Detecting equilibrium cytochrome c folding intermediates by electrospray ionisation mass spectrometry: two partially folded forms populate the molten-globule state

Observation of Protein Unfolding during pH Ramp Evoked by Lipase-Catalyzed Ester Hydrolysis

Studies of protein folding often involve offline experimental methods such as titrating protein samples with denaturants or equilibrating them in the presence of denaturants. Here, we demonstrate an online analytical approach in which the protein structure is perturbed by a pH ramp evoked by immobilized lipase-catalyzed ester hydrolysis. Changes in the tertiary structure of the protein in response to a pH ramp (from approximately 6.3 to 2.8) are monitored using electrospray ionization mass spectrometry and spectrofluorometry. Interestingly, we discovered a side reaction of ammonium and formate leading to the production of cyanide that occurred during the ionization process. We also found that only certain protein analytes were bound to the formed cyanide species. Nevertheless, this problem was readily overcome by carefully selecting a specific ester substrate. Overall, the alterations in the charge-state distribution and fluorescence intensity─caused by the lipase-induced pH ramp─reveal conformational transitions in different proteins. In line with previous reports, the acid-induced denaturation of holo-myoglobin occurs through a two-step mechanism, which is supported by identification of protein-unfolding intermediates and the loss of noncovalent protein ligand (heme). The results─obtained using the developed catalytic method─are also consistent with the results of equilibrium-based experiments, while sample preparation steps are substantially reduced. The proposed approach simplifies the identification of the pH range that has the greatest impact on the protein structure. Thus, it has the potential to be a useful tool for studying protein conformational transitions in the course of pH changes.

Effects of Hydrogen/Deuterium Exchange on Protein Stability in Solution and in the Gas Phase

Mass spectrometry (MS)-based techniques are widely used for probing protein structure and dynamics in solution. H/D exchange (HDX)-MS is one of the most common approaches in this context. HDX is often considered to be a "benign" labeling method, in that it does not perturb protein behavior in solution. However, several studies have reported that D₂O pushes unfolding equilibria toward the native state. The origin, and even the existence of this protein stabilization remain controversial. Here we conducted thermal unfolding assays in solution to confirm that deuterated proteins in D₂O are more stable, with 2-4 K higher melting temperatures than unlabeled proteins in H₂O. Previous studies tentatively attributed this phenomenon to strengthened H-bonds after deuteration, an effect that may arise from the lower zero-point vibrational energy of the deuterated species. Specifically, it was proposed that strengthened water-water bonds (W···W) in D₂O lower the solubility of nonpolar side chains. The current work takes a broader view by noting that protein stability in solution also depends on water-protein (W···P) and protein-protein (P···P) H-bonds. To help unravel these contributions, we performed collision-induced unfolding (CIU) experiments on gaseous proteins generated by native electrospray ionization. CIU profiles of deuterated and unlabeled proteins were indistinguishable, implying that P···P contacts are insensitive to deuteration. Thus, protein stabilization in D₂O is attributable to solvent effects, rather than alterations of intraprotein H-bonds. Strengthening of W···W contacts represents one possible explanation, but the stabilizing effect of D₂O can also originate from weakened W···P bonds. Future work will be required to elucidate which of these two scenarios is correct, or if both contribute to protein stabilization in D₂O. In any case, the often-repeated adage that "D-bonds are more stable than H-bonds" does not apply to intramolecular contacts in native proteins.

Scanning pH-metry for Observing Reversibility in Protein Folding

One of the main factors affecting protein structure in solution is pH. Traditionally, to study pH-dependent conformational changes in proteins, the concentration of the H+ ions is adjusted manually, complicating real-time analyses, hampering dynamic pH regulation, and consequently leading to a limited number of tested pH levels. Here, we present a programmable device, a scanning pH-meter, that can automatically generate different types of pH ramps and waveforms in a solution. A feedback loop algorithm calculates the required flow rates of the acid/base titrants, allowing one, for example, to generate periodic pH sine waveforms to study the reversibility of protein folding by fluorescence spectroscopy. Interestingly, for some proteins, the fluorescence intensity profiles recorded in such a periodically oscillating pH environment display hysteretic behavior indicating an asymmetry in the sequence of the protein unfolding/refolding events, which can most likely be attributed to their distinct kinetics. Another useful application of the scanning pH-meter concerns coupling it with an electrospray ionization mass spectrometer to observe pH-induced structural changes in proteins as revealed by their varying charge-state distributions. We anticipate a broad range of applications of the scanning pH-meter developed here, including protein folding studies, determination of the optimum pH for achieving maximum fluorescence intensity, and characterization of fluorescent dyes and other synthetic materials.

Native mass spectrometry for the investigation of protein structural (dis)order

A central challenge in structural biology is represented by dynamic and heterogeneous systems, as typically represented by proteins in solution, with the extreme case of intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) [1-3]. These proteins lack a specific three-dimensional structure and have poorly organized secondary structure. For these reasons, they escape structural characterization by conventional biophysical methods. The investigation of these systems requires description of conformational ensembles, rather than of unique, defined structures or bundles of largely superimposable structures. Mass spectrometry (MS) has become a central tool in this field, offering a variety of complementary approaches to generate structural information on either folded or disordered proteins [4-6]. Two main categories of methods can be recognized. On one side, conformation-dependent reactions (such as cross-linking, covalent labeling, H/D exchange) are exploited to label molecules in solution, followed by the characterization of the labeling products by denaturing MS [7-11]. On the other side, non-denaturing ("native") MS can be used to directly explore the different conformational components in terms of geometry and structural compactness [12-16]. All these approaches have in common the capability to conjugate protein structure investigation with the peculiar analytical power of MS measurements, offering the possibility of assessing species distributions for folding and binding equilibria and the combination of both. These methods can be combined with characterization of noncovalent complexes [17, 18] and post-translational modifications [19-23]. This review focuses on the application of native MS to protein structure and dynamics investigation, with a general methodological section, followed by examples on specific proteins from our laboratory.

