Two Cases of Mesonephric-like Carcinoma Arising From Endometriosis: Case Report and Review of the Literature

Papillary and ductal patterns of mesonephric-like adenocarcinomas are often overlooked: a retrospective revaluation of over 1000 endometrial carcinomas

AIMS

Mesonephric-like adenocarcinoma (MLA) of the endometrium is often a diagnostic challenge, due to its morphological resemblance to other more common Müllerian neoplasms. This study aimed to retrospectively identify overlooked MLA in a large endometrial carcinoma cohort, using a combination of immunohistochemistry (IHC), morphology and KRAS sequencing.

METHODS AND RESULTS

IHC was conducted on 1094 endometrial carcinomas, identifying 16 potential MLA cases based on GATA3+ and/or TTF1+ and ER- staining patterns, which subsequently underwent detailed histological review, KRAS sequencing and ProMisE molecular classification. Of the IHC screen-positive cases, one was positive for both GATA3 and TTF1, nine were positive for GATA3 only and six were positive for TTF1 only. All IHC screen-positive cases were POLE wild-type. All five tumours in the NSMP category showed morphological features of MLA, while the three MMRd and eight p53abn tumours did not show MLA morphology. The five cases diagnosed as MLA on review were all originally diagnosed as low-grade endometrioid adenocarcinoma probably because of rare morphological patterns, being predominantly papillary or ductal. Four of the five cases harboured a KRAS mutation.

CONCLUSION

This study highlights the importance of a comprehensive diagnostic approach for accurately identifying endometrial MLA and for pathologists to be aware of papillary and ductal patterns in endometrial carcinoma assessment. Further exploration into the molecular landscape of MLA is essential for refining diagnostic criteria and developing targeted therapies.

Ovarian Mesonephric-like Adenocarcinoma: Its Prevalence in a Japanese High-Volume Cancer Center and a Literature Review on Therapeutic Targets

BACKGROUND

Ovarian mesonephric-like adenocarcinoma (MLA) is a newly described histological type known for its aggressive behavior. This study aims to determine the frequency of ovarian MLA, review the existing literature, and elucidate its clinicopathological characteristics, including the potential therapeutic targets.

METHODS

We retrospectively reviewed the pathological diagnoses of 501 primary ovarian cancer surgical cases at our institution from 2010 to 2023. MLAs exhibiting typical morphological and immunohistochemical features were included. The frequency and clinicopathological characteristics of these cases were summarized. Additionally, we conducted a literature search using PubMed to collect and summarize previously reported cases of ovarian MLAs.

RESULTS

Among the 501 primary ovarian cancer cases, we identified 3 cases (0.6%) of MLA. The patients were 52-76 years old, and the initial FIGO stages were IC1 (two cases) and IIIB (one case). All the cases exhibited HRP, pMMR, PD-L1 negativity (CPS < 1), and low HER2 expression. Two cases experienced metastatic recurrence. A literature review identified 97 cases of MLA. The MLAs frequently exhibited KRAS mutations (90%, 38/42), with a recurrence rate of 39% (26/67).

CONCLUSION

MLAs accounted for 0.6% of malignant ovarian tumors at our institution, all of which were advanced or recurrent cases. These cases showed HRP, pMMR, and PD-L1 negativity, indicating a lack of current therapeutic targets. The literature also reported a high incidence of advanced and recurrent cases, highlighting the need for accurate diagnosis and the development of new treatments. The frequent KRAS mutations suggest a potential therapeutic target for recurrent or metastatic MLA.

Female Adnexal Tumor of Probable Wolffian Origin (Wolffian Tumor): A Potential Mimic of Peritoneal Mesothelioma

