Domain folding and flexibility of Escherichia coli FtsZ determined by tryptophan site-directed mutagenesis

Cell Division Protein FtsZ Is Unfolded for N-Terminal Degradation by Antibiotic-Activated ClpP

Acyldepsipeptide (ADEP) antibiotics effectively kill multidrug-resistant Gram-positive pathogens, including vancomycin-resistant enterococcus, penicillin-resistant Streptococcus pneumoniae (PRSP), and methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA). The antibacterial activity of ADEP depends on a new mechanism of action, i.e., the deregulation of bacterial protease ClpP that leads to bacterial self-digestion. Our data allow new insights into the mode of ADEP action by providing a molecular explanation for the distinct bacterial phenotypes observed at low versus high ADEP concentrations. In addition, we show that ClpP alone, in the absence of any unfoldase or energy-consuming system, and only activated by the small molecule antibiotic ADEP, leads to the unfolding of the cell division protein FtsZ.

Antibiotic acyldepsipeptides (ADEPs) deregulate ClpP, the proteolytic core of the bacterial Clp protease, thereby inhibiting its native functions and concomitantly activating it for uncontrolled proteolysis of nonnative substrates. Importantly, although ADEP-activated ClpP is assumed to target multiple polypeptide and protein substrates in the bacterial cell, not all proteins seem equally susceptible. In Bacillus subtilis, the cell division protein FtsZ emerged to be particularly sensitive to degradation by ADEP-activated ClpP at low inhibitory ADEP concentrations. In fact, FtsZ is the only bacterial protein that has been confirmed to be degraded in vitro as well as within bacterial cells so far. However, the molecular reason for this preferred degradation remained elusive. Here, we report the unexpected finding that ADEP-activated ClpP alone, in the absence of any Clp-ATPase, leads to an unfolding and subsequent degradation of the N-terminal domain of FtsZ, which can be prevented by the stabilization of the FtsZ fold via nucleotide binding. At elevated antibiotic concentrations, importantly, the C terminus of FtsZ is notably targeted for degradation in addition to the N terminus. Our results show that different target structures are more or less accessible to ClpP, depending on the ADEP level present. Moreover, our data assign a Clp-ATPase-independent protein unfolding capability to the ClpP core of the bacterial Clp protease and suggest that the protein fold of FtsZ may be more flexible than previously anticipated.

Bacterial cell division: modeling FtsZ assembly and force generation from single filament experimental data

The bacterial cytoskeletal protein FtsZ binds and hydrolyzes GTP, self-aggregates into dynamic filaments and guides the assembly of the septal ring on the inner side of the membrane at midcell. This ring constricts the cell during division and is present in most bacteria. Despite exhaustive studies undertaken in the last 25 years after its discovery, we do not yet know the mechanism by which this GTP-dependent self-aggregating protein exerts force on the underlying membrane. This paper reviews recent experiments and theoretical models proposed to explain FtsZ filament dynamic assembly and force generation. It highlights how recent observations of single filaments on reconstituted model systems and computational modeling are contributing to develop new multiscale models that stress the importance of previously overlooked elements as monomer internal flexibility, filament twist and flexible anchoring to the cell membrane. These elements contribute to understand the rich behavior of these GTP consuming dynamic filaments on surfaces. The aim of this review is 2-fold: (1) to summarize recent multiscale models and their implications to understand the molecular mechanism of FtsZ assembly and force generation and (2) to update theoreticians with recent experimental results.

The peroxyl radical-induced oxidation of Escherichia coli FtsZ and its single tryptophan mutant (Y222W) modifies specific side-chains, generates protein cross-links and affects biological function