Insights into Fluctuations of Structure of Proteins: Significance of Intermediary States in Regulating Biological Functions

Proteins are indispensable to cellular communication and metabolism. The structure on which cells and tissues are developed is deciphered from proteins. To perform functions, proteins fold into a three-dimensional structural design, which is specific and fundamentally determined by their characteristic sequence of amino acids. Few of them have structural versatility, allowing them to adapt their shape to the task at hand. The intermediate states appear momentarily, while protein folds from denatured (D) ⇔ native (N), which plays significant roles in cellular functions. Prolific effort needs to be taken in characterizing these intermediate species if detected during the folding process. Protein folds into its native structure through definite pathways, which involve a limited number of transitory intermediates. Intermediates may be essential in protein folding pathways and assembly in some cases, as well as misfolding and aggregation folding pathways. These intermediate states help to understand the machinery of proper folding in proteins. In this review article, we highlight the various intermediate states observed and characterized so far under in vitro conditions. Moreover, the role and significance of intermediates in regulating the biological function of cells are discussed clearly.

Sample Flow Rate Scan in Electrospray Ionization Mass Spectrometry Reveals Alterations in Protein Charge State Distribution

Sample flow rate is one of the parameters that influence the sensitivity of electrospray ionization (ESI) mass spectrometry. By varying the sample flow rate, initial droplets of different sizes can be generated. Protein molecules in small droplets may form gas-phase ions earlier than the ones in large droplets. Here, we have systematically studied the influence of sample flow rate on the ESI charge state distributions (CSDs) of model proteins. A dedicated programmable sample flow rate scanner was used to infuse protein samples at different flow rates into a mass spectrometer. The synergistic influence of sample flow rate and various electrolytes (ammonium acetate, ammonium bicarbonate, ammonium formate, and piperidine) was studied. Significant alterations to the CSDs with increasing flow rate were observed. For example, in the presence of ammonium acetate, at low flow rates, lower charge states of proteins showed high intensities, while at high flow rates, ions related to higher charge states of proteins dominated the spectra. On the other hand, in the presence of piperidine, a significant reduction in the ion currents of all charge states was observed during the flow rate scan. Our observations suggest that at low flow rates the protein molecules follow a charged residue model of ionization mechanism, and at high flow rates-due to structural changes in protein molecules in large ESI droplets-the charged residue and chain ejection models can possibly coexist. We propose the use of sample flow rate scan as a way to reveal the influence of flow rate on the CSDs of the studied proteins.

Supercharging and multiple reaction monitoring of high-molecular-weight intact proteins using triple quadrupole mass spectrometry

RATIONALE

Different supercharging agents were tested to study their effect on the intensity and charge state distributions of high-molecular-weight intact proteins. The goal of this work was to increase chargeability and ionization efficiency for proteins ranging from 66 to 150 kDa, to enable subsequent optimization of multiple reaction monitoring (MRM) mode transitions with a triple quadrupole mass spectrometer for potential top-down quantitative analysis.

METHODS

Supercharging agents, such as meta-nitrobenzyl alcohol (m-NBA), dimethylsulfoxide, trifluoroethanol (TFE), and sulfolane were tested in different concentrations in 50/50 acetonitrile/water with 0.5% formic acid to examine the electrospray ionization response for three model proteins: bovine serum albumin (66 kDa), holo-transferrin (78 kDa), and immunoglobulin G (150 kDa). The settings of ionization source temperature and mobile phase flow rate were also examined. MRM transitions were developed for a wide range of precursor ions for each protein, and limits of detection were determined for the proteins in the presence of favorable additive combinations.

RESULTS

For most of the proteins, m-NBA (1%) and TFE (5%) worked most effectively, both to shift the charge state and increase intensity. This is the first report of the use of TFE as an effective agent for both increasing protein chargeability and ionization response. TFE increased ionization efficiency between 3- and 14-fold for the model proteins studied. Increases in both source temperature and flow rate reduced the magnitude of the average charge state observed. The MRM transitions of six to eight different precursor ions of the proteins were optimized and limits of detection in the nanogram quantity on column were determined.

CONCLUSIONS

The feasibility for top-down quantitative analysis of high-molecular-weight proteins with a triple quadrupole mass spectrometer was demonstrated. Further, additives such as TFE can be highly beneficial for increased chargeability and response of the proteins.

pH Dependence of the Number of Discrete Conformers of Carbonic Anhydrase 2, as Evaluated from Collision Cross-Section Using Ion Mobility Coupled with Electrospray Ionization

Ion mobility experiments coupled with electrospray ionization (ESI) were conducted to evaluate the folding states of bovine carbonic anhydrase 2 (CA2) under three different pH conditions. Collision cross-section (CCS) of the CA2 ions generated by ESI revealed the presence of six discrete conformers in the gas phase under the conditions employed in this study. The CCS of the most extended conformer was three times larger than that of the most compact one. The charge state distribution of the CA2 ions was indicative of three conformers being present. Although there was consistency in conformer assignment conducted by CCS and charge state distribution, the CCS measurement was shown to be more effective because the information obtained provided more detailed knowledge of the conformation of the protein.