Wolffian tumor and its nosologic relative, the recently defined STK11 adnexal tumor are rare neoplasms thought to arise from mesonephric remnants. These tumors typically arise in the broad ligament, fallopian tube, and ovarian hilum and although most are associated with a good prognosis, up to 50% of STK11 adnexal tumors demonstrate aggressive clinical behavior. The chief differential diagnoses include endometrioid adenocarcinoma and sex cord stromal tumors. However, the morphologic and immunohistochemical features of these tumors exhibit considerable overlap with peritoneal mesothelioma. To fully characterize their immunophenotypic signature, we examined a total of 21 cases (18 Wolffian and 3 STK11 adnexal tumors) with standard markers used in the diagnosis of mesothelioma. Morphologic and immunohistochemical (IHC) features were reviewed and additional IHC performed for cases with available material. Patient age ranged from 25 to 73 (mean: 51) years. Sites included adnexa/broad ligament (6, 28%), paratubal (5, 24%), ovary/paraovarian (5, 24%), tubal (intraluminal) (2, 9.5%), pelvis (2, 9.5%), and liver (1, 5%). The mean tumor size was 9.3 cm (range: 0.2 to 22 cm). The histomorphology in most cases (14/21, 66%) consisted of tubular to solid sheets of neoplastic cells lined by columnar to cuboidal cells containing uniform round to oval nuclei. Compressed tubules with slit-like lumens and sieve-like pattern were also seen in at least 7 (33%) cases. Three cases demonstrated interanastomosing cords and trabeculae of epithelioid cells with cribriform and microacinar patterns growing within prominent myxoid stroma as described in STK11 adnexal tumors. In the cases with available IHC for 3 mesothelial markers (calretinin, WT1, D2-40), 55.5% (5 of 9) showed reactivity with all 3 markers. In cases with at least 2 available mesothelial markers, 69% (11/16) were positive for 2 markers (mostly calretinin and WT1). Claudin-4, MOC31, and BER-EP4 were negative in most cases tested (78% [7/9], 71.4% [5/7], and 100% [6/6], respectively). Given the resemblance to mesothelioma, there was initial strong consideration and/or actual misdiagnosis of mesothelioma in 3 cases (14%). In summary, the morphologic and immunohistochemical features of Wolffian tumor and its recently defined relative, STK11 adnexal tumor, can lead to misdiagnosis of mesothelioma, particularly when encountered in the disseminated or metastatic setting. Wolffian tumor and STK11 adnexal tumor should be considered in the differential diagnosis of all pelvic and peritoneal mesotheliomas.

Synchronous Bilateral Ovarian Mesonephric-like Adenocarcinomas with Separate Origins from High-Grade Mullerian Adenosarcoma and Endometriosis: Report of a Rare Case

Mesonephric-like adenocarcinoma (MLA) of the ovary is a recently recognized, rare malignancy with aggressive clinical behavior, and is thought to originate from Mullerian epithelium with mesonephric transdifferentiation. Emerging evidence suggests that MLA may be classified as an endometriosis-associated neoplasm. The presence of a sarcomatous component within MLA is extremely rare, with common differential diagnoses including the spindle cell component of MLA, carcinosarcoma, as well as mixed Mullerian adenocarcinoma and adenosarcoma. Herein, we report a 58-year-old Chinese woman with bilateral ovarian solid-cystic masses. The left ovarian mass comprised a biphasic tumor with a predominantly high-grade sarcomatous component displaying heterologous mesenchymal differentiation, including liposarcoma, rhabdomyosarcoma and chondrosarcoma-like areas, with a null-type p53 expression. The epithelial component ranged from a bland appearance in areas diagnostic of adenosarcoma to a clearly invasive carcinoma, both with mesonephric-like phenotype, being negative for estrogen receptor, progesterone receptor, and Wilms' tumor 1, variably positive for paired box gene 8, GATA binding protein 3, and thyroid transcription factor 1, with a wild-type p53 expression. The differing p53 expression between the epithelial and sarcomatous elements mitigated against a diagnosis of carcinosarcoma. The right ovarian mass showed endometriosis with focal direct evidence of the development of malignancy within a benign endometriotic cyst, exhibiting the identical immunoprofile of MLA but originating as another malignancy. To the best of our knowledge, this case represents the first reported case of synchronous bilateral ovarian MLAs with separate origins, from high-grade Mullerian adenosarcoma and endometriosis respectively, which broadens the morphologic spectrum of MLA and provides further evidence supporting the Mullerian origin theory.