FtsZ (filamenting temperature-sensitive mutant Z) is a key protein in bacteria cell division. The wild-type Escherichia coli FtsZ sequence (FtsZwt) contains three tyrosine (Tyr, Y) and sixteen methionine (Met, M) residues. The Tyr at position 222 is a key residue for FtsZ polymerization. Mutation of this residue to tryptophan (Trp, W; mutant Y222W) inhibits GTPase activity resulting in an extended time in the polymerized state compared to FtsZwt. Protein oxidation has been highlighted as a determinant process for bacteria resistance and consequently oxidation of FtsZwt and the Y222W mutant, by peroxyl radicals (ROO•) generated from AAPH (2,2'-azobis(2-methylpropionamidine) dihydrochloride) was studied. The non-oxidized proteins showed differences in their polymerization behavior, with this favored by the presence of Trp at position 222. AAPH-treatment of the proteins inhibited polymerization. Protein integrity studies using SDS-PAGE revealed the presence of both monomers and oligomers (dimers, trimers and high mass material) on oxidation. Western blotting indicated the presence of significant levels of protein carbonyls. Amino acid analysis showed that Tyr, Trp (in the Y222W mutant), and Met were consumed by ROO•. Quantification of the number of moles of amino acid consumed per mole of ROO• shows that most of the initial oxidant can be accounted for at low radical fluxes, with Met being a major target. Western blotting provided evidence for di-tyrosine cross-links in the dimeric and trimeric proteins, confirming that oxidation of Tyr residues, at positions 339 and/or 371, are critical to ROO•-mediated crosslinking of both the FtsZwt and Y222W mutant protein. These findings are in agreement with di-tyrosine, N-formyl kynurenine, and kynurenine quantification assessed by UPLC, and with LC-MS data obtained for AAPH-treated protein samples.

Flexibility in the Periplasmic Domain of BamA Is Important for Function

The β-barrel assembly machine (BAM) mediates the biogenesis of outer membrane proteins (OMPs) in Gram-negative bacteria. BamA, the central BAM subunit composed of a transmembrane β-barrel domain linked to five polypeptide transport-associated (POTRA) periplasmic domains, is thought to bind nascent OMPs and undergo conformational cycling to catalyze OMP folding and insertion. One model is that conformational flexibility between POTRA domains is part of this conformational cycling. Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy was used here to study the flexibility of the POTRA domains 1-5 in solution. NMR relaxation studies defined effective rotational correlational times and together with residual dipolar coupling data showed that POTRA1-2 is flexibly linked to POTRA3-5. Mutants of BamA that restrict flexibility between POTRA2 and POTRA3 by disulfide crosslinking displayed impaired function in vivo. Together these data strongly support a model in which conformational cycling of hinge motions between POTRA2 and POTRA3 in BamA is required for biological function.

Single tryptophan mutants of FtsZ: nucleotide binding/exchange and conformational transitions

Cell division protein FtsZ cooperatively self-assembles into straight filaments when bound to GTP. A set of conformational changes that are linked to FtsZ GTPase activity are involved in the transition from straight to curved filaments that eventually disassemble. In this work, we characterized the fluorescence of single Trp mutants as a reporter of the predicted conformational changes between the GDP- and GTP-states of Escherichia coli FtsZ. Steady-state fluorescence characterization showed the Trp senses different environments and displays low solvent accessibility. Time-resolved fluorescence data indicated that the main conformational changes in FtsZ occur at the interaction surface between the N and C domains, but also minor rearrangements were detected in the bulk of the N domain. Surprisingly, despite its location near the bottom protofilament interface at the C domain, the Trp 275 fluorescence lifetime did not report changes between the GDP and GTP states. The equilibrium unfolding of FtsZ features an intermediate that is stabilized by the nucleotide bound in the N-domain as well as by quaternary protein-protein interactions. In this context, we characterized the unfolding of the Trp mutants using time-resolved fluorescence and phasor plot analysis. A novel picture of the structural transition from the native state in the absence of denaturant, to the solvent-exposed unfolded state is presented. Taken together our results show that conformational changes between the GDP and GTP states of FtsZ, such as those observed in FtsZ unfolding, are restricted to the interaction surface between the N and C domains.