Addressing a Common Misconception: Ammonium Acetate as Neutral pH "Buffer" for Native Electrospray Mass Spectrometry

Native ESI-MS involves the transfer of intact proteins and biomolecular complexes from solution into the gas phase. One potential pitfall is the occurrence of pH-induced changes that can affect the analyte while it is still surrounded by solvent. Most native ESI-MS studies employ neutral aqueous ammonium acetate solutions. It is a widely perpetuated misconception that ammonium acetate buffers the analyte solution at neutral pH. By definition, a buffer consists of a weak acid and its conjugate weak base. The buffering range covers the weak acid pK_a ± 1 pH unit. NH₄⁺ and CH₃-COO^- are not a conjugate acid/base pair, which means that they do not constitute a buffer at pH 7. Dissolution of ammonium acetate salt in water results in pH 7, but this pH is highly labile. Ammonium acetate does provide buffering around pH 4.75 (the pK_a of acetic acid) and around pH 9.25 (the pK_a of ammonium). This implies that neutral ammonium acetate solutions electrosprayed in positive ion mode will likely undergo acidification down to pH 4.75 ± 1 in the ESI plume. Ammonium acetate nonetheless remains a useful additive for native ESI-MS. It is a volatile electrolyte that can mimic the solvation properties experienced by proteins under physiological conditions. Also, a drop from pH 7 to around pH 4.75 is less dramatic than the acidification that would take place in pure water. It is hoped that the habit of referring to pH 7 solutions as ammonium acetate "buffer" will disappear from the literature. Ammonium acetate "solution" should be used instead. Graphical Abstract ᅟ.

Conformational effects in protein electrospray-ionization mass spectrometry

Electrospray-ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) is a key tool of structural biology, complementing the information delivered by conventional biochemical and biophysical methods. Yet, the mechanism behind the conformational effects in protein ESI-MS is an object of debate. Two parameters-solvent-accessible surface area (As) and apparent gas-phase basicity (GBapp)-are thought to play a role in controlling the extent of protein ionization during ESI-MS experiments. This review focuses on recent experimental and theoretical investigations concerning the influence of these parameters on ESI-MS results and the structural information that can be derived. The available evidence supports a unified model for the ionization mechanism of folded and unfolded proteins. These data indicate that charge-state distribution (CSD) analysis can provide valuable structural information on normally folded, as well as disordered structures.

Insights into the mechanism of protein electrospray ionization from salt adduction measurements

The mechanisms whereby protein ions are liberated from charged droplets during electrospray ionization (ESI) remain under investigation. Compact conformers electrosprayed from aqueous solution in positive ion mode likely follow the charged residue model (CRM), which envisions analyte release after solvent evaporation to dryness. The concentration of nonvolatile salts such as NaCl increases sharply within vanishing CRM droplets, promoting nonspecific pairing of Cl(-) and Na(+) with charged groups on the protein surface. For unfolded proteins, it has been proposed that ion formation occurs via the chain ejection model (CEM). During the CEM proteins are expelled from the droplet long before complete solvent evaporation has taken place. Here we examine whether salt adduction levels support the view that folded and unfolded proteins follow different ESI mechanisms. Solvent evaporation during the CEM is expected to be less extensive and, hence, the salt concentration at the point of protein release should be substantially lower than for the CRM. CEM ions should therefore exhibit lower adduction levels than CRM species. We explore the adduction behavior of several proteins that were chosen to allow comparative studies on folded and unfolded structures in the same solution. In-source activation eliminates chloride adducts via HCl release, generating protein ions that are heterogeneously charged because of sodiation and protonation. Sodiation levels measured under such conditions provide estimates of the salt adduction behavior experienced by the "nascent" analyte ions. Sodiation levels are significantly reduced for unfolded proteins, supporting the view that these species are indeed formed via the CEM.

The pH Dependence of Product Ion Spectra Obtained from Precursor Ions with the Same Charge Number in ESI of Carbonic Anhydrase 2

The effect of solvent conditions, including pH, on product ion spectra obtained from precursor ions produced by electrospray ionization (ESI) was examined. Bovine carbonic anhydrase 2 was used as a model protein and the product ions generated by collision induced dissociation of the whole protein were measured under several different solvent conditions (pH 5.0, 3.7, and 0.1% HCOOH (pH 2.6)/MeCN (1/1)). The product ion spectra from precursor ions with the same charge number, the observed m/z values and the relative intensities of the product ions were similar. It therefore appears that the solvent conditions used have no effect on the product ion that is generated. On the other hand, different profiles of the product ion were obtained from precursor ions having different charge numbers. This indicates that the charge number of the precursor ion appears to be a major determinant of the product ion species and its relative intensity in product ion spectra of proteins.

Mass spectrometry-based methods to study protein architecture and dynamics

Mass spectrometry is now an indispensable tool in the armamentarium of molecular biophysics, where it is used for tasks ranging from protein sequencing and mapping of post-translational modifications to studies of higher order structure, conformational dynamics, and interactions of proteins with small molecule ligands and other biopolymers. This mini-review highlights several popular mass spectrometry-based tools that are now commonly used for structural studies of proteins beyond their covalent structure with a particular emphasis on hydrogen exchange and direct electrospray ionization mass spectrometry.