Mucinous cystadenoma and benign mesonephric-like proliferation in the ovary - Further evidence for clonal relationship

Mesonephric-like adenocarcinomas rarely occur in the uterus and the ovary. Benign mesonephric-like (ML) proliferations and hyperplasia have been described solely within the ovary. Pathogenetic data are very limited. We report a case with microscopic focus of benign ML-proliferation in association with mucinous cystadenoma in the ovary. The immunophenotype was distinct (mucinous tumor: focal weak nuclear positivity for PAX-8, CK 7, patchy cytoplasmic positivity for p16 and negativity for estrogen receptor, CD 10, TTF-1, p53 wildtype; mesonephric component: diffusely positive for PAX-8, CK 7, luminal CD 10, TTF-1, focal staining for estrogen receptor, patchy cytoplasmic for p16, p53 wildtype). On NGS-analysis there was clonal mutation of KRAS p.G12C. The data provide additional evidence for the concept of transdifferentiation (Müllerian tissue representing Wolffian/mesonephric features on histology and immunostaining) within the pathogenesis of mesonephric proliferation of the female genital tract and demonstrate the clonal relationship between these distinct morphologic components.

Pax-8: Molecular biology, pathophysiology, and potential pathogenesis

Transcription factors, as the convergence points of multiple signaling pathways in eukaryotic cells, are closely involved in disease development. Pax-8, an important transcription factor belonging to the Pax family, exerts a crucial influence on the regulation of gene expression required for both physiological conditions and pathological processes. Pax-8 contributes to the pathogenesis of many human diseases, ranging from cardiovascular disease to many cancers, and therefore, it can be imagined that Pax-8 holds great therapeutic potential. In this review, we summarize the structure, distribution, function, and regulatory mechanisms of Pax-8 to provide a new research direction for Pax-8.

Mesonephric and mesonephric-like adenocarcinomas of gynecologic origin: A single-center experience with molecular characterization, treatment, and oncologic outcomes

OBJECTIVES

Mesonephric (MA) and mesonephric-like (MLA) adenocarcinomas are rare cancers, and data on clinical behavior and response to therapy are limited. We sought to report molecular features, treatment, and outcomes of MA/MLA from a single institution.

METHODS

Patients with MA (cervix) or MLA (uterus, ovary, other) treated at Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center (MSK) from 1/2008-12/2021 underwent pathologic re-review. For patients with initial treatment at MSK, progression-free survival (PFS1) was calculated as time from initial surgery to progression or death; second PFS (PFS2) was calculated as time from start of treatment for recurrence to subsequent progression or death. Overall survival (OS) was calculated for all patients. Images were retrospectively reviewed to determine treatment response. Somatic genetic alterations were assessed by clinical tumor-normal sequencing (MSK-Integrated Mutation Profiling of Actionable Cancer Targets [MSK-IMPACT]).

RESULTS

Of 81 patients with confirmed gynecologic MA/MLA, 36 received initial treatment at MSK. Sites of origin included cervix (n = 9, 11%), uterus (n = 42, 52%), ovary (n = 28, 35%), and other (n = 2, 2%). Of the 36 patients who received initial treatment at MSK, 20 (56%) recurred; median PFS1 was 33 months (95% CI: 17-not evaluable), median PFS2 was 8.3 months (95% CI: 6.9-14), and median OS was 87 months (95% CI: 58.2-not evaluable). Twenty-six of the 36 patients underwent MSK-IMPACT testing, and 25 (96%) harbored MAPK pathway alterations.

CONCLUSION

Most patients diagnosed with early-stage disease ultimately recurred. Somatic MAPK signaling pathway mutations appear to be highly prevalent in MA/MLA, and therapeutics that target this pathway are worthy of further study.

Ovarian RASoma With Mesonephric-like Adenocarcinoma and Mixed Mullerian Components: A Case Report With Molecular Analysis Demonstrating Multidirectional Mullerian Differentiation

Gynecologic carcinomas with RAS mutations may show a wide spectrum of histologic types, including mixed types. We present the case of a 63-yr-old patient diagnosed with an ovarian tumor harboring a mesonephric-like adenocarcinoma in a background of mixed mesonephric-like, mucinous, and endometrioid components. Molecular analysis revealed that all 3 components shared the same clonal KRAS mutation (p.G12A) and chromosome 1q gain. Based on shifts in clonality, copy number gains, and acquisition of an additional mutation, our data suggest that the mucinous component likely constituted the substrate from which the mesonephric-like and endometrioid components arose.

