and interprofessional PPC faculty cofacilitated, evaluated, and debriefed the fellows after each scenario. Fellows were evaluated in 4 communication categories (general skills, breaking bad news, goals of care, and resuscitation) using a 3-point scale. A retrospective descriptive analysis was conducted.

RESULTS

One hundred sixteen evaluations were completed for 18 PCCM fellows. Median scores for general communication items, breaking bad news, and goals of care ranged from 2.0 to 3.0 (interquartile range [IQR]: 0-1) with scores for resuscitation lower at 1.0 (IQR: 1.5-2).

DISCUSSION

This experiential simulation-based PPC communication curriculum taught PCCM fellows valuable palliative communication techniques although revealed growth opportunities within more complex communication tasks. The preparation, methods, and lessons learned for an effective palliative simulation curriculum can be expanded upon by other pediatric training programs, and a more rigorous research program should be added to educational series.

Caregiver Perceptions about their Decision to Pursue Tracheostomy for Children with Medical Complexity

OBJECTIVE

To describe the perceptions of caregivers of children with medical complexity (CMC) about their decision to pursue tracheostomy for their children, in particular the satisfaction with their decision.

STUDY DESIGN

In this qualitative study conducted in western North Carolina between 2013 and 2014, we interviewed 56 caregivers of 41 CMC who had received tracheostomies in the past 5 years. Three of the CMC were deceased at the time of the interview; 8 were decannulated. In-depth interviews (35 English, 6 Spanish) were conducted, audio-recorded, and transcribed verbatim. We used ATLAS.ti software to manage data and identified themes related to caregiver perceptions about tracheostomy decision.

RESULTS

We found that caregivers often chose tracheostomy because extending the lives of their children and being able to care for them at home were important. Caregivers reported the many benefits of tracheostomy including improvement in respiratory symptoms, physical and developmental health, quality of life, and means to provide medical care quickly when needed. There were negative effects of tracheostomy such as mucous plugs, excessive secretions, accidental decannulation necessitating emergency tracheostomy tube change, and the increased infection risk. Providing medical care for CMC with tracheostomy at home was difficult, but improved over time. Caregivers were generally satisfied with their decision to pursue tracheostomy for their CMC.

CONCLUSIONS

Decisional satisfaction with tracheostomy for CMC is high. In counseling caregivers about tracheostomy, clinicians should present both the benefits and risks. Future studies should quantify the outcomes described in this study.

Pediatric Long-Term Endotracheal Intubation and Role for Tracheostomy: Patient and Provider Factors

Tracheostomy provides an alternative to long-term intubation in patients with respiratory failure, but there is little guidance for its use in pediatric patients. Our study used provider surveys of pediatric intensive care physicians managing patients intubated longer than 14 days to evaluate accuracy of physician estimates for total intubation time and the impact of medical history and illness category on determining tracheostomy placement. Providers' ability to estimate length of intubation was found to be highly inaccurate. With delayed tracheostomy conferring increased risk and mortality, better recommendations regarding indication and timing of pediatric tracheostomy placement are needed.

Pediatric palliative care in the intensive care unit and questions of quality: a review of the determinants and mechanisms of high-quality palliative care in the pediatric intensive care unit (PICU)

This article reviews the state and practice of pediatric palliative care (PC) within the pediatric intensive care unit (PICU) with specific consideration of quality issues. This includes defining PC and end of life (EOL) care. We will also describe PC as it pertains to alleviating children's suffering through the provision of "concurrent care" in the ICU environment. Modes of care, and attendant strengths, of both the consultant and integrated models will be presented. We will review salient issues related to the provision of PC in the PICU, barriers to optimal practice, parental, and staff perceptions. Opportunity areas for quality improvement and the role of initiatives and measures such as education, family-based initiatives, staff needs, symptom recognition, grief, and communication follow. To conclude, we will look to the literature for PC resources for pediatric intensivists and future directions of study.