Nanocluster isotope distributions measured by electrospray time-of-flight mass spectrometry

Electrospray ionization (ESI) mass spectrometry (MS) is a widely used tool for the characterization of organometallic nanoclusters. By matching experimental mass spectra with calculated isotope distributions it is possible to determine the elemental composition of these analytes. In this work we conduct ESI-MS investigations on M(14)E(13)Cl(2)(tmeda)(6) nanoclusters, where M is a transition metal, E represents a chalcogen, and tmeda is N,N,N',N'-tetramethyl-ethylenediamine. ESI mass spectra of these systems agree poorly with theoretical isotope distributions when data are acquired under standard conditions. This behavior is attributed to dead-time artifacts of the time-of-flight (TOF) analyzer used. It is well-known that excessively high TOF ion count rates lead to dead-time issues. Surprisingly, our data reveal that nanocluster spectra are affected by this problem even at moderate signal intensities that do not cause any problems for other types of analytes. This unexpected vulnerability is attributed to the extremely wide isotope distributions of the nanoclusters studied here. A good match between experimental and calculated nanocluster spectra is obtained only at ion count rates that are more than 1 order of magnitude below commonly used levels. Discrepancies between measured and theoretical isotope distributions have been observed in a number of previous ESI-MS nanocluster investigations. The dead-time issue identified here likely represents a contributing factor to the spectral distortions that were observed in those earlier studies. Using low-intensity ESI-MS conditions we demonstrate the feasibility of analyzing highly heterogeneous nanocluster samples that comprise subpopulations with a wide range of metal compositions.

Creation of an artificial metalloprotein with a Hoveyda-Grubbs catalyst moiety through the intrinsic inhibition mechanism of α-chymotrypsin

An L-phenylalanyl chloromethylketone-based inhibitor equipped with a Hoveyda-Grubbs catalyst moiety was regioselectively incorporated into the cleft of α-chymotrypsin through the intrinsic inhibition mechanism of the protein to construct an artificial organometallic protein.

Vapor treatment of electrospray droplets: evidence for the folding of initially denatured proteins on the sub-millisecond time-scale

The exposure of electrospray droplets generated from either highly acidic or highly basic solutions to basic or acidic vapors, respectively, admitted into the counter-current drying gas, has been shown to lead to significant changes in the observed charge state distributions of proteins. In both cases, distributions of charge states changed from relatively high charge states, indicative of largely denatured proteins, to lower charge state distributions that are more consistent with native protein conformations. Ubiquitin, cytochrome c, myoglobin, and carbonic anhydrase were used as model systems. In some cases, bimodal distributions were observed that are not noted under any solution pH conditions. The extent to which changes in charge state distributions occur depends upon the initial solution pH and the pK(a) or pK(b) of the acidic or basic reagent, respectively. The evolution of charged droplets in the sampling region of the mass spectrometer inlet aperture, where the vapor exposure takes place, occurs within roughly 1 ms. The observed changes in the spectra, therefore, are a function of the magnitude of the pH change as well as the rates at which the proteins can respond to this change. The exposure of electrospray droplets in this fashion may provide means for accessing transient folding states for further characterization by mass spectrometry.

Advanced mass spectrometry-based methods for the analysis of conformational integrity of biopharmaceutical products

Mass spectrometry has already become an indispensable tool in the analytical armamentarium of the biopharmaceutical industry, although its current uses are limited to characterization of covalent structure of recombinant protein drugs. However, the scope of applications of mass spectrometry-based methods is beginning to expand to include characterization of the higher order structure and dynamics of biopharmaceutical products, a development which is catalyzed by the recent progress in mass spectrometry-based methods to study higher order protein structure. The two particularly promising methods that are likely to have the most significant and lasting impact in many areas of biopharmaceutical analysis, direct ESI MS and hydrogen/deuterium exchange, are focus of this article.

Conformer-specific hydrogen exchange analysis of Aβ(1-42) oligomers by top-down electron capture dissociation mass spectrometry

Protein structural studies are particularly challenging under conditions in which several conformational species (e.g., monomers and aggregated forms) coexist in solution. Most spectroscopic techniques provide population-averaged data. Hence, it is usually not possible to obtain detailed structural information on individual protein species in heterogeneous samples. The current work employs an experimental strategy that addresses this issue. Solution-phase hydrogen exchange (HX) is used in combination with tandem mass spectrometry. Electrosprayed intact ions exhibiting specific HX mass shifts are selected in the gas phase, followed by electron capture dissociation. The resulting fragment ion deuteration pattern provides amide hydrogen bonding information in a conformer-specific and spatially resolved fashion. The feasibility of this approach is demonstrated by applying it to neurotoxic Aβ(1-42) oligomers that coexist with disordered monomers in solution. The findings of this study point to similarities between oligomers and mature amyloid fibrils with regard to the Aβ(1-42) backbone organization. Specifically, fibrils and oligomers appear to share a β-loop-β secondary structure motif. The spatial resolution obtained with the "top-down" approach used here exceeds that of earlier proteolysis-based HX data on Aβ.

Protein-protein binding affinities in solution determined by electrospray mass spectrometry

Electrospray ionization (ESI) allows the transfer of multi-protein complexes into the gas phase, thereby providing a simple approach for monitoring the stoichiometry of these noncovalent assemblies by mass spectrometry (MS). It remains unclear, however, whether the measured ion abundance ratios of free and bound species are suitable for determining solution-phase binding affinities (K(d) values). Many types of mass spectrometers employ rf-only quadrupoles as ion guides. This work demonstrates that the settings used for these devices are a key factor for ensuring uniform transmission behavior, which is a prerequisite for meaningful affinity measurements. Using bovine β-lactoglobulin and hemoglobin as model systems, it is demonstrated that under carefully adjusted conditions the "direct" ESI-MS approach is capable of providing K(d) values that are in good agreement with previously published solution-phase data. Of the several ion sources tested, a regular ESI emitter operated with pressure-driven flow at 1 μL min(-1) provided the most favorable results. Potential problems in these experiments include conformationally-induced differences in ionization efficiencies, inadvertent collision-induced dissociation, and ESI-induced clustering artifacts. A number of simple tests can be conducted to assess whether or not these factors are prevalent under the conditions used. In addition, the fidelity of the method can be scrutinized by performing measurements over a wide concentration range. Overall, this work supports the viability of the direct ESI-MS approach for determining binding affinities of protein-protein complexes in solution.