Polymorphism of FtsZ filaments on lipid surfaces: role of monomer orientation

FtsZ is a bacterial cytoskeletal protein involved in cell division. It forms a ringlike structure that attaches to the membrane to complete bacterial division. It binds and hydrolyzes GTP, assembling into polymers in a GTP-dependent manner. To test how the orientation of the monomers affects the curvature of the filaments on a surface, we performed site-directed mutagenesis on the E. coli FtsZ protein to insert cysteine residues at lateral locations to orient FtsZ on planar lipid bilayers. The E93C and S255C mutants were overproduced, purified, and found to be functionally active in solution, as well as being capable of sustaining cell division in vivo in complementation assays. Atomic force microscopy was used to observe the shape of the filament fibers formed on the surface. The FtsZ mutants were covalently linked to the lipids and could be polymerized on the bilayer surface in the presence of GTP. Unexpectedly, both mutants assembled into straight structures. E93C formed a well-defined lattice with monomers interacting at 60° and 120° angles, whereas S255C formed a more open array of straight thicker filament aggregates. These results indicate that filament curvature and bending are not fixed and that they can be modulated by the orientation of the monomers with respect to the membrane surface. As filament curvature has been associated with the force generation mechanism, these results point to a possible role of filament membrane attachment in lateral association and curvature, elements currently identified as relevant for force generation.

Genetic and biochemical characterization of the MinC-FtsZ interaction in Bacillus subtilis

Cell division in bacteria is regulated by proteins that interact with FtsZ and modulate its ability to polymerize into the Z ring structure. The best studied of these regulators is MinC, an inhibitor of FtsZ polymerization that plays a crucial role in the spatial control of Z ring formation. Recent work established that E. coli MinC interacts with two regions of FtsZ, the bottom face of the H10 helix and the extreme C-terminal peptide (CTP). Here we determined the binding site for MinC on Bacillus subtilis FtsZ. Selection of a library of FtsZ mutants for survival in the presence of Min overexpression resulted in the isolation of 13 Min-resistant mutants. Most of the substitutions that gave rise to Min resistance clustered around the H9 and H10 helices in the C-terminal domain of FtsZ. In addition, a mutation in the CTP of B. subtilis FtsZ also produced MinC resistance. Biochemical characterization of some of the mutant proteins showed that they exhibited normal polymerization properties but reduced interaction with MinC, as expected for binding site mutations. Thus, our study shows that the overall architecture of the MinC-FtsZ interaction is conserved in E. coli and B. subtilis. Nevertheless, there was a clear difference in the mutations that conferred Min resistance, with those in B. subtilis FtsZ pointing to the side of the molecule rather than to its polymerization interface. This observation suggests that the mechanism of Z ring inhibition by MinC differs in both species.

Glutamate 83 and arginine 85 of helix H3 bend are key residues for FtsZ polymerization, GTPase activity and cellular viability of Escherichia coli: lateral mutations affect FtsZ polymerization and E. coli viability

Background

FtsZ is an essential cell division protein, which localizes at the middle of the bacterial cell to mediate cytokinesis. In vitro, FtsZ polymerizes and induces GTPase activity through longitudinal interactions to form the protofilaments, whilst lateral interactions result within formation of bundles. The interactions that participate in the protofilaments are similar to its eukaryotic homologue tubulin and are well characterized; however, lateral interactions between the inter protofilaments are less defined. FtsZ forms double protofilaments in vitro, though the key elements on the interface of the inter-protofilaments remain unclear as well as the structures involved in the lateral interactions in vivo and in vitro. In this study, we demonstrate that the highly conserved negative charge of glutamate 83 and the positive charge of arginine 85 located in the helix H3 bend of FtsZ are required for in vitro FtsZ lateral and longitudinal interactions, respectively and for in vivo cell division.

Results

The effect of mutation on the widely conserved glutamate-83 and arginine-85 residues located in the helix H3 (present in most of the tubulin family) was evaluated by in vitro and in situ experiments. The morphology of the cells expressing Escherichia coli FtsZ (E83Q) mutant at 42°C formed filamented cells while those expressing FtsZ(R85Q) formed shorter filamented cells. In situ immunofluorescence experiments showed that the FtsZ(E83Q) mutant formed rings within the filamented cells whereas those formed by the FtsZ(R85Q) mutant were less defined. The expression of the mutant proteins diminished cell viability as follows: wild type > E83Q > R85Q. In vitro, both, R85Q and E83Q reduced the rate of FtsZ polymerization (WT > E83Q >> R85Q) and GTPase activity (WT > E83Q >> R85Q). R85Q protein polymerized into shorter filaments compared to WT and E83Q, with a GTPase lag period that was inversely proportional to the protein concentration. In the presence of ZipA, R85Q GTPase activity increased two fold, but no bundles were formed suggesting that lateral interactions were affected.