Mesonephric-like adenocarcinoma of the female genital tract: possible role of KRAS-targeted treatment-detailed molecular analysis of a case series and review of the literature for targetable somatic KRAS-mutations

PURPOSE

Mesonephric-like adenocarcinomas (MLA) of the female genital tract represent a rare and relatively recently described neoplasm exhibiting characteristic morphologic and immunohistochemical findings commonly associated with a KRAS-mutation. Most cases display an aggressive clinical behavior, but knowledge about treatment approaches is limited, especially for targeting KRAS.

METHODS

We report a series of eight cases with a detailed molecular analysis for KRAS. These cases as well as the data of previously published cases with detailed information regarding KRAS-mutational events were reviewed for a potential targeted approach and its prognostic impact.

RESULTS

Both the uterine and ovarian MLA harbor a somatic KRAS-mutation in about 85% of the reported cases, affecting the hotspot codons 12 and 13. 15.7% of the endometrial and 15.6% of ovarian MLA are wild type for KRAS. A p.G12A-alteration was seen in 5.6% (5/89) of the endometrial and in 6.2% (2/32) of the ovarian tumors, for p.G12C in 7.9% and 6.2%, for p.G12D in 32.6% and 34.5% and for p.G12V in 36% and 37.5%, respectively. Very limited data are available regarding the prognostic impact of different mutational sites within the KRAS-gene without significant prognostic impact.

CONCLUSION

Because of a specific p.G12C-KRAS somatic mutation, only the minority of MLA (7.9% with uterine and 6.2% with ovarian primary) are potentially targetable by sotarasib in that rare but aggressive subtype of adenocarcinoma of the female genital tract. Until now, the different location of a somatic KRAS-mutation is of no prognostic impact.

Extrauterine Mesonephric-like Carcinoma: A Comprehensive Single Institution Study of 33 Cases

Extrauterine mesonephric-like carcinoma (ExUMLC) shares histologic, immunohistochemical (IHC), and molecular (MOL) features with endometrial mesonephric-like carcinoma (EnMLC). Its rarity and histologic overlap with Mullerian carcinomas contribute to underrecognition of ExUMLC. Aggressive behavior of EnMLC is well-documented; behavior of ExUMLC is yet to be characterized. This study presents the clinicopathologic, IHC, and MOL features of 33 ExUMLC identified over a 20-year time period (2002-2022) and compares the behavior of this cohort to more common upper gynecologic Mullerian carcinomas (low-grade endometrioid, LGEC; clear cell, CCC; high-grade serous, HGSC) and EnMLC diagnosed over the same time period. ExUMLC patients ranged from 37 to 74 years old (median=59 y); 13 presented with advanced stage (FIGO III/IV) disease. Most ExUMLC had the characteristic mixture of architectural patterns and cytologic features, as previously described. Two ExUMLC had sarcomatous differentiation, 1 with heterologous rhabdomyosarcoma. Twenty-one ExUMLC (63%) had associated endometriosis, and 7 (21%) arose in a borderline tumor. In 14 (42%) cases, ExUMLC was part of a mixed carcinoma representing >50% of the tumor in 12. Twenty-six cases (79%) were incorrectly classified as follows: LGEC or HGEC (12); adenocarcinoma, not otherwise specified (3); HGSC (3); LGSC (2); mixed carcinoma (1); carcinosarcoma, Mullerian type (2); seromucinous carcinoma (1); transitional pattern of HGSC (1); and female adnexal tumor of probable Wolffian origin (1). Three patients had occult synchronous endometrial LGEC. IHC facilitated diagnosis in all cases with an expression of GATA-3 and/or TTF-1 in conjunction with decreased hormone receptor expression in most tumors. MOL testing (n=20) identified a variety of mutations, most frequently: KRAS (15); TP53 (4); SPOP (4); and PIK3CA (4). ExUMLC and CCC were more likely to be associated with endometriosis ( P <0.0001). ExUMLC and HGSC had more recurrences compared with CCC and LGEC ( P <0.0001). Histologic subtype was associated with longer disease-free survival for LGEC and CCC versus HGSC and ExUMLC ( P <0.001). ExUMLC trended towards a similar poor overall survival as HGSC compared with LGEC and CCC, and EnMLC trended to shorter survival compared with ExUMLC. Neither finding reached significance. No differences were seen between EnMLC and ExUMLC with respect to presenting stage or recurrence. Staging, histotype, and endometriosis were associated with disease-free survival, but on multivariate analysis, only stage remained as an independent predictor of outcome. The tendency of ExUMLC to present at an advanced stage and have distant recurrence points to more aggressive behavior compared with LGEC with which it is most frequently confused, underscoring the importance of an accurate diagnosis.