Electrospray droplet exposure to gaseous acids for the manipulation of protein charge state distributions

The exposure of electrospray droplets to acid vapors can significantly affect protein charge state distributions (CSDs) derived from unbuffered solutions. Such experiments have been conducted by leaking acidic vapors into the counter-current nitrogen drying gas of an electrospray interface. On the basis of changes in protein CSDs, protein folding and unfolding phenomena are implicated in these studies. Additionally, noncovalently bound complexes are preserved, and transient intermediates are observed, such as high charge state ions of holomyoglobin. CSDs of proteins containing disulfide bonds shift slightly, if at all, with acid vapor leak-in, but when these disulfide bonds are reduced in solution, charge states higher than the number of basic sites (Lys, Arg, His, and N-terminus) are observed. Since there is no observed change in the CSD of buffered proteins exposed to acidic vapors, this novel multiple charging phenomenon is attributed to a pH effect. Thus, this acid vapor leak-in approach can be used to reverse "wrong-way-round" nanoelectrospray conditions by altering solution pH in the charged droplets relative to the pH in bulk solution. In general, the exposure of electrospray droplets to acidic vapors provides means for altering protein CSDs independent of bulk unbuffered solution pH.

Characterization of intrinsically disordered proteins with electrospray ionization mass spectrometry: conformational heterogeneity of alpha-synuclein

Conformational heterogeneity of alpha-synuclein was studied with electrospray ionization mass spectrometry by analyzing protein ion charge state distributions, where the extent of multiple charging reflects compactness of the protein conformations in solution. Although alpha-synuclein lacks a single well-defined structure under physiological conditions, it was found to sample four distinct conformational states, ranging from a highly structured one to a random coil. The compact highly structured state of alpha-synuclein is present across the entire range of conditions tested (pH ranging from 2.5 to 10, alcohol content from 0% to 60%), but is particularly abundant in acidic solutions. The only other protein state populated in acidic solutions is a partially folded intermediate state lacking stable tertiary structure. Another, more compact intermediate state is induced by significant amounts of ethanol used as a co-solvent and appears to represent a partially folded conformation with high beta-sheet content. Protein dimerization is observed throughout the entire range of conditions tested, although only acidic solutions favor formation of highly structured dimers of alpha-synuclein. These dimers are likely to present the earliest stages in protein aggregation leading to globular oligomers and, subsequently, protofibrils.

Time-dependent changes in side-chain solvent accessibility during cytochrome c folding probed by pulsed oxidative labeling and mass spectrometry

The current work employs a novel approach for characterizing structural changes during the refolding of acid-denatured cytochrome c (cyt c). At various time points (ranging from 10 ms to 5 min) after a pH jump from 2 to 7, the protein is exposed to a microsecond hydroxyl radical (.OH) pulse that induces oxidative labeling of solvent-exposed side chains. Most of the covalent modifications appear as +16-Da adducts that are readily detectable by mass spectrometry. The overall extent of labeling decreases as folding proceeds, reflecting dramatic changes in the accessibility of numerous residues. Peptide mapping and tandem mass spectrometry reveal that the side chains of C14, C17, H33, F46, Y48, W59, M65, Y67, Y74, M80, I81, and Y97 are among the dominant sites of oxidation. Temporal changes in the accessibility of these residues are consistent with docking of the N- and C-terminal helices as early as 10 ms. However, structural reorganization at the helix interface takes place up to at least 1 s. Initial misligation of the heme iron by H33 leads to distal crowding, giving rise to low solvent accessibility of the displaced (native) M80 ligand and the adjacent I81. W59 retains a surprisingly high level of accessibility long into the folding process, indicating the presence of packing defects in the hydrophobically collapsed core. Overall, the results of this work are consistent with previous hydrogen/deuterium exchange studies that proposed a foldon-mediated mechanism. The structural data obtained by .OH labeling monitor the packing and burial of side chains, whereas hydrogen/deuterium exchange primarily monitors the formation of secondary structure elements. Hence, the two approaches yield complementary information. Considering the very short time scale of pulsed oxidative labeling, an extension of the approach used here to sub-millisecond folding studies should be feasible.

Discrimination among IgG1-kappa monoclonal antibodies produced by two cell lines using charge state distributions in nanoESI-TOF mass spectra

Charge state distributions (CSDs) of proteins in nanoESI mass spectra are affected by the instrumental settings and experimental conditions, in addition to the conformations of the proteins in the analyzed solutions. In the presented study, instrumental and experimental parameters--the desolvation gas flow rate, temperature, pH, buffer (ammonium acetate), and organic modifier (methanol) concentrations--were optimized according to a reduced central composite face experimental design to maximize the separation of CSDs of monoclonal IgG1-kappa antibodies produced by two production systems (CHO and GS-NS0 cell lines). Principal component analysis and Fisher linear discriminant analysis were then used to reduce the dimensions of the acquired dataset and quantify the separation of the protein classes, respectively. The results show that the IgG1-kappa molecules produced by the two production systems can be clearly distinguished using the described approach, which could be readily applied to other proteins and production systems.