Conclusions

We found that glutamate 83 and arginine 85 located in the bend of helix H3 at the lateral face are required for the protofilament lateral interaction and also affects the inter-protofilament lateral interactions that ultimately play a role in the functional localization of the FtsZ ring at the cell division site.

Studies on the dissociation and urea-induced unfolding of FtsZ support the dimer nucleus polymerization mechanism

FtsZ is a major protein in bacterial cytokinesis that polymerizes into single filaments. A dimer has been proposed to be the nucleating species in FtsZ polymerization. To investigate the influence of the self-assembly of FtsZ on its unfolding pathway, we characterized its oligomerization and unfolding thermodynamics. We studied the assembly using size-exclusion chromatography and fluorescence spectroscopy, and the unfolding using circular dichroism and two-photon fluorescence correlation spectroscopy. The chromatographic analysis demonstrated the presence of monomers, dimers, and tetramers with populations dependent on protein concentration. Dilution experiments using fluorescent conjugates revealed dimer-to-monomer and tetramer-to-dimer dissociation constants in the micromolar range. Measurements of fluorescence lifetimes and rotational correlation times of the conjugates supported the presence of tetramers at high protein concentrations and monomers at low protein concentrations. The unfolding study demonstrated that the three-state unfolding of FtsZ was due to the mainly dimeric state of the protein, and that the monomer unfolds through a two-state mechanism. The monomer-to-dimer equilibrium characterized here (K(d) = 9 μM) indicates a significant fraction (~10%) of stable dimers at the critical concentration for polymerization, supporting a role of the dimeric species in the first steps of FtsZ polymerization.

The synaptic protein neuroligin-1 interacts with the amyloid β-peptide. Is there a role in Alzheimer's disease?

Amyloid β-peptide (Aβ) is the main component of the amyloid plaques associated with Alzheimer's disease (AD). In the early steps of the disease soluble Aβ oligomers are produced. According to the current "amyloid hypothesis" these oligomers can accumulate over time, leading progressively to the loss of synaptic function and the cognitive failure characteristic of AD. To understand the role of oligomeric Aβ species in AD pathology, it is important to understand the mechanism by which Aβ oligomers are targeted to synaptic junction. We report here the interaction between Aβ with neuroligin-1 (NL-1), a postsynaptic cell-adhesion protein specific for excitatory synapses, which shares a high degree of similarity with acetylcholinesterase, the first synaptic protein described to interact with Aβ. Using intrinsic fluorescence and surface plasmon resonance, we found that Aβ binds to the extracellular domain of NL-1 with a K(d) in the nanomolar range. In the case of NL-2, a postsynaptic cell-adhesion protein specific for inhibitory synapses, just a very weak interaction with Aβ was observed. Aβ polymerization analysis-studied by thioflavin-T assay and electron microscopy-indicated that NL-1 stabilized Aβ aggregates in vitro. Moreover, NL-1 acts as a nucleating factor during the Aβ aggregation process, stimulating the formation of Aβ oligomers. Besides, immunoprecipitation assays confirm that Aβ oligomers interact with NL-1 but not with NL-2. In conclusion, our results show that NL-1 interacts with Aβ increasing the formation of Aβ oligomers, suggesting that this interaction could triggers the targeting of Aβ oligomer to the postsynaptic regions of excitatory synapses.