Mesonephric Adenocarcinoma and Mesonephric-like Adenocarcinoma of the Urinary Tract

Given the association of mesonephric adenocarcinoma (MA) of the uterine cervix with florid mesonephric hyperplasia, one would expect MAs to rarely arise in other anatomical locations that harbor mesonephric remnants. In contrast, mesonephric-like adenocarcinoma (MLA) is thought to arise from Müllerian origin without an association with mesonephric remnants. The current case series characterizes 4 cases of MA arising in the urinary bladder (1 woman and 3 men), 1 case of MA in the perirenal region (woman), and 1 case of MLA in the ureter (woman). All cases displayed morphologic features similar to MA of the uterine cervix and MLA of the ovary and endometrium, characterized by predominant tubular and focal glandular/ductal architecture. Mesonephric remnants in the bladder wall were closely associated with adjacent MA in cases 1 and 4. MLA in case 6 was associated with mesonephric-like proliferations and endometriosis. All cases (6/6) were diffusely positive for Pax8, and all displayed a luminal pattern of CD10 staining, except case 4 for which CD10 immunostain was not available for review. Gata3 was either focally positive (cases 1, 2, and 6), negative (case 3), or diffusely positive (case 5). TTF-1 was diffusely expressed in cases 1 and 3 and negative in cases 2, 5, and 6. Although a KRAS G12C somatic mutation was detected in case 6, hotspot mutations in KRAS, NRAS, and PIK3CA were not present in other tested cases. Our study demonstrates that MAs and MLAs of the urinary tract share similar histopathogenesis, morphology, and immunophenotype to their counterparts in the female genital tract. We propose that, in the urinary tract, MA might be classified as a distinctive tumor that arises from mesonephric remnants or presumed Wolffian origin if they are not related to Müllerian-type precursors. The tumor displaying similar morphology and immunoprofile to MA but associated with Müllerian-type precursors should be classified as MLA.

Mesonephric-like Adenocarcinoma of the Female Genital Tract: From Morphologic Observations to a Well-characterized Carcinoma With Aggressive Clinical Behavior

Mesonephric-like adenocarcinoma (MLA) was introduced as a new tumor type in the endometrium and the ovary in the 2020 World Health Organization (WHO) Classification. This is a rare recently described (2016) and clinically aggressive carcinoma with a propensity for distant spread, especially to the lungs. MLA has a characteristic morphology and immunophenotype (hormone receptor negative; TTF1 and/or GATA3 positive). These neoplasms are commonly associated with KRAS and PIK3CA mutations and in the Cancer Genome Atlas (TCGA) molecular classification of endometrial carcinomas fall into the copy number low/no specific molecular profile category. Although they show significant morphological, immunophenotypic and molecular overlap with cervical mesonephric adenocarcinomas, there are other parameters which suggest a Mullerian origin and, as such, the term MLA seems apt. MLA can be added to the list of endometriosis-associated ovarian neoplasms. In this paper, I outline the series of events which lead to the first description of MLA and review the subsequent literature on this tumor type which has expanded on the morphologic features and immunophenotype, discovered the molecular underpinnings and elucidated the clinical behavior. The discovery of MLA represents an example of "new" entities still to this day being discovered through careful morphologic observations and referral of cases for specialist opinion.