Irreversible thermal denaturation of cytochrome C studied by electrospray mass spectrometry

This work uses electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) in conjunction with hydrogen/deuterium exchange (HDX) and optical spectroscopy for characterizing the solution-phase properties of cytochrome c (cyt c) after heat exposure. Previous work demonstrated that heating results in irreversible denaturation for a subpopulation of proteins in the sample. However, that study did not investigate the physical reasons underlying this interesting effect. Here we report that the formation of oxidative modifications at elevated temperature plays a key role for the observed behavior. Tryptic digestion followed by tandem mass spectrometry is used to identify individual oxidation sites. Trp59 and Met80 are among the modified amino acids. In native cyt c both of these residues are buried deep within the protein structure, such that covalent modifications would be expected to be particularly disruptive. ESI-MS analysis after heat exposure results in a bimodal charge-state distribution. Oxidized protein appears predominantly in charge states around 11+, whereas a considerably lower degree of oxidation is observed for the 7+ and 8+ peaks. This finding confirms that different oxidation levels are associated with different solution-phase conformations. HDX measurements for different charge states are complicated by peak distortions arising from oxygen adduction. Nonetheless, comparison with simulated peak shapes clearly shows that the HDX properties are different for high- and low-charge states, confirming that interconversion between unfolded and folded conformers is blocked in solution. In addition to oxidation, partial aggregation upon heat exposure likely contributes to the formation of irreversibly denatured protein.

Protein structure and dynamics studied by mass spectrometry: H/D exchange, hydroxyl radical labeling, and related approaches

Mass spectrometry (MS) plays a central role in studies on protein structure and dynamics. This review highlights some of the recent developments in this area, with focus on applications involving the use of electrospray ionization (ESI) MS. Although this technique involves the transformation of analytes into highly nonphysiological species (desolvated gas-phase ions in the vacuum), ESI-MS can provide detailed insights into the solution-phase behavior of proteins. Notably, the ionization process itself occurs in a structurally sensitive manner. An increased degree of solution-phase unfolding is correlated with a higher level of protonation. Also, ESI allows the transfer of intact noncovalent complexes into the gas phase, thereby yielding information on binding partners, stoichiometries, and even affinities. A particular focus of this article is the use of hydrogen/deuterium exchange (HDX) methods and hydroxyl radical (.OH) labeling for monitoring dynamic and structural aspect of solution-phase proteins. Conceptual similarities and differences between the two methods are discussed. We describe a simple method for the computational simulation of protein HDX patterns, a tool that can be helpful for the interpretation of isotope exchange data recorded under mixed EX1/EX2 conditions. Important aspects of .OH labeling include a striking dependence on protein concentration, and the tendency of commonly used solvent additives to act as highly effective radical scavengers. If not properly controlled, both of these factors may lead to experimental artifacts.

Monitoring copopulated conformational states during protein folding events using electrospray ionization-ion mobility spectrometry-mass spectrometry

The precise mechanism of protein folding remains elusive and there is a deficiency of biophysical techniques that are capable of monitoring the individual behavior of copopulated protein conformers during the folding process. Herein, an ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) device integrated with electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) has been used to successfully separate and analyze protein conformers differing in cross section and/or charge state. In an initial test, an ensemble of folded and partially folded conformers of the protein cytochrome c was separated. A detailed study undertaken on the amyloidogenic protein beta(2)-microglobulin (beta(2)m), which forms fibrils by protein unfolding followed by self-aggregation and is responsible for the disease dialysis-related amyloidosis, has generated important insights into its folding landscape. Initially, a systematic titration of beta(2)m over the pH range 2 to 7 using ESI-IMS-MS allowed individual conformers to be monitored and quantified throughout the acid denaturation process. Furthermore, a comparison of wild-type beta(2)m with single and double amino acid variants with a range of folding stabilities and propensities for amyloid fibril formation has provided illuminating evidence of the role of different conformers in protein stability and amyloidogenic aggregation. The ESI-IMS-MS data presented here not only demonstrate an important and informative further dimension to ESI-MS, but also illustrate the potential of the ESI-IMS-MS technique for unravelling protein folding enigmas in general and studying protein misfolding diseases in particular.

Analytical performance of a venturi-assisted array of micromachined ultrasonic electrosprays coupled to ion trap mass spectrometry for the analysis of peptides and proteins

The analytical characterization of a novel ion source for mass spectrometry named array of micromachined ultrasonic electrosprays (AMUSE) is presented here. This is a fundamentally different type of ion generation device, consisting of three major components: (1) a piezoelectric transducer that creates ultrasonic waves at one of the resonant frequencies of the sample-filled device, (2) an array of pyramidally shaped nozzles micromachined on a silicon wafer, and (3) a spacer which prevents contact between the array and transducer ensuring the transfer of acoustic energy to the sample. A high-pressure gradient generated at the apexes of the nozzle pyramids forces the periodic ejection of multiple droplet streams from the device. With this device, the processes of droplet formation and droplet charging are separated; hence, the limitations of conventional electrospray-type ion sources, including the need for high charging potentials and the addition of organic solvent to decrease surface tension, can be avoided. In this work, a Venturi device is coupled with AMUSE in order to increase desolvation, droplet focusing, and signal stability. Results show that ionization of model peptides and small tuning molecules is possible with dc charging potentials of 100 Vdc or less. Ionization in rf-only mode (without dc biasing) was also possible. It was observed that, when combined with AMUSE, the Venturi device provides a 10-fold gain in signal-to-noise ratio for 90% aqueous sample solutions. Further reduction in the diameter of the orifices of the micromachined arrays led to an additional signal gain of at least 3 orders of magnitude, a 2-10-fold gain in the signal-to-noise ratio and an improvement in signal stability from 47% to 8.5% RSD. The effectiveness of this device for the soft ionization of model proteins in aqueous media, such as cytochrome c, was also examined, yielding spectra with an average charge state of 8.8 when analyzed with a 100 Vdc charging potential. Ionization of model proteins was also possible in rf-only mode.