The role of the local environment of engineered Tyr to Trp substitutions for probing the denaturation mechanism of FIS

Factor for inversion stimulation (FIS), a 98-residue homodimeric protein, does not contain tryptophan (Trp) residues but has four tyrosine (Tyr) residues located at positions 38, 51, 69, and 95. The equilibrium denaturation of a P61A mutant of FIS appears to occur via a three-state (N(2) ⇆ I(2) ⇆ 2U) process involving a dimeric intermediate (I(2)). Although it was suggested that this intermediate had a denatured C-terminus, direct evidence was lacking. Therefore, three FIS double mutants, P61A/Y38W, P61A/Y69W, and P61A/Y95W were made, and their denaturation was monitored by circular dichroism and Trp fluorescence. Surprisingly, the P61A/Y38W mutant best monitored the N(2) ⇆ I(2) transition, even though Trp38 is buried within the dimer removed from the C-terminus. In addition, although Trp69 is located on the protein surface, the P61A/Y69W FIS mutant exhibited clearly biphasic denaturation curves. In contrast, P61A/Y95W FIS was the least effective in decoupling the two transitions, exhibiting a monophasic fluorescence transition with modest concentration-dependence. When considering the local environment of the Trp residues and the effect of each mutation on protein stability, these results not only confirm that P61A FIS denatures via a dimeric intermediate involving a disrupted C-terminus but also suggest the occurrence of conformational changes near Tyr38. Thus, the P61A mutation appears to compromise the denaturation cooperativity of FIS by failing to propagate stability to those regions involved mostly in intramolecular interactions. Furthermore, our results highlight the challenge of anticipating the optimal location to engineer a Trp residue for investigating the denaturation mechanism of even small proteins.

Conformational changes of FtsZ reported by tryptophan mutants

E. coli FtsZ has no native tryptophan. We showed previously that the mutant FtsZ L68W gave a 2.5-fold increase in trp fluorescence when assembly was induced by GTP. L68 is probably buried in the protofilament interface upon assembly, causing the fluorescence increase. In the present study we introduced trp residues at several other locations and examined them for assembly-induced fluorescence changes. L189W, located on helix H7 and buried between the N- and C-terminal subdomains, showed a large fluorescence increase, comparable to L68W. This may reflect a shift or rotation of the two subdomains relative to each other. L160W showed a smaller increase in fluorescence, and Y222W a decrease in fluorescence, upon assembly. These two are located on the surface of the N and C subdomains, near the domain boundary. The changes in fluorescence may reflect movements of the domains or of nearby side chains. We prepared a double mutant Y222W/S151C and coupled ATTO-655 to the cys. The Cα of trp in the C-terminal subdomain was 10 Å away from that of the cys in the N-terminal subdomain, permitting the ATTO to make van der Waals contact with the trp. The ATTO fluorescence showed strong tryptophan-induced quenching. The quenching was reduced following assembly, consistent with a movement apart of the two subdomains. Movements of one to several angstroms are probably sufficient to account for the changes in trp fluorescence and trp-induced quenching of ATTO. Assembly in GDP plus DEAE dextran produces tubular polymers that are related to the highly curved, mini-ring conformation. No change in trp fluorescence was observed upon assembly of these tubes, suggesting that the mini-ring conformation is the same as that of a relaxed, monomeric FtsZ.

Mapping flexibility and the assembly switch of cell division protein FtsZ by computational and mutational approaches

The molecular switch for nucleotide-regulated assembly and disassembly of the main prokaryotic cell division protein FtsZ is unknown despite the numerous crystal structures that are available. We have characterized the functional motions in FtsZ with a computational consensus of essential dynamics, structural comparisons, sequence conservation, and networks of co-evolving residues. Employing this information, we have constructed 17 mutants, which alter the FtsZ functional cycle at different stages, to modify FtsZ flexibility. The mutant phenotypes ranged from benign to total inactivation and included increased GTPase, reduced assembly, and stabilized assembly. Six mutations clustering at the long cleft between the C-terminal beta-sheet and core helix H7 deviated FtsZ assembly into curved filaments with inhibited GTPase, which still polymerize cooperatively. These mutations may perturb the predicted closure of the C-terminal domain onto H7 required for switching between curved and straight association modes and for GTPase activation. By mapping the FtsZ assembly switch, this work also gives insight into FtsZ druggability because the curved mutations delineate the putative binding site of the promising antibacterial FtsZ inhibitor PC190723.