Capillary electrophoresis–mass spectrometry for the analysis of intact proteins

Developments in the fields of protein chemistry, proteomics and biotechnology have increased the demand for suitable analytical techniques for the analysis of intact proteins. In 1989, capillary electrophoresis (CE) was combined with mass spectrometry (MS) for the first time and its potential usefulness for the analysis of intact (i.e. non-digested) proteins was shown. This article provides an overview of the applications of CE-MS within the field of intact protein analysis. The principles of the applied CE modes and ionization techniques used for CE-MS of intact proteins are shortly described. It is shown that separations are predominantly carried out by capillary zone electrophoresis and capillary isoelectric focusing, whereas electrospray ionization (ESI) and matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization (MALDI) are the most popular ionization techniques used for interfacing. The combination of CE with inductively coupled plasma (ICP) MS for the analysis of metalloproteins is also discussed. The various CE-MS combinations are systematically outlined and tables provide extensive overviews of the applications of each technique for intact protein analysis. Selected examples are given to illustrate the usefulness of the CE-MS techniques. Examples include protein isoform assignment, single cell analysis, metalloprotein characterization, proteomics and biomarker screening. Finally, chip-based electrophoresis combined with MS is shortly treated and some of its applications are described. It is concluded that CE-MS represents a powerful tool for the analysis of intact proteins yielding unique separations and information.

The first step of hen egg white lysozyme fibrillation, irreversible partial unfolding, is a two-state transition

Amyloid fibril depositions are associated with many neurodegenerative diseases as well as amyloidosis. The detailed molecular mechanism of fibrillation is still far from complete understanding. In our previous study of in vitro fibrillation of hen egg white lysozyme, an irreversible partially unfolded intermediate was characterized. A similarity of unfolding kinetics found for the secondary and tertiary structure of lysozyme using deep UV resonance Raman (DUVRR) and tryptophan fluorescence spectroscopy leads to a hypothesis that the unfolding might be a two-state transition. In this study, chemometric analysis, including abstract factor analysis (AFA), target factor analysis (TFA), evolving factor analysis (EFA), multivariate curve resolution-alternating least squares (ALS), and genetic algorithm, was employed to verify that only two principal components contribute to the DUVRR and fluorescence spectra of soluble fraction of lysozyme during the fibrillation process. However, a definite conclusion on the number of conformers cannot be made based solely on the above spectroscopic data although chemometric analysis suggested the existence of two principal components. Therefore, electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) was also utilized to address the hypothesis. The protein ion charge state distribution (CSD) envelopes of the incubated lysozyme were well fitted with two principal components. Based on the above analysis, the partial unfolding of lysozyme during in vitro fibrillation was characterized quantitatively and proven to be a two-state transition. The combination of ESI-MS and Raman and fluorescence spectroscopies with advanced statistical analysis was demonstrated to be a powerful methodology for studying protein structural transformations.

Detection of the equilibrium folding intermediate of beta-lactoglobulin in the presence of trifluoroethanol by mass spectrometry

Nano-electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (nano-ESI-MS) was used to monitor the effect of trifluoroethanol (TFE) on the conformational properties of beta-lactoglobulin (BLG). TFE stabilizes protein secondary structure, particularly alpha-helices. However, it also acts as a denaturant above critical concentrations. In the case of BLG, TFE at low concentrations is known to induce formation of an equilibrium intermediate that contains non-native helical structure. Such an intermediate is thought to form also under physiological conditions, playing a role in BLG folding in vivo by preventing aggregation. This well-characterized system was chosen in order to test species distributions obtained by nano-ESI-MS. BLG spectra at increasing concentrations of TFE at pH 2 indicate transient accumulation of a conformer whose charge-state distribution (CSD) falls between that of the native and that of the denatured protein, indicating that the TFE-induced, partially folded form can be selectively monitored by this technique. The condition of its maximum accumulation corresponds to 16% TFE, in excellent agreement with results from solution experiments. In contrast, titrations with methanol or acetonitrile (ACN) reveal apparent two-state transitions from native to fully unfolded BLG. At 10% TFE, the protein appears to be still fully folded at room temperature but, if unfolding is elicited by the combination with other denaturing agents, e.g. heat or low concentrations of ACN, it proceeds via formation of the intermediate. Thus, TFE can also induce formation of the BLG intermediate in synergism with generic denaturing agents. This study indicates good agreement between ESI-MS and other biophysical methods monitoring protein conformational transitions in the presence of TFE.

Structural changes of α-lactalbumin induced by low pH and oleic acid

The effects of low pH and oleic acid on conformation and association state of Ca2+-depleted bovine alpha-lactalbumin (apo-BLA) have been studied by electrospray ionization mass spectrometry, fluorescence spectroscopy, and circular dichroism. The experimental results demonstrate that two structurally distinct species exist in the conformational transition of apo-BLA induced by low pH. One species populates at pH 3.0 characterized as a monomeric molten globule state and the other accumulates at pH 4.0-4.5 which is a partially folded dimer. Oleic acid promotes the formation of the dimeric intermediate at pH 4.0 and 7.0, but increases the content of molten globule state remarkably at pH 3.0 compared with that in the absence of oleic acid, indicating that oleic acid at pH 3.0 plays a different role from those at pH 4.0 and 7.0. Our data provide insight into the mechanism of pH-dependent and oleic acid-dependent structural changes and oligomerization of alpha-lactalbumin, and will be helpful to the understanding of the apoptosis-inducing function of multimeric alpha-lactalbumin in which oleic acid is a necessary cofactor.

Comparison of bovine and porcine beta-lactoglobulin: a mass spectrometric analysis

Nano-electrospray-ionization mass spectrometry (nano-ESI-MS) is applied to comparison of bovine and porcine beta-lactoglobulin (BLG and PLG). The conformational and oligomeric properties of the two proteins under different solvent and experimental conditions are analyzed. The pH-dependence of dimerization is described for the pH range 2-11. The results indicate maximal dimer accumulation at pH 6 for BLG and pH 4 for PLG, as well as a lower stability of the PLG dimer at pH 4 compared to BLG at pH 6. Conformational stability appears to be higher for BLG at acidic pH, but higher for PLG at basic pH. The higher stability of BLG at low pH is revealed by means of either chemical or thermal denaturation. Equilibrium folding intermediates of both proteins are detected. Finally, conditions are found that promote dissociation of the BLG dimer at pH 6 into folded monomers.

Assessing protein disorder and induced folding

Intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) defy the structure-function paradigm as they fulfill essential biological functions while lacking well-defined secondary and tertiary structures. Conformational and spectroscopic analyses showed that IDPs do not constitute a uniform family, and can be divided into subfamilies as a function of their residual structure content. Residual intramolecular interactions are thought to facilitate binding to a partner and then induced folding. Comprehensive information about experimental approaches to investigate structural disorder and induced folding is still scarce. We herein provide hints to readily recognize features typical of intrinsic disorder and review the principal techniques to assess structural disorder and induced folding. We describe their theoretical principles and discuss their respective advantages and limitations. Finally, we point out the necessity of using different approaches and show how information can be broadened by the use of multiples techniques.

Direct correlation of the crystal structure of proteins with the maximum positive and negative charge states of gaseous protein ions produced by electrospray ionization

Electrospray mass spectrometric studies in native folded forms of several proteins in aqueous solution have been performed in the positive and negative ion modes. The mass spectra of the proteins show peaks corresponding to multiple charge states of the gaseous protein ions. The results have been analyzed using the known crystal structures of these proteins. Crystal structure analysis shows that among the surface exposed residues some are involved in hydrogen-bonding or salt-bridge interactions while some are free. The maximum positive charge state of the gaseous protein ions was directly related to the number of free surface exposed basic groups whereas the maximum negative charge state was related to the number of free surface exposed acidic groups of the proteins. The surface exposed basic groups, which are involved in hydrogen bonding, have lower propensity to contribute to the positive charge of the protein. Similarly, the surface exposed acidic groups involved in salt bridges have lower propensity to contribute to the negative charge of the protein. Analysis of the crystal structure to determine the maximum charge state of protein in the electrospray mass spectrum was also used to interpret the reported mass spectra of several proteins. The results show that both the positive and the negative ion mass spectra of the proteins could be interpreted by simple consideration of the crystal structure of the folded proteins. Moreover, unfolding of the protein was shown to increase the positive charge-state because of the availability of larger number of free basic groups at the surface of the unfolded protein.

Equilibrium titrations of acid-induced unfolding–refolding and salt-induced molten globule of cytochrome c by FT-IR spectroscopy

Despite extensive investigations on the acid-unfolded and acid/salt-induced molten globule(-like) states of cytochrome c using variety of techniques, structural features of the acid-unfolded state in terms of residual secondary structures and the structural transition between the acid-unfolded and acid/salt-refolded states have not been fully characterized beyond the circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy. It is unusual that secondary structure(s) of the unfolded state leading to the molten globule state, an important protein folding intermediate, as determined by CD was not fully corroborated by independent experimental method(s). In this study, we carried out an equilibrium titration of acid-induced unfolding and subsequent acid- and salt-induced refolding of cytochrome c using Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy. The spectral profiles of the equilibrium titration reveal new structural details about the acid-unfolded state and the structural transition associated with the acid/salt-refolded molten globule(-like) states of cytochrome c.

Testing the role of solvent surface tension in protein ionization by electrospray

This work was aimed at probing the influence of solvent surface tension on protein ionization by electrospray. In particular, we were interested in testing the previously suggested hypothesis that the charge-state distributions (CSDs) of proteins in electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) are controlled by the surface tension of the least volatile solvent component. In the attempt to minimize uncontrolled conformational effects, we used acid-sensitive proteins (cytochrome c and myoglobin) at low pH or highly stable proteins (ubiquitin and lysozyme) in the presence of low concentrations of organic solvents. A first set of experiments compared the effect of 1- and 2-propanol. These two alcohols have similar chemico-physical properties but values of vapor pressure below and above that of water, respectively. Both compounds have much lower surface tension than water. The solvents employed allowed testing of the influence of surface tension on protein spectra obtained from similarly denaturing solutions. The compared solvent conditions gave rise to very similar spectra for each tested protein. We then investigated the effect of the addition of dimethyl sulfoxide to acid-unfolded proteins. We observed enhanced ionization in the presence of acetic or formic acid, consistent with the previously described supercharging effect, but almost no shift of the CSD in the presence of HCl. Finally, we analyzed thermally denatured cytochrome c, to obtain reference spectra of the unfolded protein in high-surface-tension solutions. Also in this case, the CSD of the unfolded protein was shifted towards lower m/z values relative to low-surface-tension systems. In contrast to the other results reported here, this effect is consistent with an influence of solvent surface tension on CSD. The magnitude of the effect, however, is much smaller than predicted by the Rayleigh equation. The results presented here are not easy to reconcile with the hypothesis that the maximum charge state exhibited by proteins in ESI-MS reflects the Rayleigh-limit charge of the precursor droplet. The data are discussed with reference to models for the mechanism of electrospray ionization.